Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

The Hanging Judgement

Episode 383November 21, 197543 min 1 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 31 min to read

Grant, was entitled to carry. Is that correct? Yes, sir. Now, Lieutenant, is it not a fact that there are thousands of police positive .38s in existence? I suppose so. And that the bullet that killed Mrs. Grant could have come from any one of them? Well, yes, I suppose it could have. Thank you. That's all.

The district attorney then calls Sergeant Beresini to the stand, who corroborates the lieutenant's testimony regarding the discovery of the body and the .32 revolver found beside it. The maid, Ingrid Svenson, is called next, and she testifies that she was awakened by two shots, that she heard voices—a man's and a woman's—arguing, and that she saw Dr. Grant's car leaving the property shortly after the second shot.

Your witness, Mr. Justin.

Miss Svenson, you say you heard two shots? Yes, two shots. And between the first and second shot, how much time elapsed? Oh, I don't know. Maybe a minute, maybe less. And you heard voices? Yes, a man and a woman. They were shouting. Could you make out what they were saying? No, I was too frightened. I hid in my room. And then you saw a car leaving? Yes, Dr. Grant's car. I know it well. Are you certain it was his car? Oh yes, the license plate, I see it many times. And how many people were in this car? Two, I think. A man driving, and a woman beside him. You think? You're not certain? It was dark. I was frightened. Thank you, Miss Svenson.

The district attorney rests his case, and Justin calls his first witness: Dr. Samuel Grant himself.

Dr. Grant, will you tell the court in your own words what happened on the night of August 29th?

I arrived at my wife's house with Cheryl Stafford. We had made an appointment to discuss the divorce. My wife was angry, irrational. She had a gun, a .32. She threatened us. I tried to calm her down, to get the gun away from her. She fired once, I don't know where the bullet went. Then Cheryl ran, and I heard a second shot. Barbara fell. I didn't see where the second shot came from. I was too stunned to move. Then Cheryl came back, and we got in my car and left. I was frightened, confused. I didn't know what to do.

And you did not fire that second shot? No, I did not. And you did not see who did? No. It came from behind me, from somewhere in the darkness.

Justin then calls Cheryl Stafford to the stand. She is young, attractive, nervous.

Miss Stafford, you were present on the night of Mrs. Grant's death? Yes. And you corroborate Dr. Grant's testimony? Yes, everything happened just as he said. And you did not fire the fatal shot? No, I did not. I was running away when I heard it. Did you see who did? No. I was too frightened. I just ran.

The prosecution cross-examines, pressing her on her relationship with Dr. Grant, on the convenience of her being in Las Vegas when he claimed to be there, on their planned marriage. She becomes flustered, contradicts herself slightly on times and details. The jury watches, skeptical.

Justin recalls Lieutenant Kinsella.

Lieutenant, you testified that Dr. Grant's car was found in the airport parking lot, and that he claimed to have flown to Las Vegas on the day before the murder? Yes. And that this alibi was subsequently abandoned? Yes. Is it not true that you checked all flights to Las Vegas on that day and found no record of Dr. Grant's passage? Yes, that's true. And is it not also true that you found no record of his stay in any Las Vegas hotel or motel? Yes. So his original alibi was completely fabricated? Objection. The witness is not qualified to characterize. Sustained.

Justin then produces his surprise witness: a Las Vegas cab driver named Morris Feltman, who testifies that he drove Dr. Grant and Miss Stafford from the airport to a motel on the outskirts of town, that he remembers them distinctly because of an argument they were having about "some woman in Los Angeles." The time was approximately 6 p.m. on the night of the murder—impossible for Grant to have committed the crime and returned.

The district attorney objects vigorously, demands to see Justin's evidence of the cab driver's credibility. Justin produces a time-stamped receipt from the cab company, Feltman's log book. The jury murmurs. The judge calls for order.

And now, ladies and gentlemen, we come to the heart of the matter. The missing gun. The phantom weapon. Without it, the prosecution cannot place a gun in Dr. Grant's hand. With the cab driver's testimony, they cannot place him at the scene at the time of death. What remains? A jealous wife, a frightened husband, a convenient mistress, and a bullet from a gun that has vanished as completely as if it never existed.

The trial continues. Witnesses come and go. The Swedish maid is recalled, admits she might have been mistaken about the car, about the number of people in it, about the time. The prosecution's case crumbles at the edges. But the central mystery remains: who fired that second shot? Who killed Barbara Grant?

Justin works tirelessly, Sandy Russell at his side, running down leads, checking alibis, searching for the missing gun. They visit the house again, the neighborhood, interview neighbors who heard nothing, saw nothing. They trace the .32 revolver, find it was purchased by Barbara Grant herself two weeks before her death. A woman afraid, preparing for something?

And then, a break. A pawn shop in East Los Angeles, a police positive .38 sold three days after the murder by a man fitting no description anyone can remember. The serial number traced, the original owner found: a retired police officer, dead six months, his effects sold at auction by his widow. The gun passed through three hands before the pawn shop, none of them traceable, none connected to Grant or Stafford or anyone in the case.

Justin stares at the gun in the evidence room, turning it over in his hands. The murder weapon, found at last, but leading nowhere. No fingerprints, no connection, no meaning.

The trial resumes. The prosecution, desperate now, introduces a new theory: that Grant hired a professional killer, that the phantom gunman was paid, that the whole Las Vegas alibi was elaborately staged. But they have no evidence, no witness, no money trail. The jury grows restless. The judge warns the district attorney to produce substance or abandon the theory.

And then, on the fifth day of the trial, a note delivered to Justin's office. Anonymous, typed, brief: "The gun was thrown in the reservoir. Check the north shore. Midnight, August 29th." Justin and Sandy drive to the reservoir, search the north shore in the gathering dusk, find nothing but mud and stones and the debris of a hundred picnickers.

But Sandy, persistent, wading in the shallows, her shoes ruined, her stockings torn, finds it. Caught in the roots of a willow tree, half-buried in silt: a police positive .38, rusting, ruined, but identifiable. They turn it over to the police, to ballistics. It matches. The murder weapon.

But whose was it? The serial number is filed off, obliterated. Professional work. They trace the gunsmith who did it, a man in San Diego, now in prison on another charge. He remembers the job, remembers the man who brought it in: tall, dark, well-dressed, paid in cash, no names exchanged. A description that fits half the men in Los Angeles, that fits Dr. Samuel Grant himself.

Justin confronts his client.

Doctor, I have to ask you again. Did you hire someone to kill your wife? No. Never. I swear it. Then who? Who had reason to want her dead? Who had access to such a weapon, such arrangements? I don't know. I thought I knew my wife, our life together. But at the end, I realize I knew nothing.

The trial enters its final phase. Justin's closing argument is a masterpiece of rhetoric, of legal precision, of passionate belief in his client's innocence. He demolishes the prosecution's case piece by piece: the missing gun now found but untraceable, the alibi now substantiated, the motive insufficient for so elaborate a crime, the lack of any connection between Grant and the professional gunman the prosecution theorizes.

Ladies and gentlemen, you have heard a story of jealousy, of passion, of a marriage failed. But you have not heard proof of murder. You have heard speculation, inference, convenient theories that collapse under examination. Dr. Grant is not a perfect man. He loved not wisely but too well, as the poet says. But he did not kill his wife. He did not hire her killing. He is guilty of poor judgment, of marital failure, of human weakness. But not of murder. Not of this crime.

The jury retires. The wait begins. Justin and Sandy in his office, Grant pacing, Cheryl Stafford weeping quietly in a corner. The hours pass. A call from the courthouse. The jury has a verdict.

We the jury find the defendant, Dr. Samuel Grant, not guilty.

The courtroom erupts. Grant embraces Justin, weeping. Cheryl faints. The district attorney storms out. Justin stands quietly, watching, his face unreadable.

But later, in his office, alone with Sandy, he sits heavily, suddenly old.

What's wrong? You won. Did I? A woman is dead. Her killer walks free. Perhaps it was Grant, perhaps someone else. I have saved a man's life, perhaps. Or I have freed a murderer. The law is satisfied. Justice? Who knows? You believe he was innocent? I believe... I believe there are mysteries beyond human comprehension, as old G. Marshall said at the beginning. This is one of them. We have a verdict. We do not have truth.

The phone rings. Sandy answers, listens, hands it to Justin.

It's Lieutenant Kinsella. He says... he says they've found the gunman. In San Diego. He confessed to everything. He was hired by... by Mrs. Grant herself.

Justin listens, his face changing, wonder and horror mixing.

She wanted to die. She wanted her husband accused, ruined, destroyed. She hired the man, arranged for him to be there, to fire after she shot at Grant. The second bullet was meant for her. She orchestrated her own murder, and the destruction of the man who abandoned her.

He hangs up slowly.

The hanging judgment. She judged him, and hanged him, and hanged herself. And we... we were her instruments.

Sandy stares at him, uncomprehending.

But... the verdict. He's free. She's dead. What judgment? Exactly. What judgment indeed?

The silence stretches between them, filled with the weight of human mystery, of motives beyond understanding, of a woman who loved so destructively that she turned her own death into a weapon.

And so, ladies and gentlemen, we come to the end of our mystery. Not solved, perhaps, but revealed. The hanging judgment hangs still, over all of us, the judgment we pass on one another, the sentences we pronounce in our hearts. Dr. Grant goes free, but does he live free? Cheryl Stafford marries him, perhaps, or perhaps the shadow of that night destroys them too. The law has spoken, but justice... justice remains, as ever, beyond our poor comprehension.

This is G. Marshall, inviting you to return to the Mystery Theater for another tale of the unexplained, the unrevealed, the mysterious. Until then, good night.

[MUSIC]

Luden's Medicated Cough Drops remind you that a cough is nothing to sneeze at. When your throat needs soothing relief, try Luden's, available in delicious cherry, honey licorice, and new menthol eucalyptus flavors. And now, this is CBS, the Columbia Broadcasting System.

Samuel Grant, was licensed to own and carry.

That is just what I meant. Well, we can go into that a little later. A couple of more questions, if you will, Lieutenant.

Yes, sir.

Now, the gun that was found by Mrs. Grant had been fired. Is that correct?

Uh, yes, sir. Once.

What caliber was that?

Uh, 32, sir.

Was that bullet found?

Yes, sir. In the back wall of the garage.

And the bullet from her 32 was fired in the direction of Dr. Grant, who was inside the garage at the time?

Yes, sir.

Yes, sir. But there were definitely two shots.

Well, of course, sir. There was one right after another. The, uh, the maid in the house heard them.

Where was Mrs. Grant shot? In what part of her body?

She was shot in the back.

In the back. Thank you very much, Lieutenant. That's really all I need.

That's what Justin does that is so great. He meanders around, gets everyone cooled off, and relaxed, and then whams home a zinger that makes the jury sit up. And that stays planted in their mind. It's like a, a baseball game. A trial. After inning. Each side striking out or scoring. Like Justin just did.

Doctor, I asked you to describe the events of the night of the 29th leading up to the death of your wife.

Oh, I did the best of my ability. My wife, against an agreement I thought we had, had taken action to sue me for divorce. I called her from Las Vegas and asked her to reconsider and we had made a date to meet that evening.

In your own words, could you tell us what happened when you arrived?

I can try. Cheryl, uh, Miss Stafford and I had driven there in her car. We parked at the downhill parking lot and walked up the two blocks to my, I mean, to Barbara's house.

Why didn't you just drive up and park in the drive?

Well, that's difficult to explain. The house is perched on the side of a hill. A cliff, really. The driveway is difficult to maneuver. So I built this parking space on our property just below. Unless you were planning to drive into the garage itself, we usually left our cars there.

Your own car? Your own house?

My wife and I were separated. Pending a divorce agreement, it was her house.

You considered it that?

I was willing to grant her that privilege.

After you and Miss Stafford had walked up to the garage, what did you find?

Well, there was no one home. I had still had my keys and I had just let Miss Stafford and myself in when my wife drove up. We'd come in the back door and it was just at dusk so I didn't bother to put on any lights. Cheryl and I just went through the inner door to the garage about the same time as Barbara opened the garage sliding door.

It's me, Barbara. Sam.

What are you doing here? You don't belong here anymore.

You know we made a date tonight to talk over the divorce.

You? You did. Not me.

Who's that with you?

I said I'd bring Cheryl along.

You get that lot out of my house and off my property.

Barbara, put that gun away. Run, Cheryl. Run.

Give me the gun, Barbara. I'll give you what you deserve, you cheeky...

No, you're wrong. Are you crazy? Oh, no.

Ducked down behind the lawn tractor and the garden tools. Even with the headlights on, I couldn't see anything. All I knew was there was a second shot and that Barbara had been hit. I went to her right away.

Was the gun still in your hand?

What gun? Someone shot your wife. If it wasn't you, are you suggesting it was Miss Stafford?

No. I mean, well, I don't... I didn't even know where Miss Stafford was at the time.

I see. So you went to your wife and then... What happened, Barbara? Are you all right?

And did she reply?

Yes, she... She said, I love you. I should have listened to you take care of the children. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know.

The children. Your son and daughter?

Yes.

Who were not home at this time?

No, they were away at school.

There was no one in the house?

Yes, a maid, Miss Trenum. I could hear her moving and I imagined calling the police.

And then what happened?

I panicked.

I'm sure you did. What did you do in your panic?

Ran down the hill to the parking lot.

Where you found Miss Stafford waiting for you?

Yes.

With the gun?

What gun? The gun that shot your wife.

Cheryl had no gun.

Then you had it. What did you do with it?

Objection, Your Honor. The District Attorney is obviously trying to put words into the mouth of the defendant.

Not quite, Mr. Justin. But I do feel, Mr. Herman, you have not established the existence of the gun up to this point.

Well, may I say it doesn't matter, Your Honor. The bullet that lodged in Mrs. Grant's heart has established that such a gun existed. Your witness, Mr. Justin.

Mr. Grant, I beg your pardon, Dr. Grant, can I take you back for a moment to the night of May the 14th? Would you be good enough to tell the court what took place at your home on Ventura Boulevard?

Both my wife and myself were away. It was Miss Trenum, the maid's night out. We were robbed.

Now, I have here a certified list from the insurance company of all the things that were taken. The stereo equipment, TV sets, jewelry, etc. Among those items, is one very relevant one. Was a .38 caliber police positive revolver also removed?

Yes, sir.

And did you immediately in the course of the insurance investigation notify the police of that fact?

I did.

And did you subsequently seek a license for a new gun of any sort?

Not for myself. By that time, I was in the course of separating from my wife. Since she was afraid of being in the house alone, I arranged to get one for her and have it licensed.

The .32, which is an exhibit, and with which she fired the bullet at me.

And you have no knowledge who might have fired the bullet that killed your wife?

No, sir.

Could it have been Miss Stafford?

Why would you suggest that?

Your wife was shot in the back. You were facing her, were you not?

Yes, but... Good Lord! Cheryl was scared to death of firearms. She didn't know anything about guns. She's the last person who could have been responsible for my wife's death.

I have no further questions. Thank you, Doctor.

But there were. The D.A. went after Dr. Grant. He ran on redirect. Tooth and nail. And worse than that. Oh, I've been around court long enough to know that when Cheryl Stafford got on the stand, she was in for hell. Most of all, I couldn't understand J.C. You work for a man long enough, love him too much, like me, and you know too much about him not to know he wasn't putting out his best effort here. I called him on it.

Alexandra, don't ask questions. That's my business.

I get the put-down. Anytime you call me Alexandra, I get the put-down.

Oh, but I can't let it go, J.C.

All right, all right. Now, look, we're skating on a lot of thin ice. And I am supposed to be advocate, not judge. Now, why don't you just leave me be and let what is to be to take its natural course?

Okay. If you think your clients are guilty, do you?

I have a basic rule to try and consider my clients innocent.

Oh, but the way things are going, you're gonna lose.

Well, that's a very absolute term.

It's the way it's going. Like, well, if things go now, one of them killed Mrs. Grant.

Well, and since she was shot in the back, it's Cheryl Stafford. But it's still collusion, and both of them are guilty.

That's the way it may look, my love. But not enough hard facts to pin it down. That should worry Al Herman. But you notice that it doesn't. He still has something big to hit us with in this case. So, let's go grab some dinner and some personal life.

Oh, I don't know. Sometimes I wonder about you. Whether you care. About winning?

No. About how you win. And if it's right that you do.

Sandy, you have to make your own judgments on that like anyone else. Everything in its time. Let's wait until all the cards are in.

As J. Carr Justin knows from experience, there is no drama more tense, more uncertain in its outcome than the arena of the courtroom. And no theater in which the incredible surprise, the shocking factor that follows no law of dramaturgy, simply pops up to turn upside down all the facts which have gone before. So, ladies and gentlemen of the jury, it will be with some startling new evidence that I return with Act Three.

Everyone in the trial, of course, was waiting for the appearance of the femme fatale, the other woman, Cheryl Stafford. But before her appearance, the surprise witness suddenly appeared on the chair. A witness guilelessly introduced by Cheryl's brother, the other woman, who was testifying as a character reference for his sister. A witness named William Aloysius Brody.

It's not often, J. Carr Justin is blindsided. But this time he was. And the D.A. had set his trap well. William Brody was a complete surprise to us and to the jury. Just listen to the unflappable muscle man on the stand in the midst of the story he had to tell.

Mr. Brody, you actually discussed murder? Murder with Cheryl Stafford?

You called it, ma'am. And she named the victim?

Yeah. Miss Grant, dame.

Well, I must admit that I'm caught a little out of my depth here, but would you describe in your own words just what you mean?

Well, it's no big deal. Like I say, I'm at this party and a kid I know named Stafford gives me the big intro to his sister here. Her. So who's gonna back off? She's a real good-looking dame and one thing leads to another and I get an invite to come up to her apartment like the next night.

Did you go?

Why not? What kind of guy would pass it up?

Please continue your story.

Well, I rigged myself out in some fancy threads figuring this is a score and I ain't got no reason to change my mind when she opens the door. I mean, she's like you say, undressed for action. And the welcome sign is out. It's a big hello, a big drink and this kid is...

Hi. I think the picture is graphic enough. Suppose you just tell us simply and directly what happened.

Can I get you some more to drink?

Uh, no, babe. I'm coasting easy now. Your kid brother told me you want a favor.

Uh, that's right. Try me. I deliver.

Supposing I was to tell you I want someone... I mean, I... I want someone out of the way.

Out of the way. Huh. You mean total? Wiped out?

I mean killed. Dead.

Okay. You don't have to draw pictures, just name numbers. How much?

Say, $2,000.

Oh, you gotta be kidding. I wouldn't touch it for under a five.

I haven't... I mean, I... I don't think I could raise that much.

Who's the pigeon anyway?

Well, if I tell you, can we make a deal? $3,000 is my top figure. It's all I've got. All I can get.

Yeah. So we got a deal. Give me a name.

Her name is Grant. Barbara Grant. She's married to my ex-boss. But it wouldn't be hard. They're separated and she lives alone.

Oh, lay the bread on me. $2,000 advance. Third on delivery.

You actually contracted to kill Mrs. Grant?

Are you kidding? Uh, this was all con as far as I know. I was concerned.

Did she pay the money?

I took the money and blew. I was only doing her kid brother a favor.

But you took money and promised a killing.

Look, uh, her, that, uh, Cheryl Stafford says to me, Mrs. Grant has given us a bad time, causing us a lot of grief. Now, if you don't take care of her, Sam will have to do it himself.

So I wanted to make her feel better. And when the date came, you were supposed to deliver. What happened when nothing happened?

I gave it the wide-eyed eye. I said I took her out with a shotgun in the chest and I hit her behind the convent.

What was her reaction?

Well, I never saw her so happy. Then she calls us Dr. Grant and he levels with her. His wife is still alive and kicking.

What was Miss Stafford's reaction?

She said, you must have shot somebody else.

And you said?

Maybe I goofed. If I made the wrong hit, I'll go back and do it again. But I need more money.

And Miss Stafford said, there isn't any more money. This time, we'll handle it by ourselves.

Thank you, Mr. Brody. No more questions. Your witness, Counselor.

Oh, no, Mr. Herman. Not mine. You turned over your own rock to produce this specimen.

You know better than to make a remark like that, Counselor.

My mind does, Your Honor. My throat just threw it up involuntarily.

Are you courting a mistrial by exhibiting prejudice towards a witness?

My apologies to the court.

Do you intend to cross-examine?

I think not, Your Honor. I would prefer to wait for Miss Stafford's side of the story.

Uh, perhaps just, uh, one or two questions.

The witness is yours.

Would you repeat your name, please?

Uh, Brody. William Brody.

Hmm. William Aloysius Brody?

Yeah, yeah, yeah. But like, man, I dropped the middle go-around in high school.

You also dropped your other names?

What other names?

Well, don't be alarmed. If you have any, the aliases, I don't know about them. I just mean the various public nicknames that people have hung on you, such as Dream Man and the Treasure Chest.

Well, I got cooler.

Will you cool it, man? Everybody has his own bag. I like to build up the body, right? Anything wrong in that? To each his own.

By the way, what did you say, uh, that you do for a living, Mr. Brody?

I did.

Would you now?

Well, this and that. You know, man, I hang loose. No big deal.

Oh, I think you're much too modest, Mr. Brody. I have here a list. Dance hall bouncer, shill, candy butcher, beach boy. But I don't mean all of these. I mean your real profession, since gigolo and ladies' man are a little out of style. What shall we call you? A professional stud?

Objection, Your Honor.

Objection. Sustained. Strike that last sentence from the record. Mr. Justin, I am tempted to find you in contempt of court. You know you cannot discredit a witness without objective proof.

Your Honor, respectfully, it is my contention that the witness has already discredited himself. And when I bring Miss Stafford to the stand, he will be even further discredited.

So at last, it was the defense's turn. And finally, Cheryl Stafford was on the stand. Small and slight. Very pretty in a quiet way. Somehow defenseless. To try to puncture the obvious effects she had on me, the audience and jury, the D.A. tore into her mercilessly.

And you were not ashamed to face the woman whose husband you had stolen?

No. Sam, Dr. Grant, had already left his wife before I... before we fell in love.

Why didn't you drive straight up to the house?

But Sam explained that.

You didn't use that way to approach the house with the object of surprising Mrs. Grant?

Why should we? She was expecting us.

To discuss divorce?

Yes.

Then will you tell me why it was necessary for Dr. Grant to take his bag up to the house with him? He wasn't making a house call, was he?

No, but...

Well, now, were you aware that that bag contained, along with the expected items you might think of, a hank of rope, rubber gloves, a butcher's knife and a box of cartridges? Perhaps even a gun? Which was missing, of course, by the time the police found the bag abandoned in the garage. Wouldn't you say that was less a doctor's bag than a murder kit?

Objection, Your Honor.

I withdraw the question. Now, uh, let's skip to the moment Mrs. Grant arrives and takes out a gun and fires at her husband. What did you do?

I... I ran just as hard as I could the way Sam told me to.

And did you stop to see what was happening before and at the moment the fatal shot was fired? Did Dr. Grant run and duck? Could someone else have approached and fired the shot into Mrs. Grant's back?

I don't know. I... I don't know.

Only you admit the possibility, can't you? Perhaps even a probability. That it could have been you who returned and fired that fatal shot to protect your lover and to carry out the scheme you were both agreed upon before you went there that evening of the 29th. To kill the only thing that stood in the way of your happiness and your future. Since you couldn't hire someone successfully to kill her, didn't you and Dr. Grant by one means or another carry out her death sentence yourself?

The coil of rope was only some leftover line that Dr. Grant had used to secure a bumper on his boat.

Yes.

And the so-called butcher knife was a simple kitchen all-purpose knife which Dr. Grant had bought because we needed it to cut bread and prepare salads and so on.

Yes. It wasn't even that big. Couldn't be less important.

And the rubber gloves I think of course are self-explanatory.

Just one question. Why did he lug that bag up the hill?

Because when he talked to his wife, she said she was having her migraine headaches again. He thought he might have something to relieve them.

All right. Let's move to another shield for a moment. You've heard the testimony of William Brody.

I have.

Was he telling the truth?

Mr. Brody is a liar. If you want the real truth of what happened in our interview, here it is.

Well, here I am, babe. Let's break out the booze and get the party going.

This is no party, Mr. Brody. You were recommended to me by my brother.

Count on me. I deliver.

I'm embarrassed about this. I don't quite know how to say it.

Hey, hey, hey. Don't run a fever. I'll lay it out. You want a dame compromised enough to make a case for her husband to sue for divorce.

I'm ashamed to say you're right.

That could run into real dough, you know. Who's the dame?

Her name is Grant. She lives alone.

Hmm. She's gonna run five big ones.

Five thousand? Hmm. Well, I haven't got that much. Three thousand is the best. It's the most I could raise.

No, okay. If that's what the traffic will bear, you got a deal.

You paid him?

Yes. But he just took the money without...

Delivering.

You hated what you felt you had to do, didn't you?

Oh, yes.

Then how could you have done it? Attempt to compromise a woman as decent and vulnerable as you are?

Because Barbara Grant wasn't like that at all. She was cold and hard and calculating. She didn't want Sam for herself. She was just determined that no other woman should have him. She hadn't allowed him to touch her in over two years. She wasn't a woman, just a machine. And if that was the only way Sam could get his freedom, I was willing to take it. Because he's the gentlest, kindest man in the world. I love him.

One more question. Did you shoot Barbara Grant?

Mr. Justin, I wouldn't even know how to fire a gun.

Thank you, Miss Stafford. The defense rests.

The jury's been out three hours, Mr. J.C. What do you think?

Mostly at a time like this, I try not to.

Oh, I wish I could make my mind a blank.

Why?

Because I love you and I don't know why you took this case. Now, don't give me the lawyer's ethics line again. Everyone is entitled to a defense.

You know he's guilty as hell.

Do I?

Yes. And how do I feel about her? Well, that's not so easy.

Excuse me. Yeah. They're coming out? Okay, we'll be right there. The jury has a verdict.

The jury has a verdict.

Verdict?

Yep. What do you think it'll be?

All right, ladies and gentlemen of the radio jury, what was your verdict? Was the stolen gun just a cover for Dr. Grant to have a weapon to kill his wife? Did they struggle so that she was shot in the back? Did Cheryl fire the fatal shot? Or did the incredible Mr. Brody decide to earn his money by coincidence that evening? It's your decision. Who killed Barbara Grant?

I might add that this was an actual case. Only the names and some locations changed. So you were guessing at an actual result.

A hung jury?

Oh, then you lost.

Well, that depends on the point of view. Now, he conned me into representing both of them. I had to fight for Dr. Grant as hard as I could to save a trusting if stupid little girl who gave her love not wisely, but too well.

Oh, but in saving her, you got him off.

No, no. No, no. They'll be tried again. This time, separately. And this time, I will represent only one, Miss Stafford. Without her as a shield, he'll be convicted. She won't get out of it clean. We all have to pay for mistakes. But at least she won't have to share the death chamber with him.

Three months later, Dr. Grant broke on the stand and admitted that he had taken advantage of the robbery at his house to pretend the gun was one of the articles stolen. He had had it with him in the murder kit bag. And in struggling with his wife, as she had turned to flee, he had deliberately shot and killed her. He got life imprisonment. Cheryl was convicted as an unwitting accessory after the fact. She was sentenced to a two-year term, but released on probation.

On the basis of the facts, would your verdict have been the same?

I'll be back shortly.

How does a nice young woman like that get mixed up with a man like Dr. Samuel Grant?

One of the oldest questions in the world, which people have been trying to answer since time began. A few of them, love is blind. To a more than woman, to be wise. Or perhaps to wind things up, a quote from Mr. Thackeray. Every single woman I ever knew is a puzzle to me, as I have no doubt she is to herself. With no apologies to women's lib, it's the way of the world.

Our cast included Mandel Kramer, Leon Janney, Ken Harvey, E.V. Juster, Joan Shea, and Earl Hammond. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown.

Radio Mystery Theater was sponsored in part by Anheuser-Busch Incorporated, Brewers of Budweiser. This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our Mystery Theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant dreams.

Tonight's Mystery Theater was brought to you in part by ShopRite Supermarkets, where you get a lot more for a little less. The preceding program is furnished by CBS Radio.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑