The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 27 min to read
...of the most heinous of human crimes, murder. Our law decrees his execution. The matter is one of increasing and heated controversy. But whether we are pro or con, one inescapable enigma must be confronted, that you or I, one of us, must carry out the execution. You or I, someone among us, must release the fatal gas, pull the switch, to bring the hangman's trap. Here, then, is our enigma. If you were the executioner, would you yourself not become a murderer?
But you have to do it, Tom. You're the sheriff.
Sure, but I'm not the hangman.
If you don't do it, somebody else will.
Not me, Sarah, is what I'm saying.
Tom, we have to face facts if you want to be sheriff.
That's just it. I don't have to be sheriff. Not if I take a man out and kill him. Just because I'm paid to do it.
The mystery drama, The Hanging Sheriff, was written especially for the Mystery Theater by Bryce Walton and stars Fred Grimm. I'll be back shortly with Act One.
Tom Bender never really wanted to be a sheriff. It was his wife's idea. But when he gave in and wore the badge, he also accepted the moral stance of his office. He represented the good people. He was their defense against the bad. Then Sheriff Bender awoke one morning to find the distinction between good and evil can turn into a puzzling blur. In our story of retribution, Sheriff Bender finds that he who catches killers can eventually, of necessity, catch up with himself.
Morning, Big Sheriff, man. Oh, what got you up there? I swear you had this course built on just so you could dawdle your life away. Dream about that food boat instead of getting yourself killed up in the town. Bet you don't even know the time of day.
Morning. Morning's the best time to be out on the old river. That's the last day. That trial don't need me no more. Maybe it never did.
Yeah, but you need that trial time. You look good and tall sitting there, everybody knowing you brought in the killer. Might a good public release you.
That courthouse is awful hot in August. Hot and ugly to see in.
What really working on you. You've had the blues ever since that trial started. You act scared or something. Now, what is it?
It's that salesman.
Now, what about him?
I'm just not eager to see sentence passed on him. He's sure enough guilty.
Yeah, sure enough guilty. And he ought not get nothing worse than a second degree.
I don't see it matters much, but maybe that's all he'll get.
No, no, no. That salesman's gonna hang. Anyway, you've done your bit, brought in a killer.
Sorry, your hand. No way. It's all gonna be in my hand. Now, just watch that post, Newt. It means that I, I gotta do the hang.
You have to do it.
Because I've been told to do it. Told by who? By town council. Burt Clippinger, Leo Bates, old Seth Boney. They decided. Bates told me. Called me into his office yesterday afternoon. Oh, smile. Oh, smile. Like he's doing me a favor.
Tom. If the judge calls for a hanging, we're gonna have to let you do it.
Oh, me. I gotta do their dirty work. And you know why? Well, I don't.
Save money? They figure me already being on salary, they'll just hand the execution over to me. Save their taxpaying voters a bundle from hiring a professional hangman.
Well, maybe they'll give you a fat bonus.
Bonus? Holy crap. That's not the point.
What? Well, what I am saying is, I, I don't, I don't. Well, getting yourself all worked up won't help matters, Tom. Tom, you wait. You wait, you hear? No, it was ever so in a minute.
Tom, wait. Oh, I feel so good. Oh, that makes two. One of my splitting headaches is coming off. Oh, boy. Worse than usual, I feel real dizzy. Huh? Like I'm just going blind with another old stress headache. Oh, sorry about that. You know what Dr. Crowe said about my stress?
Yeah, I don't know about stress. Okay, well, try not to give me stress, Tom. Simmer down. Stop worrying about that no-count salesman.
Uh, I'll, I'll try. Bye-bye, Sarah. And Tom. Yeah? You stop on your way to the office and see Dr. Crowe. You know, he said he had a new prescription for my headache. You tell him to bring that prescription right out here. I just don't know how I'll get through this day.
All right, Sarah. I'll send him out. And don't you worry. Maybe the judge will let that sell.
Isn't it all easy? Order in this court. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I'll clear this courtroom. Now, Mr. Frank Tanner, our blue-ribbon jury has found and declared you guilty of felonious homicide in the first degree. You got some final say for this here court?
Well, Judge, Your Honor, that's real consider of you. I... I don't have much... to say more than what I said already. I didn't mean to kill anybody. Especially your Mr. Hambrook. I know he was well thought of here in Lakeville. I know he had a family and all. And what I want to say is I'm sorry. I had no intention of killing Mr. Hambrook. I didn't mean to do it. Judge, I wouldn't have hurt our man if I could help it. It just happened. It was all an accident.
Being born can be an accident. It was an accident, too, son. But never an excuse.
Please. Please, Your Honor. Your Honor, I've told the truth. Just how it all went. How we got to exchanging words and scuffing around a little. That's all, sir. I didn't mean to hit him hard. He just fell. Hit his head on that bar stool. Just an accident. I sure didn't plan on nothing. I've never even been in this town or in that bar before. I never knew. I knew Mr. Hambrook never seen or heard of him before. I wish I'd never had that drink with Mr. Hambrook.
If wishes were horses, boy, beggars would ride. Got any more final say for us, Frank?
Looks like I might as well save my breath.
You're right. It is my solemn duty to pass sentence on you. Third sentence being that you shall be hung by your neck until you are declared dead. Until the day of your execution, a day not yet decided on, but in the near future, you shall be handed over to the administrations of our dedicated lawman, Sheriff Tom Bender.
Hard to say if I'm awake or in a bad dream. Hard for any of us to figure out sometimes. How's your appetite?
What appetite? I'm too depressed to have an appetite.
Well, maybe some baked beans would cheer you up. Didn't I hear you express a little yen for... Say, this is spartan of you, Sheriff. Thanks. Yeah, well, what about some cornbread? Oh, it's fresh and still warm. Your wife just baked it. Hey, this is mighty good. I like cornbread. Hey, this is real special. Your woman must be some cook.
Well, she's got a knack for cornbread. Oh, and here. Hey, man. My favorite brew. Hmm. Nice and cold jail cellar for you, too, Frank. This part of the courthouse is old, from way back in Civil War days. So these walls here are real thick. Cool in summer, warm in winter.
Thanks for the fair shake. You're something all right for a lawman. You know, whatever I can do, Frank. And raisins. I never did have cornbread with raisins.
You're okay, Sheriff. The first time I ever got a decent treatment in a slammer. You're, you're all right, Sheriff. I got the hang. The judge, he said that. He said it. You heard him say it. I've been sort of crazy thinking it wasn't real. It's a dream, it's a joke, something. But it's no joke, is it? I'm going to hang. I'm going to die. I'm going to be as dead as a sack of oats.
Now, now, Frank. You can use it. You've got to keep a tight rein on yourself.
But I never meant to kill anybody. It just happened.
I know that, Frank.
Sheriff, you don't think it's right, do you? I ought to hang?
No, I don't think it's right.
Hey, you being Sheriff, isn't it something? Anything you can do?
Uh, where do you hail from, Frank?
Oh, here, there. Up north, mostly. Uh, you got any friends up there you could call?
No, no. Always been on the road. Loads going, selling. Oh, I had a... Thought I had, anyway, some friends once. When my wife left, they just stopped coming around. Seems they were more her friends.
Uh, how about relatives?
No one that could do me any good. A good lawyer might help, but, uh, of course, their services come too high for me. I haven't done too bad selling. But the wife took everything. I figured it would do better if I could open new sales routes down here. And I wasn't doing it. I wasn't doing too bad, either. Until this.
Yeah. Thought the stone he broke. Flat out.
Yeah. Sure got off onto a rough and lonely road now. Roads ought to go somewhere. All the roads I ever took just kept going. Till this road finally ends. At the end of a rope. Oh, Sheriff. Can't you do something? My friends call me Tom.
Tom, please, help me. I'd like to, Frank. I want to. I mean, there must be something or other.
Uh, there's hope.
Well, what kind?
Uh, the kind a man always has when he's still alive.
Uh-huh. No, no, that kind won't last me long. Anyway, I can't last. I can't hold it together. I, I could never face that rope.
Yeah, neither can I.
You don't have to.
I hope not. Huh. You're a good man of faith, if I can do anything at all. And of an executioner.
A good executioner presents society with a troublesome philosophical dilemma. Then what about our chosen hangman? Tom is an easy-going, amiable fellow who would apparently rather do almost anything than hang a fellow man. Now a dilemma is defined as a predicament that seemingly defies a satisfactory solution. Yet Sheriff Bender implies a possible way out. Does he believe in miracles? I'll be back shortly with that.
Behind every successful man, we are told, is a woman. We might add, in the case of Sheriff Tom Bender's wife, Sarah, an ambitious, perhaps even an unscrupulous woman. We also know that ambitious drive may carry you to the top, or drive your spouse to the top, which is presumably where she wishes you to be. I might add, as possibly germane to our story, the legend that a hand-picked husband once had chiseled on the tombstone of a domineering woman. She is at peace, and so am I.
You commit me to supper.
I'm not so hungry, Sarah.
You'd better stop moping over that no-count salesman if you know what's good for you.
What's good for me?
Yeah, I've been thinking about that. Well, you can think that after a good supper.
I need time. I've got to work things out.
Oh, come on now, honey. I've baked up a big pan of cornbread.
Oh, yeah? With the raisins in it?
Booze and raisins. Yeah. Ham hocks, beans, gravy.
That's mighty generous of you, Sarah, but I'm just not so hungry.
I can't understand why you have to get yourself in a spousal over that no-good salesman.
Maybe it'd come a sight more clear if you'd consider how in three days I've got to take that salesman out and murder him.
Murder him? Why do you have to talk like that?
Because that's what I've got to do. Murder him.
It isn't murder. You're just going to hang him.
Yeah, that's right. Until he's dead, he'll be dead on account of me. Because I put the rope around his neck. Tom, you just have to stop thinking about it.
Stop thinking about it? I have no idea what I'm up against. Of course I do. The fact is, I've got to take this, put a rope around his neck, kick a trap door out from under him. The fact is, I've got to kill a man who never did me a wrong. A man I hardly even know. Is that murder?
But I'm not a hangman. I don't have to kill a man just because I'm told to do it. Because someone pays me to do it. I'm not a paid killer.
Honey, you've got a big career ahead of you. If you don't do your duty now, somebody else will.
Not me, Sarah. That's what I'm saying. Not me.
You will, Tom, if you want to be sheriff.
Is that all you think about, all you care about?
If somebody else has to hang that salesman, then somebody else is going to be sheriff. And that's the worst thing you can think of?
Just about. If murdering a man isn't worse, what is?
I'll tell you what's worse. The thought of being married to a man working for $4 an hour in the Lakeville paper mill. And that's where you'll end up, Tom, if you don't hang this salesman. Back to the paper mill. Where I found you. Where you'd still be if it wasn't for me.
Sarah, please, listen to me.
Yo, you listen.
Remember, there's an election coming up. You do remember the election.
Now that you mention it, sure.
Oh, Tom. Tom, I don't feel so good.
Huh?
I feel faint. Uh, uh, get in one of your heads. Yes, it's coming on. And it's all your fault. Now, you call Dr. Cole. He's got to take me over. I think it's my heart, too. He said I had to watch my blood pressure. Now, you call him.
Uh, what were you saying about the election, Sarah?
I'm saying you better do what you have to do, or you'll be out of office and you know it. Everybody's just waiting to see if you've got the guts to give that salesman his just deserts. If you don't, you'll not only be nosing around the paper mill looking for work, you'll be looking for this nice, big house on the river. And you'll be looking for that big woman. That sailboat you've been dreaming about. And you'll be looking for me.
You, Sarah?
Tom, hold up. I think I'm going to faint.
All right, all right. I'll call him. I won't be married to any mill hand. I married a man I could look up to. A man going places. Sheriff of Lakeville. Sheriff of Grundy County. You're not going to settle for less, Tom Bender. You won't.
Rise and shine, Mr. Tanner.
Leave me alone.
When you roll over, roll out.
I'm not good, Tom. I'm Sheriff Tom's deputy. You get a special appointment for the hanging?
Nope. I've been up river after a guy been dynamiting fish. That's against the law. Almost had him, too. But I got a call from Sheriff Tom to hurry back here and give him a hand.
And you didn't waste no time.
No way. Like Ben Franklin used to say, time is money.
Now, Frank, how much do you weigh?
About 165.
Hey, what's it to you?
Vital statistics. Why are you taking notes?
Data. Vital data.
Vital data? On hanging. Nobody around here, hardly anyone anywhere knows much about hanging. I didn't know anything about it either. Had to check a book on it out of the library. They had a good book on the subject published in England called A Handbook on Hanging. You have to know plenty. You have to be an expert to assure what they call a neat drop. You know? You can't bungle a hanging. You can't have a roughneck job.
A rough job?
Right. Everything's got to be carefully worked out. But you figured it was just a simple job any amateur could pick up on.
I figure you can take your little notebook and get lost.
Oh, now, psychologically speaking, that's the worst thing you can do, Mr. Tanner. Try to dismiss the subject. Try to put it out of your mind. That's bad. You have to think about it in depth. From A to Z.
From A to Z. From A to Z. From A to Z...
Of course not. Sheriff Tom's my uncle. He lets me work for him during summer vacation. But I've never been in on a hangin', so I had to bone up fast. See, it's a delicate problem in logistics, but I'm going to work it down to a T. Now, look. You take weight. Weight is the most crucial data. Every job is different. You always have to figure the weight, the strength of the rope, the number of feet of drop, all like that.
What's that?
This? Oh, it's a chart I got out of the book. You see here? Length of drop in a neat job averages six feet. This varies inversely with the body weight, give or take a few pounds either way. But here, see, you go down the chart here to where it says 165 pounds. You did say 165?
I might be off a few ounces.
Well, it's no matter. I'll make due allowance. Now, you run down the chart here to 165. 165, then mark across to the left-hand column here, and it gives the correct feet of drop. It seems to be approximately three feet. But you're young and strong-built, so here it says you add a foot to make it a four-foot drop.
Get out of here! Get away from me! Get away from me, you computer creep! Get away from me! You control me! You killer! You madman creep!
You got me all wrong! You're worse than me! You're worse than any cold-blooded killer I ever heard of. Weighing a man out like a Christmas turkey. Killing a man for pay.
Me? Oh, no, Mr. Tanner, not me. I wouldn't. I couldn't hang anybody against my moral principle. I'm doing this for you and for Sheriff Tom. He's the one who has to do the hanging.
What? Tom? Oh, sure, he has to do it, but see, he doesn't know anything. He doesn't know anything about it, so I want to make it easy for him. And for you, Mr. Tanner, for all of us, I...
The sheriff? Tom? Oh, the guy. He doesn't like this any more than we do. But he wants to make the best of it. We all want to do that.
No! No, he's... he's my friend. Tom's my friend. He said he'd help me.
Morning, Sheriff Tom.
Morning, Judd. I'm duty-abiding early again, I think. You've got to see that scaffolding's up on schedule, and according to plan, has to be precise on the button.
Mm-hmm. Good to see these days. Young man's so involved.
It doesn't work. Gallows have to be built according to specifications if we want a neat drop.
Hmm. Mighty neat from here. Looks about finished.
Will be today. Had to have an essential heavy crossbeam up there, and then two special fastening bolts terminating in hooks to hold the rope. Blacksmith had to make those up over in Ridgeway, and that trap...
A trap, or a drop, as they call it. That's a very special custom job, too.
Uh, how's that, Judd?
Well, it has to be made of heavy pine fixed in an oak framework. Has to be on a level with the floor, and over a deep pit. Oh, it's gonna be done right, Sheriff Tom. There won't be any slip-ups.
How's our prisoner?
Oh, not good. Not good at all. His morale, I mean.
Well, let's face it. His future's not too bright. I don't think he's made of it.
The right stuff?
You know, I mean, to make a proper adjustment. As long as he has to go, he ought to be more cooperative, more considerate. Want to make it easier for all of us.
It isn't Tom Bender, the friendly sheriff.
Yeah, now, easy, Frank. I just want to have a talk with him.
I don't want to talk to you, you Judas creep.
You have to see my side.
I've seen too much of you already. Going to help me. Going to be my friend. And all... All the time, you're fixing to hang me.
It's... It's supposed to be my job. But I was not lying. And I'll do anything I can to help you. I'm in it. And I still mean it.
Sure. You and that kid computer, you're both going to help me. Stay out of my sight. I won't see you till I have to.
Oh, Sheriff Tom, I forgot to tell you about the rope.
Yeah, yeah. You just listen to your little helper. Huh? What kind of hand would you have without a rope? Huh? What? What about the rope, Judd?
I just wanted you to know we got the best. Had to send over to Ridgeway for it. Had to have the finest hemp that won't shred.
Only the best for me, huh, Judd?
Oh, it is the best. Three-quarter inch rope of five strands of Italian hemp. Like the book says, nothing is so bad as a broken drop.
Yeah, fine, Judd. That's just fine. Come on now, let's move along. And, uh, Frank, uh, you keep the...
There's only one place. In hell!
I might... Quote to all concerned, an old Chinese proverb that of 36 ways to avert disaster, running away is the best. But running appears out of the question for Frank and out of character for Sheriff Bender. We shall learn in Act Three if Frank's desire to see the sheriff in hell is a curse or prophecy.
We all play many roles between birth and death. But it may be a wrong role. And if it is wrong enough, playing it out, it can lead to disaster. Maladjustment, freely translated, means an inability to adjust oneself to circumstances. Desperately, one seeks a way out. Any way at all seems a better way than to go on playing an intolerable part. Then you must change the circumstances. Change them at any cost. It's easier said than done. We commend you to a better world of forgiveness. And to mercy.
What's wrong? Oh, Lord, what's wrong?
Me? Tom. Look, he's still kicking. Too light. Should have had another foot of drop. Get down there, Tom. Down there, into the pit. Hurry, Tom.
In the pit? No. No, I can't.
In the pit. You want him to suffer. His neck's broke. Get down there. Get hold of his feet. He needs more weight, boy. More weight.
I got him. I got him.
That's right. Keep hold of his feet. Pull. Pull harder.
That's right. Hold on. And pull me out. Help me out.
Tom, it's all right. Let me.
I can't breathe.
Now, honey. Tom, honey, you're awake now. I'm here and it's all right now.
I won't do it.
You've just had another of your old night's sweat. But you'll do it when the time comes. You'll face up.
No.
Yes, you will.
No way.
You'll do what you have to.
I don't have to hang that man on anybody. I'm putting in my resignation. I'm going to tell Seth Boney to take this sheriff's badge and choke on it.
Please. You're going to put my eye out.
Sheriff's. I'm sorry. I didn't mean it. What's got into you? You're acting crazy. Crazy as a loon.
I said I was sorry. But now I've got to go to court.
You picked up that badge. Put it on the bureau and come back to bed.
Being sheriff was your idea in the first place, not mine. I'm getting out.
You mean running away.
Get out. Back to sleep. That's payable. I can get it cheaper and I'm going.
You are going to stay sheriff of Lakeville or I'll make a little call to Seth Boney myself. And to the county. I'm a county prosecutor.
What would you have talked to them about?
You know.
Know what?
What I can tell them.
What would you tell them?
Why, I'd remind them of those sales of all that land down the river. Where the new superhighway's cutting through. Those illegal contracts with the harbor construction outfit. And all those other payoffs and dirty deals. I know all about them, Tom. All those debts you was running up for this. This house. That, that new car. And I figured I had to do something. Anything to hang on. And you went along. You went along, Sarah. And, and now you do this to me.
Yes, you try me, mister. You want to walk out and ruin everything I've planned on? You go ahead. And I'll ruin you, too.
Is it enough to hang a man without having to talk about it?
Uh, the talk's about done. Time for action. I'm going to bail you out.
Sure you are. The moon's going to turn to green cheese.
No, no. I mean it. We're breaking out. I'm a man of my word. You ought to have seen that.
Susan Hammond.
Frank, listen. What'd I say? You'll be out of here and long gone. Free as a whistle.
Fooling, are you?
I am not fooling. What I had to figure out was how to get out of the hanging.
Oh, what's my chances of getting out of this country?
From this brig, nothing. Drop down. This is quick. Two weeks. Two months is quick. Two miles out. Right under the west side of that little bridge.
From who?
I'll be there for you. That's it. I'm not your buddy, Sheriff. My old friend, Tom. There's any bridges near there, old buddy Tom?
Just this road and the dog.
Frank.
Huh?
What held you up?
Oh. Tom. Thank the Lord. I thought, I thought you—
What happened?
My leg. I hurt it bad. Maybe broken. But it's no big deal.
You tell me, what's the big deal?
Oh, it's nothing.
Well? Now, how'd you manage that?
Well, they'd dropped out the window. Getting out was easy, but it was a long drop down into the weeds. And I landed on a rock. My foot's been wet.
Can you get over a ways to the river?
I don't know. It's no more than 50 yards.
You've got to make it.
All right. All right. Sure, Tom. I can do it.
This path goes through the willows to the riverbank. Robo's tied up there. Go down the river a mile. Stay close to this right bank. You'll see a white boat landing.
It'll be shining clear in the moonlight. It goes up to a big white house. Can't miss it. Pull in there. Let the boat go on down the river. Two miles down over Cawood Falls. It's going to be so snug and safe in that half. Why, sure. You'll hold up there a while until the chase cools off. I'll pick you up with some clothes and travel money. Find a way to get you over. The last place anybody would look for you would be...
Are you here, Tom? Lord, this is good. What a relief. Those dogs, they sure threw a fit when they lost me on the river.
Yeah, nothing much meaning the dog back. Sure, it's in bad shape. It's all swollen. Tom, I haven't been able to do something about it.
Yeah, we're going to do something about it. Okay. Now, you see I'm going to hide out here someplace?
Where's the wife?
Uh, that's her. That's her. Where? I don't, I don't... lying there by the table.
Oh, blood. What's she doing lying there?
Waiting. There was an accident. She's waiting for the undertaker.
What are you doing? Stand right there, Frank. Don't move now.
What's the gun for?
Just don't move or try anything. It's a lost cause.
What's this about? Who are you calling?
We had a misunderstanding, the wife and I. I hit her. Lost my temper and hit her. Might too hard. It was an accident. You know about accidents. You killed her.
But I really didn't mean to do it. I was...
Hello, State Trooper's Office. This is Sheriff Tom Bender over in Lakeville. Right. We had a man jump jail here during the early morning hours. Right, right. A man named Frank Tanner. Well, I just got back to my house, and I'm calling from there now. Tanner was waiting here for me. Yeah, must have known how to find my place. I guess he figured he used my wife as a hostage. That's right. Right. Yeah. But looks like she put up a fight, and he killed her. That's right. Tanner killed my wife. Right. Oh, yeah. He's here, and I got him covered. Right, Lieutenant. You best run right over here and pick him up. He's a mad dog killer, and liable to do anything.
You... you just... I know what it's like in jail, Frank. I've been there a long time. See, I never wanted to be sheriff. I'd have been long gone if it hadn't been for Sarah. What I always wanted was a boat, a Tahiti-rigged ketch. Something to haul deck cargo over on the go. That's all I've ever wanted.
I am missing, but Sheriff Tom, he would have gotten away with pinning his wife's murder on that escaped killer, Frank Tanner. Mighty clever idea, no doubt about it. But there happened to be a witness to the sheriff killing her just a few minutes before Tanner got there.
Yep. That was some break, Judge. How'd it happen?
There was a doctor, old Doc Crowell. She was always complaining. Complaining about bad headaches, always running Doc Crowell out with prescriptions. She ordered some medicine delivered about an hour before the sheriff killed her. Doc was a little late to help his patient.
Now, what we have to do here is, we've got to find someone to hang the sheriff.
Sheriff Bender, driven by desperation to play the extreme role of killer, might have gotten away with pinning his wife's murder on the hapless scapegoat, Frank Tanner. But it is with murder, as it is in a theater, bad timing can be a fatal flaw. And there happened to be a witness to the sheriff killing his wife just a few minutes before Tanner arrived. It was the sheriff's doctor.
I'll be back shortly.
Of course, I do not recommend crime, especially the perfect crime. For one thing, perfection has its imperfections. And no matter how... you find the crime, the punishment meted for it will be the same as for just any run-of-the-mill felony. Which returns us to the enigma presented in Act One. Now, we must find someone to hang the sheriff.
No one is born a hero. But if he becomes one, it is only through the forces of fear and circumstances. Perhaps those same forces can turn any one of us into a killer or a hangman.
Our casting included Fred Gwynne, Elspeth Eric, Bernard Grant, and Russell Horton. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown.
Radio Mystery Theater was sponsored in part by Raven House Paperback Mysteries.
This is Tammy Grimes, inviting you to return to our Mystery Theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time.
