The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 30 min to read
Mystery Theater.
Welcome. Welcome to the Mystery Theater. I'm Hyman Brown. There are people who seem to bestow happiness and good fortune upon all whom they encounter. Their very presence is an enchanted thing. However, just as there are those who bring the sunshine, there are also those who bring the rain. And not just the occasional refreshing sprinkle or the useful beneficial shower, but a cloudburst. Is there really, truly such a thing as a jinx? Is our fate cast forever at the moment of conception?
They die because I fall in love with them. Yeah, it's that simple.
But you haven't told me how it works, Lieutenant.
Well, I don't know how it works. It's nothing you can prove. But whenever you fall in love with a man, it seems he dies.
And I kill them?
Well, they... they die. It's a matter of statistics. Four men have been engaged to you. All four died of various causes. But there's one constant. You were in love with each other.
Really?
Yes, Miss Butler. Just because you fell in love with them, they're dead?
Well then, Lieutenant, be very careful. I just might fall in love with you.
Our mystery drama, "The Lady Is a Jinx," was written especially for the Mystery Theater by Sam Dann and stars Larry Haines and Marian Seldes. I'll be back shortly with Act One.
If you could know the last day, the last hour, the last minute of your life, would you want to?
Kevin Lindstrom never thought much about that. Never thought much about such a thing. Why be concerned with death when death is over and the waiting is done? Never thought much about such a thing. Why be concerned with the coming dawn and having mysterious moments like this all my life? Seems very strange to me. Like ornaments for life. And what you pressured him to take far too good an implement. Ah, I die. Why he tired? But he doesn't own us. Your way into this silent loneliness while there is so much to live for, especially now that he's about to marry Caroline Butler. Lovely Caroline, the golden girl. This is his last night as a bachelor, and Kevin walks home from Caroline's house, as the poet would say, in a transport of delight. The moon is shining, the stars are winking, and perhaps that is why Kevin does not notice the car that has silently rounded the corner and is pulling up alongside him. And even if he did notice, there would be absolutely nothing he could do about it, because the man sitting next to the driver has thrust the muzzle of a submachine gun out the window.
This was swift, even merciful. He never heard the shot. He never knew what hit him.
Are you Lieutenant Pirelli? They said you were in charge of the investigation.
Can I help you? I thought I might be able to help you.
Oh, well, if you have any information that could lead to the apprehension of the killer or killers of Mr. Kevin Lindstrom, we'd appreciate it.
My name is Martha Lindstrom. I'm Kevin's sister.
Lindstrom. Your brother was killed by accident.
I'm not so sure of that.
Miss Lindstrom, he bears... he bore a remarkable resemblance to a hoodlum named Jack Mace. It was uncanny. Certain people were out to get Jack Mace.
I don't think it happened that way, Lieutenant.
Miss Lindstrom, this was supposed to be a gangster execution. It went wrong.
I wish I could believe that. Your brother wasn't a member of the underworld. You must admit that.
Yes.
Nor would the underworld have any reason for killing him, as far as we know.
Lieutenant Pirelli...
And furthermore, this Jack Mace is known to have lived in the neighborhood. So the executioner was sent to... dispatch him. And in the darkness, your brother looked enough like Jack...
Everything you're telling me has already been printed by the newspaper.
Well, it's a matter of time, but we'll find out who's responsible for your brother's death.
But I know who's responsible.
Surely, Miss Lindstrom, you're not an expert in the machinations of the local underworld.
I have a problem, Lieutenant.
Oh, and what's that?
My problem isn't a what, it's a who. You are my problem, Lieutenant. You, as a representative of authority, are my problem. You're nice, you're polite, but you can't wait to get rid of me. You believe I'm wasting your time.
Well, you said you know who's responsible for your brother's death.
Yes, but how can I get you to believe what I'm about to tell you?
All right, why not tell me and see how it works out?
Very well. The killer of my brother, Kevin Lindstrom, is his fiancée, Carolyn Butler.
Yes?
That's my statement.
So what you're saying is that Miss Carolyn Butler somehow or other obtained possession of a .45 caliber Thompson submachine gun and with this weapon murdered Kevin Lindstrom.
No, that's not what I'm saying.
Well, if that's not what you're saying, you can't say Carolyn Butler is the killer. Your brother died of multiple bullet wounds.
I tell you, Carolyn killed him.
According to the coroner's report...
I don't care about the coroner's report.
Let's just... Oh, good Lord. You think I'm crazy.
Well, everyone says... entitled to her own opinion. But an opinion's always worth more if it's based on a fact.
Fact? Yes, that's a sacred word. Yes. What's a fact? Now, stay with me, Lieutenant. A fact is merely an assumption that is legitimized by custom or convenience or the will of the majority. Now, I shall give you a fact. Carolyn Butler has been engaged four times. Not one engagement has ever been consummated by marriage. Each engagement has been terminated by the abrupt and violent death of her prospective bridegroom. Now, what do you say to that?
Well, I would say, uh... it's a coincidence. Now, Miss Lindstrom... I know you're eager to get rid of me, and I'm going. But please, Lieutenant, read what I have in this envelope. I'll leave it with you, but promise that you'll read it.
Well, it's our duty to consider all relevant information.
Really read it. And if you need further details, my name and address are all on the back of that envelope.
I didn't know you were...
I'm a Ph.D. I teach economics at State U.
Oh. Well... Now, you don't know what to say. You don't know what to make of it. You were prepared to write me off as a nut, but a doctor, a college professor, a teacher of a sober science like economics.
I... I, uh...
Inspector, what do you think?
Vince, what I think is you ought to put in for some leave. You got plenty of time coming.
Oh, I see. If you believe a word of this, you gotta be as nutty as she is.
Maybe it's my fault. I think I've been working you too hard.
Did you read what she wrote?
Every single word. This dame, Carolyn Butler, has been engaged four times. Every fiancé meets with a violent death.
That's right.
So what? Miss Carolyn Butler never killed any of them herself. She didn't kill her latest. The guy before was an innocent bystander during a bank hold-up. Then there was the guy who was a reserve officer and got killed accidentally on maneuvers. The first guy was scuba diving and he made a meal for a shark.
Inspector, didn't you read what Miss... what Dr. Lindstrom wrote in her analysis?
Are you sweet on this dame, Vince?
Oh, come on, Jake.
Why not? You're 35. You ought to be married. I know your mom is a great cook, but you want to cut that cord.
When something occurs with regularity, persistence, predictability, it must be classified as fact.
Maybe this is the kind of a dame you've been looking for all your life. Your studious intellectual type.
Jake, Jake, you're not listening to me.
You're in love with her.
Oh, for crying out loud.
Don't you understand, Vince? It's love. Love at first sight. This dame knocked you out the split second you saw her.
She isn't even my type.
Famous last words. So you figure, how can I score with her? And her life? Pretend to believe her.
Okay, okay, Inspector Coleman. If you want the truth, I can't remember what that dame even looks like.
Which happened to be true. Weeks later, we bagged the machine gunner and that was the end of the Kevin Lindstrom murder case. And after a while, I forgot all about it. Until...
Lieutenant.
Oh. Oh, Miss, uh, Dr. Lindstrom. What can I do for you?
Sit down, please.
Thank you, Lieutenant. I, uh, I want to apologize. I was angry last time. And I realize now, of course, it's easy to ridicule the police. But if I was sitting in your chair and someone told me the story that I told you, well, of course, I...
All right. How can I help you, Doctor?
Did you by any chance read the Post yesterday? There was an item on the Society page.
Well, I don't usually read the Society...
Well, I took it out. I'm sure you'll find it of interest.
Okay.
Please, read all of it.
It says the engagement of her daughter, Carolyn Joy... Mr. Charles Morton Russell, noted actor, son of Mr. and Mrs. Stanley K. Russell. Couple plan to marry Sunday, June 8th at St. Bartholomew's Church.
Yes. Now, that's exactly eight weeks from yesterday. I'm asking you, Lieutenant Pirelli, can we permit this young man to die?
Damn it. I've already told you what happens to the men who are engaged to this woman just before the wedding. They die suddenly, violently.
We've been through this before, Doctor.
Can you take the chance?
I propose that the police alert this young man and see if reason cannot prevail on him to break this engagement.
Now, Doctor Lindstrom, the police do not have nor do they want the right to tell people they can't get married.
Now, Doctor Lindstrom, I'm trying to be sympathetic to your problem.
It's not my problem. It's your problem, Lieutenant. What will your position be if this young man also dies before the wedding?
Well, of course. You have no answer. You see, you're accustomed to handling regular, predictable problems. And when something of a completely alien aspect emerges, you're helpless.
Now, look, I appreciate how you feel. I wish there was something I could do for you.
But I want to do something for you. We are moving more and more into a psychic age. Now, just bear me out. Now, till now, the police have operated on a superficial level. External evidence. The power to kill with a gun or a knife. The power to kill with a weapon. But now, there are people who can kill through the force of the mind.
Doctor Lindstrom.
I know. I'm very busy. I know. But she has it. Carolyn Butler has it. She may not be aware of it, but it emanates from her and it expresses itself through a predatory shark or an imperfect missile, a hoodlum in a bank, a button man. That's the right term, I hope.
Doctor Lindstrom, I don't want to be impolite.
Be impolite. Be anything you want. Be open-minded. You're asking me to do something and I don't have the authority.
Well, who does? Who would have the authority to assign round-the-clock guards to this Charles Russell?
The inspector.
Lieutenant, admit there is something, no matter how far-fetched, to what I propose?
Well...
You know there is. So it's your duty to try to convince your superior.
Doctor Lindstrom, what you're asking is highly...
I know. I know. But suppose you do nothing and this man dies the way all the others did.
You sure got it bad, Vince.
Inspector, will you get it through your skull? This girl, this lady means nothing to me personally. I'm not trying to score a point. Now, suppose there is something to this story. Okay, suppose there is. Well, then we've got to do something to stop it.
We're not set up to stop it. I have no way of justifying this kind of expenditure.
Okay, okay. Here's a girl who obviously has found some way to get people killed. Now, can she be allowed to get away with murder?
Yes, sir. Until somebody can furnish legally acceptable proof, this Butler dame will get away with murder.
Well, does she or doesn't she? Are we dealing with coincidence or with fact? Or how many coincidences do you need to add up to a fact? And our good Inspector Coleman has also enlightened us on another point. If you can find a way to kill someone that is not specifically prohibited by law, you can theoretically get away with murder.
I'm going to get away for just a few moments and then Mystery Theater will return with Act Two.
His hands twitch. Well, that's not a sign of death.
Blowing his lines. The other actors are covering for him.
Well, he's nervous. Maybe he's worried about getting married tomorrow.
He is not worried. He is being drained of his life force.
Look, if you think he's sick, call a doctor. If you think he's in danger, hire a bodyguard. But don't ask me to sit here and watch a man die of stage fright.
Then watch him die of something else.
The curtain comes down for intermission. Russell goes to his dressing room. I go backstage, flash my badge, talk my way in. The door to his room is open. I hear voices. Carolyn Butler is in there with him.
Charles, darling, you're magnificent.
I was terrible. I couldn't remember my lines.
You were wonderful. Everyone thinks so.
No, I wasn't. I was... I was...
Charles, what's wrong?
I don't know. I feel so strange. As if... as if something is pulling at me. Something is draining me.
You're just tired. The wedding tomorrow, the play...
No, it's not that. It's her. She's doing this to me.
Who?
Martha. Martha Lindstrom. She's been following me. She's been watching me. She's been...
Charles, stop it. You're talking nonsense.
I saw her in the audience tonight. I know I did. And she was looking at me with those eyes. Those terrible eyes.
Charles, you're imagining things.
No, I'm not. She's a witch. She's put a curse on me. I know she has.
Charles, listen to me. Martha Lindstrom is a sick, jealous woman. She couldn't hurt a fly.
Then why do I feel this way? Why do I feel as if I'm dying?
You're not dying. You're going to marry me tomorrow and we're going to be so happy.
I don't know if I can go through with it.
What?
The wedding. I don't know if I can...
Charles, don't say that. Don't even think it.
I can't help it. Every time I think about tomorrow, I feel this coldness. This emptiness.
That's just nerves. Everyone feels that way before their wedding.
Not like this. This is different. This is...
What? What is it?
Death. I smell death. I smell my own death.
Charles, stop it! Stop talking like that!
I can't help it. I know it's coming. I know she's going to kill me.
No one is going to kill you. I won't let them.
You can't stop it. No one can stop it. It's already begun.
Then I hear something. A sound from the hallway. I look out. Dr. Lindstrom is standing there, her face white, her eyes fixed on the door.
You see? You see the signs?
I see a man who's upset. That's all I see.
He's not upset. He's being called. The gods are calling him.
Dr. Lindstrom, I'm going to have to ask you to leave. Now.
I won't leave. Not while he's in danger.
If you don't leave, I'll have you arrested.
Arrested? For what? For trying to save a man's life?
For disturbing the peace. For harassment. For anything I can think of.
You don't understand. You don't understand anything.
I understand that you're frightening that man half to death with your talk of curses and gods and death. Now go home, Doctor. Go home and leave these people alone.
She looks at me for a long moment. Then she turns and walks away, her shoulders straight, her head high. But I can see her hands are shaking.
I go back to my seat. The second act begins. Russell comes on stage. He looks better now, more composed. The wedding scene. He takes the actress's hands.
Do you take this woman to be your lawful wedded wife?
I do.
And do you take this man...
Then it happens. A light fixture, one of those heavy old stage lights, breaks loose from its rigging. It falls straight down. Russell looks up, throws the actress aside, and the light crashes down where they had been standing.
The theater erupts in chaos. Screaming, shouting, people rushing the stage. I push my way through, flash my badge, get to Russell. He's on the floor, the actress in his arms. She's crying. He's shaking.
I saw it. I saw it coming. I don't know how, but I saw it.
You're all right. You're both all right.
It would have killed us. It would have killed us both.
But it didn't. You're safe.
He looks up at me, his eyes wide and strange.
Safe? No. Not safe. She won't stop. She'll never stop until I'm dead.
Who? Who won't stop?
Martha. Martha Lindstrom. She did this. I know she did.
Dr. Lindstrom was in her seat the whole time. I saw her.
Then how? How did she do it?
It was an accident, Mr. Russell. A piece of faulty equipment. It happens.
No. Not an accident. Never an accident. Not with her.
I help him up, get him to his dressing room. Carolyn Butler is there, white-faced, clinging to him.
Charles, Charles, I thought you were dead. I thought you were dead.
I'm all right. I'm all right.
What happened? What really happened?
I don't know. I don't know anything anymore.
I leave them there, go back to find Dr. Lindstrom. She's gone. Her seat is empty. I ask the usher, he says she left right after the accident, walking fast, almost running.
I drive to her apartment. The lights are on. I ring the bell. No answer. I ring again. Finally, the door opens. She looks older than I remember, tired, defeated.
You came to arrest me?
No. I came to ask you some questions.
I didn't touch that light. I didn't go near it.
I know. I saw you in your seat.
Then why are you here?
Because I want to understand. I want to understand what you think is happening here.
She steps back, lets me in. The apartment is small, crowded with books, papers, strange objects I don't recognize. A skull on one shelf, crystals, dried herbs.
You think I'm a witch too.
I think you're a woman who believes something very strongly. I want to know why.
She sits down, gestures for me to do the same.
My brother Kevin was the gentlest man I ever knew. Not weak, but gentle. He believed in goodness, in kindness, in love. He thought Carolyn Butler loved him.
Didn't she?
She loved what he represented. The hero. The good man. But once she had him, once she was engaged to him, he had to become something more. A martyr. A sacrifice.
To what?
To the old gods. To the forces that work through women like her.
Dr. Lindstrom, I've been a policeman for twenty years. I've seen every kind of killing there is. I've never seen one that couldn't be explained by human motives. Greed, jealousy, rage, fear. Never gods.
Then you've been fortunate. Or blind.
Maybe. But I know this. Carolyn Butler didn't make that light fall tonight. No one made it fall. It was old, it was poorly maintained, and it broke.
And Charles Russell? What about him? Will he survive his wedding night?
I don't know.
I do. He won't. Unless I can stop her.
How? How can you stop her?
I don't know yet. But I will find a way. I must find a way.
I leave her there, surrounded by her books and her beliefs, and I drive home through empty streets. I think about what she said, about old gods and sacrifices and women who find heroes and watch them die. I think about Carolyn Butler, so beautiful, so reasonable, so convincing. And I think about Martha Lindstrom, so certain, so desperate, so alone.
The next morning, I'm at my desk early. Jake comes in with coffee and the morning paper.
Hey, Lieutenant, you hear about Russell?
What?
Called off the wedding. Says he's too sick to go through with it.
Sick?
That's what it says. Nervous exhaustion. Doctor's orders.
I read the article. It's brief, discreet. Charles Morton Russell, due to marry Miss Carolyn Butler today, has postponed the ceremony indefinitely due to illness.
I drive to his apartment. The doorman says he's not seeing anyone. I show my badge, he lets me up. Russell answers the door in a dressing gown, unshaven, hollow-eyed.
Lieutenant. I was hoping you'd come.
Can I come in?
Please. Please, I need to talk to someone.
The apartment is expensive, tasteful, empty of personal touches. He pours himself a drink, offers me one. I refuse.
I couldn't do it. I couldn't marry her.
Why?
I kept seeing that light falling. I kept seeing myself dead. And then I'd see her face, Carolyn's face, and she'd be smiling. Smiling at my funeral.
That's not rational, Mr. Russell.
I know. I know it's not. But I couldn't help it. Every time I thought about being with her, I felt this... this coldness. This certainty that something terrible would happen.
So you called off the wedding.
I had to. For my own sanity. For my life, maybe.
What does Miss Butler say?
She's furious. She says I've humiliated her. She says she never wants to see me again.
And how do you feel about that?
Relieved. Terribly, guiltily relieved.
I stay a while longer, ask more questions, get the same answers. When I leave, he's drinking again, but he looks better than he did last night. Less frightened, more resigned.
I go to see Carolyn Butler. She lives in a smaller apartment, not as expensive, but well-furnished. She receives me coldly.
So you've come to gloat? To tell me I told you so?
No. I've come to ask you some questions.
I have nothing to say to the police. Charles Russell made a fool of me. He led me to believe he loved me, he wanted to marry me, and then at the last moment, he backed out. Because of that woman. That insane, jealous woman.
Dr. Lindstrom?
Who else? She's poisoned his mind against me. She's made him believe I'm some kind of monster.
Has she threatened you? Physically, I mean?
No. She doesn't need to. Her words are enough. Her terrible, crazy words.
Miss Butler, four men you were engaged to have died. Doesn't that seem strange to you?
I've explained that. I've explained it over and over. They were men who took risks. Men with death wishes.
And Mr. Russell? Does he have a death wish?
He did. Until she got to him. Now he's just a frightened child, hiding in his apartment, afraid of shadows.
She paces the room, her golden hair catching the light, her blue eyes bright with anger. Beautiful, yes. But something else too. Something I can't quite name.
What do you want from me, Lieutenant?
I want to know if you're going to try to see Mr. Russell again.
Why? Are you going to stop me?
I might. If I think you're harassing him.
Harassing him? I love him. I wanted to marry him. How is that harassment?
When the other person doesn't want it, it can be.
She stops pacing, looks at me directly.
You believe her. You believe that crazy woman.
I don't know what I believe. But I know that Charles Russell is alive today because he didn't marry you. And I know that four other men aren't alive, and they all did.
Coincidence. Terrible, tragic coincidence.
Maybe. But I'm going to be watching you, Miss Butler. Very carefully.
I leave her there, her anger palpable, her beauty undimmed. And I wonder, not for the first time, what I really believe.
That night, I go to see Dr. Lindstrom again. She's different now, more animated, almost hopeful.
He called off the wedding. You know that?
I know.
He's safe. For now.
For now?
She won't stop. She'll find another way. Another man.
Then what do we do?
We wait. We watch. And we hope that next time, we can stop her before it's too late.
Dr. Lindstrom, I have to tell you something. I'm not sure I believe your theory about gods and sacrifices. But I believe you care about saving lives. And I believe something strange is happening around Carolyn Butler. So I'm going to help you watch. I'm going to help you wait.
She looks at me for a long moment, then extends her hand. I take it. Her grip is firm, her palm dry and warm.
Thank you, Lieutenant. Thank you.
We sit there in her crowded apartment, two people who shouldn't be allies, bound together by uncertainty and the shadow of something neither of us fully understands. Outside, the city moves on, indifferent to our fears, our hopes, our fragile alliance.
And so we wait. And we watch. And somewhere in the darkness, Carolyn Butler moves through the world, beautiful and terrible, seeking her next hero, her next sacrifice, her next bridegroom for the old gods who may or may not exist, who may or may not act through her, who may or may not be waiting in the shadows for the next man brave enough, foolish enough, doomed enough to love her.
This is E. G. Marshall inviting you to return to our Mystery Theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant dreams.
He shouldn't be on the stage.
Then why did they let him go on?
Well, tomorrow, after his marriage, he'll go on vacation. They just want to get all the performances they can out of him.
Banged his leg against that chair and now he puts it down. He's going to lift another. What a piece of business, isn't it?
No. Heaven would do that to him. The life seems to be draining out of him. He's losing his line. I did steal. Now look. That cigarette he put down. Now it's rolling off the table into that pile of papers and rubbish. Starting to smoke.
Because of the fire.
Well, maybe that's supposed to be a part of the play.
Ladies and gentlemen, please stay in your seats. There's no danger. There is no danger.
Look, Lieutenant. Look at what happened.
Danger of fire on stage. A stagehand immediately cuts the rope that holds the heavy asbestos curtain in place. The curtain comes crashing down and anybody who might be standing on a spot where it falls can be killed if it hits them.
Your girlfriend, Dr. Lindstrom, was right.
Inspector, she's not my girl.
Ah, quit fighting her. I believe her.
You believe her?
Yeah. After a while, you have to see the light. Carolyn Butler's doing something to these guys. What or how, I don't know. But they die. They all die the night before they get married.
Okay, she'll kill them. So what are you going to do about it?
Nothing.
You mean you believe it and you're not going to do anything about it?
There's lots of things we can't do anything about. A lot of people get away with murder. We know they're guilty, but we can't touch them.
The girl seemed so, so sincere. I was thinking, but it was something I never felt before. Couldn't even explain it. It got hold of me and somehow or other, here I was, ringing a doorbell.
Lieutenant Pryor, see, I remembered your name. May I come in, Miss Butler?
Miss Butler. I may very well remain Miss Butler for the rest of my life.
Yes, please come in. Thank you. I really think I have set a record for engagements. Do they keep such records, I wonder? Won't you sit down? Drink?
Uh, no, thank you.
Oh, I'm sorry. I should have realized you're on duty.
Well, uh, to tell the absolute truth.
The absolute truth. I like that.
I'm, uh, I'm not really on duty.
Oh?
Yeah, I just dropped by to see how you're doing.
Oh, that's very kind of you.
Yeah, and, uh, I was wondering if, uh, if you had any plans for dinner.
If so happens, I do.
Oh, well, maybe some other time.
But I intend to change them. I would much rather have dinner with you.
Oh. I have this weakness, I told you, for strong men. Tight men.
Oh, I'm not really an exciting person.
And modest men. To you, I suppose, danger and excitement are the everyday, ordinary, commonplaces of your job.
Yeah.
We talked about it at dinner that night, so we continued the following night and the one after that. We were having dinner together regularly, and I kind of liked that. We also discovered that both of us like to hunt, fish, ride horses, climb mountains.
You're a sly one, Vince. I have to find out about it by reading the paper?
Find out what?
Yeah. Pirelli Butler. Mrs. William Stephen Butler announces the engagement of her daughter, Carolyn Joy, to Police Lieutenant Anthony Pirelli, son of Mrs. Serafina Pirelli.
Vince, how could you do this to me?
You want to be my best man, Jake?
Sure, if you live that long.
Now, that's nonsense and you know it.
There was a time you didn't believe it was nonsense.
Jake, all that was before I knew her. She's so wonderful, so filled with life, so generous, so, so, so good.
When is the happy event?
A week from Sunday.
So soon. I, uh, I can only wish you the best.
Okay, okay, I'm up. What's, what's the matter, Jake?
It's ten o'clock. You were due here at eight.
Ten o'clock? It can't be ten o'clock. Vince, we gotta go see the commissioner. You get dressed and get down here.
Vince, what's wrong with you this morning?
Wrong? Nothing. What could be wrong?
First, you overslept, and you're two hours late. That never happened before. And just now with the commissioner. You're in line to make Captain of Detectives. I could see he really wasn't very much impressed.
What do you mean?
He asked you about some ideas for increased efficiency, and you just sat there.
Yeah, yeah. Funny thing, Jake, I, uh, I don't know what happened to me, but my mind seemed to go blank.
I think you better see a doctor.
Why?
You've been acting strange all week, absent-minded, forgetful. Now, look, tomorrow's Sunday, your wedding day. Now, why don't you go and leave right now? Go home, you're nervous. I'll see you tomorrow, but Jake.
No, no, no, no, that isn't right. You're shorthanded. I'll, I'll tell you what I'll do. I, uh, I gotta put in my shift on the state car. I can spare a lieutenant for that.
Yeah, but Smitty's been on for 24 hours.
Uh, let me send him home. I'll, I'll stay till midnight.
Well, okay, he would really appreciate it.
Inspector Coleman?
Yes, ma'am, can I help you?
Yes, I'm Martha Lindstrom.
Oh, we meet at last.
It's about Lieutenant Pirelli.
I know.
What do you know?
Your concern. You're afraid he'll die tonight, and that he'll be number six.
Well, aren't you concerned?
Yeah.
Well, how can you just sit there?
Well, what can I do?
Talk to him.
I have talked to him.
You can't just let him be killed.
Dr. Lindstrom, if there's anything to what you're saying, you know it has to be.
Must be some way to protect him.
You, you're in love with him, aren't you?
Well, I don't think that's germane to this discussion.
Well, tonight, he's as safe as he can be. Before midnight, Vince will die.
Well, I don't know anything we can do.
He's been acting strangely, hasn't he?
Well, yeah. Yeah, and that's how it happened to all of them. They lose their perception, their critical judgment, so death can overtake them.
But what can happen to Vince? Who knows?
Well, there's only one way to save him. Where is he?
He's parked over there, across the street.
Vince? Vince? Vince?
Well, I told you to go home, Vince.
And he's asleep on duty.
Oh, I'm okay. Jake, I just closed my eyes for a second.
Lieutenant.
What?
Doctor, what are you doing here?
I want to save your life.
What are you talking about?
Break your engagement. That way you're safe. You're no longer her hero, her intended. She no longer has to bring you to Valhalla, the place for heroes.
Jake, what are you doing here with her?
Remember, Charles Russell, you saw him die.
That was an accident.
Yes, because he couldn't think straight. He couldn't hear, he couldn't think. He was half dead before that asbestos curtain hit him, and you're half dead now.
I'm okay.
Recognize Carolyn Butler for what she is. She's beautiful. It's the face of death.
I do love her.
How can you love her?
I love death. You love life. You love me.
I love you.
Say you love me and you're free from her. Say it. Say it before it's too late. Say you love me.
Hey, that guy driving the truck is acting crazy.
Say you love me.
Hey, he's gonna hit the car, Vince. Get out.
Say you love me.
I love you.
Say you love me.
I love you.
I'll be back shortly with a final thought.
Ring became number six because he broke the engagement in the nick of time. Or maybe because the truck driver was able to apply his brakes in time. We always give you more than one perspective on Mystery Theater. However, Miss Caroline Butler is still around, still looking for a hero. So, you are a hero? What can we tell you? Our cast included Larry Haines, Marian Seldes, Patricia Elliott, and Dan Ocko, associate director Marlo Sweet. This is Himan Brown, producer-director, inviting you to return to our Mystery Theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time then, pleasant dreams.
