The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 25 min to read
Getter presents, I'm E.G. Marshall. Good luck is a giddy maid, fickle and restless as a fawn. She smooths your hair, and then the jade kisses you quickly, and is gone. But Madame Bad Luck scorns all this. She shows no eagerness for flitting, but the long and fervent kiss sits by your bed and brings her knitting. And so, you have them, the Luck Sisters, good and bad. Two ladies who cannot be wooed or courted. They pick and choose their own time and place. If only we knew how to capture one and escape the other.
If it's wrong. I know. It's indecent. I agree. It's immoral. Admit. Murder can never be justified for any reason. That's a fact. Why? Read to it.
Our mystery drama, The Luck Sisters, was written especially for the Mystery Theater by Sam Dan and stars Fred Gwynne. It is sponsored in part by Buick Motor Division. I'll be back shortly with Act One.
When you add up the minutes, something less than an hour to relate our stories. And most of the time, it's enough. We usually attempt to tell a tight and taut little tale that honors the Aristotelian strictures for the unities of time, place, and character. However, every now and then, we come up with what can only be called a saga. A saga. An epic that sprawls across a vast and multicolored canvas, rolling, rollicking, swashbuckling, filled with violence, intrigue, conflict, adventure, and sex. Well, what you are about to hear may qualify as a saga.
Ladies and gentlemen, I am in the town of Bulwer, high in this rocky mountain valley. Bulwer is hardly more than a hamlet. It was on its way to becoming a ghost town when suddenly an enormous vein of gold was discovered in an abandoned mine. Right now, this little village has just about been invaded by the news media. I believe we even outnumber the residents. But those residents of Bulwer, the 100 registered, tax-paying, and voting citizens of Bulwer, will each become a millionaire because the mine itself is owned by the town of Bulwer.
Let us rejoin the press conference outside the store of Mayor Jefferson McDowell, who is also the town barber.
Yes, sir. The town is named after Major Poindexter Bulwer, who was adjutant to General Grant. It later came out he was a speculator in army supplies and stole a million dollars.
That's Major Bulwer, not General Grant. But by that time, he was dead.
Mr. Mayor, what about the mine?
It's the old Bulwer mine. The town grew up all around it. It never was worth much. Mine, I mean.
How did the town get possession?
Well, after Major Bulwer died, and without issue, I might say, the town took it over for back taxes.
Mr. Mayor, what would you say this new discovery means to the citizens of Bulwer?
Well, it means once we get her into production, everybody in Bulwer is going to become a millionaire.
How was it discovered that there was gold in the mine? She's been abandoned almost 100 years.
Then, little Billy Blackburn found a shaft. When they dug him up, there was all this gold dust.
Do you think this will change the people in this town?
Now, if you were to become a millionaire, wouldn't it change...
Supper. Yeah, yeah. Let's eat.
Jeff, something's wrong.
Maybe it's not true. The mine doesn't belong to the town. We're not going to be rich.
The mine does belong to the town, and the town can distribute the revenue from it any way it sees fit.
Jeff, are you trying to tell me maybe it all isn't on the level somehow? Maybe there's no gold?
Nope. As far as we know, there's gold. An engineer might even rival the Comstock Lode, that look on your face. Oh, I see. I think I do. That lovely, decent little town transformed suddenly into a... What can I call it? A flesh pot filled with neon light. The pure, fresh air poisoned by smoke and pollution. Bulwer will become a city with all those urban problems. Juvenile delinquency, crime, prostitution and the like. That's what's bothering you, isn't it?
No.
It isn't? I care what happens to Bulwer.
We're spending our time in sunny Spain, in the Riviera in Florida. We have an apartment in New York. Are you crazy?
No, Maria.
There you maintain a certain standard of living. Well, I never get to the point. Afraid to tell you. Whatever else you may be, one thing you are not is afraid.
Maria, maybe. I guess. What are you expecting? I don't know. I don't understand.
No, no. You're starting to scare me. You're the most level-headed person I know. What's bothering you?
Something bad is going to happen.
Why? Why do you say that?
Because it's the history of this town. Bad follows good like night follows day.
I'm not sure I understand.
Yeah, well, look. Go back to the beginning. The town is named after a civil war hero.
Mm-hmm.
It later turns out he's a crook. He's the location of a great new gold. Like Sutter's Mill or the Klondike. Turns out to be a false alarm.
Oh, right. But that's all ancient history.
Granted. The history of the last 20 years. 500 jobs. Oh, well, I don't believe they were serious.
What are you talking about? They already started digging the foundation.
Well, that doesn't prove anything.
And the Air Force was going to put up a base on Spencer's Plateau.
Well, that wasn't definite.
What do you mean it wasn't definite? We were going to contract for the land.
Oh, Jeff. You know, where the government's concerned, you've always got politics. But the fact, it was yes, it was no. What happened now? A fate history, Maria.
But you yourself told me we know there's gold. Millions of dollars worth. And the engineers said it's high-grade ore. There's a real problem. And getting to it, what can happen?
Maria, honey, this is Bulwer. Depend on it. We're in trouble.
What kind of trouble?
Mr. Mayor? Hmm? Do that. Report it.
How come you haven't left for the rest of them?
Because I think the real story's yet to happen. For example, Mr. Mayor, why do you appear to be so troubled?
Well, obviously, something's bothering you. Tell me. You've been around. You're a college-educated man. You believe in... Whatever happened. Then you look back at it and say, Yes, that was fate.
Mr. Mayor, I'd like to talk to you about the mine, if I may.
The mine? Yes, and the sociological impact it'll have on this tiny community. If you'll excuse me, I have an important... Midnight? My goodness, then I'm really, really late. Good night, sir.
You're a special reporter in Bulwer. And I can report the town is behaving in a manner close to what you might expect. There's great happiness here and great expectations. Mayor Jefferson McDowell, however, seems somewhat different from his fellow townspeople. He takes long walks at night. Those who know him say he's suddenly become very serious. Certainly, he appears to be extremely introspective. It's almost as if he knows something that is hidden from everyone else. Is it true? More on the town of Bulwer on my regular broadcast this evening.
Jeff, why aren't you asleep?
Just turning and tossing is keeping me awake. Sorry.
Jeff? Can't you explain what's bothering you? I told you. It's this good and bad that seems to...
True. Not fighting me anymore. Surely and simply in the interest of getting my beauty sleep, I solved the problem. Darling, this will be the craziest thing you ever heard. Do you believe in luck?
Sure.
Well, let's say good luck is a good angel. So then bad luck would be...
A bad angel.
Right. Now, we got... Two of those angels in this town.
You've really got to explain this.
Well, the Miller sisters. Eunice and Janice. Eunice Blackburn and Janice Hollings. Those two. You lost me.
Well, all I've been doing is exploring your subject, history. Now, here you have those twin girls, Janice and Eunice Miller. By now, they're grown women.
Eunice and Janice? Yes. Study it. Everything that Eunice does, everything and everybody she's connected with... ...turns out fine. On the other hand, Janice... Wait. As far back as you can remember, hasn't it been that Eunice brought everybody good luck and Janice caused nothing but trouble?
No, as a matter of fact...
Now, before you dig around for all the evidence, and there's whole volumes of it, just a couple of simple things. Janice was engaged to Tom Patterson, who went off to Vietnam and got killed. Eunice married Bob Blackburn, who put in four years, never got a scratch. Got the Congressional Medal of Honor and came back a colonel. And the mine. Little Billy Blackburn goes berry picking with his Aunt Janice and falls down that abandoned shaft just because he was with Janice. But just because he's Eunice's son, he not only comes out without a scratch, but we strike gold.
Okay. Review the past 20 years, and now maybe you know what I mean when I say I'm waiting for the other shoe to drop.
All right, all right. But what possible... What calamity can Janice bring about now? It has to follow. It has to. Remember, it was through Eunice's husband, Bob Blackburn, the Air Force was interested in building the base.
Mm-hmm.
Right?
Mm-hmm.
The guy who was the head of planning came down. He was impressed. He was interested. The deal was just about to go through. We put him up for the night in Janice's house. The next day, somehow, everything cooled down.
Oh, still, you can't blame Janice.
It's not time for credit, and it's no time for blame. All we can do is... All we can go by.
The same thing with the factory that was going to be built here. It was Janice who...
Jeff, we have no proof. We have facts.
Where are you going?
Out.
Three in the morning.
I know, but I don't have to save the town. For what are we talking about? We seem to be talking about people who carry luck, good or bad, around with them. Superstition? Old wives' tale? Before you make your judgment, consider many of the commonplace things we take for granted today, like... Telephones, airplanes, not to mention space flight, were once old wives' tales, and people who spoke about them seriously could be burned or hanged. You will hang around with burning anticipation for act two.
Chemically, structurally, it's a simple and relatively uncomplicated element. And yet, it has within it a mysterious essence that can completely change human nature. Or is that really true? Can we basically be altered by gold? Or does gold merely act as the catalyst to speed up changes that was ready and waiting?
Janice, it's me, Jeff McDowell.
Janice, I've got to talk to you.
What time it is?
I know what time it is. Can I...
As Miss Valentine, our fifth grade teacher, used to say, begin at the beginning. You never should remind a lady of her age, Jeff. And, uh, and many things have happened.
In love with me? Is that it?
Janice, that's not what...
Do you want a divorce, Maria?
No.
Are you suggesting that we have an affair? Janice, listen. In a small place like this? How long do you think it could be kept a secret?
You've got it all wrong. I... I want to ask you to...
Oh, Jeff, you've got it all wrong. It's not what I came here to talk about. I came here to ask you to leave town, and it has nothing to do with me, or you. It's... it's for the good of Bulwer.
Is that a fact?
Janice.
Morning. To tell me to leave town? If it's a joke, I'm not amused.
I'll put it this way. Three hundred years ago, you would have been burned at the stake.
Your conversation isn't getting more pleasant, either.
You and Eunice, the Miller sisters. What's the history of the Miller sisters?
I must ask you to leave, Jeff.
You, Janice, you bring misfortune, tragedy. Eunice has always brought good things, great things. Wonderful things to everyone about her. I can't believe I'm sitting here listening to this. She brings us good luck. Be spread like a disease, and... and you...
There's the door, Jefferson McDowell.
Janice, there's no malice in this. I... I... I promise you, I'm... I'm stating a fact.
So am I. Get out.
Consider, Janice, everybody who's ever been associated with you has. You went out with Freddie Price. So did other girls. Come on, Janice. Remember the senior album? You and Freddie were voted Romeo and Juliet, and he had a great future as a ballplayer.
Lee's scouts were here to see him. But the day he gave you his pin... And what did I have to do with that?
It doesn't get any better, Janice. The Vietnam...
Jeff, I have had a very tragic life. Things have always gone badly. That's what I'm trying to tell you. And there's a reason for it.
Are you saying it's my fault?
Yes. Oh, you're unaware of it. You're not personally responsible for it. It's just... it's just one of those things.
And you have come here, at three in the morning, to tell me that.
Yes, because we may not have very much time.
Time for what?
The mine. Look, look, we could sit here for hours, going all the way back to when you were a little kid, and we could come up with hundreds of examples, but, well, here we have the mine. The rediscovery of the mine. It could mean millions, maybe billions of dollars. So, I don't know. How did you kill all those other things?
But I'm telling you, I didn't do anything.
And I'm telling you, it's not you do, or what you did, but...
Am I? What does that mean? I'm scared something will come up to... He's what?
One of the hundred citizens of Bulwer. I understand. I own one percent of that mine. Steal my share. I swear to you, I believe with all my heart, that if you stay here, any money or shares or anything for it will happen to that mine.
So, I'm to leave town?
Yes, Janice.
Town, and go where? I don't know any other place. This is all I have.
Janice, I know how you feel.
How? How do you know? How do you know what it feels like to be a woman who has nothing and nobody? No husband, no kids, no career. I never even went to college. They sent Eunice out east. She was the smart one, the pretty one.
Janice, it isn't anybody's fault. It's the way things just happen to be, I guess.
And now, you want me to give up the only thing I have in the world, my home. The answer is no.
Janice... This is my home. This is my home. This is my home. This is my home. This is my home. You can't force me to leave it.
Good morning. This is your special reporter in the tiny town of Bulwer, which has been struck by the golden lightning of sudden wealth. Let me say at this point that I seem to feel an unexpected reaction. You would expect most people to be exhilarated by the prospect of wealth. And yet, most of these town folks seem sobered by it. Does this mean that they are highly mature, sensitive, to the responsibilities of great wealth? Or is there something we don't know?
Dawned on me. Finally, dawned on me.
What?
We're going to be rich. It may not happen, Miss... Actually, Janice... I don't... Was it just talk? Conversation or what? I don't know if I believe it or not. I... Jeff, I wish I knew.
I believe it. It's what she asked me.
What did you tell her?
The truth.
What did she say?
Yes, you do. You... You... You know you're going to talk it over with Jim Delray, Harvey Parkins, and Colonel Bob. And then you're going to... Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. I guess I am going to do that.
Eyes in shape of it, Colonel Bob. What do I think of it? Anybody of the town's leading citizens. You're the mayor. You're famous. What's your opinion? Believe it? What I gather, so does everybody else in this town.
Oh, then... Everybody talks to me, Jeff. I know what I am. I'm a provincial education, but I've never done anything. Just... Just a country boy. Engineering school, Jeff. In our lab courses. Studied the scientific method. You... You know what that is? That's where you're wrong. It's very, very simple. Has to do with cause and effect. Follow this? Classic one they give is with a dog. Every time, just before you feed a dog, you ring a bell. Oh, then that has to do with the experiment. The dog hears the bell. He sees the food to salivate. Now then, after a while, every time the dog, even hears the bell, he begins to salivate. That's what's known as cause and effect. Got the same thing here. Cause and effect. Every time we get something going in this town, thanks to Janice, it goes up in smoke.
Then you're saying there is something to it.
Something. Say what? And to who? The idea was before that I see that other folks have come to the same conclusion. It's, uh... And we all got together. You know. It's your duty to get something done about it.
I wish I knew what it was I've done.
Yeah, truly. We are, Jeff, not like where nobody does. But we are at the point where we have to do something about Janice. I admit it, but... I think you know, Jeff. I think you know. You're a member in good standing of our audience. I think you know, too, who were Janice Miller-Hollings. It is her fate to be a carrier of bad luck. Such people, when found out throughout history, have suffered for it. Ah, but you say this was all in the past. Today, we are advanced, sophisticated, civilized. We will be here shortly. We give up some of our liberty for the greater good. Our ancestors sacrificed the individual to turn aside the wrath of the gods and spare the tribe. A general sacrifices the battalion to save an army. For the common good, the majority can usually justify anything. Especially morality. How weak, how fragile, how friendless he can sometimes be. You know what we have to do about Janice, Jeff. There's just no way we can force her to leave town. I admit that. Besides, you've got this newspaper correspondent poking around. I wouldn't worry about him. Nobody will tell him anything. But you just admitted we can't force Janice to leave town. That's right. Even if she up and left, that wouldn't do any good. Because she'd still be alive. Right, Jeff?
Jeff, take a little more time. You tuck yourself into it.
Very well, Bob.
Jeff, right now, the mayor and the town council of Bulwer, that's you, me, Harvey, Jim. We're receiving bids from mining companies to develop and exploit the property for us. The lowest one is for $250 million. We have 100 citizens, so that's a minimum of $2.5 million each. I know, I know, I know. Better than that. Because you and Maria each get $2.5 million. So do Eunice and I. Harvey and his wife have three grown sons, so his family stands to get, what, $12.5 million. That's what's involved here, Jeff. I know, I know. Oh, and you know what you have to do. Jeff, the second the idea occurred to you, you knew how it would have to end. You've been fighting it.
Yes, I've been fighting it. We've all got to agree. We have all got to agree.
Have you spoken?
Not everyone. Not everyone. He's been gathering momentum without you. Now you've got to come on board.
How about the women?
Oh, yes, they have to be part of it.
You mean you told Eunice?
Who? She's the one who convinced me.
This is your special correspondent in Bulwer, Colorado. This is the strangest town I've ever seen. The prospect of wealth, fabulous wealth, has frightened every inhabitant. There'll be wealth. Each of them shall become rich beyond their dreams. I understand the bidding to exploit the property. We'll go as high as half a billion dollars. Ladies and gentlemen, divide that a hundred ways. I have been promised an interview with a lady who lives in this town later on, Janice Miller Holling.
Well, that's not going to help. It's murder. And it's wrong. Yet, I know after we say it. Are we? It isn't right, Jeff. It isn't right. What I mean is it's right to tempt human beings like this. It's just too much money. It's worth Janice Miller's life. Janice Miller. You want to know the truth? The terrible truth? I never liked her. I'll say it too. Whatever it is, we're starting to justify it. Finding reasons for it. I realize. We have to. A little look at us, though. Not. I'll never be able to again. As time goes on, you'll find reasons to be convinced that she was the most evil woman in the world. And we'll discover facts to prove it. Oh, Jeff, I... You know what? You know what? You know how I always like to study history, Maria. Well, most... Jeff, we're going to have blood on our hands. Nothing like...
Miss Miller, or is it Mrs. Holland?
It can be anything you like.
You promised me an interview, remember?
Did I?
You most certainly did. Now, I understand you have a twin sister, and the two of you are as different as night and day.
Well, if you know all about me, why do you wish to interview me?
None of us really know all about another human being, Miss Miller. Nor should we. You strike me as a very sensible person. I'm sure we could have a most agreeable interview. I was warned about big city types like you.
I promise I'll be all business.
But I'm not too sure I like that.
Don't I take you to dinner this evening?
Why don't I cook dinner at my house?
I can't think of a single reason against it.
Till this evening, then.
Jeff, the shop would be empty this time of day. How about a little trim?
Sit right down.
Spoke to Maria?
Yeah.
And?
Call that terrible machine, but he could stop. A juggernaut.
Yeah, yeah, that's what it is. Just rolls over everybody and everything. You just can't make any argument against it.
That's true.
So?
Be blithely. Nobody's gonna enjoy it. Do we have to even talk about it?
Yeah. You know, Jeff, I've been barbered in New York, London, Paris. I even spent 50 bucks for a haircut, but none of those characters can touch you.
What's there to talk about now?
How to do it. A hundred citizens in this town. Get 99 to agree.
Why is it funny?
Because that's life, being citizens. Marvin Jim. Mayor. It has to be an accident.
You think you're taking too much off the front there?
If I thought I was taking too much off the front, I wouldn't do it, would I?
Fortunately, her house is just across from the abandoned shaft opening.
What about dynamite?
This company, International Precious Metals, that's bidding for the mine, they have a truck here. It's got dynamite in it. It's parked near the shaft that's just across from Janice's house. It can, uh, blow up.
How do I know?
An accident. Dynamite in the truck?
Oh, yes, there certainly will be. The four of us will help wire. We'll have an automatic fuse to set it off. All of our problems are over as soon as it gets dark. The thing will rattle windows all over town, but all the damage is going to be directed towards that. I give all the money I'll ever see from that mine, not... We're a hundred yards away from the dynamite. At fifteen seconds, can you run a hundred and fifteen seconds? Well, in school I could run a hundred and nine-eight. Now, here we go. You got eleven seconds back there. Pull the fuse. Now you get ten. Now, you're past the point of no return. We better hit the ground. Seconds off.
You're a reporter at the town of Bulwer. Except there is no town of Bulwer any longer. It is buried under millions of tons of dirt and rock. The only survivor is the luckiest woman in the world, Miss... Janice Miller, who is standing beside me now. Miss... Miss Miller, what exactly did happen?
Well, uh, we don't get them often, but when we do, we do. This was an avalanche. As you know, Bulwer is, uh, was in a valley hemmed in by very steep mountains.
But what set it off, Miss Miller?
Well, uh, you and I heard what set it off.
Oh, uh, ladies and gentlemen, I should explain. Miss Miller and I had made a date for her interview to be taped at dinner, which she kindly offered to prepare for me at her house. But at the last moment, for some reason, we decided to drive to a restaurant in Council Fork, some forty miles away. Uh, why did we decide to do that, Miss Miller?
I don't know. We just decided.
What did set off the avalanche, Miss Miller?
We were a long way off, but we heard an explosion.
Yes, I thought it was thunder. If you'd been raised in a mining town, you'd know the sound of dynamite.
But where was the dynamite?
I noticed a truck outside my house just before we left. I'm sure there was dynamite in it.
But what could have set it off?
Who knows? Anything or nothing, that's dynamite.
And this explosion triggered the avalanche?
Definitely. Ladies and gentlemen, this is an eerie sight. Here was once a hamlet of over a hundred human beings. All of them are now covered by tons of rock.
This disaster struck, without warning, with bewildering speed. There was no time to sound an alarm, no time to make an escape. I suppose all this debris will be bulldozed away, and this fantastically rich mine will belong to the sole survivor of Bulwer, Miss Janice Miller.
Miss Miller, you are the luckiest lady in the world. Fortune's favorite.
Mm-hmm. Funny. I always thought of myself as Miss Fortune's favorite. But I guess if you live long enough, the worm turns. The road turns. And your luck turns.
Of course. There's a category of stories known as the getting hoist by your own petard type. Or the scaffold of Haman kind. You know, Haman who built the scaffold for Mordecai and wound up stepping off it himself. We love such stories because you can't beat poetry. Poetic justice. And they speak for themselves. At the end, they leave me with nothing to say except that I shall return in a few moments.
We began these ceremonies with a poem by Heinrich Heine, which celebrated the ladies who control fortune, good and bad. And if they are fickle, volatile, and unpredictable, would you have them any other way? Isn't it marvelous to live in suspense, uncertain of the morrow, not knowing which of these ladies will knock on your door and enter your room? Do you require a word of caution? Well, remember, since luck is a lady, treat her like one. And she will always treat you like a gentleman.
Our cast included Fred Gwynne, Bryna Raeburn, Russell Horton, and Carol Teitel. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown.
Now, a preview of our next tale. Grand is certainly cheap enough to save your life. But by coming here, you could be signing your own death warrant.
Why?
Oh, Lieutenant, isn't it possible that some people may be motivated by idealistic considerations?
Oh, sure, sure, sure. In the movies, in the books. Because that's what we'd like to believe. But you and I, we can't afford to believe that way. I mean, you're a doctor, I'm a cop. We know how people behave when life and death are on the line.
But still, there are those few people...
Yes, yes. Every now and then, you run across a saint. And somehow, I don't think that's you, Mr. Tarbell. So, I'm going to ask you that question again. Why are you here?
Lieutenant, I... I have a confession to make.
Radio Mystery Theater was sponsored in part by Ex-Lax. This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our Mystery Theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant dreams.
