The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 27 min to read
from the files of the world-renowned Pinkerton National Detective Agency, the first law enforcement agency doing detective and police work in the United States. It was founded by Allan Pinkerton in 1850 and carried on by his sons, William and Robert. Such was their reputation that it has been said, had they been guarding President Lincoln that night at Ford's Theater, Lincoln would never have been assassinated. Today, we pull the files marked train robberies.
Tell me again, Mr. Newton. What do you remember of the robbery of the Rock Island train?
Oh, I'm glad to, Mr. Pinkerton. They say the Pinkertons always get their man.
Well, we try to. I'll be frank with you, Mr. Newton. We have been keeping track of you.
Keeping track of me? You mean, you mean you've been having me followed?
I'm afraid I do.
I'll be, I, am I under suspicion?
In a case like this, one is suspect.
Mystery drama, The Pinkerton Method, was dramatized from the files of the Pinkerton Detective Agency especially for Mystery Theater by James Agate Jr. and stars Ian Martin and Lloyd Batista.
Crime was an everyday national threat in every American city from the Civil War to World War I. In New York, Baltimore, Chicago, and Boston, people were afraid to walk the city streets after dusk. Citizens would be robbed or they'd completely disappear. Gunmen fought daily battles right in the open streets. One of the most lucrative forms of crime was the train robbery. There was a train robbery and the only law enforcement agency able to stem the tide of lawlessness were the Pinkertons.
Who can tell this story better than someone who was there?
It makes sense for me to give you the facts about the Rock Island train robbery because I'm pretty much the only person who knows what happened. I was a brakeman on the night, wintry March night with snow everywhere. Walked into the express car.
We on schedule?
As far as I know, golly, it's nice and warm in here.
What are you doing?
Oh, you know, usual. Making sure the $22,000 are all accounted for.
You've got that much in the safe?
Not a dollar more, not a dollar less.
You're a lucky stick. Express messenger is such an easy job sitting here doing paperwork at a desk in the express car. I really envy you.
Well, now as a matter of fact, you didn't wear a collar, a shirt, and a tie in this job. Look at me, dirty overalls, my hands all banged up, greasy from oil cans, fingernails dirty. Fifteen years. Nowhere to go.
Ah, it's too long, Nick. Nobody on the line appreciates how hard a brakeman has to work.
Well, like I told you before, Harold, I'll put in a good word for you with the chief up at U.S. Express, if you like. He's an old pal of mine. Maybe he can use an extra messenger, huh? Besides, we messengers don't do too bad when it comes to salary.
Don't rub it in.
And you could learn the work, Harold. It's easy. I think this time I'll take you up on that. I sure could use the money with a new wife and everything.
I'm sure you could. Will you ask him?
Okay, it's a promise. When we get back from New York, I'll talk to the chief.
Uh-huh. Of course, your job's a little more dangerous than mine.
Huh?
Oh, you mean train robbers? Well, I guess I've been lucky so far. I mean, say, one of the gangs knew you had 22,000 in that safe. They could get aboard anywhere after Joliet.
Hey, when do we arrive there?
Half an hour. Pick up the mail, and then our next stop is Morris.
Oh, Morris, Illinois. I've been there with a dead person.
Well, hand me the poker, will you? The fire's getting low. I want to give the stove a stir.
Here you are.
Oh, thank you. Well, I'd better be heading back, Nick. Doing my train rounds. Say hello to George D. Newton for me, will you? He's on this run in the baggage car, isn't he?
If he isn't asleep, he's supposed to sort all the baggage before we hit Morris. I'll bet anything all he's doing is snoring.
Well, wake him and tell him I said to get busy. I don't want to be hanging around Pennsylvania Station when we get in.
Oh, hey, I forgot to ask you, Harold. What's your wife's name?
Elizabeth.
Yeah, yeah, Elizabeth. That's a sweet name. I'll bet she's just as sweet as she sounds.
Oh, no kidding. I'll try to see if I can get you that job with U.S. Express. I won't be surprised, but you'd make double the money.
I'm all for that.
We did the rounds, ten cars, baggage car included, the length of the train and back. We pulled into Morris and took on water for the engine. George Newton, the baggage master, and I opened the express car door.
I'll go first.
What's the hurry, George?
Well, I've got to be sure that... Lord, no.
Huh?
Harold, look. Look, I'd better get the Pinkerton man. He's in the third car.
The safe's blown open. Don't touch anything. If there was 22,000 there once, it sure ain't in there now.
Look at all that blood.
I was afraid of this, Harold.
I'm scared. What do you mean?
I can't take time to explain. I'm going back for the Pinkerton man, and don't touch anything.
My name is William Pinkerton. I told the baggage man. What's his name?
Newton, George Newton. Ask him to wait in his car. I thought I'd speak to you first. You're Harold and the brakeman.
Name of the deceased, the express messenger?
Nick Kelsey.
And what was the last time you saw Mr. Kelsey alive?
Not an hour ago.
Alive when you left him?
Mr. Pinkerton, of course he was. I swear it. Good Lord, he was even going to put in a good word for me with his chief so I could perhaps get a job with U.S. Express.
Oh, why would he do that?
Well, I just got married, and it's no secret, but a brakeman doesn't make much money.
I see.
Gang of train robbers must have come aboard. No shots. Not far back is the last.
Is he in that safe, Mr. Black, or don't you know?
Well, sure, I know. Nick told me. $22,000.
Uh-huh, I see. You asked Mr. Newton to join us.
Georgie?
Car's a mess. It's like Nick put up an awful fight.
What can you tell us, Mr. Newton?
It must have happened between the time the train left Joliet and when we stopped here in Morris. There was this noise of broken glass, and I, well, I looked up and I saw the ventilator on the side of the baggage car was smashed. At that moment, a man with a black mask over the lower part of his face came into the car.
Why didn't you call for me?
I called for help, Georgie. I couldn't have been far away.
Well, the masked man said that if you dare move an inch, that man up there will blow your brains out.
The man up where?
Well, there wasn't a man, exactly, Mr. Pinkerton. It was a hand, a man's hand, through the broken ventilator and pointed right at me.
And then what did you do?
I just tried to keep breathing. I buy a baggage car and...
You must have felt...
Agony, believe me, Mr. Pinkerton. Daren't give the alarm, you know, that that gun was aimed right at my head. And finally, I guess, when we rolled into Morris, I looked up in the ventilator and the hand was gone. And just then, Harold came in and we went right into the express car and, uh, well, the rest you know.
Mr. Pinkerton, any idea how Nick was killed?
Looks like a pistol whipping, maybe. Others, I can't say what made those.
Mr. Newton, are you sure you didn't hear any gunshots?
Well, I couldn't swear I didn't. You know, the train makes pretty much of a racket going fifty. I was, uh... Well, I don't know what I was with that gun pointed at me. I... How many there were, but I knew they were after the money. You didn't hear them blow out the safe?
I wish I had. I mean, I wish I could say I did. Uh... Twenty-two thousand. You know or you're guessing?
Oh, no, I'm just guessing. No one's touched anything in this car so far, as you know. When George was getting you, Mr. Pinkerton, I stood right there. No one came in here.
Well, I think I've found what they beat him with. Back here in the corner, there's a...
Mr. Pinkerton, yeah, that appears to be blood on it.
You gentlemen can return to your duties for a moment. Tell the engineer I'm impounding this express car. Have him uncouple and move it to a siding right here at the station. And then he can take the rest of the train on to New York.
You mean George and I can go along with the train?
No, I don't mean that. I'm gonna need both of you to help me. I believe there's a hotel in town.
Oh, yes, I can see one from here.
I'll make that my headquarters if the telegrapher is still up, have him wire Chicago to have the Rock Island put you both up at that hotel until I give the word.
Rooms at the Delaney, right on Thompson Street. I had the telegraph operator wire Chicago what had happened. And somebody had better notify Nick's wife, Mrs. Kelsey. I had him also get a message to Elizabeth. There'd been a delay on the run. Not clear about me, but I was all right.
Here she goes. Seems funny to be standing here in the window of this hotel, watching our train pull out, and we've got to stay here.
Listen, so long as the Rock Island pays me my wages, I don't care where I am.
I wish Elizabeth was here. She loves hotels. You know, when we left Chicago and I was talking to Nick, you know, he said this town of Morris is a dump, a dead town, he said.
Let's not talk about Nick, okay?
I wonder if it...
You wonder what?
I don't like seeing that express car in the siding right from this window and knowing what's in it.
Well, you know, it could have been any half a dozen gangs. The Youngers, Jameses, Daltons, and McCoys.
Hey, Georgie, you really know your train robbers.
Well, I read the newspaper a lot, but it could have been.
Oh, sure. We've been up all night.
Yeah, I'm beginning to feel all this. I'd say we're entitled to the best breakfast that Delaney can come up with. Go on downstairs and have us one.
Agreed. After what we've been through, breakfast is none too good for us.
There was hardly an American train going anywhere that was not robbed. Bands of outlaws would pile ties on the rails, derail trains, shoot at the passengers while the express car was being dynamited. Traveling by train in those days was hell on wheels. Only the Pinkertons, with their network of operatives, were equipped to offset the bandit buccaneers and murderers.
I'll be back shortly with...
Even before the Iron Horse started rolling the rails across country, the Pinkertons chased and captured desperados and stagecoach bandits. Before there was even a thought of a federal bureau of investigation, the Pinkertons were the only law enforcement agency of any size who could get any results. Allan Pinkerton, who founded the agency in 1850, set a pace and a practice never forgotten by his two sons, William and Robert. In the early days, the Pinkertons pursued lawbreakers on horseback. Now they were tracking and trailing by telephone.
Are you there?
It was robbed of $22,000. Now cut that out. You know very well we try to apprehend, but not anticipate them. There are not too many.
There were two robbers, according to a witness, the baggage master on the train. One of them was... One held him at bay, and the other must have killed the messenger and dynamited the safe.
Looks like number four, I'd say. The, uh, messenger was shot. I'm having the bullet removed from the body now to see if I can identify it.
Which Cassidy?
Uh, I'm not so sure. In addition to being shot, the messenger's skull was smashed in with a poker. That's not Cassidy style. Eyewitness account, and the clues don't match up. Right here, outside the Morris Depot, I found a black mask a few feet from the express car, but not... One foot. And I walked the track in 12 inches of snow. Well, the baggage man claims he was threatened from the top of the car, but there are no footprints there either. Or I need to do a little more talking, a little more listening.
Why, do you need me, Blum? I'll try. I'll get there when I get there.
You asked me to come up to your room, Mr. Pinkerton?
I did, Mr. Black. You don't mind if I call you Harold?
Oh, what happened? Oh, lots of ideas. That's good. Up and get myself back to Chicago, wife? Heh heh. It certainly does. But then you're on to something, Mr. Pinkerton. There are quite a few aspects of this case which do not... I'd even go so far as saying it's downright mysterious, and I'd like you to give me as much help as you can. Whatever assistance I can be, I want to. Nick Kelsey was a good friend, and I really want to do anything I can to track down his killer.
Uh, you know George Newton, the baggage master, of course.
Georgie? Well, indeed. Good. I want you to do a little detective work. I'm releasing you both so you can get back to Chicago. Callum to assign you to the home office in case I need you both. So you won't be going out on any more runs for a few weeks.
That suits me just fine. My wife will love that.
My wife? I just got married. Now, when you're back in Chicago, I want you to associate as much as you can with George Newton and get him to... to talk about the case. You know, the... the man on the broken ventilator and the gun pointing at him, what time it was and so on. And each night, I want you to call the Pinkerton office in Chicago and make a full report of what you've learned that day.
I will, Mr. Pinkerton. As I said, anything I can do to bring the assassin to... justice.
As Georgie goes, I think there, you're... on tree. That may be, Harold, but we... You do that and we'll see what develops. I, uh, I won't be in Chicago, but they'll know you by a code number.
Where are you going to be?
In this case, so I'm going down to Tennessee on another train robbery. The telephone number for you. And the code you identify as.
How's it going, Billy? You're doing great. Bit to death for these darn chiggers, Bob. How much further is it?
Last there's landing. Well, I think we're almost there. They told me at Hickman the landing was just... miles into this swamp. Going after dark through a Tennessee swamp isn't my idea of fun, believe me.
Since when was the Pinkerton Detective Agency in the amusement business? To think a week ago I was looking for footprints and twelve inches of snow at... ten below. Must be a hundred and ten degrees right now.
You're pretty sure it's the Farrington brothers we're looking for?
Absolutely. I asked the express messenger twice just to make sure I heard right. And Levi Farrington. Those were his last words before he died. He recognized them all right. He'd seen all our flyers and posters on their last job when they hit the mobile in Ohio and Kentucky. It's too bad we couldn't go overland to track them. It'll help us get the drop on them. Look. An old fellow fishing.
Like to see him fishing? What you want to do, scam a dinner away?
Sorry, we're... We're looking for Lester's landing.
Well, who are you? What are you Yankees doing here?
We're looking... Ah, Bob, what do you want me... Tolliver? It'd better if some folks didn't make so much noise. Ha, ha, ha. My name is Bill Pink, this is my brother Bob. We're looking for two friends of ours.
You find friends when you want them, I always say.
Uh... Maybe you know them.
I ain't, can you? Never heard of them.
In Tennessee, right?
Yep.
Lester's landing, eh?
Yeah, is that far?
Just around that bend there. Say, Billy, what'd I tell you? I don't mix much with other folk. Keep to myself, mostly.
Oh, just around the bend, you say? Fine. Well, we'll... We'll be moving along. Thank you.
Well, good luck, boys. Keep the powder dry. I think I got me mic. Big one.
This is it. Let me tie this end of the rowboat to the dock, which is shown tonight. See some shadows around that table with the lantern on, crawling up the dock. Close it, maybe we can hear something.
Stupid, now, I've been doing this for years, and the way I tell you to make the nitro soup is the honest way.
Sure, sure, Levi. I always know everything better than anybody else.
You shut up and hear me, now. Now, you take 75 sticks of dino, and you thaw it out near a stove. And then, you crumble it up like sawdust, so you don't have to watch me. Pour hot water on it and stir. We make it, isn't how we... Smooth like... Would you watch me?
Hey, now, Paul, won't you try it my way?
Hey, boy, when I need advice on how to blow a safe, I'll ask for it, huh? Now, Hillary, I want you to mosey on down to Hickman to see if you can locate some more dino. Now, they've been blasting the road down there. Now, you just help yourself to as many sticks as you can carry. Now, do you hear me, boy?
Can you handle Levi and whoever else is in there?
How did you get here, stranger?
Well, matter of fact, the road.
Oh, you just little old road, huh?
Yeah, and I got the mosquito bites to prove it. Now, what'd you say your name was?
Well, I didn't say, but...
That's him. I'll tell you about Levi. Him better. He's like to whack them old friends. He knowed your name, Levi, and Hillary said his name was Bill Pink.
Pinkerton. I can't see you, Pinkerton, but I can hear you. I'll just put your brother out of commission. Will you come quietly?
Billy, Billy, where are you? Let me light this ladder. Oh, Billy, you did it.
Huh?
Levi is out cold.
Yeah, that makes it easier to snap the handcuffs on him. Well, there's a body over here on the floor.
Hey, isn't that the old man we ran into fishing?
Yeah, how is he?
Looks like his fishing days are over. You'd think at his age he'd know better.
Your shoulder's bleeding. You got your corn knife handy, Bob?
Sure I do. Here, give me the lantern. I'll hold it. Okay, take your knife, Bob, and dig out the slug. This is gonna hurt a little.
Yeah. Well, don't you worry, Bob. That little old... What favor? It helps me to forget those mosquito bites.
Mountains, forests, trails, whatever the terrain or the weather, Robert and William Pinkerton did more to put an end to train robberies than any other security outfit. The Farrington case closed. Robert returned to Denver headquarters. William went back to Chicago. The case of the Rock Island theft, and I'll be back shortly, with the accomplishments of the Pinkertons, has set the example for all the law enforcement. What was their system? How did they either capture or kill or gather evidence that put an end to every train or bank robber? Their secret? Never rest. Pursue the criminal on horseback across oceans, never letting up until he is either dead or behind bars.
You can't get used to this telephone invention. It's Dog One talking to you, Bob, in Denver like it's in the next room.
What's the problem?
I'll tell you what I called you. Do you remember the Rock Island?
Yes. Witness Harold?
Well, I took him into my conference and had him do a little detective work following the baggage master, George Newton, and reporting to the office every day while I was in Tennessee with you, movements and comparing — And they just don't jar you, Bob. Well, I said the reports phoned in by the brake man are all made up, the places Newton is supposed to — So on, you know. Anyway, Bob, the reason I'd put through this call to you is that Harold Black has asked — I told the general superintendent to grant it, and Black is starting west with his new wife. Keep them under surveillance, will you, Bob?
Mr. and Mrs. Harold Black is how we marked the tags on our luggage. It was really like a honeymoon. And Elizabeth and I were sure looking forward to it. Elizabeth wanted us first to go to Niagara Falls, but I said, let's head west first. I take that way. So off we went, westward. Everywhere we went, we had ourselves a great old time. And, of course, we had money to spend.
Come in, come in, Mr. Newton.
Mr. Pinkerton, I'm glad to see you again. You've, uh, been away from Chicago on another case.
Yes, I have. I asked you to stop by, Mr. Newton. Oh, by the way, you don't mind.
Sure, not at all. I thought I'd like you to tell me again just what you remember.
Hey, well, I'm glad to, Mr. Pinkerton. It's, uh, fresh in my mind, like that awful morning when I last saw you. I guess things like that happen every day in your life. It's not for me. I like a quiet life.
I've been keeping track of your...
Keeping track of me? Well, I'll be... Am I under suspicion?
In a case like this, everyone is suspect. Why do I keep these offices so hot? No, no, I don't mind. Why don't you take your overcoat off?
Huh? No, no, no, I won't bother. I don't expect to be with you that long.
You sure it's not too hot for you?
No, no, no, no. You want me to remember it all over again, huh? Well, all right, here goes. As I told you, uh, two weeks ago, I was moving boxes in the baggage car, and, uh, well, I'd say it happened between the time we left Joliet and stopped at Morris. Now, there, uh, was this noise of broken glass? Well, I looked up, and I saw the ventilator that had been smashed, and at that moment, a man with a black mask over the lower part of his face came in the car and said, If you dare move an inch, that man up there will blow your brains out. Huh? Well, I looked up, and the muzzle of a pistol was pointed right at me through the broken ventilator. And with the mask left, I looked up again, and the hand holding the pistol was gone, and, uh, yeah, well, that's what I remember, Mr. Pinkerton. The way you told it to me last time, word for word.
Yeah, yeah, is that suspicious?
Well, let's say it isn't usual. Then overheated. All right, yeah, so sure. And it'd be easier if you'd first take off your gloves, wouldn't it?
My goodness, whatever happened to your hands?
Yeah, they're pretty scratched up, aren't they? But that's the nature of my job. Here, uh, uh, handling baggage is rough on them.
You know, I thought, well, they gave you a desk job since you came back here to Chicago.
Well, yeah, yeah, they did. Uh, these scratches? Well, I'd say they happened a month ago. Takes a long time to heal, doesn't it?
Uh, may I ask, Mr. Pinkerton, when your man followed me, I mean, uh... Well, actually, you were followed by two men, one a Pinkerton operative and the other was a flight to see his reports. A friend of mine? But you're kidding. You said he was... George Newton by Harold Black. You don't actually mean it.
I certainly do mean it. In your hand is one week of reports, including a Sunday, where you went, what you did, what you two talked about.
I-I-I don't believe it. Why, that dirty, two-timing bigamist.
Bigamist?
Oh, yeah, you didn't know about your pet spy, did you? So he two-timed me just like he's two-timed his own wife. Oh, yeah, he's got a wife in Philadelphia and two children. Deserted them last year.
So Elizabeth is not Harold's wife.
Oh, no, no, she thinks she is. But, uh, no, she's a nice girl. She's too nice for him. That's what makes me so darn mad.
Well, well, well, the things that finally come to light are... So, frankly, if I were you, Mr. Pinkerton, I'd take Harold's reports about me with a grain of salt.
Well, I'll most assuredly bear that in mind. All right, George, I won't keep you any longer today.
I can go now?
Yes. Oh, and, George, you should have those hands looked at. You wouldn't want to get it, in fact.
It was just bad. I should have waited a little longer before flashing those 50s and 100s. But the feel of having big money was just too much for me, I guess. And sweet Elizabeth. Oh, she was having the time of her life. In Phoenix, Las Vegas, and then California. Seeing all the sights, theaters, shows, restaurants. We had ourselves a time.
It was sheer luck that day in San Francisco that she was upstairs in the hotel room resting. I was alone downstairs in the bar.
Robert Pinkerton, I believe you've made the acquaintance of my brother, William.
Oh, I certainly have.
Wondering if you're enjoying yourself?
You bet. My wife and I have never been to San Francisco before.
Oh, I thought your wife was in Philadelphia.
Take your hat and coat and come with me.
But I... I haven't done anything.
From Philadelphia's where you're going to get it, Mr. Black. Your friend George Newton told us.
George. And we checked it out and found your real wife. Fine children you left behind you.
Mr. Pinkerton, did George say anything else about me?
Yes, sir. Wash up your drink, Mr. Black. Elizabeth, to stay in San Francisco and not to worry. I'd be back, I said. I got me a good lawyer and with $2,000 cash bail I was a free man again.
We got a medical report that says they discovered human skin. Underneath the fingernails of the deceased. Looks like to save his life he scratched someone pretty bad.
I didn't know how much the Pinkertons knew. I didn't know how much Elizabeth knew or had told them. Was he in cahoots with the Pinkertons? I didn't know, but I didn't think so. Because if he started to sing, he must be aware I know the same tune. If he ratted on me, I sure wasn't going to take the rap alone.
We've got a visitor, George Newton. How are you two?
I've got some... Locking me in here, huh? They don't trust us.
Should they, Georgie? Are you to be trusted?
What a question, of course I am. I'm your friend.
Are you, Georgie? Philadelphia. And say that.
Now, now, now, hold up. If you're talking about friendship.
Peach on me, huh? Give reports to the Pinkertons about where I went and what we talked about.
You stupid. I pretended to go along with them to take the heat off.
Shh, not so loud. Now listen. I asked to see you saying I wanted to straighten things out with your wife in Philadelphia. The Pinkerton's on to something. He saw these hands, see? I don't know if he believed that I got it handling baggage or not, but why he didn't believe me. That's what I want to know. Why is he suspicious?
That's your problem, Georgie. I don't want to talk. I'm not going to say anything.
You'd better. You'd better, I swear.
Is that what you're going to tell the Pinkertons? I'd be footsie with them or send them reports like some people I know. Don't fool yourself, Georgie. With this, it was all my idea business. If I go, you go. You're the one who shot Nick. He was already dead when I hit him with that gun. With that poker.
You're crazy. The gun went off because he was fighting like a tiger clawing at me. I wasn't going to kill him. Now, you're the one who panicked when your mask fell off and you thought he recognized you, so you smashed his skull with that poker.
You liar, you. Help! Help, let me out of here!
What's the trouble?
Get me out of here, Mr. Pinkerton. You're a liar. That's what you are, a dumb liar.
All right, now take it easy, Harold. Okay, Georgie. Let's move along.
Am I glad you were handy. That man's a wild beast. George Newton is just as guilty as anyone. Don't let him get away. It's too bad that Harold's gone off his head.
Let me see your hands, George, both of them.
Hey, Mr. Pinkerton, what you putting handcuffs on me for?
Only for a few minutes, George, until we can book you and find an empty cell for you. And the chief of police and I were right there in the next room.
George Newton, you're under arrest. The train robbery, except what Harold and Elizabeth had spent on their wild vacation, was recovered. Their marriage, of course, was invalid. Mr. Black and George Newton stood trial for the Rock Island robbery and the murder of the express messenger, Nicholas Kelsey.
I shall return shortly. The trial of the two Rock Island railroad robbers was a quick one. One juryman, however, did not believe in capital punishment, so they were sent to the penitentiary for life. Over the years, the Pinkertons never boasted of their achievements. When asked, all they would say was, it's all in a day's work. Diligence, doggedness, study and character, knowing your man. That, their day's work, was the Pinkerton method.
Our cast included Ian Martin, Lloyd Battista, Nat Polen, and Earl Hammond. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown.
