The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 22 min to read
CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents... I'm E.G. Marshall.
We call ourselves modern, don't we? We say these are modern times. The years past are prehistoric or ancient or medieval. We say with some pride that we are modern, as though we'd smartened up considerably and discarded old, worn-out, discredited theories and practices. Yet our medicine has its roots in antique magic and our science has its origins in archaic superstition. Without magic and superstition, it is unlikely we could have survived to become modern.
She has everything. A loveliness to take your breath away, your sweetness and gaiety. But she has something else. I don't know what it is. She has a wild talent. She's always had it. But what is it, a wild talent? No. She knows precisely. Except those, perhaps, who take the trouble to learn.
Our mystery drama, The Red Frisbee, was written especially for the Mystery Theater by L. Smith Erick and stars Robert Dryden. It is sponsored in part by True Value Hardware Stores and Luden's Medicated Cough Drops. I'll be back shortly with Act One.
One of the Earth's loveliest seas is the Caribbean. In a gentle curve on the bosom of that sea, lie the islands known as the Antilles. A man has come to one of these islands, not only for the brilliant sky, the soft sands, the hot sun, and the cooling winds, but for the quiet and the isolation that only an island can give. What he finds there, we will tell you in this tale.
I'd come to the island after three years spent with an aboriginal tribe in the interior of Australia. I needed to relax and reflect and try to see what was there. To sort out the ideas I wanted to incorporate into my article for the Anthropological Journal and later expand into a book. With me, I brought my voluminous notes, a suitcase full of old clothes, and my dog.
Haven't you had enough? Okay, okay, one more time. Okay, fetch. Ah, good dog.
He's so beautiful.
What?
He's beautiful.
Oh, whoa, thank you. Have you always had him?
Since he was a puppy. He's been all over the world with me. We just spent three years in Australia together before we came here. Look, here he comes.
What's he got in his mouth?
Oh, that's a frisbee.
A what?
A frisbee. You know, one of those round plastic things that you throw, you know.
Oh, no, I don't know. I never had a frisbee.
Oh, well, they're kind of fun. They go sailing through the air. All right, drop it, boy. Drop it.
Oh, he doesn't want to. He knows he looks handsome with a red frisbee.
What's he got in his mouth? With his black hair and all. What kind of dog is he?
Labrador retriever. All right, drop it, boy. Good boy. That's enough now. I'll throw it again for him. I like to see him swim with it in his mouth. He looks so beautiful.
Okay. Fetch.
Oh, he's a good swimmer, isn't he?
Oh, yes.
Well, he swam out very far.
Well, as far as I can throw the frisbee, I guess.
That's wonderful. Do you like to swim?
I can't.
You can't? You can't swim? You live on this wonderful island and you can't swim?
I used to be able to.
What happened?
I forgot how.
You forgot?
Yes.
Oh, here he comes with his red frisbee. How could you forget?
I just forgot.
Oh, look. He wants you to throw it for him again.
I'd do this all day if I threw it for him. And would he swim very far out?
I suppose he would. All dogs can swim, I guess.
No. No. Not right away. They have to be taught. Like people.
Not exactly, but they have to be made to realize that they can. That's about what it amounts to, I guess. They don't always know that they can. They're as surprised as anybody when they find out.
That's fascinating. Are you going to throw the frisbee again?
I think he's had enough for today. We both have.
Will you be coming back tomorrow?
I imagine so. Maybe I'll see you here.
That'd be nice. Well. Bye, Ben.
Bye. Hey. Wait a minute. You, young lady.
What?
How did you know my name?
See you tomorrow.
I watched her swinging off down the beach. I judged she might be about 17, though she could as well have been 12 or 20. She wore a sort of shapeless smock. Her legs were a ruddy brown from the sun, and her hair was streaked in shades of gold. I remembered her eyes. Which were this... startling blue of Delft, China. I heard again her clear, young voice calling. Goodbye, Ben.
And the next day, I was on the beach early in the morning. Not now, boy. No, no, no. We're waiting for someone. What is it, boy? Hey, hey, hey. What are you doing? Where are you going? Come back here.
He'd seen her before I did. Before she rounded the curve in the shoreline. Or had he simply sensed her coming? Or what? At any rate, there she was. Swinging down the beach. Swinging down the beach toward me.
Hello.
Hello there. You're out early.
So are you. I didn't keep you waiting, did I?
No, I'd have waited all day.
Oh, you wouldn't have had to do that. I knew you were here.
How did you know I was here?
I knew.
But how?
The way a person knows those things.
But people don't just know those things.
Don't they?
Oh, you saw me from your house. Where do you live? Do you have a place on the beach?
Oh, no. We live in the great house.
What's the great house?
Just a house. They call it the great house because it used to be where the governor lived. The Spanish governor. Long time ago. Ben, aren't you going to throw the red frisbee for the dog? See, he wants you to.
How did you know my name is Ben?
I guess you told me.
I never told you.
You never asked.
I never told you. But when you left yesterday, you said, Goodbye, Ben.
Why don't you throw the frisbee? Ben is my name. But you had no way of knowing that.
My name is...
I really don't care what your name is. May I throw the red frisbee?
Go ahead if you want to.
I do want to. Now swim beautifully.
What's your name?
Mickey.
You told me yesterday that dogs had to learn how to swim.
Now what I said was they have to find out that they can swim.
I guess that's true of people, too. Probably we can all swim, but we have to find out at some time or other that we can. It's quite a discovery for a person or a dog.
How did you know?
How did your dog find out he can swim?
Well, it was when we were in Australia. I made a weekend trip to the Great Barrier Reef, and of course I took him along. I was sitting on the beach with him the way we're sitting now, and I had this red frisbee, same one I have now, and I threw it into the water. Then he plunged in after it and brought it back. Next time I threw it further, and he brought it back. I'd never thrown it so far that he couldn't stand up in the water. But then I did. I threw it way out. Out to where the water was. Out to where the water was over his head.
But he went after it?
Oh, yes. And he got to about three feet away from it, and all of a sudden his feet didn't touch bottom anymore.
But he stretched his neck out and grabbed the frisbee anyway between his teeth. And he tried to turn around to bring it back to me, and that was when he found out he couldn't touch bottom.
And he started to swim?
Not yet. He sank under the water.
Oh, no.
He came up again right away. He looked so surprised, and then he went under again.
What did you do? Did you just stand there?
He went down for the third time, and I started in after him.
I should hope.
But before I got to him, he started to swim, paddling away like mad. You know the way dogs do?
Oh, I know. And there was such a look in his eyes, such a look of triumph, belief in himself. It was as though his ancestors from way back, hundreds of thousands of years ago, had whispered to him somehow, down the ages, as though they'd said, you know how you can do it. And he did it. Never forgotten that.
That's a beautiful story, Benedict.
It's true.
What did you call me just now?
I don't know.
Yes, you do. You called me Benedict.
Yesterday, you called me Ben.
Well, that could be a lucky guess, but Ben is usually short for Benjamin. And my name is Benedict. And that's... That's what you called me.
Well, if that's your name...
Yes, but how did you know? How could you know that? You're kind of hurting my arm.
Oh, I'm sorry. Ben, would you like to meet my mother?
I'd like you to.
All right. Anytime.
Oh, you come this afternoon for tea. I'd love to. Ask anybody where the great house is. Everybody knows the great house.
All right.
Oh, and Benedict, be sure to bring your dog with you.
It was easy to see why it had been called the great house. The woodwork was... solid mahogany and carved. The doors were mahogany, too. Nearly six inches thick. The rooms were large and square and full of sunlight. The girl, Nikki, met me at the door and took me to her mother, a beautiful woman with the same Delft blue eyes.
This is Benedict, mother. And this is his dog.
I'm so glad, Mrs.—
Why don't you call me Monica? Since you and Nikki are such good friends, we're very informal here.
Oh, thank you.
Ben, may I take the dog down to the beach?
Nikki, please.
I just want to throw the red frisbee for him. Please, Nikki. May I, Ben?
Well, if you want to.
I won't stay long.
I, uh... I hope you don't think my daughter's rude. She has strange ways, but... she's a good girl.
She's a wonderful girl.
Oh? You think so?
Mm. She has everything. She has a... a loveliness that takes your breath away.
Yes, she is lovely.
She has sweetness and gaiety.
Yes.
But she has something else. I don't know what that is.
You don't? Do you?
She has a wild talent.
A... a what?
A wild talent.
Well, what is that? What is a wild talent?
No one knows precisely. Except perhaps those who take the trouble to learn.
No talent is wild, really. It comes from heaven knows where. It cannot be coaxed, or bribed, or bought. It cannot be cultivated. It cannot be manufactured, or in any way acquired. But no matter where it comes from, or in whom it resides, talent is never a tame thing. It is always wild, as the winds are wild, as the seas are wild, as the world was, in its beginnings, and as it remains at its core. Wild.
I'll be back shortly with another episode of...
That, too.
Sands the color of a ripe peach on an island in the blue waters of the Caribbean Sea. Benedict has met a girl called Nikki who lives with her mother in a stately home called The Great House. Nikki has persuaded Benedict to come to The Great House to meet her mother. But no sooner had introductions been made than she asked to be excused to take Benedict's dog to the beach, leaving Benedict alone with her mother.
I hope you don't think my daughter rude. She has a wild talent.
A wild talent? Is that what you said?
You've never heard of such a thing?
I can't say I have. What is a wild talent?
No one knows precisely. If you take the trouble to find out...
Well, what is it? Is it mystical? Is it magical?
Would it help if I said that it had something to do with extrasensory perception? Thought transference?
Did your daughter... Did your daughter tell you that she knew my name without my ever having mentioned it?
No, she didn't tell me. But then she wouldn't.
And not only that, she called me Ben, which is my nickname. And the next day she called me Benedict, my given name.
Suppose she was lucky in guessing that I'm generally called Ben. She could have assumed it was the diminutive of Benjamin, a pretty common name. But she didn't. She called me Benedict, a fairly uncommon name. And I'm surprised she didn't mention it to you.
Nikki's very casual about such things. She takes them for granted.
But does she think that everyone is so intuitive? Doesn't she realize that she is somehow different?
I don't think she gives it any thought at all.
Tell me, has she always had this wild talent?
She never showed any sign of it. At least none that I noticed until two years ago.
Until...
Yes?
Until her brother died.
Oh. Oh, she didn't tell me. I, uh, I didn't know she'd had a brother.
He was drowned.
I am sorry.
Well, my goodness. You were invited here for tea and I've never given you any.
Oh, that's quite all right.
No, no, I'll put the water on right away. It won't take but a minute.
Nicky.
She'd heard me. She'd heard everything. She stood there, white as a sheet, staring at me with those enormous eyes. And I knew in that instant that I'd destroyed her. Destroyed whatever love she might still have had for me. For I'd made it plain, hadn't I? Plain that I valued my son above my daughter. That I wished it had been she who had drowned, not he.
Benedict, I tried to take it back. I ran to her, I held her, I told her I didn't mean it, that I loved her, that I loved them both equally. But she didn't believe me. How could she? She'd heard the truth. The terrible, unforgivable truth that had come bursting from my heart.
And from that day, she's never been the same. She brings men to me, yes. Men of all ages, all nationalities. She wants me to love again, to replace what I've lost. But she doesn't want me to love her. She can't bear my love now. It would be hypocrisy to her. She'd rather I loved a stranger than pretend to love her, after what she heard me say.
That's why she can't swim, you see. She forgot how to swim because she was swimming after her brother when he drowned. She tried to save him, and she couldn't. And then she heard me wish that she'd failed. That she'd drowned instead. So she's punished herself ever since. Punished herself by forgetting the one thing that might have saved him.
I don't know why I'm telling you all this, Benedict. I don't know what I expect you to do. Perhaps nothing. Perhaps I merely needed to tell someone before I went mad with the keeping of it. But you asked about the turning of the tide, and now you know. The tide turned, and my son was carried out to sea. But the greater turning was in my own heart. The moment when love turned to something else. Something that looked like grief but was really preference. Preference for one child over another.
Will you come back tomorrow? No, don't answer. I have no right to ask. But if you do come, bring your dog. She likes your dog. The red frisbee reminds her of simpler things. Before the tide turned. Before everything changed.
I walked back to the beach in a daze, the tropical sun beating down on me, the sound of the surf suddenly ominous. The tide was going out now, I noticed. Going out fast, the water retreating from the sand as though some great hand were drawing it back. And there was Nicky, still throwing the frisbee for my dog, her brown legs carrying her through the shallow surf, her laughter ringing out across the water.
She looked up as I approached, and her smile faded. She knew. She knew that her mother had told me everything.
Did she tell you about wishing I had drowned?
Yes.
I thought she would. She tells everyone eventually. It's her penance, you see. She thinks if she confesses it enough times, someone will forgive her. But I can't. I try, but I can't. Because every time I look at her, I see him. And every time she looks at me, she sees someone who wished me dead.
Nicky, she didn't mean it. Not really. It was shock, grief...
I know what it was. I know exactly what it was. But knowing doesn't change anything, does it? The tide turned, and everything was carried away. My brother, my mother's love, my ability to swim. All carried out to sea.
She threw the frisbee again, far out into the retreating water, and the dog splashed after it, joyful, oblivious. We watched him in silence for a moment, the two of us bound together by this terrible knowledge.
Will you come back tomorrow? she asked finally, echoing her mother's words.
I don't know, Nicky. I really don't know.
But I did go back. Of course I went back. How could I not?
Nikki. Nikki, my daughter. And the look on her face. The stricken look on her young face. She couldn't have misunderstood what I meant. But if one of them had to be saved and one had to die, why couldn't it have been the boy who was saved? Why couldn't she have been the one to die?
What can I say? What can anyone say? I've tried to atone for my awful words. But there isn't... there isn't... there isn't... there isn't no atoning. I said them. I meant them when I said them. And she knew.
What has happened is that Nikki has been trying to give me back my son in some way. Anyway, any man who was attracted to her, and many have been, she's brought to me. Laid them at my feet, so to speak. Offering them to me as though she were the guilty one because she lived while her brother died.
That's Nikki at the door with my dog. She said she might... Well, shall I let her in or shall I tell her to wait or go back to the beach?
Tell her to go back.
I can't. Not right now.
Of course.
Where's Nikki, boy? It's just the dog. Nikki's not with him. Where would she be? I left her with the dog at the beach.
Monica, the dog's telling us something. Well, Nikki, where is Nikki? Come on, let's go to the beach.
It's not here.
What are you looking for?
The red frisbee.
What for?
I don't know. Except she said she was going to stay here. I'll throw it for the dog. Well, why would she have changed her mind? Why did the dog come to the house without her? Could she have gone someplace else? Where? Why? She'd have taken the dog with her.
Ben, I see something.
What?
Out there in the water. It could be... Nikki can't swim. I'm going in.
It could be her. I'm going to fetch a boat. One of the fishermen... Hurry. If that's Nikki, she's pretty far out. I see a boat. I see a boat.
The fisherman with their boat got to her before I did, and it was they who saved her. When the doctor had been called, treated her for exhaustion, ordered her to bed, and left, Monica joined me downstairs in the drawing room of the great house.
She's going to be all right.
Yes. Thank God. In a few days... Benedict.
Yes, Monica?
Nikki was right. I do love you.
Because I saved your daughter?
No, I didn't do that. The natives did. I loved you before that. Nikki knew it right away.
That wasn't love. It may have seemed like love, but it wasn't. You felt gratitude. You felt relief. Because after two years, you told me the story of the drowning and all that came after. You trusted me to understand, and I think I did. There's a feeling that mothers have for their sons that's unlike any other. It's the closest thing to pure love that a woman can feel. I don't know why this should be so, but it's so.
No. No. You love me, Monica.
Now I'd like to go up and say goodbye to Nikki.
You're leaving?
Mm-hmm. Going back to the mainland.
I hope you'll come back one day.
Oh, I shall. I shall.
Hello.
You knew who it was, didn't you?
Of course.
I'm leaving tomorrow, Nikki. I came to say goodbye.
Oh. When are you coming back?
Oh, next year. After I've done some writing. You knew I'd come back, didn't you?
Of course.
Nikki, when I swam out to try and save you...
You didn't really have to do that, you know.
I was afraid you'd drown.
But I was swimming.
You can't swim. You told me...
I was swimming. Not very well. But I was swimming. It came back to me.
Why did you swim so far out? When they picked you up, the water was way over your head.
I had to.
Nikki, were you trying to drown yourself?
I told you. I was swimming.
Yeah, but so far out.
I was looking for my brother.
Nikki, you must have known you couldn't find your brother.
I had to try. I've been trying for so long to give her something. Someone. I couldn't.
It's not up to you, Nikki. Your mother has to find someone to love who loves her. She has to do that by herself.
But if I could do it for her, she'd... she'd forgive me.
Forgive you for what?
I don't know. Being alive? I guess so. I guess.
Nobody has to be forgiven for that, Nikki. It's not a sin to be alive.
Are you sure?
I'm very sure.
Nikki, when I was swimming out to try and rescue you, I found something floating on the water. I found this. It's the red frisbee. The waves should have brought it back to shore. Why didn't they?
Because. Because. Because I kept it with me. It's how I learned to swim again. Remember you told me how your dog found out he could swim? How you kept throwing the frisbee further and further until he was over his head? And how it came to him all of a sudden that he could swim? Well, that's what I did. I kept throwing the frisbee out further and further and suddenly it came to me. I could swim. Then it was just like you said about the dog. I felt so... so triumphant. I believed in myself.
Nikki, I have to go now.
Ben, you love me, don't you?
Now, how did you know that?
I just knew.
You haven't lost your wild talent after all, have you?
Oh, that. It's a beautiful thing to have a wild talent.
I suppose so.
Do you, uh... do you by any chance love me?
I don't know. Not yet. Maybe it'll come to you. I hope when it does, you'll discover that you do love me. Next year. When you come back. Then I'll know.
While I was packing, the dog sat watching me, the red frisbee in his mouth. There was always a chance we might go back to the beach again. And I thought, what will Nikki say a year from now? Will she say yes, she loves me? A warm feeling swept over me, a certainty that she would. A bright glow of anticipation. She loves me even now, I thought. She just needs time to find it out.
What do you think, I said to my dog. And he dropped the red frisbee on the floor, stood up on his hind legs and licked my face. Was he trying to tell me that I would still have his love, even if I couldn't have hers? Or was he telling me that I was right? That I, too, had a wild talent?
Does a wild talent live in... this one! Can we stop trying to be so clever, so learned, so successful and return somehow to what we call primitive. To the style of living where our feelings count for more than our brains. Where our feelings count for everything. If they are free and tuned to the world we inhabit. And the creatures that inhabit it with us. Once again, I can only ask the question. I do not have the answer. I'll be back shortly.
They say that when Gertrude Stein was dying, she knew that she was dying. She turned to her friend and companion of many years and said, Alice, what is the answer? And Alice replied, no one knows. Then Miss Stein, after a long look at her friend, said, all right then, what is the question?
Our cast included Robert Dryden, Jada Rowland, and Terry Keene. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown. And now, a preview of our next tale.
I want to see you, Edith. Not, not you.
Radio Mystery Theater was sponsored in part by Buick Motor Division. This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our Mystery Theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant dreams.
