Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

The Return of Edward Blair

Episode 1109August 13, 198044 min 33 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 28 min to read

The CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents... Welcome. I'm E.G. Marshall. This is not the ordinary world you have now entered. Our stories are about the unusual. About persons who have had strange experiences. Some a little beyond understanding because human understanding is limited. As yet, there is no explanation for such phenomena as specters, extrasensory perception, or a person's retrogression into another century and life. Still, they exist.

One night in a bedroom of a large, well-preserved old farmhouse near the base of Mount Rainier in Washington State, an elderly manservant, Andrew Casey, is speaking to a man in his late twenties.

Nothing's been changed, Mr. Edwards, since the fine room. They're a dust once a week. Otherwise... Closed off. Been that way ever since you left five years ago.

I see. You'd better get out of your wet clothes. I'll see about some supper for you.

Five years. Wondered about you, Mr. Edwards. Your aunt said you'd return. She won't see you, though. After what happened.

Our mystery story, The Return of Edward Blair, was written especially for the Mystery Theater by Roy Windsor and stars John Lithgow. I'll do that shortly with Act One.

Oh, what happens to us? Can we? Leaving the question to philosophers, it does seem that, sometimes at least, what happens to us was beyond our control. Life is unpredictable, meaning perhaps that fate is predetermined, that our life's course is laid out for each of us. The question can be argued, of course, but keep it in mind as the following story unfolds. It's told by the young man to whom it happened.

I had quit my job in a logging camp near Mount Rainier in Washington State and was hitchhiking to Seattle. It was a miserable night. I needed shelter. Near Lost Cabin, I saw a light in a farmhouse set back on the road.

Good evening. I wonder if...

Mr. Edwards. Come in out of the rain. He said you'd return.

Well, thank you. I want to explain.

You're soaked.

I sure am. The heat feels good. I was hitchhiking.

You better get out of there and wet clothes. There's dry ones in your bedroom closet.

My bedroom?

Nothing's been changed. It's just where you left it. I'll follow you up. I'll dry out what you're wearing.

Well, Sarah, you've come back. Wild night out there.

It was a crazy mistake.

I guess it was, Edward. We never knew. Don't know even now. Every once in a while, Sarah would ask, why did you light out, Andrew? But I had no answer.

Miss Blair, you had your reasons, I suppose. For what, Andrew? Forgotten where your bedroom is? You lead the way.

Look the same. It's a fine room. Just fine. Miss Blair said to leave it the way it was when you went out. Sarah keeps it dusted is about all.

It's a nice room. Your desk and your books. Haven't been touched.

Well, you'd better get out of them wet clothes. I'll take them to the kitchen and dry them out. And I'll speak to Sarah about some supper.

I think I'd better see my aunt.

I'm afraid you can't. She won't see you.

Oh.

You know how stubborn she can be. Strong-willed. Give her time. She might come around.

Why won't she see me?

You should understand, Edward. Miss Blair hasn't been out of the house since you left about five years ago this month.

I see.

You gave her a bad shock. And you? I didn't believe it. Nobody did. It's five years and the talk hasn't died down. There's still gossip about it.

How did you feel?

Kind of let down. I didn't understand you leaving. You did a lot of harm, Edward. My aunt felt disgraced.

Is that it?

Of course. Miss Blair's proud. She's a family name. She feels it's her duty to be an example to the rest of us. Everyone looked up to her until... Until you just vanished.

What happened then?

What did happen, Edward?

I don't want to talk about it. What's done is done. Your aunt doesn't want it discussed.

Well, don't I have a right to know what happened?

You know. Or I'm afraid you'll know soon enough. For now, you come back.

To what?

What do you think? There's folks in Lost Cabin who'll never forget. Or forgive.

Edward Blair. A nice old man has mistaken me for someone else. I don't know what to do. The storm hasn't abated and I have shelter and dry clothes for the night. In the morning, I'll insist on seeing Mrs. Blair and telling her the truth.

I've prepared some supper for you, Edward.

Oh, thank you.

Is it all right?

Yes. They're very comfortable. I thought you might have put on some weight.

I've tried to stay in shape.

I've been glancing through the photo album. A lot of warm memories there, Edward. Pictures bring them back. There's a good snapshot of a man on horseback.

Yeah, your Uncle Jack. And of course this gentleman.

Killed along with the stallions when they were crushed by a falling tree. You came home from college for the funeral. Right after that, your aunt sold all the timberland. Over half a million acres. Mostly Douglas fir.

Where's the fortune?

All yours. At least, it was all yours. Now, all that's changed?

Don't know.

Well, if you're ready, come on downstairs.

How does Tara feel about my return?

You'd better find out for yourself.

You've been great. Thank you. I'll bring the cake.

Steak and home fries and a salad. They're your favorite.

It sounds fine. I'm really hungry.

Why? Not a day older.

Would you like a bottle of beer? We have some.

Oh, thank you. I would.

Hold me a minute. That's a shot. Treat nice, so be careful. Now, tell us where you've been between bites.

Oh, all over.

Tell us about Japan.

I wish I could, but I've never been there.

They said that's where you were heading, folks around here. You said you always wanted to see the Orient. Your aunt even sent Andrew Creighton up to Seattle to check the steamship line.

Oh, that's too bad. Where were you?

Don't you want to talk?

Well, I kind of drifted.

That doesn't sound like you, Edward. You always set your mind on something and went after it.

I wanted to acquire that experience. I worked on an oil barge out of Duluth and on a farm in Iowa. I went down to Mississippi as a deckhand on a tug.

Why? I know that's just common labor, and you with a college degree.

Well, there's nothing wrong with that. Except you've got a big farm right here, Edward. Not that you ever took the farm, but Luke still manages it for us. He's got a bunch of clapper apples this year and enough wheat to make a profit. You remember Luke?

Oh, he was real mad when he wasn't left. More upset even than your aunt. She didn't show her feelings. First, she just didn't believe what you'd done. Then she just froze up. You know that hard look?

She hasn't left the house since... Not to walk into the village. But she does take walks in the fields once in a while. Sometimes, if it's a nice day, Luke saddles the old mare for her and she rides.

That's a lonely existence.

She was embarrassed. I caused a lot of trouble.

I think I'd better push on in the morning.

Yeah, that might be best.

Oh, I don't see why you shouldn't stay for a few days, Edward. Your aunt might come around. You know, you're all she's got.

No, not Michaela Blair. She won't even talk about it. When Edward left the way he did, he might just as well have died.

I'd like to make amends for whatever I did.

You can't, Edward. You haven't seen her. We have. We have.

What had Edward Blair done to become an outcast? My curiosity was aroused. When the old man accompanied me up to my bedroom, I had made up my mind about what I would do.

You're tired out, huh?

I sure am. I walked a long way.

Where from?

I was a lumberjack up range, about 40 miles away.

You walked from there?

I tried to hitch a ride to Seattle, but it's not a well-traveled road. A few cars went by, but it was foggy, and then it began to rain. No one stopped.

You've been 40 miles away for how long?

About four months. I got to hankering for the sea. From Seattle, I was headed for Puget Sound to look for a job on a tanker.

And you decided to stop here.

I needed shelter. There was a light on.

You didn't intend to stop in Lost Cabin?

No. You're still headed for the sea?

Tomorrow, or the next day.

I know I'm not welcome, Andrew. You and Sarah have been kind, but there's a kind of bad feeling here.

I have something for you, Edward. Here.

A hundred dollars?

I told your aunt you'd returned. She just nodded and pointed to a drawer and told me over and over. And told me to open it. The money is for you.

To send me on my way, or to suggest that I stay on?

For a while, maybe. I don't really know. Maybe she wants you to face up to what you did.

I see.

If you stay... I will. But briefly.

We still have an old mare. You might like to ride the farm.

Oh, thank you. I think it'd be wise, though, to avoid the village. It's five years, but the folks down here... As you know, they get an opinion stuck in their minds, and you can't shake it loose. And their opinion of you isn't good.

You think I could face up to it? To what I did?

If you can explain, maybe. If not, you'd be in danger. You know Mr. Manning? He's an angry man. And he's taken the law into his own hands before.

Manning?

Yeah. Still lives on his big estate. Five miles away. He... He's the one with the... The biggest grievance?

That's a foolish question to ask, Edward.

I suppose it is. Why have you and Sarah been so kind to me?

We remember the past. You brought us a lot of joy. You were a son to all of us during your growing up years. And I can't just wipe them out.

I'd better speak to Manning.

No. That I wouldn't advise.

I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know.

I had... I can't even describe it. No... That really effectiveness, Edward, was just, just... Was that... That was... Drowning in pain. My soul, I can't even feel it, has gone to sleep. I... That's how you feel. My time has come. It has.

Are you okay?

Now, listen... I will warn you. I... I... I'm tough. You will be fortunate. Liar, you will believe me and I won't fail her. Big time, big time, big time, that you could imagine. I... What I said, that you... You know... You know... You know...

He liked his supper.

Like an old flower pot, I have to say.

She's been good to us, Sarah. She wouldn't know what to do without us.

He is different, Andrew. Not as high and mighty as he used to be. He'd become quiet and polite. Scraping for a living, can't he, yeah? Sure enough. He has changed. Not in appearance. He's a fine-looking young man. Even the scar has disappeared.

Scar?

Remember when he was 12 or so? He tattooed his name on top of his hand and Mr. Blair had Dr. Ryder take it off? Oh, I've forgotten that. That left the white patch.

Oh, how right. I made a point of studying his hand. There is no scar, Andrew.

Brought a young man identified as Edward Blair who disappeared five years before to the Blair farm. Coincidence? Destiny? I can't answer that because I don't know. Nobody can know. What seems to be coincidence could be. We'll see what happens in Act Two. Hopefully, we will learn the narrator's name. We may even learn why he disappeared five years ago.

There's an Irish proverb that maintains that he that's born to be hanged needn't fear water. In our kind of story, I often have to fall back on... or reach for an explanation of the strange. Just as often, I come up empty-handed because sometimes there is no explanation. Certain experiences are unique to the persons who have them. You may doubt them. They do not.

I slept as if I'd been drugged. Andrew mentioned an old mare, so I pulled on riding britches and after breakfast, he saddled her and I trotted off into the sunshiny day.

Good morning.

Good morning.

Not wise.

Pardon me?

I said it was a good morning.

Oh, so you've come back. I didn't think you had the guts.

Do you like to stay?

Well, that depends.

You're, uh, Luke? Luke Chance?

Who do you think I am? Your dead uncle?

You crazy or something?

I wasn't certain.

Now, don't tell me you've lost your memory. You can't get away with that, Edward.

Well, it happens.

Oh, are you serious?

Yeah, in a way.

I don't believe you. Even if I did, I'd never forgive what you did.

Good. Tell me what you think I did. After you skipped out, I could have killed you because of what happened. You can't explain that away.

I mean to try.

Well, stay away from me. Give me an excuse and I'll hang you up on this pitchfork. I mean it. Now, right off. What reason have you to hate me? The entire village hates you.

Me?

I wish you were dead.

Why?

Stay clear of me or I'll break in, too. Now, right on.

Enjoyed your sermon, Pastor.

Thank you, Edward. And you, Mrs. Stigler.

Oh, yes. At least. He's back, you know, Pastor. Just five years, sir. Have you experienced anything?

No, sir.

Does he come up?

He seems kind of puzzled-like.

That's a good way to put it, Andrew. Puzzled. He stands fast. He did. We don't talk about it. Of course, Mrs. Blair said not to. Well, we don't. We don't want to. There's something unhealthy about it.

I'm worried, Pastor.

So am I. We try to treat him the way we used to because we remember the good. But others are not forgiving. Not that we forgive, but we've been trying to forget.

No, no, no. That's not right, Reverend. We can't forgive what he did. I don't know what I'm saying.

You're a kind man, Andrew. Andrew, you're torn. You can't forgive. You can't forget. You're trying to suspend judgment. I take strength. I confess something to both of you. I don't think that I have that kind of strength. I see them at least once a week. When I do, the anger comes out of my throat and I can't control it.

Have you seen them?

Just once. Even though we're just Mrs. Blair's couple, you weren't welcome. It was pitiful. Once so young. I'd advise them to leave, Lord. Kevin, there's no life for him here. A black opinion is frozen against him. If he stayed, he wouldn't feel that barrier. He mentioned wanting to see Miss Manning. If he does, he'll cause a real murder. His own.

Andrew and Sarah returned from the service. I asked Andrew to have a talk with me in my bedroom. He told me what Reverend Burnett had said. My mind was in an ever-tightening vise. I had to speak out.

He's a good man, Edward. Like the rest of the sea, he was soft.

By what?

I demand no. I don't know what Edward Blair did. I can't believe that. I'm so confused. I'm going crazy.

Then you'd better leave.

I don't want to leave until this is cleared up. It's torture. This silent treatment has got me screaming. Why won't anyone talk to me? Tell me what Edward Blair did and I'll understand. But this is torture.

Maybe that's your atonement, Edward. The Lord moves in mysterious ways.

What do I have to atone for?

You don't believe anything I said, do you?

No. How can you expect me to? Maybe I have cracked up.

Then I'll speak to your aunt about calling in a doctor. In the meantime, don't sit here and brood. I'll settle the mayor. Get out in the fresh air.

Okay.

Been to the cabin yet?

No. Slow to muse, these days. But I keep it tidied up.

All right. This afternoon. First, I have something to do.

Don't go into the loo.

Am I some kind of criminal?

Well, we won't go into that.

Did I murder someone?

You did something worse.

Someone would talk.

Oh, was I so damned that everyone would shun me?

I wore my own clothes and I had my hat pulled down. Except for a few young persons. The streets were... empty. I went to the rectory and rang the bell.

I'd like to talk to you.

Come in. Follow me. This is my study. Sit down.

Reverend Lynette, what did Edward Blair do?

Ask yourself.

I don't know. Now, either you are an awful liar or you have literally lost your mind. I am acquainted with that nature. If you don't know why you are an outcast, get medical advice elsewhere.

There's nothing the matter with...

There is with your soul.

Look, I was working as a lumberjack about 40 miles from here and I quit. It was a rainy night.

I have no more time for you, Mr. Blair. Your presence is distasteful to me and I will not discuss the subject with you. No one will.

Of course not. Those on whom you inflicted unbearable suffering stand high in this small community. We respect them enough not to discuss what happened.

And I'll never know what I'm accused of.

No. No. No. You know the charge, Mr. Blair.

But I don't.

Your return is a shock. Your performance with Mr. and Mrs. Cagey at Booth Chance and now with me has been amazing. Mr. Manning comes looking for you, Mr. Blair. You will recover your memory mighty fast.

I returned to the farmhouse and went for a ride on the mare. It was just as well I did because later I learned that Mr. Manning had called.

Andrew, are you here?

Oh, Mr. Manning.

Now, is that the truth? I know he's come home. Now, where is he?

I believe he went riding.

I'll wait. Why was he allowed in in the first place?

He just wandered in off the road a few nights ago during the rainstorm.

Will you come in?

No. No, no, no. But thank you, Andrew. This isn't a social visit. You see this?

A gun will only cause more trouble.

And you've had enough, Mr. Manning.

You've seen Liz.

Yes, sir. I see her every day. Do you think I could forget what Edward Blair did to her?

No.

You're welcome to come in.

No, no. No, thank you. I'll wander around and I'll wait by my car. Don't use the gun, Mr. Manning. No one would testify against me if I did.

Goodbye, Andrew.

Goodbye, sir.

Sarah. You heard the door?

Uh, it was Mr. Manning. Toting a rifle.

What?

He's got murder in his eye. Where is Edward?

I don't know. Riding. But where, I don't know. I'm going to slip out the back and try to find him. If Manning knocks again, stall him off.

What are you doing half a mile from the house?

Mr. Manning is looking for you. It's worth your life if you return.

Is he armed?

You've seen a cabin in the northeast corner of the land?

From a distance?

You told me about it. You'd better go there and stay for a day or so. Or dismount. I have money with me. And cut out for the state highway. And lose yourself in Seattle. Disappear again. And save yourself.

I'm going to find out what Edward Blair did if it costs me my life.

Where's Manning now?

He's waiting for you at the house. When you don't return, he'll begin to search. If I decide to spend the night at the cabin... Is there any way you can inform me about what Manning's doing?

There is a telephone extension from the house to the cabin, but... I advise you, for the last time, Edward... Not to chance it. Leave by foot. With that tragedy enough, without adding murder to it...

He'd shoot me just like that?

He would.

I certainly did not want to die. But I had to satisfy my curiosity about Edward Blair. So I walked to the cabin and opened the door.

I hadn't sat long in the blue in the morning.

Edward?

What is it?

I asked you not to risk coming here.

I brought you some hot soup and a thermos. And bread and butter.

Well, thank you. If not, you might come here to see what I watched from an upstairs window. I saw a light through the curtains of the cabin.

You shouldn't duck, Edward. I'm not a common criminal.

That's very true. And I'm not going to hide like a prairie dog in a hole. And I'm armed.

But... Yeah, I see that. You're making a grave mistake. For the last time, leave, Edward.

I want to talk to him.

I warned you. There's nothing more I can say. I'll come down in the morning. Thank you for the hot soup. And don't worry. There is nothing more to worry about. I'm resigned.

The course of a person's life is perplexing. Gift is a two-letter word. But it's a mighty... If I had only done this, or if I'd done that. Every day, we make decisions. Most of them, by instinct. They're like forks in the road that lead sometimes to dead ends. Edward Blair's case is one now. What happens to him will occur in Act Three. I will return.

Short explains a death caused by a falling object. A molding from a building. A limb from a tree. Why was a particular person at the spot, at the precise moment, to have his life ended? Call it the mystery of life, but try to explain it. About Edward Blair, or the man thought to be Blair. Why couldn't he have found shelter for the night at some other farmhouse? Well, it's his story.

After Andrew left me, I was nervous. And not all that brave. Later, I learned that he'd... mixed me with his wife, Sarah, and talked about me. And I think I'd better speak to Mrs. Blair. Let her decide. Decide what? Is he Edward Blair, or a dead ringer for him? He's got me wondering. The scar on the top of his left hand. Oh, I wondered about that. That guy just don't disappear. I swear he's Edward. If he isn't, he's identical. What really puzzles me... is that he don't seem to know what he did to the Mannings. The real Edward Blair would never forget. Nor would he ever show his face here again. No, the more I think about it, Andrew, the more I think that... someone else. Well, I'm going to find out.

Now?

Are you captured, Andrew?

The man's in danger. And a night like this?

Yeah, Manny hates him. When it won't stand in his way, he might kill an innocent man.

Well, use the telephone and... tell Edward to come back to the house. He said he's set on finding out... why Edward Blair's hated here worse than sin.

Well, we'll tell him.

Of course, my heart breaks about Liz, Manny. They must say at first they didn't feel too bad about her father. Oh, Peppy, man. He gets himself a hair. Well, I'm sorry for him living in that big house of his... and Liz stuck in the room. Do you saw her, Sarah?

Oh, she's beautiful. Oh. Shaded flower.

Yeah. Well, you can see it in her blank eyes. Will we ever be free of this?

No. No, even if this man isn't Edward Blair, Edward is somewhere. And I hope he calls him, Andrew.

After Andrew telephoned, I turned out the lights in the cabin... and drew the screen across the fireplace. I opened the door.

Who was the devil?

Just to let you know I'm here, Edward.

Well, you could see I was here. I'm not in hiding.

Now, lie to me, Hank.

Well, what do you want?

What I want isn't what I'll get. Here, Mr. Manning. Here, Mr. Manning.

I've got a gun, and I know how to use it. Try anything and you'll find out.

Don't.

Where do you think you're going?

Back to the farmhouse.

What for?

To learn the truth.

Learn the truth. What kind of crazy are you, Edward? First, you don't know me. Next, you don't know what you did five years ago. Think anyone will believe that?

What if it's true? What if it's true? Until I rode up to you in the field, I'd never seen you before.

You're Edward Blair. So you say. So is everyone. Andrew, Sarah, Reverend Lynette. They're mistaken. We can't be.

There's no such thing as identical.

Well, there is now.

Then why don't you say who you are and get out of lost havoc?

Because I want to find out what Edward Blair did.

You know I don't. You don't know about the engagement and the big party and everyone in town at the church? And what you did?

What did Edward Blair do?

Let out. He left the girl at the altar.

That's happened before. Maybe she was well rid of him.

He didn't think so.

And?

I think Mr. Manning ought to force you to see it. First. And next?

He'll kill you. If he don't. I will. And one of you will have it.

Don't bet on it. Village will support it. Action.

See? It's happened before.

Want the truth, Andrew?

I want the truth. I want the truth. I want the truth. I want the truth. I want the truth. I want the truth. I want the truth. All of it.

What was that gunshot?

Look. He fired at you?

Fair warning. And it came up to me as I was leaving. He said Edward Blair jilted Manning's daughter and disappeared.

What happened next?

She turned into a vegetable.

Good Lord.

You might well say that, Edward, if you are Edward.

My name is George Constable. I never heard of Lost Cabin or any of you. I told you the truth. I've dressed it everywhere. It's nothing.

Yeah, well, when you come to the door that rainy night... I was wet and cold and broke. I saw no harm in drying out and having a good night's sleep. Then I'd be on my way. But the next morning... I don't know. It's hard to explain.

It was a fantastic situation. You believing I was the black sheep come home. I wanted to find out what Edward Blair had done. But no one would tell me.

Well, you know now, George. Now, now, sit down if you don't mind. Tell me about Manning's daughter.

Folks said that you... That is, Edward, you'd gone to Japan or China or some such in the Orient. We never heard from you again. Not to this day.

Why? Why did he disappear?

I don't know. Busting his aunt's heart. Ours, too. Then came the disgrace. It's what happened to Liz. It was a kind of breakdown. Right in the chest. She turned the color of her sheet. And then she crumpled. That was after waiting an hour for Edward to appear. Andrew and Luke and some other men went looking for him. But he'd just vanished. Like he'd dropped through a hole in the earth. Manning got her home. Liz, I mean. And kind of a pall settled over the village.

Oh, she was a beautiful, frail girl. A lady. And lots of fine young men had their hearts set on her. But Liz could only... You see, Edward. Well, she was reserved and retiring. Edward was brash. That's the thing we used to say. And he loved her. Well, so it appeared.

What happened?

No one knows.

Heaven's sake, there has to be an explanation. Was he kidnapped? Shanghaied? Killed?

We'd like to think so. That would explain it.

I can't believe it.

Neither could we. Except for Liz. She's a living reminder of what he did to her. We've seen her, Sarah and me. Mm-hmm. Once. She's young. Younger than you. But she's like somebody's genital. Blighted. The light's gone out of her eyes. Skin is a reed. She sits in her room and stares. Her living death.

What if I saw her?

What?

Apparently, I look exactly like Edward Blair.

Yeah, maybe the shot. I see what you mean. Maybe seeing you would restore her.

Andrew? It's an idea. Manning's on his way here. I'll go out and tell him you're not Edward Blair and then tell him about your suggestion. Oh, it might be a miracle. I'd do anything to help.

You really would give it to me? I give you my word. I meant what I said.

I went to my bedroom and changed into dry clothes. I was excited. I might, I thought, be doing something. I thought, I was expecting to repay the kind old couple. Then I heard something. Manning, probably knocking at the front door and listening from the top of the staircase.

Mr. Manning, I have something to say to you.

Where is he?

Mr. Manning, he's not Edward Blair. His name... I'm coming in, Andrew. Stand back. I don't want you to be hurt.

Please, you're making an awful mistake. His name is George Constable. Sarah and I had the whole story. I'm sorry for him. Get back.

What?

He lives. Maybe if he does kill... No, no. I won't listen to you. If he's upstairs, I'm going up after him.

No, I have... We have five years. He's just a look-alike. He's a lumberjack from the camp uprange near here.

I'm going upstairs.

You don't have to do that, Mr. Manning. I'm coming down. It's... It's you all. I want to explain.

Hey, you selfish evil... Give me a chance to tell you who I am.

What you did to my daughter and to me, this is my revenge.

Mr. Manning... Oh! Oh!

You shot an innocent man.

I shot Edward Blair. And I hope he's dead. He deserved to die.

But he isn't Edward Blair. His name is George Constable. He just wandered in out of the rain.

You're a loyal man, Andrew, but you're soft in the head. Notify the police. Nothing will happen to me. I've done the village a service. Good night.

Oh!

If he's alive, I'll tell it from the doctor. If he's dead, Manning will be charged with murder.

Hello, Andrew. Then get him out of the lost cabin or I'll finish him off. May I speak with you? Inside? No. Come on. You shot an innocent man. The sheriff chased him to the logging camp. Then to where he worked in Michigan. Then to his parents in Illinois. The father will be here tomorrow. I... I didn't shoot Edward Blair.

You shot George Constable.

George... George Constable? Not Blair?

I thought you ought to know. The rest of the devil is... He's still out there somewhere. I only lived to get even with him.

I understand that. And you choose to premeditate an attempted murder.

Yes.

You might see... Kate played your wicked trick. To be blighted. How else can you explain a look-alike who wanders in out of a rainy night, is mistaken for another, and is shot by a man who hated him?

I don't have an explanation. It just happened.

Now, what do you think of the two concepts? Free will and predetermination?

I'll return shortly.

George Constable, the young man who looked exactly like Edward Blair, recovered in time from the gunshot. Although Mrs. Blair, the aunt, invited him to stay on, George continued his interrupted journey to the sea. Manning received a suspended sentence. His daughter never recovered.

Our cast included John Lithgow, Joan Shea, Robert Dryden, and Earl Hammond. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown. This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our mystery theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant dreams.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑