Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

The Rivalry

Episode 993July 2, 197942 min 59 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 29 min to read

Let's see it here, please. Come in.

Welcome. I'm E.G. Marshall. There's a common belief that in matters of criminal investigation, Scotland Yard stands fingerprint and microscope above the French Sûreté, the Italian Questura, the Russian NKVD, and even our own FBI. I've often felt that we in the USA could match malfeasance, felony, and forensic probing with anyone, anywhere. With pride that we present a tale of deviousness, deceit, device, and detection in that city of American law and order, Washington, D.C.

Have you no faith, Inspector, no belief that I, Andrew Wolfe, could have gone straight?

Andrew, you wouldn't know how. After 40 years of embezzlement, bank robbery, every con, swindle, and heist in the book, how could you go straight?

Oh, I have the... I have a surprise for you, Inspector. I have not only become a law-abiding citizen, but I'm going to help you solve a murder that hasn't happened yet.

Our mystery drama, The Rivalry, based on one of the first Arsène Lupin adventures, was adapted especially for Mystery Theatre by James Agate, Jr., and stars John Beale and Court Benson. It is sponsored in part by Contact, the 12-hour cold capsule. I'll be back shortly. With Act One.

To those of us who are connoisseurs of criminal cunning, it's an axiom that patterns of wrongdoing repeat themselves. It's as though the malefactors of today have taken example from the masters of past crime, which is why today's detectives must be as scientifically knowledgeable and unrelenting as a Father Brown, a Lord Peter Wimsey, or a Sherlock Holmes. And indeed, such a man is Inspector James.

Interesting case, this. Probably the one that gave me the greatest headaches of my career. And certainly the first in which I had the assistance of a retired professional lawbreaker, Andrew Wolfe. It began one sunny afternoon on the 1st of December. Sergeant Holloway and I were tottering down Connecticut Avenue, returning to police headquarters.

Let's walk a little slower, Inspector. See that man, half a block ahead of us, who keeps turning around?

How could I miss him? A raggedy old man. A raggedy old man wearing a straw hat in the middle of winter?

He's stopped now. He's bending down, tying his shoelace.

Not at all. I've been watching him. Watching us.

Let's duck over to this store window and see what he does. Look. Now he's moved over to that hardware store. He's looking into those mirrors on display. So that he can keep an eye on us back here. Now, where have I seen that crazy straw hat before?

He's taking a package out of his coat, Inspector. He's put it on the sidewalk.

Let's see what's in that package.

Hold on. Isn't what he's doing a little obvious?

Obvious? It's not the package on the sidewalk that's important. He's trying to attract our attention. So, why don't we take the hint and follow him? Look. There he goes. Dropping another package into a trash can. And he knows we're watching. You pick up the packages, Holloway. If they're at all suspicious looking, call the bomb squad. I'll keep an eye on our man. There's something about that straw hat he's wearing that really bothers me.

But... But if he's up to something, why would he want the police to know about it?

Sergeant, that's exactly what I'm going to find out.

The old beggar hailed a cab. And I followed in another. As far as a doorway on M Street in Georgetown. Then up a flight of stairs over a bookshop.

You'll forgive me for not knocking, won't you? My little room is honored by the presence of Washington's finest. I hadn't expected you for another ten minutes, though.

Andrew, when I saw your scroungy-looking friend here wearing that particular straw hat, I said to myself, that's the hat. I've seen that hat at every racetrack in the country. It belongs to Andrew Wolfe. Now, how about that? You recognized my straw hat and wondered why this old bum, Louie, was wearing it. Perhaps old Louie has murdered my friend, Andrew Wolfe. Yes, indeed. Inspector James had better follow and find out.

I admit, that was about the size of it, Andrew. I'm touched.

Excuse me a moment, Inspector, while I keep a promise. Louie, thank you for inducing the Inspector to follow you. Here's the ten bucks I promised you. Goodbye, Louie.

Where ever did you find that character?

Inspector, in my profession there's an army of such characters ready to do little jobs for a few dollars. And old Louie is one of them. Oh, darn, he took my straw hat. Kind of an ungrateful fellow, isn't he? Didn't even say thank you, just left.

Well, Louie can't speak. He's quite dumb. And a little deaf, too. I prefer an assistant who's speechless. Gets us both into less trouble.

I thought after all those years in prison you'd retire, Andrew.

What, from active service? I have.

Well, then why this elaborate scheme to get me here? Does the parole board have your address?

You'll never forget the past, will you, Inspector? You have no faith that I, Andrew Wolfe, have gone straight.

Andrew, you wouldn't know how. After forty years of embezzlement, bank robbery, every con and swindle and heist in the book, how could you?

So you're waiting around for me to stick my hand in somebody else's cookie jar, eh? Well, I have a surprise for you, Inspector. I'm not only a law-abiding citizen of Washington, D.C., but I'm going to become a friend of the police. I'm going to help you solve a crime.

Andrew, will you get on with it? Have you had a report yet at your precinct of the murder of a young lady last night?

Murder last night? No, things were pretty quiet as far as I know.

Hmm. You're quite sure? A ballet dancer or an opera singer? Someone who wears a costume? A young lady?

No.

Supposing I told you that a murder had been committed, and it's only a matter of hours before you find out?

Andrew, will you go ahead with this undiscovered murder of yours?

Right. Last night, a friend of mine who has a little private boat business up and down the Potomac was passing under the Arlington Bridge, and a paper bag landed on his deck. Some of the contents of it. That paper bag fell overboard, but I have here what my friend brought me, and I thought it might interest you, Inspector.

All this has something to do with a murder?

All right, take a look at what I've spread out on this table. A piece of a crumpled and torn newspaper, right? A cut glass inkstand with a silver top. Then, a small piece of broken glass with a tiny hole in it. Two folding paper boxes. A large Dixie cup. And lastly, and most interesting exhibit, an ornate kind of red-colored shawl with a gold tassel at one end. It's the kind of thing one might see on a costume.

I'd say probably was part of a costume. People haven't worn brocaded shawls for over a hundred years.

Well, what do you think, Inspector? You get me up here for a look at this junk pile. You don't think it means anything?

For sure it means something. Some jerk of a second-story amateur was getting rid of what he didn't want by tossing it over the bridge.

Well, now, I'll tell you how I see it, my dear old friend. Yesterday evening, between 10 and midnight, a young lady dressed in some kind of a costume was wounded with a knife and then choked to death by a well-dressed gentleman wearing a monocle and interested in horse racing, with whom this young lady had been eating a hamburger and drinking a milkshake. And to think I'm listening to all this gibberish in broad daylight.

Note. The piece of newspaper is a racing form. Note. The piece of glass has a little hole in it. I'd say part of a monocle.

Note. Sure, sure, sure, sure. No one I know has worn a monocle in 50 years.

Well, that should narrow down the field then, wouldn't you say? Note the paper boxes and the Dixie cup. The well-dressed man picked up two hamburgers and a milkshake and joined the young female who wore a costume. Perhaps they went to his apartment, perhaps to hers. Maybe late after the show. First, he stabs her with a knife and then strangles her with his shawl. If you look closely, Inspector, you'll see on the red material darker red stains. To me, it looks like a bloody knife has been wiped on it. After the deed, our murderer has to cover his tracks, get rid of the evidence. He wipes off the knife, picks up a piece of his monocle which probably broke in the struggle, takes a pair of scissors and cuts off this bloody, stained part of the shawl. I'll bet you the rest of it is still in his victim's hands. He then wraps everything in a piece of the racing form he had in his pocket, adds a heavy cut glass inkwell to weigh the parcel down, shoves it all into the paper bag he brought the food in, and over the bridge it goes. Fortunately for Justice, it falls right into the hands of Andrew Wolfe.

Thank you, Andrew, but I've got to go.

Why don't you take all this evidence along, Inspector? It may come in useful.

All right, if it'll make you happy. The only thing I'd like to hang onto is this piece of the shawl. I know you don't believe there's blood on it. When you've discovered the other end of it, as I say, around the victim's neck, why don't you come back here in, say, four weeks, the end of the month? Ah, New Year's Eve. And I'll give you this part to match up with it. Oh, by the way, Inspector, when you arrest the fellow with the monocle, you be careful. He's left-handed.

Glad you showed up, Inspector. Chief was asking for you. You know those packages that the old bum in the straw hat left in the street?

Don't tell me. I know. Empty boxes.

You never cease to amaze me, Inspector James.

Well, did you catch up with that old bum in the straw hat?

I did. I certainly did.

Well, what's with the chief?

A murder at the far end of Wisconsin Avenue. Top floor, 1333, uh... or 3313.

The victim, a man or a woman?

It was a woman. The medical examiner is up there right now.

Ours?

Oh, yeah.

When did you get the report?

About an hour ago.

Did you say a woman?

Yes, young woman. Musical singer or ballet dancer. Someone in show business. She was wearing a costume.

Oh, be a son of a gun.

Well, hi, James. Welcome to another fatality. I'm just about finished. Labs are on the way to take pictures.

You know who it is?

The name on the mailbox. The top floor of Jenny Sapphire.

Hmm. Well, there she be. Not much left of her.

Oh, Lord, that's awful. The poor girl. What's she got in her hand?

Let's have a look, Sergeant.

A piece of red shawl. It's been cut off with scissors.

Oh, no.

What do you think, Doctor?

Isn't the inspector miraculous? Well, James, you do fast work.

It is cut with the scissors. Oh, but look at the poor girl's neck. And the expression on her face. Did you ever see such work? Did you ever see such fear?

Well, my conclusions are that the victim was stabbed twice with a sharp instrument. A knife. A dagger. Well, maybe even with the scissors. And then strangled. The probable cause of death is fixed here.

Yeah, but, Doctor, there's no discoloration on the neck.

Well, she may have been throttled with that shawl. The way she's hanging onto it. The hands clenched.

Hmm. I wonder what happened to the rest of the shawl.

It's possible the murderer cut it off, Harry. Because it had blood stains and fingerprints on it.

Let's have a look around the apartment all the way.

We worked over the case the rest of that week. Everything we came up with matched the conclusions handed me by Andrew Wolfe. It burned me up no end to think that that no-good thug had flaunted the right answers to a crime he didn't even know was committed. Or did he know? It bugged the blazes out of me that Wolfe could have been right all along. And as a result, it put me into a terrible temper.

Well, where the devil is that man? He was here a moment ago, Inspector.

Yes, Inspector. Coming.

Well, it's about time. Now, you go in there and wait at my desk for me to come back. You hear?

Yes, Inspector.

Oh, boy. What's the matter with him, Harry?

It's hard to find out. It's been coming on for days.

Coming on? It's here. Every time we get to a new conclusion on the Jenny Sapphire case, the Inspector gets angrier.

Well, that's a good thing.

The day before yesterday, I found a few more pieces of glass in the victim's room. And I said, hey, these all fit together. It's a miracle. Oh, you should have seen him, Harry. He hit the roof.

Uh, take a look at that sheet of paper at the Inspector's desk. Look at his doodling. He's drawing animals.

Huh. What is that? Head of a dog?

Oh, no. That's a pretty good likeness of a wolf. Look at that. Look at those fangs. Now, why would he draw a wolf?

Well, the Inspector might draw an Andrew Wolf if he could. You heard what Inspector James said, didn't you? That it burned him up. That a man he'd sent behind bars could take a few assorted pieces of evidence and string them together to make sense. To be outwitted by an ex-felon was an indignity that no self-respecting guardian of the law could put up with. Could you?

I'll be back shortly with that case.

The problem facing the good detective is to distinguish between hard evidence and red herrings. Henry David Thoreau, who went to jail rather than compromise his beliefs, had an amusing view of law and the lawless and used to joke about it. He said that sometimes circumstantial evidence is very strong, as when you find a trout in the milk. However, Inspector James doesn't think this such a laughing matter.

Some more background on the Sapphire case, Inspector.

All right. What's my work?

Well, I checked the place where she worked. The old music hall at the end of the alley behind Wisconsin Avenue. Her boss, a Billy Jacobs, told me she'd been to Russia about two years ago on a State Department exchange program and brought back with her a very expensive sapphire. Some bigwig over there gave it to her, he said.

A sapphire?

That's right. That's why she took it for her stage name.

Did anyone decide to sell it?

No.

So I called the old music hall and asked for the boss, Billy Jacobs. He wouldn't be in till that night during the second show. I got there at nine and waited in the wings for him.

Glad to see me, Inspector.

Are you Billy Jacobs?

The one and only.

I'd like to know all you can tell me about Jenny Sapphire.

Wonderful girl. Great loss. The sergeant there is there by as much as I know. Told you didn't he how she got her name. From that Russian sapphire she brought back. A big son of a gun it was.

Of course. Tell you that.

Was Miss Sapphire married?

Not so far as I know.

Had a lot of boyfriends?

You kid, she danced with me a couple years. Since she was 17. What I'm saying is she attracted a lot of attention.

So she had many admirers, huh?

Well, at least twice. Twice a week.

Anyone in particular of steady interest?

When I tell you this man's name, huh? You say, well, forget it for me. Not that I owe the man anything. So high up in the government, this what I told you.

You're probably not the only one who knows his identity.

Oh, yeah. I think I am. At least so far as Jenny is concerned. I never saw him. Outside in the big shades drawn. On out. Climbing. I sure know who he was. I swear it's quiet and okay.

Congressman, then became an ambassador?

Yeah, the same. He's the one who used to pick up Jenny Sapphire in his car every night?

Well, not every night. But after, maybe I'd say, times a week.

What's Clay doing now?

He's retired. Said he was through with politics. Spends a lot of his time at the racetrack. That post in Moscow was the last one he had. That's where he is. That's where he must have met Jenny Sapphire. In Moscow.

Mr. Jacobs. Now, now, listen. You expect that everyone dies. Oh, Billy.

Billy, that last night when Jenny played here at the old music hall. You remember anything particular about it?

Oh, for the second show. Second evening show. And she asked me, would I get her two burgers, a malted duck. Came off with them. And I say, oh, yeah, sure. She say, order. Order for dinner time. We ought to wait until no one comes to... Oh, I can't. I can't. I can't. How can you order?

Mr. Jacobs, how did he get my burgers from a police burger. My orders for her. He hadn't bought the burgers in the malted himself. He might have given us a witness. But I knew I didn't have enough to tie Clay or anyone else to the murder, not one solitary fingerprint. Then, suddenly I began to suspect Andrew Wolf that he'd deliberately laid a smoke screen across the trail.

Police headquarters.

Bring you anything.

That piece of the racing form he'd given me, and there was a yellow address tag on it. Whoever it belonged to was a subscriber to the sheet. The name had been torn off, but a few numbers remained. I put Holloway on it. He came back in a few hours.

You won't believe this, Inspector.

Sergeant, were they able to identify the subscriber or not?

I presume what you gave me is something to do with the Jenny Sapphire murder?

To whom did the paper belong?

Holloway.

To Robert Clay. You know who he is?

A former ambassador to Russia?

I know, I know. Come on, Inspector, why don't you let me in on this? I don't follow you. This isn't a simple old murder case involving a musical entertainer and a politician. This has got international implication.

Oh, don't you trust me? Do you think that the State Department will let us work with them?

Fergus Holloway, what in blazes are you talking about? International complication, State Department.

The inkwell.

The inkwell?

One of those items in the box marked evidence, case 3536, the Sapphire case. The chopped up shawl, the burger cartons, and so on. The glass inkwell. I had it checked out.

Inkwell?

Well, I knew you wanted me to. I have to do some things without being told. It's Russian. Russian glass. Silver hinged top with a little bit of gold on it. Russian glass. Russian glass. Russian inscription on it.

So it's an antique inkwell. Jenny could have picked it up as a souvenir. Or when she was in Russia, maybe she even knew Clay. Maybe he gave it to her. But just the same, you have given me an idea about something very peculiar.

I have, Inspector?

When it was checked for fingerprints, what did the lab report?

No fingerprints. Nothing.

What Holloway had helped me realize, was whoever had murdered Jenny Sapphire had wiped that inkwell very carefully. Only since the days of the Tsar, someone should have left fingerprints.

Have a look at these photographs. Here's Robert Clay, former congressman, ambassador to Russia, now a Georgetown resident. How would you size him up? You're an expert on physiognomy.

Tough, disappointed, playboy maybe. Could be cruel. Oh, that monocle. Is he kidding?

It's an affectation.

Oh, maybe. That monocle is made to order by a firm right here in Washington. They make all of Clay's. The prescription is identical with this one. I'm sure of it.

I'll dump the pieces out of the envelope. You recognize these pieces?

Well, of course I do. Holloway picked them up from the floor near Jenny Sapphire's body. All except this one piece. The one with the little hole at the edge. I got that from an informant.

Oh, yeah. Well, that must be, uh, a hole through which they string the thread you put around your neck.

Huh?

I think we've enough evidence here to put a much heavier cord around someone's neck.

However, you're telling me that this man, this, uh, Robert Clay, knifed and strangled Jenny Sapphire?

I got a real strong hunch, yes.

Yeah, but you don't have a motive.

If he needed money, she owned a sapphire worth a great deal. Maybe he gave it to her. Maybe he wanted it back. Bosses at the racetrack. We don't know yet. He's hidden the stone. He turned the place upside down. Must be an angle.

That could be it. The angle.

Could you tell from the angle of the knife thrusts how strong the attacker was?

Oh, quite strong, yeah.

Was he very close to her?

Yeah, just close enough.

Anything else?

Well, there weren't serious wounds, mind you. It was the strangling that caused her death.

You know, I always... We thought it strange the way we found her holding on to that shawl for dear life that wasn't cut away.

I haven't figured that either.

How do I think now about the assailant?

You know anything else?

Yeah, but I think I told you, didn't I? The, uh, murderer was left-handed.

Interesting belief about left-handedness, which since early days has been linked with the sinister. A left-handed compliment even today is considered malicious or insincere. It begins to dawn on Inspector James that the man he is looking for may not only be left-handed, but two-faced.

I shall return shortly with Act Three. In case your attention has been wandering, let me capsulize. Andrew Wolfe, a retired criminal, gives his old nemesis, Inspector James, a number of material clues which make it appear that a man once in high political office may have caused the death of a music hall entertainer. The problem is that no one has yet identified the suspect as having anything to do with the victim. Much hearsay, but no fact. And so we find the inspector burning the midnight oil at police headquarters, puzzling out a solution.

Police headquarters, Inspector James speaking.

You're on meat, aren't you, Inspector?

Andrew, what do you want? It's a little early to wish me Happy New Year.

You're having trouble getting proof positive, aren't you, Inspector?

But it's not open and—

Well, this business is never easy. Retrace your steps, Inspector.

I've been lying.

Hello, Mr. Jacobs.

Hello, Inspector. You're too late. The last show's over. Everyone's gone home. I'm just checking the receipts.

That's you I've come to see, Billy. Do you remember identifying the two little boxes in which you brought some hamburgers to the theater?

Yeah. Yeah, I do. And a malted milk for Jenny.

Well, I'd like you to come down to police headquarters with me now and let us take your fingerprints.

My fingerprints? Why? I haven't done anything.

Well, if I were less than honest, Billy, I'd tell you it's purely routine, but it's not.

You mean now? This time of night?

Of course. You're going to find my fingerprints on those boxes. I handle them.

True. Then again, we might find your prints somewhere else.

What do you mean?

Well, shall we say in Miss Sapphire's room?

Yeah, I was never in her room. I swear I have never.

The night Miss Sapphire died, you weren't there?

Billy, it'd be much easier for you if you'd tell me the truth.

How did you know?

Why didn't you tell me before?

It was easier to say it happened the way I said it did. I didn't want to get involved.

Go on, Billy.

It was all true. About Jenny asking me to pick up her stuff. But I guess she was so excited about her date that she ran out the stage door before I could stop her. So anyway, after the theater was empty, I walk over to where she lived. Top floor, number 1332. Wisconsin. I knock on her door and I say, Hey, Jenny, I brought you hamburgers. You forgot them. And this man opened the door. He was her boyfriend, I guess. It was the first time I'd ever seen him. He took the bag from me. He nodded. He goes back in. Then I hear Jenny call her. Thank you, Billy. That was real sweet of you. Good night. She was alive then, Inspector. I hear her voice. Then I walked away. Now. That's the real truth.

I show you her photograph, Billy. Was this the man who answered the door?

Yeah, yeah. That's him all right.

Those are the ABCs of investigation. Sometimes you have to buck your way to the truth. Billy Jacobs had left no fingerprints in Jenny Sapphire's room. But then again, he might not have been above helping himself to a valuable sapphire. However, as they say, the finger of suspicion pointed directly elsewhere.

Uh, yes, gentlemen.

Mr. Robert Clay?

Yes, that is me.

We're from the Washington Police.

I'm Inspector James, and this is Sergeant Holloway.

Oh, well, I would like to help you, gentlemen, but I am just on my way out. You'll excuse me.

This won't take long, Mr. Clay, and it's a rather urgent matter.

I'm afraid I can't talk to you now.

I'm the door right in our face. Shall I break it down, Inspector?

I'm afraid we're going to have trouble. Holloway, go around back and cut him off in case he tries to leave that way. I'll hit the call box for some more men.

Mr. Clay? I'm Sergeant Holloway. I can see you're opening the back door a crack. Now, let me warn you that to try to run for it only makes your case worse. Now, why don't you just come out peaceably?

I won't be harassed this way. Do you hear me?

Mr. Clay, I ask that you cooperate with us. It'll make it easier all around. Now, would you just mind opening the back door wide and standing away from it?

Now, don't you come any nearer, whoever you are. I haven't got the slightest compunction in defending myself with this crowbar.

Now, Mr. Clay, don't be childish. We mean you no harm. Holloway, duck! He's got a gun in his left hand!

No one was hit. I had Andrew Wolfe to thank for warning me that the man I wanted was left-handed. It was with that hand he had fired. Holloway and I rushed him and disarmed him. And by 9 o'clock that morning, we had Clay in custody.

You know I have the right to consult my attorney before answering any questions. Now, I have put in a call to him, but he is not yet at his office. Let us get this over with.

I want you to know, Mr. Clay, that I've sent Sergeant Holloway with a warrant around to your house.

What for?

To search for anything that would link you to the murder of Jenny Sapphire.

I do not know what you are talking about.

Jenny Sapphire had a four-week singing engagement in Moscow when I believe you were there as ambassador.

I didn't know any Jenny Sapphire.

At that time, she called herself Jenny Hart. I understand all exchanges of Soviet and American artists were known to your office. You never met Jenny in Russia?

No.

I have asked a witness who has identified a photograph of yours to be present.

Well, what does that prove? I have had my picture taken. Have him in. Let's get this over with. Turn around in your chair and face the wall, Mr. Clay. I shall address you as Mr. Jones.

Mr. Jacobs, will you come in, please?

Mr. Jacobs, you told me that you believed Miss Sapphire and a certain gentleman knew one another. Where did you get that information?

I don't know exactly, Inspector. I mean, I heard it and I assume the man she was seeing regularly was Mr. Jones.

Was that gentleman?

Will you turn around, Mr. Jones?

Mr. Jacobs, I ask you now to take a look at this gentleman. Have you ever seen him before?

I'm not sure. The man I saw in the evening clothes and, uh, the, uh, whatchamacallit, in the eye. Uh, Mr. Jones, I notice you have a black silk cord from your lapel to your handkerchief pocket. Is that a monocle?

Yes, it is.

Would you mind placing it in your eye?

No.

Not yet. Your right eye. Your left eye. That's where you usually wear it, isn't it?

Can you identify the gentleman now, Mr. Jacobs?

No. I wish I could be more positive, but I can't. There's no similarity to the man you saw in the doorway of Miss Sapphire's apartment?

I wouldn't say no. It might be him, but I couldn't swear to it.

You wanted to see me, Chief?

Sit down, James. About the Sapphire case. It's been a week since you picked up Robert Clay. I think we'll have to drop the charges against him.

Why so?

His attorneys produced a pretty hard alibi for the night in question. He turned up a ticket stub and a program for a concert at the center. That concert lasted till half past midnight, so Clay couldn't have picked up Miss Sapphire at the music hall at 10:30. She went with someone in a car. It wasn't him. Moreover, there are a number of young men in the diplomatic service who wear monocles, four of them actually living in Georgetown. Those daggers found in the Clay house would be clean and inconclusive. So what do we have? Half of a shawl with a tassel, no blood, no fingerprints on it except the victim's. If we could lay our hands on the other half of the shawl, maybe we'd have a case.

The other half?

We have no case against Clay, so I'm notifying his attorneys we're dropping the charges.

Chief, can you wait till tomorrow?

What'll happen tomorrow?

You had almost a month. I think I can come up with the evidence you need.

What, the other end of the shawl?

Yes.

Is this a hunch?

It's more than that, but I need one thing. Would you authorize the property clerk to release to me the half of the shawl we found in Jenny Sapphire's hands?

Why not? James, I don't know what you're up to, but I wish you luck.

Andrew Woolworth had said you'll be coming to see me on December 31st with the other half of the shawl. Then I'll let you have this piece. I hated like anything to find myself obeying this devil, but I had to.

Was I right about the shawl? Cut in half with scissors?

Right on the button. Frankly, Inspector, I consider this caper the epitome of my career.

Did you bring the shawl?

I did. The half that was in the victim's hands.

Have you the other half?

Right in this bag.

All right, let's compare. Let's put them on the table. Spread yours out on the right and let the tassel hang over the edge.

Right. And I'll spread mine on the left.

Well, well. Inspector know-it-all, wasn't I right? Scissor cuts correspond exactly. Let me show you something else. Come to the window. I'll hold my piece of the shawl against the glass. What do you see?

Great Scott, this is it. You see what I see, don't you? The mark of five fingers and a palm. Bloody fingerprints.

What did I do?

It's the evidence. If those prints will show up. The murderer held that shawl with the same blood-stained hand with which he stabbed the victim. Yes, a very clear imprint of a left hand. All right, take this half. It's yours. I promised it to you and good luck and good hunting in your laboratory.

Andrew, I was angry with you. Furious, in fact. But in all truth, I have to admit, no more. I wanted to have a look at that piece of the shawl the victim had. Let me see it for a moment, will you? Don't be afraid. I'll give it back.

Sure, here you are. Almost identical to the half-thrown off the bridge. Tassel and everything. Will you look at that tassel? She must have made this shawl herself. You know, I examined the piece I had and inside the tassel I found a sacred medal. She must have stitched into it. Touching, isn't it?

What are you doing to the other tassel? Be careful of that half. Don't smudge those fingerprints.

I won't, I won't. Interesting the way these tassels are made. Braided gold cord wound around a tiny wooden cup big enough to hold a medal or anything. Even a sapphire. Will you look at that? Beautiful, isn't it? Did you ever see a stone this perfect? This size?

Give that back to me. It's part of police evidence. Just think, that poor girl had hidden the only thing precious to her. Andrew, hand it over. You give that sapphire back or I'll...

Oh, what, you idiot? Did you think I handed you all that evidence for nothing? A murder has been committed for this stone. For four weeks I've kept you on the move and you never even guessed. Now you listen to me, my friend. I've given you five fingerprints of a left hand for your trouble. You can have the murderer and I'll have the sapphire.

And so the curtain descends on today's Theater of the Mind where you see what...

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑