Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

The Second-Chance Lady

Episode 642April 28, 197745 min 18 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 35 min to read

The CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents... Welcome. I'm E.G. Marshall. I have often regretted my speech, never my silence, said the Roman philosopher. And speech is silver, silence is golden, goes the old proverb. Thus, from childhood, are we taught the relative merits of speech versus silence. However, the world has changed, and the value of gold itself can skyrocket or plummet on any given day. And had the philosopher lived in our time, he might discover that people can have cause to regret their silence.

Who fired that shot, Ralph? You? I'm not the one who hit him. How do you know you didn't hit him? All of us fired. How do you know it wasn't your bullet? Because I couldn't hit the side of a barn. But you promised me, you promised me there wouldn't be any... I'm going to be killing.

The Second Chance Lady was written especially for the Mystery Theater by Sam Dann and stars Marian Seldes and Terry Keane. It is sponsored in part by General Electric Citizen Band Radios and True Value Hardware Stores. I'll be back shortly with Act One.

There's a universe of illusion just outside your door. It can also be said there's a universe of illusion just inside your door. Naturally, it depends. It depends on which side of the door you happen to be on at any given time. However, some of you may say this is all for dreamers. There's no such thing as illusion to begin with. Well, to begin with, we should never end a sentence with a preposition. Maybe that's an illusion, too. At any rate, we have in the beginning of things a young lady, a Miss Sarah Ruth Arben, and she is ringing someone's doorbell. She rings, as you can hear, several times. And just as she figures there's no one home...

Yeah?

How do you do?

Oh, well, what are you selling?

What are you buying?

I asked you first.

Do you know the story of the three stone masons?

Is it clean?

Well, it's old. They're the best kind. A man passed by a place where a building was being erected, and he asked one of the masons, Well, what are you doing? And the mason replied, I'm working. And he asked the second mason, What are you doing? And that man replied, I'm laying bricks. And he asked the third mason, What are you doing? And that mason replied, I'm building a cathedral.

That's the story?

That's the story.

So what are you selling? Cathedral?

Yes.

Oh, well, I'd like to buy one, but I really wouldn't know where to put it.

On your face.

My face?

Okay, listen, if you don't mind, I... When you asked me what I was selling, I could have said cosmetics, but I didn't.

Why not?

Because what I'm really selling is what you find in a cathedral.

Oh, well, we're back to that. Belief. Illusion. Hope.

It's been real nice talking to you.

I look at your face, and I see what can be.

Yeah.

Mine here, a shadow there, a touch of it. Pinpoint of color.

Oh, let's go inside, and we'll talk about it.

Well, I'll show you a you you never dreamed existed.

Here?

You will look in the mirror, and you will exclaim, who is she?

Listen, will it take long?

Time? What's time? I look at you, and I say, here's a girl who can't be a day over 25.

I'm 30.

30? No.

Yes.

Come to yourself.

Well, I... I'll tell you. For years and years, you've smeared on your lipstick, slapped on your powder, and rubbed on your rouge. And for what purpose?

Well, every girl has to use make-up, doesn't she?

Make-up. Have you ever considered all the implications of that word?

Uh, no.

Make-up. What a confused and crazy word. And how many things it can mean. Hold still. Hold still. I'm going to take yours off with this cleansing cream. Make-up. Well, for instance, you make up your mind. You make up your mind. You make up a story. Down at the freight yard, they make up a train.

Hey, listen. What are you doing?

You and your husband...

I'm not married.

Well, you and your boyfriend, you kiss and make up. That's what make-up is. It can mean anything. Everything and nothing. But you're finished with make-up forever. Look. Look in the mirror. See? It comes off.

But what are you... We will create a cathedral.

Listen. Listen. I don't have time to...

Time! What do you do with your time today that's more important? You see the improvement already? See how it comes off? In layers. But we have here another person. Is this the face that opened the door?

No. But this could be another face to launch a thousand ships.

I never went out with a sailor in my life.

You never will. When I'm finished, you'll date no one below the rank of admiral. Now first, we shall apply a space.

Look, I'm really very busy.

Busy? Busy with what? And for whom?

Well...

I'm the one who's busy. Look. Huh? Keep looking in the mirror. See? See what's starting to happen?

What I'm trying to say is...

The building blocks of illusion. But they must be a brush, never a trowel.

Miss...

Arben. Sarah Ruth Arben. Your... Second chance, lady.

And you are?

I'm... Millie. Millie Smith.

See how light, how delicate. It's as evanescent as beauty itself.

Will it take much longer?

We've only begun. It's just that I don't know when...

Already a softness. Already a sweetness. Already a certain air...

What are you... What are you doing?

I am building a cathedral.

Yeah, but that's not me. It isn't. Look. I've been like that since I... I graduated from high school.

Of course. That's how I looked when I was 17.

Certainly. And I wore my hair back.

In a ponytail, I bet.

Yeah, that's right. With a ribbon.

I can't believe it. Huh? It's you.

Brookside High School.

Oh. You were so pretty.

I was a cheerleader. A head cheerleader.

I bet you were. You should have seen me.

Well, I can see you now.

You should have heard me.

All right. Let me hear you.

We come from Brookside. We couldn't be prouder. If you can't hear us, we'll yell a little louder. Way to go, Brookside. Oh, hallowed halls of Brookside High, we'll love you till the day we die.

See? There you are again. Not a day over 17.

I was beautiful. Yes. I was voted most beautiful girl in the class.

Well, I can see why. And they wrote a kind of a slogan under everybody's picture. You know what I mean?

Yeah. Well, underneath mine, they wrote, she walked in beauty like the night.

Oh. Oh, she walked in beauty like the night. Oh, I bet you thought that.

No, I'm not. I'm not. No, I'm not. No, I'm not. Oh, she even talked like the night. Oh, I'm not. I'm not. Oh, well, I guess she was. Oh, well. I don't know, I guess she was. Oh, that's great. Yeah. All right, we're going to get out of here. Yeah. Oh, now, let's go home.

Go home?

Yes. I had a nice day. Were you too busy in school? Did you have time to spare to go to class today? I had a good time going to class yesterday. Why? I really liked it. Oh, did you have fun? much in school. I guess I was too busy being prettiest girl in the class.

Well, I bet you're still the prettiest girl in the class.

Well, the dumbest is more like it. I was going to be a movie star. Melisande Schlegel. They all said, you're going to be a movie star. All you have to do is change your name. But you could still be a movie star.

No, I'll never be anything. That's no way to talk. I'm stupid. That's what I am. Stupid. But I could have done it. I could have had everything. But I had to get tied up with him. With Ralph. You stick with me, baby. You'll be sitting on top of a million bucks. Oh, yeah, sure. So what have I got? Believe me, if I could do it all over again.

Hey, wait a minute. What did you say you were?

Me? I'm Sarah Ruth Arben. The second chance lady.

Yeah, that's what I mean. Second chance. See, I saw this movie. It was maybe on TV or maybe I heard it on the radio. Well, it doesn't matter. But there was this person and he came to these people and said words like to the effect, listen, did you blow it the first time around? I'm going to fix it for you to have a second chance. You know what I mean?

Well.

And he went on to say, this person did. Would you like to have another opportunity to go back and live your life over and travel a different road? Do you follow this?

I think so.

Well, is that you? I mean, could a thing like this be on the level? Is that what you're trying to tell me that somehow in some way I'm going to get a second chance?

Yes.

You mean I'm going to go back and live my life over?

No.

Well, what do you mean?

Oh, my dear Millie, I represent the Second Chance Cosmetic Company. Surely you've seen our ads in the magazines on TV and heard about us on the radio. I'm one of many second chance ladies. Ring your bell and they give you a second chance. Another opportunity to duplicate the beauty nature gave you when you were very young.

Yeah, I see. And now you see that beauty needs just the tiniest bit of help.

Yeah.

Now, what I've given you is a touch of our number four base, our number eight lipstick, number three rouge and number nine shadow and number fourteen powder. We'll set up a little kit. This is your very own, your personal.

Well, I better wipe it off, all of it off.

Oh, why?

Because it just isn't me, see? It's little Melisande Schlegel and, well, she's just, she's dead.

Oh, no, she's alive. Look at her.

No. You don't know what happened to Melisande Schlegel. You don't know what she did to other people and what other people did to her.

Well, whatever it was, it can be all over.

Oh, yeah, sure. And you can start again.

Second chance, huh? Don't tell me you believe your own sales pitch.

Well, why not? That's the secret of selling. Belief in your product. Everybody can change.

Hey, listen to yourself, little Miss Goody Two-Shoes. Come on, get out of here. You don't mean that.

Little Mary Sunshine, who asked you to come around? Who needs you?

You need me.

I need you for what?

Melisande Schlegel needs me.

Oh, come on, will you cut it out? You say Melisande Schlegel is dead, but she isn't. She never died. No way. She's been with you all the time. Look in the mirror. All she needed was a little shadow, a little color, a few lines. You see? Her spirit is there.

Yeah, sure.

Now look at this kid. What's in here?

Well, we call them cosmetics. That's from the Greek. Kosma, meaning order, a pleasant arrangement.

Okay, fine. What is this stuff when you get right down to it? Just cut everything into... They can even make... You look like Melisande Schlegel again, provided, provided you feel like. They can put the color in your face, but they can't give you the sparkle in your eyes. Now, Melisande, give me a T. Give me an E. Give me an A. Give me an M.

No, you're happy. Now, Melisande again after all these years. Come on. Let me show you how to put on the base.

No, look, I don't want...

Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. Come on. I take the number four. Don't move. No. No.

Ralph.

You, sister, stretch your hands across the table.

Ralph, don't be crazy. You don't need a gun.

Frisk her, Millie.

What?

Search her for crying out loud.

I think you're making a...

Shut up. Millie, look her over.

You want me to do it?

What's in those bags?

One is my handbag, and the other is my cosmetic kit. I'm a beauty consultant.

No, I said shut up.

Actually, I'm a salesman. I mean, I'm a salesperson for the Second Chance Cosmetic Company.

What'd you find?

Nothing.

Actually, we're a subsidiary of...

I said shut up. Get her identification.

You'll see. It says...

All right, now you're here. There's a wallet and a driver's license. Sarah Ruth Arben. See? And here's your identification card. Sarah Ruth Arben, consultant, Second Chance Cosmetic.

All right, sit down, Sarah Ruth Arben, if that's your name.

That's my name.

That's your story. Sarah, obviously you have me confused with someone else. Let me tell you my story. I've been watching the house the past couple of hours, and I saw you coming down the street. You're working every door on the block.

That's my job. I sell from door to door.

It also could be a way of getting into each house.

Why would I want to do that?

Because you're a cop.

What?

That's right, sister. You're a cop, and you're looking for us.

You made a mistake.

Oh, no. You made a mistake. Remember that rather popular advertising slogan, does she or doesn't she? Here, we can say, is she? Or isn't she? Well, one thing we do know, she's a convincing talker. But as the man said when he put his head in the lion's mouth, it's always easier getting in than out.

We'll get into act two shortly.

Walk down the street of the city, past a row of houses. Each house looks very much like its neighbor. You go by door after door, and you ask yourself, who lives inside there? What goes on behind that curtained window? What drama takes place within those four walls? Well, here we have a rather ordinary house, a rather ordinary block, and a rather ordinary city. The drama that's going on is certainly something you don't find every day.

You're a cop.

No.

You're a plainclothes cop, and you're looking for us. Now, don't you make one move.

Please, that gun makes me very nervous.

That's not all. Ralph, she's a second-chance lady. That's her story. Look what she did to me. She has to know something about makeup.

You're a chump. It's her cover for the job.

Sir, I am really not...

I told you to keep your mouth shut.

Ralph, are you sure you're not...

I never forget a face, and I've seen her face. She was wearing a uniform.

You could be mistaken.

I never make a mistake. Look, I'm an expert on faces. It's because of the work I do.

Ralph, what are you going to do now?

That's what we're going to do now, and back. Don't hit me again, please. I ought to beat the daylights out of you.

Please, no, Ralph. What kind of crazy stunt did you do?

I'm not going to do that. I'm not going to do that. I'm not going to do that. What did you pull? I always knew you didn't have any brains, but a thing like this? I told you and told you over and over. What did I tell you?

Sir, you can achieve better results with kindness.

You shut up. Now, what did I tell you? Not to leave anybody in here. Isn't that what I told you?

Yes, Ralph.

But you went ahead and let her in anyhow, didn't you?

Yes, Ralph.

Why? Why? I'll tell you why. Hear what you do to me. I've been sitting here all day, Ralph. You got the TV? I've been fed up with hard luck stories just to see somebody. I want to talk to somebody. This one isn't just somebody. She's a cop.

How is she a cop?

She's a cop. She's a cop. She's a cop. She's a cop. She's a cop. She's a cop. I don't know. Don't you see the word cop? It's written all over her face.

Sir, you keep insisting. I'm not another human being. It was another person. It was another voice in this place besides my own. Somebody would listen to me. I can't live shut away by myself. You know what? Let's stay here. I don't care. Go ahead.

Honey, I know it's been rough. You didn't have to hit me.

All right, all right. Forgive me, baby. It'll never happen again.

We're just at the last try.

Well, this time I mean it.

The time before.

Now, just shut up. I didn't mean to yell at you. It's just that I'm nervous. That's all. Look, baby, this is the big one. The one that kept us there all the way. You have to understand that. I love you. Do you?

Sure. I yell at you because I want to yell at myself. And if I hit you, it's only because I'm mad at myself.

Oh, that's a completely discredited psychology. It simply doesn't hold water.

I love you, baby. You know I love you. Now tell me you know I love you. Come on.

I know you love me, Ralph. I know you love me, Ralph. You sure we're going to walk away from here with a quarter of a million bucks, baby. That's why I'm so nervous. I'm not myself. I can't believe it finally happened.

You two really don't need me. Why don't I just don't move? Look, whatever's involved here, I really know nothing about it. So wouldn't it be a good time to sit right where you are? Don't you see? The longer I stay, the more I'm going to learn about something which it would be better. I knew nothing about. If I leave right now, I promise you I'll forget all about this place.

Oh, yeah. Whatever it is that's supposed to be happening here.

Oh, sure. Nellie, you know I couldn't possibly be a police officer. Now, I know I've seen you someplace and in uniform. Look, telephone the Second Chance Company. They'll tell you I'm a salesperson.

Sure. Why not? You took the job as a front.

Oh, no. You're going to sit right where you are, lady.

Ralph, listen. What are we going to do with it?

Well, that's for Jojo to say. He's the boss.

I thought you were the boss.

Well, nobody's the boss. Me, Jojo, and Theodore. Uh, we're all equal.

Well, what are we going to do with her?

Whatever we have to do.

Now, wait a second. This was the kind of thing where nobody was going to get killed.

You should have thought of that before you let her into the place.

Wait a minute. Are you saying that this is...

I'm only saying that it's going to be up to Jojo.

Why Jojo?

Okay, me and you, Jojo, and Theodore. We'll take a vote. Are we going to make you feel better? So, where are they?

They'll be here. Meanwhile, they got the money. Meanwhile, we got the tickets and the passports. Maybe they got picked up? Jojo? Theodore? Never. It's half past on ahead. Go ahead, get the news.

Ralph. Will you turn on the radio?

To bring you the news at this... Two blocks away. Three miles... Fired that shot, Ralph. Did you?

Ralph, he would never...

It doesn't matter. You said you didn't shoot.

I said I didn't hit him.

How do you know?

Because I couldn't hit the side of a barn. But I thought you said you didn't fire. All of us fired.

You promised no one would be killed.

But would you lay off? Ralph, whether your bullets hit him or not...

You in particular keep your mouth shut.

Ralph, you're on borrowed time.

What does that mean?

Nothing.

Ralph, what does that mean?

Everybody's on borrowed time.

What he's trying to say, in an indirect way, of course, is that he will have to kill me.

No, Ralph, Ralph, we can't do that.

We're not going to do anything until Jojo and Theodore get here.

And then?

Then we'll see. Meanwhile, get a rope.

A rope? What for?

To tie her up. What do you think? You want a cup of coffee?

No, thanks. Listen, I'm sorry. Where are Jojo and Theodore?

They'll be along soon.

But where are they now?

Hiding out.

Why aren't you all hiding out together?

Well, you listen to those questions and she still says she's not a cop.

I'm just interested. After all, I seem to have a stake in this thing.

Okay, okay, you might as well know. We planned it. After we got out of there, I went one way to this place. Jojo and Theodore went the opposite direction to another hideout.

Really?

Always best to split up.

I wouldn't know about such things. Not much. We decided to give it 48 hours. Just to cool. And we're all to meet here. We stay a couple of days till it cools off some more, then we leave the country.

Could I ask you a question? Who has the money?

Jojo and Theodore, they're holding it.

Really?

Oh, don't hand me any of that. Jojo, Theodore, and me, we've been buddies since we're 10 years old. $125,000? That's what each of them has to gain to forget your address.

Not Jojo, not Theodore.

Well, I hope not, for your sake. Besides, I'm holding the passports. Special passports. Jojo and Theodore couldn't get out of the country without them.

Significant.

Yeah, what?

That they have the money.

That's the way we arranged it.

That's the way who arranged it. Now, listen, I don't know what you're trying to pull, but it won't work. Look, evidently there was a plan. Hold up the payroll office at this factory, and two of you go hide somewhere with the money. One of you hide somewhere else with the passports. Passports? All I'm asking is, whose idea was it for Jojo and Theodore to hold the money?

What does that have to do with... Was it your idea?

Well, why don't you answer her, Ralph?

Well, obviously the answer is it wasn't his idea. It made more sense for them to hold the money.

Why?

I don't have to explain anything to you.

You want to explain it to Millie?

Now, look, there were two of them. The money was in two suitcases, so naturally...

Why split up in the first place?

I already told you, it was Beth.

Why?

Because!

Whose idea was it to split up?

You better shut up, or I'll put a gag in your mouth.

Whose idea was it, Ralph?

I think... Well, it's his caper.

Oh, that's a word for you. Caper? You must think you're a character in a movie. And after a while, the... Everybody who paid $3 per seat will get up and go home. But you killed a man.

I didn't kill him.

He's dead.

Ralph, I'm scared. Don't you see what she's trying to do? It could all have been for nothing.

For nothing?

Yeah. And you could be sitting here holding the bag.

Oh, no. I'm holding the... The what? The tickets? The passports? The what?

So this, wise lady, I had to swipe these passports. Jojo and Theodore couldn't get them on their own. You know why? They got police records. They're on parole. That's a fact.

Well, how did you get the passports?

I arranged with a guy.

But if you could arrange with a guy to swipe some passports, why couldn't they?

Because that was my job!

Of course. Certainly. And wouldn't it be to their advantage to let you think so? That would keep you quiet. While they ran off with the money.

Ralph, anybody can get a passport if he wants one badly enough. Certainly for much less than $250,000.

Oh, God!

Ralph, she's right. She's a cop. You can't trust her.

I am not a cop. You can't trust Jojo and Theodore.

Oh, how cleverly they've worked it. They got you to kill that man at the office.

I didn't kill him.

Oh, you all killed him. Which means if they run out... If they run out on you, as they have, you can't go to the police. If it was just a robbery, you could turn state's evidence and get off. But first-degree murder? You're finished unless...

Unless what?

I would assume if the other two get away, the law would make Ralph pay in full for everybody.

But...

Yeah, yeah, but... But if he can help them capture Jojo and Theodore, I'm sure it will be taken into consideration.

Ralph?

Ralph, I know where they are.

No.

I know where they're headed.

So do I. They're headed here.

Are they, Ralph? Are they?

Why don't you answer her?

Millie, this is how cops operate.

I'm not a cop. I believe her. She's not a cop. Baby, Jojo and Theodore and me, we...

Yeah, I know, I know. You've been pals since you're ten years old.

The three of us. We're closer than brothers.

Yes, of course, but this closeness, is it worth $125,000 apiece to each of them?

Now, listen, I...

Ralph, ask yourself, honestly. Just suppose it were you, and you had all the money. And a chance to keep it for yourself. I'd never double-crossed my buddies.

Now, too quickly. Think a minute. And remember, the worst thing a man can do is lie to himself. Would you keep it all?

Well, of course you would.

Don't you say that. Ralph, you made the choice, not me. You decided of your own free will to become a thief. You know as well as I do there's no honor among thieves.

Ralph, what are we going to do?

Once they leave the country, you're finished. And if you're ever caught, you stand all alone.

Millie, Jojo and Theodore, they would never... I mean...

They would.

Yeah, they would. And I'm a chump. Why do they ever hold still for letting them split with the money? It's that Jojo. He could always convince me, talk me into anything.

Well, they won't get away with it.

Okay, you're a cop.

I'm not a cop. Now, what kind of a deal could I get?

Well, I imagine... I'll tell you what you do. You call in, see? You say you can bring in one of the guys in the payroll thing. Ralph, you can do... You can do part of this now. Now, listen, we've got to keep Millie out of this. That's part of the deal. There's actually no reason why I'd want to bring her into it. Now, you ask him what it's worth if I can lead him to the other guys and the money.

Certainly.

Now, that's all you ask him. Because I've still got this gun pointed at you. Millie, bring the phone over here.

Yeah, sure.

There's no good two-timing, double-crossing... They thought they could pull a fast one on me.

Here's the phone.

All right, what's the number?

Just ask the operator for police headquarters. Go ahead, Millie.

JoJo!

That's right. JoJo and little Theodore. Did you go out and get a dame for me? You were so close at hand. And, well, we all miss by so little, don't we? A few inches, a few seconds. At least we've widened the canvas somewhat. We've added two new characters, the celebrated JoJo and Theodore. And we've also increased the odds against poor Sarah Ruth Arban. Resolution is almost at hand as Act Three returns shortly.

People like to work in the silence and isolation of an office. Others prefer to be up and about and meeting the public. The public, as you may appreciate, is a many-faceted entity. And you can never really know exactly what to expect from an encounter with any segment of it. Our Miss Sarah Ruth Arban is now bound hand and foot to a chair, while four members of the public ponder her fate.

She's a cop, JoJo.

Really, I'm not. I'm a second-chance lady.

Okay, maybe that's what you mean. She says she is, but it doesn't matter anymore.

Why not?

Because she knows who we are.

Do you, Miss...

Arban. Sarah Ruth Arban.

Arban. Why is that name familiar?

You sure it's familiar?

Yeah. I can tell you something about yourself.

Oh, is that a fact?

As a boy, you studied music.

Hey, one of you must have told her that.

You played an instrument.

The trumpet.

How do you know?

Because one of my ancestors was Jean-Louis Baptiste Arban. He was one of the great teachers of the horn. And to this day, young players still study the Arban book.

Yeah, that's it. I remember that book. That's why I had to give up music. The book was too tough for me. Sorry. Hey, I like this dame. She's with it. Class. You can tell by the way she talks.

It's, uh, too bad we'll have to, uh...

But why? You swear. You swear to walk out of here and forget who we are and what we look like. Could you?

Never.

That's, uh, that's what I mean by class.

Are you saying we have to kill her?

Now, why do you use a word like that, Millie? It's bad enough we have to do it. We don't have to say it.

Is that why we have to kill her? Because you say so?

That's right. Because I say so. You see, Ralph, I told you. He's the boss.

That's right. I'm the boss. Is there anybody here who doesn't think so?

Now, look, JoJo. Just, uh, what have you got to say, Ralph, huh? Where would you be without me, huh? Who's done all the thinking for you? Whose brains have been keeping you out of jail? We have to kill this cop.

I must interrupt for a point of information.

And why do we have to kill her?

Because the job went sour.

Oh, yeah, yeah, we got the job, but we killed a guy. And why did we kill him? Because you panicked. You fired first. You didn't have to. The old guy was just scared. But, oh, no, oh, no, no. On account of you, it became the Fourth of July. So, that's it.

But... But murder...

This dame is a cop.

No, I'm not.

She knows the risk she takes. It's part of her job.

But we just can't...

Yes, we can. And, uh, you know who's gonna do it? You are.

Me? JoJo, what are you saying?

The three of us, Ralph. You and me and Theodore were in it for the killing in the office. So, Millie has to join the party. Become one of us.

No.

Ralph, it's up to you. Make her understand.

Yeah, but JoJo... JoJo.

Ralph, am I right? Look, JoJo. Just forget the personalities. Am I right? Isn't this what she has to do? Won't that make all of us equal?

Millie, he's right.

No. For 12 years, we've been knocking around. And we always missed out. Now we got it. We got a quarter of a million for the jewel. The bad days are over, honey. All over. Everything I ever promised you, you can have.

Ralph, it's not...

And this dame, who is she anyhow? A stranger. And who's gonna know, Millie? Who's gonna know? You know what they say? You can't make an omelet unless you break your eggs.

Millie, honey, you gotta do it. For us.

Please, Ralph, don't make me do that.

All right, that's enough. What are you doing, Millie? Putting on an act? You never got your hands dirty before? Who worked over that old lady till she came up with her bank book?

I...

And enjoyed every minute of it, too.

But that wasn't...

All right, so knock it off. But murder...

Yeah, murder. Sooner or later, with people like us, it comes to murder. Well, you don't have to do it right away. We just have to keep cool here for at least a week. Now, uh, Miss Arban, excuse me, uh, Detective Arban, we'll have to keep you locked up in the next room, but we're gonna see to it you're as comfortable as possible.

I can't tell you how much I appreciate that, Mr. JoJo.

Miss Arban, I wish we'd met before. Different circumstances.

When do you plan to kill Ralph and Millie?

Well, this friend...

You didn't answer my question.

You didn't answer my question.

Why would I want to kill him? They're not in your class. Neither is Theodore. But at least Theodore seems useful.

Yeah, he's like a faithful puppy, isn't he?

Mm, more like a great dane. He doesn't say much.

Oh, he's, uh, deaf and dumb. And you're gonna hold on to his money anyhow.

Well, that's, uh, that's how he likes it. Aside from the killing, it was a job.

Well, I planned it.

How?

Well, the big problem, the only problem was to get into the office. It's always locked.

Uh-huh. How did you solve it?

Millie. She got a job, one of those office temporaries. She went to work there. Had the key. It was in the cashier's desk. And she was able to get a wax impression.

You say you're not a cop.

I read a lot of detective stories.

So that's the lead.

What lead?

You know what lead. I heard it on the radio. The police say they have a lead. Everyone who works in that office, they're looking for Millie.

Maybe you're right. And they have a description of her.

Yeah, that's possible.

Oh? That's why you're... You have to kill Millie. But you can't kill Millie without killing Ralph.

Didn't I tell you, Ralph's my oldest friend?

Oh, I think you've outgrown him. Why did you have to be a cop? We could have made such beautiful music together. From the Arban book, I remember. Oh, there were these great duets in it.

When do you plan to kill Millie?

Right after she...

Is that you, Millie? I'm awake, Millie. Oh, I hear him. Did you... Want to kill me in the dark?

I don't say that.

Were you hoping I'd be asleep?

Look, I...

You've got a gun, haven't you?

No, I...

You're holding it behind your back.

Look...

Would you rather shoot me while I was asleep or in the back?

Don't you do it. I'm going to look at you. You are going to see my eyes as long as you live.

I don't care. Too bad. But I got this chance, see? This only chance. I went off in the wrong direction, but with this money, I'm back on the track.

When I first walked in here, I showed you how you could get back on the track.

No. That's the only way to do it. To become Mellison Schlegel again.

No, I can't.

You know I'm not.

Oh, come on. Come on. Mellison, you can win this game. Oh, hallowed halls of Brookside High, we'll love you till the day we die.

Stop it. Now, that's for kids. It's for stupid kids who don't know the score.

Do you know the score?

Yeah, the only score that counts is money.

That's right. And the whole three quarters of a million is how much JoJo plans to have when he walks out of here.

I don't believe it.

Trust JoJo. JoJo has to get rid of you.

I... I don't believe you.

Whose idea was it for you to get a job in that factory?

How do you know I...

Because you had to get a key to the door. Now, the police are going to check on everybody who worked there.

I didn't... I didn't give my right name.

Oh, do you know what you look like? Do you have a police record, Mellison? Are there pictures of you in the files? Are you known to associate with Ralph? You're finished, Mellison.

You're only saying this to just scare me.

To what?

Is it true or isn't it true?

JoJo wouldn't...

Yes, he would.

Oh, I see. Is it possible... Just possible that you and Ralph may have had an idea to double-cross JoJo?

I... We never...

Is there honor among... Among thieves? But you still have to... Be killed.

I'm sorry. Let me tell you what's going to happen. Ralph, JoJo, and Theodore are in the next room. They're waiting to hear the shot. And the minute they hear it, Theodore is going to stab Ralph. And the second you walk through the door, JoJo is going to shoot you.

I don't believe you.

You do. You do believe me. You don't want to believe me, but you know it's true. You pull the trigger, and Theodore's knife goes right into Ralph's heart.

No.

You're kidding.

Oh, poor little Melisandre Schlegel. You just took the wrong turn and got in too deep. Well, you'll have to fight for your life. But you can still walk through the door and start to shoot. And he... He is going to kill Ralph. And then me.

Sure. He's smart, that JoJo. But not smart enough. I'll take care of you later. I'm afraid... You're dead.

No. You shot both JoJo and Theodore, but Theodore was able to... Oh, no. Millie, you're bleeding.

No.

JoJo, hit me. I don't think I'm going to... Would you have come back to kill me? Would you, Millie?

I... No. Not you, Melisandre. Not you. Oh. The halls of Side High will love you, JoJo. The day we died, I wanted a second chance. Oh, there was a swift flavor of cork. Most regrettable, madame. For this, the sommelier deserves to be fired.

Oh, no. I'll give him a second chance.

Madame is most generous. Everyone deserves a second chance. I should know.

Yes, madame. Would madame care to see the menu? We have the finest cuisine on the entire Riviera.

If you please. One moment. The American lady. The mystery woman. Everything must be perfect.

I suppose we might go on to describe the further adventures of Miss Sarah Arban then. But that would be another story. One story each day is all you're entitled to. You must admit, she was a believer in her own philosophy. It certainly took her a second chance. You'd better not take any chances. Just be here till I return.

There may be some of you who will say our story enabled someone to enjoy stolen wealth. Well, there's an entire school of thought that says that's the only kind you can enjoy. After all, if you work hard all your life, by the time you're wealthy, you're too old to enjoy it. We do not take sides. We do not point morals. Our task is to tell the truth. To show the human condition. Our cast included Marian Seldes, Terry Keane, Larry Haines, and William Griffis. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown. A preview of our next... She ran out into the moor without a cloak. But Heathcliff's horse was not in the stable, and no one knew where he had gone. Catherine returned after midnight in the midst of a thunderstorm, soaked to the skin, and coming down with a severe chill. Oh, Miss Catherine, you must let me help you to bed. He's gone, Nellie. He's gone. And my nightmares are coming true. You'll feel better when you've had some sleep. I'll never sleep again. I've been abandoned. Oh, it's just like my dreams. I saw myself tapping on the window, begging. Let me in. Let me in. Oh, hush, Charlie. And no one answered. And my hand broke through the glass, so the blood was running down my arms. Oh, get the blood stains off, Nellie.

Radio Mystery Theater was sponsored in part by Sinoff, the sinus medicine, and Buick Motor Division. This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our mystery theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time. Pleasant dreams.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑