The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 30 min to read
CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents... Welcome. I'm E.G. Marshall. Here, the commonplace is not our booze. If boy meets girl, you can be pretty sure that the expression in her eyes might conceal a demon or a witch. In a way, this story is like that. Because not one, but several persons are possessed. Its origin goes back 20 years and might have gone farther back except for a man's good behavior. For what? His son, Rob Hudson, is in a reflective...
I was only seven years old, Margo, when he was sent to prison. And that was the end of my boyhood.
Were you ever bitter? I mean, kids are cruel.
Oh, sure. I had lots of fights defending him. The kids called me killer. Nice, huh?
Poor Rob. And you're still defending him.
Because I can't believe he murdered his best friend.
Our mystery story, The Secret of Laurels, was written especially for the... The Mystery Theater by Roy Windsor and stars Norman Rose and Don Scardino. It is sponsored in part by True Value Hardware Stores and Buick Motor Division. I'll be back shortly with Act One.
What is destiny? A course through life predetermined by fate. Most of us believe in it. The belief is very old. Greeks and Romans believed in the fate to control the birth, life, and death of every man. They're considered cruel... They pay no attention to the wishes of anyone. And they are cruel... to the individual, but also to those close... Someone goes berserk and kills. Mad act casts a pall over his family. Philip Hudson has had 20 years to think about that.
Rob?
Welcome back to life, Dad. I thank you for meeting me, saying that.
There's a life ahead for you. I know that. I certainly haven't helped you.
Rob, I'm very proud of you. I've often thought of...
Don't think about it. Don't think about it. Don't think about it because it isn't true. Look, I'm a doctor, remember? I never forget it. That's a great achievement, Rob. Circumstances are... I'll make it up to you. There's nothing to make up. You've served your time and you're a free man.
Hardly that. I'm free, but I'm not free. People don't forget or forgive. To them, I'll always be the man who murdered... I'm an outcast. I can't pick up life where I left it, Rob. Your Margo knows what I mean. And your wife, I'm sure, has felt it for you. Loyalty is placed to... A chip on your shoulder.
I'm not aware of it.
Don't kid your old man, doctor. Admit what I'm saying.
Well... If I know Margo, and I know her only... I bet she's told you many times not to be...
Well, yeah. I'd never turn my back on you, Dad, no matter what you did.
Oh, you were so jealous of Mother and Johnny Marsh that you murdered him in the library at Laurel's. Then I was convicted and sentenced to life in prison.
Rob, let me ask you a blunt... You're my father.
The other reason?
Well... Well, despite the evidence, I can't believe you'd commit murder.
Well, everyone's capable now.
Well, that may be, but you wouldn't... You don't want to think murder Johnny, isn't that it?
Yes, I don't want to think it because...
Now, let me finish for you. If I murder Johnny, your defense of me becomes a cruel joke.
Well, that... It was pretty well. I'm sorry, Dad.
Johnny Marsh. Well, they were never... I know. I've checked into that.
Well, the evidence... Airtight. I know. Well, let me amend what I said. I might kill Johnny, but I'm convinced that I didn't.
Well, then, who did?
Fine man he is, Rob.
Thank you, darling. I think so. He was always good to me when I was a little boy. He taught me to ride, and he bought me a horse. And then it all went smash. I was the kid whose father was a murderer. I like him very much. Stay with us. Too much to do. He was an important man in Jefferson Falls. He wants to recapture that image. He'll stay at the Lee Hotel. He'll stay at the Lee Hotel until he vindicates himself. Or has to admit that he blanked out and really did murder that man. That could have happened, of course. At the trial, he said he blanked out. Couldn't remember what happened. Because of his position and Johnny Marsh's reputation, the court wanted to show mercy. Otherwise, he'd have been hanged.
Johnny really turned on the ladies, right?
I guess so. I remember him, of course. He was at our house, moral, a lot.
Why does your father think he's innocent?
Well, you heard him. You heard him, Margo?
But I didn't really understand him and his talk about Paris. Do you?
It's the world he moved in. Johnny Marsh may have had his eyes on lots of girls, but he'd never fool with anyone in his set. That was an unwritten law. Unheard of.
So, those rumors about Johnny and your mother weren't true?
Oh, the two were flirtatious. But what my father is saying is that he never was really concerned about them. If he wasn't jealous, he had no motive for the murder.
Right. All right. If he didn't murder Johnny, who did? The housekeeper and your mother found him dead in front of the fireplace, and your father sprawled on the floor with a revolver in his hand.
I know.
You don't think your mother...
I don't want to, but I've wondered about it. And Mrs. Groh? No, no motive. She was our housekeeper. A nice, simple, confident woman. I liked her. I don't think he's got a chance, Rob. He was caught cold. He must have murdered Johnny. Johnny, you can't get around the fact. What can he possibly dig up now that might help him? Your mother's dead. Your old home is run down. No one will buy it because of the story and the rumors. The haunted house. That makes me sad. Laurel's was a wonderful place. I remember it clearly. Victorian. Lots of fireplaces and the library with its books and the smell of leather and fruit wood burning. My favorite room. I hate the memory. I forget that the murder took place there, Rob. I may have to. All of it should be forgotten. Maybe it's foolish to rake up the past.
Good evening. The real estate agent gave me... To see the house. I know that it's late. There's no electricity here now, so if you come back tomorrow... I won't be here tomorrow, Mrs... Betsy, used to be the housekeeper here years ago. They kept me on as the caretaker, the owner.
Well, you best come in. Thank you. I won't keep you long. But you won't be able to see much. It's got candlelight. The other rooms are empty.
This is...
That's right. Used to be a regular mansion. One of the finest in Jefferson Park. Mind, Laurel? I might be. It's lost the money for repairs. It's real run down.
Why? Why hasn't it been maintained?
Well, it... Is there something wrong with it?
Who fired that gun?
Ain't no gun, mister. Been one for 20 years. 20 years ago. The man was murdered. Hudson was arrested. And this time of day, going on six. So you heard it. What does it mean? No doubt. That's what he got. Mr. Hudson? No, Johnny Marsh. Hudson, no. Mrs. Hudson and Johnny Marsh were... They carried on. She was up first. Got lots of girls in trouble. Then flung herself. She was laid up for months. Out on the sofa. Johnny Marsh and Mrs. Hudson walked in. I murdered Johnny Marsh Betsy. I don't blame you, Mr. Hudson.
Rosie Grove. I know her, Phil, from the hospital. She's a woman in her late 30s. You must know her, Phil. Red hair, good figure. Right, I've seen her. But I never talked to her. So that's Rosie Grove. She used to babysit with me. Remember, Dad? I had a real crush on her. And you never introduced yourself and you became an intern? I had my eye on a younger nurse. You, Margo. Rosie's old enough to be my mother. Oh, hardly. You were seven and she was about 19 when I was arrested for shooting Johnny Marsh.
Margo, you see her every day?
Almost, why?
Well, I've been doing a lot of thinking. Rob, do you remember Johnny Marsh?
Sure. I like him. He was handsome, manly. He had... Charisma, presence, appeal. And those lively eyes seldom missed a pretty girl. Mother? No. He made her his sparkle. But I don't believe Betsy Grove when she implies that there was an affair. No, no, I mean young girls around town. What's your point, Dad? I helped him out of a couple of... with angry parents. Rose? Is that what you're thinking, Phil? Rose? I don't get it. I do. Rose was around Laurel's a lot, wasn't she, Phil? Probably. And if Rosie was at Laurel's on the day of the murder... She might have murdered Johnny Marsh.
It is better that ten guilty men escape than that one innocent person. Justice is not perfect. And innocent men have been tried and convicted before because circumstantial evidence has condemned them. Is Philip Hudson innocent of murder? Did he deserve imprisonment? His search for the truth about himself... Mystery surrounds murder. It is wise and practical to study the victim. Why was he killed? This is determined. Then match death with motive and study the suspect. There may be several, each with his own reasons for thinking of committing murder, but only one who is irrational enough. I'm referring to premeditated murder. The problem for Philip Hudson is that he acted impulsively when he murdered Johnny Marsh. He's proven guilty and now is attempting to prove his innocence.
It is nine o'clock at night. Betsy Grove rings her daughter's doorbell.
Oh, come in. I couldn't tell you. I know, I know. Oh, why do you stay out there at the Laurel? No electricity, no telephone. It's out of the Middle Ages. It's a living room. Well, I'd rather be a lighthouse keeper. You look kind of upset. Anything wrong?
Mr. Hudson, come back. He's out of prison?
Mm-hmm. Well, did you see him? He come to the house just before six and he heard the shot. I didn't know who he was. Oh, how could you forget him? His mustache is gone and his hair's white and thin. Well, what did he want? He wanted to see her. Library. Well, why not? There's a curse on the room. Well, there's no such thing, Ma. It's just an empty room. You heard the shot, Rose. Oh, or something that sounds like a shot. Can't believe that shot goes on echoing all the time. Murder was done there, Rose. And it's like they never want it to be forgotten.
Well, I've forgotten it.
Well, does Mr. Hudson want to buy the house again? I don't know. He just wanted to see the library.
Yeah. The murderer returns to the scene of the crime. Well, let him see the room and then forget about it, Ma. He'll go.
No, he won't. Not as long as he wonders what happened.
Well, there's nothing to wonder about. He murdered Johnny and that's that. I'm glad he did. Now, you know what I went through. You turning your back on me. Do you ever think back on what you've done, Rose? Once in a while. It's only natural. There was a funny look in his eyes. Mr. Hudson. Kind of intense. What are you talking about? Didn't murder Johnny.
Of course he did. We were there when Mrs. Hudson came through the door and Johnny on the floor. A gun in Mr. Hudson's hand. True or not, he did it all right. What else is bothering you, Ma? Oh, the dog come back and he came showing up. The trouble you had. I told you a hundred times, move in with me. I make good money at the hospital. No, no, no. I have your own life to lead. Well, it's a dandy, believe me. You should have married. There was only one man for me. I believed he was serious. Then I find out I was just another doll in his collection. Well, I'm alive. That's something, I suppose. And he's dead. When I feel low, I think about that. He's dead. That makes me feel good. A lot to Mr. Hudson for killing that pig.
Let me reconstruct the scene of the shooting. I'll draw the library and place the furniture. How big was the room? About 25 by 18 fireplace opposite the double door. Your desk in front of the bookshelf? Sofa. You were lying there? No. I was lying down on the sofa. My legs propped up and my hip hurting like the devil. Mrs. Grove came in with my painkiller pill and I took it. And the revolver? I've been cleaning it. They say that I left it on the mantel. So, Johnny Marsh comes into the library. You get up, go to the mantel, pick up the revolver and shoot him. And they found you on the floor with the gun in your hand. Who found you, Phil? Betsy was there and my wife was standing over me.
She staggered and Betsy led her to a chair.
What did she say?
I can't believe it. Johnny is dead.
You've gotten up and gone to the mantel for the revolver and not facing the door. How come?
What do you mean?
Well, if you'd gone to the mantel for the revolver and Johnny came through the door and you shot him, he'd have been facing the fireplace. And didn't the bullet lodge in the paneling by the fireplace?
Yes.
The positions are wrong. You're at the mantel facing Johnny in the open library door. Only if you faced him with his back to the fireplace can you explain how he fell and where the bullet lodged.
I see. He had to have his back to the fireplace and Phil had to come around and face him. And that doesn't make sense. He'd see you had a revolver in your hand. You don't remember any part of it, Dad?
No, none of it. But you're right. It doesn't make sense. It wasn't gone into at the time because I was found on the floor with the gun in my hand.
How high on the paneled wall was the bullet hole?
I don't know. Why?
Were you taller than Johnny?
An inch or so, yes. And he was shot through the chest.
The position of that bullet hole is important.
Why, Rod?
It can determine from what height the gun was fired. Given Phil's height and Dad's, the bullet would be five feet or so from the floor. If it's higher, then the shot was fired by a shorter person or from the floor.
Back to where they found me, son. You went to the mantel, got the gun, fell down and fired him?
Unless there was a struggle, that doesn't make any sense.
We have to examine that bullet hole, Dad. I intend to. Three other persons could have fired that gun and then wrapped your hand around it. Your mother, Betsy. What about Rose? Was she in the house at the time?
Betsy had said earlier that Rose wanted to talk to me.
What about?
I don't know, but I can guess. If Rose was in trouble, she wanted advice from me. Or money. And if Johnny Marsh was the man, Rose had a motive for murdering him. So did Mother, if Johnny had rejected her. I'm supposed to have had a motive, and I admit I sometimes wondered about your mother and Johnny, but if I'd been concerned, I would have spoken to him. But Rose... What about Betsy?
No, no, I can't see that. She was devoted to... And it was Betsy who gave me the medication.
Were you given a blood test after you came out of your blank out, Dad?
No, that's one way of explaining blanking out. I'm convinced you didn't shoot him.
So am... How do I prove it?
Before we get dizzy theorizing, we have to find out why Rose wanted to see me that day. I'll make a lunch date with her tomorrow, Phil.
She won't talk.
Why shouldn't she? Leave that to me.
You asked the right question. And you'd be surprised how much a person will tell you.
Oh, yeah? What kind of question?
How you go about adopting a baby.
Hi, Miss Grove. You mind if I join you?
No, how are you, Margo? How's obstetrics?
Oh, we delivered three this morning. It was pretty busy.
Well, keep them healthy so we don't have to come to the rescue. You've always been in pediatrics, haven't you?
Yeah. Little kids get diminished. They're so helpless. I wish I had one.
Oh? What's wrong with that doctor husband of yours?
No, it's me.
Oh. Well, that's too bad. I'm sorry. You don't know my husband, do you, Ron?
Not really. Oh, I know he's an internist, that's all. Did you ever wonder about him? He was bad.
Well, the name means nothing to you? Hudson?
I knew some Hudsons a long time ago. My mother was their housekeeper. That's, I don't know, 20-some years ago.
You know, there's lots of Hudsons. His name is Rob.
You need to tell me. Hudson? Uh-huh. Well, I was a babysitter to a little kid named Rob Hudson. Now, don't tell me.
But I do. That little boy is my husband.
Well, I don't believe it. Rob. And I didn't know him. I've got another surprise for you. His father's come home.
No surprise. I heard. Relief for good behavior.
Mr. Hudson. That name brings back memories. Bad one. I suppose. But I don't regret what he did. I hated the man he killed.
You did?
I'm, uh, not a pure spinster, Martin. Yeah. Well, I, uh... It's no great secret. Johnny Marsh got a couple of young girls pregnant. Including me. I said he had to marry me, but he told me to run along. I begged him for money. He had none for me. Yeah. It's a messy story. You, uh, you had the baby?
Yeah. Johnny's mother helped me out a little. And the baby? Oh, I don't know. I don't know. I... Let her go for adoption. Was a long time ago.
Do you know Laurel's, Martha?
Well, yes, I've seen it from the outside.
Oh, it was some place back then. I lived there, you know, with my mother. We had two rooms on the third floor with a view of the garden. It was beautiful. I left when I was 18 for nurse's training. Mr. Hudson paid the tuition.
Was there, um, anything between Johnny and Mrs. Hudson?
Who knows? My mother thought so. She was straight-laced, I can tell. When she found out about me, she condemned me straight to hell. She got her wish. I'm 38. All I've got is my job. Otherwise, the last 20 years have been empty.
You never thought of getting married?
Not after my experience. Anyway, Johnny, no matter how rotten he turned out to be, he was it. He must have been something else.
He was. You know something, Margo? I'd like to see Mr. Hudson again. He was very good to me. I'll tell him.
Kill Johnny. He doesn't think so. He blanked out when he shot Johnny, he says. Maybe prison really blanked him out.
Will you see her, Phil?
I don't know. I'm surprised that she talked so freely.
I'm not. It was the biggest thing in her life. The only thing. Johnny Marsh and his murder. There's no question in her mind that I shot him.
No. She also had a motive. She was in trouble and Johnny didn't want to be bothered with her. Your best friend was a...
A real dandy, Dad. I knew it then, Robert. I guess you were like a father to her.
I helped, but she deserved the chance. You know, I can't imagine Rose hurting me. Allowing you to go to prison?
I can. If Rose shot Johnny and set you up as guilty, she'll never admit it. As time goes by, people have a way of fantasizing, believing what they want to believe about something that happened. I was stuck. It has to be Rose or my wife.
Oh, Betsy Groves. You said no, Phil, but... From what Rose said, her mother is a very self-righteous person.
Margot's got a point. It comes down to what is sin. Think of the Inquisition, the witch hunt. It was death to the disbelievers. You give me a self-righteous person, I'll give you... No, no, I can't believe that Betsy would commit murder.
For the sake of her daughter.
Well, she had rejected the daughter, Rob.
Well, what if it was both of them? Betsy gave her the medication and it must have knocked you out. Rose walks in, grabs the revolver, waits for Johnny to appear, and bang. That's what happened, Disney. Nothing to be gained in my talking to Rose. It's too long ago. I have no evidence with which to make a charge.
The position of that bullet hole, Dad.
That's clever, but after 20 years, who's going to buy theory? We have too many suspects. Me, your mother, Rose, Betsy.
Again. If she'll let you in.
Oh, she will. And then I'll make my accusation. If I come down hard on Rose, Betsy might break. We just might begin.
It's a funny thing in life, how friendships arise and what their consequences might be. Here is Philip Hudson, a sound, sensible man, who, when he was young, became friendly with Johnny Marsh, a different kind of person. Unsound in the sense that he lived for the day and forgot about it tomorrow. We know the outcome of that friendship. The question we're pursuing to an answer is this. Is Philip Hudson destined to live out his life as a marked man? I'll return shortly with Act Three. It would be an agonizing experience to be imprisoned for 20 years, thinking all the time that you did not commit the crime. Of which you were accused. Yet, there is the evidence. You must have committed murder. If, in fact, you did not, how can you ever trap the guilty person? Not with facts. They're against you. By admission? Maybe. Under the pressure of fear and guilt, a person has been known to break down. And that is what Philip Hudson hopes for as he waits for Betsy Grove to open the door to...
I have to talk with you again, Betsy.
I've nothing to say. I don't want to in the house. You see the... He's pointing a gun at me. Now, step aside and close the... I had something to say to you.
No, please. And you will listen. Please put the gun away, Mr. Hudson. It reminds you of 20 years ago, doesn't it, Betsy? The day that someone shot Johnny Marsh.
Sure.
You murdered him, you know that.
I don't think so. That's what we're going to review. Put the candle into the old library. And do as I say.
Please, Mr. Hudson.
The sound of the shot that killed Johnny Marsh. You know what it means?
I'll open the door. 20 years. And ever since... Ever since you can hear that ghost gunshot at the same time every night. Because I was falsely accused of murder. Isn't that right?
No, sir.
You killed him. I seen the gun in your hand and so did she. And Rose? Rose? She was here, Betsy. Don't you remember she wanted to talk with me?
No, Rose wasn't here, Mr. Hudson.
She says that she was. Rose? You talked to her?
She told my daughter-in-law Rose was here. And you know why Rose wanted to talk to me, don't you? Rose and I weren't close. No, I don't think... She was pregnant. Oh, merciful. My life was... And I spent 20 years in prison for a crime someone else committed. Rose was pregnant by Johnny Marsh. He wouldn't marry her and he had no money. That's why Rose wanted to talk to me. Isn't that so, Betsy? Why do I have that grace in my face? Rose was going to have a baby and that she led it for adoption to the Davis Foundling Home. Oh, you poor, poor little girl. Unwanted. Rose couldn't support the baby and she lost her head.
What are you saying? Betsy gave me my medication. Do you remember?
Well, you were in bad pain.
The painkiller never before had knocked me out, Betsy. Why did it knock me out then? Why did I blank out?
Maybe you're just phasing from the pain.
Oh, no. I think that you drugged... What do you say? You know what I'm saying, Betsy. ...heated Johnny Marsh. She was in the house waiting to see me. You came in with my medication and drugged me. Rose grabbed the revolver off the mantle and waited for Johnny to come and then Rose shot and killed him.
No, not Rose. No.
Rose murdered Johnny Marsh.
No, she didn't. Mrs. Hudson was... She and Johnny...
Are you saying that it was Mrs. Hudson?
I'm saying nothing more. Did my wife put Rose or you up to drugging my medicine? You won't get another word out of me. You can't come back after 20 years and blame innocent people. I'm going to tell Rose.
You don't have to. I'm going to tell her myself.
Don't you go near her. You try and stop me.
I have an idea. Pretty far up, but it might work.
What is it?
Remember the play within the play in Hamlet?
Sure, that's how Hamlet trapped the king.
Well, why don't we... That's a murder. When a detective is stuck, sometimes he gets everyone together, goes over the case, and then someone turns pale or something, and that's it. But we don't have all the suspects.
I could be Mrs. Hudson. I mean, your wife. You'll never get Rose or Betsy Grove to cooperate.
Oh, there's a way around that.
Yeah? What is it?
Well, I have to think it out. You two visit. I need a pencil and paper and some quiet. I won't be long. I hope.
Well, it's pretty far fetched, Rob.
What else is left? No one's going to confess.
Don't you want to try it?
I don't want to make a fool of you two. We believe in your innocence, Dad. So do I. And I'd like to make it up to you. But the chance is so slim, Rob.
It's up to you, Dad. If you don't want to take it...
I don't think that I do. What's changed your mind?
The facts. I sat in prison so long, I convinced myself that I didn't murder Johnny Marsh. But the facts were... I was jealous of him. Motive. Opportunity.
The revolver in my hand. Let's call it sanity and let it go.
What about that?
No, Phil. I heard what you said, and no. We're going to try my... He's gotten away with a horrible crime.
I'm not revengeful, Margo.
Well, I am. Now listen to me. And I'll tell you why Rose and Betsy will cooperate.
You're a dirty little snake. Said it was common knowledge, Rose. Did you have to pry and gossip about it to Mr. Hudson? Do you know what he did last night?
Yes. He told my mother that I had murdered Johnny Marsh.
Well, I'm seeing a lawyer when I go. I'll sue him off duty, and Mr. Hudson will hear from him. I'll sue him for everything in the book. And you, too, for putting the idea in his head.
Okay. That's all you can say. Okay? You're in trouble, Margo. Look, he was sentenced for murder, and he comes back, and he says he didn't do it? Well, that's a lot of nonsense.
He didn't, Rose.
Well, of course he did. Is he crazy or something?
No. We don't think he did it. I did. Is that it?
That's what he suggested to your mother.
Suggested? He pulled a revolver on the old lady. She... And he'll pay for that, too. Oh, I like Mr. Hudson. He did a lot for me, but this... Tell him we'll see him in court. Oh, accuse me of murder?
He didn't, Rose.
Well, of course he did. He said I did it. Or Ma and me conspired to do it.
Well, you were glad to see Johnny die.
Well, I still am. But I didn't murder him.
You couldn't. Look, if you'll calm down, I'd like to tell you something. Mr. Hudson says he doesn't remember the shooting.
Well, what else could he say?
He may have had reason for the shooting.
Sure, jealousy. But you also had reason to shoot Johnny.
I did, but I didn't do it. Can't you get that through your blonde head?
Well, your mother...
Oh, come on. My mother? She hated me for getting into trouble, not Johnny. She knew what he was. But shoot him? Oh, not a chance.
And then we come to Mrs. Hudson.
What about her?
Johnny had rejected her.
Ah, no. They were together a lot, and he rode those trails. You know what can happen.
Oh, that supposition. I am not naive. Mrs. Hudson was a beautiful woman, and she enjoyed her conquest. Johnny was one of them.
What if he wasn't?
They said he belonged to just... didn't tamper with each other's wives. Do you get what I'm saying, Rose?
That she murdered Johnny?
That's what we really think.
Oh, she's dead. You'll never know.
We may. If you and your mother will help us.
Huh?
We want to reconstruct the scene of the murder. Tonight, in the library, just when that gunshot is heard.
What for?
To see if we can't jog your memory. Mr. Hudson, or you, or your mother, just might remember something about what happened that will point to the truth.
I... I do remember she came into the room, but she didn't go past me. I wonder. The windows in the library are French doors. Very beautiful. Betty, that's what I'm getting at. If you'll help us, Rose... Mr. Hudson accused me of murdering her. Mr. Hudson accused me of murdering her. Mr. Hudson accused me of murdering her. Mr. Hudson accused me of murdering her. Mr. Hudson accused me of murdering her.
But why? Ask yourself why. He did get your mother to admit you were there, Rose. But don't you see? He was fishing for information. But, Margo, he did it. The gun was in his hand. But he was in pain. The revolver was on the mantel. And the shot was fired from the wrong direction.
What?
Well, tell me about that.
Oh, we... We won't bother with your mother.
Well, okay. One more shot and she's gone. I'll show her. All right, I'll play your game. All right. I'm grateful to you, Rose.
It's all right, Mr. Hudson. Last night I could have killed you for saying I murdered Johnny. But Margo explained what you were up to. It's okay. I'm going along. Maybe Ma and me will remember something.
You haven't told your mother about our plan, Rose.
No. I hope there's something to scare her to death.
No, Margo. Remember, you'll be on the staircase, Rose.
Okay, I do remember that. I was coming down to talk to Mr. Hudson. And, Rob, you... You're outside.
I'll be at the fence.
Now, Phil, don't forget to check the door and unlock it.
I will.
You know, thinking about it, it could have been Mrs. Hudson. She was hard and always had her way. If Johnny passed her up, I'm sure she could have shot him. He just didn't himself, Mrs. Hudson. All right, Phil, it's time. Now go up to the door.
Hello, Betsy. I really shouldn't let you in, Mr. Hudson. I told Rose how you come raving in here last night and excusing her of the murder.
Well, I changed my mind, Betsy.
Well, thank the Lord for that. I thought you were... Get out of your head.
What is it this time?
Let's go to the library.
But, Mr. Hudson...
There is nothing to be afraid of.
What are you up to?
Betsy, will you listen to me very carefully?
Go on.
I want to see if I can't reconstruct what happened 20 years ago.
What?
Now, I'll be on the sofa cleaning my revolver.
What?
Bring me my medication. Just pretend, Madison. We'll hear... The library? The woman. You're suspicious of Johnny and my wife. He pulled the wool over your eyes. And? And think about Rose. By Johnny. Think about all that. I remember that. We're back from our ride. On the floor, Mr. Hudson. Betsy, what are you doing? Drag on your own to the floor. Hudson has... I wanted the truth. Now, call the police, Dad.
No, no, Rob. I'm not vindicated.
You?
I will give this room for the last time. Did you notice anything different?
I didn't hear that ghostly gunshot.
So, Philip Hudson was vindicated. The evidence against him was circumstantial and, as we have learned, if he and Johnny Marsh had not been friends. If Mrs. Hudson had not been attracted to Johnny. If, as we set out on our visit to the realm of the Macabre... I mentioned... De... Predestined... Dropped into a still out waves of a different kind. Who affects others and interactions begin. When the deed is murder, the effects are... Mr. Hudson and his son and daughter-in-law suffered a great deal. It's behind them now. Scardino, Ann Williams, and E.G. Marshall. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown.
A preview of our next tale. It was time for his bottle.
I get the message. I'll give it to him.
I've got it right here.
Why don't you take him back to his room so somebody can get some sleep around here?
Okay, darling.
Mystery Theater was sponsored in part by Buick Motor Division and Contac, the 12-hour cold capsule. This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our Mystery Theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant dreams.
