Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

The Sign of the Four

Episode 613March 8, 197744 min 48 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 35 min to read

The CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents... Come in. Welcome. I'm E.G. Marshall. There is documentation to prove that a person's hair can turn white because of a terrifying experience. It has also been proven that a person can actually die of fright, although that eventuality is more likely to occur if the person already has a weak heart, as did Major John Sholto in the Sherlock Holmes classic tale, The Sign of the Four.

No, sir, Thaddeus. I don't think I have much time before I die. I want to whisper to you the place where I've hidden the treasure. That's it. A little more. Huh? That face!

Our mystery drama, The Sign of the Four, was adapted from the Sherlock Holmes classic, especially for the Mystery Theater by Murray Burnett and stars Kevin McCarthy. It is sponsored in part by Contact, the 12-hour cold capsule, and Ex-Lax. I'll be back shortly with Act One.

A famous poem goes, London is a man's town. It's a lady's town. It's a lovely fancy, but London is also a town full of ghosts. The wives of Henry VIII wailing in the tower, the echoes of the voices of William Pitt, Cromwell, and Edmund Burke, of course, the lean figure of Sherlock Holmes in his deer-stalker hat, prowling the streets in search of a criminal. Our story today starts in the famous bachelor quarters of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson, 221B Baker Street.

Miss Mary Morstan, please have a seat and tell me what brings you to me.

I have come to you, Mr. Holmes, because I can hardly imagine anything more strange, more utterly inexplicable than the situation in which I find myself.

Capital, capital. You hear that, Watson? State your case, if you please.

Well, nearly ten years ago, on the 3rd of December, 1878, my father, who was a senior captain of a regiment, came home from India on leave and disappeared without a trace.

Hmm. You notified the police?

Oh, of course. When I came to his hotel, I learned that he had left the night before, and had not returned. I called the police immediately.

His luggage?

Remained intact at the hotel. The police were very thorough, but a search produced no clue at all.

Had he any friends in London?

One. A retired fellow officer in the same regiment, Major John Sholto. We communicated with him, of course, but he hadn't even known my father was in England.

Singular.

Well, I haven't come to the most singular part. A year later, on my birthday, May 4th, I received through the post a small cardboard box, which, when I opened it, contained a single, large, lustrous pearl. Since then, every year on my birthday, I receive an identical box containing a similar pearl and no clue as to the sender. I took them to an expert who pronounced them to be both rare and valuable. But I brought them. You can see for yourself.

Better and better. But surely something else has happened to bring you here.

I don't know. I don't know what happened to me today. Just this morning, I received this letter. Perhaps you'll read it for yourself.

Thank you. "Be at the third pillar from left outside Lyceum Theatre tonight at 7 o'clock. If you are distrustful, bring two friends. You are a wronged woman and shall have justice. Do not bring police. If you do, all will be in vain. Your unknown friend."

Now, this is really a pretty little mystery. What do you intend to do, Miss Morstan?

That's exactly what I want to ask you. What should I do?

We shall most certainly go. You and I and Dr. Watson.

My notes show that the charming Miss Morstan, Holmes and myself were on hand at the dot of seven and were met by a coachman who, after ascertaining that none of us was from the police, took us up in the coach and whipped up his horse.

Mr. Holmes, do you have any idea where we are going?

Well, I imagine to meet the man who sent you the pearls and wrote the letter. I've examined the handwriting and find there can be no question but that the same person was responsible for both.

Yes.

Watson, you look closely at the address in the note. What do you make of this fellow's scribble?

Oh, well, it's legible and regular, even though he's tried to disguise it. A man of business habits and some force of character.

No, no, no, no, my dear chap. Look at his long letters. They hardly rise above the common herd. The D might be an A and the I an E. Men of character always differentiate their long letters, however illegibly they may write. There's also vacillation in his Ks and self-esteem in his capitals. We'll soon see if my diagnosis is correct because I believe we're almost at our destination. Let us descend.

Your servant, Miss Morstan. Your servant, gentlemen. Please step into my little sanctum. Oh, please make yourselves comfortable. I am Thaddeus Sholto and you, of course, are Miss Morstan. And these gentlemen?

Mr. Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson.

A doctor! Have you your stethoscope? Well, might I ask you to listen to my heart for a moment? I have grave doubts about my mitral valve, if you'd be so kind.

And there in that strange small room with the glossy tapestries, richly mounted paintings and two great tiger skins on the floor, I listened to the strange little man's heart and found nothing in it. Nothing amiss except that he was in an ecstasy of fear, for he shivered from head to foot.

Well, doctor, what do you find?

Well, you've no cause for uneasiness. Appears to be normal.

Oh, excuse my anxiety, Miss Morstan, but I'm a great sufferer and I've long had suspicions about that valve and I'm delighted to hear that they're unwarranted. Had your father, Miss Morstan, refrained from throwing a strain upon his heart, he might have been alive today.

Oh, I'm sorry. I was afraid he was dead. Perhaps, sir, you can tell me how he died.

So I shall at once. My father, as you may have guessed, was Major John Sholto, a dear friend of your father, Miss Morstan. Now, eleven years ago, he retired and came to live at Pondicherry Lodge in Upper Norwood. Now, my brother and I were his sole relatives, my mother having died in India. All that we knew was that our father was rich and lived both in luxury and fear. He never went to bed. He never went out alone and employed two prizefighters as bodyguards. Well, we'd become quite accustomed to it until the arrival of a letter from India early in 1882. He fainted at the breakfast table and from that day, he sickened to his death. At the end of April, we were informed that there was no hope and he wished to make a last communication to us. I shall try to repeat his own words.

At this supreme moment, I have much... I shall make... First, I lied to you, my sons, when I said I knew nothing about Morstan's death. I knew all about it, but I swear it was none of my... Please, Father, please don't excite yourself.

No matter now. Morstan and I, through a remarkable chain of circumstances, came into possession of a fabulous treasure. I brought it to England upon retirement. When Morstan got leave, he came straight here to claim... Father, you don't have to tell us any of this. Save your strength.

I must right the wrong I've done, Morstan. You see, that night, he and I quarreled over the division of the Agra treasure. He'd always had a weak heart, which he'd concealed from people for years. Sprang out of his chair, in the paroxysm of anger, fell backwards suddenly, hitting his head on the desk. When I stooped over him, to my horror, I found he was dead.

But why keep his death a secret?

Because my own faithful servant for twenty years, Lal Chowdar, wouldn't believe me. He said he'd heard us quarreling. But that I should have no fear. He'd dispose of the body. No one would be the wiser.

Oh, surely, Father, that was most unwise. Why did you ever...

You're a fool, Thaddeus. I told Lal that he didn't. Now, if my old servant thought I'd killed Morstan, what would the police have thought?

No, no, no, no. Oh, no, that was right. Of the treasure. And you want us to right this wrong?

Yes, yes, yes. He did the treasure. We'll then make... My brother and I rushed to the window. But we were only in time to catch a glimpse of a wild, cruel-eyed, hairy face before it disappeared. When we returned, our father was dead.

Aye, McMurdo, surely you know my knot by this time. It would seem your brother Bartholomew also protects himself against intruders. And, Mr. Thaddeus, where do be the others?

I've had no orders about them. I distinctly told my brother last night I was bringing friends.

Well, I ain't went out of his rooms all day, Mr. Thaddeus, and I have no orders. I can let you in, but your friends must stay where they are.

If I guarantee them, that should be good enough for you. Now, you can't keep a young lady waiting out on a cold night like this.

Very sorry, Mr. Thaddeus.

Mr. McMurdo, I don't think you can have forgotten me. Don't you remember that amateur who fought three rounds with you in Alison's rooms? The night of the benefit, two years back.

Mr. Sherlock Holmes. Indeed. That murderer won't keep us out in the cold now, I'm sure. In you come, sir. You and your friends. Mr. Thaddeus, glad to see you. The master needed a thing all day. Brought him up a tray and knocked. He didn't keep an answer. I don't understand any of it. Bartholomew was expecting us.

I suggest we go up to your brother, Mr. Sholto.

There's something amiss with Bartholomew. My nerves can't stand him.

Quiet, quiet. Let's see if we can rouse him. Open up. Open up, Mr. Sholto. It's your brother and some friends.

Watson, put your eye to the keyhole and let us know what you see.

Good Lord, Holmes. There's something devilish in there.

What's to be done?

The door must come down. Give me a hand. All right.

The scene which met our eyes was so bizarre it might well have been a mistake. The door must have come straight out of the Grand Guignol. The room had been fitted up as a chemical laboratory with glass stopper bottles, Bunsen burners and other scientific paraphernalia. Bartholomew Sholto sat in a wooden chair by a large table in the center of the room. One glance showed that he was dead with a ghastly, inscrutable smile on his face.

Look here, Watson. What do you make of this?

It appears to be a thorn, a thorn stuck in the skin just above the ear.

Precisely. You may pluck it out, but be careful for it's poisoned.

Oh, dear. And read what is scrawled upon that torn sheet of paper.

"The sign of the four."

In heaven's name, what does it mean, Holmes?

Murder, Watson. Murder, vengeance. I have but to supply only two more links to have an entirely connected case.

Only two more links and the puzzle will fall in place?

Watson has a hundred questions. And I'm sure that you have an equal number that you'd like answered. They will be, as we follow the clues with Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson, when we continue with Act Two in just a few minutes.

From time immemorial, men have sought buried treasure. Few have found it and many have died in the search. Fabulous riches seem to be a Pandora's box which unleashes the human passions of greed, deceit, and treachery which ultimately lead to death.

Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson are examining the room in which Bartholomew Sholto met his dreadful death.

Now, Watson, we have a half hour before the police come. Let us make good use of it. In the first place, how did these folk come? How did they go?

Folk? You mean there was more than one?

Well, surely. First examine the window.

Window locked on inside. No hinges. We open it. No water pipe near. Roof quite out of reach. Yet a man mounted by the window. It rained little last night and here is the print of a foot upon the sill. And here is a circular muddy mark. And there again on the floor by the table. You see, Watson?

That's not a foot mark.

Well, it's something much more valuable. The impression of a wooden stump.

Oh, come, Holmes. You never make me believe a wooden-legged man climbed up that wall and...

Come here a minute. I look out the window. Could any able-bodied man scale that sheer brick wall?

Absolutely impossible.

Agreed. But suppose you had a friend up here who lowered you this good stout rope that I see over there in the corner. Then I think, if you were an active man, you might swarm up, wooden leg and all, and then get away in the same fashion. Your ally would then lock the window from the inside after drawing up the rope.

Well, it seems possible, but how can you be... How can you be so certain?

Well, you notice I examined the rope from which I deduced that our wooden-legged man, though a fair climber, wasn't a professional sailor. His hands were far from horny. If you look closely, especially towards the end of the rope, you'll see that he slipped down so fast he took a good deal of skin off his hands.

All right, but what about this mysterious ally? How did he get in?

Capital, Watson, capital. You've hit upon the singular aspect of the case. Although there are parallels in India, but if you look around the house and the grounds, you'll find a solution.

Aside from the fact that it looks as if all the moulds in England have been let loose about the place, I see nothing to help us.

Once again, you've hit upon it, Watson. The holes, of course, were dug in the course of the search for the treasure, which was ultimately found in the secret room above here, between this room and the garret.

Of course. He came through the hole in the ceiling by way of the roof.

Of course he did. And now it... ...proves us to extend our investigation to the secret room in which the treasure was found. Now, Watson, a trap door which leads out to the roof. This, then, is the way number one entered. Aha! Look, on the floor, we shall find other traces of his individuality. The print, small, naked foot.

Good Lord, Holmes! A child has done this horrible thing?

Nonsense, Watson. This was something I should have foreseen. My memory failed me momentarily. Well, there's nothing more to be learned here.

Well, Holmes, if it wasn't a child, what was it?

Well, you know my methods, Watson. Apply them.

Well, I... I know, Arthur!

Well, what are you and what are you doing?

Constabulary. We'd best go down and explain our presence.

Why, it's Mr. Sherlock Holmes, the theorist.

Mr. Athelney Jones. The same, sir. Nah. But there's no room for theories here. By his own admission, Sholto was with his brother last night. And the brother died of some fit or other, and Sholto walked off with the treasure. Now, how does that strike you?

On which the dead man got up and locked the door on the inside.

Um... Hey, but we mustn't lose sight of the facts. Well, this Thaddeus Sholto was his brother. There was an argument. The brother is dead. The jewels are gone.

Well, you're not quite in possession of all the facts, Inspector. This splinter of wood, which I have every reason to believe to be poisoned, was in the man's scalp. You can see the mark?

Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. This card inscribed, as you see it, was on the table, and beside it lay this rather curious stone-headed instrument.

Well, there's no difficulty there. The house is full of Indian curiosities. If the splinter's poisonous, Thaddeus could well have made use of it. But the only question remaining is, how did he get out? I've got it. The hole in the ceiling. It must lead to the roof. Uh, you were up there, sir. Is there a... It's that door, which could be open, which leads on to the roof. Well, then I have my case. I'm going to charge Thaddeus Sholto.

Well, I must warn you, Inspector, that you're moving too fast, too soon.

Well, with all due respect to your theories, Mr. Holmes, I'm satisfied that I have all I need.

Well, then you would have no interest in the name and description of one of the two men who were in this room last night.

I'm a police officer, Mr. Holmes. And if that's a joke, it's in very bad taste.

His name is Jonathan Small. He's poorly educated, small, active. He's lost his right leg and wears a wooden stump, which is worn away. His left boot has a coarse, square-toed sole with an iron band around the heel. He's middle-aged, much sunburned, and has been a convict, and there's a good deal of skin missing from the palms of his hand.

It beats me how you come up with all these things, Mr. Holmes. But I admit, you make it sound mighty convincing. How about the other man?

The other man, Inspector, is a rather curious person. I hope to be able to introduce you to the pair of them before you drag poor Mr. Sholto into court.

Holmes sent me to see Mary Morstan safely home and meet him back at Baker Street. There was little conversation on the ride back to her lodgings in the cab. I accepted her offer of tea.

Dr. Watson, I'm truly sorry that I seem to have dragged you into a nightmare.

Oh, my dear girl, don't apologize. Holmes and I, uh, well, we've investigated some pretty rough cases, and besides, had you not come to us, we should never have met.

It's kind of you to say that.

Kindness has nothing to do with it. Mary, I mean Miss Morstan.

Well, you may call me Mary.

Mary, I, I...

Yes?

Well, I was going to say that you need have no fear. Holmes will get to the bottom of this.

With your help?

Oh, sure. Holmes is kind enough to say that I act as a sort of catalyst to him, but...

I'm sure it's true. But you said something before. About the case bringing us together. Was that important to you?

Well, I should say... Well, you know that, don't you, Mary?

Well, I thought so, but... Well, you seem changed.

Well, you know Holmes will surely recover the treasure. That will make you a very rich young lady.

Well, I'm not thinking about that.

Well, I am. Why?

Because it's important. Very.

Not to me. And I shouldn't have thought that you were the type to be so concerned with money. At least you didn't appear that way when we first met.

Well, the situation was a bit different then, wasn't it?

How?

Well, for one thing, I had no idea you'd turn out to be such a wealthy woman.

And why should that matter?

Well, hang it all, Mary. If you can't see how it matters, I can't possibly explain it to you. But I wish you a very good night.

I left Miss Morstan's lodgings in a foul mood and went directly to our rooms at Baker Street and then to bed. I was awakened very early the next morning by the curious sound of what I was sure was a dog barking. I thought I must have dreamed it because I knew Holmes would never have a dog in our lodgings. And then Holmes rapped on the door and called out sharply.

I need you, my dear chap. Get dressed. And be sure to put on a pair of stout walking shoes.

I was out of bed, washed and dressed speedily. And upon entering the study, saw that I hadn't dreamed the dog.

What's this, Holmes?

Well, Lincoln, you might... My dear chap can see that this is a dog. His name is Toby. He's probably the best tracker in London and today we're going to use him to lead us to Jonathan Small.

With all due respect to Toby's nose, Holmes, how in the world do you expect a dog to track a scent which is at least 24 hours old?

I asked you to sniff this handkerchief.

Huh? Hmm? Well?

There's a distinctly tarry smell about it.

Exactly. Now, in my investigations at Pondicherry Lodge last night, I ascertained that our small man had stepped onto some creosote on the edge of the window. If you can smell it, I have no doubt that Toby here will have even less difficulty in tracking. So, let's be off to Pondicherry Lodge and start our hunt.

Just as the sun was rising, I found myself with Holmes on the grounds of Pondicherry Lodge. Holmes began to circle around the house, looking, as he put it, for a likely spot where our small man descended.

It would have to be someplace that's climbable.

Oh! Ah! Here. There's a water spout that seems pretty firm. What do you say, Watson?

Well, I can't budge it, Holmes. So, it should certainly have held the small man's weight. And here's a water barrel.

Here. Bring Toby over here, will you? And I'll let him get a whiff of this handkerchief, and then we shall see what happens. There you are, Toby. Smell it. Smell it.

He's on the trail, Watson.

Toby led us across the grounds and over to the boundary wall, whining eagerly. He led us to a break from which we could see people who had clambered over the wall. Holmes climbed up. I handed Toby up to him, joined him, and then we dropped down to the other side.

Ah! We're in luck. There's been no rain. The scent's still very strong. Toby should have no trouble.

Hello. Hello. What's this?

Well, appears to be a cigarette case.

Oh, something much more deadly, I suspect. You see these hellish things, Watson?

Yes. They're the same as the thorn we found in Bartholomew Sholto.

Exactly. And mind you don't pick yourself. I'd sooner face a bullet myself.

All right, old boy, all right. We're with you.

Well, we're fortunate that one of those devils put his foot in creosote, Holmes.

Chance has given us an easy way of tracing them, but I have enough knowledge to enable me to trace them in four different ways. This is just the simplest.

I marvel at the way you obtain your results. How, for example, could you describe the wooden-legged man to Inspector Jones with such confidence?

Ah, yes. No miracle there, my dear fellow. As soon as we heard of the existence of a treasure, everything became obvious. Think, Watson. Two officers assigned to India. It was child's play to ascertain from the War Office that they were in command of a convict guard. Now, you recall the piece of paper belonging to Captain Morstan that Miss Morstan showed us on the way to Pondicherry Lodge?

Well, it was some old map.

Yes, precisely. The sort of map used to locate a treasure, and it was signed Jonathan Small and three other non-English names.

Ah, the sign of the four.

Excellent, Watson. Now, think back on how Major Sholto died.

Well, his heart gave out.

Yes, why, man? What caused it?

Well, Thaddeus told us he saw a face at the window. It frightened him.

Exactly. Now, doesn't it follow that a man who deprived his own partner of a treasure would also deprive a convict of his share and would then live in fear in the event that the convict escaped?

Hmm. Full fear of his life.

But, Holmes, you said it wasn't Small who killed Bartholomew, his associate.

Quite so, quite so.

Did you take a pistol with you?

No, I had my stick.

Well, I'll leave the wooden-legged man to you, but if the associate turns nasty, I shall shoot him dead.

They seem to be approaching their hiding place.

Undoubtedly. Keep a sharp eye out.

They seem to have taken refuge in a lumberyard.

There's a little beast taking us.

Holmes! Holmes, what does this mean?

Ha, ha, ha! It means, my dear Watson, that Toby's nose is infallible.

Huh?

That barrel on which he jumped so proudly is a barrel full of creosote.

In the famous Conan Doyle story, A Scandal in Bohemia, Sherlock Holmes was outwitted for the first time in his life by a woman, Irene Adler, who Holmes ever after referred to as the woman. Now it appears that the great detective has been misled by a dog.

Dog?

We'll return with Act Three in just a few minutes.

The legendary pot of gold at the end of the rainbow is old stuff, and I dare say most of us have chased it at one time or another, only to have the sought-after treasure turn out to be worthless. However, I doubt if any of us have had the unfortunate experience of Sherlock Holmes and his friend Dr. Watson, believing they'd found the hiding place of a pair of criminals and a cache of fabulous jewels found instead only a barrel of creosote.

It's obvious what happened, Watson. If you remember the place where our good friend Toby seemed to lose the trail, that must have been where two trails crossed. Toby just chose the wrong one. We're fortunate that it's not too far back. Come, let's retrace our steps.

And so it proved. Taken back to where he'd been running in circles, Toby happily set off on another trail which led us through Belmont Place and Prince's Street right down to the water's edge. Where there was a small wooden wharf. Toby led us to the very edge where he stood whining, looking out on the dark current beyond.

We've run out of luck, Watson. They've taken to a boat here.

Well, that's that then, eh? They've gotten clean away.

Not necessarily. Look at that sign. Mordecai Smith. Boat for hire by the hour or the day. Including the steam launch Aurora. And we see from the pile of coke on the jetty that the Aurora is indeed a boat. We see the steam launch and that she isn't here. Come, Watson. Just keep Toby quiet while I see if anyone's in the shack.

Yes?

I'd like to speak to Mordecai Smith.

Oh, I'm sorry to say, sir, my man's away. He's been away since yesterday morning, sir. And truth to tell, I'm beginning to feel anxious about him.

I wanted to hire his steam launch.

Oh, I bless you, sir. It's in the steam launch that he's gone. And that's what puzzled me. For I know there ain't enough coals in her that would take her to Woolwich and back.

Well, mightn't he have bought some at a wharf down the river?

Oh, it weren't his way, sir. Besides, I didn't like that wooden-legged man with his ugly face and outlandish talk.

You say a wooden-legged man?

Oh, yes, sir. A brown monkey face. It was him that coaxed my man away yesterday night. And what's more, there was steam up in the launch. Oh, I tell you straight, sir, I must be...

I'm sorry, Mrs. Smith, it's because I wanted a steam launch. And I've heard good reports of the Aurora. She's green with a yellow line and very broad in the beam.

Oh, then it can't be the Aurora you're asking about, sir.

Ah.

She's just trim a little thing as any on the river. And she's been painted black with two red stripes.

I was all for engaging a launch and setting off downriver to track the Aurora. But Holmes pointed out what a colossal task that would be. Therefore, after returning Toby to his grateful owner, we found ourselves in the office of Athelney Jones at Scotland Yard.

Well, Holmes, I'm very happy to tell you I've got the whole lot of them in jail now.

The whole lot?

Yes. The brother of Thaddeus, that prize fighter McMurdo, and the Indian servant, Lal something or other. Now, there's no question that they were in it together.

How did you arrive at that interesting conclusion?

Well, you helped by showing me that there had to be two people. What more likely than those two who were always with him?

Well, haven't you overlooked the fact that they were loyal servants of the murdered man?

Oh, according to Thaddeus, Mr. Holmes. He wanted to lead us up the garden path, you see.

And the motive?

The missing treasure, of course. The murdered man was, by all accounts, a tight-fisted skinflint who didn't want to give up his share of the treasure to his partner. And he must have been the same way with his servant. Treasure is the key, Mr. Holmes. Mark my words.

I agree with you. But I gave you the name of the man I believe responsible.

Hmm. And you're sticking to that. Well, we shall see, Mr. Holmes. We shall see.

What brought you here, then?

I'm here to ask a favor. I'd like a missing steam launch located. It's the sort of job you people here at Scotland Yard do so well.

A steam launch? Don't tell me one of your clients mislaid his launch.

I won't. I believe it's connected with the Sholto killing.

How?

I think the criminals used it to effect their escape.

All that day, and the morning of the next, Holmes was dreadfully complaining about the fact that Scotland Yard had been unable to locate the Aurora.

The whole river's been searched on either side with no success.

It's too much. There's no word today. I'll be forced to believe they've scuttled the crowd.

But there aren't too many logical objections to that. I put an advertisement in the agony column of the Times, and if we hear nothing today, I'll have to take to the river myself.

Well, I shall accompany you.

No, no. No, you'd be much more useful if you stay here as my representative.

But, Holmes...

No need to argue. For it may not come to that. We may yet have news today.

But we heard nothing. And the following day, Holmes left before I was up. I lounged around the flat all day, hoping there was no flaw in my companion's reasoning. Under three o'clock, there was a knock on the door.

Good day, sir. Mr. Holmes is out, I understand.

Yes, yes, Inspector. I don't know when he'll be back. But if you'd care to wait, take a chair and try one of these cigars.

Thank you. I don't mind if I do. Your friend, Mr. Sherlock Holmes, is a wonderful man, sir. I had this wire from him this morning. Here's the message. Go to Baker Street at once. If I have not returned, wait for me. I'm close on the track. You can come with us tonight if you want to be in at the finish. What do you make of it?

Sounds helpful. Are you expecting someone?

Perhaps an answer to Holmes' advertisement. Excuse me. Yes, my man? What is it?

Well, now, sir, you must give an old cart like me time to catch his breath after these stairs.

Oh, yes. Is Mr. Sherlock Holmes here?

No, but come in, come in. I'm acting for him. You can give me the message.

Nay, nay. It was only to himself I was to tell it.

But I tell you, I'm his representative.

Who is it?

Who was it?

About the Aurora? Mordecai Smith's boat? I know where it is. And I knows where the men she's after are. And I knows where the treasure is. I knows all about it.

Well, then, tell me. I shall let him know.

It was to him I was to tell it.

I'm a police officer. You have important information and we shall keep you whether you like it or not until our friend returns.

Pretty sort of treatment, eh? I come here to see a gentleman and you two seize me and treat me in this fashion.

Oh, now, now, now. I promise you, you shan't lose a penny for your loss of time. Just sit over there on the sofa and you won't have to wait long.

All right. We'll see. We'll see.

Well, now, Inspector, where were we?

I was just about to say that I think Mr. Sherlock Holmes would have made a most promising police officer.

Oh, here. Your cigar's gone out. Allow me to relight it.

Well, I think that you might offer me a cigar, too.

Holmes! Holmes!

Where's the old man?

Here he is. Wig, whiskers, eyebrows, and all.

Good Lord. I hardly expected my disguise to stand a test like this.

Oh, you are a rare clerk. The case is all but solved. You may have all the official credit, but I insist on certain conditions. Agreed?

Entirely. If we're successful.

We shall be. First, I want your fastest fleet boat. A steam launch at the Westminster stairs at seven o'clock tonight.

Easily managed.

We shall need two staunch men in case of resistance.

We shall have them.

And when we capture the men, we'll get the treasure.

Here's our launch, Mr. Holmes, right on the dot.

Oh, have that green light taken off the side. We don't want to have it spotted as a police launch.

I see to it, men. Come aboard, gentlemen.

Where to, Mr. Holmes?

To the Tower. Stop opposite Jacobson's yard.

Oh, for heaven's sake, Holmes. Are you going to tell us how you've located her?

Deduction, Watson. Pure deduction. I knew that if Scotland Yard reported she hadn't put in at any wharf or slip along the river, she hadn't. Therefore, where would one hide a steam launch which didn't have enough coal to go very far?

Well, I might very well hand the launch over to some boat builder to make some slighting repair. She would then be removed to his yard and effectively concealed.

Well, that seems a very simple solution.

It's always the simple things which are overlooked. I drew fourteen blanks until I learned that the Aurora had been handed over to Jacobson's yard for a repair to her rudder. A needless one, I might add. And that she would be called for at eight o'clock sharp tonight.

But where are they going?

Either to Gravesend or the Downs to board some ship that will take them out of the country.

Well, you've worked it out all very neatly. But if the affair were in my hands, I'd have some policemen at Jacobson's and nab them when they came down.

Which would be never. This man's small as a shrewd article. Hmm. He'd undoubtedly send someone ahead to make sure that there was no one lurking around the yard.

Hmm. Well, now we wait, huh?

Exactly. And the minute we sight her, we go after her.

It's after eight, Holmes. And there's the Aurora. And going like the very devil.

Get after her. The launch with the yellow light.

By heaven, she's a flyer.

Huh. I think we're gaining.

Oh, I'm sure of it. Oh, we'll be up with her in a very few minutes. And Holmes, that is a savage on the deck.

You should have consulted the encyclopedia, my dear Watson, about the aborigines of the Andaman Islands who are reported to be the smallest race on Earth as well as the fiercest and most intractable.

We're near enough to hail them. Ahoy, Aurora!

Down, then! Aim low! Down to your right!

You hit him, Holmes! That little savage won't blow any more of his poison darts.

I thought we'd found all of them in the pouch.

All except the one he carried in his blowpipe.

They've turned. They're heading for shore. But they'll do it on the ground.

Stand clear. Swing about and mind her stern.

The Aurora had run aground on a mud bank. The wooden-legged man, mouthing curses, sprang ashore, but his stump sank in the mud. He was easily captured. The treasure chest was intact on the deck of the Aurora, and in a very short time, I brought it to Mary Morstan.

The chest wasn't heavy, but my heart was.

You weren't hurt?

Oh, Dr. Watson, I'm glad to see you're all right.

Oh, I came through with flying colors. And here's your treasure.

Well, aren't you going to open it?

It's strange, but the treasure seems to mean more to you than it does to me.

Well, I'd rather say that it means a lot to both of us.

You need some help with the lid there.

Thank you.

Why, it's empty. It can't be. It's impossible.

Would you see who that is, please?

Oh, yes. Yes, certainly.

Oh, how do you know... Oh, do you know that the treasure is gone?

Yes.

Well, do you know where it is?

At the bottom of the Thames. He threw small stones through the gems, piece by piece, during the chase.

Oh, dear. Wouldn't it have been simpler for him just to chuck the chest overboard?

Well, that was a compliment to me. He told us that any man smart enough to track him would be smart enough to fish up a whole chest from the bottom of the river.

Well, that means that Mary will never get...

Well, I think she'll get something she treasures a lot more, Watson. If you'll ask her to be your wife.

Oh, Doyle married Watson off to Mary Morstan and they lived happily ever after. But Doyle didn't. He found that having Watson a married man interfered with his being able to accompany Holmes on his cases. He regretted ever having created the character. But, being a true English gentleman, he never killed Mary off. But was forever sending her on vacations to allow Watson to move back with Holmes.

I'll be back shortly.

Here in my hand is a little capsule. It's Contac. It contains enough cold medicine to help relieve cold symptoms caused by every known virus. Think about that the next time you're sick. Sneezing, dripping, all clogged up. Then, let us help you with real medicine like Contac. We're number one in the whole world. Give your cold to Contac. Real medicine for real colds. Take only as directed.

I guess I'm lucky. My family's always been healthy. Oh, a touch of constipation now and then. But, we've got Ex-Lax for that. When you need a laxative, shouldn't your first choice be the one more families buy than any other? That's Ex-Lax. Families like the chocolatey taste. You'll like the way Ex-Lax works gently overnight for relief in the morning. Next time, make gentle chocolatey Ex-Lax your first choice for occasional use only as directed. We've always been healthy and Ex-Lax is part of that.

One of the most intriguing elements of the world of the Sherlock Holmes stories was the fabulously provocative titles of cases that Holmes had worked on but which Watson never chronicled. Years later, Doyle's son and John Dickson Carr collaborated on writing some to fit the titles. But the most tantalizing title of all has never been attempted. That title is The Adventure of Ricoletti of the Club Foot and His Abominable Wife.

Now, there's a title that conjures up all sorts of deviltry. Maybe one of our mystery theater writers will come up with a story to fit it.

Our cast included Kevin McCarthy, Court Benson, Jackson Beck, Earl Hammond, and Joan Shea. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown. Radio Mystery Theater was sponsored in part by Buick Motor Division.

This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our mystery theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time. Pleasant dreams.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑