Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

The Way to Dusty Death

Episode 708September 13, 197743 min 56 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 27 min to read

The CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents... Welcome, I'm E.G. Marshall. In those primitive societies where a strong central government has not yet taken shape, or in those where it has decayed, justice, as we know it, is not always easily enforced. When that occurs, people begin taking the law into their own hands, as happened in our country, in many places, when the United States was a little younger. However, the frontiers of U.S. history were often characterized by private justice and the blood feud, based on simple vengeance.

This land belongs to me. You come on it only if I want you here. That corpse can just lay there and rot. But, Pa, you can't do that. Who says I can't? It can lay there and be dinner for the vultures. But if anyone is foolish enough to dare lay a finger on that dead body, for any reason, they'll pay. In blood, do I make myself clear?

Our mystery drama, The Way to Dusty Death, was adapted from Sophocles' great Greek tragedy, Antigone. It was especially adapted for the Mystery Theater by Stella and Arnold Moss. It stars Arnold Moss and Marian Seldes. It is sponsored in part by Buick Motor Division and Sinoff, the sinus medicine. I'll be back shortly with Act One.

The Civil War. The war between the... ...and the state has been over for more than ten years. But in the mountainous terrain of Thebes County along the rugged Kentucky-West Virginia border, there is still no peace. For years, two families, the Carpenters and the Webbs, have been taking the law into their own hands in a deadly feud that has robbed each side of its share of sons.

It is a warm summer night. Paul Carpenter and his younger sister, Isabel, are stealthily making their way across the fast-running mountain brook that separates their land from that land.

Tell you, Paul, the cold is on the other side.

I know it. And Amanda knows it. You two girls have got a feeling in your bones, is that it?

You don't believe us?

Of course I do, Isabel. Else, why would I be wandering over to the land that belongs to the Webb family in the dark of night, hoping to find a little colt of ours that's been a-missing since last Thursday? I believe you. I believe our sister, too. Ain't often that Amanda's wrong. And what's more, I'm sure I know just how it got there.

You mean, the little colt somehow crossed the mountain brook all by itself? And after it crossed, somebody kept it. I don't put it past them. What's stealing to a pack of murderers? If Captain Webb could put a rifle bullet through our father's head with no good cause... He's just in hate for all us Carpenters.

Quiet. We're almost on the other side. Almost on their land. Come on. Keep your voice down.

We alone.

Here we are. On enemy territory. Will Amanda will be pleased by what we've done?

Just watch your step. The stable, where the colt would be, is over toward that way. Stay close behind me.

I'm following you, Paul. This is what Papa would have done if he was still alive.

I reckon so. Over there. There's the boss. Lucky we got a moon.

Oh, we'll get that colt in no time at all. And then we'll make a run for it. Over the brook and home. I can just see Captain Crane Webb's red old face when he looks into the stable in the morning and finds... Isabel! Are we going to get... Go, Isabel, you go quick, run.

No, no, I can't. Or they'll get you too. Get over this way, Harmon. Follow me. Right with you, Pa.

Please go, Isabel. Don't you worry, Pa. Amanda and I...

Who is it, Pa? Who is it?

I got one of them anyway. The skill I was known for in the war. Wait a minute, Pa. Look who it is.

Yeah, I know who it is, Harmon. It's the carpenter boy.

Yeah, I know. You killed him, Pa.

He was trespassing on my land. I was hoping that one of these days... I was hoping...

What do you think you're up to, Harmon?

Well, you ain't gonna let his body lay here on the ground, are you?

The carpenter fell here on my property. He's dead. He's gonna stay where he fell. Now, you put that... Put that body down.

But, Pa...

I don't want to say it twice, boy.

Better? You started to say that you was, uh... Hoping something. I thought maybe all this bad blood between our two families might someday soon be coming to an end.

Why is that?

I've got reasons. Now I'm afraid that things are gonna take a turn for the worse. Let's get back into the house before your ma begins to worry.

Things are gonna start happening all over again.

Well, then you just let him start, son. Mm-hmm. Because whatever the carpenters begin, you can be sure we Webbs will finish.

No, we're the best. Was Harmon with the captain when the shot was fired?

But you ain't sure.

I ran away so far. Harmon was with him. But I think I heard his voice.

You've got to pull yourself together, girl. What's wrong with you, Amanda? You got no feelings? You're acting just as hard as stone.

Listen. Now, listen. We cannot bring him back. But that Harmon and me, that we'd be the thing that would bring our two families together. Once and for all.

What? What? What? What? What? What? I don't know the hatred that's been poisoning both our sides since before we was ever born.

You do love each other. Harmon and you?

Well, no one knows that. And you and me and Harmon. Now, not only is that not to be, but the carpenters and the Webbs will go on spilling each other's blood till there ain't no more to spill.

Ain't we already got there, Amanda? With Paul's death?

No. Not quite. In this house of ours, there's still two of us. Two girls. Two almost helpless girls.

Helpless, is it? I can shoot a rifle as well as any man in this county. You know that. And I'm now head of this family. The honor of this family rests in my hands. We got lots of men who are kinfolk. Men who'd stop at nothing to get back at the Webbs for our brother Paul's death.

This is one matter I want to handle by myself. With your help.

You think you can?

I'm sure I can. Now, right now, our job is plain. At sunup. As soon as it gets light. We gotta carry back our dead brother's body. So that we can give him a respectful burial. Now we'd better get some rest.

Oh, Amanda. Couldn't possibly carry Paul's body? There's the two of us.

Well, I think I know where maybe we'd get some help.

Where?

Never you mind. But I don't.

Then we'll do it by ourselves, Isabel. The best we can. The last night I...

Keep walking straight ahead toward their front door, Isabel. And hold your head up high.

Back there.

Well, supposing Captain Crane had it in his head to take a shot at us. The way he did at Paul last night. In the broad daylight. Right out in the open.

Amanda. I know what I'm doing. He has to listen to me.

Don't take another step. Neither one of you.

You can put down your rifle, Captain. We mean no harm.

What do you two want?

I think you know. We want our brother's body. Let us take it.

Well?

We're here to get Paul's body. To take him off your land and give him a decent burial.

And where would that be?

Where he belongs. Six feet under carpenter's soil, is that it?

Yes, Captain. You are out of your mind.

What is that supposed to mean?

Just turn around, the two of you. Take yourself straight back to where you come from.

But, Crane...

We are not about to do that. We want our brother's body. And we are here to get it. With your permission or without it.

Your brother had no respect for private property. He'd come onto my land, Webb land, uninvited. So he can stay there.

But he's got to be buried. Can't just let him lay there.

Why must he be buried? And who's going to make that happen? You two girls? Or your kinfolk up near Sandy River? You think maybe they'll try to snatch a dead body off of my land?

Times are changing, Captain. There is such a thing as the law. And law is beginning to come here to the mountains. Through the... The great power of old Judge Calvin, I suppose.

Judge Calvin, yes. And others.

On my land, there is only one law. And that's the law of Crane Webb. It's always been that way, and no one... No one is going to change it.

If nothing else, I think common decency would make...

Decency? A carpenter talking of decency? The only decency I know is in the speed of my trigger finger. For over 50 years, it's been you kill... Or you get killed. Webb or carpenter. You're getting pretty close to the end of the line, girl. Smart about face.

Where you been, Harmon?

Inside the door. I've been hearing everything that's been said.

Here. Take my rifle, son. Get these two carpenters off of our land. Real quick.

I'm not sure I can do that, Pa.

Why not?

Let the girls give their brother a proper Christian burial. And put an end to all the bad blood that's rankled our two families all these years. Why not? It's no more than you would ask if it was me, Lay.

I'll tell you why not. And you two girls had better listen, too. I mean for that body out there to be a warning to everyone that this land belongs to... You come on it only if I want you there. That corpse can just lay there and rot. It can lay there and be dinner for the vultures. And if anyone, you hear that, anyone is foolish enough to dare lay a finger on that body. For any reason, they'll pay for it in blood. I make myself... Clear.

The Greeks had a word for it. They called it hubris, meaning excessive pride, insolent, overbearing arrogance. The one sin of man the ancient gods would not tolerate. And Captain Crane Webb is such a man. A man weighted down with pride, false pride, with hubris. How will the fates deal with his stiff-necked unwillingness to bend? Join me shortly.

We're back in the 1870s. Thebes County, somewhere along the mountainous border between... Kentucky and West Virginia, where family feuding is a way of life. Crane Webb, a man who considers himself a law unto himself, has shot and killed Paul Carpenter for trespassing on his land and refuses to let the body be taken off his property or to be buried. Confronted by the two young sisters of the dead man and by his own son, Crane says...

Now, Harmon, who sees to it that these two carpenter girls get back on their own side of the brook? Is it you or I?

We don't need any company, Captain Crane. We can find our own way back.

I ain't asking you. They're girls, Pa. Ain't the same as if they were men.

A carpenter's a carpenter, son. I'll see them back myself.

No, give me your gun, Pa. I'll do it.

On your way, Harmon. And keep them covered. I don't trust no carpenter. They're women no more than they're men. Get moving, both of you.

We're going.

Will you, Captain Crane?

You better hush up, Isabel.

Well, keep on moving.

Fair. Who can leave with that gun?

I'll be waiting for you, son.

Put down your gun, Harmon. What has got into you?

You just keep walking, Amanda. I'm keeping you covered till you're in your own meadow.

Real scared of your Pa, ain't you? He shakes a finger at you, you jump like a puppy through a hoop.

I'd appreciate you walking a little faster.

You hear what I hear, Amanda?

I know that sound. It's our little colt. We mean to get our colt, Harmon.

I'm not discussing colts. You keep... Keep going. Across the brook and on to your own place.

Please, Amanda. I know what I'm doing. Just wait till we're out of my father's sight. Trust me. Please.

But Juniper belongs to us.

Never mind Juniper for the time being.

Harmon, what are we going to do?

I'm not sure. We're counting on you.

I know you are. Because if for any reason we can't, we're far from helpless, Isabel and I.

I know that, too.

No, no, no. No, don't come over to our side. Stay where you are. I'm sure he's still watching. Why don't you just turn around and walk slowly back to your own place?

I have to talk to you.

This is not the time.

But tonight, after dark.

You're sure he doesn't know where you are?

I just said I was going out for a breath of air. Now, Harmon, just listen to me. Your father has lived all these years making his own laws. Fitting your life, your mother's, everybody's, to however it pleased him.

Yeah, we all know he's not an easy man. But whether he goes along with it or not, that's all about to end. There is such a thing as the law.

There is such a thing as right and wrong.

What are you getting at, Amanda? The law goes for everybody, including your father. And he has to know that no one, not even he, is above it. And that means the law of Thebes County.

You're not thinking of bringing old Judge Calvin into this, are you?

Why not?

Captain wouldn't pay him no mind, you know that. He'd just laugh at the old judge.

Well, that remains to be seen.

Amen. Amen. Amen. Amen. Just go on back home. Fast. Whatever you do, don't forget, my father is a very dangerous man.

I can't tell you how sorry I was to hear about Paul.

Thank you, Judge Calvin.

Cold lemonade?

Oh, no, thank you. Long walk from the carpenter place all the way here to town.

No, I'm fine. What exactly was on your mind? How can an old servant of the people be of help?

Judge Calvin, my father used to say that no man in the whole county, whether they agreed with you or not, could look at things as fair as you.

That's a real compliment. And that everyone had respect for your honesty, for your good judgment. What are you leading up to, Amanda?

I need your help with the law.

What for? To do what?

To get Paul's body back from Crane Webb land, so that Isabella and I can see he gets a decent burial.

As I understand it, uh, Paul was trespassing on Webb property.

But trespassing or not, the fact is, Paul is dead. How he was killed and what led up to his death is not the question. What is important is, he can't be left lying out there in the hot sun, unburied, with a bird waiting to pick out his eye.

Well, what is it you'd like me to do?

I want my brother's body. I want you to give me the legal right to go in there and take it. Right away. Uh, a paper of some kind. With your signature on it that says that I can do it.

I've known Crane Webb since he was a boy. Uh, 50 years, more. He never learned respect for anything that he considered weak. And to him, I'm weak.

Because I'm a girl, is that it?

He'll never change.

Well, then where does the law come in?

Well, that's hard to say. Especially here in the mountains. I could serve a piece of legal paper on Captain. He'd just, just tear it up. And then, what would I do? Force him to let us take possession of our brother's body. Force Crane Webb to do anything? I know him much too well for that, Amanda. The bitter truth is that any judge, any keeper of the peace, who dares to raise a gavel against a man like Crane, may do it at the risk of his own life.

He's afraid of me, my girl, but I cherish him.

You're afraid of him. Is that it?

Well, I know that. History of this county. Your father, now your brother, had proof of it. And you won't lift a finger to change that, will you? A man who's supposed to deal out justice, who claims to have been my father's friend. Judge Calvin, you make me want to be sick. You're a tired, scared old man.

No, no, no. Just a minute, Amanda.

I just don't want to waste any more time with you. Now, don't make trouble, girl. There's been enough. My sister and I will find a way to do what we think is right.

And if those were the words I heard your father speak, it cost him his life.

It won't cost me mine. I'll do what has to be done with or without the help of what you call the law.

Oh, don't bother. I know where the door is.

I'll try. I'll try to make him change his mind. But, Harmon, you know your pa.

He's willing to hire him. It don't make sense, though, Ma.

Well, that's up to him, Harmon. To him, that's all that counts. Now, I beg you to stay away from Paul's dead body. Don't you so much as talk.

There's something this time I told you, Ma.

Hmm? What's that?

Paul Carpenter was my good friend. I'm glad the captain never knew. And that's not all. Amanda and I, we love each other. We've been hoping to get married.

Married? To a carpenter? You're out of your mind. Your pa would kill you first.

If I don't help her move Paul's body onto their own land, she'll never speak to me again. Never.

How could you dare disobey your father?

How could I dare think of not helping the girl I love?

Your father says there's no greater wrong than betraying your own flesh and blood. Harmon, my son, don't let your feeling for this girl turn you against your own kin. I beg you.

What would you have me do?

Try to do what you're told. Even if it means choking this carpenter girl out of your heart. You've got to try to do just that.

I don't want to hurt no one. Not you, not Pa, and not Amanda.

It's your choice. Whatever you decide.

I couldn't bear it.

Come on now, Paul. I have no idea. I'm not waiting for him. Or for old Judge Calvin, either. Or anyone. There's one thing we can do, just the two of us.

What's that?

We could dig a shallow grave. Right here. And then we'll throw some earth over Paul's dead body.

Oh, Amanda. No, that way we'll be trying to give him something like a decent burial. Come on, hand me the shovel.

Sit down, little eye. You can go home if you want to, Isabel. I can handle this alone.

Amanda, darling. Isabel.

Oh, Harmon, we thought you weren't coming.

What are you two doing?

We're burying him.

Here? Why not?

Well, if my pa catches you.

We have a right to take care of our brother. Once we've given him a shallow burial, a token, we'll have done part of our duty to him.

Give me the shovel.

Thank you, Harmon. What do we do after that?

What?

We'll cross that next bridge when we come to it.

A little deeper, Harmon.

All right, then. No, that'll be fine. Let me try to move him over here. All right, now. If I can remember the words. I'll sprinkle a handful of earth over him. I say, in certain hope of the resurrection. Amen. Amen. And may he rest in peace.

It's my Paul. What about that man, Isabel?

I don't know of either of you.

No. No. You two go. I'll take care of my father the best I can.

Oh, be careful, Harmon. Go. Just go.

I love you, Harmon.

And I love you. Now, run.

Is that you, Harmon?

Who else should it be?

What are you doing out here this time of night?

Well, it's too hot to sleep. What are you trying to hide? What do you got there behind your back?

Nothing.

What is it?

Just a shovel.

I have it, Harmon. Oh, you might as well know now, Pa. Paul's body has been buried.

By who?

The girls. Ritual of burying's been done. The earth is scattered on Paul's flesh. A prayer's been said.

My son? You had a hand in this?

Yes, I did.

You hit me.

What shame. The name of Webb.

I did what any decent human would.

You just scrape off the earth that sits on that dead body. It stays unburied.

I can't do that, Pa.

You'll do what you are told.

I can't. I just can't.

What's that supposed to mean?

It means I can't. It means I won't.

Thinks of himself as a man with a will of steel. Cannot, must not be denied. But, as the poet John Milton wrote, what is strength without a double share of wisdom? Vast, unwieldy, burdensome, proudly secure, yet liable to fall by weakest subtlety. Captain Webb continues to stand up against the resistance he is meeting from all sides. Even from his own son. I shall return shortly.

A vendetta, we are told, is the right or obligation a person assumes to be his. In retaliation for a wrong, often a murder, he thinks has been done to a member of his family or group. Vendettas go back to the most primitive times and even find their place in great literature. In Hamlet, for example, where the young prince seeks vengeance for his father's murder. In our story, it's the feud between the Webbs and the Carpenters. Captain Crane Webb speaks to his son, Harmon, who he thinks has betrayed him.

Harmon, you brought the name of Webb.

I only did what any decent human—

You scrape off the earth that sits on that dead body.

I can't do that, Pa.

You'll do what you are told.

I can't, Pa. And I won't. I won't.

I thought you were too, maybe too old. Don't try it again, Pa. I warn you.

Let me tell you something, boy. A man prays he may beget a household full of dutiful men. His sons share with him the punishing of enemies, the honoring of his father's friends.

I won't listen to this.

Oh, yes, you will, boy. He's a young one that won't stand by him. He's done nothing but sow trouble for himself. Laugh at him. When I was your age... Oh, not again, Pa, please. I had respect for my Pa.

Maybe he earned it.

Harmon, maybe you just better go into the house and help Roseanne thread the needles up that shelf.

Pick it up yourself, Pa. I'm going to bed.

So young. I will disobey. For it is what ruins a country, tears down a home.

This is your own son, Crane.

All the more reason. Another thing. I will not let myself be beaten by a girl. To be threatened, let it be by a man, not by some girl. But stick with hate.

I will not listen to this.

You don't really know why you hate. And if you're hating, it'll destroy all of us in the end.

You should be sharing that hatred with me.

I cannot share in hatred. Good night, Roseanne.

One last thing. Harmon's my only son.

Your only son. And there are more carpenters than just them two girls. If anything happens to those girls, it'll be the end of Harmon, too.

Nothing will happen to Harmon.

I've done all I can, Amanda. My father's like a rock that no amount of prying can move out of the earth.

And if the rock goes on, refuses to be moved?

Well, then you and I'll have to find our way around it.

Well, we can't depend on old Judge Calvin. My threat to him was just a waste of time.

Maybe if I would go and talk to him...

No, Harmon. I don't want you getting in any deeper than this. When you really are ready. There's just no telling what your father might do.

I wouldn't care.

Well, I do. For your sake. And for ours.

You're a man.

No, Harmon. Don't. Right at this moment, I don't feel at home either with you, the living, or with Paul. The dead. Forgive me, Harmon. I need to be alone. There's things I gotta figure out where no one can help me.

We offer you something to drink, Judge Calvin.

No, no, thank you, Crane. Apologize for dropping in on you after dark.

Perfect. And turn up the lamp a bit. Leave the Judge and me together.

Yes, Crane.

For the honor of your Calvin.

Next door neighbor, Amanda Carpenter. I have here...

What, if I might ask?

I don't want you to take offense, Crane. It's, uh, the removal of her brother Paul's dead body off your property. So he can receive a proper burial.

That's it? Just about.

Put it over on the table there, won't you, Judge? Glad to.

Expect this order, I hope. It's a law.

And if I don't?

It'd be easier for all of us if you did, Crane.

Well, I'll look it over. Maybe tomorrow morning. At the time, I'm a very busy man, too, you know.

It's a law, Captain.

So you said. You know something, Judge?

On second thought, I will take that piece of paper.

You're a reasonable man, Crane. I knew I could count on you.

What are you doing?

Now, I would appreciate your getting out of my house just as fast as your old legs will carry you.

You can't defy the law forever.

I can't? Who says I can't?

Goodnight, Crane.

Wait one minute. Someone's sneaking around down there, near the stable. What are you doing with that rifle? Is someone there?

Let me get by.

Are you out of your mind? Don't you worry. I'll take care of everything.

Crane, put down that rifle. I'll take care of them good, once and for all. I know. Judge Calvin's up there talking with him and with my ma. We got to be quiet, quick.

Oh, you're wonderful, Harmon, to be doing this.

Don't let's talk. I'll just try to hoist Paul's body over my shoulder and carry him to the stream. In no time at all, he'll be back where you want him.

He is heavy. Can I do anything?

When I grab him here, you get your hands under his head. That'll help.

Oh, Harmon, I love you so.

And I love you.

What was that?

My poor darling. Harmon.

That's the last shot he'll ever fire on this earth.

What are you doing?

Paying back my father. This time, he's more than asked for it.

Put down your gun, Harmon. It'll do no good.

We'll see. I want you to die, Paul. I want you dead.

Can't say they did. I didn't get fair warning.

Crane, you'll hang for this.

Maybe. Maybe not. They're shooting back at you. Not bad aim, either. That one nearly got me. I'm going to have to stop this foolishness.

Like? You like what you're doing?

I think I do.

Those are them Carpenter girls, both of them. Judge Calvin, Roseanne, come on down with me and take a prize. I'll go a little ahead.

I hope you know what you're doing.

You are about to see, Judge Calvin, what I call justice.

I'm afraid so. Watch out for that big rock there, Judge.

Roseanne.

It's a Carpenter girl. Amanda. Dead, Crane, by your hand. And Harmon, your son, Harmon, he's dead, too. And he's holding her in his arms. You killed your own son. Murderer.

Sovereign. No idea. You never thought. Not once. You never had a decent thought in your head.

Why were they here? Why were they here?

They're here together. His arms around her.

There's something else you didn't know. They loved each other. They were going to get married. It was their hope that all these years of feuding might be ended by their marriage.

You must try to control yourself, Roseanne.

You can be real proud of yourself, Crane. The great Captain Webb, maker of corpses.

What?

I ask you to forgive me if you can. I'm a killer. I look on the son I killed. I look on his bride that she'll never be. And by my hand.

Why don't you both go back into the house? I'll ride my horse to town and see that what must be done will be done. I just can't stay here.

My son. My son. Let me take my son up in my arms.

He's again. Never, never. Up there. Down and strong. Me never. Seed tomorrow's sunrise.

We better see where Roseanne has gone to. She shouldn't be alone.

Isabel. It's lost. It depends on wisdom all the way. The gods must have their due. Great words by men of pride bring greater blows upon them. So, wisdom comes. With those words, Sophocles ends his tragedy of Antigone. I'll be back shortly.

The Antigone of Sophocles has been updated many times, in many places, since its premiere nearly 2400 years ago in ancient Athens. A contemporary French playwright, for example, presents Antigone as a doomed young woman without hope. And Creon, her antagonist, as a wily political figure. Both of them very French. You've accepted Amanda Carpenter, Antigone, and Captain Crane Webb as suitable American counterparts. Our cast included Arnold Moss, Marian Seldes, E.V. Juster, Don Scardino, and the rest of the cast included Arnold Moss, Marian Seldes, E.V. Juster, Don Scardino, and Gilbert Mack. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown.

Now, a few of our next... That's simple. You grow a beard, we dye it dark for you. Also, your hair. Colored contact lenses to make your eyes brown. You and Carol book a 30-day in advance one-week excursion cruise. You get into Rogaria, we make the contact for you, you turn over your passport, and who James Otescu uses them as his...

How come Carol, too?

She has a wife. Who looks like Carol? You know, chance we gotta take.

How about our chances? How do we get out?

No problem. Famous last word.

No, no, no. What if you shave off your beard, wash out the dye, take out the contact lenses, and come back on a passport of your own that we issue, complete with entry visa? And what if something goes wrong? The chances we take, that's our business.

E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our Mystery Theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant dreams.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑