The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 23 min to read
CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents, Come In, Welcome, I'm E.G. Marshall, your host for another excursion into the world of the macabre, where we meet persons not quite like you or me, because they have had experiences that often defy explanation.
Oh, no, no, no, certainly not. Now, you've aroused my interest. But you'll have to give me a little time.
No, of course. I'd appreciate it very much. Brandt is a distant relative of Mrs. Smalls, by the way.
Oh, is that so? And now the old portrait has a name. Once it had a life. Who was she? Why did she die? How did she die? And what's the meaning of the unique design?
Come in.
Come in, Ginny. Don't lurk there as if you're looking at a corpse.
You'll be one soon enough if you don't stop wandering, Uncle.
No, Humbug. It's my thoughts that keep me alive. Except for her nightly visits. I'd be glad to be dead.
Nonsense.
That's what's the use of talking. There is none.
No, my girl. What about that medal? I'm taking it to a jeweler on Monday.
You've had it a week, my dear.
But you insisted that I take it to a designer, not just any jeweler.
That's right. Have you found one?
What about old... Williams? He's still in business?
Dead, ten years. I found a man highly recommended, named Maiden.
I don't remember his first...
If that don't beat the Dutch. I just... Tim. You sound like you're wondering, my girl.
It's St. Luke's. I wonder if he's the same man.
Well, if he attends St. Luke's, he must be an antique.
No, no, he's quite a young man. He was taking pictures and admiring the church. Higby showed him around.
Yes, well, I do wish you'd see him soon. Ginny, that missing pearl may be hard to duplicate.
I understand.
Is there anything special on your mind, Ginny? It has a look of purpose on your face. Is it the usual?
You worry me, Uncle.
Oh, Humbug, I'm fit. I feel fine. Get around when I want to.
You still insist that she is with you every night?
She has been for almost 70 years. I see her every night. Yes, and then I'm happy. We talk about what happened and how I avenged her.
No one believes your story, Uncle. The facts bear me out. They're all mixed up, crazy. They make no sense.
They make perfect sense. My testimony got him acquitted. And then, with the help of God, I willed his death, and he died.
Uncle, you mustn't.
You think I'm deaf? Am I, girl? On this subject, what else can I think? Willed his death. What? That sacrilegious uncle. I'll account to God alone when I join Melanie, and that will be very, very soon.
The name was Melanie Brent. And she died when she was only 25?
Yes. Why or how, I don't know, but Higby will find out from the church register. I'll drive out next weekend to see him.
Stay here, Paul. You're welcome, and I'll go with you to see Higby.
Oh, thanks. Did he have any idea of what the coat of arms means? That... diamond-shaped thing?
No, not offhand, but I've been giving that some thought. First, it's unique. Two reasons. The design itself is one of a kind. At least, I've never seen one like it. And isn't it unusual for a woman to have a coat of arms?
That's the other reason. I've never heard of one.
Well, what could it mean? Three small birds and one branch in its beak. At the end of which, there's a pearl.
You know what I think it all means? Faith, hope, and charity.
Could be, Paul. In the Book of Common Prayer, regarded as an outward and visible sign of inward and spiritual grace. Someone had absolute faith in Melanie Brent. Some man, of course. Who might still be alive.
Oh, no. Let me see. She died in 1911. Sixty-six years ago. I had 25. Assuming it's a young man we're talking about. And he'd be 91 or older. There's no one around here.
Wait a minute. Who are you thinking of, Kirby?
Old Andrew Scott.
An interest in unusual design. A portrait of a beautiful young woman in a green silk dress. Her haunting expression clues to a life long-ended and forgotten. She is part of a family's heritage. Their roots. You had them. So do I. You can be certain that they both are good and bad.
What is the mystery that surrounds Melanie Brent? Search deeper when I return with Act Two.
I was curious about Melanie Brent's portrait as leading him to the story of the young woman who died 60 years ago. When she was only 25. Well, it's a weekday now. Paul is in his jewelry store. An elderly woman approaches him.
May I help you, madam?
Miss, I miss Jennifer Morris.
Well, my goodness, of course. Miss Morrison, I was introduced to you. At St. Luke's by Reverend Higbee.
Oh, I'm glad to see you again. You know, when we met, I thought I knew that name Maiden and now I know why. I've been trying to decide on a jewelry designer and I settled on you.
Oh, thank you. My great-uncle has an old goldmine. A gold medal. A small pearl is missing from it and he wants to have it replaced. Let me show it to you. Here, dear.
For heaven's sake.
You seem startled.
Well, I am, Miss Morrison. I know the design.
You've seen it before. Twice. The diamond shape with the three birds enclosed in it.
So that's where the missing pearl belongs. On the end of the branch being held by the topmost of the three birds.
And it's on the portrait on the wall tablet in your church.
It is. It's the coat of arms or an emblazonment of a woman named Melanie Brent.
There's a portrait?
Yes. Mr. Small found it in his attic and now it hangs in his living room. I've been trying to trace her genealogy.
May I ask why?
Well, curiosity more than anything else. Because it's a haunting portrait. The young woman is very beautiful and she died when she was only 25. Perhaps you know the story.
It's better forgotten, Mr. Maiden.
Oh?
I don't mean to pry.
She is long dead and so is the scandal.
I see.
He said there was a portrait but we didn't believe him.
He? Your great uncle?
It's his design, that diamond shaped thing.
Would you object if I visited him, Miss Morrison?
Not if you'll be discreet. He's old and infirm. A shock could very well...
I understand. You could repair his medal and return it to him. Who was Melanie Brent, Miss Morrison?
I'd rather not say. She must have meant something to your great uncle. He's still... obsessed with her.
Mr. Maiden and Mr. Small. Good afternoon, sir.
Hello, Mr. Higby. Thank you for seeing me again.
No, not at all, not at all. But I can't help you very much.
No entry in the church register about Melanie Brent?
I have it here. You may see for yourself.
Oh. Melanie Brent. Born April 27th, 1886. Baptized July 15th. Died September 9th, 1911. Her parents, the Godparents, the page torn out. Who did that?
I, uh, I have no idea. It is most unusual. What would have been written there?
Oh, what she did for the church, her confirmation, probably her marriage, if she married. But a few lines about her death and her burial. And half the page is torn out.
Morrison said there was a scandal and that it had best be forgotten.
Let me show you something. Diamond escutcheon. Beautiful medal. It belongs to Andrew Scott. That diamond-shaped design is on the portrait of Melanie Brent. It's carved on that wall tablet and it's on this medal. Andrew Scott and Melanie Brent. No question about it. Miss Morrison said that he was obsessed with Melanie Brent.
Mr. Higby, may I see the register entry under Andrew Scott?
Yes, why yes. It would be in this register. Let me look. Uh, how did you get the medal, Paul?
She brought it in for repair. The pearl at the end of the branch was missing.
Oh, yes, yes, here it is. Andrew Scott, born 1882 and so on. Well, that's the usual. Read it. Engaged to wed Miss Melanie Brent, but service never performed because of her sudden and tragic death. May God have mercy on her soul.
What happened to them? What happened to Melanie Brent and to Andrew Scott? She dies suddenly just before she's to be married. His memories about her are blasphemous? Did he kill her?
I noticed you speaking to Mr. Maiden. It's so nice to see him at service again. Did you find time to see my great-uncle Reverend?
I, uh, tried, but he was indisposed.
I have expected that.
Because of his obsession?
Well, perhaps he realized it's better kept to himself.
And with you?
It's nothing I want to talk about, Reverend. But you're burdened with it, Jenny. I'm a minister of God.
Share it with me and you will be comforted.
I, I just can't. It's too incredible. Melanie Brent received a Christian burial and Andrew Scott has always been a true church member.
Yes, I know that. There's a scandal about them. Was your, was your great-uncle...
No. It was the other way around.
Well, I, I don't understand. Andrew Scott is still alive. And pray for death so that, so that he may join her forever.
Sit down, Mr. Maiden.
Thank you, sir.
Old-fashioned.
Pardon me?
Sir, it's old-fashioned. It's gone out of style. Used to be a sign of respect for one's elders, but these are different times.
I, uh, I have your medal, Mr. Scott.
So, oh, Jenny finally did something about it. That's good. Well, here it is. The design is unique.
Yes. Yes, it is. I struck it myself.
And the birds, they mean hope and charity?
Well, how did you figure that out, young man?
Because of its association with someone in the past.
Well, this is good work, Mr. Maiden.
Oh, thank you. Ah, the shade of the pearl is correct. Was that luck?
No, sir. Seen the pearl before.
Oh. Well, then you're, you're not a member of St. Luke's Church, are you?
No, but I've attended Vespers there a couple of times with Kirby Small. He used to be a member.
Oh, you noticed the heraldic symbol carved on the wall tablet, eh? That was the second place I'd seen it. Kirby Small has a portrait of Melanie Brent, which now hangs in his living room.
Ah, yes, yes, yes. I, I knew it existed. Jenny's never believed me. Of course, she considers me a little addled, and, well, she may. She doesn't. She doesn't believe that I'm with her every night. Melanie Brent?
Yes, my boy. Does that seem fantastic to you?
Depends on what you mean. Appears to you?
Oh, yes, yes, in green silk dress.
That's what she wears in the portrait, Mr. Scott.
I know. You say it's in Small's house?
It was in his attic.
Jenny tries to persuade me to live in the present, but there is no present for me. My life ended in... 1911.
But you had a very successful career.
Well, work was all that I had left.
Are you aware that half the page in the church register about Miss Brent has been cut out?
No, no, but I'll, I'll take your word for it. Was it because of what Miss Morrison said was a scandal?
It was worse than that, Mr. Maiden.
May I ask?
Oh, no, it's none of my business. I'm, I'm curious about Melanie Brent, but I won't intrude on your memories.
Why, why are you curious, Mr. Maiden?
Because, and you'll forgive me, I... Well, if I'd ever married, I'd been to someone so lovely. Sentimental, but it's true. I'm sorry you lost her.
I didn't lose her, Mr. Maiden. She was murdered.
So, Uncle Andrew?
Oh, my dear girl. Well, I am pleased to see you. What's that, Mr. Maiden?
I saw leaving the house.
Yes, yes, I like him. He's gone to Small's house to bring me the portraits.
You, uh, tell him the story?
Only that she was married.
Only that she was married. Only that she was married. Only that she was married. Only that she was married. Only that she was married. Leave it at that.
Yes, yes, he'll want to know why. You don't know why or how, Uncle. The why is simple enough. Rob Claridge wanted her as much as I did. And she chose me. So he kidnapped her and later killed her. The how is also simple. Claridge was a young doctor. One of his surgical instruments had been driven through her heart. Damn it. But she had had her revenge. And I had mine. And that's why I'm here. That's what was miraculous. Dr. Claridge couldn't be in church and outside on the green near the pond at the same time.
He was, though. At his trial, you testified that he was sitting right in front of you during the service.
Yes, he was. I hated Claridge. I knew he'd kidnapped Melanie and had her hidden someplace. I saw her the night before she disappeared. She was wearing her green silk dress. That's the last I saw of her. The police must have been drunk.
No, no, no, no. That is not true. There were two of them. And they found Melanie's body in the rushes in the pond. And they found Dr. Claridge painted on the green not 20 feet away.
But he was sitting right in front of you in church.
So he was.
Your story is impossible.
So it seemed. But during the service, I kept saying to myself, Confess. Confess. And the force of my thought and the will of God transferred his soul outside where the constables found him. Not here. His apparition, if anything. What they saw, they told in court. And they saw Claridge. But he was freed because you admitted he sat in front of you in church.
That's true. But my words, confess, confess, drove into his soul. And soon after, he took his own life. I willed it, Jenny.
And you don't see how incredible this is.
Well, it may seem that way to you.
It seems that way to anyone with common sense. I pray. I prayed for Claridge's death. That sinful. I prayed for revenge, and it was granted. God saw to it. Oh, there is truth in the old proverb. Revenge is a morsel reserved for God.
I can't bear hearing you talk like that.
Oh, I am sorry, Jenny. But I have lived for over 90 years. And Claridge's death is all that has sustained me.
If I understand what I've heard, I must say that I'm sympathetic. I'm sympathetic to Jenny Morrison. Can a body be in two places at the same time? That's what Andrew Scott maintains, and the facts seem to bear him out. Dr. Claridge was in church with him, but the constables found this same Dr. Claridge on the green outside the church and near the pond where Melanie Brent was found murdered. Is it possible that Claridge could be in two places at the same time? We'll learn more when I return with Act Three.
A miracle is an event which deviates from the known law. It deviates from the laws of nature. There are many instances of them, most of them found within the framework of religion. Visions appear before a person and reveal the future and the course he must follow to make it come true. Is that what confronts us here? A miracle? Is it conceivable that a body physically could be in two places at the same time? Paul Maiden has returned to Kirby Small's house for the telltale portrait.
He'd like to see the portrait, Kirby.
Of course. What's the story? What's the story about Melanie Brent?
She was murdered in 1911. I don't know the details. I hope you'll tell me.
Murdered? Maybe that's why Dora kept the portrait in the attic. But she doesn't know who Melanie Brent was. I think she sensed something about the portrait. I did, too. That haunting look.
You felt it, too.
Yes, I did. Give him the portrait, Paul. You have my color enlargement. I must know the entire story, Paul. Well, if he tells me, I'll tell you. I wonder why... Jenny Morrison or Andrew Scott never told Dora. Jenny's Dora's aunt, isn't she?
That's another story. Leave it at this. Bigoted. Jenny renounced her sister, Dora's mother, when she married me. I see. I think you do. And Andrew Scott?
I'm my married Dora. But it's gratifying to discover that Scott and Jenny have a really big skeleton in their family closet.
It's a terrible story, Mr. Scott.
Well, you don't have to believe it, Mr. Maiden. Nobody else does.
Dr. Claridge? Dr. Claridge was brought to trial because the constables found him lying on the green near the pond.
They had to be drunk.
Oh, they were cold sober. I spoke to them outside the church. So did the old minister. And they never changed their story?
No, sir. They repeated it in court. And you had to testify that Claridge was sitting in front of you in a pew in St. Luke's?
His physical body, Mr. Maiden.
What other kind is there, Uncle?
Oh, only God knows.
It's extraordinary. It's absolute nonsense. My great-uncle was... so in love with a young woman that when she... when she passed on...
Murdered, my girl. Don't avoid the fact and the word. What you're about to say, Jenny, is that I became a babbling idiot. You've thought that all your life. I appeal to you, Mr. Maiden.
Well, I'd have to defer to Reverend Higley, Miss Morrison. This is beyond me.
Well, in fairness to Jenny, you cannot abide scandal.
It's true that after Melanie's murder, I was... Well, I was driven. I was torn apart. Probably temporarily insane. But I remember Rob Claridge's trial and what I heard there.
What did he have to say for himself, Mr. Scott?
Ah, he was an arrogant devil. He denied kidnapping Melanie and then stabbing her. But he could not deny that the weapon was his. And your testimony freed him.
I'm an honest man. I trust God. Do you believe me, Mr. Maiden?
I want to, Mr. Scott. Isn't Reverend Higley the person who... to judge? The church knows about miracles. I asked him to pay you a visit, Uncle, but you were in despair. You said, will you see him? Won't you confess to him that your thoughts are sinful?
I declined to see him for your sake, Jenny. The story is an embarrassment to you. But now, every Tom, Dick, and Harry knows it, so it's time it was laid to rest.
No, no, that's rude to Mr. Maiden, my dear.
Oh, I didn't mean him. I'm sorry, young man. But you'll tell Kirby Small, and he's sure to gossip about it. Now, Dora will see to that.
Well, I don't think they'd deliberately try to offend you or Mr. Scott. Why would they?
That's neither here nor there. There's a small skeleton in their closet. You see, Mr. Maiden, they had to get married.
Uncle!
As in in my arrogant pride, Jenny and I turned away from them. They sinned. You didn't sin, except in your mind, thinking you willed Rob Claridge's death. He took his life because of his guilt.
Say that he did, Uncle. Say he murdered Melanie. Say he killed himself. Did anyone ever prove it?
The discovery by the constables of Rob Claridge's sprawl, fainted on the green, drove remorse through his soul, as surely as he drove that knife into Melanie's heart.
That's what you want to believe, Uncle. But I say again, it just couldn't be.
Then we'll leave it at that.
Mr. Scott, may I ask you a question about the portrait?
Yes.
Did you commission it, and when?
Two months. Before the wedding date.
And it was completed?
I intended to give it to Melanie for her wedding present. You saw it completed before the murder?
Yes. I have the portrait in the hall. Before I bring it in, another question. Did you sense a premonition in her expression?
No, not that I remember.
It's there.
You mean she anticipated her death?
That's provocative, Mr. Maiden. I also take it that you don't think... But I'm entirely damned that I have told you the truth.
The truth as you say it, Uncle.
Which, Miss Morrison, may be the truth. Melanie was murdered. Claridge was in church, never expecting to be tried. At the same time, the constable saw him on the green near the body. That's why he was tried. And the fact of the trial is what led to Melanie's revenge. Bring Higby. He must hear my story before I die. I must apologize for involving you in all its foolishness.
Well, I involved myself. Don't forget.
Ah, yes. The portrait and the diamond-shaped coat of arms. Well, there's all our dirty linen, Mr. Maiden.
I can accept the murder, but I simply cannot believe Uncle's story. Either his story is true and we doubt it, or he's dwelt so long on the young woman he loved and lost so cruelly that his hatred of Rob Claridge created the story in his imagination.
Self-hypnosis?
Yes. When did he become obsessed with his memories?
After he retired. He was 70 then and wealthy. I urged him to travel, see the world. He became kind of a recluse. It's a tragic story.
Jenny?
I'll bring the portrait from the hall.
Yes, Uncle. Are you all right?
I must have dozed off. Is Mr. Maiden still here?
I have the portrait for you, Mr. Scott, which, by the way, Kirby Small wants you to have and to keep.
Oh, thank you. Thank you. Place it over there against the wall, if you please.
Yes, sir. I'll take off the wrapping. Nice. Oh, my goodness. Striking young woman. Turn on the lights, Mr. Scott.
No, no, no. No, no, thank you. The early evening light is soft and warm. It was at this time of day that I last saw her alive, wearing that same green dress.
Oh, I thought she never looked so lovely. It was that night that she chose me over Rob Claridge. She's very beautiful. She still is very beautiful, Mr. Maiden. I see her every night.
I believe that. But neither you nor Jenny believes what the constable saw on the green, do you? You explain it, Mr. Maiden. And what is this coming towards us now?
Heaven help me. The woman in the green dress is stepping out of the portrait and coming toward us. I don't believe my eyes. Melanie!
Here, Mr. Scott. But you're following the woman. And he's also in your... Oh, he carried me in two places at once. But we saw it, Miss Morrison. I... I said, Miss Morrison, I'm so sorry.
You did say it, Mr. Maiden. Am I the one who was crazy? No, I... I saw it. Walked toward Melanie Brent. Not an apparition, a whole man. Mr. Maiden. He just died. May God bless his soul. Amen. It was sudden. It... It happened not five minutes ago.
And, uh, Miss Morrison?
Under control now. The circumstances were so strange, you... You... You'd better hear them from both of us.
The Reverend Higbee, Miss Morrison. Reverend, I... I... I had just witnessed a miracle. We saw my great-uncle call to God, and he... He walked out of his body and into eternity.
Andrew Scott, Claridge's death? By driving his soul out to the green where the constables... Where they found him lying prostrated near the murdered body of Melanie Brent. And we just saw Andrew... Andrew Scott walk away with the woman while I held him in my arms, dead.
Can it be possible, Reverend? May I see the portrait?
You haven't answered my question, Reverend. In a moment, my dear. The portrait's in his study. Shall I... No. Look. That the portrait?
Miss Morrison, something's happened to the portrait. Please come here. It isn't me. What happened to it? The colors are faded and the flesh is sagged. It's cracked and chips of paint have fallen away. It's what's left of it. It's the fact of a woman who was 25 and died almost 70 years ago. Don't you say the portrait depicted a young woman? In glowing health, wearing a green silk dress. A beautiful young woman. It was in perfect condition when I unwrapped it. What can it mean?
In mysterious ways, his wonders to perform. You and Mr. Maiden have witnessed miracles happen only to those. My great-uncle did. And now he's reunited with the woman in the green silk dress.
I think our story requires... Much comment from me, for you don't believe what happened to old Andrew Scott. But before you make up your mind, I suggest that you reflect on the broad subject. Miracles do come to pass. There's a world apart within each of us. And a world apart from all of us. Which we do not. Perhaps we should leave it at that.
Men's lives can be controlled. Their wills. Andrew Scott's life ended. Melanie Brent was murdered. But he willed her revenge. And it was achieved. Because of what the constables saw on the green near the pond outside St. Luke's. And there was no gainsaying their testimony, even though it was incredible.
Our cast included Michael Toland, Lois Kibbee, Guy Sorel, and Earl Hammond. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown.
Preview of our next tale.
That's another one of those words. Sure. Yes, but suppose I devote a lifetime of hard work, and I fail. A devotion is your success. Madame, you breathe rarefied air. My name is Regina Somerton. How do you do? I am Walter Owen. Ah. Thank you. Thank you for talking to me, for spending so much of your time with a complete stranger. But you're not a complete stranger. Or even an incomplete stranger. Oh, have we met? Yes. We have. No, I... I don't think so. I mean, I say this because I'm sure I would never have forgotten. You're how old? Thirty? Yes. We met, I think, before you were born. Oh, before I was born? Yes. I'm sure of it.
Radio Mystery Theater was sponsored in part by Buick Motor Division and True Value Hardware Stores. This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our mystery theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant dreams.
