Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

To Hang by the Neck

Episode 539October 21, 197642 min 34 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 28 min to read

Marshall. It was William Congreve, the early 18th century playwright, who first penned the words, Heaven has no rage, nor hell a fury, like a woman scorned. It is a basic truth, whatever century. Certainly is true in the 19th, where this story lies. But the woman, in this case, not exactly what you might imagine, but I'm getting ahead of myself. begin at the beginning. Our mystery drama, To Hang by the Neck, was written especially for the Mystery Theater by Ian Martin and stars Marion Seldes. It is sponsored in part by Buick Motor Division and CertainTeed fiberglass attic insulation. I'll be back shortly with Act One. The Calvert-Conway spread, brand marked C Circle C, used to lie between Dallas to the north and Houston to the south.

and east by west between the Louisiana border and Waco. It wasn't the largest cattle ranch in Texas, but in its own right, between those two extremes, it was an empire. The ownership of empires, or the succession to them, has caused most of the turbulence in history and has always brought tragedy and agony to the individuals involved in them, as witnessed the story of... See Circle C. Carrie, what are you doing here? I came back, Mother. Of course I need you. But what good is this? You're gone. I've had enough of dreams. Maybe this is a little more than dreaming. What? Remember Becky Pop? Who's going to be my maid at night? I had a letter from her recently. She's coming to visit from New Orleans. But you don't want to see her.

That isn't... Your father felt that perhaps the way I am, it wouldn't be the best idea. He's very solicitous of you, isn't he? Of course. He loves me. And me, Rebecca Pryor. I want to protect that woman, man, and human. But you've just got to be who I'm looking for. Miss Rebecca Pryor? I'll answer to that name, sir. What is yours? I'm Teague Whitman, ranch hand of the Sea Circle Sea. I was sent to meet you. Oh, how nice. I was afraid I might have beaten my telegram here. No, it's come on time. The only thing was I reckon Mrs. Carstairs didn't have enough time to answer you back. Well, I'm glad because being an anniversary and all, I wanted to come. Anniversary? Yes, sir. Just about one year ago, I came off this same old train to be maid of honor at my friend Carrie's wedding, only to find out the terrible news. What news is that, ma'am?

Both Ravish and her husband-to-be had run out on her and carried her. You have no need to go on, Miss Pryor. I know what you're talking about. The hanging. I still can't believe anyone, especially Carrie, could kill herself that way. And I don't want to talk about it anymore. I can understand why. I got the rig waiting. Let me get your bags and take you out to the ranch. It's me, Julie. Come in. It's your house, Jack. Wouldn't have disturbed you except I heard you talking to someone in here. Well, who could I be talking to? I don't know. Silly of me, perhaps. I thought maybe Becky Pryor had arrived earlier and we expected her. No. Rebecca isn't here yet. Well, I was out riding a fence and just came in. She might have arrived without my knowing it. There's very little you don't know that happens, Chad. Well, I'm human. Can't be ever where it wants. So am I.

And I find that I'm not anyplace anymore. Now, Julie, don't talk like that. I try not to, Chad. But since the accident, and most of all, Carrie, what do I have left to live for? Me? Yes, Chad, my husband. I do have you to live for. Sometimes I wish you felt that more strongly. You must believe me. You are the only thing that keeps me alive, Chad.

Listen, someone's driving up. That must be Rebecca. Is she planning to stay long? Well, I shouldn't guess. She just said in her letter she'd like to come and visit Carrie's grave on the anniversary. Why didn't you mention the letter? It's just one of those things. I replied and invited her. Do you mind, Chad? Oh, why should I mind? You need some companionship stuck out here in the back of beyond the way we are. I reckon maybe I do, Chad. Especially since my accident. Oh, that damn mare. I told Punch Williams her milk wasn't proper drawn after she lost the cold and she went plum loco. I should have fired Punch. Lance Foreman was here to let it happen. You cannot blame him. I should have been ready when the mare shied. It's just that she was always so surefoot and gentle. I never believed that... Don't dwell on it, Julie. Well, what else can I do? My back's broken.

shackled to a chair the way I am, in pain most of the time. Well, as it's your visitor, all right, I'll go on out and make a welcome. I'm going to let Rebecca come here, except somehow I must find a way back to my own child. Oh, my lovely darling, the flesh cut and scarred, the staring eyes moving a little yet. They just had life of their own. All the rest of you were still alive. Life could still have been good. Nothing should have made it worth throwing away. Can I hand you down? Oh, thank you. Mr. Conway, we had you a long time? Oh, no, ma'am. Just since I was mustered out a few weeks. I'm a Johnny come lately. Were you a Johnny Red? Um, not from these parts. I was Union. I'll get your bag.

But what brought you to Conway Ranch? Or maybe I should say the car stairs. It's still the C Circle C. Even though Mrs. Conway married again with Mr. Carstairs, most of the old hands still call it the Conway Spread. My dear Becky, how nice to see you again. Oh, Mr. Carstairs, thank you. I hope it was all right to come. Well, of course. You're the nearest thing to a daughter we got left. You're always welcome here. That's nice of you. See, you can put the horse rig away and report to Punch Williams. I'm sure he can find you something to do. I reckon. Mr. Whitman. My duty, ma'am, and my pleasure. That's a nice young man. Teague? Mm. Oh, too close mouth about himself and everything for my fancy. I think he's just kind of shy. Well, he's a good worker, I'll say that. Hands haven't been so easy to come by with the war. Let me open the door for you. I was just thinking how different it was the last time I came into this house. Don't, don't, Becky.

Please don't. I'm sorry? Try not to talk too much about it to my wife. She... Oh, I understand. Well, I just hope I didn't make a mistake. But I'm really welcome. Why, you know I couldn't be more pleased. The only reason Julie isn't down to meet you is because she can't walk anymore. She's confined to her bed or her chair. And it was seven or eight months after she wanted to go riding one day. Jill didn't like to see her. Don't you run along, Chad. Us women can find plenty to talk about ourselves. Well, I thought I ought to see Becky several for dinner. Well, Mrs. Ames can see her things are put away. Now, right now, I'd like to talk to Becky alone. Very well, Julie. See you at dinner, Becky. Right, Mr. Carter. Go on. You see, he doesn't want us to be alone a minute. Now, don't upset yourself. Upset myself? I'm torn apart. Yes, I think so. Isn't it, Mrs. Carter?

Miss Costas? I have no right to put you into jeopardy. I need help. And the only chance I had... Miss Costas, what is it? Shall I ring for help? What's wrong? It's just another spasm. Here's my drawer. And some water. Oh. How many of these pills? Two. And water. Here. I need help. Gary can't rest in peace. And two. And two. And two. What's the matter, Becky? I thought I heard Julie cry out. I gave her some of these pills, two of them. Is that all right? Yes, it's all you can do when these attacks come. Yes, it's a very strong drug. Puts a person to sleep almost immediately. Frankly, I don't like her to have them so near at hand. I'm afraid if the pain is too much, she might take an overdose. She seems rational enough. Ever since Carrie's death, her mind wanders.

flights of fancy, feelings of persecution. I don't know to spare you this, but now that you're here, afraid, my poor stock. Rebecca Pryor looks at the handsome man, the lines of sorrow etched deep in the gentle face, and her heart goes out to him. And then suddenly, she is remembering the haunted face of her dead friend's mother and her cry for help. Against what? Rebecca doesn't know. What she does know is that she will not be able to relax till many questions are answered. I shall return shortly with Act Two. In the year of our Lord, 1865, the war between the states is over now, but you remember vividly one year ago the excitement of traveling from New Orleans to the ranch in Texas, where you now are, in order to be made of honor at your best friend's marriage.

You were roommates and inseparable at Mrs. Covington's seminary for young ladies during the war. And it was there that your roommate, Carrie Conway, met Bo Fabersham, who was to have been her husband. Now, one year later, after the wedding that never happened because Bo disappeared and Carrie's awful death by hanging herself, you are back at the ranch. I'm writing you because something is strangely wrong up here. At the sea, circle sea. And I think it might need you to help set it straight. Do you think there's any possibility you could come here as though to fetch me home? And then, while you're here... Who is it? It's Ed Carstairs, Becky. Can I see you a minute? Of course, Mr. Carstairs. I'll be right there. If it's too early... No, I'm all up and dressed, as you can see.

Come in. Thank you. How is Mrs. Costas this morning? Not much better, I'm afraid. I'm going into town to fetch a doctor. I thought perhaps you might like to ride with me. Oh, that's kind of you. But maybe I can help here with your wife. Oh, I doubt it. She'll be keeping to her bed today, and the housekeeper, Mrs. Ames, will be there to keep an eye on her. Let me persuade you to come with me. We could have a nice meal at the hotel and give you some little... holiday feeling on your visit. That's kind of you, but I am a bit tired after my trip up. I think I could just rest here at the ranch today. Well, if that's what you want. I tell you what, my ranch foreman hasn't quite decided what to do with that new hand who brought you from the station. I'll have him stand by. Don't bother. I can take care of myself. Yes, that's fine, but Teague will be available. And you're sure I can't help Mrs. Carson? Oh, no, no.

Best thing is to leave her alone. She's a whole lot more than you. In my window, I watched Mr. Carstairs climb into his buckwagon and give some orders to T. Gritman, who glanced once towards the house. I drew back as he looked up. I found suddenly that I was a turmoil of mixed feelings. And the only thing I could think of to do was to finish my letter to Daddy. But as I did, I blamed myself bitterly for not going into town with Mr. Carstairs. I could have posted the letter myself. Now, who was I going to trust to get it sent out? Once I've sealed the envelope, I felt the need of some air. Well, howdy, Miss Pryor. What you got there? A letter you want mailed? Yes. I reckon I should have finished it sooner in time for Mr. Costas to take it to town. You won't have to lose out. I'll be riding in after sundown. I'll see it goes out with the morning stage. Oh, I wouldn't want to bother you. Or trust me. What ever made you say a thing like that? I don't know.

Maybe because I wish I was sure you did or would. I kind of got the notion Mr. Carstairs has it in for me some way and plans to let me go. Oh, I don't think so. What, Mr. Carstairs? I'll tell you straight out what he said to me. He thinks you don't talk very much about yourself and he'd like to know more about your background. And he asked you to see what you could find out? Not exactly. Anyways, I wouldn't have any part of a thing like that. It's none of my business. Maybe you could do something for me. A pleasure. Matter of fact, I was told by Mr. Carstairs to keep an eye on you. An eye on me? Well, he seemed to want to make sure you stayed away from Mrs. Carstairs in the stable here. Why the stable? Well, I wasn't here when it happened, but I suppose because this is where Miss Carey... Well, you know, I should think it'd be the last place she'd want to see again. But I was going to ask you if you could saddle me up a horse or...

hitch one up to the trap, so I could ride into town and mail my letter. Oh. Well, I don't know about that. There's only one horse left in here, and Punch Williams, the ranch boss, took all the hands in the remuda out this morning to graze up on the northwest fork. There's just this one mare left. Well, it's just this one girl. That'd suit me. Will she take a rig? No, ma'am. The way I heard it, this poor little black mare got stole sometime back, and... Whoever the horse thief was, he hitched her to a split rail fence somewhere and left her to starve or die of thirst. When she got so frantic, she broke the string right out of the posts. And when they found her lying exhausted in the royo, she plain had dragged that heavy log Lord knows how many miles till her strength gave out. Buck Henry, the oldest of the hands, told me about her. Ever since that day, you try to hitch her to anything and she goes just plum loco.

Other times, she's as nice a little filly as you'd ever want to see. Will she stand if you just let the rains dry off? I reckon. Well, then I'll just change into some jeans and you can saddle her up and I'll ride her into town. I don't think Mr. Carstairs would want that. Well, I do. Would you come inside this table with me for a moment? No, I don't want to go in there. Why? Did you see her hanging? Tom! Yes, I did. Just before they cut her down. Oh, how could she have done such a thing? I was hoping you might know the real reason. What do you mean, the real reason? Well, it's mighty hard to believe a girl could hang herself just because a man ran out on her, if he did. Oh, he did, all right. Where is he now, this man? I don't know. I don't reckon he'd dare show his face anywhere in this state, or Mr. Carstairs would be out looking for him. What are you doing? Opening the stable door. What for?

Just where was she hanging? Could you point it out? From that big beam there. See how she could have... Plain and simple, Miss Pryor. You toss a lariat over the beam. Tie off the hitching rail so it hangs with a noose some eight feet off the ground. Climb on a horse, get under it. Put the noose over your neck. Kick the spurs home. Left hanging. Just like that, it's... Chances are on the first drop you break your neck. And you don't know anything after that. Sam, the how is not the question. It's the why. Just like you said. And I get the feeling you know more than you want to say about that. Let me ask you a question first. What brought you back here a year after it all took place? What are you looking for? What right have you to ask? Maybe none. You afraid to answer? I don't see any of your business. Supposing I could convince you it might be. What's that? Oh, that's someone coming.

Why, it's Mr. Custer. Oh, come on, so soon? I reckon he forgot something. Um, anything wrong, Mr. Custer? No, no, no, just something slipped my mind. Uh, Becky, didn't you say something about a letter you wanted to get in the mail? Why, yes, I did, but I hope you didn't come all the way back here for that. Well, weekend coming up, suddenly crossing my mind could be important. I should take it in. I'll change my mind and come in with you. Well, who is it? Ladies' privilege. Tell you the truth, it's just what I hoped you'd do. It crossed my mind after I left. This was no place to leave you alone. Soon, Becky? What do you say to that, Mr. Carsten? Well, a letter to your father. I thought it might be to arrange to have him meet you. There's no place for a young girl anymore, I'm afraid. I hadn't planned to leave right away. But if you want me to... Oh, I'd be the person to chase you out.

with Julie as she is and the memories. Sure don't blame you if you include in your letter the news that you're coming home. There's a train day after tomorrow, stagecoach, and as soon as we get to town. But not a day long enough to be of some help. Well, no one can help Carrie anymore. Julie isn't the same way. The only difference is she's alive. What are you doing sneaking around up here, young man? I wasn't... Sneaking, Mrs. Ames. Then what were you doing? Before we left for town, Mr. Carstairs asked me to tell his wife that he'd come back to take Miss Pryor with him. Mr. Carstairs told you no such thing. There'd be no need to tell Mrs. Carstairs anything. She's sound asleep. You're lying. Maybe we both are, Mrs. Ames. I hear talking in there. That's her. Talking to herself again. Crazy.

If you ask me, she ought to be put away somewhere. Like her daughter and Bo Faversham? What does that mean? I was just asking. Did you mean dead like him? Who said Bo Faversham was dead? If he isn't, where'd he disappear to? Nobody knows that, of course. After he ran out on Miss Carey, he wouldn't dare leave any traces of business. Is that a yours? None. Who are you? Mr. Hart, I am. With a large bump of curiosity, I'd like to know why. And what you're doing in the house. I'm sure the cat, Mr. Carstairs, wouldn't like it. Does he have to, Mrs. Ames? Couldn't you and me share a secret or two between us? You keep your ideas to yourself, young man. You picked the wrong woman to smart around. Now, get out of this house.

And before the sun rises tomorrow, I'll see that my... that Mr. Carstairs gets you off this ranch. How, Mrs. Ames? Feet first, like both Aversham went? Why do you say that? Are you... Oh, just an interested bystander. You listen to me and listen close. If you're counting on Mr. Carstairs inheriting the C-Circle C, or ever controlling it, forget it. Oh! And you might want to keep your own skirts a little clean. So I'm asking you a question. What really happened the night Miss Carrie died in the stable? How did she die? And why? Why, everybody knows that. They know what was supposed to have happened. What I'm looking for is the truth. Good Lord. No. Don't tell me there was a child. No, there wasn't. I'm afraid he'll kill me just as he did you. No, no, Carrie. Leave me alone. I'm afraid. Don't ask me to find him. Is it Mrs. Costello? No, nothing. No.

A dream. About what? Who's that? I'd like to have you talk to me, ma'am. I don't want to, except maybe, maybe Rebecca Pryor. Is Carstairs a daughter who seems to haunt her? You must believe that the Carrie who talks to her is a figment of the imagination, a reflection of a guilty conscience. But exactly why does she have a guilty conscience, if she has one? And who is Teague Whitman, or Mrs. Ames? And most of all, why should a stranger like Rebecca Pryor be the one who, in her agony, Mrs. Carstairs seems to want to turn to for help? I'll return shortly with Act Three. While events at the Sea Circle Sea have been moving to their own climax, they have also been moving more slowly to a decision in Becky Pryor's life. First off, she has a strange feeling about the letter to her father.

This is the general store. We can mail your letter right here. Why don't you give it to me, Becky, and I'll take it in. Oh, I can do it myself. Oh, it's no trouble. Won't take a minute. Unless you don't trust me to carry the mail. Why would I feel that way? But as I gave it to him and he swung from the backboard and went into the store, I wished I hadn't. Nagging doubt tugged at me. For a moment, I almost followed him in. But I was too late. For at the moment of decision, he was already returning. That's that. Now we can go visit Doc Medford. Do you really think he can help us? I don't know what that means. I'm afraid to say it means anything. It was honestly just a question. Then I'm going to be just as honest in return, Becky. I don't think he can. I don't think anyone can. Then why do you go to him? What other choice do I have? I couldn't save my daughter. I'd like to save my wife. Why did Carrie do it at the cost of his life?

Hang herself? That's really, I suppose, why I'm back here. I just can't understand. That she counted the world well lost for love? No, she was young like I am. Some other men would have come along. To tell you the truth, I am never going to rest till I can understand five. Well, you were very young, Becky. So many things you don't know. If it'll help you, I'll tell you the one secret. What? Why Carrie killed herself. It wasn't just because her promised husband walked out on her. Then why? Why? If she had a child, it would have no name. Roe Ferguson? If he wasn't a father, who else could she claim? Then how could she face bringing a fatherless child into the world? I came back and I stuck my nose into it, stirred up muddy waters, couldn't leave well enough alone. What is well enough? What is it I'm looking for?

If Carrie didn't put a rope around her neck, who did she die? And most of all, why am I so scared? Becky, I don't know what you wrote in the letter to your dad, but I didn't mail it. Here it is, unopened. I just felt there was no point in mailing it the way I feel now. I don't understand. I figured with you taking the train tomorrow morning, you might even get there before the mail's delivered. You want me to leave? Would be best for everyone. I didn't see Mrs. Costes that evening. I went through all the preparations for leaving, haunted by some inner voice that I shouldn't. Something was being left undone. I didn't get a chance to talk to the doctor after he'd seen Mrs. Costes. And when T. Grittman came to get my bag, he was escorted by that dour Mrs. Ames. So we had little to say to each other. I might have made some opportunity to try to see Mrs. Costes.

But the truth is that after dinner with Mr. Carstairs, the wine seemed to go to my head, and I barely made it up to bed before I was in a profound sleep. Deep, but uneasy. Because it seemed to me that in my sleep, I was talking to Carrie. Becky. Becky. Who's that? Who's calling? It's Carrie. But you're... Dead. In the grave. Becky. You've got to get up. Here. Let me help you to your feet. That's it. Start walking. What are you doing in my room? I'm trying to revive you. You've been drugged. Drugged? With what? Keep walking. Breathe deep. With Mrs. Carstairs' medicine for her back pains. But why? Why should I be drugged? So you could be killed more easy.

Who would want to... Why would anyone want to kill me? Same reason Carrie was killed. And my brother. Your brother? Yes, Bull Fabersham. You see, Fabersham is my real family name. I don't understand. Of course you don't. Becky, Becky, it all goes back to what is the most unattractive of human sins. Greed. Chad Carstairs was foreman of this ranch. And he wanted to own the C Circle C so bad he'd stop at nothing. He tried to romance old man Conway's wife and wouldn't have gotten nowhere except, well, fate gave him a lucky break. Mr. Conway died of a heart attack. So he swarmed around and finally up and married the widow, only to get a real shock. What sort of a shock? Well, he found out the spread wasn't left to the widow, but to Carrie, the daughter. He tried romancing her, but she didn't want any part of him. She had her own man.

My brother, Bo, but Chad cost his. A man set on getting his own way, so he didn't stop at romancing. It wasn't my brother's child she was carrying. Oh, oh, no. So that's why Bo walked out on her. And why she, why she... Bo didn't walk out on her, Becky. He loved her too much. I figure Chad had some hired guns to take care of my brother and leave him in the desert to have his bones picked clean. Carrie didn't hang herself. She was hung. But how? At the point of a gun. He had the rope all tied to the spike on the hitching post and made her climb on the horse, dropped the noose over her neck and kicked the horse out from under her. I reckon, poor lady, she didn't care all that much about living anyway. But she didn't take her own life. It was took. How do you know all this? No, I don't.

I'm only guessing. How are you feeling now? I don't think I'll ever want to sleep again. Good. Good? Yeah. Because I've got to get you out of here while there's still time for you to get away. Well, I'm leaving tomorrow morning. Well, that may be too late. Too late? For what? To save your own life. Why should my life be in danger? Because this evening, while you were asleep, drugged, Doc Medwick and I witnessed this will by Mrs. Carstairs. Leaving the C Circle C to you. She'd ask you to take it home with you. To your father to be recorded. But why will the ranch to me? To anyone rather than the man who murdered to make it his own. You were her daughter's best friend. But what difference does it make? A will could be changed at any time as long as... As long as the person who makes it is still alive. Becky, Mrs. Carstairs died less than an hour after this will was made. A few more pills and you were fed.

Mrs. Ames took care of that. She's in on it? She's Chad's real wife. What? It's true. Now, you come on with me. We're going down to the stable and get you some transport to get you out of here with a whole skin. Saddled and brighted our purr. We have to get you into town so you can pick up the midnight stage. Aren't you going with me? No, ma'am. I'm staying to even up some old scores. You don't mean to kill Chad. That's exactly what I aim to do. Oh, no, please, T. Please, there's been enough killing. What good would it do? It would save your life, for one thing. Is that so important to you? Or is it just revenge for what you think might have happened? I guess that's a question I'd better let you answer. Maybe I can answer that for the both of you. No. Don't move, Teague. Except real slow to loosen your gun belt and let it drop while I light this lamp. Put a bullet in her. You can't get away with any more murders. Do it, Teague. What does it matter?

Once we do, we're both dead. If I kill you both first, I can just take it. Except that killing us both might not be as easy to explain as all the others. Carrie, my brother, your wife. I'm not so sure. You're losing your touch, you know, Chad. You finally had to poison Mrs. Carstairs. Because you missed the first time. What does that mean? Oh, don't try to spook me, Chad. You took her out on this poor little... air here you knew was loco, didn't you? Boy, that's enough talking, ain't it? And then you stopped somewhere before she had a chance to dismount. You jerked at the reins against the bit in her mouth as if to tie her up. And Mr. Scott? She didn't mean it, but she saved our lives. What happened? She trampled him to death. Sort of poetic justice, what he spent his life doing to women. Only at the end, this particular one turned the tables.

In one quick move, Teague Fabersham had flipped the halter rope over the hitching rail and immediately the mare had reacted by going berserk. Chad, caught off balance, was unable to protect himself against her flailing hooves. The special death he had planned long ago for his wife, unsuccessfully, was successful by accident and became his own. True poetic justice. That ideal justice which... poets exercise by making the good happy and the evil unsuccessful. I'll return shortly. The C Circle C has changed its brand, but the ranch is more successful than ever. It's now the T Bar R, framed in a sort of circle that looks a lot more like a heart, and it's run by Teague and Becky Fabersham. Their first child is on the way.

but both of them feel, in a sense, it is their second. The first is a little black mare that Teague has spent a long time gentling and who no longer fears being hitched. Maybe she takes an example from Teague and is a bride, Becky. Our cast included Miriam Seldes, Bob Caliban, Anne Petoniak, Martha Greenhouse, and Bill Griffiths. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown. Radio Mystery Theater was sponsored in part by Contact. the 12-hour cold capsule. This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our mystery theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant dreams. Tonight's mystery theater was also brought to you in part by ShopRite Supermarkets, where you get a lot more for...

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑