Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

Too Many Women Can Kill You

Episode 115July 8, 197442 min 11 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 24 min to read

It was Sigmund Freud, the master himself, who said, "The great question, which I have not been able to answer, despite my 30 years of research into the feminine soul, is, What does a woman want?" Well, such a question may have disturbed the immortal doctor, but not the man you are about to meet. His name is Silas Cunningham. And if you were to ask him, "What does a woman want?" Yes, Silas Cunningham would look at you in all sincerity and say, "Well, every woman I've ever met has always wanted me." And it's evidently true, because there is one woman who wants Silas forever, even after she's dead.

Go in with her now, Silas.

Is she better, doctor?

No. But, Dr. Pearson...

Go see her now, while you can.

Is that you?

Yes.

I... I want to tell you...

Please, Georgia, please, save your strength.

I... I have nothing to save my strength for. Listen to me. I... I... I'll be here.

Of course you'll be here. You'll get better.

I'll be here after I'm dead.

Darling, I... I don't even...

I'll be in this room. This room. I love it so much. We love each other. And by death...

Dr. Pearson!

When did I ever break a date with you, darling?

Why, you're late?

I didn't take the early train to town.

Why not?

Well, I began... each day... with a visit to Junior's grave.

Yes, I... arrive each morning at nine and... and sit an hour.

What? Meditate. You're such a fraud.

Marilyn, darling, how can you say that? I suppose everyone in the village knows about it.

Oh, yes, yes. The talk of the town seems to be... how grief-stricken I am.

Absolutely no more. But it's true, dear. I am grief-stricken.

After the waste... you drove you crazy.

Oh, was all that just talk? For my benefit.

Oh, Julia was all right. In her way. She made very few demands of me. If it weren't for that... since she was all wrapped up, then I... I could have even been happy.

Why is it so important for you to create this appearance of... the bereaved and ravaged lover?

Well, when very rich wives die young, certain nasty-minded, suspicious persons may begin to formulate all sorts of... evil thoughts.

Hmm. I understand. And so, for a year or so, there should be a show of decorum.

I still have the apartment. But there's no reason why we shouldn't enjoy the estate. Boating, tennis, so much to do. Darling, I want you out there.

Oh, doesn't that go again?

No. No, no. Because, you see, I decided to write a book.

Book?

Yes, and I'll need an editorial assistant.

You're going to write a book? About what?

About the occult. The two-person... supernatural. The very strong possibilities of communication with the dead.

But you know as well as I do that that's all nonsense.

Now, please, dear. This book is to be dedicated to the memory of my beloved wife. Simon. Now, you have had considerable experience in the publishing field. You were Julia's very best friend. And besides, as far as the outward appearances go, we shall be impeccably chaperoned.

By whom?

By the redoubtable Mrs. Watson herself. I shall ask her to stay on as housekeeper.

Mrs. Watson?

Mm-hmm. Madam Hatchetface. My darling, she radiates respectability from every pore.

When do I report for duty?

Saturday. Call when you're ready. I'll have Hastings drive in to town and pick you up.

Well, here's to the book. And, uh, to other things.

Mr. Cunningham, I brought you some nice hot tea. Now, you must have something. Look, I know how you feel. Everyone knew. It was a real love match, you and that wonderful lady.

Just so. But would Julia Cunningham want you to despair like this?

Thank you, Mrs. Watson. What would I do without you?

Good evening, Silas.

Oh, Dr. Pearson. Um, you want to fetch me a cup of that tea, Mrs. Watson?

Yes, doctor. Thank you.

Mrs. Watson says you don't eat. Thought I'd stop by, to see if you're all right.

Oh, I'm fine.

I'm worried about you.

Me? Your marriage was something special, Silas.

Well, every marriage is special.

You and Julia. No two people ever seemed to be more close, more content, more in love.

She was everything to me, doctor. Everything. In a marriage like yours, when one partner goes, well, sometimes the other one loses all interest in life. Now, don't let it happen to you, Silas.

I don't care much about anything right now, doctor.

Get hold of yourself. Don't let your mind wander. Don't shut yourself away. Life must go on. And it can be quite a life for you. She came into all her money last year.

You know, I'd give every penny to bring her back.

Yeah, you would. That's what worries me.

What are you saying, doctor?

Julia was very much taken with the idea of being able to communicate with the dead. It was a very sincere belief. I'm sure you discussed it. You even decided that in the event one of you died, there'd be an attempt at communication from beyond the grave.

Doctor, this is a very personal and private matter between Julia and me.

I notice you say "is" instead of "was."

I'd rather we don't discuss it.

In those final feverish moments, she talked about it. She said...

I know what she said. She said her spirit would always be in her room.

Doctor, why do you insist on...

Because it's hokum. Sane, sensible people know these things simply can't happen, period.

Well, don't you worry about it.

I worry because in this world there are all sorts of unscrupulous confidence operators who prey upon vulnerable people. People like you.

Well, I can take care of myself.

Your tray, Dr. Pearson.

Oh. Well, one thing's in your favor.

What?

Mrs. Watson's staying on and she's the most level-headed person I know.

Mrs. Watson, can I depend on you to keep Mr. Cunningham here out of trouble?

Yes, Doctor. You can depend on it. And you can depend on me.

Mr. Cunningham!

Got a bead on him now. Darn, I missed him again. Oh, well. It's too nice a day to hit anything anyhow. I just feel like making some noise in the woods.

Mr. Cunningham!

What is it, Hayes?

Well, I don't know. I've got to talk to you. I mean, I don't know what it was. I wanted to start at the beginning, Hayes.

Yes, sir. Look, you know what just happened to me, Mr. Cunningham?

No. What happened?

Well, I've been fired.

Fired? Well, how could you be fired? That's what I can't figure.

Well, who in the world could have fired you, Hayes?

Oh, Lady Ironpants. I mean, Mrs. Watson.

Well, why?

Well, I don't know. She comes up to me and she says, "Hayes, things, you're finished. Here's your money. Get out of here." Just like that.

Well, I don't understand. Why?

Well, she figures if Mrs. Cunningham passed away, she can rule the roost. You know what I mean? She's always had it in for me, anyhow.

Why, Hayes?

Well, I guess I'd pop off about her.

Pop off? How?

Well, I was only kidding, but it was about, uh, about sex.

Sex? Sex? Oh, come on now, Hayes. Hey. Why would anyone talk that way with Mrs. Watson? Why, she must be at least, uh, well, at least, uh...

Yeah? How old do you think she is?

Well, late fifties. Even sixty may be over.

Next time, take a good look. She ain't even forty yet. And she's been a widow eighteen years.

Oh. Well, I'm sure we can adjust the matter.

Well, I... I told her to go soak her head. I told her, Mr. Cunningham hired me. Therefore, only Mr. Cunningham can fire me.

Uh, is that right?

Yes, Tasty. That's right. Now, you go back to the garage. You'll have to go to the city this afternoon.

If I'm to perform my duties in a satisfactory manner, I must have the right to hire and fire, Mr. Cunningham.

Yes, yes, of course, Mrs. Watson. It's been with us for such a long time. I dismissed him for good cause. He's a thief.

A thief?

I found out. He's been getting together with some of the service places in town. We've been paying bills, for repairs that were never made, for gasoline that we never bought.

Oh? Are you sure?

I'm positive. The sooner he's off the premises, the better for all concerned.

Well, it's just that I, uh, I would want him to drive into the city this afternoon.

Oh, yes. Yes, I'm expecting a call from, uh, from, uh, Mrs. Ralston.

Marilyn Ralston, of course. She called while you were out shooting.

Oh? Did she say what time she wants to be picked up?

If we fire Hastings, I'll drive in myself.

Well, that won't be necessary, Mr. Cunningham.

What do you mean?

She isn't coming out this afternoon.

Oh. Something the matter?

Or any afternoon, for that matter.

Why? Did she suddenly change her mind?

No. But I told her that you had changed yours.

What are you talking about, Mrs. Watson? I never told you I changed mine.

It wasn't necessary for you to tell me, sir. I acted in your best interest.

Mrs. Watson, I'm very capable of determining my best interest. And furthermore, yes, Mr. Cunningham.

What are you staring at?

That, uh, that bracelet.

Yes, this bracelet.

Well, how dare you, Mrs. Watson. That was my wife's bracelet.

I know.

Well, what right do you have to wear it?

She told me I could have it. She whispered it to me.

Well, that's a lie.

The day she died.

It isn't true.

The day she died of, uh, what did the good Dr. Pearson say? An infection? Nobody questioned, dear, Dr. Pearson's diagnosis. How fortunate he signed the death certificate without questioning it himself.

Now, you couldn't prove anything?

Of course not. I couldn't prove anything, but if they were to exhume the body and perform certain tests, but they'd never do it unless someone suggested it strongly. And, uh, as of right now, I don't plan to suggest it.

Well, there you are. You get what you consider to be the perfect setup for the perfect murder. You get rid of a woman who is a thorn in your side, only to discover you've just acquired one who could be a rope around your neck. The rope either gets tightened or loosened.

On her deathbed, Julia Cunningham promised her husband, Silas, she would communicate with him from the other world. However, it now develops that Silas may have more trouble than he can handle in this world. It seems that Mrs. Watson, the faithful housekeeper, has discovered that Silas had actually hastened Julia's exit from what is sometimes described as this veil of tears.

Mrs. Watson, what makes you think I would have something to fear from an autopsy?

Isn't it obvious?

Isn't what obvious?

The situation we find ourselves in. Now, if you didn't fear an autopsy, this bracelet would be off my arm, you'd fire me on the spot, and I would be out on my ear.

Now, I know.

Just what do you know?

I know I was right about the bottle of poison.

What bottle of poison?

Oh, come, sir. It was in your room. I made a few discreet inquiries. I learned from a doctor that small, steady doses could produce symptoms which might appear to indicate an intestinal infection, and it would be treated as such until suddenly the patient would die. Incidentally, that doctor was not Dr. Pearson.

And, uh, just how would I be implicated?

Well, if I were to voice my suspicions strenuously, and if the coroner should find poison...

Oh, I see.

Isn't it your duty as a reputable citizen to, uh, report this?

Yes, it is. Why haven't you done so?

Well, I could set in motion a chain of events that could place you on a scaffold or, you know, on a shelf, or, you know, or in a prison for life. And I ask myself, what would be in all this for me?

Well, the satisfaction that you would perform. Your duty as the responsible citizen of a democracy.

Oh, I've been doing that all my life, and I have very little to show for it. And so, I said to myself, "Vera?"

I went to you and didn't know my first name was Vera.

Well, to be honest, I didn't even know you had a first name.

That's true. To you, I've always been the invisible Mrs. Watson. And so, for the first time in my life, I did something different, unusual, unprecedented.

And what was that?

For once, I thought about me, my own welfare. You see, Mr. Cunningham, you had committed the perfect crime.

Well, how? You seem to have detected it.

Oh, the key element, Dr. Pearson. Old, fumbling, superannuated Dr. Pearson.

Well, he's not old. He's not all that incompetent.

Oh, no. He's merely obsolete. And you counted on that. You counted on him accepting your wife's death as a purely natural event and getting a death certificate without an autopsy.

Well, Mrs. Watson, now what? I assume you intend to blackmail me.

Well, that's a harsh word.

How much money do you want?

Oh, I don't want any money.

You don't want any money?

No.

Well, then what do you want?

I want you.

You want me?

Yes. What do you think it means? I want to be Mrs. Silas Cunningham.

Would you mind saying that again?

I think you heard it.

Yes, I heard it. I can't believe it. You know, people like you are completely unaware of people like me as human beings. Our mission in life is to serve, to be useful, to cater to all your creature concerns. But I have feelings. I have desires, emotions, yearnings.

Well, I... I'm only three years older than you are.

That's young enough. There's still time enough for me to enjoy a rich, exciting life. I've heard of shotgun weddings. Why turn you over to the police? I have a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity. Finally, Vera Watson, you too can become somebody. Nobody's maid, nobody's servant. Cross the line.

You know, I... I wish I could say I admire you.

Oh, well, we'll... We'll... We'll let a year go by, a decent interval, and then we'll announce our engagement. I can assure you, Mrs. Watson, you're hardly my type.

Perhaps. But you're mine, and after a while, I'll become yours.

You think so?

Oh, you'll come to value me when you know me better.

Oh, by the way...

Yes?

Unlike so many women in love, Mr. Cunningham, I'm not the only one. I'm not blind. For example, I see how you've been glancing at your shotgun.

Oh, have I been doing that?

Well, I, uh... I wouldn't recommend anything hasty, sir. You see, I've written a letter to my sister. It's to be opened in the event of my death. Need I say more?

No. I think you've said quite enough.

Julia!

Yeah, I didn't. My dad lied to me. But, Julia... I can't believe it. I've come from such a long way. Julia, please. Why did you kill me? Julia, I... I didn't... Julia, I... I didn't mean to. I must have been crazy. It was for you. Julia, Julia, please. Will you listen to me? Will you... Julia, I didn't know. I didn't know what I was doing.

Silence. Julia, please. Julia. I didn't mean to kill you, Julia. Be quiet. I didn't mean it, Julia.

How... What are... What are you doing in here? What did you slap me for?

It's a good thing none of the servants sleep on this side of the house. You were having a nightmare.

No, no. She was here. Julia was here. I saw her. I heard her.

Oh, snap out of it.

You don't understand. Can't you understand? You were screaming that you murdered her. All you need, all we need is for someone to hear that.

But it was so real.

Oh, look. You've got to get hold of yourself because if you don't, we're going to have a problem.

Yes. Yes, yes, yes. You're right. At least you... You're beginning to see how much you need a woman like me. You must keep your sanity and I can help you do it. Now, listen.

No, not now. Now, you take this sleeping pill and get yourself some rest.

Fine. I'm just fine. But you don't go anywhere. You don't do anything.

Well, I don't care. Silas, you've lost your color. You look thinner. You've got to develop an interest in life once again.

I'll be all right.

Silas, you're not getting all twisted up in that occult business, are you? You're not getting visits, I hope.

Doctor, I loved my wife very much and I still haven't recovered from the shock of having lost her and I wish that everyone would let me alone.

All right, Silas. I'll leave you some vitamins.

Oh, Mr. Cunningham.

Oh, good morning, Dr. Pearson.

Good morning, Miss Watson. Our friend here looks a bit peaked. Hasn't been eating much, I bet.

No, but... I'm on my way to town to buy some things to tempt his appetite.

I'll give you a lift.

Oh, thank you. I just have to stop by the kitchen to leave some instructions. I'll see you outside in a couple of minutes.

Hmm. You know, Silas, something's different about that woman.

Different? No. In what way?

Well, for one thing, she looks much younger. For another, she's not too bad looking.

I hadn't noticed. Something's come over her. Now, what do you suppose it could be?

I... haven't the faintest idea.

Oh, I'm sorry. She's downtown shopping.

Yes?

Yes, certainly. Don't mention it.

Is this how you spend your evenings, Mrs. Watson? Knitting?

Knitting, reading, listening to music. I've often wondered what you did with your time.

That's not true. I don't imagine you ever gave me a second thought.

Well, for better or worse. Do you know what I, uh, like to do on a lovely night like this?

No.

Go out in the boat.

Well, why don't you?

Well, I, uh, never cared to go out alone.

Are you asking me to go with you?

Mm-hmm.

Why?

Well, it's, uh, part of my courtship, Mrs. Watson.

Oh. You are a remarkable man, Mr. Cunningham.

And you are a remarkable woman. You know, actually, you were right the other night. You're the woman I need. The woman who can keep me balanced.

The earth?

Mm-hmm.

Yes, Vera. You know, I have the feeling that I'm, uh, falling in love with you, Vera.

Mr. Cunningham.

My name is Silas.

Ah, Silas. Vera, I need you. I need your strength and your good sense.

Who knows? We'll be very good for each other. You'll see.

Oh, yes. You'll supply the common sense and I'll supply the romance. Now, how about that boat ride?

I'm very happy. Oh, Silas. Life is so, so unpredictable, isn't it?

Yes, that's the one thing you can say for sure. A month ago, who would believe you and I would be drifting along out here close together.

You know, it's getting a bit late.

Oh, do we have to go back in now?

Well, we, uh, we better. The breeze is freshening. We may be in for a gale. You wouldn't want to be blown out to sea, would you?

Oh, no.

Well, we, uh, we must do this more often.

Yes.

So where are we headed? I mean, we're not going towards shore.

That's right.

But you said...

What did I say?

Well, that it was time to go home.

I'm going.

Silas, what... What are you saying? What I'm saying is there's no one within miles and this should be far enough.

Far enough for what?

Well, you see, you took the boat out tonight all by yourself and I guess you fell overboard.

Silas!

And here you go.

Oh, no!

I must have forgotten my letter to my sister.

Don't! Don't! Don't! Don't! Don't! Don't! Don't! Don't! Don't! Don't! Don't!

I've got to tell you, you had a phone call from your sister. You see, she had an accident last week. She went out in the boat and she drowned. It was a terrible thing.

Darling, I can explain everything.

Is it that poor girl is going to get stood up again?

Well, who are you?

This is a good idea for the two of you to be seen together.

Now, wait just one minute. What are you doing here? Who are you?

How do you do, sir? I'm your new housekeeper.

Now, see here. Let's cut this nonsense.

I'm your new housekeeper for a very good reason.

My name is Emma. Emma? You remember. Emma, Vera Watson's sister. The reason I'm your new housekeeper is because I found that. Julia cramped his style. Goodbye, Julia. Then, Vera Watson had him cornered. Goodbye, Vera. Now, here comes Emma. It never rains, it pours.

What are we going to do about Emma? How does Silas Cunningham keep track of all his women? They all fall madly in love with him. They all want him. How does he manage them? Well, some of them have accidents. For example, his wife died of a stomachache. His housekeeper drowned. It seems she went out in the boat by herself and fell overboard. Or anyhow, that's what the sheriff thinks. Now, the latest woman who has entered his life is Emma. That's right. Emma. Yes. By the way, I spoke to you on the telephone.

That's right.

And I told you about the letter.

Uh-huh.

What are you doing here? I didn't think there was anything to that letter.

Well, there isn't. Silas, when I read that my poor sister, well, actually, she's my stepsister, drowned. Well, you know, she shouldn't have gone out in that boat alone.

Oh, she didn't go out in the boat alone, Silas. You went out in the boat with her. What did you do? Throw her overboard?

Now, you can't prove that.

I don't have to prove that. I still know about the other thing.

All right, let's get this over with. Huh? What do you want? You don't catch on at all, Silas.

What do you mean?

I think you're kind of cute.

Good. You're obviously an intelligent woman. Why, uh, why don't we make a settlement?

What did you have in mind?

Well, uh... Before you tell me, let me tell you what I had in mind. I can marry you, then sue you for divorce and strip you clean.

You know, you drive a hard bargain.

Ha! You'd have been better off with Vera. Better off with Julia.

Yes. Yes. Please, what do you want of me? What do you want? What do you want?

I'm keeping our promise. I killed you. You're dead. Oh, Julia, Julia. You are alive. Oh, Julia. I love you, too. It's the worst for me. I know. To kill this, this horrible woman, this Emma. You must kill her. She destroyed... How, how can I kill her, Julia? Julia, how? Tell me. Tell me, Julia. Please, tell me. The poison. And to poison me. You're oblivious. Why would she want to poison me?

Mrs. Watson. Mrs. Watson. Julia, please. Darling, Julia, please. My beloved Julia.

What's going on in here?

Oh, Julia. Hey, snap out of it. You're having a bad dream.

No. No, no. That was not a dream.

Okay, have it your way.

Don't you humor me. I saw her. She was right here.

Oh, sure. She's keeping her promise.

Her promise?

Yes, she said she'd come back and she told me how I could... Oh, I...

Wonderful. Oh, this is terrific. Keep it up. Keep what up?

Oh, what you're doing now.

Huh?

And after we get married, I can have you put away in the nut house.

Oh, no, no, no. She was right here. You can laugh all you like, but she was here.

Oh, sure she was. And she was wearing a white dress with blue shoes and a green hat and there were little men seven inches tall with heads like pancakes.

Shut up.

What?

And get out of here.

Don't you dare insult the memory of my wife.

You better be careful how you talk to me, Sally.

Why? You know what I can do.

Yes, but that's all you can do.

Oh, I can put you on a scaffold.

You do that and you won't get one single cent.

You're bluffing.

Am I? Call it.

Silas, honey, we're stuck with each other. Why not make the best of it?

We may be stuck, my dear, but not for long.

Good morning, Silas.

Good morning. I hope you feel better today.

I don't.

Breakfast?

No, just coffee.

You haven't hardly eaten a thing for the last three days. You got me worried.

Worried?

Yeah, you're my meal ticket. I don't want anything to go wrong with you. Besides, as I said the first day I met you, you're cute.

I don't think I'll have any more coffee either.

What's the matter?

Nothing, nothing.

But it has to be something.

Well, I have these pains.

What kind of pains?

I don't know. Just pains.

Where?

Everywhere.

Do you want me to call the doctor?

No. No, not yet.

Not yet?

No.

What are you waiting for?

I'm waiting for just exactly the right time.

What do you mean by just exactly the right time?

There's an exactly right time for everything. Now, I better go upstairs and lie down.

Can you manage?

No, I can manage. I can manage everything.

Doctor, this is M... Mr. Cunningham's housekeeper. Dr. Pearson. Mr. Cunningham's been sick the past four or five days.

Sick? Well, he can't eat. He has pains. Looks kind of feverish to me. I said to him, call the doctor. But he said he wanted to wait. He said he wanted to wait for just exactly the right time. Don't talk to me. I'm going to call Dr. Pearson now. I better not wait any longer. Maybe my system is different. I only took a little bit.

Julia, please. Where are you?

I'm here, Silas.

Is this how it was with you?

Yes.

I can't stand it. Can I? Let go.

Yes. I can't take it anymore.

I know. But I have to hold out until Pearson gets here.

I don't have the strength. I can't stand the pain. Oh, just a few...

It's obvious. Killed him, was a skull fracture. Fell out of the window and hit his head on a rock near the window, Emma.

I don't know. Did he say anything?

He just called.

He simply never got over her death. I suppose he couldn't accept it. Julia. It was as if he could see her.

Yeah, maybe it's for the best. There was really no living for him without her. You know that.

Yes, doctor.

Never knew him even to look at another woman.

Is that so?

That's right, doctor. A very unusual man.

That's true, doctor. He's the kind of exceptional person you meet so rarely in this world. All of us will be the poorer for his loss.

You can say that again, doctor. All of us will be the poorer.

You know what they say. De mortuis nil nisi bonum. Which means only speak nice things about the dead. And after all, Silas Cunningham, he paid the price. Ironic, isn't it? So many men envied him his fantastic good looks and his successful way with women. It shows you can have too much of a good thing.

But you cannot have too much of Mystery Theater. Our cast included Larry Haines, Evelyn Juster, Ray Owens, and Guy Sorel. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown. This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our Mystery Theater for another episode of The Mystery Theater. We'll see you next time.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant dreams.

The Mystery Theater program was furnished by the CBS Radio Network. This is WOR New York and RKO General Station. At the WOR time signal, exactly 8 o'clock, here's John Scott with a...

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑