The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 22 min to read
The Mystery Theater presents... The sun, we are told, shines on the good and the evil alike. And the rain falls on the unjust as well as the just. Rain and sun, water and light. Without them, nothing can grow in the garden of life. And so it all comes down to this. Since we may nurture the flowers of good or the blossoms of evil, which shall we choose?
Shouldn't I?
Well, you've just been informed that you've been reduced to poverty.
That's merely a temporary condition.
Oh, then you do have other assets.
I have one other asset.
Certainly. It's you. Yes, you. Trina. We shall conquer the world.
Our mystery drama, Virtue Is Its Own Reward, was written especially for the Mystery Theater by Sam Dann, and stars Fred Gwynne. It is sponsored in part by Contact, the 12-hour cold capsule. I'll be back shortly. With Act One.
Today's little sermon is provided by Mr. Robert Burton, who was a contemporary of Mr. William Shakespeare, and no mean phrase maker himself. Mr. Burton polished off a series of little gems that included Penny Wise, Pound Foolish, and Birds of a Feather, Flock Together, which should prove he was a gentleman of great wisdom and deep perception. Mr. Burton also said, Every man has a good and a bad angel attending him all his life long. If that proposition was good enough for Mr. Robert Burton, it may be good enough for us.
I'm not out to take anything away from Brother Burton, whoever he was, but as far as I'm concerned, my man is an old-time Roman you never heard of, a fellow named Silas Italicus. And he said, Virtue is its own reward. Yes, sir, that's what he said. And I happen to be stuck with it.
Very good. I suppose you will want to know who I am. Well, we'll get to that shortly. The fact is, you really can't appreciate me until you meet my client, Mr. Julius K. Barley.
And where is he now?
In his office, and up to his old tricks again.
Miss Minzer, Miss Minzer, after you're in here a couple of three minutes, ring my phone. You care what for, just ring the phone. I don't pay you to ask questions, just to follow instructions.
Hello, Mr. Julius K. Barley. Won't you have a chair? To what do I owe the honor of this visit?
I have a bill here.
Yes, that does look like a bill.
It's for water.
Do you question the accuracy of the bill, Mr. Lamb?
I question the legitimacy. Do I have to pay for water?
Well, that should be obvious. You're using it.
You can't send me a bill for using my own water.
You are 100% correct. While I cannot send you a bill for using your own water, I am entitled to charge you... for using mine.
Yours? You happen to be drawing water from the Armagansett...
Well, that's on my property, the property you sold me.
True. But I didn't sell you the water right.
Well, this is the craziest thing I ever heard. If you consult the deed, and I happen to have a copy here before me, you will note where it says...
Well, that print's so small. I can hardly read it.
It is, nevertheless. Seller holds in perpetuum... all rights to the heretofore described Armagansett...
Actually, it says that...
...with $50 per month for use of water. Stead fee to increase 8% each year.
Well, this is an outrage. I didn't know that clause was in there.
Surely your lawyer was aware of it.
My good, Mr. Lamb, we have an agreement. You're a crock and lover. Under any circumstances or conditions, will I do business with you again?
Yes. Yes, indeed. Yes, I'm proceeding as quickly as possible. There's one tiny obstacle, but we can clear that in short order. I'll have good news for you very soon, Mr. Roulette. Goodbye.
Now, sir, where were we?
I was telling you that you were a thief, an unprincipled scoundrel, and that I shall never, under any circumstances, ever do business with you in the future.
Hmm, I'm sorry you feel that. Would you mind putting that in writing?
Uh, well, uh, putting what in writing?
Uh, the fact that you do not... You do not intend to exercise your option.
What option?
Look at paragraph four. You will see it says that you have an option to purchase the adjoining plot to the Armagansett property for the same low price that you paid for the first parcel.
Well, why would I ever want to buy even so much as a square inch of ground from you at any price and any condition?
Well, that, of course, is your prerogative. Once again, sir, good day.
Uh-huh. Then you release me from my obligation to sell you the adjoining plot. And thus, permit me to place it on the open market.
Well, you can do whatever you please. Knowing you, I'm sure it'll be something crooked.
Then, in the statement...
I sign nothing.
Uh, Mr. Lamb, you cannot arbitrarily refuse to acknowledge my right to...
Just a minute. You have a buyer for that property. You are making an infamous Babington roulette. He was on the telephone just now.
Was he?
Putting up hotels with gambling casino. The other half of the Armagansett Park. What a perfect place for a resort hotel.
Hmm. Do you really think so?
Just this once, you may have outsmarted yourself. In what way?
With that option, Claude. You thought it was all worthless hatred.
I may have. Now you have to let me have it for ten thousand.
You insist on exercising that option.
Absolutely. A man has to be worth at least a quarter of a million dollars to roulette.
Oh, you'd love to have clear, unobstructed rights to the land so that you could sell it to him yourself.
Ha ha ha! This time I've got you. I'll make the fortune. Mr. Roulette will have to buy that land from me. And that's my price.
Am I to understand that you wish to exercise your option?
Have the papers drawn up.
My client, Julius K. Barley. And who am I? Remember when the fellow was talking about the good angel and the bad angel that attends every man his whole life long? It so happens that I am Benjamin Benign, Mr. Barley's good angel. And I don't have an easy time of it. I'm usually on the carpet for the way I handle Mr. Barley. My supervisor, Mr. Nimbus, lives and breathes the rule book.
Mr. Benign, I have a report here concerning Mr. Barley's latest escapade.
Mr. Nimbus, it isn't exactly an evil deed. No one forced Mr. Lamb to buy that second parcel of land. Mr. Barley implied there was an eager buyer for the property. Mr. Barley never said so directly. Mr. Lamb chose to make the inference. The fact is you cannot cheat an honest man.
The fact is Mr. Barley cheated Mr. Lamb on the first transaction.
All the conditions were spelled out in the agreement. Small print, but it wasn't illegal.
It was done with the intention to cheat. What have you been doing to keep Mr. Barley honest, upright, virtuous?
I've been trying very hard. He goes from bad to worse. I suppose I'll just have to try harder.
I wonder if you're qualified to handle this assignment.
I never lost a client yet, that's true. Yes, it's a fact. I have the computer readout for activity since the beginning of time.
Well, that should mean something.
It could mean you never had a client that the other side really wanted.
We have no way of knowing if that's true.
We do now. You see, Mr. Benign, we have received a report from our intelligence. The other side has replaced Mr. Barley's current operative.
I... I can't believe that.
It means they think he has the potential to go all the way.
Oh, not Julius K. Barley. I don't think there's any real harm in him.
They've called in their ace, Nick Hellborn.
Nick Hellborn?
Nick Hellborn. So while you get to know the competition, they were putting in Nick Hellborn on Julius K. Barley. It was proof they thought he had terrific potential. Nick only worked presidents, kings, dictators, robber barons throughout history. Only the top people. And it was Nick Hellborn who had turned them into men of evil.
Mr. Nimbus, don't replace me.
You must admit you haven't been aggressive enough.
Yes, but now that I've got some real competition, it'll kind of spur me on to greater effort.
We won't make a change just yet, but you'll have to show some positive results. And soon.
Results. That's all they care about. I wish Nick'd give us a little more ammunition. The other side offers them wine, women, and song, or as someone put it, power, wealth, and pleasure. And what can we give them?
I said before that we generally know the competition and they know us. I ran into my opposite number, Nick Hellborn. Or maybe he ran into me.
What do you think?
Nick, all your credit. And Junior's cave. I say he isn't. No, I'm sorry. Get him. Or the challenge. At the bottom, it's always the case of doing right. All of our arguments and justifications for pursuing a questionable course of action. Well, Barley wasn't exactly a good man. He wasn't exactly a bad one either. But now the other side had their eye on him. And aside their top operative, Nick Hellborn, it was a cause for concern. How and when would Nick Hellborn strike? And through whom?
Good morning, Mr. Barley. I'm Mrs. Quackenbush.
You're Mrs. Quackenbush?
Of course.
Well, I somehow... You hadn't. Well, you hardly look like someone named...
Well, that's my name. Sincere Dolly Quackenbush. The very sound of the name calls to mind an elderly...
But I'm happiest when everyone calls me Dolly.
What may I do for you?
We are about to enter a rendezvous. A rather intimate relationship.
Certainly.
That is, in a business sense. Now, you were recommended to me as one to whom I could safely trust my affairs.
Was I?
Well, now that poor Hubert is no longer with us...
Hubert was my late dear departed...
Oh, I'm sorry.
We must all leave sooner or later. And Hubert left me rather well provided for, I think. You would have to evaluate the investments and so forth. Now, you must excuse me.
Oh, of course. And I'll make a complete study.
Will you do that?
I'm due for lunch with the Baroness Duval.
The Baroness Duval, you say?
She's a dear friend. I always use her apartment when I'm in Paris.
Do you?
Yes, I'll try to analyze your portfolio as soon as possible.
Oh, no rush. See, I'm leaving tomorrow for Washington. Biff is doing a command performance at the White House.
Biff?
Valentine's Turkish.
Oh.
Well, Biff's a dear friend. And he always makes sure the gang's invited to come along.
Oh, when do you think you'll be back in town?
Well, that's hard to say. See, now, tomorrow's Thursday. And we're all going to the Costa del Sol for the weekend.
Oh, sorry.
Yes, it's been discovered. We're all sought to go now. But these are democratic times, so what can you do?
Yes, yes. Then you'll be back next week.
Next week? That's an eternity away.
Uh-oh, when will you return?
Eventually, my dear. Eventually.
Nick Hellborn's opening gun. And what a gun, eh? Dolly sparkled with delight and glowed with promise. And every word she said touched a nerve. She was raising the curtain on a new, fantastic world for Julius K. Barley. And what did I have to fight her with? Who did I have to fight her with?
Supper's almost ready, Julius.
Yeah. Oh, I'm sorry I didn't get home till late.
It's such an exciting day at the school. I didn't think I'd been able to reach the Everett boy.
Well, Artie Everett, I do believe he'll be able to read any day now.
Poor Julius. What kind of life is it? Paper. Four pieces of paper. You can do it.
Naturally, there are those people who say you can do it too well. Everything I've ever done is legitimate and above board.
Oh, I'm sure of that.
Business is a battle of wits. And from you.
I'll tell you what let's do tonight. Why don't we go to the community house? The girls' swimming and basketball. I want to sound pretty lucky. We're fairly young, strong. You make good money. I think sometimes it's not enough, but it is enough.
You look at this. Here's a picture. What am I doing in America? Reporter, I've come here to have lunch with a friend. Just to have lunch?
Mm-hmm.
Why not? She can afford it.
Can she? People can afford it, but can her conscience?
She's got a hundred dollars on some trivial foolishness.
Well, maybe it's not so trivial or unimportant to her.
What are things with her money?
It's her money.
She has that right.
She does?
To death. Just looking at it.
It was an old argument, and she never got the better of it. But what other ammunition could I give her? Like I said, the opposition has all the big guns. She wasn't tall and willowy like Dolly. Nor did she have long, lustrous hair. Nor black hair or gleaming red lips. Nor was she full-bodied, and yet gracefully slender like Dolly. Ah, Dolly was definitely going to be my problem.
Well, Mr. Denny, we have just become aware of Dolly.
I know all about Dolly.
And what are you doing about her?
There's only one thing I can do within the restrictions placed upon us.
Yes?
I can only strengthen Mrs. Ruth Barley.
Strengthen?
I can only make her as attractive as possible. No paint and powder, at least for any other world, could hope to make Ruthie Barley as attractive as Dolly. I can only hope for the best.
I think I'd better call in your replacement.
Why?
Perhaps he could try some other tactic.
Such as?
Well, Mr. Nimbus, you know as well as I do that there simply isn't any other tactic. Pride is the one tactic, the single method. And if it doesn't work, we're finished. We lose another one. Oh, I prayed we would be able to keep Junius K. Barley. Oh, I'll admit I was being selfish. I was thinking of my own record. But it was more for his sake than mine.
It wouldn't have been all so bad if I didn't keep running into Nick Hellborn.
About what?
I don't have Junius K. Barley yet.
Oh, wrapped in a package?
I could remind you not to count your chickens. I could also tell you that you can't sell the skin of a bear that's still in the woods.
You know what I can ask you, don't you?
Any time.
The concert. The command performance. And she would be there. Dolly would be there. And of course, Junius would be watching on his TV. I could see from the way the camera was pointing that just past the soloist, you could most of the time see this absolutely fantastic-looking woman. And I could picture Junius staring at her.
Have her come in.
We were doing Thursday night ages ago. You were on television. That is, I could see you while the recital was on at the White House.
Oh, darling, this command performance. Didn't you just adore the way he played?
Well, to tell you the truth, I...
Why not? Was there a problem with the audio on your set?
No, I...
Are you sure that was wise?
Oh, for what?
Well, then we should strike it from the record.
I have some news.
What sort of news?
Very... Well, just tell me, that's all.
No, I... No, I can't do that.
Why not?
Because it isn't the kind of thing you can just say in so many words.
But if it needs to be said...
Oh, to avoid saying... Then I'm waiting.
Good news, it can keep. Bad news, we should in no hurry to hear it.
Both good and bad. That is, good for Nick Hellborn and bad for our good angel, Benjamin Benign. Or vice versa. Well, we'll get all the news as usual when the curtain opens on Chicago.
Beauty, it is said, is its own reason for being. It means that beauty is entitled to special consideration. Beauty is always being preserved and protected. A beautiful lady in distress is always sure to draw a crowd. Which proves beyond all doubt that if you have a choice of being beautiful or homely, you shouldn't hesitate for one moment. Right now, watch a beautiful lady go to work.
Uh, Dolly, I... I have examined all of the papers that you left with me.
Ah.
Prize your late husband's estate.
Yes.
Sooner or later, you will have to say it.
Uh... Then say it now.
Your husband left you no estate.
I beg your pardon?
I said, your husband left a... Oh, but that's impossible. Uh... I gave you that portfolio. I... I am... Then how can you say he left me no estate?
All the stock, all the bonds, all the securities are worthless.
I don't believe that. I... Can't be.
You own hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of bonds from the Triple Square Corporation. It's a moribund company.
But I don't understand.
Nothing there could be worth anything. A silver mine abandoned years ago. Played out. One company after another, dead or... or ready to die. Your husband left you all this.
Well, he speculated. There would be wild swings one day. He'd be up. One day, he'd be down. Unfortunately, I suppose he died on a down day.
Well, I must say that you're taking this rather calmly.
Shouldn't I?
He's been informed that you've been reduced to poverty.
Well, I... I could never be poor.
Hmm?
You didn't?
I have too many friends.
Well, it is a valid friendship, sir. Only possible among equals. And you're no longer equal to your friends, naturally.
Oh, that's merely a temporary condition.
Ah. You have other assets.
Oh, yes, of course.
Good to hear that.
I have one other asset at this time.
You should say, who?
And I would answer, you.
Of course. Come here. I'm sure I can explain it. Ah, darling. Come with me, genius. Anywhere. Everywhere. Do you want to spend the rest of your life in this suffocating little law office, pulling little deals here and there?
Well, how can I...
You have a nice little home, and a nice little wife, and a nice little life. Is that what you want? You're bored. That's why you fleece little suckers like Mr. Lamb.
Uh, how do you know that I...
Oh, come out into the world, genius, and meet some big suckers.
What are you saying?
You belong out there with me. I have the contacts. Whom do you want to meet?
Oh, Mr. Lamb. Oh, Mr. Lamb. Oh, Mr. Lamb. Oh, Mr. Lamb. Oh, Mr. Lamb. Oh, Mr. Lamb. Oh, Mr. Lamb. Oh, Mr. Lamb. Oh, Mr. Lamb.
Who are you talking to?
Oh, Mr. Lamb.
You belong out there with me. I have the contacts. Whom do you want to meet? All the doors are open to me. Let me take you inside. You belong up there with me.
With you?
We belong together.
But I'm, uh, married now.
Oh, it's just as easy to get yourself unmarried.
Divorced, Wolfie?
Do you love her?
Haven't thought about it, uh, uh, lately.
That's what I mean. You should be thinking about her day and night.
Okay.
I could make you think about me day and night.
Well, but I...
Oh, I understand. You did love her at first. After all, that's why you married her. But do you still find her as interesting, as stimulating, as exciting? Look at me and answer that.
I...
Do you want to spend the rest of your life with plain little Ruthie?
She was sneaking through my fingers. I was getting panicky. I had never lost a client before, but this one was going. He was just about gone. They wanted Junius K. Barley. They wanted him so badly, they were pulling out all the stops. I'd never felt so much pressure in all my career. And, of course, Nick kept rubbing it in constantly.
Far from over.
I saved him somehow.
Say, do you want me to put in a good word for you?
What are you talking about?
Well, you've got style. Anytime you want to jump the... We can find a good spot for you.
No, thank you, Mr. Hellborn.
Oh, it should be with a real outfit. Where you get something to work with.
We do.
Like... Happy with Ruthie. A way of the beholder. Uh-huh.
My own supervisor, Mr. Nimbus. He had not only pressed the panic button, he was sticking on it.
What do you propose to do now, Benjamin?
I'm doing everything I possibly can. We can only hope for the best.
If it is one we cannot afford to lose, we can't afford to lose any of them. But, Junius K. Barley?
Yes, I understand.
Oh, do you? Do you? A man with Barley's brains happens along once every millennium. In the long run, in the hands of Nick Hellborn, he could become a monster. He could take over the world.
I know that.
You must fight for him.
What did he think I was doing, anyhow? But every day, I would watch what Nick Hellborn was throwing at Junius. And Colette has this darling penthouse in Paris. And Giorgio says we can use his... yacht to cruise the Greek islands at any time. What did I have going for me? Volunteer for the Hospital Blood Donor Committee?
The question that Nick had Dolly casting her spell. She was ready to make her kill.
The money is no problem, darling. First, we can sell all my poor late husband's securities, especially the mines.
But they're worthless.
Of course.
Well, then that's not exactly... Honest, is it?
No, not exactly.
I've never done anything before, Dolly, that was out-and-out dishonest.
So why not? You flirt with the idea constantly, don't you?
Well, I...
You come close. Oh, so very close. And then you... you back away. Why?
Well...
You delight in toying with the concept. You want to. You want to so badly. Why don't you? You want to be rich. Really rich. It can happen. You can sell anybody anything.
But mine?
You've already sold worthless land.
I made no claims for it. Oh, I may have allowed people's imaginations to run unchecked, but I never lied. Let the record show that.
Why are you so concerned with the record?
What record?
How do you know there actually is a record? Or that somebody is watching or even cares? You want me. You know you want me. And you want wealth. And power. And you can have it all. It's all yours. Take it. Take it.
He softened up for the kill. Sooner or later, he would have to talk to Ruthie and tell her. For days, I'd been watching him, trying to nerve himself for the ordeal. He was going to leave her. That much he had practically decided. But first, there would have to be a scene. And he didn't like scenes. Of course, there was no way I could talk to him. There was no way I could talk to Ruthie either. But there was one idea I might be able to get across to her. Just one little thing she should say to him.
The way you... She has a lot to the shop, a little deal here and there. But who did you ever hurt? Who did you ever destroy? Uh, handsome of you. And those worries. No, Ruthie, I would... You were going after the wolves. You would be a wolf, too. To get you, things, associates. No, Ruthie. The wolves. The wolves were there.
Well, here's my record. Mr. Nimbus no longer nibbles on his fingernails when he thinks of Junius K. Barley. And even old Nick Hellborn had a compliment for me.
Well, dear. That was way back when a dollar a day was a... But while tomorrow will always be another day, yet in some ways, it will be the same day as today. In one way or another, it will present us with the same problems, the same challenges, the same reward could there possibly be. For if virtue were bought or sold, why, then, it simply wouldn't be virtue. And the very next time some small voice within you urges you to follow a virtuous course, remember it's the voice of Mr. Benjamin Benign or one of his colleagues. They need all the help they can get.
The cast included Fred Gwynne, Bob Dryden, Ray Owens, and Bryna Raeburn. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown. We're also inviting you to return to our mystery theater for another adventure in the macabre.
