The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 26 min to read
CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents. I'm E.G. Marshall.
"Tell me your dreams," said the ancient seer, "and I shall reveal the fate the immortal gods have cast for you."
"Tell me your dreams," says the modern psychiatrist, "and I shall reveal the innermost secrets of your psyche."
Cut it, slice it, shape it any way you like, but after all these years, it seems we're still in the dream business.
Why do you want to kill Mr. John Joseph Hill?
Madam, who are you?
Answer the question. Why do you want to kill Mr. Hill?
I don't know anyone named Hill. I'm not a killer by instinct or choice.
Don't evade the question. Madam, you are obviously a disturbed person. I have to make sure you don't kill him. Put that gun away.
Our mystery drama, "You Tell Me Your Dream," was written especially for the Mystery Theater by Sam Dann and stars Terry Keane. It is sponsored in part by Buick Motor Division and True Value Hardware Stores. I'll be back shortly with Act One.
Knowing how to use tools is important before you start the job. Knowing that a tool will last is important before you buy the tool. Pat Summerall for True Value Hardware Stores to suggest you pick up the March issue of Popular Science Magazine. In it, you'll find an eight-page tear-out section telling about Master Mechanic tools. True Value Hardware Stores' exclusive line, all American-made, with the finest materials.
Like the Master Mechanic 16-ounce fiberglass hammer, balanced to put the weight on your work, not on your arm, and it's just $9.95. Or the Master Mechanic wet and dry shop vac, with attachments and dolly, for just $36.95. And the Master Mechanic seven-piece propane torch kit, a useful tool for year-round household repairs, is just $9.97. See the March issue of Popular Science Magazine for the eight-page tear-out section featuring Master Mechanic tools, available exclusively at participating True Value Hardware Stores and Home Centers.
It happens. What was that sound? Everyone looks at you quizzically. Obviously, you were the only one who heard it. A sound, or perhaps a brief bar of music. A voice. A glimpse of a face. A flash of a color. A fleeting sensation. So strange, so unreal, it defies description. No one else has seen or felt or heard any of these things. But they were real. For you. In which a neat, lovely lady is now living.
Like a knife?
Well-kept hotel room. One thing. Dr. Geller. And Dr. Abramson.
Let's get it over with. I was your star pupil, too. You see? Even the great Dr. Geller can make mistakes.
Lucy, what happened?
You know what happened. I made a statement.
Why did you kill him?
I had to. To save my patient's life. And my own.
Come now. It's all there. I wrote a statement.
You'll take a long... you'll take a long way, my dear.
I know you do, Doctor.
Lucy, I have known personally the great pioneers of our science. Starting with Freud, who was the very first archaeologist. All the good ones had that certain quality. You have it, too.
I'm afraid not. No more.
Dreams. Our first discoveries came from dreams. What have you discovered in dreams?
I've discovered that I can... I can be charged with murder.
Lucy, what happened?
I told you. I made a confession.
Lucy, I am not just the court-appointed alienist. I'm your teacher, your colleague, your friend. You know you can trust me.
Oh, but can I trust myself?
I came into the office. A man close to 50, in his prime of life. Tall, attractive, handsome. His name, John Joseph Hill, Jr. He was quite ill at ease. After a few minutes, I said to him, Dad, he's bothering you.
Doctor, you don't know what it's costing me to sit in this chair.
Mr. Hill, we've already discussed the fee.
I'm not talking about money.
Well, then what are you talking about?
Dr. Abelson, for a guy like me to go to a... I didn't mean that as an insult.
I understand.
A guy like me, shrinks, psychiatrists, it's all a joke. Like they're all crazy. Who goes to weirdos, you know?
Yes.
I can only give you one half of the help.
A guy without much education, which I never did get, but I put up buildings all over the world.
I understand. I've been to the White House and all that. Why did you choose me?
I couldn't ask anybody's advice about a thing like this. So I opened up the classifieds, and I looked under doctors, and where it says psychiatrist, there was a whole list. First one listed. They all got degrees, one's as good as another.
The waiting room, then I found out, the L stands for Lucy.
And did you consider walking out?
Yes.
Why?
Bad enough I gotta go see a shrink, but I figured the bargain, she said, Dane, you know what I'm talking about?
Yes.
So?
Well, I'd already made the appointment. It wouldn't be fair to you.
Mr. Hill, you are obviously a man who demands the very best for himself. Now, why would you settle for an inferior psychiatrist?
I never said that you were...
But I'm a woman. How can I be the equal of a man?
What I'm gonna say is if I was crazy.
How do you know I won't do the same thing? Except it doesn't really matter what I think of you. But for a man to think you're crazy, means a personal loss of stature. You can't tolerate that, even from a doctor. You have to take me seriously. You can't look at me like I was some nut that walked in here off the street. I mean, I've been to dinner at the White House.
I've already made a note of that. And I'm telling you the truth all the way down the line. Suppose you begin to tell me when it started.
You didn't think anything of it at first?
Dreams, aren't you?
What happened?
Then every night I keep dreaming about this guy. It's always there.
Where?
You speak to it?
Why not?
How it isn't a dream.
You want to do something?
But somehow you can't manage to do it.
Well, who do you think he is?
I know who he is. A guy named Morley K. Sutledge.
Well, how did you find out?
I was dreaming. I'm at the airport, okay? And this voice on the PA says, "Will Mr. Morley K. Sutledge please report to the information desk?"
And until this time, you've never known a Morley K. Sutledge?
No, Doc. I never did.
Had you ever heard that name before?
Never.
Very well. We have this fictitious individual.
No, he ain't fictitious. He's real.
Yes. In your dream, perhaps.
In real life.
How do you know?
I looked him up in a phone book.
And there is such a person?
Yeah. I wrote down the address, went over to where he lives, parked my car, waited. After a while, he got out of a cab and he went inside.
The same person?
I had no trouble checking all that out.
What did he teach?
One of them. He's the world's greatest expert on the ancient Sumerians.
And never, to the best of your knowledge, have you ever had anything at all to do with this man?
I told you, never. Never.
Is there any conceivable way in which your paths may have crossed?
No.
Can you be certain?
Sure I can.
Yes?
Practically his whole life. You know something? There's no way the two of us could ever have been in the same place at the same time.
Except in your dream.
To the cottage. So I dropped over there. I went to the cabin.
Can I sit down?
You're welcome.
And it's a good thing.
Oh, sure. Why?
Well, because things go better in good weather, don't they?
Count this live. During wartime.
Now, sir, I have enjoyed our conversation, but I must be excused.
Oh, sure, sure. Hey, you know, you look familiar.
I?
Yeah. Do we know each other?
Well, could we maybe have met someplace?
No. I'm virtually certain.
Well, in other words, I don't look familiar to you?
Not in the slightest. As far as I'm concerned, this is the first encounter between us.
Then we've never met. Why do I... I got up to... I got up to the chair.
But how could I?
What question?
Ah, Doc, what would it sound like if I asked, "Why do I dream about you?" You know what the guy would think?
So you just walked out of there.
Well, maybe you could say I ran.
Well, Doc?
Well, I'm not.
Why do I dream about this character? I never met him.
You can't be sure.
I'm telling you, I had an army of private investigators.
You could have met him somewhere without either one of you being aware of it. Something about his appearance may have buried itself in your subconscious, and now it's been released into your dreams.
Why should a man like... How can you say that? I know exactly where he's going to do it, when he's going to do it, and how he's going to do it.
How can you be so sure?
Because I've already seen him do it. Every night for a week, I've been having the exact same dream. Just me and him. It's his gun at me. I don't know, and I don't care. All I know is he kills me.
It all depends on your point of view. For example, the ancient magicians believed that dreams predicted your future. Modern psychiatrists believe that dreams reveal your past. So you see, as far as revelation is concerned, the old and the new agree in principle only. Nothing's changed very much, as do shortly.
Mid-sized Buick Regal. It meets the demands of today without losing the special things about Buick that people have always loved. Now that's some trick. On the outside, it's trimmer than last year's Regal Coupe. Mid-sized. More legroom. More trunk room. Turbo-charged sport coupe. And such traditional Buick qualities as luxury, elegance, and road feel. A down-to-earth dream car at your Buick dealer.
Of life. Into what?
For a deeper reality than the one we think we know.
Found us? Sumerian cars, Mr. Hill?
I never had anything to do with them in my life.
There must be a basis for this fantasy of yours.
Fantasy? Doc, you didn't hear a word I told you. The guy's gonna kill me.
Sumerian cars. He's a harmless professor of history.
Who says he's harmless? Who says he's a professor of history?
You told me that he teaches at the university.
Yeah, yeah, but who says that's all he does?
Well, what else does he do?
I don't know.
Well, you said you'd had him thoroughly investigated. If he were involved in any other sort of activity, surely your detective would have...
Well, maybe he does things that a detective can't uncover.
Such as?
Such as... okay. Such as getting himself into my dreams.
What does that mean?
That... that, oh.
You just said, "Oh."
Oh. Does it mean that you...?
No, it got me down to some nothing. There ain't no more past to go down to, Doc, than I...
Mr. Hill, we have begun this journey together. We must go where it takes us.
Dream where he shoots you. Tell me exactly how it happened.
Woods. And what are you doing there?
I'm on a hunting trip.
Do you know where?
Yeah. I'm up at Joe Langley's hunting lodge.
Joe Langley? The Joe Langley?
Yeah. He's maybe the fourth or fifth richest guy in the world. It is one beautiful day. You can hear the birds and... sometimes there's a chatter... or a squirrel or a chipmunk. And I'm thinking, what a shame to kill anything on a day like this. But Joe Langley only talks business at the lodge with guys who like to hunt.
Then I hear someone coming.
Hey, Professor Sutledge. Is that you?
Yes, it is. Who are you?
We met. We had a cup of coffee together at the college cafeteria. Bill's the name. John Joseph Hill, Jr. But everyone calls me Jack.
And what do you do, Mr. Hill?
I build buildings.
Big ones?
Maybe some of the biggest in the world.
That's fascinating. What are you doing up here?
I'm supposed to be hunting.
Oh? I'm a guest of Mr. Langley's.
I assume you are also, since I understand this is his preserve.
Oh, yeah. This whole place, it's over 10,000 acres.
There's something regal in that concept. The divine right of ancient kings to say that only I may run this land and kill at my pleasure.
Regal or obscene?
Do you like to hunt?
I despise this.
What are you doing here?
I've been seduced. I'm seeking support for an archaeological expedition to a site in ancient Mesopotamia. Langley is interested.
There's no man who hates to hunt.
I must lie in order to pursue an honest endeavor.
I joined a club. I got a development project. So I have to come up here to score points, too.
What kind of gun you got there?
It was just something I bought for the occasion.
.30. I wouldn't know one from another. I just asked the store clerk for a sort of middle-quality rifle.
Is the safety catch on?
What? The safety? Oh, you shouldn't walk around in the woods or any place else with a safety off.
Which is the safety?
No, no, no. Not that. Oh, but that. Take your finger off that. Be careful.
Mr. Hale. Run, run, run.
I'm sorry. I just... Don't stay in there. Get a doctor.
The whole idea of a gun, it makes me nervous. Get a doctor. Yes, yes, yes. That's right. That's right. He drops his gun. He runs off. And I'm just lying there. My chest, blood is soaking through my shirt.
It was in your dream.
What is there that I can do for you? We would have to work together for weeks, months, perhaps years to discover the wellsprings of this fantasy.
Is it, uh... Months, years. You're supposed to be a doctor.
I'm not supposed to be a doctor. I am a doctor.
All right, then act like a doctor. Why do I dream of this guy? Am I all right? You know what I mean?
I think so.
Then why? We could... Today, you have been given a warning.
Yeah? By who?
I couldn't hope to explain it. I'm not sure I can understand it myself. A warning. By whatever incomprehensible forces that swirl about us. A man named Sutledge will kill you.
But why? You need him.
Kill me? Perhaps you don't want to be doing business with Joe Langley.
Why wouldn't I?
I don't know. How hard a bargain does he drive?
I don't know. The only time you go to him is when you can't raise financing.
I don't know anything anywhere else.
How did you know? It's true, isn't it?
It's true. So, your dream is only telling you to keep away.
But I figured myself. For what?
You had the answer all along.
Yeah, but a bum like me, where do I come off getting bright ideas? If somebody smart agreed with me.
That was a reasonably accurate analysis of the situation, Dr. Abramson.
Thank you, Dr. Geller.
And he walks out of your office?
Yes.
May I ask, why wasn't that the end of it?
Dr. Geller, it would have been the end of it. Except, except, I had a dream, too.
A dream?
Yes, a recurring dream.
What sort of dream?
It was a dream that developed over a period of months.
Yes?
The first few times I dreamed it, I'm driving along the turnpike. My radio is playing. I'm listening to Mozart. And I look in my rear view. I notice the car is very close behind me, actually tailgating. And just as it seems it must hit me, I wake up.
And that's it's all?
At first. And each week, the dream becomes more and more filled with details. Finally, it has a beginning, a middle, and an end. Especially an end.
What sort of end? Can't you imagine? That's all you told me.
All right, I will. Well, the complete dream... A dream as it has existed every night for more than three weeks now. I am driving along the turnpike. I'm listening to Mozart. I look in my rear view mirror. The car behind me is very close. Too close. He will hit me. I know he will hit me. I try to move away from him, but it still follows. Finally, I feel the shock. The impact of the crash. The car is hurled off the road and into a concrete abutment. Great light glares up in my brain. And then all goes black. And I'm dead. I know I'm dead. A light glares up and then goes out.
Yes, and in that light, I see something.
Yes?
I see the face of the driver.
Do you know who it is? Tell me.
Morley K. Sutledge.
The same? Are you sure?
I see the license plate. K00890. I checked that registration. Do you know whose it is?
Morley K. Sutledge.
Morley K. Sutledge. Amazing coincidence. I remember something else.
Yes?
The radio announcer's voice just before he started the Mozart recording. Do you know what he said? Tell me.
Good morning, ladies and gentlemen, and what a bright morning this is. The 28th day of October. Let's get off to a sparkling start in sprightly Mozart.
The 28th day of October. That would be about...
About a month from now.
Yes, Doctor. So I knew that on the 28th of October, Mr. Morley K. Sutledge would kill me.
Because your dream said so.
Yes. And that's why I had to kill him.
Couldn't you have done something less spectacular? Couldn't you have saved yourself by not driving on the turnpike on October 28th?
No.
Well, why not?
Because the dream has taken over, and it cannot be changed yet.
But, my dear, the dream is only an illusion.
Yes. The dream is only an illusion. Doctor, how do you know? How can you be sure that this, what's happening right now, our conversation, how can you be sure that this is not an illusion? But how do you prove anything? They tell the story of a famous philosopher during his class on illusion and reality. And a bright young student asked, Professor, how do I know I exist? And the professor replied... Who is asking the question?
All of your questions should be answered shortly, when I return with act three. A Spanish playwright who said, is a dream, and even dreams, all in the mind. And the mind is a divine engine that is capable of wonders far beyond our comprehension. It leads us into places that the intelligence cannot yet understand. Indeed, when you add it all up... How little we know.
Very well, Lucy. You dream of being killed by this Professor Morley K. Sutledge. Yes. In an automobile. But I must ask you again, why didn't you keep off the turnpike?
I couldn't.
I don't understand. If you are convinced, you are going to be killed.
Believe me, I couldn't. I tried. Every morning as I would leave my apartment to drive to my office, I would deliberately attempt to use Main Avenue. But I always turn off at the ramp. Even now, surely... It's as if I'm responding to someone else's will.
Who?
I don't know. It's something that overrides my own powers. I'm forced to take the turnpike.
Well... You don't know what to make of me, Dr. Gatlin. I don't know what to make of myself either.
Now, Lucy, you know why you dream of Sutledge, don't you? It's all other suggestion. His name was brought up by your father. It was brought up by your patient as a menace. And so it has crept into your own subconscious.
That's an easy assumption. Does that make it invalid?
My father was a doctor, a general practitioner. When he heard I was to become a psychiatrist, he said, good. You know why? I can't imagine. He believes that doctors were constantly exposed to the infectious germs of their patients. Well, we psychiatrists are no better off. We can also be infected by the virulent psychosis that constantly surrounds us.
I don't believe it. I know for a fact you are not a very confident driver. Is that true?
Well, I...
You are afraid of the turnpike. That is not so. Lucy, you force yourself to use it because you realize your fear is irrational. So, a frightening thing. Your patient mentions a man named Sutledge. A frightening person. Your subconscious puts both of them together. And your dream declares that Sutledge...
You know, doctor, one day a psychiatrist will listen to a patient and say, you are right. I am wrong. I wish I could say that to you.
Now, to return to your sworn statement. You came to your office about a week ago. Mr. Hill was waiting for you. He was waiting to see you.
Yes. He was agitated, nervous, was smoking one cigarette after another. He said to me... Doc, all that stuff we went through last time... What do you think it meant? Oh, come on, doc. I pull that same stuff in business. Answer me a question with a question. On one level, it meant you really don't want to do business with Joe Langley.
Yes.
So threatened by Joe Langley that you see your death symbolically. Going up to the Langley Lodge this week. Sutledge will be there too? How did you know? I'm afraid to think about how I know. Is it true? Yeah. I had to be sure, so I made an excuse to call Langley's secretary. By the way, I asked, anybody else going to be there? And she said, yeah. A Morley K. Sutledge.
There's only one thing I can tell you. Don't go.
Yeah. That's what I keep telling myself.
Joe, what's the problem? I know I can't stop myself from going. I know I have to be there. But... I'll be in the woods just like in the dream. I'll go through with it because I know I can't change any of it. Why can't I just not go? I don't want to go.
But you are going. You know, of course, that you will do nothing to stop Sutledge from shooting you. Nothing anybody can do about it.
Maybe there is. Maybe everything will be all right.
That is how you would make it be all right? You would kill Sutledge?
Yeah. He couldn't change the course of his fate, but I could. It wasn't my dream, my vision, my revelation up there at Langley's. It was his. He might be helpless, but not me. If I could stop Sutledge from killing him, he could later on stop Sutledge from killing me on the turnpike.
But if you would kill Sutledge up at the lodge, how could he later on kill you on the turnpike?
You keep using that word kill, Doctor. I wasn't going to kill him. Just stop him.
Very well. Somehow I would get the gun away from him. Then I would explain to Hill that he must save me on October 28th by somehow preventing Sutledge from using his car.
I see. Why do you seem so skeptical, Doctor? You fight it.
No, no, no. Please continue.
You're only going to stop Sutledge, but in the end, you killed him. Why?
Everything went wrong. Sutledge was under a compulsion.
What compulsion?
He too. He too had to carry through the dream.
Whose dream?
Well, if we only knew.
Lucy. And so on that day, I drove up to the hunting preserve. Hill was right. It was a place of awe-inspiring beauty. I knew I had to find Sutledge before he encountered Hill. Once that scene began, it could not be stopped until I hurried through the woods till suddenly I saw him. This tall, thin man with gold-rimmed glasses carrying the rifle.
I asked him, Are you Professor Sutledge?
Yes.
Professor, I must ask you for a favor.
Why should I do you a favor?
My name is Lucy Abelson, Dr. Lucy Abelson.
Yes?
I'm a psychiatrist.
Well, why should that be of interest to me?
I have a patient who happens to be up here in the woods. The sight of the rifle, well, any weapon, in fact, frightens him.
Really? And I was wondering perhaps if you could let me, have your rifle till he's gone safely away.
Let you have this rifle, my good woman.
Please? It's vitally important.
Are you saying... You must believe me. I don't know what your game is, but I have no desire to play it.
You have to believe me. It's the truth. In just a few moments, a man named John J. Hill will walk by here.
Who's he?
A man. And the two of you will chat briefly. Now, that rifle of yours, there will be an accident. It will go off.
Are you serious? And you will kill him. Now, believe me. Believe me.
Well, how can I believe such nonsense?
I know it's difficult, but I'm a responsible person. No. Have you heard of Dr. Benjamin Geller, the noted psychiatrist? Come back to the lodge with me. You phone him. You ask him about me. He'll tell you I'm one of his colleagues.
You should be one of his patients.
Please. I beg you.
And into the bargain, you're probably trespassing.
Just let me have the gun. Can't you see? I hear someone coming. Oh, I hope it's one of Mr. Langley's servants.
Then admit it'll be too late. For what?
You will kill Mr. Hill.
But I don't have the slightest desire to kill anyone.
That is... Unimportant. Now, will you please stand aside?
It'll be an accident. I'm asking you.
No.
No?
See? Now, there he comes. It's Mr. Hill.
Wait, is he an accomplice of yours?
Mr. Hill? He's coming closer.
Can't. I can't help myself. I can't. I'll save you. Professor, give me the gun.
What are you trying to...
I said give it to me.
Remove your hands from...
No. Let go. I said let go.
You foolish woman. Did you hope to accomplish...
Mr. Langley's servant. The servant saw what happened and read their statements. They said you and Professor Sutledge were having a fight. Attacked Professor Sutledge without warning.
But that isn't true. When I go to trial, I'll explain the whole thing.
If you go to trial. You have been assigned by the court to determine if you are competent.
You can't believe I'm not qualified to stand trial.
Oh, no. I'm sane. I'm sane. Mr. Hill will testify about dreams, and that will give me credibility.
I'm afraid not. You see, I have spoken to Mr. Hill. He has no memory of those dreams.
He can't deny he came to see me.
Oh, yes, yes, but he cannot recall why. It is quite possible that the trauma of seeing Professor Sutledge die erased the memory of the dream completely.
Oh, no.
It is also possible that Mr. Hill... being very much the practical man of the world, does not cherish the idea of telling everyone he went to a psychiatrist because he was afraid of a dream.
But he did.
Poor Lucy. You fell in love with him, didn't you?
No.
Why not? We hear of so many patients who fall in love with the analyst. Why shouldn't the analyst fall in love with the occasional patient?
He won't testify.
No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No.
Everything will be all right. You'll get the best of care and treatment, and in a year or two, you'll be as good as ever.
You don't believe me, Dr. Geller. I'm telling you it's true. Future in a dream. My dear Lucy, if you persist, I can see your future while we are wide awake. It will be here in the sanitarium.
But I'm telling you the truth.
Please, Lucy, try to understand.
No. The truth. I'm telling the truth. I see the truth. I know the truth. Thus speaks the prophet, discoverer, the innovator. And they speak, these people do, to those who have neither the vision, the faith, nor the courage to understand. And so, it is their fate to languish, neglected, unheeded. Lucy Abelson telling the truth. Reveal itself in dreams. Stranger things have been known to happen.
I shall return shortly.
I'm Hyman Brown, producer-director of Radio Mystery Theater.
Recently, when we celebrated our 1500th broadcast, I asked if you would write to us. Tell us how you like our thrillers, and also tell us a little bit about yourself and your family. I'm deeply pleased and gratified by the abundance of mail that came in. We are trying to answer your wonderful letters, but you can easily understand that the time pressures involved in producing and directing Mystery Theater are such that we are not able to get to every letter. So, right now, I want to thank all of you for writing and for the warmth and the possessiveness of your comments on our seven nights a week dramatic series. From E.G. Marshall, from me, from the actors, actresses, and technicians of Radio Mystery Theater, thank you very much.
So many of our dreams blurred. We shrug. It is because perhaps our minds are too active. Suppose the dreams do not originate in our own minds. Suppose our minds are like, well, TV sets that are receiving visions and messages. Suppose at this point, the TV sets of our minds are too primitive to receive the picture. Right here, when you tune us in. Terry Keene, Ralph Bell, and Robert Dryden. Entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown.
A preview of our next... I told you we'd arranged it. Get yourself another boy. The Contessa Entremont will be a senorita. A thousand dollars placed in your...
Sponsored in part by True Value Hardware Stores and Buick Motor.
This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our Mystery Theater for another adventure in the macabre.
