Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Workshop artwork

From the CBS Radio Workshop collection

Portrait of Paris

Episode 024July 6, 195629 min 5 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 20 min to read

<!-- kimi_cleaned -->

I am Parisian, of course, and I think there is a great difference between the two. I think the American way of life is much more optimistic and much more generous, but it's also much more naive. And I think the Parisian way of life is much more pessimistic, much more bitter, but also much more realistic. I think the American people are always looking for a solution to their problems, and they think they can find it. And the French people are always looking for a problem in their solutions, and they always find it.

Well, that's very well put, Jean-Jacques. Now, you are a man who is always in the middle of a storm. You are always fighting for something or against something. Why is this? Why are you so controversial?

I think it's because I am a Parisian, and I think Paris is a city of controversy. It's a city of doubt, of intellectual curiosity, and of soul-searching. I think the French people are never satisfied with anything, and they are always looking for something better. And I think this is a very good thing, because it keeps them from being complacent. But it's also a very bad thing, because it keeps them from being happy.

Well, you say Paris is a city of doubt. I think that's very true. But isn't there also a great deal of certainty in Paris? I mean, the certainty of the communist, the certainty of the Catholic, the certainty of the businessman?

Yes, but I think these certainties are always being challenged. I think the communist is always being challenged by the socialist, and the socialist is always being challenged by the radical, and the radical is always being challenged by the conservative. And I think this is what makes Paris so exciting, because there is always a debate going on. But I think it's also what makes Paris so exhausting, because there is never any rest.

Well, I must say that I find that very typical of Paris and of you, Jean-Jacques. You are never satisfied, you are always looking for something better, and you are always in the middle of a storm. And I think that is what makes you such a good journalist and such a good Parisian.

Thank you, David. But I must say that sometimes I get very tired of all this controversy and all this doubt. Sometimes I wish I could be an American and just believe in everything and be happy.

Well, I'm afraid that's not possible, Jean-Jacques. You are a Parisian, and you will always be a Parisian. And I think that is a very good thing, because Paris needs you and you need Paris.

Thank you, David. I hope you are right.

We leave now the editorial rooms of L'Express and the Champs-Élysées and go to another part of Paris, to the Left Bank, to the Boulevard Saint-Germain, to a café called the Café de Flore. This is the headquarters of what is known as the existentialist movement, the home of Jean-Paul Sartre and Simone de Beauvoir. This is where the young intellectuals of Paris come to argue and to drink and to write. This is where the philosophy of despair is turned out with the regularity of a factory. This is where the young men and women of Paris come to be unhappy in a very sophisticated way.

But we are not going to the Café de Flore to meet Sartre or de Beauvoir. We are going to meet another kind of Parisian, a man who represents something very different from the intellectuals of the Left Bank. We are going to meet a man who is a symbol of the Paris that most Americans know and love, the Paris of the boulevards and the cafés, of the wine and the women, of the song and the dance. We are going to meet a man who is a symbol of the Paris that never changes, the Paris that is always gay and always young. We are going to meet Maurice Chevalier.

Maurice Chevalier is not at the Café de Flore, of course. He is at his own café, the one he has made famous in his songs and his films, the café that is called the Moulin Rouge. But we are not going to the Moulin Rouge either. We are going to meet Maurice Chevalier at his home, a beautiful apartment on the Avenue Foch, where he lives with his wife and his memories.

Maurice Chevalier is 68 years old now, but he doesn't look it. He is still the gay, charming, debonair Frenchman that Americans have loved for 40 years. He is still the man who can make a song about a broken heart sound like a celebration of life. He is still the symbol of Paris, the Paris that Americans want to believe in.

I asked Maurice Chevalier what Paris meant to him, and this is what he told me.

Paris? Ah, Paris is my life, my love, my everything. I was born here, I grew up here, I sang my first song here, I fell in love here, I became famous here. Paris is not a city for me, it is a woman, a beautiful woman who has always been kind to me. Even when I was poor and hungry, even when I was in trouble, Paris was always there for me, smiling at me, encouraging me. And now that I am old and famous, Paris is still there for me, still smiling, still beautiful.

But Maurice, I said, isn't Paris changing? Isn't it becoming more American, more modern, more like every other city?

Ah, yes, he said, Paris is changing, of course. But the heart of Paris, the soul of Paris, that never changes. You can put up all the skyscrapers you want, you can build all the superhighways you want, but you cannot change the heart of Paris. The heart of Paris is in the people, in their love of life, in their love of beauty, in their love of love. And that will never change.

But what about the political problems, I asked him, what about the communists and the Catholics, what about the wars and the revolutions?

Ah, he said, waving his hand, that is not Paris. That is politics, that is history, that is the things that men do to each other. But Paris is something else. Paris is the spirit, the joy, the beauty that survives all of that. I have seen two wars, I have seen revolutions, I have seen terrible things. But Paris has always survived, and it will always survive, because Paris is not just a city, it is an idea, a dream, a way of living.

And that, I think, is what Maurice Chevalier believes, and that is what many Americans believe about Paris. But is it true? Is Paris really just a beautiful dream, a city of joy and beauty that survives all the troubles of history? Or is that just the myth, the legend, the thing that tourists want to believe?

I think the truth is somewhere in between. I think Paris is both the dream and the reality, both the joy and the sorrow, both the beauty and the ugliness. I think Paris is a city of contradictions, as I said at the beginning, and that is what makes it so fascinating, so frustrating, so unforgettable.

And now, as I end my portrait of Paris, I want to take you to one last place, a place that is not famous, not beautiful, not even very interesting. But it is a place that means a great deal to me, and I think it says something important about Paris.

It is a small bakery on a narrow street in the 15th arrondissement, not far from where I live. It is run by a man named Monsieur Dupont, who has been baking bread there for 30 years. Every morning at 4 o'clock, Monsieur Dupont gets up and starts his ovens, and by 7 o'clock the smell of fresh bread is filling the street. And every morning at 7:30, I stop at Monsieur Dupont's bakery and buy a baguette, still warm from the oven, and take it home for breakfast.

Why do I tell you about Monsieur Dupont? Because I think he represents something very important about Paris, something that is not in the guidebooks, not in the history books, not in the songs of Maurice Chevalier. He represents the ordinary, everyday, unglamorous side of Paris, the side that tourists never see, the side that makes Paris a real city, a city where people live and work and raise their children, not just a city where people come to dream.

Monsieur Dupont is not a communist or a Catholic, not an intellectual or an artist, not a cab driver or a journalist. He is just a man who bakes bread, who gets up every morning at 4 o'clock, who works hard all day, who goes home to his wife and his television set at night. He is not very happy, not very unhappy, not very anything. He is just a man, living his life, doing his job, getting by from day to day.

And yet, when I talk to Monsieur Dupont, I find that he is proud of his city, proud of his country, proud of his bread. He will tell you that French bread is the best in the world, that Paris is the most beautiful city in the world, that France is the greatest country in the world. He is not being ironic, not being intellectual, not being anything but sincere. He believes these things, and he lives by these beliefs.

Is this the real Paris? Is Monsieur Dupont the real Parisian? I don't know. I think there are many real Parises, many real Parisians. There is the Paris of Notre-Dame and the Eiffel Tower, the Paris of the cabarets and the nightclubs, the Paris of the intellectuals and the artists, the Paris of the communists and the Catholics, the Paris of Maurice Chevalier and Monsieur Dupont. And there is my Paris, the Paris I have lived in for 12 years, the Paris I have learned to love and to understand, the Paris I have tried to paint for you in this portrait.

It is not a complete portrait, of course. No portrait of Paris can ever be complete, because Paris is too big, too old, too contradictory, too human to be captured in any one picture, any one story, any one broadcast. But it is my portrait, the Paris I see, the Paris I know, the Paris I love.

And so I end where I began, with the great bells of Notre-Dame chiming across this timeless town, echoing from the River Seine up to the hill of Montmartre and across to the tip of the Eiffel Tower. This is Paris. This is my Paris. This is your Paris. This is everyone's Paris, and no one's Paris. For Paris, like all great cities, like all great loves, belongs to those who give themselves to it, who live in it, who breathe it, who become a part of it. And in becoming a part of Paris, they become more than themselves, they become a part of history, a part of beauty, a part of that endless, fascinating, heartbreaking, glorious thing that is the human adventure.

This is David Schoenbrunn, in Paris, for the CBS Radio Workshop.

The CBS Radio Workshop has presented "Portrait of Paris," written and reported by David Schoenbrunn. This is Bill Leonard speaking. The CBS Radio Workshop is produced by Paul Roberts. Your announcer has been Charles Stark. This is the CBS Radio Network.

Well, if you mean, David, that whether I prefer to live in Paris or would I like to live in America, I prefer to live in Paris. Each time I go to America, I feel very much at ease and I like being in America. These days and in recent years, I seldom agree with the state. I agree with the State Department, with the foreign policy of America, but that has never interfered with my great love of the way of life in America.

Well, I wasn't really talking about way of life or where you live. I was thinking of your approach to your work. You have an American technique in making your paper. What would you describe as the Parisian about you?

What is the thing that you think distinguishes a young French intellectual like yourself from an American counterpart in general?

Well, maybe it would be pretentious to say so, but I think we are less prejudiced on many problems. I think we as French journalists or French young people in politics, we ask ourselves more questions than our American friends. For instance, take a very difficult subject, a delicate one like communism. We don't classify it as easily as the Americans do. We try more perhaps to understand it, to see what is the future of it, what will be the European future towards communism. Perhaps we are not so satisfied as the Americans are with our own explanations.

Would you say then that you believe that the essence of being Parisian in the sense of French culture and civilization is the universalism of French thought, the openness, the curiosity, the ever-seeking and constant doubt and examination, which is so French?

Well, yes, I would say more intellectual instability, which is a good thing.

Yes, and non-conformism?

Well, that would be pretentious to say so. I don't think the Americans are conformists, but we are more ill at ease, so we are seeking more, perhaps.

Jean-Jacques, would you care to say anything about Mendès and what you think the future of Mendès-France is in this country?

Well, as you say, David, I'm not his spokesman.

What's your opinion, your personal opinion?

These days, I have no opinion. And I don't think it's the problem of one man. I think the crisis now is much larger than the problem of one man.

It is indeed. Thank you very much, Jean-Jacques.

Mademoiselle de Paris, so chic, so elegant, the envy of every woman of fashion in the world, and yet, another Parisian paradox, you see more Paris gowns in New York or London, Rio or Berlin than you see in Paris. For the haute couture, one of the most important industries is mainly an export business, a big business, quietly, elegantly conducted, as the new fashions are shown to buyers from all over the world.

Good luck, peace. Numéro cinquante-cinq, suivez-moi. Number fifty-five, follow me.

This is the showroom of one of France's great fashion designers, one of the great designers of the world, Pierre Balmain. And the voice you've just heard calling the numbers in his latest collection is that of a great friend of mine. Her name is Ginette Spanier. If there's anybody who means Paris and is Paris through and through, it's Ginette.

Yes, David, I am Parisian through and through, and yet, you know, I feel completely English. And that's one of the joys of Paris, is that nobody seems to think it at all strange that one of the great French couture houses should have British directors with a British partner. I have a British passport. I've kept my British passport. I feel terribly British, and yet I feel completely Parisian with all that that name means.

And what does it mean to you, Ginette?

It means being able to work here easily, live as I feel like living, with great freedom of mind and spirit.

Thank you very much, Ginette. Ginette, do you think Pierre is in? I'm sure that he'd love to speak to you.

Oh, there he is, coming in at the door right now. Mr. Balmain, Mr. Balmain, would you like to come here for a minute, please?

Yes. Hello, David. How are you doing here today?

Well, Pierre, as usual, giving you some free publicity.

Oh, thank you very much.

Pierre, I'm here doing a show about Paris for the CBS Radio Workshop, and what I'm doing really is describing my Paris. It sounds funny for me to come here to tell you about my Paris, but really, Ginette and you, this wonderful, graceful house of yours, this is part of my Paris, too. And you, Pierre, one of the great figures of Paris, and I'd like to ask you a very simple and yet a very complicated question. Pierre, you're a Parisian. What does it mean to be a Parisian?

Well, you know, David, I wasn't born in Paris. I was born very far away in France, but in the Alps, in the mountains of Savoy. I had never been in Paris. I came to Paris for the first time when I was 19. I was coming to study at the École des Beaux-Arts to be an architect. That was my first contact with Paris, and fortunately, I was taken by some friends through the subway from the station to the Place de la Concorde at 8 o'clock at night. All the fountains had the lights on and the obelisks and the Arc de Triomphe in the distance. I stood in the middle of that square for the first time and I had tears in my eyes and I decided that I wanted to become a Parisian and I have never left Paris since that time.

Thank you for talking to us today, Pierre Balmain and Ginette Spanier.

Thus, the Paris of fashion, of politics, of children, well, it's only one of the Parises. There's the Paris of song. Certainly, no city in the world is the subject of as many songs as Paris. For Paris is a woman, eternal woman, beloved mistress of all men everywhere. Here is Paris seen through the rose-colored glasses of Edith Piaf.

And here is the Paris of Maurice Chevalier.

I love you, I love you, I love you with tenderness better than a mistress since the time we met. Paris, we never know to abandon, to blow our airs to London or to Cannes, the heart full of flames of love, of love, I have sung your women, I have sung your women, all in me is yours forever, is yours forever. All that remains to me, Paris, I love you, I love you, you speak of love.

And Jacqueline François.

Paris, Paris after dark. Paris at night, Paris, in the streets, in the courts, Paris waits, Paris at night, in a noise, a few million souls seeking rest, men, women, little beautiful hens, Paris always, the Paris of love, and that of sermons, the Paris of lovers.

A Parisian is someone who loves Paris and who loves life. By that definition, there must be hundreds of millions of Parisians in the world, for millions of visitors come here every year and most of them love Paris, as did their fathers and their grandfathers. For Paris, Paris has been a mecca of the western world for centuries. Not only for expatriates, but for patriots, for men who love their own countries best of all, but who found room in their hearts to love Paris too. Men from all walks of life, statesmen, writers and painters, businessmen, scientists and philosophers, all have found new inspiration here in Paris without ever losing their own originality, their own nationality. Picasso, the Spaniard, Modigliani, the Italian, Marie Curie, the Pole, Karl Marx and Lenin.

No more typically American novel has ever been written than James T. Farrell's Studs Lonigan. It was written here in Paris. Surely there's no more homespun American folk song than Home Sweet Home. It was composed here in Paris. And surely no greater American patriot ever loved his country more than Thomas Jefferson.

Well, the day that Thomas Jefferson left Paris, where he had been our ambassador, to return home to become President George Washington's Secretary of State, this is what Thomas Jefferson wrote in his diary. He said, "The hospitality of Paris is beyond anything I had conceived to be practicable in a large city. Their eminence too in science, the ease and vivacity of their conversation, give a charm to their society to be found nowhere else. Ask any traveled inhabitant of any nation, in what country on earth would you rather live? Certainly my own, with all my friends, my relations, and the earliest, sweetest affections and recollections of my life. Which would be your second choice? France."

Thus wrote Thomas Jefferson in the summer of 1789, just a few weeks after the storming of the Bastille, the birth of the French Revolution. Many other men have since echoed or paraphrased those words of Jefferson. Every man has two countries, his own and France. When you say France, you mean Paris. For Paris is the heart and soul of France.

You are listening to the great organ of Notre Dame Cathedral, Our Lady of Paris, and the music that thrills the souls of free men everywhere, La Marseillaise, here on this island of the Cité, where Paris was born more than 2,000 years ago. Here, where this 800-year-old cathedral stands, was once a temple. Before that, the shrine of a tribe called the Parisii, an obscure tribe who have lived in history by giving their name to this little island. Here, in the vast shadows of this great church, the men of the Terror during the Revolution tore down the crucifix, erected an altar to the God of Reason. Here, too, Napoleon crowned himself Emperor. And here, only 12 years ago this summer, as thousands of worshippers knelt in prayer, before the liberation of their beloved city, a German sniper fired from a lofty balcony, and panic swept the crowd as they sought cover. One man, the man they were aiming at, remained calm, quiet, and erect, a tall, thin, doer man, General Charles de Gaulle. His voice reverberated throughout this ancient temple, "Français debout! Frenchmen, up on your feet! Frenchmen, on your feet! The world needs you. The world loves you."

The world, I think, would indeed be a sorry place without France, without Paris. This is David Schoenbrun reporting from Paris, and returning you now to the CBS Radio Workshop in Hollywood.

You have been listening to the CBS Radio Workshop, which tonight has presented transcribed, Portrait of Paris by David Schoenbrun, CBS Paris correspondent. The CBS Radio Workshop is produced in Hollywood by William N. Robeson. Hugh Douglas speaking. Next week, at the same time, the workshop will present from New York, The Case of the White Kitten, a satire on modern mystery stories.

Interested in earning extra money easily? Let improved Series E bonds earn it for you now. Series E bonds earn more money in less time than ever before. And now they pay back four dollars for every three in less than ten years. You can hold your bonds ten additional years at the same high interest too. Stay tuned for five minutes of CBS News to be followed on most of these same stations by My Friend Irma.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑