The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 20 min to read
The Damon Runyon Theater. Once again, the Damon Runyon Theater brings you another story by the master storyteller, Damon Runyon. And this one, Lonely Heart. To tell it to you, here is Broadway.
Thanks. I believe that I once told you a story concerning Nicely-Nicely Jones, who likes to do nothing better than to eat. Well, this story happens before the other one I tell you, and it is what the newspapers and magazines like to call a spine-chiller. And they are right, because it puts an inch of frost on Nicely-Nicely's back. And how that happens, I will tell you in a minute.
Now, back to the Damon Runyon Theater and the famous story, Lonely Heart.
It seems that one spring day, I am sitting in Mindy's enjoying a bite of lunch, consisting of chicken and dumplings, hot biscuits, butter, pie, and coffee, when in walks Nicely-Nicely Jones. He speaks to me.
Hello, Broadway.
Nicely, well, how you doing?
Oh, Nicely-Nicely. Well, why are you so pale?
I just get out of the hospital.
You? How come I do not hear of it?
I am in a hospital in Brooklyn.
Oh, that accounts for the lack of news. But, um, what is wrong with you?
Pneumonia. The doctors there quote me odds of 100 to 1 against me finishing. But, here I am.
Yeah. You, uh, you look different, Nicely. How?
Well, I do not know. Just different. Like you have got something on your mind.
Ah, I have. Broadway, what have we got? Take me, for example. One racetrack after another. Hit and miss. Heavy feet one day, a bare bone the next. Why?
I never hear you speak like this before. What brings it on?
The hospital. You know, there I am, laying in the bed, lonesome, nobody comes to see me, because I have got no family. I have a lot of time for thinking. And you know what I think?
Want me to guess? The next day's entries at Belmont.
No. I am thinking about a home. A wife.
Huh? Nicely, I do not think you are over the pneumonia. Maybe you better go back and lie down some more.
No, my mind is made up. I am going to find myself a wife and a home.
Where?
I will scut around and take a look at the end. Maybe I will dig up a filly that answers the purpose.
I do not see Nicely-Nicely for a couple of days. Then, I am standing at the corner of 50th and Broadway, when I see a familiar figure, about 5'5" and weighing about 200. It is nobody else but Nicely. I catch up with him, and what happens is this.
Oh, Broadway, I am glad I run into you.
Hey, Nicely, you are all dressed up.
Broadway, I think I am going to meet my future wife.
You do not say. Then you find an entry.
Uh-huh. All the dolls I know will not think seriously of getting married to me. I am all right for maybe 10 minutes, even stretch it to a half hour when I am in the dough, but marriage, no. But you say you find somebody. Where? And who?
Well, one day I am rummaging through some old newspapers, looking for old racing forms, when I come across this.
That is not a racing form.
No. It is just a paper, but look, read this ad. "Widow of middle age, no children, cheerful companion, neat, excellent cook, owner of nice farm in Central New Jersey, wishes to meet a home-loving gentleman of not more than 50, who need not have money, but who will appreciate warm, tender companionship. Object matrimony, address Lonely Heart, this paper."
Nicely, you are going to follow this up.
Certainly. In fact, it is already followed up. But this is like walking down a subway track. You never know what you run into. Nevertheless, I am now on my way to meet her. I answer the ad, make arrangements, and here I am.
Here you are now. But where will you be later?
Sitting on a nice farm in Central New Jersey, appreciating warm, tender companionship and a pleasant home and good cooking. Oh, tell you what. Why not come along with me to Central New Jersey?
Certainly not. The lady cannot marry both of us. It would be dishonest. Now, come on and meet her.
Nicely has it no other way but that I tag along to meet the Judy he never sees before, but with whom he is going to enter matrimony. I do not mind because naturally I am more than somewhat curious to see what she looks like. Nicely-Nicely takes me to a little restaurant. We go inside and he says, "We arranged to meet at a booth in back. She says she will be wearing a blue hat." And there she is.
Oh, she looks like she is shading maybe 40. And she looks a little like a first baseman the Giants once had. But she is not bad looking.
No, she is not.
But but what?
I do not like her eyes.
Huh? What's the matter with them?
Well, from here they look kind of pale. In fact, those are the kind of eyes a bookie I know. They never change expression.
Please do not criticize a good cook that way.
Look, Nicely-Nicely, before it is too late, why not turn around and forget this? You get all the good food you want in Mindy's.
When I can pay for it, yeah. But that is not always.
Nicely, I tell you, I do not like her eyes.
You are prejudiced.
That could be. I tell you, this is my chance to settle down and make something of myself. Come on, Broadway, let's meet her.
I beg your pardon.
Yes.
I am Nicely-Nicely Jones. I take it that you—
That's right. I'm the widow Crumb.
Crumb?
That happened to be my last husband's name.
Oh, I see. Well. Sit down.
Sure. Maybe I'd better leave.
Oh, stay, Broadway.
Of course. Please stay.
Thanks. I pictured you different than you are.
Who, me?
No, me. That's right. You're heavier.
I am carrying a little extra weight.
You're nice looking.
Thanks. What do you do for a living?
Well, at present, I am unoccupied.
Have you got any money?
Money? I have to have money?
No, I've got enough. And my farm pays pretty good. Oh, that is very good. But I've got to make sure that you're the kind of man who won't get tired of farm life and run out and leave me alone. That happened to me once, and I wouldn't like for it to happen again.
Oh, I am very steady. Am I not, Broadway?
Well... Skip it.
Farm life isn't city life.
I guess not.
It's simple, plain, but we eat well.
You say you are a good cook.
I won five prizes at the county fairs for my fried chicken.
Will you marry me?
Are you sure you want to?
Yeah, sure.
Now, tell me one thing more.
Sure, what?
Do you believe in the return of a person after death?
Huh? Nicely. I will leave you here.
No, wait. Mrs. Crum... Mary.
Oh, yeah, sure. Mary, what do you mean by that question you ask?
Nothing. It's just that I'm very lonely. Do you know there are men who'd be willing to marry me to get my farm?
No.
Yes. Uh, why are you looking at me like that?
I'm making up my mind. This is a serious step. I'd hate to think I was making a mistake. I couldn't bear it again.
Well, maybe, maybe we better forget that we ever—
And I want someone to cook for. Someone who'd appreciate what I can do for him. Make him happy, feed him well. If I could find such a man, I'd stand over the stove 24 hours a day.
You would?
Yes.
Mary, I think you have got yourself such a man.
That is that. Nicely-Nicely is a sucker where food is concerned. And all he can see is the widow Crumb's fried chicken. I look at her eyes. And they are still pale. Never change expression. I do not like her. But the whole thing is Nicely's business.
Then I hear he marries her and they go to that farm in central New Jersey. And what happens there, I hear later. And it is like this.
Nicely, Harley is my hired man.
Oh, well, so this is a farm.
Do you like it?
Well, it is certainly out in the open.
Call me Mrs. Crumb?
Yes. And call me Mrs. Jones.
Oh, this him?
This is my husband. Nicely, this is Harley.
Fat, ain't he?
Say, one more crack like that and I'll put a button on top of your head with a bat.
Maybe you will, maybe you won't. Take our suitcases in, Harley. Then get back to work.
Sure, sure.
He ever work a farm, Mrs. Crumb? I mean, Jones?
No.
Who says anything about work? I've got to see about that. I've got something. Harley will take care of you nicely.
So you two got married, huh?
Yeah. Why?
Kind of different than the others.
What are you saying?
Nothing. Give me a hand with these suitcases.
Sure. Widow is a fine woman, a fine woman. She tells me she is a good cook.
I say something funny?
Nope, not at all.
Then why the laugh?
Well, it's just that sometimes what she cooks is mighty peculiar, mighty peculiar.
This way, Mr. Jones.
That seems like a funny thing for Harley to say, but Nicely thinks no more about it because that evening they sit down to eat, Harley, Nicely, and his new wife. Now, from what I hear later, the food is everything Nicely wishes. In fact, he never eats food like it before. There is one thing that worries him a little. And when Mary is out of the room, he speaks of it to Harley.
Harley, you say something?
Yeah, I wish to ask you a question.
Go ahead.
I noticed that there are only three of us that eat here tonight.
Yep.
I also noticed that there is another place set at the table next to her.
That's right.
I also observed that Mary fills up that plate like it is something special.
Yep. Give me the biscuits, will you?
Yeah. I wish to know. Oh, what is the idea of that extra plate that nobody uses, but which is filled up with such ever-loving care?
But ask her, if you dare.
Dare?
Yep.
Oh, well, I guess it is none of my business. Maybe it is just a habit that she doesn't have.
It might be, might be. Yep, that's it, a habit.
It is a very peculiar one.
Some people might think so, others might not.
Well, I am just thinking that maybe—
Finished eating already, Nicely?
Well, as a matter of fact, I am just thinking about another helping of fried chicken.
There's plenty of it.
Harley.
Hmm?
You all finished with the chores?
Just about.
Better get them finished then before it gets dark.
Huh? Oh, sure. Sure.
Like my cooking, Nicely?
Mary, in my book, it is one-two over anything I ever taste before.
I'm glad. I will have some more fried chicken.
I'll get some.
No, no. I will just take what is on this plate here.
Don't touch that.
Huh? But I just—
I said don't touch it. Leave it alone.
Okay, okay. I'll, I'll take it away.
Sure. Don't look like he wants it.
Huh? Who?
Nothing. Never mind.
Um, Mary, it is none of my business.
That's right. It ain't none of your business. I'll get you some more chicken.
No, never mind. You said you wanted some?
That is a couple of minutes ago. Funny thing. Seems that my appetite is not as good now as it is then.
So that is the story of Nicely-Nicely's first day with his new bride at her farm. It makes Nicely a little nervous, but not half as nervous as what comes later, which I will tell you about in a minute.
Back to the Damon Runyon Theater and the famous story, Lonely Heart.
Two weeks go by, and Nicely-Nicely forgets about that first evening, but he does not forget that at each meal there is that extra plate which nobody uses. And it is almost always filled with food which Mary throws away later. However, this does not bother Nicely too much because he never eats food as good as he gets there. Then it is one night after a real good meal. It is dark and Nicely and Mary sit on the front porch. Nicely rocks back and forth in a rocking chair.
Nicely.
Nicely.
Huh? Say something, Mary?
Yes. Will you do something for me?
Sure. Anything. Anything.
It's a kind of favor. What?
I want you to go to the city with me tomorrow.
New York?
No, not New York.
Is there another city someplace?
I want you to be examined for an insurance policy.
Examine?
Yes.
I am healthy.
But you may not always be.
I am expecting no trouble.
No, sure not. But you can never tell where you're here today or gone tomorrow.
You are expecting me to go someplace?
Sooner or later, we all have to.
Oh, Mary, I wish you would not talk like that.
I'm not getting any younger, Nicely. There'll come a day when I won't be able to work the farm.
We will hire somebody to help Harley then.
But I need protection.
Against what?
Against the day when I don't have you.
I never notice how dark it is out here.
It's nice though. Quiet. But still, sometimes I think I can almost see you.
Him?
Who?
Nobody. Nicely, you didn't say you'd go with me tomorrow.
So soon?
Never put off until tomorrow what you can do today.
Well, I... Look, Mary. You don't love me.
But I do.
No.
I do.
Then go with me.
Why?
All right, I will go with you.
What is that?
Harley! Harley, what are you doing?
Never put off until tomorrow what you can do today.
That'll be enough, Harley.
Sure, sure. That'll be enough. Just enough. I, uh... I think I will go inside. All of a sudden, it is very cold out here.
Well, Nicely, Nicely is insured like Mary was. Three months go by and Nicely is thinking what a wonderful life he lives. He does nothing but eat and sleep and the meals keep getting better all the time. Until Nicely is as fat as a goose and can hardly wobble. However, there is still one thing that worries him. And that is the extra plate at all meals. The best of everything goes on that plate. And after the meal, Mary always throws away what is on the plate. Then one day, Nicely takes himself down to where Harley is fixing the fence. And the scene is as follows.
Hello. I wish to speak to you for a couple of minutes.
Something wrong, Mr. Jones?
Oh, no, no, no. I merely wish to satisfy my curiosity about something.
Sure, sure. Sit down.
Yeah. On what?
On the ground.
It is slightly damp and I do not wish to endanger my health.
That is funny, Harley?
Don't mind a little dampness, Mr. Jones. You'll get used to it.
Huh? What are you talking about?
Nothing. But what did you come down here to talk about?
I noticed that at every meal there is a fourth place. I wish to know who that is for and why it gets the best of everything.
You ain't guessed, huh?
Look, Harley, before I tap your noggin for you, answer my question.
All right. Only don't tell her I said anything.
Why not?
She's kind of funny.
Never mind that. Who is the fourth plate for?
Jake.
Jake who?
Jake Crumb.
Crumb?
Yep.
I... I hear you say Jake Crumb?
That's right. And is that not the widow's name before it becomes Jones by reason of my marriage with her?
Sure. Jake was her last husband. Died three years ago.
Died? You mean that fourth place is for him?
Yep. Mary loved him pretty much. She was always sorry for what she did to him. She tries to make it up to him.
What... what does she do to him?
I ain't real sure, but I think it was poison.
What?
Damp or not damp, I have got to sit down.
Of course. Husband number one met with a real funny accident. A big 200-pound keystone fell on his head. Funny, too, because that keystone stayed up for a hundred years before he just happened to walk under it.
Husband number one? Then Ed Summers, he was number two, died from having a charcoal shot. He had a stove in his room. Coroner said it was awful dangerous. Put some kind of gas in the room. Sooner or later, you have got to stop talking like this. Numbers three and four, I kind of forget, but it was awful sudden.
What number am I?
Let me see now. I guess number six.
Yep, you're number six. Wonder what she'll think of for you.
You know all this, but you do not go to the cops?
Me? Ain't none of my business. Besides, I like it here.
I do not. Not anymore. I'm going to leave.
Leave me, Nicely? Why?
Mary. Howdy, Mrs. Jones. You'd better come to the house now, Nicely. Supper's ready. And tonight, there's a real special treat for you.
It is out in the middle of no place, and Nicely is caught. All the way back to the house, Nicely looks for a way out. But Mary watches him like a hawk. He knows he cannot run, because he is too fat by now to outrun anybody. He's thinking fast. Then he sits down to eat, but with practically no appetite. And he notices that Mary whispers something to Harley, who nods and disappears. And Harley does not sit down to eat. Then Mary fills that fourth plate.
That is a pretty good meal you are putting there.
Yes, it is. But why don't you eat, Nicely?
Me? Oh, I'm going to. I will wait for you to sit down.
I've got something to do in the kitchen. You go right ahead. Enjoy yourself.
Oh, enjoy myself. All this wonderful food, and I am afraid to eat it.
You say something to me, Nicely?
Huh? What?
I said, did you talk to me?
To you? I... No. No, no, I do not talk to you, Mary. You're not talking to Harley.
Oh, no. I... I am talking to Jake.
You... What did you say?
I say I am talking to Jake.
Jake? Jake who?
Why, nobody else but good old Jake Crumb, who finally joins us after all these weeks.
Where? Where? Where?
Why, no place else but at the plate you set for him.
You're lying. You... You don't see anybody. You don't.
Now, why do you say that, Mary? You know as well as I do that good old Jake is here. Else, why is there a plate for him?
Jake! Jake!
Mary, he is saying something to me.
What? What?
If you will be quiet, I will hear him. He speaks very soft.
Oh, you do not want to eat, Jake? But the food is very good indeed.
Is that so? Oh, but I do not believe that, Jake. It is impossible.
Nicely! What did he say? Tell me, what did he say?
He tells me some peculiar story about the food being poisoned, and he does not want to eat it.
Oh, it is all right. Now he is going to eat. He says he will eat like he does three years ago.
Yes, yes, but this food tonight, it's all right. Tell him it's all right.
Why should it not be? Jake, what is the matter, old man? Why do you look like that? What is it? What's the matter?
It is very peculiar. Good old Jake Crumb takes one bite of his food and falls off the chair. He is now lying on the floor at your feet.
Oh, my poor darling Jake. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I loved you, Jake. I don't know why I did it. I don't.
Mary, he is looking up at you and shaking his head.
Oh, no, no, no!
Operator, this is Nicely Jones, and I am speaking from the... Like I say, this is Nicely Jones, and I am speaking from the Widow Crumb's farm. I wish to speak to the cops, the police, the Army, the Navy, the Coast Guard, and a goodly portion of the Air Force. I need out of here real bad.
Now, that is not quite the end of the story. And what the payoff is, I will tell you in a minute.
One day, I am sitting in Mindy's, enjoying some lunch, when who comes in and sits down with me but Nicely, Nicely Jones? He fills me in on the story I tell you so far. Then he says, It takes 10 years off my life, Broadway. Also, it takes 50 pounds off someplace else. This I am able to understand. But what becomes of the Widow?
It seems she runs out that night and runs right into an old, open well. It seems that the cover is off, like she tells Harley it should be.
You mean you are supposed to walk into that well?
That is the general idea.
Oh, Nicely, you are a very lucky man.
I guess so. They take poor Harley away. It seems he has some loose boards in the attic and is not responsible.
Nicely, you have a terrible experience.
Terrible. But I come by $1,200, which I get for the farm because I am the widow's heir.
1,200 fish, well. And today, I bet it all on a horse.
Why?
Well, it is a hunch I play. Like the hunch I play when I pretend I am talking to Jake Crumb's ghost. I do not understand.
The horse's name is Apparition. Get it?
Oh, sure. Jake's ghost and Apparition. It is a good hunch. What happens?
Broadway, you cannot expect the same hunch to win two times in a row. Apparition loses. It seems like a person just cannot count on anything anymore.
And so ends the famous Damon Runyon story, Lonely Heart. Listen in again next week for... The Damon Runyon Theater.
The Damon Runyon Theater with John Brown as Broadway is directed by Richard Sandville and the story is adapted for radio by Russell Hughes. Vern Carstensen is in charge of production. This is a Mayfair production.
