Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Dark Fantasy artwork

From the Dark Fantasy collection

A Delicate Case of Murder

Episode 014February 20, 194225 min 19 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 15 min to read

I say, Winstead, will your wife be down shortly?

Yes. Laura promised a special seance for Miss Keaton here at two.

Yes, and I can hardly wait. I've always been so curious about things like this, but I've never attended a seance before.

Well, I assure you, Miss Keaton, you'll find it most fascinating. I've been watching Laura practice for almost five years. She makes more progress with every sitting. It's absolutely astounding what she can do. Isn't it, Winstead?

Yes, quite.

Oh, yes. She really didn't know she had the power, you know, until about 1937. Remember, Winstead, the penthouse party gave the beastly thing. Do you remember?

Yes, I remember very well. It was Quentin Ramsey.

Oh, yes, that's who it was. Ramsey had a mystic oracle board, you know, Ouija. No one could get the thing to work until they coaxed Laura to sit down and have a try.

And she made the board work?

Oh, indeed she did. All over the place. It was absolutely weird. She got messages from... Several of the guest's friends who had passed on some time ago. People she'd never heard of until that night.

How wonderful. She used the board for about a year and then found out she could get pencil messages.

Pencil messages?

Yes, she simply substituted the pencil for the little heart-shaped board with the icing glass window. Her messages came in more rapidly that way, more complete, and this method was less tiring for her.

You mean she actually contacts departed spirits that way?

I mean she did. But she gave up the writing method two years ago, didn't she, Winstead?

Yes, thank heavens. Every place I'd go, I'd find a paper simply covered with strange scratching and harebrained so-called messages.

What? Look here, old fellow. Do I detect a shade of sarcasm in your voice?

I dare say you do. I'm rather bored with the whole thing.

But why, Winstead?

Simply because it's all a lot of... Well, go on.

No, I wish she'd come on downstairs and get this thing over with. But, Rika, I urge you not to waste your time with this foolishness.

Foolishness? Now, look here, Winstead. You can't talk about your wife's work like that.

No, darling, really. I'm absolutely fascinated by it all. I can't wait for Mrs. Winstead to come down.

No, she'll be down in a moment.

I say, Winstead, really, I can't understand your attitude about Laura's work. Why, you used to enjoy watching her work immensely.

Yes, I used to love her immensely.

What? I say, does that mean that you...

Mr. Rodgers. Mr. Rodgers, you said a moment ago that Mrs. Winstead doesn't communicate by means of pencil writing any longer.

Why, no, she doesn't. After about a year of it, she undertook a profound and comprehensive study of spiritualism and communication with those who have left this level. In her study, she learned that those departed ones can sometimes make contact with us through the use of a medium's voice. Well, she began very slowly at first, lying relaxed on a couch, eyes closed, and eventually her contact began to use a Laura's own voice for their messages.

And that's what she'll do for us tonight?

That and more.

More? Oh, yes. You see, Miss Keaton, after Laura Winstead perfected her means of vocal communication with spirits, she continued her studies and experiments until she became able to bring about materialization.

You mean...

I mean, now we see the departed one with whom we commune.

Oh. Well, I really didn't expect that. I thought possibly a few table wrappings...

Oh, there'll be more than mere wrappings here tonight, Miss Keaton.

Oh, here's Laura now. Laura, dear.

Good evening. Or should I say good morning? It's after 2 a.m.

Yes, Laura. We've been waiting for you. Really, I think you could be more prompt.

Do you, Harvey? Well, perhaps you should hold the seances instead of me.

Now, Laura, there's really no reason for you to make a scene.

Oh, now, now, of course not. We're not here for a scene. It's for a seance.

Yes. Shall we begin, Laura?

Yes. Harvey, if this is going to bore you, I suggest you go into the library until we've finished.

No. I'll remain here.

Then I must ask you to assume the right attitude. You know we always have difficulty getting good contact whenever a disbeliever is present.

Oh, I'm sure Mr. Winstead believes, don't you, Harvey?

I'd rather ask that same question of you, Frederica.

We're finished here.

Oh, don't worry about me, Mrs. Winstead. I'm quite open-minded.

I'm sure you are, dear. Now, if we'll all gather around the table. Rogers, will you turn off the lights, please?

Oh, yes. Secondly. There we are. Now we'll all... Oh, what's that?

What's wrong? What's happened?

Oh, never mind, Laura. Frederica, are you all right?

Oh, yes. Yes, of course she is. I'm really missing my chair and bumped into... Oh, it was. So sorry, Miss Keaton.

Oh, I'm sorry, too. Please forgive me, but I was startled for a moment.

There, now. We're all settled. It was entirely my fault, Miss Keaton. I'm terribly sorry.

It's quite all right, Mr. Rogers. Is everyone quite ready?

Yes, Laura. All ready. Shall we begin any time now?

Harvey, we will begin when the opportune time arrives. Let me tell you once again that if you are impatient, it will be best that you will... Leave us.

Oh, no. No, Harvey, please don't go.

Don't worry. I have no intention of leaving. You please all join hands. Roger, give me your hand. Miss Keaton, yours, please. Now, now you two clasp hands with Mr. Winstead.

Yes, I understand.

Harvey, where's your hand?

Oh, oh, there it is. All set, Laura.

Now, whatever happens, no one is to break the contact. Is that perfect? Is that very clear? No one. We will soon make communication with one from another level.

Where will we see this?

I must ask you to be very quiet, Miss Keaton. No one is to speak. And when the materialization takes place, please do not utter a sound unless it addresses you personally.

We're gathered here to commune with whomsoever wishes to contact us. We've gathered with open minds. And with a unity of purpose. If there is someone who wishes to speak to us, or any one of us, will he or she please make herself known? Is someone seeking contact? Please knock twice for no, thrice for yes. Do you have a message for someone present? For me? For someone else who is present here? Through me? Do you wish to show yourself to us? Very well. We will await your arrival. And your appearance now, when you are ready to speak through me, please begin.

I hear you. I hear you. I see you. My mother. Saw her so plainly. It was my mother. I know it was. Harvey, did you see her?

Yes. I saw her.

Will you turn up the lights, Roger?

Yes, of course. Feeling all right, Laura?

Yes, quite all right. Thank you. Miss Keaton?

Yes. I... I saw her. I saw her. I saw her. I saw her. Yes, I... I suppose so. I... I don't know what to make of this. It's... It's all so wonderful.

I'd take it with a grain of salt, my dear. And try not to think too much about it.

Harvey! I'll not have you say such things. Miss Keaton, you've just seen and talked with your mother. You may do so again whenever you wish. And in case there's the slightest doubt in your mind, I can assure you that it was your mother.

Oh, yes. Yes, I'm sure it was, Mrs. Winstead. And as I say, it's... It's so wonderful. Tell me, why haven't I heard of your ability to do this before now?

Because, Miss Keaton, I permit no one to speak of it. I do not wish to become a public figure. I... I give sittings for my friends. I don't wish the world at large to know about my power. So I... I swear every newcomer to complete and absolute secrecy. I'm asking you for your assurance now.

You mean you don't want me to speak of it? You don't want me to speak of this to anyone?

Yes, that's what I mean. You must promise to speak to no one of what you have seen here tonight.

Very well, Mrs. Winstead. As you wish. I shall expect you to keep that promise. The séance has ended. I shall bid you all good night.

Now, Laura dear, won't you stay and talk for a while?

Thank you, no. I'm very tired, and it's almost three o'clock.

I'll see you to the stairs then, and then I must be going. Now, Winstead, old chap, I'll see you at the office tomorrow.

Very well. Thank you, Rogers. Good night, Miss Keaton.

Good night, Mr. Rogers. Here's Winstead.

Good night, my dear. Please come back again when you can.

Oh, thank you. I will. Good night, Laura. I'll run Frederica home. I'll be long shortly.

Yes, Harvey. Take your time, my dear. Now, whatever made me say that? I'm sure you will anyway. Good night.

Harvey, she's suspicious.

That I'm in love with you? How could she have found out?

I told her.

You did?

I had a clean breast of it to her. I told her it was no good she and I trying to continue to make a go of it. It didn't do a bit of good. She refuses to give me a divorce.

Oh. I'm really desperate, Frederica. I can't stand living with her another day. She, she's changed so. There's no love in her heart anymore. No warmth. She's suddenly become such a different person. Begging, sharp tongue, overbearing. Oh, poor. You do need someone to look after you.

She must neglect you terribly.

She does. I minded a lot at first. Believe me, Frederica. I was always in love with Laura. Now she's, she's so indifferent. Everything I try to do for her.

But why has she become so indifferent to you?

I stopped trying to explain that months ago.

You do love me, don't you, Frederica?

Oh, yes, dear. Of course I do. But we can't go on like this. With no solution in view.

But there must be a solution. There must be some way.

But there isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't. There isn't.

See? That's almost an exact image of my mother. Nothing but a papier-mâché face, painted to resemble an old lady, an old gray shawl and some old-style spectacles. How does it work? How did she make it appear?

Easily. Look, up above there, an almost invisible wire strung across the room. Laura simply releases an electrically controlled lock on this cabinet behind her chair. Since the invisible wire is placed at a single angle, the so-called spirit slips slowly out in front of those sitting at the table. Here, like this. Then Laura says whatever she wants to, changing her voice. When it's all over, she simply manipulates this cord on a pulley inside the cabinet. The image is returned to the cabinet.

Oh, then she merely tricked us.

Tricked you. I've known for years that Laura's nothing but a fraud.

You might have kept what you know to yourself, Harvey.

Oh, Mrs. Winstead. Laura, I asked you not to come here.

She insisted that since you extended the invitation, she was obliged to. I felt it only fair to show her that she'd been the victim of a hoax.

Oh, Harvey, please.

Never mind, Miss Keaton. I'm not in the least embarrassed. The apparition was a trick, yes. But I assure you, my dear, the voice was not.

Oh, of course it was, Laura. You know it.

Indeed, Harvey, my dear, there are many things between earth and heaven, that none of us know. There are many things that you don't know. Yes, I have used tricks at our meetings. I admit that. But not everything that has happened here has been trickery.

You'll have to convince me, Laura.

Harvey, I have a feeling. A feeling that someday, somehow, I will convince you. And that when I do, you'll never be able to scoff at me again.

We simply must settle this thing once and for all.

I can't see that there's anything to settle. You haven't the right to hold me like this, Laura. You don't love me. Why don't you give me my freedom?

Simple, Harvey. Because no woman likes to see another take her place.

And besides, it's so convenient being married to your income. You're the most selfish, the most self-centered woman I've ever met.

Am I, darling?

You certainly are. Laura, all I ask is a divorce. I'll see to it that you're well cared for financially.

No, Harvey. You're wasting your breath. I told you no yesterday. I say no again today. And I'll keep on saying no as long as I live.

Long as you live.

Oh, darling.

Yes?

Oh, Laura. How are you?

Excellent, Frederica. I'm driving out to Cliff Point. Won't you ride along with me? We'll be back by noon.

Oh, thank you so much. I... I would like the fresh air.

Then come along, Frederica. I need some company, and besides, I want to have a little talk with you.

Frederica!

Laura! Laura, stop! The car, for heaven's sakes!

Good heavens, Frederica! She'll be killed!

Here's your evening paper. Harvey Winstead's wife dead in plunge over Cliff Point. Two women forced off highway by unidentified truck driver. Mrs. Harvey Winstead killed instantly. Miss Frederica Keaton expected.

There you are, folks. Here's your evening paper.

How is she, doctor? How is Miss Keaton?

She's, uh, slightly improved, Mr. Winstead.

Thank heaven.

She's still in a very serious condition. She regained consciousness early this morning after a ten-day coma. She seems to recognize people, but something is wrong with Miss Keaton's nerve centers. For one thing, she can't use her voice.

An operation, perhaps?

Yes.

Oh, look here, it's none of my affair, really, but I know things have been going very badly for you lately. Losing your wife and all. You need some money, old man.

Oh, no, no. No, thanks. Thanks a lot, Rogers. My money's not completely gone. Yet.

Good news. Good news, Winstead.

Yes, Doctor?

The operation was a success. Believe me, I never dreamed it would require three operations to make Miss Keaton able to speak again.

She can talk?

Yes, after almost six months of silence.

Oh, that's splendid. When can I see her, Doctor?

Why, now, if you wish. Here, this way. Just a few minutes now. She's very weak.

Yes. Harvey, my dear. To hear your voice again. I thought I'd never speak to you again.

You must forget all that, darling. Get well soon, please. Because just as soon as you're strong enough, we'll be married, dearest. Just as I've always told you we'd be.

Wait a minute, Frederica. I want to carry my bride. Over the threshold.

Oh, sweetheart. Up you come, now. There we are. Now. There you are, Mrs. Winstead. In your new home at last. Now, how about a kiss from Mr. Winstead's new bride?

Harvey, you're always the fool, aren't you?

Frederica. Frederica, darling.

Oh, stop it. Stop it. You're so annoying, Harvey.

Frederica. Whatever's come over you.

You thought your problem was solved, didn't you? You thought sending me over the embankment to my death was the solution.

I don't understand.

Look at me. Whom do you see?

Frederica Keaton.

Yes, of course you do. But whose voice do you hear?

Laura.

You've been so stupid, Harvey. You hadn't even noticed.

It... Are you a believer now?

Laura. My wife.

You've heard A Delicate Case of Murder. The 14th original tale of Dark Fantasy. By Scott Bishop. Georgiana Cook was heard tonight as Laura Winstead. Ben Morris was Harvey Winstead. Eleanor Naylor-Coven played Frederica Keaton. Muir Hite was Rogers. And Fred Wayne was the doctor. Next Friday night at this same time, listen to the 15th unusual tale in this series of Dark Fantasy. Spawn of the Subhuman. In which the nation's favorite soprano star makes an airplane flight to an incredible destiny that awaits her at the end of the day. And that awaits her at the hands of a strange and mysterious madman. Tom Paxton speaking. Dark Fantasy comes to you from WKY Oklahoma City. This is the National Broadcasting Company.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑