The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 12 min to read
Now step into the incredible, amazing future as we go Exploring Tomorrow. And now here is your guide to these adventures of the mind, John Campbell, Jr. For many years, a lot of us have been interested in considering the possibilities of meeting other life forms, other intelligent beings from other stars. Now if there is life out there, some form of life, and remember it may be beyond our most... Far-fetched imaginations. If there is life, and we have our own Earth ships going out, in constant, regular deep space exploration, someday, somewhere, maybe even out in the gas cloud of the Crab Nebula, sometime we will meet. Step it up. Step it up the scanner. Maximum. Maximum magnification. Maximum mag. More, more. I'm sorry, sir. Max is max. You see? Can you see?
Bow visibly. Quarter it, quarter it. Quarter it, quarter it, sir. Step up the scanner. Step it up. Don't you understand? I've got to see. Nothing. According to the reading, Captain, nothing, sir. Sir, Captain, hold it. On the bow quarter. Huh? Solid object. 80,000 miles, sir. One o'clock. Unknown object changing. Changing. 12, 12 o'clock. Sound collision. Make ready, Mr. Dort. Mister? Nothing, sir. Now I see nothing on the busy place. But radio locator. Here, look at it, sir. Up and down, up and down. Something monstrous. Monster in size, sir. Making lunatic dashes toward us. At collision speeds. Then skipping away at the same fantastic speed. We are not a warship. Here it comes. There it goes away again. All on radio locate. On busy plate by eye, nothing. Can't detect a thing. How many solar systems in our galaxy? How many? How many planets fit for life?
And how many kinds of life could there be? If this ship isn't from Earth, and it isn't, it has a crew that isn't human. And things that aren't human but are up to the level of deep space travel in their civilization could mean anything. Yes, sir. Something like this has been talked about and speculated about for years. Mathematically, it's been an odds-on bet that somewhere in our galaxy there'd be another race with a civilization equal to or further advanced than ours. Nobody could ever guess where or when we'd meet them. It looks like we've done it now. Well, do you suppose they'll be friendly, Captain? Thank the Almighty for the blasters. Here they come in for us fast again, sir. Oh, pulling away again. Yes, I can read the beam. If you'll pardon, sir, the blasters are for me to ride, sir. They were never, were they, designed as space weapons? They can serve as pretty good ones. Because we don't know what they're like, you fool! And we can't take a chance. We can't trust them the fraction of an inch. Sure, I know. Let's try and find out all we can about them. Let's meet. Let's try to be friends.
For that ship out there, well, we don't. And you realize why? Because they have locators. Because they might trace us all the way back home without our knowing it. And we can't risk a non-human race knowing where Earth is unless we're sure of them. And how can we be sure? Do you know, Mr. Dort? Do you know, Mr. Dort, with your sentimental Pollyanna? Slush pile that calls itself your brain, your mind? Unidentified object retreating against our locator, sir. Back and forth. Back and forth the game goes on. They're afraid. We're afraid. Oh, sure. They could come to trade, of course. Import, export. That wouldn't hurt. Or maybe these creatures will be aesthetic marvels, nice and friendly and polite and underneath the Tojo type. Or am I going to risk the possible future of the human race on a guess that it's safe to trust them?
The one thing I won't risk is having them know how to find Earth. Either I know they can't follow me or I don't go home. Well, they'll probably feel the same way. Ready to ship for supplemental command. There, sir. By sight, on the busy plate. I see it. For the first time by eye. It's a small... No, sir. It's bigger and bigger. Bulb. Bulbous shape, like a pear. Headed for us at extremely high acceleration, sir. Hard about. Hard about, sir. Put us about. Put us about. He's crossing the T. George, pass me a relay. Put a relay key to the blasters. Direct to the blasters under my hand. This is the captain. Ready blasters. Exploring tomorrow continues in just a moment. All of us, as American citizens, believe in our inherent liberties and freedoms, such as the freedom of the individual to choose and elect his own national representatives. It has been said that there is only one ruling class in America.
the people themselves who, through their vote, have established the law of our land. The real importance of this freedom depends on our accepting the responsibility not only to know what we are voting for or against, but also to choose our leaders for the best interests of the nation. So, accept your responsibility and ensure your freedom. Two spaceships, two scientific expeditions. Each uncountable miles from their own home. One from Earth. One from... where? The other ship stopped, Captain. Cut power. Quite stationary, sir. Repeat. Stopped dead, sir. They are? Dead for sure. Have a look. How far do you make them? Range 20 miles, Captain. Now descending modulated shortwave at us, sir. Frequency modulated? Yes, sir. Yes, I see your needle. Apparently a signal.
Not enough power to do any harm. Look up in the left bow busy plate, sir. There's something now. I see movement on the outside of their hull. Their cold black hull. We shine like a mirror. Did you ever hear of a jet black spaceship, mister? We want to reflect the sun. Perhaps they... Want or need to absorb heat from a passing sun. I know. Now, what's that thing? Small, round, whatever it is, it's coming out of the side of the ship. Watch. Huh? You're dripping sweat on your instruments. I'm sorry, sir. Yes, I realize what they're up to. If they send anything toward us, it might seem a projectile or a bomb. So they come close, let out a lifeboat, and go away again. Figure we can send a boat or a man to make contact without risking our whole ship, too. Captain, that means... That means they think pretty much as we do. Yes, I'm glad that finally occurred to you. Mr. Dort, by law of space command, I'm not allowed to leave my ship except to jettison. Mr. Dort, this is not an order. No, sir?
Would you care to go out and look the thing over, whatever it is? The alien ship continued to retreat. 40, 80, 400 miles. It came to a stop and hung out there, waiting. Earthman Tommy Dort, climbing into his atomic-driven spacesuit inside the airlock, heard this mileage report and felt safer, but just a little bit safer. For if the unknown black space intruder had stopped its retreat at 400 miles, he reasoned it might not have weapons effective at a greater distance. But Tommy felt lonely and a little expendable, speeding toward that tiny black dot which hung in the incredible brightness of the star gas. 4,000 light years from his wife and family and home. Speeding toward that tiny black spot, the only solid object he could see in all this glowing space. And then it landed. It was a slightly distorted sphere, not much over six feet in diameter.
There were small tentacles or horns projecting from this black space, orange. They looked rather like the detonating horns of an old era submarine mine, where there was a glint of crystal at the tip of each. Then through his suit he began to feel vibrations. A section of the rounded hull beneath his feet opened up. He moved sideways fast. It opened up and out. And when he looked inside into the now open insides of the little sphere, No, he didn't see the first non-human civilized beings he expected. What he saw was simply a flat plate, and on that flat plate, a dim red glow of light came and went. Even inside the protection of his spaceship, Tom Dort felt the hairs on his neck rise and bristle. In momentary terror, he pressed his sleeve button switch communicator. Very good, Mr. Dort. Don't panic. It's your scanner to look into that plate. What's that? They dumped out a robot with an infrared visiplate for communication, that's all.
to personnel. SOB for them. What we might do would only damage the scenery. That's good. That means they value your life as you value yours. Ooh, with a spear. I'll send a visiplate off with a man to face one. You return to the ship. Yes, sir. But which way is the ship? Head straight away from the double star. A tiny, black, bulbous robot floated in space between two spaceships. Ours and theirs. It represented a culture. Theirs. Which was at least up to ours. Now our two races could be friends. We'd also be deadly enemies. We were a monstrous menace to them and they to us. And the only safe thing to do with a menace is, of course, to destroy it. This truce. Weeks and weeks. It started to get the crew. Mr. Dort. I'm busy. Still calculating, Captain. Let's see, where was I in thinking? How do we establish friendship without risk of treachery, hmm?
Friendship is based upon confidence. Or is it? Can confidence be established in a foundation of necessarily complete distrust? If you can be patient a bit longer, sir, I think... I think I've figured out a way we can talk their language. I mean communicate. Since they seem to be stone deaf. You can. I think, sir. You can. I believe now, sir, we can say almost anything we wish to them. and understand what they say back. But of course, sir, you'll never be able to know how much of what they say is the truth. Well, neither will they about us. Go on, mister. Well, I've managed to hook up what amounts to a mechanical translator. We showed them our recorder in the vision plates, and they showed us theirs. They record the FM direct, I think. Now, they don't use sound at all, even in speech. My guess is, sir, that they use microwaves for what you might call person-to-person conversation. I think they make shortwave trains as we make sounds.
Telepathy? Yes, sir. I think, sir, I'm ready if you are. If you are, that is prepared to talk with Skipper. Turn on your mechanical translator. What shall I say to them, George? What shall I say? They're waiting. They keep sending something like a CQ. They're oxygen breeders, sir, and they appear not too dissimilar in certain ways. I'm sure I detected signs of irony. Irony? I mean, sir, that implies humor. In other words, sir, I think they could be likable. All right. Send this. All right, sir. They're acting suspicious. All right. The appropriate things about this first contact, two dissimilar but civilized races.
and of my hopes that a friendly intercourse between the two peoples will result. Excuse me, sir. What appropriate things? Oh, just a second, sir. The skipper sent you the following, quote, That is all very well, but is there any way for us to let each other go home alive? I would be happy to hear of such a way if you can contrive one. At the moment, it seems to me that one of us must be killed. Unquote. All right, then. Send this. Look here out there, whoever you are. It looks like we have to fight and one batch of us gets killed. All right, we're ready if we have to. But if you win, we've got it fixed so you'll never find out where Earth is. And there's a good chance we'll get you anyhow. We've stayed here a month and we've swapped information and we don't hate each other. There's no reason for us to fight except to protect our races. Well, he says, sir. Yes, all you say is true.
but that his race has to be protected just as you feel that yours must be. He says, quote, perhaps this will help us to think clearly. Suppose we make it so we can't find each other's home planet, but leave a way to communicate in the future. So work out grounds for a common trust. If our governments want to be fools, let them. But we should give them the chance to make friends instead of starting a space war out of mutual panic. unquote. All right, I have it. Send this. Okay, sir. Whoever you are, let's swap spaceships. Send it! Send it! He answers. Interesting. What is rest of your swapping proposal? Send this. Swap ships and crews. I remove all star charts and anything else evidential. He removes all his navigational records. We train each other's key crewmen and I go for home with my crew and his ship. He goes for home with his crew and his ship. That's my proposal.
Tell him that's final. If he refuses, I'll... Hold on, please, sir. He says, accepted. He says, accepted. With one proviso that we arrange to meet here, at this star, Fitz, in exactly one astronom of the double star. Agreed. To us, that'll be a year. Send it. That any intelligent entity can, may. I wonder just what a lie is and... why it is that we expect intelligent entities to lie. Could a machine lie? Could an intelligent machine lie? Well, next time we have a discussion on that that I think you'll find interesting. It's called Liar. Join us for a fascinating adventure in Exploring Tomorrow. Heard in our cast tonight were Lon Clark and Lawson Zerbe. Script was by Murray Leinster, adapted by Peter Irving. Produced and directed by Sanford Marshall here in New York.
Bill Maher speaking. We pause now for station identification.
