Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
The Fred Allen Show artwork

From the The Fred Allen Show collection

Charlie McCarthy Sues Fred for Slander

EpisodeOctober 28, 194529 min 21 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 15 min to read

It isn't my Perkins, kiddies. The Fred Allen Show, with Fred's guests Edgar Bergen and Charlie McCarthy. And the biggest court trial of the year, Charlie McCarthy versus Fred Allen. Portland Hopper, Minerva Pius as Mrs. Nussbaum. The DeMarco sisters and Al Goodman and his orchestra. And for those who weren't at my christening, my name is Kenny Delmar. Well, this past week, the National Federation of Business and Professional Women's Clubs met to discuss the problem of post-war jobs for women. And so our question is, how do you think women will fit into the post-war business world? Shall we go? As one headache said to the other headache, let's take a powder. It's so quiet and restful here in Allen's Alley, Portland, but I can put a stop to that just by knocking on the senator's door. Somebody, I say, somebody knock.

Yes, I... Claghorn's the name. Senator Claghorn's the name. I know that. I'm from the south, way down south. Every week... Where I come from, when we say cotton, we don't mean no movie actor. Now, wait a minute. Look, don't butt in, son. Stop blabbing. I'm not trying to... Keep interrupting. Try listening. Listening, I mean. If I could only get a word. Don't give me no Gettysburg address, son. Now, look. Senator, slow down a minute, if you will, please. You've only two more years in office. What is your opinion... What is your opinion of women in the post-war business world? It's got... I say it's got us worried, son. Senator Glass is all broken up. Well, then you... Glass is broken. That's a joke, son. That's witty. Well, I know it's witty. I'm here. That's real southern humor. I sensed that it was real southern humor. I'll go down there and enjoy it some place.

You, uh, you ain't very quick, are you? Oh, now, look. Senator, what do you, as man to man, or as man to what I am, what do you think... What do you think about women going into business? I say let them go into business. Fine. Women can be politicians. Women can be bartenders. Bartenders, that is. A woman, a woman can even be president. Good. But there's one, I say there's one thing a woman... A woman can never be, son. A woman can never be? The father of our country. So long. So long. So long, that is. Well, the senator has an answer for everything, even before you ask him. Say, I wonder if Titus Moody is in tonight. Howdy, bub. Well, Mr. Moody, how do you feel about women working? Oh, some women overdo it, bub. Overdo the working? You're speaking from experience? Yep.

For 20 years, my wife's been raising chickens. And she's overdoing it? She's in the hen house morning, noon, and night. I see. One morning, the rooster was sick. Yes? My wife got up and crowed, so the hens would know the sun was coming up. Well, that is overdoing it, isn't it? Last week, my second hen got a dizzy spell and fell off the nest. Yes? My wife sat on the nest day and night till this morning. What happened? Have a cigar, Bob? A cigar?

I, uh, I'm a pupper. A pupper, eh? Ten of the prettiest Plymouth rocks I ever seen. Don't offset. Well, Mr. Moody, Mr. Moody owes me nine cigars. Well, I think I'll try this next door. Ah, Mrs. Nussbaum again. You were expecting maybe Dinah Schnorter?

Uh, not necessarily. Tell me, uh, tell me, Mrs. Ann, how do you feel about women working? On account of working, I am losing mine appeal. Your appeal, huh? How do you mean? When I'm 19, I'm having beautiful legs. You had beautiful limbs, huh? They are calling me the Dietrich of the Lancer Street. Uh-huh. Then I'm taking a job in an old girl orchestra. Not, uh, not Spitalny? Oh, no. No? and her Brownsville boogie-woogie babies. Good. I am playing the cello. Oh, the cello, huh? For five years, every night, I'm sitting between my knees, the cello. For five years. One night, I'm looking at my beautiful legs in the mirror. Yes. You mean the... I'm playing... Every day with your bow legs. Instead, Dietrich of the Lancer Street. Yes? They are calling me Long Nosebaum.

Well, here we are at the last house in the alley. I wonder if anyone's home here tonight. Oh, it's you again. Ah, McGee and McGee are songwriters. What's new, boys? We got a great mother song. It's a sensation. What is your mother song called? You remind me of my mother because you are my mother. Mother, oh, mother of mine. Now, wait a minute. You ought to write something for the senator, boys, when you get a chance. Look, fellas, tonight I'm down here in Allen's Alley getting reactions to women working. We got just the song you want. About women working, how does it go? Hit it, Tim. My grandma's working on the railroad. My mother drives a hack. My sister's helper to a sand hog. My aunt's a steeplejack, a steeplejack. My mother a low-key, but you won't hear me sigh. Cause I'll be leading the life of rye when I get my job.

And now, and now from the musically ridiculous McGee and McGee, we go to the melodic sublime, the five DeMarco sisters. With maestro Al Goodman safely atop his podium conducting, the kids sing California Sunbeam. So Al Goodman has just made a first payment on I'll Buy That Dream. It was hardly worth his while going to sleep to get so little music. Yes, Portland? Did Charlie McCarthy sue you last week? Did he sue me? Yes, Portland. My trial was bigger than the Dreyfus case. Dreyfus was there and told me himself through an old interpreter. What happened? Well, last Sunday, as you remember, Charlie McCarthy's lawyer served me with a subpoena. I got down to the courtroom even before the judge. And as I came in, I saw a mob of reporters around McCarthy. The reporters were saying... Gentlemen, gentlemen, please, one at a time.

One statement, Mr. McCarthy, please. Yeah, well, just tell the world I'm a poor defenseless lad looking to the court for justice. Not bad, Avery. Not bad, that's her. Poor defenseless lad. There won't be a dry eye in the joint here. So isn't this Fred Allen coming? Yeah, there's that swindler. I'll habeas his corpus. I'll mow him down. Now close that knothole you're talking through, McCarthy, or I'll pull your arms off and use them for chopsticks. Go peddle your margarine, baggy face. Now, quiet. Quiet. If I give you a hot throat from the knees down, you'll be charcoal. There, your father's mustache. There, your father's mustache. Quiet. Quiet. Quiet. The judge is coming into court. Hear ye. Hear ye. The court will rise. His Honor Judge McEaster.

Order in accord, order in accord. What's the first case? Charlie McCarthy versus Fred Allen. Here, let's get going. What's the charge? The plaintiff McCarthy claims that after he auditioned with Allen, the defendant Allen took the show alone, thereby swindling, mulking, bilking, and diddling said plaintiff out of his rightful share of the property. Ah, shut up. The plaintiff is suing for damage. He alleges... Ah, quite enough. McCarthy, take the stand. Yes, your honor. Are you the plaintiff? Yes, your honor. I'm Charlie McCarthy. Why, you're only a little kid. Yes, your honor. Just a poor defenseless lad looking to the court for justice. How they doing, Megan? Great. Is the defendant in court? That's the skunk over there. Now, who's the skunk? Why, you woodpecker's hors d'oeuvre. Your father's goatee. Your mother's sidebar. Order! Order! What do you think this is, a long showman's meeting?

I'm sorry, Your Honor. This big bully frightened me. Your Honor. Shut up, you. You ought to be ashamed of yourself. Chiseling this poor innocent kid out of his money. Your Honor, I... Quiet. You're guilty, Ellen. Guilty? You haven't even tried the case yet. Oh, yeah? It'll only take a minute, wise guy. Hey, kid, what happened? Well, Ellen... He gave me the Cornish hug. Why, that dirty sneak thief. Yes. Have you got any witnesses, kid? Yes, your honor. Ray Noble. Ray Noble in court. Yes, here I jolly well am and all that sort of judicial nonsense. Mr. Noble, where were you on the night of October 21st? Well, frankly, I don't recall, old prune. But while I have the floor, I would like to say a few words about continuing lend lease. Now. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object. I object Prostate, Ken. Ray? Yes, Charlie? Remember the night Miss Sneak Allen came over to our program? Why, that was the night I took out that debutante I met at the Automat. Yeah. Yes, we made a night of it. Ligets, you know, to all hours. And then a minuet or two at Roseland. And then we topped it off with a ride through Central Park at dawn.

Charlie, I put my arms around her. I object. Amazing. That's exactly what she did, old bun. I don't know why. Good work, Ray. Good work. Are you true with the witness, McCarty? Yes, your honor. You're a witness, Alan. Good. Now, Mr. Noble, isn't it true... Next witness. Next witness. I haven't even had a chance. One more blab out of your big mouth. One more blab and I'll throw you in the clink. I'm being railroaded. Why, you, if I had something on under this robe, I'd take it off and come down there. I dare you to. Quiet. I got a good mind to try putting me gravel in your mouth for size. Next witness. I guess, I guess that's me, Mr. Bergen. That's you. Yeah, the witness, the witness looks as if he's half asleep. Well, I just woke up. Where am I? You're in court. Oh, oh.

Well, guilty, Your Honor. You ain't on trial, stupid. What's your name? Well, it's, uh, well, the name is, uh, sort of caught me off my guard, I mean. Uh, Mortimer Snare, yeah. Yeah, raise your right hand. Yeah, the right, yeah, right, uh, which is, uh, I think the right, uh, well, point it out and I'll raise it. All right. You promise to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? No, sir, no, Mortimer, nobody's gonna trap me. I object. Your Honor, may I ask this witness just one question? Well, do you think you can handle him tonight? Let me at him, Judge. He's my meat. Mortimer Snurd, isn't it a fact that you are unfit to testify? Well... Isn't it common knowledge that you are a chowderhead? No. A moron junior grade? And a dehydrated nincompoop? Hey, Mr. Bergen, yeah, he's got me cornered there, isn't he? Judge, if this is a trial, quiet, pass...

Stand down, Snide. I did the best I could, Mr. Larkin. Yes, I know. He was just too quick for me. Nice going, Snide. This testimony's been pretty damaging, Alan. Before I sentence this fink, Mr. McCarty, how about you sum it up just for the record? Well, Your Honor, my story is the oft-told tale. The innocent youth led astray by the honeyed words of a chiseling lowlife... I object! Objection ignored! Trust things, kid. Thank you. I was happy. I had a kind friend in Mr. Bergen. And then this snake, this dirty... I object! Save your breath, Alan. Pour it on, kid. I arranged for us to meet a sponsor, and then this guy... And then, Your Honor, and then we auditioned. The sponsor said that this talking stump had absolutely no talent. So naturally, I got the job. Quiet, Alan, quiet! You got him in a hot seat, kid. Turn on the juice.

Humiliated, broken in spirits, I went back to my first and only friend, Mr. Bergen. Dear Charlie. Dear Edgar. Oh, this is ridiculous. I object. Order in the court. One more peep out of you, Alan, and I'm taking off this robe regardless. I dare you, Charlie. What damages are you asking, McCarty? Well, I was... You see, I was swindled out of the program. Yeah? And I was libeled and slandered. Yeah? My reputation was damaged beyond words and ground repair. How much do you want, kid? Well, would $14 be too much, Your Honor? $14? You got this jerk over a barrel. Take it around number 200 bucks. 200 bucks? Benedict Arnold got a fairer trial than this.

Order in accord. Alan, I'm fine and you're guilty. I'm awarding the kid 200 bucks. But, Your Honor... Yeah, 200 snackers, meathead. Get it out. Get it out. But, Judge, before you stands no hardened criminal, I have no record. As a boy in Boston, my father was known as Honest Fred. I was Honest Fred II. Honest Fred? And you say you come from Boston? Yes, Your Honor. Are you the little Fred Allen who used to live in the stable back at Paul Revere's house? Yes, Judge McKeister. Honest Fred, don't you recognize me? No, Judge. Wait, I'll take me toupee off. There. You know me now? Pinhead McKeister. Gosh, Pinhead, you a judge? Yeah, ain't it a laugh? Pinhead McKeister. Yeah, say, uh, say, Fred, about that money I still owe you. Oh, forget it, Pinhead. What's mine is yours.

Ah, Chief Fred, you're okay. Your Honor, I... Shut up, you little runt! You know, one more out-voice out of you, and I'll have you thawed up into dominoes. Don't look now, Bergen, but something happened to that 200 bucks on the... Judge, I have important evidence. Your Honor, I've been thinking perhaps this whole suit was too hasty. Let's forget the whole thing. No, he can't, Your Honor. He can't drop this case. I have a paper here, Judge. Oh, Fred, let bygones be bygones, huh? Come on, all together, huh? Should old acquaintance... Quiet! Go ahead on it, Fred. I will prove, Your Honor, I will prove, Your Honor, that Charlie McCarthy is not a poor defenseless lad. Charlie McCarthy is the most dangerous mind in America today. Should old acquaintance... Quiet! Quiet!

Mr. Bergen, did you know McCarthy was plotting a campaign to dominate the entire radio industry? Not little old me, no. Yes, little old subversive you. You don't know, Charlie McCarthy, that I found this document with your nefarious plan in your dressing room. Give me that paper, Charlie. Quiet. Quiet. Listen to this, Edgar, and I quote from Charlie McCarthy's secret white paper here. The Charlie McCarthy Radio Empire. Quiet, you monopolist. Go ahead, Fred, go ahead. From there, McCarthy was going to muscle in on the entire radio industry, Edgar. Listen to this lineup of radio shows he had planned. We the McCarthys, Young Dr. McCarthy, Charlie's Other Wife, One Man's McCarthy, Just Plain Charlie, McCarthy Faces Life, Breakfast with Charlie.

Edgar, it goes right down the line to news with Gabriel McCarthy. It's so lovely out, I think I'll take a ramble into Wildwood. Gangway! Grab him, grab him, Bayliss. Bring the little crumb here to the bar of justice. Your Honor, the Charlie McCarthy cartel is too big for this court. It's a case for the FBI. Not a federal rat, fellas. Don't call John Edgar. A foul, conniving fiend who would take over the entire radio industry, ruthlessly tramping all in his path? Dear Edgar, dear Mr. Bergen. Quiet, you monster. McCarthy, I'm holding you on federal charges of violating the Sherman Antitrust Act, violating the principles of the San Francisco Conference, and conspiring to start another war. Bergen, Alan, mercy, Judge. Mercy, mercy. Yeah, what'll I do with him, honest Fred? Give him life? Well, I'm not vindictive, Pinhead. Let Mr. Bergen decide his punishment. Okay. McCarthy, let this be a lesson to you.

I'm paroling you into custody of Mr. Boykin. Case dismissed. Thank you, Your Honor. Thank you, thank you. Now, Charlie, from now on, you're going to think of nothing but your schoolwork. Yes, sir. And you're going to respect your elders, always. And you're going to apologize to Mr. Allen. I'll apologize to that dirty rat. Why? I'll split you up the middle and make you a clothespin, young man. Father's mustache. Your grandmother's deal. You can't pull that stuff on me. Oh, wait a minute. Let him do it. I've got my water wings here. We'll be back again next week at the same time. This is the Armed Forces Radio Service.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑