The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 11 min to read
And the story of a man who moved with it. I'm that man, Matt Dillon, United States Marshal. The first man they look for and the last they want to meet. It's a chancery job, and it makes a man watchful. Go bring his horse over here, Benson. Sure, Jake. And wait till we get him up on his horse before you tie that rope to Val. There'd be too much slack otherwise. All right. We couldn't hang you very good with your feet touching the ground, could we, Tillman? No, Jake, you couldn't. We've been neighbors a long time, Tillman. If I could figure some way to make it easy for you, I'd do it. That's all right. You get to hanging, I couldn't put a bullet in you. I'd be beholden to you. Okay. I'll do it then. And would you drop by and tell my wife on your way home, Jay? Sure. I figured I'd do it anyway. You know, I've always liked you, Tillman. It's gotten too bad about this. You're mighty calm for a man with a noose around his neck. You man got your minds made up.
We can't have no men stealing horses around here. None of us feel safe less than we've caught them and hung them. I reckon I'd feel the same way, Jake. Well, of course you would. You'd hang me just as fast if I'd done it. I would. Only difference is, I'd want to be awful sure it was you that done it. Well, I'm sure. Heck, we caught you red-handed, didn't we? I told you a hundred times, I found them horses running wild. I was driving them back to you. Now, tell me, you was headed in the other direction. They got away from me. I was trying to turn them back. Except that we don't believe you. None of us do. Well, ask Jennings. He saw me rounding them up for you. Jennings ain't here. Well, why don't you find him? You can't take the time. You delay a hanging, the first thing you know, the man's got loose. You'd have just encouraged horse-feeding.
Like I said, you got your minds made up. We better protect ourselves, Tillman. Get his horse, Jake. Get him out of Tillman. Sure. Okay, Duval. Take off the slack and tie it off around the tree trunk. Look out there, Jake. Someone's coming. Yeah, so they are. Let's get this done. We might have trouble. He's a long way off yet. We got time. You want to slap his horse, Benson? No, you do it, Jake. Okay. So long, Tillman. I'm inside. No, thanks, ma'am. I'll stay out here. My husband ain't here, Jake. He's out on the prairie someplace. I know. Blade's around, though. You want to see him? No. No, I want to see you. Me? What about? About your husband, Miss Tillman. Something's happened to him. Well, it was like this, ma'am. You know, me and Duvall and Benson's been losing some horses lately. I heard. But Tillman ain't somehow.
And when we caught him driving a bunch of mine this afternoon, we figured it was him who's been stealing them. I don't believe it. My husband's an honest man. Oh, I know that. Now, Jennings saw him rounding them up where he found them running wild on the prairie. I guess whoever stole them got scared and left them there. Where is my husband, Jake? That's what I want to explain to you, ma'am. Jennings come and told us about it, but he got there too late. Too late. We'd already hung him. Well, Claib... Tell him what you've done, Jake. Done? Claib, we hung your old man this afternoon. You what? We hung him for stealing horses. They found out he didn't do it. After. Yeah. I guess the joke's on us, though, right? Ma, wait a minute. Ma? She's kind of upset, Claib. You better go with her. Somebody ought to kill you, Jake. No, don't talk like that.
I said we were sorry. Well, I got to go get home. It's getting kind of late, and my missus will have supper on. You're still bothered by the Tillman hanging, aren't you? He was lynched. Oh, lynched. But you'll never find out who did it. Now, that was nearly three weeks ago. I got a pretty good idea who did it. Who? Probably some of the ranchers out there who've been losing their horses. Benson, Duvall, and Kaiser in particular. Benson? I heard he got shot the other night, right in his own house. Yeah, I did. It was about a week ago. Maybe his conscience was bothering him, Miss. What do you mean? Well, maybe the other two killed him to keep him from talking. Anyway, you had it coming to him. It's still murder, Kitty. You feel worse about Tillman, don't you? You know, there's nothing I hate more than a lynching. You know, on Tillman, my guess is he was completely innocent. What about Mrs. Tillman and the boy? Do they have any ideas? Well, if they have, they didn't tell me.
You've done all you can, Matt. Might as well be in St. Louis. I'd like to be in St. Louis, Matt. Why don't you go, then? I guess I'm afraid of the dark. What are you talking about? Never mind, Matt. Matt! How about, Doc? Hello, Kitty. Sit down, Doc. Thank you, thank you. Say, Matt, that fella Duval. What about him? He's been shot, Matt. Shot dead. His hired hand brought him in. When did this happen? Early tonight, he said. You know what's the funny thing about that, man? Duval was shot through the window of his house with a .50 caliber rifle. I dug the bullet up. Just like Benson, huh? Yes. I thought it was kind of interesting himself. That makes Jake Kaiser the only one left, man. You think Jake did it? I don't know, Doc. He's been sitting right over there in the card game since noon. Huh? Oh.
He was gone for an hour, but he was there when I left, and he was there when I got back. He couldn't have done it in an hour, Matt. Look, Matt, he's leaving. I'll be back. Jake. Hello, Marshal. Let's sit down a minute, huh, Jake? I want to talk to you. Sure, Marshal. What's it about? Here's the table. Wait, you're not home. Jake, Paul was shot tonight. He was? Yeah. The same way Benson was. Same way, huh? You know anything about it? I'm beginning to, Marshal. It's that Tillman boy, Claib. I know it is. Why would he do it, King? Why, he's crazy. That's why. Marshal, I'll tell you. Claib has took it into his head that we hung this old man. How do you know he has? Well, I saw him right here in town this morning. And he was here last Saturday, too, come to think of it. You talked to him? Sure. And he keeps saying that we've done it. Don't you believe anything he says, nor Mrs. Tillman either, that they're both liars, Marshal.
I've known him a long time to be liars. Did Clay threaten you, Jake? Sure he did. You go arrest him, Marshal. There's not much evidence. I just told you, I know. You mean you ain't gonna arrest him? Not yet. He ain't gonna shoot me. I'm gonna go kill him on the way home. Right tonight. Jake, you're talking to a U.S. Marshal. All right, you do something about it. I will, but you get any ideas of shooting him out of your head? If you'll arrest him, I will. And don't you forget what liars they are out there. You leave that to me, Jake. You hear? Sure. But not for long, Marshal. Not for very dang long. Killed young Claib Tillman and it happened to occur to him again. Still, I couldn't arrest Claib for two murders just on Jake's word that Claib had threatened him. I needed a lot more evidence than that. And the only way of getting it I could think of was from Claib himself. So the next morning, Chester and I rode out to the Tillman place.
It was only about 15 miles from town when we got there early. Come on inside. Thank you. No problem. I'm looking for Claib. I'd like to talk to him. He's out back. He'll be here in a minute. Good. Mr. Tillman, Duvall was killed last night. All right. Several people have been murdered around here lately, Marshal. Including my husband. You think Benson and Duvall were in on that? I didn't say they were. What about Jake Kaiser? You're prying, Marshal. That's the trouble with the law. It's always prying. What do you want Claib for? I thought he might tell me what he knows. You won't. We don't know nothing. And Claib ain't shot nobody. He was in Dodge yesterday. Yeah, I know he was. I wouldn't put it past Jake to have shot Duval himself. I thought of that, too. You have any idea why he might have? No. Well, here's Claib now. Well, we got business. Hello, Claib. Marshal? Yes, sir.
All right, Clayton. You been hunting this morning? Nah. Put that rifle back where it belongs, son. Okay, Ma. I was shooting hawks with it yesterday. Left it in the barn. You should have brought it in last night, son. Sure, but... Well, it was dark when I got back, Ma. I didn't see it out there. I should have brought it in myself. What are you doing here, Marshal? Duval was murdered last night, Clayton. He was? Yeah, shot. Same as Benson. What do you know? Jake Kaiser thinks you did it. He does, huh? He also said that you threatened to kill him next. Maybe I ought to... Clay, don't talk like that. You know, there's a law against murder. They murdered my father. Where was the law then? I'd have him in jail right now if I knew who they were. Too bad you weren't there, Marshal. I could still arrest Jake. We don't know nothing about Jake, do we, son? No. No, we don't know nothing. Okay. Okay.
But you'll hang for murder if you kill him, Cleve. I just seen him, Mr. Dillon. Walking right up front street. Hello, Chester. Cleve. It's sad, isn't he? He's back in town, just like you said he'd be. Well, I wasn't too sure. Jake might have killed him during the week. It must have slipped his mind somehow. Well, I know what you're thinking. Cleve's gonna ride past Jake's place on his way home, ain't he? And the man's been killed each Saturday the last two weeks. It could happen again. You gonna stop him? Get our horses, Chester. We'll ride out to Jake's. Now? Hadn't we ordered a baller of clade when he... No, it's Jake. I want to keep an eye on him. Well, mine, I don't understand. Just get the horses, Chester. Yes, sir. And be sure there's a rope on my saddle. We gonna hang somebody? No. Now get going. Yes, sir. I wish I was a moon tonight. Better duck. Just out of the way of my rope. You want a rope, then? All right, Chester. All right, grab the rifle. I got it.
No. Stand up now, Mrs. Tillman. You shouldn't have stopped me, Marshal. It won't do any good. Two murders are enough, aren't they? I was saving Jake for the last. I wanted him to sweat, and I'll kill him yet. Who's out there? Marshal Dillon, Jake. Now, put that gun down. What's going on here? Mrs. Tillman. She wants to kill you, Jake. And if the shop's 50, I think I'd do it. Sure would. What? You killed Benson in Duval. And I'll kill you if I have to use a knife, Jake Kaiser. A woman going around killing people? Well, that's terrible. You hung my husband. I told you it was a mistake. I said we were sorry. That's what I've been waiting to hear. All right, get us gone, Chester. That's right. I got it. Mr. Tillman, you're both under arrest. Well, as long as Jake hangs, too. He'll hang.
But you will probably go to jail. What's Clemson? He knew about this when he found a rifle in your barn last week, but I guess he figured there was no way to stop you. You found the only way, Marshal. I guess maybe I should have told you everything from the first. Yeah, and it's too late now. Don't you feel bad about it, Marshal? I don't mind. I don't really mind at all. I know something, Mr. Tillman. It's the worst part of it. Come on, let's get back to Dutch.
