The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 20 min to read
The Jaws of Schlitz Brewing Company of Milwaukee, Wisconsin presents The Halls of Ivy, starring Mr. and Mrs. Ronald Coleman. When there's beer on your mind, your best thought is Schlitz, the beer that made Milwaukee famous. More people like the taste of Schlitz than any other beer. That's why Schlitz is the largest selling beer in America. Now, the halls of Ivy. Welcome again to Ivy. Ivy College, that is, in the town of Ivy, USA. For all the headaches of being the president of a college, Dr. William Todd Hunter Hall has achieved a full measure of contentment and peace. And now witness this peace and contentment this evening.
Dr. Hall entranced by the fingers of flame in his fireplace. Mrs. Hall profoundly absorbed in the book. There indeed is a portrait of tranquil, fruitful domesticity. Well, if you don't mind, darling, I think I'll... Please, Toddy, just a minute. I was only going to say that I think I'll turn in now. Good, good. I'm on the last page. Come on, darling, read it aloud or I'll fall asleep in my chair. Well, you won't know what it's all about. Well, that's the acid test of a mystery novel, Vicki. If I can't tell what it's all about in the last page, then you've been led wickedly astray by an unscrupulous author. I thought you never read murder stories. Oh, I once read them, but they're gross. But my very wholesale consumption of them defeated me. I acquired such a facility for spotting the culprit halfway through the book that the fun was gone.
I don't mind escape literature, but it should amuse or relax, not frustrate and annoy. I'm not being frustrated or annoyed. I'm loving every word of it. I'm sure I don't know whodunit. Simply lack of experience, my darling. When the element of surprise is identity, there can be only a limited number of suspects. My objection to the whodunit is the who. I've always preferred the howdunit or the whydunit. with their infinite possibilities. It's an easy thing to unmask the criminal, but to explore his motives, that is the challenge. Well, I don't want to be challenged, dear. I just want to be thoroughly frightened for 265 pages and then be able to say on page 266, well, who would have thought it was him? Uh, he. Oh, excuse me. Certainly not.
And now I must get to bed. I have to address the Student Honor Society tomorrow afternoon, and I must be my own flashing, concise, dynamic servant. It's difficult enough when I've had enough sleep, but when I've only... Company, at least, sir. Well, it's not late, but I hope whoever it is is a mere dropper in her, and not a hang-around-till-heaven-knows-when-I'm. Oh, good evening, Professor Warren. Didn't see another light on faculty row. Couldn't resist it, Dr. Hall. I'm the flying Dutchman of the campus, all sails set and no port in mind. I'm glad to have you aboard. Personally, I detest unannounced visitors, but I just got tired talking to myself. Good evening, Mrs. Hall. Why, Professor Warren, it is nice to see you. Thank you. And if you promise to throw me out in 15 minutes, I'll sit down. It's too late for social calls in dear old Ivy. Well, that was almost the first thing I discovered when I came here. People sleep nights.
I didn't when I was a student. I just went out and raised the devil. Best part of the curriculum, as I remember it. I can take a head mint, Professor. What'll you have? Not a thing, thanks. No, I finished my bacchanalian research years ago. Have to keep my reflexes on split-second timing at my age. Oh, you're the youngest man I know, Professor. Well, that's my considered opinion, too. But unfortunately, the Board of Governors doesn't consider age. Just the number of years. He just lopped off. Sixty-five and you're dead. Sheer murder, if you don't mind a sheer undergraduate expression. We were just passing a bloodless evening discussing the subject of murder on a whodunit level. And speaking of homicide, Professor, I hope you don't mind if I slaughter a few cherished misconceptions in my speech to your student honor society tomorrow. My honor society? Dr. Hall.
My being chosen as faculty chairman of that elite little group is one of the unanswerable questions of Ivy's history. We have nothing in common except complete mistrust of each other's opinions. As you will observe at the meeting tomorrow. Well, time's up. I'm off. Well, next time drop in for a longer visit. Perhaps some of your unorthodoxy will rub off on me. I feel I could use it now and then. Old roads are good, but... Sometimes they're the longest way around. Well, I've always said the difference between being in the groove and getting in a rut was just a matter of width. I wish he'd come over more often, Toddy. He's so outrageous and so honest. He is the last of the tobacco-jewing professors. He hasn't won a compromise in his entire constitution. Sort of older, but not wiser, Dr. Hall. Oh, nonsense, my dear. I'm a creature of compromise. Every president has to be.
Tomorrow, for instance, I would like to tell an exclusive society exactly what I think of intellectual snobbery. But that would be discriminating against merit. So instead, I'll season the usual phrases with my spicy murder theory of the how and the why instead of the who. You'll kill him, Doctor. Well, if I do, it'll be with a blunt instrument known as truth. The four students you have chosen as outstanding in achievement and promise should consider this honor as a responsibility. A responsibility to examine, in the privacy of their own hearts, the ways and means by which they earned their distinction. Success by itself is meaningless. It is exemplary only in the how and why it has been achieved. Thank you. Thank you, Dr. Hall.
Of course, you know you stole my thunder, so I'll skip my speech. It was full of cliches anyway. I'll just introduce the four elected candidates for future fame. A burden I wouldn't wish on my own children. First, the three seniors. Please stand and take your bow. Mr. Edward Tomlinson. Mr. John Nordstrom. And Mr. Paul Costello.
the first junior ever to be invited to the Honor Society, Miss Dale Anderson. Professor Warren, may I say something? You certainly may. Well, please, don't misunderstand me. I'm not ungrateful, and I want to thank the members of the Honor Society for choosing me, but I especially want to thank Dr. Hall for what he said. He made it clear to me that I can't accept this honor. What do you mean you can't accept it? Well, I just... It's a personal matter. I'm sorry. Well, how do you like that, Dr. Hall? She turned us down cold. Yes, and from what she said, it looks like I am to blame. I wonder why. Or is it how? Not so wrong. As we return to Ivy, it's after dinner, and Mrs. Hall is just opening the front door. Good evening, Mrs. Hall. Oh, good evening, Ms. Anderson. Come in. Thank you.
Dr. Hall wanted to see me. Yes, he's right here. Hello, Miss Anderson. Yes, I did want to see you. Since that slight furor you caused this afternoon, some people are full of surmises. After all, you were the first junior ever elected to the Honor Society, and this is the first time anyone has ever declined the honor. I wasn't trying to be conspicuous, Dr. Hall, but if I had accepted that honor, I'd have hated myself. Well, frankly, I was baffled when you thanked me for something I said which led you to your decision. You made me feel responsible. Oh, well, then you misunderstood me. Well, I thought perhaps you had misunderstood me. But that, it seems to me, clarifies the whole situation. Nobody understands anybody. So, let's start all over again. Well, no, I'm sure I understood Dr. Hall. He simply made plain to me something that's been bothering me for a long time. I should have realized right away that I couldn't accept.
Dr. Hall, I don't deserve any honors. You see, I cheated to get into Ivy. Oh, cheating is a crime one commits mostly against oneself. But why do you admit it now? Well, this afternoon when you asked us to consider how and why we accomplished what we have, I came up with a miserable answer. I wanted a college education desperately. I managed to get into Ivy and... More than two and a half years, I've been willing to let it go at that. I never felt that I'd hurt anybody. I made all my grades honestly. That wasn't enough, and I should have known better. Dale, not that I expect to use the information, but I'm curious to know how one goes about cheating one's way into Ivy. The standards are pretty high. Well, I had to quit high school at the end of my third year, Mrs. Hall. My cousin, who was in the same class, went on and graduated, but he didn't go to college.
So I used his credits, that's all. My cousin had the same name, Dale Anderson. Miss Anderson, you still haven't explained why you suddenly felt the necessity of making a clean breast of all this two and a half years later. I told you, Dr. Hall, I couldn't accept an honor I don't deserve. Yes, but from your record, it's quite evident that you earned your election to be on the society. Earned it fairly by virtue of superior grades. The only trouble is you never did properly qualify for Ivy, and that's a serious problem. I suppose that means I'll be expelled. Well, how can you be expelled when you haven't even matriculated? You're simply the victim of your own ingenuity. You got into Ivy, all right, but technically you're not in Ivy at all. Well, then technically, William, Dale's cousin, Dale, is already a junior at Ivy, even though he never came here. This is confusing. Where do we go from here?
Well, in the first place, I suggest we go to Dale's faculty advisor. Well, he shouldn't have any objections. Dale's record speaks for itself. Who is your faculty advisor, Dale? Oh, Professor Grosvenor. Oh, shh. I mean, he's a nice man, Grosvenor, though a bit on the sour side for me. I've heard rumors he was weaned on a pickle. Grosvenor is a man of great integrity. Also of great inflexibility. The paragon of protocol. A man who is so meticulous in his punctuation of a sentence that he forgets the meaning of it before he finishes it. I know he's very strict, Dr. Hall, but he's always been helpful. I'll go see him. Well, not yet, I think. We must consider strategy. Do you mind waiting until I formulate a campaign? No, not at all, Dr. Hall. This isn't a case which requires much defense. As the old saying goes, circumstances...
And rum runners alter cases. Oh, Todd, yes. Well, this case, anyway, this case just needs some clarification and a little understanding. Oh, thank you, Dr. Hall. And thanks to both of you for making sure I'll get some sleep tonight. Good night. Good night. Good night, Dale. You know, Todd, that's my kind of girl. She knows what she wants and she goes after it. She reminds me of myself. You, you, you didn't cheat to get into Ivy. You did it the hard way. You married me. Is substantially the story. Miss Anderson was enrolled in Ivy on her cousin's credentials. You know her fine record here, and however irregular this case may be, we are not dealing with just an ordinary student. I've asked you here, Professor Grosvenor, because you are the young lady's faculty advisor. And you, Professor Warren, well, I felt you were entitled to some explanation of her actions.
Well, as far as I'm concerned, Dr. Hall, she may have got in here by misrepresentation, but I'll let her represent Ivy's standards any time. We need a few more bright little crooks like her. Beyond facetiousness, the issue is not that simple, Professor Warren. It's true that Miss Anderson is an outstanding student, but as such, she sets an example. If we were to relax our regulations in her case, this would suggest that nobody need fulfill our requirements. The use of any kind of trickery to get registered is justified if you continue to pass your studies. That's a lot of sheep, Dick Grosvenor, and you know it. You're suggesting that we penalize the girl because she's good. And you're recommending that we acquit her because she's dishonest. You call her dishonest. I'd say she was in a hurry. I think anybody who can make the grade in college deserves to be there.
And anybody who admits taking an unethical shortcut is honest enough for me. That may be all right in principle, Professor Warren, but as Professor Governer points out, in practice, it could be dangerous. A bad president. Yes, yes, that is exactly my point, Dr. Hall. The credential system is so well established, it can easily withstand Professor Warren's nonconformist attacks. Who's attacking whom? I'm just proud that we got a girl like Dale Anderson at Ivy. I don't want to throw her out. Well, neither do I, Professor Warren. Well. And I'm sure that Professor Grosvenor is of the same opinion. We all want to keep her here. I'd like to suggest a solution. Obviously, we don't want the girl to go back to high school, but we can give her a second chance. Why not a special examination to qualify her properly? Well, I don't know. Now, that is a departure. What's the matter with that? We've got to have departures now, and the end of the world would be full of starving red cats.
Sounds like a good out to me. Dr. Hall, nobody denies Miss Anderson's qualifications as a student. But she already passed her entrance examination when she came here, so any other would be a waste of time. Well, I was speaking of a final high school examination, Professor Grosvenor. That's the only one that's lacking in Miss Anderson's record. Don't you think she deserves a chance to pass it now? Well, what's the matter, Grosvenor? You think you'll be committing a crime if you give the girl a break? Oh, shut up. Of course, there's no question about her passing yet, but I suppose this is the only procedure unless you expel her outright. This is still a circumvention of our rules. However, I will accept the decision of the examining board. Now, if you don't mind, I'm due with my class. Oh, yes, of course. And thank you, Professor Grosvenor, for taking time out to settle this affair.
I think that in this case, the most valuable examination Miss Anderson has taken was of her own character. As if more people would take a careful look at themselves, it would be a very good thing. Increased tremendously the sale of rose-colored glasses. Yes. Well, good day, gentlemen. Hi, Professor Warren. You busy, Doctor? No, no, come in. Say, have you taken a high school examination lately? Oh. Yes, that's right. Dale Anderson took a test this morning, didn't she? Professor Warren. Oh, well, I'm glad it's you. Don't be too sure. Why? What's the matter? Your husband had a brilliant idea. Which one? The high school examination for Dale Anderson. Oh, yeah. I thought that was rather neat. I gather from your long face that it wasn't such a good idea. What happened? She took it. The examining board got their list of questions.
From that pompous-ass Pomeroy down at Harvey High. I guess he figured this was his big chance to stump the experts. Well, don't tell me she didn't pass. Nobody seems to know. Yet, it all depends on how you look at it. She missed a lot of questions. Well, if she missed them, they must have been doped. The word is loaded, darling. Uh, were they, Professor? We'll see what you think. Here, wait a minute. Here they are. Meet the clock on this one. itemize the disposition of forces and list the squadron commanders in the Battle of Lepanto. Well, Lepanto was one of the most important battles in the Crusades. Now, the commanders, let me see. Oh, yes, yes, there was Don John of Austria. John of Austria's going to the war. It flags straining and the night blasts cold in the gloom black-purple, in the glint all gold.
Torchlight crimson on the copper kettledrums, then the tuckets, then the trumpets, then the cannon, and he comes, Don John, laughing in the brave beard curled. Isn't that cute? Well, I'm sorry, but nobody ever called G.K. Chesterton cute, but he's an old favorite of mine. Chesterton is not required reading in high school, and furthermore, you only mentioned one of the commanders. What about the others? And how many galleys in the Turkish fleet? And how many galleys in the leagues? Dr. Hall? How many? Do you know? Well, I'm a history professor. I'm supposed to know. Do you? Well, I missed on the number of galleys. Here's an easier one in mathematics. Now listen carefully. You're trying for $64.
When I am as old as my father is now, I shall be five times as old as my son is now. By then, my son will be eight years older than I am now. The combined ages of my father and myself are a hundred years. How old is my son? Now, let's see. Five times as old as he is. Eight years older. One hundred years, you say? Yes, a hundred years. All right, five times my son's age. Five S plus eight, and then to get the half is HF. Thirteen. Mrs. Hall. Vicki. I think it's thirteen. It is thirteen. But can you do algebra that quickly in your head? Oh, I don't do algebra. To me, pi is something you put on the table, not on the blackboard. I like it better that way myself. Thirteen, eh?
Well, of course, it's a well-known fact that intuition and apperception are factors in mathematic calculations. It explains the thinking process of a child prodigy. Oh, did that make me a child prodigy, Charlie? No, but it makes me very curious. Not about you, Vicki, I'm very proud of you, but about those questions. May I see them, Professor? Here, keep them. They only confirm some of my more passionate ideas about our conventional examination system. Well, at the moment, I'm more concerned about Dale Anderson. If she's really failed in enough of these questions, Professor Grosvenor will insist upon adherence to what he calls proper procedure. So, I guess I'd better proceed against Professor Grosvenor. Yes, I've heard about the examination, and I'm sorry, Dr. Hall. You can exercise your authority in this matter, of course, but I must remind you I was reluctant to take this step in the first place. The girl has been given a fair chance. Fair chance. Professor Grosvenor, may I ask you a couple of questions?
Of course. Would you describe for me, please, the behavior of the hydrogen ion in aqueous solutions and illustrate by giving five examples? Dr. Hall, you're not serious. Chemistry was never one of my best subjects. I know. I know. Your memory has failed you and so has mine on many of these questions. It could be very embarrassing if it ever got out that the head of the English department flunked a high school examination, couldn't it? Well, after all, they're trick questions. Ah, but they're not exactly trick questions. These subjects are covered in high school courses. With sufficient saturation and a little extra cribbing, they're answerable. Otherwise, nobody would ever get out of high school. Well, you know, Doctor Hall, I was never in favor of the high school examination idea. Yes, I know. I know. It was my idea, and I was wrong.
And it was extremely unfair to Miss Anderson. On the basis of my own score in this test, if she does not pass with flying colors, they'd better flunk me out of college. Any objections? John of Austria is shouting to the ships. Don John pounding from the slaughter-painted poop, purpling all the ocean like a bloody pirate's sloop, scarlet running over on the silvers and the golds, breaking of the hatches up and bursting of... Pardon, Miss Anderson, but thanks to you, I have rediscovered my old friend, Chesterton. Oh, that's a wonderful poem, Dr. Hall. It's the first time I've heard it. You haven't heard the half of it, Bale. I'm sure that whenever you want, Dr. Hall will gladly oblige. Ever since he was reminded of the Battle of Lepanto, Stone John has been marching up and down the living room and shouting to the ships. Also, Miss Anderson, thanks to you, I have discovered that I married a mathematical genius. Uh...
Well, Pardee, I didn't want to embarrass you while Professor Warren was here, but the fact is, whenever anybody asks me a mathematics question, I always say 13. I'm very attached to it. Of course, if this theory ever gets around, Einstein might yet wind up fiddling for square bounces. But, um, Dale, you took the examination, didn't you? Oh, yes, and I can't tell you how confused I was when I first saw it. Well, if you can keep a secret, it might be a sure you to know that certain prominent members of the faculty had even more trouble with the examination than you did. Yes, that's true. But at least you passed it, though it was a very narrow squeak. Oh, I was afraid of that. I could have used that year I missed in high school. Yeah, you're the first girl I ever heard of who graduated from high school in her third year at college.
Just imagine this whole thing arose from the discussion of mystery and murder. The hows and the whys. From this to my honor society talk and your own self-examination of the why and the how. I have to read more murder mysteries. I owe it to them. Well, there's probably a great lesson in all this, if I could only think of it. There may not be any great lesson, Vicki, but I think I may be permitted an observation. As long as this affair stemmed from murder and turned out happening, I might suggest that the difference between manslaughter and man's laughter is merely an apostrophe and a space, and that life requires some very careful proofreading. When there's beer on your mind, your best thought is Schlitz, the beer that made Milwaukee famous. More people like the taste of Schlitz than any other beer.
That's why Schlitz is the largest selling beer in America. Now here again are Mr. and Mrs. Ronald Coleman. Good night, everybody. We'll be seeing you next week at this same time at the Halls of Ivy starring Mr. and Mrs. Ronald Coleman. The other players were Gene Bates and Arthur Q. Bryant. Tonight's script was written by Barbara and Milton Merlin and Don Quinn. Music was composed and conducted by Henry Russell. The Halls of Ivy was created by Don Quinn, directed by Matt Wolfe, and presented by the Joseph Schmitz Brewing Company of Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Ken Carpenter speaking.
