The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 16 min to read
Good evening, priest. Tonight, your mystery playhouse presents Inner Sanctum. Mr. Holmes, the door. Good evening, friends of the Inner Sanctum. This is your host to welcome you through the squeaking door. What, sir? You're scared. Don't be afraid. Why, we've been beating our brains out to make things pleasant for you. Yes, take that fellow lying on the floor. Now, that's a nice guy, really, sir. He put a bullet through his head because he didn't want you to be bored. Oh, you don't like that pretty lady hanging from the chandelier. Well, we'll fix that. We'll cut her down and nail her to the wall. Then she'll be a pin-up girl. And now, friends, do whatever it is that you do when fear fastens cold fingers on your spine.
A cigarette, perhaps? Or a handkerchief, perhaps? Anything to brace you against tonight's tale of horror. It's an original radio play written especially for Inner Sanctum by Michael Sklar. And called Death is a Double Crosser. Our star tonight is Lawson Zerbe, who plays the part of Harry Smith, the murderer. I looked at the blood-splattered mallet still gripped in my hand and down at Marie's body. It was like coming out of a bad dream. Only to go into a nightmare. Instead of using a mallet to cut the King Midas diamond, I'd used it to murder my wife. And the big diamond was still in the vice. Still sparking in the light of the work lamp. Still tormenting me with the glow of its inner fires. The thing was evil. Anderson had warned me. It had been all bad ever since I came to his house. Through all those old New York brownstones. Big enough for several families, but only two people were living there when I came.
Anderson and my wife. Marie was working as his housekeeper and she gave him the land. He's about 70 years old, Harry. He lives all alone here. It's perfect for you. No family? No wife, no children, no friends. He never goes out except on business and no one ever comes to see him. Sounds good to me, Marie. Good. It's perfect. I'll tell him you just got out of the army. He won't ask questions. He'll never find out you were in prison. What did he do for a living? He's a diamond cutter. A diamond cutter. You don't say. He was famous, Juan. Diamonds. He doesn't cut little ones, Harry. Only the great big diamonds worth thousands of dollars. I moved in with Marie, and for a while everything was quiet. I didn't mind the quiet after that five-year forgery rap and sing-sing. Then one day the peace and quiet ended. I met old Anderson on the steps going down the street. Good morning, Harry. Oh, hello, Mr. Anderson.
You look all excited. Some good news coming your way? I hope so, Harry. Of course, I can well afford to be idle, but it would be pleasant to work again. And it's nice to know that people still remember you. Is it a job? A wonderful job. If I get the assignment, I'm sure I'll get it. I wouldn't give it to anyone else. One of the largest diamonds in the world, the King Midas Stone, discovered last year in the Kimberley Fields, was purchased recently by Johnson, a multimillionaire. I'm on my way to his home. To discuss the cutting. Wow, good luck. I sure hope you get the job, Mr. Anderson. The next afternoon, Anderson invited me up to his workroom. On the bench was a square of black velvet covered by a white cloth. Something big was underneath that cloth. Anderson lifted it. For the first time, I saw the king Midas diamond. How do you think of it happening? For a second, I couldn't talk. The blood was pumping too fast. 215 carats. When I finished cutting...
It'll be reduced to 125. How much will it be worth? A diamond like that? You could get $100,000. Questions asked. Funny, it's kind of oily on the surface, but down inside it gleams like it's on fire. Does it frighten you? A moon like that does things to you. The story of great diamonds is a history of intrigue. You said something about cutting it. I'd have to study the King Midas until every detail of the task is clear in my mind. and just a few light blows of the mallet on the chisel, and the result will be a flawless diamond. How long will it take? I should say about two months, Harry. I went downstairs to Marie. One look at me and she knew something had happened. I told her my plan. If they catch you, they'll send you back to jail. They won't catch me. I've got it all figured out. This is our chance. He told me himself that the diamond will be worth a hundred grand when he's finished. Hundred grand? Yeah.
No more pots and pans and scrubbing floors. No more passing phony checks. We'll be set for life, Marie. How are you going to go about it? I'll wait until he's finished cutting the diamond. How will you know when he's finished? You'd have to know the exact time. If you waited too long, he might turn it over to the owner, Mr. Johnson. Then where would you be? Don't worry. I've got that figured out, too. You want to become a diamond cutter, Harry? If you'll teach me the work, Mr. Anderson, I promise it won't be any bother. All I want to do is watch you while you go about cutting the King Midas. Diamond cutters aren't made overnight. It takes a great deal of time. I spent 50 years learning the craft. Oh, please, Mr. Anderson. You don't know what this means to me. Yeah? All right, Harry. I'll let you watch me as I work. That's how it began. Every day for two months, I went upstairs and watched Anderson as he studied the King Midas diamond. Cleavage must take place along planes parallel to the octahedron faces of the crystal.
Step by step, he explained the job. How he would split it. Where he would place the notches so that the diamond would split along the exact lines he wanted. He went over every detail again and again and again. Finally, he cut the notches for the splitting. Slowly, carefully. And then he placed the diamond in the vice. He got out the chisel and the mallet and placed them on the workbench. It was like a wedding ceremony. I was on fire. I couldn't wait. Just a few taps with the mallet. Are you going to do it now? No. Tomorrow. Tomorrow. Tomorrow, tomorrow. He kept putting it off. I realized what it was. He was scared. He couldn't trust his unsteady hands. It hit me like a ton of brick. He was never going to cut that diamond. You're so smart. What are you going to do now? I'm going to cut the diamond myself. You? Yeah, me. I know how to do it. It's all set.
There's nothing to it. But what about Anderson? We don't need Anderson anymore. You mean... Yeah. But that's murder. So it's murder. They'll never pin it on us. I figured out a way to do it without leaving any trace behind. I went upstairs. Anderson was standing where I left him at the workbench. He was so lost in thought that he didn't hear us come in. Get it over with. I could do this if Anderson honest. Betty. Betty. Stop it. It's no use, Mr. Anderson. I don't... For mercy. He fought back, but it was useless. I had a firm grip on his neck, both hands, and he was an old man. I stayed tighter and tighter till his voice was cut off. His body stopped washing around. Held him like that a couple of seconds more for good measure. You can let go of him now.
He's dead, Harry. Imagine that. Blooded murder. Killing a harmless old man like Mr. Anderson, choking him to death. Doesn't that slay you? And all because of a piece of ice. Why, it makes me hot under the collar. And that cool cucumber, Harry Smith. I'll bet he gets so hot that he'll burn before he's through. Let's get back to Harry Smith and his charming wife. Such nice people. They killed old Anderson, the diamond cutter, to steal a piece of ice worth $100,000. And unless they have a lot of another kind of ice handy, they'll have to do something fast to get rid of the body. We carried Anderson's body down to the cellar and broke open the brick wall. Placing the old man's body behind it, we bricked it up again. Then we went through my plan. I wrote a suicide note. To whom it may concern.
I, Olaf Anderson, because I failed in the task of cutting the King Midas diamond, have decided to take my life. When this note is found, I will be dead. It was easy for me, a professional forger, to fake the suicide note in Anderson's handwriting. I had him say he was going to end it all on the river and that he was taking the diamond with him to his death. And that night, Marie and I took a walk across the footpath over the Hudson River Bridge. When we reached the middle, I... You got the suicide note in Anderson's overcoat pocket? Yeah. No cars coming from either direction. Now's a good time to drop it. The cops will find the coat and figure that he took it off before he climbed the rail and jumped. All right. Come on, hurry. Let's get away from here. We went home. Marie telephoned police headquarters and asked for the missing persons bureau. I want to report a missing person. The man I work for, Olaf Anderson. Yes, Anderson. I'm his housekeeper.
And I'm worried because it's so late and he hasn't come home. My name? Mrs. Harry Smith. We went to bed. I guess we would hear from the police the next morning. And I was right. Yes, what is it? Megan is the name, lady. Detective Joe Megan, Missing Persons Bureau. Oh, yes, come in. Are you the party who reported a man named Olaf Anderson missing? Yes, did you... Did we find him? I think so. I'd like you folks to come down to the morgue with me. The mark? What for? They've got a body down there. Body of an old man that fits the description of Anderson. It was fished out of the Hudson River early this morning. You might be able to identify it. Now, folks, before I lift the sheet on this slab, I ought to warn you. This stiff ain't exactly pretty. We can stand a little shock, Megan. I just thought the lady... I'm all right. Okay, then. You recognize him? His face is gone like he... like he went through a meat chopper.
Most of his clothes were gone, too, when we got him. Cool guy must have got caught in the propeller of a passing ship. Hooray. It's Mr. Anderson. Harry. Don't you recognize the pants? They're from that old suit he always used to wear. Oh, yes. Yes, you're right. So you can identify him, eh? I'm sure that's Mr. Anderson. Well, I guess that closes the case. Body recovered. And a great big hunk of diamond at the bottom of the Hudson River. It was a lucky break for us. We were in the clear and the King Midas diamond was ours. We went back to the house. I took the diamond up to the work room and I placed it in the vice. I got out the mallet and the chisel. I thought it would be easy to cut the stone. Until I tried. Well, what are you waiting for? My hand is shaking. I'm kind of nervous. Things have been coming too fast. Let's put this off until tomorrow. I know I said I'd do it tonight, but... But what?
I don't feel so well tonight, Marie. You're lying. How long are you going to keep this up? I take it easy. You said you knew how to do it. I do. Well, then cut it. For heaven's sakes, get it over with. Don't rush me. If I make a mistake, it'll cost us $100,000. You've been putting it off for three days now, Harry. First this and then that. There's always something. You've always got a reason for not cutting that diamond. Listen, Marie, I've got to be careful. Knowing how to cut the diamond is one thing. Doing it is another. You're scared. That's what's the matter with you. Don't say that. You're frightened.
Look at your hands. See how they shake. Well, you can hardly hold the mallet and chisel. You're as bad as Anderson was. She was right. My hands were shaky, just like Anderson's before I killed him. I tried for control. I told myself the diamond was nothing but a chunk of carbon crystal. I placed the chisel against the stone. I raised the mallet, but I couldn't bring it down. Now what are you waiting for? I don't know how hard this strikes. A gentle blow. That's what you said Anderson told you. I, uh, I can't do it. You can't do it. Of course you can. You stupid fool. There's nothing to it. She went wild. She began to shake my arm and scream at me. But her voice seemed to come from a distance. I kept staring at that diamond as though I were hypnotized. My throat was dry as dust. I was dizzy. Pinpoints of fire shot across my eyes. The diamond was doing things to me and it was driving Marie crazy.
Suddenly I couldn't stand it. Her voice snapped something in my mind. You, you fool, you stupid idiot. Don't stand there like a silly fool. Shut up. Don't you dare shout at me. Shut up. I can take from you. Why, of all the nerve, you... I'm sorry. I lost my head. Marie, say something. He's dead. I killed him. I took her body down to the cellar, reopened the wall, placed her body with Anderson's. I'd hardly finished putting the bricks back into place when the front doorbell rang. Cleaned my hands, went upstairs and...
The detective. He came in, looked around suspiciously, and closed the door behind him. What's the matter with you, Smith? Me? Me? Sick? I never felt better in my life. It's the light. Is your wife at home? No, she isn't. Take her home soon? Why, no. No, she went to Baltimore to visit her mother. Left kind of suddenly, didn't she? What are you driving at, Megan? Take the chip off your shoulder. Nobody's picking on you. Yet. What do you mean? Is this Anderson's suicide? You said the case is closed. It's closed until this morning. Now, there's a couple of angles in the case that don't make sense. I'm not even sure that the old guy we pulled out of the river is Anderson. But I identified him. Sure you did. Yesterday, a guy named Keeler showed up at the morgue and swore that same body was his father. It must be Anderson's suicide note. Suicide note said Anderson was killing himself because he made a mistake and ruined the King Midas diamond. Red, don't you see? But Anderson never got the job of cutting that diamond. Hey, what?
Say that again. Anderson never was commissioned to cut the King Midas diamond. How do you like that? It can't be. He told me himself. I got that information straight from the owner, Mr. Johnson. I don't believe it. Johnson was out of town until this morning. I got in touch with him, making a routine check on the facts. He told me he never commissioned Anderson to cut the stone. Said Anderson was too old and unreliable to be trusted with the job. But I saw the diamond sawed on Anderson's workbench. The diamond you saw. Must have been a phony. A diamond. Still upstairs in the workroom. Still waiting to be cut. I couldn't believe it was a phony. I wouldn't believe it. It had to be the King Midas. Megan was getting more and more suspicious. I had to act fast before he got down to the cellar and noticed the fresh plaster on the wall. I had to make sure about the diamond. I'd gone too far now to back out. I hit Megan on the head with an and iron. It was unconscious.
I dragged his body into the closet and locked the door. Upstairs in the workroom, I grabbed up the chisel mallet. No time to think now, no time to be frightened. I had to know if that diamond was the King Midas. I put the edge of the chisel to one of the cleaving grooves, struck with the mallet. It is glass. Nathan was right. I blew all this for nothing. The whole thing was clear now. Anderson had lied to me. He had lied even to himself. Yeah, that was it. He had been unwilling to admit even to himself that he was no longer good enough to be trusted to cut the king Midas diamond. He was nuts. And he made up that crazy story. And I swallowed it. I had to get away. Far away as possible and as fast as I could. I ran upstairs. Going somewhere, Smith? Make it. Ice your hands. Get him a pile. I'll come on down here. That's close enough. How'd you get out of the closet?
No trick at all to force that door when I recovered from the crack in the head you gave me. That sock did something for me, Smith. You know, it gave me a brand new angle on this case. New angle? How's this? You thought Anderson had the King Midas diamonds. So you killed him for it. And planted that phony suicide note on the bridge. You know, we almost fell for it. No, I... You killed Anderson. Wouldn't be at all surprised if you murdered your wife. And all for a... a pony five and ten cents to a dime. Poor Harry Smith. What a life. A Smith caught between the hammer and the anvil. You know, he never should have lost his head and murdered his wife. No, because now it looks as though he's going to have to lose the rest of him. Yes, right now, Harry is really harried.
And when the state executioner gets him, he'll be fit to be tied in a noose. Well, thank you, Mr. Host, for an enjoyable performance in our mystery theater. This is Hunter Galloway saying good night. Sleep tight.
