Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Inner Sanctum Mysteries artwork

From the Inner Sanctum Mysteries collection

The Dead Laugh

Episode26 min 1 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 15 min to read

Tonight, your mystery playhouse invites you to listen to Inner Sanctum Mysteries. Come on out, Mr. Host. This is your host to welcome you through the squeaking door. Around for a nice case of murder? You have. And you've come to the right place because the characters on this program simply kill themselves to keep you amused. Why, only the other day we were accused of making murder our business. But we wouldn't do that, friend. Oh, no. Remixing business with pleasure. And we consider it a pleasure to give them to the business. Concerning a man, a woman, and a murder. You've heard it said that those who laugh, laugh. That it never pays to get into a laughing contest. I know he's dead. His body has been in the grave for weeks. Dead? Although I tell myself it's impossible. I can hear him laugh. Mocking, foul, and haunting. Same laugh I heard for the first time in the courtroom.

He had never laughed during all the weeks of the trial. Never even smiled. This day, when he came before me for sentence. John Spencer, you've been found guilty of murder in the first statement before sentence is imposed. I killed Hicks. I'm willing to admit it now. But he was no good. He got just what he deserved. And everybody knows it. I'm not a killer. I never committed a crime before. And all I ask now is a chance. John Spencer. The jury took all that into consideration when it recommended life imprisonment. You are to ignore that recommendation. It is my firm conviction that to allow one man to take the law into his own hands is to encourage others to do likewise. Override the recommendation of the jury and sentence you to be hung by the neck until dead. No. Judge, please. I've got a girl. We were going to be married. All I ask is to live so I can see her once in a while. You should have thought of that before you committed murder.

It's easy for you to tell me what I should have done. But you won't always be on top. Maybe someday you'll be down here where I am. When that happens, I hope they throw the book at you just like you're doing to me. Caleb, remove the prisoner. Won't I be laughing when that happens? Wherever I am, I'll be laughing. Same old story. Prisoner pleads innocent so guilty with good cause. Asks mercy. When clemency is refused, condemned man curses judge and hopes that judge will someday find himself in a similar plight. Spencer's outburst failed to move me in the slightest. I'd heard it many times before. I went home to forget about the Spencer case. I'll come in as soon as I've freshened up. I've been waiting here all day. Surely it's not too much to ask the judge. All right, all right, Laura, I'm coming. Richard, I want you to meet my new nurse, Margaret Cummings. This is Judge Thornton at Cummings. How do you do? Miss Cummings, haven't we met before? That's hardly likely. It's probably my fate.

It's so ordinary. On the contrary, Miss Cummings. I should say your face is rather unusual. Richard, suppose you stop that silly chatter about faces and talk to Miss Cummings about her duties. Very well. Come into my study, Miss Cummings. We can talk better there. Now, sit down, please. There's not much to say, really. In the first place, my wife's heart condition isn't really dangerous. Yes, I gathered that from Dr. Fletcher. Oh, he told you about my wife, eh? Oh, yes, yes. You're a professional person, nurse, and I believe in frankness. It makes things easier. My wife is 11 years my senior, getting on past middle age. She is a bit worried. Not that I give her any grounds for it. Jealous. You understand? Perfectly. She's not an easy person to get along with. You'll have to humor her. I'll do my best. And Miss Cummings? Yes.

I was just wondering where it was that I saw you before. Escapes me. You know, Miss Cummings, your face is rather haunting. That was how it began. We played a game during those first few weeks. I would ask, Miss Cummings. Don't you remember yet? No, I don't. Well, I do. And someday, if you're nice, I'll tell you. We would laugh together. Having the girl in the house made me feel young again. It didn't last. It ended one evening in Laura's room. Richard, put down that newspaper. I want to talk to you. I'm listening. Don't you think you're going a bit too far, Richard? Too far? What do you mean? I mean Miss Cummings. Oh. I won't stand for it. I won't allow you to disgrace me in my own home with a woman who's little more than a servant. Oh, Laura, for heaven's sake. I may be a bedridden invalid, but there is a limit. You're jumping to ridiculous conclusions, Laura. Ridiculous, am I?

I suppose you'll deny you're in love with Miss Cummings. That you've been carrying on with her right under my nose. Certainly I'll deny it. I've got eyes, Richard. I've seen you two whispering together. I've watched how you look at her. Oh, you're talking utter nonsense. There's nothing between me and Miss Cummings. Nothing? Nothing. Absolutely nothing. Well, then, I'll give you a chance to prove what you say. I don't want Miss Cummings here. Dismiss her. You want me to dismiss her? Yes, Richard. I do. Miss Cummings, I... This is going to be rather unpleasant. You see, my wife... Yes, I know. She wants me to leave. Yes. How did you know? I couldn't help overhearing the conversation. Well, then you also know why she wants you to leave. Yes. But you warned me when I first came here that she was jealous. It's been very pleasant having you here. Thank you. I'm going to miss you. Miss Cummings, could I have your home address? Of course. Why do you want it? I hope you won't think me presumptuous, but...

Well, perhaps we might be able to see each other. Would that be wise? No, it wouldn't be wise. But I might as well face it. I couldn't hide it from Laura, and now I can't hide it from myself. I love you, Miss Cummings. I heard Spencer's laugh for the first time since the day in the courtroom. I set it down as a picnic of the imagination born out of a feeling of guilt due to my disloyalty to Laura. I put it out of my mind. I had other things to think about. The slip of paper with Margaret Cummings' address on it was in my pocket. A dozen times during the next week I picked the telephone to call her, but something held me back. Fear, I guess. Fear that if I saw her again, I would be taking a final, irrevocable step. And then I couldn't stand it any longer without seeing her. I dialed her number. Is that you, Margaret? This is Richard. Judge Thornton. Little chance of that. Could I see you tonight, Margaret? I dressed carefully. Examining myself in the mirror, I saw a tall man, still on the right side of 50.

Still trim in figure and distinguished in appearance. When I got to Margaret's apartment, my heart was beating fast. Like a boy on his first date. Somehow, I don't know quite how it happened. She was in my arms. I was kissing her. Oh, no. We're being foolish. Sit down, darling. I guess. Mary, you can't be serious. I was never more in earnest in my life. Aren't you forgetting a little detail? No. I'm not forgetting about Laura. She has a weak heart. She may die. And if she does... I wouldn't count on it. Your wife takes very good care of herself. She may live to be a hundred. But if she should die, would you marry me? I don't know. It's not fair to ask me now. Not while your wife is still alive. Ask me later. I didn't go to the club, Laura. No? I lied to you. I spent the evening with Margaret Cummings. Rich! You were right. I'm in love with her. I never knew what love meant, but...

before. I can't live without her. You're mad. You don't know what you're saying. I want a divorce, Laura. Divorce? No. I want it immediately. You can't do this to me. Oh, my heart. What? Now see what you've done. Oh, chills, Richard. I knew she was pretending the heart attack to play on my sympathy. Laura's favorite trick that always worked before. Not this time. This time I was pretending until I was ready to act. Watched her take them and sink back in the pillow. Oh, thank you, Richard. Feel better now? Yes, dear, much better. I don't know what I'd have done without you here. I would have died. Oh, Richard, say you didn't mean what you said before. Don't you see I couldn't go on living without you? You won't have to, Laura. Then you won't leave me for that girl. I'll take care of you. Here, let me make you more comfortable. Pillow needs rearranging. Yes, it does. I'm fixing the pillow. I still have it twisting around.

Different from a heart. Please come quickly, Doctor. My wife has had a... It was nothing important, Doctor. Just a domestic quarrel. And suddenly she had the attack. I gave her the pills, but by that... Well, by that time it was too late. It's true. I'd only known that a condition had become so dangerous... Oh, Judge, you've nothing to reproach yourself for. These things happen. Will you take care of the formalities, Doctor? Oh, yes, of course. The death certificate? I'll list the cause as failure of the heart.

There was no need to act the part of the stricken husband after Dr. Fletcher left. I stood looking down at Laura's body. A Fletcher certificate would clear me of any suspicion of murder. Pray to Mary Margaret. I walked to Margaret's apartment that night. The street was dark. I had the uncomfortable feeling that I was being watched. Followed. Then I heard footsteps behind me. I hurried my pace. The man behind me did likewise. Frightened as I was, I decided to stop and confront the follower. He came toward me. His face and figure shadowy in the dark. Are you following me? You ought to know, Judge Thornton. Who are you? Come closer so I can... It can't be. You're dead. Dead am I? You ought to know, Judge... Now, take it easy, mister. Take it easy, then. Just tell me what happened. I was being followed, officer. So I turned around to see who it was. And did you see who it was? Yes. And that's why I fainted. The man following me was a dead man. He was a... What's that? The man following me is dead. I know he's dead, officer.

I ought to run you in. You're crazy. I had intended to tell Margaret that Laura was dead. I meant to ask her to marry me. But the encounter on the street drove those thoughts out of my mind. Arriving at her apartment, I went directly to the window and looked out. And there, across the street, leaning against the wall, I saw John Spencer. Richard, I'm insulted. What? You didn't kiss me. You haven't even said hello. I'm sorry, dear. That man across the street. He can't be real. And yet, if he isn't... What man, Richard? Don't you see him? No, there's no one across the street. He was there a moment ago. I turned my head to talk to you and now he's gone. Darling, you're trembling. You must be sick. Don't look at me like that. Richard, what's the matter? I... I guess I am sick. I'd better go and have a talk with Dr. Fletcher. You could have spared Spencer's life, but didn't.

And now you imagine that he follows you? Yes. But the man is dead. Then it was his ghost that followed me. His ghost I spoke to. His ghost that laughs. With one exception. The ghosts we carry about inside us. What do you mean? These things you hear and see, these are hallucinations, springs of guilt. Spencer's been dead for weeks. So the question is, why should you experience guilt feelings at this late date? I don't know. Well, psychiatry has an issue. Quite often, it's that one refuses to face the guilt object and transfers his guilt feelings to some other person. What are you driving at? I'm suggesting that your guilt feelings are not caused by the Spencer incident. And I'm going to ask you a blunt question. Did you murder your wife? Why, of all the idiots... Now, just a moment, Judge. I've been rather uneasy about the second bit of Thornton's death. But to yourself, I accepted what you told me that night. The superficial examination of the body did indicate some conclusion, yes, but...

but your wife's cardiac condition was mild. Now, your guilt feelings lead me to suspect... This murder talk is ridiculous. Were there any signs of struggle, any marks of violence? Of course not. Mrs. Thornton might have been suffocated. Oh, nonsense. I intend to recommend to the coroner that an autopsy be performed. An autopsy? It would determine whether or not death was due to suffocation. You should have no objection if I am mistaken. You meddling fool. Judge Thornton! Too far now to stop off my head. I should have agreed to the autopsy. That would have given me a day or two in which to plan my escape. But now, as things were, it would be only a matter of hours before Fletcher's body was discovered. My thoughts twisted and turned in panic. I ran. Ran like a frightened child. I needed help, and there was no one to turn to. Margaret. She loved me. She'd help me. I went to Margaret and told her what had happened. You killed your wife? For you. So we could be married. And then Dr. Fletcher... I had to kill him, Margaret. He was going to recommend an autopsy.

Why did you come here? We've got to run away. We still have an hour or two. But we could charter a plane to Canada or Mexico. What makes you think I'd run away with you? I thought you loved me. Don't be stupid. I'm going to turn you over to the police. Margaret, you can't mean... Can't I just watch me? Margaret, listen before you pick up that phone. Even if you don't love me, even if you won't go away with me, give me a chance. Have mercy. You make me laugh. Judge Thornton, who never gave anybody else a break, pleading for mercy, will turn around and ask the man behind you for mercy. Behind me? That's...

right. John Spencer. Take another look, Judge. No. No, you're not John Spencer. There's a resemblance, but you're not John Spencer. I'm his brother. No, the man that was following me. That's right. I was tricked, led on by Margaret to kill my wife, and forced by you to betray myself to Dr. Fletcher. But why? Why, Margaret? Why did you do this? For revenge. Revenge? Yes. The first day I came to your house, you thought my face was familiar. Well, now I'll tell you where it was that you first saw me. It was in the courtroom at John Spencer's trial. Courtroom. Yes. Yes. Yes. Remember how he begged for mercy? He told you he had a girl, that he was engaged to be married, and you could have given him his life. But you sentenced him to his death? Were you the girl? Yes. Spencer. Did he know about this? All this was his plan. His revenge. Want to report a murder? Yes, that's right, a murder. Tell them it's very important to get... I'm waiting now for...

for the police to come, for the trial, for the sentence which I know will be death. As I wait, my thoughts go back to the courtroom. Certainly misjudged Margaret Cummings, which was a grave mistake. Why, he didn't have the ghost of a chance with her. She double-crossed him right into the graveyard. A word of caution. If you must commit a murder, be sure to select the proper weapon. I suggest a sharp-edged axe. because it provides you with a handy alibi. When the police want to know why you did it, you can claim the killing was accidental. Well, good night and thank you, poison puss, for your inner sanctum story, tonight's performance in the Mystery Playhouse. Until next time, queet. Good night. Sleep tight.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑