The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 15 min to read
On the other side of the creaking door, this is your host to welcome you into the inner sanctum. Well, you may as well relax. Wipe the perspiration off your brow and listen. As the lads who dumped their victim into his own icebox remark, we'll chill you. Tonight's inner sanctum mystery, Death Rides a Riptide, was written by Lou Vittis and stars Arlene Blackburn in the role of Carol, with Lawson's Irby as John. Tonight, we're featuring a jovial little item about a girl named Carol Bain. She married a man whose first wife had been drowned. After a little while, she discovered that she herself was in hot water over her head. It's the night that John Bain has brought his new bride home. Home to the Cliff House above the ocean. Welcome. Cliff House is very beautiful, John.
Yes, it is. A bit lonely, perhaps. I could never be lonely with you. Oh, darling. Let's go in. All right, dear. Mmm, a bit musty. We'll get the place aired, though, first thing in the morning. How does it get this way after they've been shut up for a while? Of course they do. Oh, the place hasn't been opened since... Since... Since Margaret died, John? Yes. John, you mustn't be self-conscious about it. Well, it wasn't very tactful, my mentioning. John, I love you. Tax doesn't belong. I'm sorry. Darling, the hour's late and your husband... John! It's all right. It's someone with a very bad sense of humor throwing stones. That wasn't supposed to be funny. Son, you've got the stone. Yes. There's something wrapped around it. Paper. Let me see it. No, no, I wouldn't... Please, John. Well, I don't imagine I could keep it from you indefinitely. Keep what from me? Here's the stone. The paper.
It's a note addressed to me, John. It would be. It says, To the new Mrs. Vane. If you listen carefully, you can hear the waves beating against the cliff. The waves in which the first Mrs. Vane died. Did she fall? Or was she pushed? Listen. It... It isn't signed, John. No. You can hear the waves. Oh, I'm sorry. That's silly. But the note was so nasty. You're not to pay any attention to things like that note. You're not to pay any attention. I won't, John. I won't. Can we go to sleep now? Of course. It's true that Margaret was drowned, but it was an accident, wasn't it? Wasn't it, John? John fell asleep after a while. And the waves kept pounding against the rocks. I remembered having heard how badly she'd been bruised by the rocks. I remembered seeing her and John in the village.
And how beautiful she'd been. And how I'd envied her. And now, now after the waves and the rocks, she didn't care anymore. And before I could fall asleep, I envied her even now. That was a very fine dinner, darling. John. Yes? Exactly how did, did Margaret die? Carol, there's no point. I want to know. She was drowned. She was a good swimmer. Even good swimmers get drowned. What happened, John? I think you'd be wiser if you'd forget about Mark. All right. There's a beach below Cliff House. It's there at low tide only. A beach and a ledge. Nice place to swim from, the ledge, at low tide. But when the tide comes in, beach and ledge are covered. The tide's strong then, and there are rocks around. Margaret got caught by high tide. That's all. You mean she stayed down below on the ledge?
Longer than she should have. That's right. And... And that's all, John? What else should there be? I don't know. It's low tide now, isn't it? Yes. I'd like to look at that ledge. Why? Oh, because I'm silly. Because I'm a fool, but... John, I want to look at that ledge. There are steps leading down, aren't there? Yes, I had them built some years ago. Carol, we should go back to the house. This business is idiotic, morbid. But we're at the ledge now. The tide's down. The ledge is broad and safe, isn't it? It is. High tide, I suppose it would be covered. Yes. Cracks in the ledge. Seaweed caught in the cracks. From the time the ledge is covered by the water, I guess. And... What is it? This was wedged in one of the cracks. This? Oh. Yes, Charles. It's part of a heel. A woman's high heel.
So it is. Oh, the tide's rising. Let's go up. All right. Part of a woman's high heel. Caught in one of the cracks. John. Yes? Could it be from Margaret's shoe? I couldn't tell. Throw it away, or better yet, give it to me. Yes, of course. Here. Thank you. John, a woman was going swimming. She couldn't have been wearing high heels. We didn't speak on the way back from the ledge. And once back at the house, John sounded stuffy or something, I suppose. He muttered at me and went out into the night. The night that had become so suddenly of so intense a darkness. Who is he? You startled me, my dear. Hearing Mary Madowa, you know, for a moment I thought you were my niece. Your niece? Yes. You're not, of course. My niece is dead. Who are you? Jeremy Mangan, my dear. Mangan?
Mangan. Your predecessor, my dear, was named Margaret. Her father. Uncle. May I come in? For an elderly gentleman like myself, the night is cold. It's cold for me, too. Come in. Thank you. Where is dear John? He's out. Oh, too bad. I did want to see him. What about? Money. I hope I don't shock you by my frankness. He... Owes you money? No, but I think he'll give me some. Why? You're a crying little creature, aren't you? Why do you think John will give you money? My dear, I intend to sell John a letter. Sell him a letter? A letter written to me by my dearly beloved niece. Mark, why should John want to buy it? Let me read you a bit of it, shall I? All right. It isn't a letter, among other things. I...
Uncle, come for me. At once. I must get away from Cliff House. Because if I don't, I'm going to die. I'm afraid. Please don't think I'm making this up, but I'm going to die. I'm going to be killed. Well, I rather think that's enough, don't you? Why didn't you come in answer to a letter? She sent the letter out two months ago. Two months ago, I happened to be detained elsewhere. To be precise, I was... Momentarily in jail. I didn't get the letter which had been sent to my lodgings until this week. Tragic, hmm? John has nothing to be afraid of, whatever the letter says. My dear, I never suggested the ad. But I still feel he'll buy my letter from me. For old times' sake. How much? A couple of thousand will be enough. I'm not a grasping man. You saw John. Spoke to him as you've spoken to me.
He'd kill you. A habit of his? I'll get you the 2,000. Give me the letter. I'd be, my dear. Not that I don't trust you. Well, then. I'll be at the hotel in the village. Shall we say tomorrow afternoon? Tomorrow afternoon. Good night, my dear. Oh, it occurs to me. Am I likely to run into John? I don't know where he is. Ah, well, the night is dark. I dare say I met him. I did mention cash, didn't I? But, uh... It's my soul. You startled me. It's standing there at the edge of the cliff. I... Now, be careful. My mind, I... It's devil. I won't go over the cliff. No, no, no. Here we are. back again with Carol Vane, who married John Vane after his first wife had been drowned. Officially, it was an accident, but a lot of people feel that John believed in the old saying, cast your dead upon the water. At any rate, late one night, the drowned woman's uncle, a man named Mangan, visited Carol. He had a letter from the first Mrs. Vane in which she wrote of her impending murder.
Carol agreed to meet Mr. Mangan the next afternoon with some money. But long before then, somebody heaved Mr. Mangan over the edge of a cliff. Maybe for exercise? At any rate, it's the next morning at breakfast. Carol? Yes, John? You're upset about something. No, I'm not. Not really. When you went out last night, where did you go? For a walk. Why? Nothing. What's in the paper this morning? Oh, same old stuff. International criteria. John? Look at something else. Mangan, Margaret's uncle, Carol. Yes? What about him? It seems he fell off a cliff last night. Oh, John. He was wandering about in the dark. Was it near here? Oddly enough, yes. And they found his body this morning. John, did you... Did you see him last night? No, I haven't seen him for months. Why do you suppose he came here? I've no idea. Where... Where is he now? Probably at the morgue.
What they call them, Org. Finney's drugstore in the village. I... I think we should go down there. Why? Well, you knew him. He was your wife's uncle. I never liked him. Still, it would look better. Carol, what are you thinking? How his death... his accidental death fits. He was lying on a table in the back of Finney's drugstore. The fall hadn't marked him much. Nobody had gone through his things yet. So while Fanny and John and I stayed at the dead body, I gasped. Carol. I feel faint. Mr. Fanny, could you get me something? Of course, Mom. Be back in a minute. Oh, John. Oh, I just remembered. Tell Mr. Fanny not to get ammonia. I can't take it. But, all right. Mr. Fanny, could you get me something? I love my husband. So I went over to where the dead body lay and put my hands in his pocket. And I found him.
The letter. Carol, he fixed something. Here. Oh, thanks, John. You're white. Shaken. Maybe this stuff will help. Feel any better? A little. If we can leave now. Of course. Carol. Yes? What did you take from Langdon's dead body? I told him nothing. I lied. Later that evening, he went upstairs. There was a fire burning in the fireplace, and I threw the letter in. Carol, what's that? What? In the fireplace, that paper. Nothing, just waste. I think I'll take a look at it before it burns. Charlie, you don't. Carol, let go of me. No, John, I love you. I don't care. No, I want to get that paper. I don't want to hurt you, but I must get it. It's all burned, John. All but a tiny piece. A tiny piece of paper. The end of a letter. Signed, Margaret. A letter from my wife. My dead wife. I didn't want you to see it. Why?
Because she wrote silly things. What kind of silly things? I don't remember, John. You got the letter from Mangan after he was dead. How did you know he had the letter, Carol? I didn't know. You got rid of Fanny and me so you could get at Mangan. Carol, how did you know Mangan had a letter from my... from Margaret? He told me. Then he was here before he fell. Yes, John. Did he tell you what was in the letter? No. Did you read the letter before you burned it? No. Then why did you burn it? Because... Oh, because I was jealous. I still am. I have everything to do with Margaret. You loved her before you loved me. You're telling me the truth, Carol? Why should I lie about it, John? Why? It wasn't very good after that. John took the staying away from home. I saw very little of him. We avoided each other. Each of us for reasons we didn't dare speak of. It wasn't very good there in the cliff house above the ocean.
The ocean where Margaret Vane had died. And where Mangan had fallen to his death. I might have gone away. That would have been the safest thing of all for me. But I loved John. I hoped. And in hoping, I was betrayed. Yes, my beloved, John. Oh, I'm glad you're home, even though... Even though the hour is too late to be respectable? Oh, I don't care. There's a lot you don't care about, isn't there? I don't know what you... You put on quite an act, don't you? About not knowing. But you do know, don't you? I do know what? That my wife, excuse me, my first wife, was murdered. John. Yes, it's out now. It's been said now. Margaret was murdered. They don't have to whisper about it in the village anymore. I'll shout it out. I won't listen to you. You think that'll make it right, huh? It won't, my love. Because you see, the fishing boat Evangeline is back. Fishing boat? It's been away for three months. The men on board didn't know about Margaret's death.
They know now, and a couple of them remember something. What do they remember? Seeing Margaret on the ledge just before the tide turned. But it's... The trouble is they're prepared to swear that Margaret wasn't alone. John, that doesn't have to mean anything. Look at me, John. It doesn't mean anything. Carol, what was in that letter you burned? I didn't read it. John, you're hurting me. What was in that letter you burned? Oh, let me go. I'll tell you. Thank you. Margaret was afraid. I was afraid she was going to be murdered. Yes. I rather thought so. That was why Mangan had to die. John, I'm leaving. No, you're staying. Here, with me. You're the only wife I have left now. You're insane. Am I? That's a thought. Hadn't occurred to me before. I'll think about it. I won't stay. Why not? I'm afraid. Are you? Get away from my desk. No. You keep it as I have it now. You wouldn't shoot me. You love me. I do, John. But it's no good anymore.
I'm going away. You're mistaken. Don't come any closer to me. You're not going away. You're never going away, Carol. John, if you take another step, I'll... You what? Vibration. You did shoot after all. Come on. I didn't think you would. I told you not to come any closer to me. I underestimated you. I've always underestimated you. But Carol, when I am going to die, what will you tell her? The police. But I have to tell them that I shot you in self-defense. Of course, that would be your line. Not a bad one. It might have worked. It's the truth. Of course it is. But Carol, defending yourself against a murder charge isn't considered good motive for acquittal. What do you mean? I would have bought Mangan off because I was in love with you. Even though I knew that Mangan was murdered anyway. By you. Very consistent story. But Carol, You remember that shoe heel? Yes. High heel. Woman's shoe. You know where it is now? No. On the ledge down below. In the crack where it was before. And the police are going to examine that ledge once again. Now they've heard the story of the fishing boat people. It has nothing to do with me. Carol. Margaret never wore high heels. Never.
Something wrong with her feet. So the heel has to be. To be yours. My beloved murderess. Dead as Mangan. Dead as Margaret. And I? I. There was the ledge and the broken heel in the crack. A little item of unfinished business that I had to finish. Mangan was dead and the ladder burned. I was safe there. John was dead and his knowledge dead with him. I was safe there. The men on the fishing boat hadn't seen the second figure on the ledge. Clearly enough to identify, I was safe there. There remained only the heel broken off one of my shoes when I hit Margaret. And I'd get it before the police did. And I'd be safe there. The tide's coming in. The ledge is still above water. The ledge where my heel had been. But the heel, the heel wasn't there. Maybe I mistook the place. The ledge is broad. I began to hunt over it. There isn't too much time. The tide's coming in. The riptide that had battered Margaret against the rock.
Fundamentally a nice girl with a slight character defect. She killed people. Of course, her reasons were the finest. She only wanted to get married. Unfortunately, she never learned the old proverb. As you make your dead, so you must lie about it. She tried, but she was tripped by a heel. Incidentally, if you happen to be out fishing one of these fine evenings, and the tide's going out, say hello to Carol. We invite you to join us again next week at this time for Inner Sanctum. This is the United States Armed Forces Radio Service, the voice of information and education.
