Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Inner Sanctum Mysteries artwork

From the Inner Sanctum Mysteries collection

The Murder Prophet

Episode24 min 6 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 14 min to read

Sanctum Mysteries. Good evening, friends of the creaking door. This is your host to welcome you into the inner sanctum. Into a gay little world of homicidal maniacs, vampires, ghosts, werewolves, and assorted forms of sudden death. Friends, if you ever walk through a cemetery at midnight and see a girl whose hair is on fire, and who's carrying her head under her arm. You know what to tell her, don't you? Well, just say, uh, keep a cool head on your shoulder, Church, and run like crazy. All right, fellow ghoul. You know what's going to happen now, don't you? Hmm? That's right. You're going to scream your little heads off and love it. And let's hear our star, Agnes Moorhead, in the role of Claudia, tell us the story in her own words.

At exactly midnight, I saw him for the first time. My headlights picked him up when he hailed me along a lonely stretch of road near my home. I wouldn't have stopped. But the storm was so fierce, I felt sorry for him. I drew up to the side of the road. Thank you. Going far? No, not far. Where to? I'll let you know. Tombstone. Oh, there's a cemetery where I picked you up. Yes. Birch lawn. He said nothing for a few minutes. In the reflection of the dashboard light, I saw his face for the first time. Sunken eyes, hollow cheeks, mouth set in a queer grin, a skull barely covered with a thin layer of milk-white flesh. I realized he was staring at me. I've seen you before. I don't think we've met. I know you. Are you sure? Yes. I'd never forget someone so beautiful. You're Claudia Dale. Why, yes. You're married to Howard Dale.

Yes, that's right, but I don't seem to place you. No, you wouldn't. I know quite a lot about you. Your first husband was Willard Banks. How do you know that? He died eight years ago. A suicide. Who are you? You don't know me. Be careful, you're speeding. I'm sorry, I didn't realize. You're trembling. How do you know so much about me? I just know. Really? I suppose you have second sight or some such rubbish. It's not rubbish. Then tell me where I'm coming from. Pittsfield. You dare? Went there to visit a sick friend, Martha Wollstone. Couldn't guess that. Would you care to know more of yourself? No, I... I don't find your little trick particularly amusing. Besides, what else do you think you can tell me about myself? Your future? No. Your present husband is dead. Murdered. You'll find his body on the floor near the piano of your living room when you get home. There are two bullets in his head. Get off me! Carl, you hear me?

It happens that this is where I wanted to go. Good night, and thank you, Mrs. Dale. He vanished in the shadows on the side of the road. And then I noticed something white and shining queerly at the spot where he disappeared. I looked closely. It was another tombstone in another cemetery. I raced madly for home, fighting the hysteria that seized me. The nightlight was burning in the living room. Nothing he had said could be true. Howard would take me in his arms and kiss me when I stepped into the house. Somehow I managed to get my key in the lock. I ran into the living room. Behind you, I've got a gun. Get away from the body. Who are you? Keep quiet. Sit down. I said sit down. I had to slap you, but you were losing control. You don't have to scream for the police. Here's my badge. Detective Sergeant Quinn, homicide. Yes, I know. Here, drink this.

Who is he? You sure? About 20 hours ago? Four yesterday morning? No. One of the bullets went wild, hit that clock on the mantel. Where were you yesterday morning? I stayed with a sick friend, Martha Walstone. Look at these things. I took them out of his pocket. Are they all his? There were no rings. But he had... All right, now look. Oh, and did he wear it on the third finger of his left hand? Yes, there's a mark, but no ring. When did you come here? I drove in behind you. You left the front door open. I think I know who killed him. Who? A man I met on the road coming here. My husband had been murdered. He did? He even said his body would be near... Where did you see this guy? Oh, he came up on the road. Where? On cemetery. What's his name? Oh, I don't know, but he looked like a human cadaver, like a man who's dead. I never... Why did you kill your husband? You heard me.

Why did you go there? Were you there at four yesterday morning? Don't lie! Another scotch lady? No, thanks. Here. I'm leaving. Sit down, Mrs. Day. You? Yes. Won't you please sit down? Yes. Are they making it difficult? It's a nightmare. Who are you? I'll tell you later. Why'd you come here? To talk to you. I knew I'd find you here. Yes, you knew. You're not so skeptical now. No. What did you want to tell me? That you're the most beautiful woman I've ever seen. That I love you. I've loved you since I first saw you seven years ago when you came here to live with me. Is that why... Why I killed him? Is that what you were going to say? Yes. I'm not an ordinary man, Mrs. Dale, but I'm not a fool. This card, you'll find my name, address, and telephone number. Do you really believe I'd phone you? There'll come a time when you'll want love. Good night, Mrs. Dale. Hello, operator.

Get me a police headquarters. Hurry, please. That's him, Detective Quinn. That's Garth Dragman. Thank you, Mrs. Dale. Would you mind coming down to headquarters, Mr. Dragman? Not at all. Did she tell you I murdered her husband? Yes, as I thought she would. I didn't sleep a wink that night. Twice I got out of bed and drove to police headquarters. The lights were blazing in Quinn's office, but I didn't go in. The third time, I couldn't bear waiting. I went in. Oh, Mrs. Dale. Well? I'm glad you stopped by. We checked everything Dragman said. Seems he was in the same bar and grill where you met him tonight when your husband was killed. What about the things he said to me in the car? What about the murder before you were all right? I don't know. Perhaps he does have second sight. He's an odd-looking fellow, isn't he? But you can't arrest a man for murder because of that. He's criminally insane. I know he is. My dear Mrs. Taylor. He is. I know...

Oh, what's the use? I had loved Howard. I was determined to find the man who murdered him. I went to Garth Dragman's home. I was about to ring the doorbell when... Don't ring, Mrs. Dale. The door is open. You... You were expecting me? Yes. I was expecting you. Do you still think I killed your husband? I don't know what to think anymore. Do you want me to find the person who murdered him? Yes. More than anything in the world. I have strange gifts, Mrs. Dale. Your murderer for you. On one condition. What's that? That you marry me. I felt my body turn to ice. I knew I was talking to a man. I was sure I was talking to the man who had murdered my husband. Or maybe you think that Claudia doesn't have the courage to trap this idle Romeo. Well, we'll let our star Agnes Moorhead on the role of Claudia tell you. Go ahead, Claudia. Shock him into the...

Two weeks later, I married Garth Ragman. He was the strangest man I ever knew. He would disappear for days at a time and then suddenly turn up without warning. He had all the money he wanted, yet I never knew where it came from. There was a closet in his room which was always kept locked and bolted. I knew from the way he acted about it that the closet contained the answer to all the things I wanted to know about him. One night... While he was away, I obtained tools and tried to force the lock. Good evening, Claudia. You didn't expect me back, did you? No. I knew you'd try to open that closet someday. Why do you keep it locked? So that no one but me could know what's in there. Not even me? You in particular. But Bob. Don't attempt to open it again, will you, Claudia? Forgive me for striking you, but I'm not quite myself tonight. I sometimes do things I regret when these moods come upon me.

Yes, of course. It's something few people know, but a person who has extraordinary powers carries an extraordinary burden. You mean your gift of prophecy? Yes, yes. I didn't care to mention it. It seems to upset you so. It doesn't frighten me any longer. Did you read in the newspaper about a woman's body being found in the river? She'd been murdered. Yes, it was. In this evening's paper, they don't know who she is. I can tell you who she is. Josephine Ford, a stupid girl, Claudia. I could have told you three days ago that she'd be murdered. How do you know these things? Because I see them in a sort of vision. Just now, just now I'm seeing another vision. It's a house 346 Harbor Street down near the waterfront. A young woman lies in bed reading. She's very attractive.

In an hour, she'll be dead. And when the police come, they'll find her body decapitated. Garth. While you were gone, Martha Walstone telephoned. She's ill again. She asked me to come up immediately. Why didn't you go? I was waiting for you to get home before I left. You want to leave immediately? If you don't mind, it's really an emergency. It took only a few minutes to get to the waterfront. I found the house at 346 Harbor Street. I went in. The lamp in the bedroom was burning. I looked at the bed. I fainted. All right, Mrs. Dale. You think you can sit up now? Yes. I hardly expected to find you here. I came because Garth Dragman predicted this would happen. Now, Mrs. Dale. You still don't believe me. You're a strange woman, all right. You accuse this man of killing your husband, and then you marry him.

Now I suppose you're going to accuse him of this murder, too. Yes, this and heaven only knows how many others. Mrs. Dale, don't you realize that you haven't got a single piece of evidence to back up your contention? Well, I'll get the evidence tonight. Will you let me have a gun? No. Well, I'll need protection. Now, after all... What must I do to... I've risked my own life. Are you going to wait? I'll give it a try. I'll come back to your house with you. If you want me for an emergency. Smash the window pane. We drove back together. I dropped Detective Quinn on the corner. The house seemed deserted when I came in. I wasn't taking any chances. I went to the kitchen, got a knife, hid it in the folds of the long-sleeved gown I was wearing. I went into Garth's room. He wasn't there. The closet door was open. What I saw in there nearly made me ill. Clothes. Garth's clothes. Some of them bloodstained.

Forced myself. Then I found something that made my heart beat faster. A little jewelry case. I'll take that, Claudia. Give me that jewelry case, please. No, no, don't take it. Thank you. If I get away from that window, Claudia, do as I tell you. You were so anxious to see what's in that closet. Well, now you have. Sit down. Tell me who killed your husband. Now, you. I've written out a confession for you to sign. What will happen if I don't sign? I credited you with more imagination. Would you like to hear us? Please. Sit over here away from that window. I, Claudia Dale, murdered my first husband, Willard Banks, for his insurance by administering poison. My first husband? Yes, Claudia. I mean to make this document strong enough to send you to your death if I wish. I've got all the details here. Just how you murdered your first husband and how you killed your second. Shall... Shall I go on? No!

You know it's a lie. Will you sign it? Of course not. What is your game anyway? If you want to kill me, shoot. You've been very successful before. There's no reason why you shouldn't succeed again. Go on. Go on. Shoot. You put me in a very difficult position, Claudia. You see, you have found out certain things about me. Things that would cost me my life. I should prefer to see you live. Because I love you. But I shouldn't hesitate to murder you. You love me? Yes. Yet you haven't taken me in your arms once since I've known you. The right time hasn't arrived. And what do you consider the right time? When I feel that you understand me. When I feel that you, who murdered two men, would understand my deep and strange desires. You really believe I'm a murderer? Yes, and that's why I love you. Then the time is now.

The time to take me in your arms? He still held the gun. It wasn't more than two inches from me. I turned my lips up to him. I twisted my body to get out of the range of his revolver. When I felt his lips touch mine, I slowly let the knife slip into my hand. Slowly, caressingly, I drew my hand up toward his neck. Then I plunged the blade in. Human body, now do you believe me?

Realize that you as the district attorney must know all the facts. And there they are. Thank you. There are a few points in this story that interest me particularly. First, the confession that he asked you to sign. What about it? The confession says that you were not in Pittsfield at 4 a.m. when your husband was killed. That you gave your friend Martha Waldstone a sleeping pill, drove down here, shot your husband. Drove back to Pittsfield, turned Miss Wallstone's bedside clock to 4.15 and wakened her. Then you gave her some medicine to impress the time on her. She thought it was 4.15 and went back to sleep. Well, Garth was very clever at things like this. He had the extraordinary brilliance of the insane. Just one question. Was that the way that you murdered Howard Dale? I murdered him. The ring promised it. He never had the ring. You put it in the jewelry box. I see what you say. Garth was a homicide.

He predicted the death of the people he murdered. Mrs. Dragman, don't you know yet? Know what? Garth Dragman was a detective working out of my office. That's how he knew about those deaths. He was put on the case because we suspected you of murdering your first husband as well as your second. Yes. And you are going to die for killing him. It's extremely daring and clever of you to murder him. But you never would have gotten away with it if he hadn't kissed you. He kissed you because he fell in love with you. The poor fool. Well, friends, that just goes to prove you should never pick up hitchhikers who come out of cemeteries at night. I'll bet you've guessed the moral of our story. Well, it's taken from a famous quotation that Harry the Hangman uttered during a nightmare. Quote, Never steal the rings of people you murder.

On account of that's robbery. Friends, it's time once again to close that creaking door. Until next week at the same time when we'll be back with a little hunk of horror. You'll be sure to listen, won't you? Until next week then. Good night.

Inner Sanctum has come to you through the worldwide facilities of the United States Armed Forces Radio and Television Service.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑