The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 24 min to read
He inscribes the foibles of man in public performance. Many have tried to imitate him, but none can quite match the original. Capital City's Broadcasting Corporation presents Elizabeth Ribbon in A Conversation with Jack Benny. Sitting opposite you, I want to say, Bista Benny, or Hey Bub, or... so many of the lines of many of the characters that were with you on radio. And going back so many years through the different facets of show business that you've been in, what do you think about today's state with yourself in it? About today's what? The state of today's entertainment with yourself in it. Well, I think entertainment is fine all over. I like all the different facets, you know, of show business.
I like to be in every one of them, which I try to be in. As you know, I give concerts. So I've managed to get into every branch. I've had so much of radio and television that now I'd like to do other things and still have my finger in it just a little bit, you know? You know, Mr. Benny, there was a... Listen, you can call me Jack. Okay. And I'll call you Liz. All right. Or I'll call you Liz, you can call me Phillip. Either way, I don't care. Either way. Yeah, that doesn't make any difference. Okay, Jack. Or I can call you Liz, and you can call me Mr. Burton. I don't care anything you want. Okay, Jack, then. All right, Liz. There was a contest on your radio show some years back that said, Why I Hate Jack Benny. You know, you amazed me.
like we were talking one day, you go way back and remember everything. You look so young. You remember everything I've ever done. You remember better than I do. Well, I studied it. I didn't live. I really think I may have lived back there, but that's another matter. But there was this contest called Why I Hate Jack Benny. And the public was invited to send in and people wrote in because you were stingy and because you were not a good violin player. and you mistreated Rochester, and so many other things. And the winner, as I recall, that was reported in the newspapers, that won, said in poetry form, because he reminded me of myself. And I wonder if anything of this was included in your thinking, in your writer's thinking, in establishing the character that we've all known. Well, let me, can we talk a little bit about that subject, about the...
the contest. We were going to have a contest called why in 25 words or less, write why I hate Jack Benny. Then nobody liked the word hate, particularly it was during a war. So we were almost going to throw it out when suddenly we were going to give it up. The word hate, it's not a nice word. So finally, one of my writers. Came up and said, hey, I think I've got it. I said, what? I can't stand Jack Benny because. I said, this is it. Now, a lot of people were against it, you see, but I knew it was going to be good. It was right. Now, I can't stand a person. You know, you can love a person, you can't stand them, because they drive you crazy. And you wish they wouldn't, you know? So I said, I can't stand Jack Benny because. Now, that's better than I can hate.
So when the publicity came out, we were going to have the contest. Then radio critics, everybody thought, well, Jack finally put his foot in it. He should never have done that. And even some members of my cast said, Jack, I think you're making a big mistake. I said, no, I'm not. And this is one thing I'm sure of. It all depends how you get into it. Now, you see, if I said... on my program let's have a contest i can't stand jack benny that's contrived but when my fresh publicity man says hey benny i got a great idea for you you know some people like you some people don't some people hate you some people can't stand you why don't you have a contest i can't stand jack benny because i said now i'm supposed to be against that in the show i said no no we can't do it we can't do it and before i know it my publicity man has it out So at least it was against my will. Now we had this contest. And then the critics said I made a big mistake. I finally did the wrong thing. Well, in the side of three, four weeks, it became the most popular thing. We had to hire, I can't tell you how many people to get the letters. And thousands and thousands of letters came in. And I kept, you know, I was against this on every one of my following shows, apparently only, you know, on the show. But I loved it, of course. So we had this contact. We kept it going for weeks and weeks and weeks. And the mail kept coming in. And a lot of people thought that if they write wonderful things about me, that this is the kind of thing I wanted, which was wrong. I can't stand Jack Benny because he entertained, he was able to go out and entertain all the...
troops, you know, and a great American. And they thought this was going to win it. And that's not what I wanted. This was not clever. Some people thought, well, I'm a nice fella and I'm really charitable. They thought this was the fella that really won it. And God rest his soul, Fred Allen was one of the judges and the main judge. But the fella that won it lived right near Los Angeles. Pacific Palisades, strangely enough. And he won it by sending in the most beautiful poem. And the poem, I don't remember the poem, of course, but the idea of the poem was that Stingy, I'm so-and-so, I'm so-and-so, and he has the same fault and is ashamed to admit it. This is the interesting thing about the character of Jack Benny through vaudeville and radio and motion pictures and television and now the concert stage.
such as your performances here at Melody Fair, where you take a lot... Well, that's not a concert, Melody Fair. That's a big show. Well, I mean, yes. A concert is a different thing. Well, that's another area, too. But where you take some of the little old frailties of man, making fun of them, the vanity about the age. How did that start, about the 39 years? Because the 39 now is sort of a pivotal age. Yeah, well, I'll tell you how. This started... Like everything starts by an accident. When I was 36, I let that run for a little while. When I was 37, 38. Then when I got to 39, I thought 39 is a real funny number. That's the place to stop. Because when you get to be 40, then little kids think, hey, that's old. You know, when you were a little kid, you thought your mother and father were old. I thought 16 was old at one time. So we stuck at 39. Now.
This and we wouldn't get over that you see and to go over that and this became a great thing for many reasons It's a good thing from a humorous angle It's also a good thing from a serious angle. It makes people say well, I'm gonna stay young I'm gonna be 39 I'm not gonna get any older and I'm gonna keep young and I'm gonna work and I'm not gonna retire when I'm 65 Jack hasn't retired He remains 30 and he's gonna work. It's a wonderful thing It has proven to be a great thing through the United States and any place, even in England, Australia. Because when I was going to have a 40th birthday, really one, I got a lot of letters and editorials and newspapers begging me not to do this, and not comedy letters. These were really serious letters with editorials. We had one editorial this long.
telling me the mistake I'll be making, that it will be harmful almost. Well, it probably served as a great morale booster for people. It did. The other thing, too, you don't think in the past very much, do you? No, no. I don't care about the past at all. There's nothing, I don't get involved with anything nostalgic. I don't believe in it. I think that it can keep you, it can make you old. See, I wouldn't care, like, if you liked me on radio so much, let's say. Well, that's gone, you know? Or even on my past television shows. I'm much more interested, naturally, if the radio hadn't been good and the television hadn't been good, I wouldn't have been able to draw them in into a theater. So that, I'm glad of that, but I don't want to go back to it. I'm only interested in how good the audiences are right here at Melody.
Fair. You've been traveling around. Melody Fair. And how much business we're going to do? I'm really not financially crazy about how much business I'll do. I just want to see a packed house, you know? A lot of people must ask you why you do continue to work. You've had a television series for many years. You're going into television specials. Why do you work? You don't really need the money. I mean, other than, of course, the... the novelty included in your character of being stingy, you're not really in dire need of anything, are you? No. No, and I don't think I will ever be in dire need of anything. But let me tell you what you can do with money. In the first place, I don't need it. But why would I stop working? What would I do with myself? Really, if I didn't work, I'd be giving concert after concert, which I do for nothing. But let me tell you about money. Supposing...
I want to donate a lot of money for something, and donate a lot of money here. Supposing, you know, I love music. Supposing I want to donate my services and money for musicians, or for this, or for that, or for different charities. It's kind of nice to have all that money to be able to do it with, you see? Because I'm not as rich as a lot of actors, or as rich as a lot of people think I am, because I've always spent money, contrary to my characterization on television. I'm a terrific spender, and so is my wife, Mary. We both spend a fortune, you see. So the more money you can get, the more money you can give away, the more money you can help friends with, the relatives who need it. So it's always good to have a lot of money, as much money as you can possibly have, if you know what to do with the money. If you're just going to have all that money and keep it, you know, in a mythical vault or in your own vault, then...
Then it's ridiculous. With a man, a vault keeper who doesn't know what war is over. It is ridiculous to make a lot of money and do nothing with it. That's quite admirable in your position because many people would rather really hoard things and keep them within themselves. That's right, because I know some actors who are worth millions and millions and do nothing with it. They might be a little bit charitable, but they got money they'll never be able to use. And they've got enough money for their children, their grandchildren, and still money they'll never be able to use. Well, why not do something with it? What you have with music, in your concert series where you have gone with probably every major philharmonic but the Buffalo Philharmonic. Buffalo and Louisville, I missed. Well, we hope we get you here in Buffalo. When did this first happen? How did it come about? I'll tell you how and when. See, when I was a little kid, I studied the violin.
then i stopped when i was about 14. and i loved the violin even as a little kid but i wouldn't practice but i loved it and about 10 years ago and now i haven't touched the violin for years and years and years but at least if you could play once it's like riding a bicycle you can still ride it a little bit so we had the los angeles philharmonic orchestra as my guest on one of my shows in which just like We're having an interview now. This was part of a show where a lady reporter would ask me how it feels to be a comedian of some importance. So I tried to explain to her that rather than go out right now on the stage, because she was supposed to be my dressing room, to tell a joke, I would much rather be in Carnegie Hall and the thing fades into Carnegie Hall and there's a symphony orchestra and I come out in tails and I play some simple number.
Suddenly after that show, I went to my music arranger and I said, and to Mr. Fine, who was with me, my writers, I said, I've got a great idea. I'm going to give concerts with symphony orchestras. Well, they looked at me like I had eight heads. How? How are you going to suddenly move your fingers? I said, I don't know how, but I'm going to practice like mad. And I got the fiddle and I started to practice and I took lessons. And I practiced and practiced and practiced and got to love the violin more than ever. Every day. And the very first concert I gave about almost a year later was at Carnegie Hall with the symphony. And I stopped by on the way here to the university in which Sasha Schneider, Alexander Schneider, who...
conducts also for pablo casals that's how i met pablo casals to him is a very dear friend of mine and he has he's doing a marvelous job we had a man who just passed away in los angeles doing the same thing in which he rehearses with a lot of kids and they're giving concerts every night now this is a wonderful thing it's a wonderful thing to combat juvenile delinquency it's a wonderful thing to make good musicians out of children because they have a challenge by playing with other kids, you see. And I went there and I played with them, a number, because I can read, I'm a good fast, I'm a good sight reader, unless the number is too difficult, you see. So I played with them and I got a big kick out of them. In fact, they're all coming to my show Saturday at five o'clock, which I'm glad I thought of because...
I would like to mention, you don't mind if I do. Go, give a commercial. I want to mention, yes, this is my commercial. I want to mention that on Saturday, we're going to have two shows at the Melody Fair. Five o'clock and 9.30. What do you do between shows? I'll eat. Oh, I thought maybe you had, you know, a little job on the side for a few extra dollars. I'm going to do those two shows. And then Sunday, we're having a show. because we weren't going to have a show Sunday. Sometimes they don't have them. And Mr. Fisher felt that business was very, very big. A lot of people won't be able to come in, and therefore we should do a Sunday show. I said, if you think we should do it, we'll do it. Jack, when you go on tour, as you have been this past season, and in concert, do you find that your overexposure, some of your material perhaps, may have been overexposed? Do you have to constantly be on the lookout for new material? Well, yes, but you see, what I do in a concert hall... Because I was thinking in radio, well, of course, in vaudeville, you would do the same act all over. That's right. And in radio... Well, of course, since the advent of radio and television, you've got to change all the time. But in the concerts that I give, where I do talk also for about ten minutes, The material really practically just fits the concert. See, I don't use much of that. Very seldom do I use it in a theater. Only once in a while I might go into it, you know. The interesting thing, if you don't mind reminiscing with a little nostalgia, probably one of the most exciting moments in radio was your, quote, feud with Fred Allen.
How did this actually come about? Because it's a rather... Well... You were friends, were you not? Oh, we were very dear friends, always. We couldn't have had that feud if we weren't. That's right. And as a matter of fact, Fred Allen was probably the only comedian I could have had a successful feud with, you see. And this feud, when I play a number in the theater, I explain. This feud started by Fred Allen having a little boy. play a number, and then making derogatory remarks about my violin playing, knowing I was listening and knowing I'd laugh at him. And so then I answered him, he answered me, and we were into this feud for eight months before we even got in touch with each other and said, now let's alternate and be on each other's show. The first program that you were on together, according to some statistics, got as high a rating as...
President Roosevelt's fireside chats, or was a very close runner with it? No larger audience had ever been attentive to Radio 4. No, I think we had one of the largest audiences because, well, they were interested in that feud, you know. As a matter of fact, I made a picture with Fred Allen called Love Thy Neighbor, which was not really a real good picture. But because of this feud, this picture did tremendous business. You know, you had mentioned to me in an earlier, un-televised conversation about you were just ready to venture out in writing a book. Why had you waited so long to write, to chronicle really a career that has spanned all the areas and certainly been filled with them? I have promised publishers for the last 20 years or 25 years that I would write a book. But I dread going into it.
because it's a terrific job. It just eats up every minute, you know. And I'm going to do it with Maurice Delateau, who's going to help me. I'm the other writer. And I even dread going into it now. I almost wish I could get out of it. Well, too many people would really be waiting to hear and read about your life because... many of the comedians who have reached prominence in this country and even abroad, the ones who have come from rather deprived backgrounds, have been filled with feelings of hatred perhaps, trying to prove their own point. This is not true with you. You seem to have come from a stable situation. This is what frightens me a little bit about writing a book, because unless you've had all of this adversity. Is that right? Is that a correct word? That's a good word. And it's correct. Is it really? Because half the time I don't know. Sometimes my writers give me words and they don't know at all what they're talking about. But I haven't had much of that. So it isn't altogether. If you're going to read about a tragic life or somebody who had nothing and was born with nothing or had a very poor family or had a lot of setbacks, this I've never had. You see?
I would almost rather that there was a biography written about me than my writing the book as an autobiography. I really would prefer that. And I would help. You see, I would come in on the editing and help writing, but I would prefer that than writing an autobiography. Now, I've got to be very careful. I don't want to make it too jokey. I don't want a million jokes in it. No more than we're doing it in this kind of... People are interested probably in what we're talking about. We hope so. Well, I hope so too. I imagine after they see you do comedy for about a hundred years, they'd like to find just a little serious side. And I'll have a lot of that in the book if possible. And yet, it must be kind of a funny book. And there are a lot of humorous things. I could write a book on concerts alone. I would prefer to write...
six small books, you know, then one big book. I wish I could take six small books and put them all together as volume and sell it that way. As a matter of fact, I might suggest that because I could devote a small book to concerts alone with the humorous notices, reviews from the music critics and what happened when I gave the concerts, how I started. Now, if you're going to put that in the story of your life, You can't put all of that in because the book will be then this long. But I could write a lot of short books. Well, you yourself... You know, that isn't a bad idea now that I think of it. No, listen. Wouldn't it be funny if that started here? It certainly would. If I do it, you'll get a volume for nothing. For nothing, okay. Autographed, I hope, without a signature charge on that. As an editor yourself, though, you edit and have through the years your own shows and your own performances with very precise...
observation, that you know what's right for you. Yes, I think I do, yes. I know in radio and television, I'm not so sure that I know exactly what's right for me in the movies or on the stage, because the author, if he is positive it's right for me, or a director like Billy Wilder or Willie Wilder, one of these great directors, they can see. certain things on the screen. They know exactly what's going to be on there, and I don't. See, I might read something and think, now, for instance, David Merrick has a lovely, funny play he wants me to do. He's dying for me to do it. And I've read it, and I screamed at the play, but I don't happen to think it's quite right for me. I think it's right for a Sid Caesar or a Joey Bishop or somebody like that. I don't think it's right for me, and yet I laughed at it. Now, I don't know.
It might be, but I doubt it. I wouldn't want to take that gamble. Now, the author thinks it's for me, and he's written successful things. The director flew to Los Angeles, who had never been to Los Angeles before, just to talk it over with me and listen to me read some of the things. And David Merrick, who has been a very, very successful producer, thinks that I'm silly if I don't do this play, you know. And yet, Merrick read it. My manager, Mr. Fine, Irving Fine, read it, loved it and everything, but they agree with me. They don't think it's quite the thing for me to do. Now, I will say this. If I did it and did it very, very well, then it would be a feather in my cap because it's entirely, in a way, it's entirely different from anything that I do. And through the years, what do you consider your finest feathers?
your cap, because you really have quite a headdress, you know, if you were to put all those feathers in one cap. That's a good line, you have quite a headdress. What would you say, do you yourself consider your finest achievements or the moments in your professional life that have meant the most to you? I would have to say my concerts, because there I'm in a field where I'm competing. with great violinists. I am doing a satire on a famous violinist. I'm appearing with the greatest orchestras in the countries and the finest conductors, including George Zell of Cleveland and Leonard Bernstein, Alfred Wallenstein, Steinberg. But in these concerts, I can also give them an awful lot of laughs and talk to them with a lot of laughs.
combining both now and the achievement has been this that i've been doing it for 10 years and never once had a among the critics not one critic has ever said it's funny but it shouldn't be done instead of that they would say it's very funny mr benny is not a high fit he's not a nice extern but what an evening in a concert hall so i would think from an entertaining point this is the best achievement, plus the fact, the reason I like it so much, what greater background can a comedian have than a hundred musicians behind him and a famous conductor who only conducts for Stern and Heifetz and Milstein, Zagetti, those kind of people, you see? So this, I think, I would consider the finest achievement. Now I would say that, radio and television, you can't call those achievements.
Places for comedians to entertain. There have been a lot of successful people. I think my going over to London to appear for the first time at the Palladium and being a big hit there was an achievement. To know exactly what to write. Did you ever think, Jack, back when you started in Vaudeville, that you would be an institution in your own lifetime? That the name Jack Benny would remain in the... No, as a matter of fact... Everybody knows you. As a matter of fact, when I went into radio and even into television, when people said to me, you know that 15 years from now or 30 years from now, all these characterizations are still going to pay off for you, I would have thought they were silly. Now, Dennis Day, if anybody told me when Dennis first came on my show, now here's a fella came on, a single kid, young kid, since he's been on my show, he's been married.
has nine children and a tenth one coming. Now, if anybody had told me that 25 years from the time Dennis came to work for me, he could still go on and be the same silly kid and be funny or funny or never, I would have thought they were crazy. Anybody would have ever told me that. Well, at one time when you were the subject on Mr. Hush, the famous... personality from Waukegan, Illinois, and still, despite Pat Nugent, you are still Waukegan, Illinois' favorite and famous son. Thank you so much, Jack Bennett, for being in conversation. WKBW-TV has presented Elizabeth Dribben in A Conversation with Jack Bennett. Furnishings by Softman. This has been a pre-recorded public affairs production of the Capital Cities Broadcasting Corporation.
