The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 69 min to read
I want to thank Lee again for heroically filling in because we didn't know what time the... Let's bring the table back a bit. Okay. Time our special guest today would get here. Nor did we think we'd be so crowded here, but I guess we are. And I want to say that it's wonderful. And it's a great thrill for me to be here because 28 years ago, we met in an elevator backstage of the Ziegfeld Theater in New York City. I was at that time a young college reporter working on the entertainment beat, and I was given the assignment of interviewing Jack Benny. During his New York stay, he was acting at the Ziegfeld and one-man show with Jane Morgan, the singer. And I was extremely nervous. And there was a blonde woman who kept saying to me, you'll do fine, you'll be okay, my father's not difficult, just ask him the questions. And I did.
But I always thought about the blonde woman who held my hand and took me down the elevator. And about a week ago, I got a call from her, and I was just knocked out. I was knocked out 28 years ago by her, and still am. And it gives me great, great pleasure to introduce Joan Benning. Thank you very much. This is how we're going to do it. It was really only 10 years ago. I mean, let's not... We're going to work it this way. After our talk, we're going to have questions. And then we're going to have signings. For those who have copies of her book, which I understand are all sold out, we're going to have signings afterwards. Okay, so I said I'd open it up by saying whatever you want to say, Joan. That's very difficult because my favorite topics, of course, are my grandchildren, my new grandchild, my children, politics. Am I not close enough? Can you hear? It's not on.
We can bring it down. I can't tell. Okay. If you can hear me, that's fine. As I started to say, my favorite topics are my children, politics, religion, the state of the world, and I know that's not what you all want to hear about. So it's going to be easier for me, since I don't quite know what you want to hear about, if somebody would like to start it off with a question, because all I need is one question, and I'll talk until 4 o'clock this afternoon, which is setting me off. Could I raise one question? Yes. When did you first realize that your father was a big celebrity? Well, I don't think that I ever realized in one moment. I mean, it wasn't like somebody sat me down and said, guess what, your father's a star. It came gradually. You know, I grew up, as I'm sure you all know, in Hollywood, where most of my friends were the children of celebrities. So I didn't think it was terribly unusual. And I don't know that there was ever any one time when I realized that my father was a star.
Even now, people will tell me on occasion, you know, your father was an institution. And it makes me kind of scratch my head because that was daddy. And it's hard to relate that. There's a story I tell in the book that apropos of this. My daughter, Maria, who was at that time about 12 years old, she was bicycling to the dentist on South Beverly Drive. And all of a sudden she heard a voice yelling, Maria. And she turned around. And it was her grandfather. And she said, the first thing that crossed her mind was Jack Benny saying hello to me. And then immediately, no, it's granddaddy. And that's very confusing. And it's something, not confusing, but it's something, there's granddaddy and there's Jack Benny. And for me, it was very much the same thing. There was daddy and there was Jack Benny. And yes, they were the same, but no, they weren't the same. And even today.
I'll go places sometimes and there's my father's picture in a strange place, a place I've never been before. And I'll walk by and there will be something about my father or a picture of him. And I think, isn't that strange that, you know, there's my father on the wall of this strange hotel or something like that. So that is rather odd. Yes. Did you ever have an opportunity to be on his program? Was it ever considered making you a kid? Yes, I think both of my parents would have liked had I become an actress, and I did try it very briefly, and I was an absolute flop. It is not my forte at all. I can't act my way out of a paper bag. I did do the radio show a couple of times in small parts, and then there was a time when, and I'm not totally clear on this because it was such a long time ago, the very last year that my father was on radio, My mother didn't want to do the show anymore. She didn't want to go to the studio. She didn't want to face the audience. She was the most nervous woman I've ever known. And so at that time the technology was such that they could record her at home and then splice her voice into the tape. So I went to the studio and I played her part for the live audience. Then what you heard on the radio was her voice.
In television, I think I was on the show twice, maybe three times. Once I played myself in that my father dreamed he was married, and he was married to Mary Livingston, and they had a daughter, and the daughter was yours truly. And I played that part. I'm sure I was awful. Later, there was a show about Beverly Hills Police Station, and I played a receptionist. And the only thing I remember about that was that at the end of the program, I danced with one of the Beverly Hills policemen to an orchestra playing. It was a spoof of... the Beverly Hills Police. I never really had any intentions. It wasn't my interest. I then found that I liked doing talk shows. You can tell I like to talk. I can be here till four in the afternoon. It's easy to be me. It's very difficult, and I have such admiration for all of you in the audience who were actors, who can take somebody else's words and make them sound like they're yours. I always said I could be terrific in, I mean, I could do Blanche DuBois.
If I could do it in my own words. It just doesn't work that way. Yes? What are your feelings when you see your father on film? It seems very natural to see my father. The question was, if you can't hear in the back, what does it feel like to see my father on television? And it just seems perfectly normal. That's where I would expect him to be. Yes? Your book has kept me up until after midnight for the last two nights. And I... And it's a glorious way to lose sleep at night. What a nice compliment. The first thing, one thing I'd like to ask you is about those radio transcriptions. Where are they now? As a matter of fact, I'll answer your question as well as if anybody else has the same. I have very little knowledge of where anything is today. I know that the television shows were sold at one time to MCA. Some of them belong to CBS. I don't know where they are. I don't know how they're cataloged.
A lot of them are at UCLA. That's an archival collection. Because I've had people call me many times about, you know, how can I get hold of a clip from a particular show? And I'm not much help. As I say, you'll have to call UCLA, CBS, MCA. I mean the ones that were actually brought home to you. They are at, I believe they are at UCLA. The radio transcriptions, all those big acetates from way back. They're at UCLA. Yes.
I'm sorry, I can't hear you. Was I on You Bet Your Life? Never. No. No. Yes. I don't know how long this question will be answered, but could you sort of describe your relationship to both your father, Jack Bentley, and your mother, Mary Livingston? We all know them as the actors. The question is, could I describe my relationship with them? I'll be extremely brief, only because I want you all to read the book. It's all in the book. Every answer to that question in detail is in the book. But so very briefly, in general, it was a wonderful relationship, particularly with my father. My mother was the disciplinarian, and as I said, you have to read the book. I had problems with my mother. She wasn't an easy woman. My father was a pussycat. Yes?
several paragraphs about his relationship with your mom and dad, and he describes your mom a little differently than his wife. Was George Burns accurate? Yes, George Burns was accurate. Yes. In the 50s, Irwin Shaw did a novel called The Troubled Air, which was somewhat of a romantic play of the Jack Benny organization programming his participation in keeping everybody producing and it was a bit nasty it was a bit dictatorial sonny and not just i i had no idea at all however accurate it might have been did mr benny glance through whatever he must have had a person say look there's so many bad hints that this might be you when we know it's not you did he ever respond the trouble there um The fact is, I've never heard of that book. I never heard my father mention it until you mentioned it this moment. I've never even heard of it. But now I'd be very curious to read it. It's easy to find. Irwin Shaw. Okay. The Troubled Heir. I'll look for it because I don't know anything about it. Yes. My father's relationship with the cast and the crew and all the rest of the people, including me, did I ever go to rehearsals or so on. I was in on all of it when I was a little girl.
I used to come home from school at that time. The writers, there were four of them, wrote the show in our house in the library. And I would come home from school and get my glass of milk and cookies and creep in the den and sit in the chair in the corner and listen to the writing of the show. I believe that was something like two days a week. It would happen Wednesday and Thursday. And then, again, the book is much more accurate about the actual schedule because I was unclear about it. You know, one's memory gets a little fuzzy after all these years. There is in the book the accurate way the show worked, and when the writers started, when my father wrote with them, when it went into rehearsal, and so on. But I used to love those sessions. I loved the laughter. I loved them all trying to think of a punchline. And I loved what you all know, of course, because you're all professionals, was this group of writers looking terribly serious and nodding their head and saying, that's funny.
And the whole thing was a delight. As far as his relationship was concerned, he was, in his profession, a kind of Harry Truman. The buck stopped here. And it really did with him. He was in on the writing. He was the final say about everything. And again, you all know there's so many performers, comedians, who rely totally on their writers and never saw anything until they went in to do the show and they read the script. My father was in on the whole thing from the idea in the very beginning, what they were going to do on next week's show, whether it was going to be a Christmas shopping tour or he was going to visit a neighbor, whatever it was, that was his decision with the writers. He then wrote with them. He then edited the show with them. It was his decision what was cut and what would go. And from everything I've heard, this is funny, it took me a long time to write this book. It took me a long time to even get started because...
The years went by, and I thought, I'd love to write about my father, but who is going to read a book about a nice man who had a nice career, who had a nice wife, a reasonably nice daughter? There's no dishing, there's no gossip, and people are reading Mommy Dearest and things like that. Nobody's going to buy a book about a nice man. So I hesitated and I hesitated. Finally, well, and the reasons are kind of funny, partly after my mother passed away, I found a manuscript. that was my father's autobiography. It had been written in 1968 with a ghostwriter and at some point abandoned. Now, I knew that this had happened because he talked about writing it. But at that time, I was married, raising four children, and pretty busy with my own life. And like many things, it kind of went out of my mind. I forgot about it. He abandoned it. It was never talked about again. So when I came across this manuscript, when I was going through this office full of memorabilia and files and whatever, And there was the manuscript. And all of a sudden I went, oh, of course I remember this. I had really forgotten it. And I thought, well, now I have to write a book. I mean, now we've got the autobiography, which belonged to me. At the same time, I was in New York and I was walking down Park Avenue one evening. And let me digress. I was married to a man who was head of production for United Artists. And he would come home with scripts. As I said, I'm not a good actress. I'm not the least bit creative.
And he would come home with scripts and he'd say, honey, think of a better title for this. And in all the years I was married to him, I never, ever thought of a title. Not once did I come up with a title. So I'm walking down Park Avenue and all of a sudden, like the cartoon character with the balloon, this balloon goes bang. Sunday nights at 7. What a great title, I thought. I thought of a title. And that's actually, isn't that funny? I thought, well, now I've got a title and a lot of blank pages. And that's how I started writing the book, and I thought, well, we'll worry about it later if people want to read it. Now we're back to what was he like, the nice guy in his relationship. So now I start interviewing people, and I wanted the book to have some contrast. I mean, I didn't want it all to be he was nice, he was nice, he was wonderful, he was perfect, he's the most wonderful man I ever knew, and so on and so on. So now I'm interviewing the people who still remain, because of course quite a few of them have passed on, but the writers.
at that time Dennis Day was still alive and other people who were associated with him both socially and in business and I could not get one person to say one unkind word about him it almost became frustrating I mean it's not that I wanted to knock him I just wanted some contrast isn't there anything bad about this man he was before I answer I'm just going to talk now before I answer more questions because It's such a delight to remember him and talk about, as I said, what an incredible man he was. He was not an educated man. I think most of you know that. But he had the most unbelievable instincts and the most unbelievable kind of intuition about what was right. Not only what was right for him personally in comedy, but he felt that, for example, he didn't have a jealous bone in his body, unlike many performers.
He felt that if other comedians did well, it was good for comedy. He loved to help young comedians. He loved to have them do well. He never felt it was competition with him. He just felt it was good for the business. And, of course, when you think about it, he was right. Why do Broadway producers knock other producers and say, you know, God, I hope their show fails? They're wrong because if Broadway is doing well, it's good for everybody. And my father instinctively knew that. In comedy, about the joke being on him, where he was the patsy, there was a rather famous show in its day, the opening show of a television season, where he didn't even appear on the show until the very end. And Bill Paley called him and said, that's the bravest thing I've ever heard. How could you do a show when you weren't on it? And my father said, was it a good Jack Benny show? And the answer was yes. So it didn't matter. He didn't have to be the star.
He was not only generous in person, obviously you all know that. I mean, that's the myth, you know, the miser. But not only was he generous financially and so on, he was the most generous man professionally. And again, that instinct. There's a story, and I'm not going to tell it now because I do want you to read the book. There's a wonderful story that has to do with a marquee and the size of lettering. And it was an example of his professional generosity. Because, again, it had to do with, you know, his name being bigger than somebody else's or smaller or whatever. He knew that it doesn't matter what size your name is. It doesn't matter whether your name is above the title or below the title or in 100% or 75%. The audience knows who's the star. And he knew that. And so I think he was the most unusual man.
He was just a wonderful person. So those are just some nice things about him. Yes, back there. The friends who would drop in at our house in our personal life, it changed over the years, of course, as everyone's do. But my earliest recollections, and this does date me, and it gives you, well, you'll know in the book how old I am anyway, isn't that? Even my girlfriends called and said, do you have to tell your real age? I said, well, it was there. I mean, it's really hard not to do that. And I don't know how I can lie anymore. I mean, I've been lying for years. But the truth comes out. So this was in the late 30s. But I was very little. I remember Betty Grable coming to our house to swim with George Raft. They were going together at the time. I mean, that's how long ago.
Their very close friends were, of course, George and Gracie went through the whole thing. I mean, they were the closest friends. It goes without saying. The other close friends were Barbara Stanwyck, who was then married to Robert Taylor. And they were always at our house and very, very close friends. The Ray Molans, Mal and Ray Moland, were close friends. And it changed over the years. But I do remember, and again, I talk about it in the book, the parties where it was, you know, I look back and I think, Maybe I dreamed this. Was I really there? Now, I wasn't allowed to go to the parties, but I would observe from an upstairs little watching post. I would see all the people come in. And it was the heyday of Hollywood. I mean, there was every big star that there was at that time and would come to these New Year's Eve parties. And it was glamour, and as most of you know, that doesn't exist anymore. But they were wonderful. Yes? Joan, I'd like to do something different. I'd like to throw in a few memes.
Okay. Let me answer one thing before you ask, because it might eliminate a few people. My father's relationship with the cast, the writers, was totally professional. They were not our personal friends, and I'm constantly asked, what was Rochester really like? What was Dennis Day really like? Now, I don't know that that's what you're going to ask. But I really did not know these people. I went to the studio on Sunday, and I got a kiss and a pat on the head, cute little Joanie. And the show was over, and that was that, and I saw them the following Sunday. They were not personal friends, and I hate to disappoint you, but I didn't really know them well. What I was going to ask is not really what they were like, but your own personal reminiscences. Okay. Your personal thoughts. Let's start with Dennis Day.
Well, I think I almost answered that in that I remember, I mean, everybody, of course, was very nice to me. I was the star's daughter. They were wonderful to me. They were all delightful. I don't have a way of answering that without saying I liked them. Who were your personal favorites? Oh, okay, good question. That's easy. Mel Blanc, Mel Blanc, and Mel Blanc. Mel Blanc had the patience of a saint because from the first time I met him until... maybe three weeks before he died, which was the last time I saw him, I was still saying, Mel, do Porky Pig, do Bugs Bunny, do Tweety Pie, and he always did them, and I never got tired of it, and I felt like an absolute fool, where here I was in my 50s, and I'm saying, Mel, do Tweety Pie. Yes? No, he did not help me with homework.
The question is, what was he like as a dad? Difficult to compare, again, when people say, what was it like to be Jack Benny's daughter? My flip answer is, how would I know? I've never been anyone else's. Well, obviously, I've never had another dad either. Now, yes, I've read enough novels to know what the all-American father is supposed to be like. Now, my father was not the all-American father. For me, he was a wonderful father, but... he was my father and this is what i grew up with he was caring he was attentive he as far as i can tell he absolutely adored me i was the apple of his eye i was daddy's little darling but no he wasn't the kind of father who helped me with my homework uh he probably couldn't have because he dropped out of high school so he didn't he wouldn't have been too much help on homework uh and that was not his thing he was also not a man who wanted to really deal with problems. He was very focused, like a horse with blinders. He was focused on next week's show. He was focused on the next joke, the next routine, who his star would be, which, of course, I think any performer, I mean, that's what makes them successful is that kind of focus on their career. And he was very attentive to both my mother and to me.
We didn't lack for anything. We certainly never lacked for love or attention. But there were things that were simply out of his realm. He didn't really want to deal with. If it was a problem, he said, go see your mother. Homework, I was on my own. And I was a good student, so I didn't have a problem with homework. I didn't really need help. And all in all, I just, I can't imagine anybody being luckier. As most of you know, I was adopted. talk about being born under the right star or at the right time or you know people say my he was famous for his timing but quite frankly I don't think he ever taught me for being in the right place at the right time yes oh the feud with Fred Allen well I think most of you know that was a professional thing it began as practically everything on his show began inadvertently it began I think with Fred Allen on his show insulting my father's violin playing and which Fred Allen of course did as a joke for the audience and my father picked up on that on the following show and insulted him back and that's how the feud began and of course they were in cahoots with each other after that and then because my father was a great admirer of comedy writing I think he had more respect for writers than practically anyone else, and I can remember so well that he felt that the Amos and Andy show he thought was the best written show in the business. I remember he thought that Fred Allen was the best single comedy writer in the business. He had great admiration for Fred Allen. Yes? Where did we live in Beverly Hills? We lived on an incredible block. We lived at 1002 North Roxbury.
which is the second house in the second block north of Sunset. Our neighbors to the south, the 1,000 Roxbury, eventually became Lucy Ball and Desi Arnaz moved in that house. Not when we first had it, but some years later they moved in. The next people down across the street are the Jimmy Stuarts. And back in the old days, when the sightseeing buses used to go up and down, the 900 and 1,100 blocks of Roxbury were really quite fabulous. Jack Haley lived in the 900 block, Hedy Lamarr, Jimmy Stewart, as I just mentioned. In our block way back then was Eddie Cantor, later Polly Berg, and Peter Falk now lives next door, but this, of course, was much later. Agnes Moorhead. That two blocks, there were a lot of celebrities and a lot of sightseeing buses going up and down when I was a kid.
Yes, a little bit to the west of the Beverly Hills Hotel, and the cross street there is Lexington, for those of you who are familiar with Beverly Hills. Was he really friendly with Ronald Coleman? I'm sorry? Was he really friendly with Ronald Coleman? Well, they weren't neighbors, as so many people... We're talking about Ronald Coleman. Was he really a good friend or neighbor? No, they were casual social friends. I think that at very big parties, Benita and Ronnie Coleman were invited to our home, but they weren't intimate friends. Whereas later in television, the Jimmy Stewart's became the neighbors, and that was true. But the Ronald Coleman's were never our neighbors, not in real life. Yes. As a child, were there any stars who had children that you played with or labored with? Were there any stars whose children I played with? Absolutely. As I said, most of my friends were celebrities' children.
But again, and I repeat myself, as most of you know, I love talking to a professional audience because I don't have to explain things. The echelon system in Hollywood, of course, was the studio heads were the biggest stars by Hollywood standards. And of course, the famous producers and directors were equally as important as the stars within Hollywood, within that social milieu. My friends were the ones I remember the best at a very early age. I mean, we're talking about playing in the sandbox. And then that reminds me of the war years. I have a funny story about that. My best friends were Loretta Young's daughter, Judy. I'll go back and forth because as things occur to me. Later, Gary Cooper's daughter, Maria. Maria is about two or three years younger than I. So when we were very little, we didn't play together because, you know, a six-year-old doesn't play with a three-year-old. So that came a bit later. But early on, Joan Bennett's daughter, Melinda. Of course, George Burns' daughter.
Sandra, and oh my God, there were so many and my mind's gone blank. Elizabeth Montgomery, Robert Young. There were two Robert Young children. I don't remember older or younger. And then, as I said, so many of the studio heads. Jewel Stein's two daughters were very close. Jack Warner's daughter, Barbara. Daryl Zanuck's two daughters, Susan and Daryl. And we were all pals back then. L.B. Mayer's granddaughter, Barbara, Barbara Goetz. And those were really the close friends. And we were kind of almost in a way low men on the totem pole. I mean, we lived in a very beautiful house, but it couldn't compare to the Jack Warner estate, which most of you know just sold to David Geffen for $48 million. And that was an incredible mansion.
And now we all had our governesses or nannies, and it's now the war years. And our nannies got together and decided that this little group of children, and there were boys and girls. Oh, Barbara Stanwyck's son, Phil Harris's son, Tookie. Oh, Tookie, isn't that funny? I don't know what his real name was. I call him Tookie. I haven't seen him in 40, 50 years. I have no idea whatever happened to him. And Andy Devine's son. Tad. Goodness, how am I remembering these people? Anyway, they decided that we were going to knit blankets for our boys overseas. And, I mean, just picture this. Here's a group of 20 little Hollywood brats, each one with their nannies, and we're sitting by the pool at the Warners, which is an Olympic-sized pool with the slide and the gorgeous pool house.
And here's this group of kids knitting these dumb little squares, dropping every other stitch. Ugly, you can't imagine what these things look like. And the nannies are correcting them, of course, and picking up our drop stitches. And tea is being served by a butler and two waitresses on silver trays and doilies. I mean, the picture of that somehow just, it really gets to me. But that's the way it happened back then. Yes, I'm sorry. I'll get over here. Of the people associated with my father, who did I not care for? I don't remember any one person specifically. I think, and again, it wasn't a matter of not caring about them, but I found that I was always an observer. And I remember when I was a little girl.
that I noticed that there were certain people, and I don't remember who they were now, but I tend to think, and this is a bad thing to say, that they were more likely agents or PR people, that kind of person, who made a big fuss over me when I was with my father and didn't know who I was when I wasn't, or shoved me aside, you know, get lost kid. And I just found that very interesting. As I said, I was kind of an observer, and I thought, isn't that interesting? I get treated one way here, and I get treated another way here. And it was a lesson. And later I discovered I was nobody. That was at the premieres, you know, when they stick their head in the car and yell to the bleachers, that's nobody. So that's when I found out I was nobody. Do you still live in the old house? I'm sorry, we'll get back there in a minute. Do I still live in the old house? No, not at all. They sold that house on Roxbury, oh, I'd say 15 years probably, even before my father died, and they moved to Holmby Hills.
to a house that was right across the street from the Playboy Mansion on Charing Cross. Yes? Well, that's a many part question. The question is, I'll go backwards and add if I forget something. What do I think of today's films versus old comedy? The fact that I, in my biography, mentioned I'm a film historian of sorts, and I'll tell you about that, which was my favorite of my father's films. I'll start backwards. This is kind of a funny story. As I said, I was born under a lucky star, and things kind of fell in my lap. And one day... About, oh, maybe six, seven years ago, I was in Aspen. It was in the summertime. And I love to ski, by the way. And I met a man there who said he was putting together a film conference and would I be interested in taking part. This was a social kind of thing at lunch. Well, my first thought was, he probably wants money. And so I was kind of, you know, well, I don't know. And I said, well, you know, what are you talking about? And he said, the month of January in Aspen. I went, January, Aspen.
Oh, I said, that sounds a little more interesting. Tell me more. And he said, well, there are going to be seminars and classes for college students, and would you be interested perhaps in either holding a seminar or teaching a class? Now, I had never taught anything in my whole life. In spite of the fact my biography says something about teaching math, what I did was I taught remedial eighth grade math at the local school when my kids were there because I didn't have anything else to do. That's not real teaching. I had never really done anything like this. But in the meantime, my head was going January skiing Aspen, and he said, how about would you do? And without hesitation, I said, well, I'll teach a class in the evolution of film comedy. I don't even know how I thought of it. It just came to me. But I was so sure of myself, he said, oh, you've done that before. I said, of course.
So all of a sudden, there I was in January in Aspen. In the meantime, I went through, I went to the video store, and I bought videotapes. Actually, what I did was I rented videotapes, and I paid my own. Anyway, I went through every comedy that has ever been made, wrote notes, voluminous notes. I then went to the New York Public Library at Lincoln Center. went through every old review, books on Capra, books on Lubitsch, books on... So by the time I got to Aspen in January, I knew my subject. And it was great fun. I had 15 sessions, so of course I had to narrow it down. I couldn't take the whole history of film comedy in 15 sessions, showing a film per session. And so arbitrarily, I subtitled this course, From Lubitsch to Wilder.
So I took that period of time, and to this day, Lubitsch, with maybe a nod to Sturgis, Lubitsch is absolutely my number one favorite comedy director. So, again, needless to say, my favorite film of my father's was To Be or Not to Be. And, by the way, my students, I don't think most of them, I mean, oh, I have a funny story for you because you're all of an age like me. My first class, okay, I'm introducing what we're going to be talking about, what films we're going to be doing, and so on. And these are college kids, right? Girl raises her hand. I said, yes. She said, I've never seen Cary Grant in a film. And I thought, oh, my God, what am I dealing with here? And then I realized at that time he had not made a film in 18 years. So it wasn't all that out of the ordinary, but it was a shocker to realize.
how little these kids knew. They had never heard of any of the directors I was using. They had never heard of any of the films. And they were very apprehensive about seeing a black and white film that was made, well, to make a long story short, by the end of the three weeks, they had fallen in love with these comedies and they wanted more Capra and more Sturgis. I mean, they really couldn't wait to see more. So it was a very successful kind of thing. I found it very rewarding to open up this whole world of comedy to kids who had never seen it before. And I showed, but they didn't know who Jack Benny was because they were too young for that. So I don't think they even related that this Miss Benny who was teaching the class had any relationship to anybody they might see. And I presented, which I would always do, I presented To Be or Not To Be as a Lubitsch film. It certainly wasn't really...
My father happened to be in it. But it's a Lubitsch film, and it's one of, I think, one of Lubitsch's best films. It was a brilliant film, and my father was lucky to be in it. What was the title of the film? To Be or Not to Be, that Mel Brooks later remade. Yes. Can I get back to the problem? Yeah, I'm sorry. How well did you play the violin? Did you learn to play? How concerned were you about yourself? Okay, I've got three questions. um how well did he play the violin did he really wear a toupee which i'll answer no he didn't he used a little cork to black up a little ball spot and the third was how did he feel about his health he was a hypochondriac as really as long as i can remember but he was a funny one he didn't take a lot of pills but he on his bedside table he must have had 60 bottles of pills i don't think he took very many of them Yes, he was concerned about his health more as he got older, and I think he was very afraid of growing old. He didn't want to be old, and he really felt that. That concerned him a lot. How well did he play the violin? As well as you all heard. That was it. There's been speculation that the U.S. Postal Service will be issuing a stamp in the near future honoring your father and several other comedians. Have you heard anything definitive about that?
The question is about a stamp honoring my father, the Postal Service. And no, I haven't heard anything in about a year, two years. I got a call from Norm Cosby, I think, who was sort of in the forefront of trying to get this done. And quite frankly, I'd forgotten about it, and I haven't heard anything since. It would sure be nice. I would like that. Yes? The question has to do with my father's feeling about radio versus television. That could be a very long answer, but again, please read the book because I don't want to make it as long. This could be an hour because it's a very involved kind of thing. His forte was radio. He was very comfortable in radio. Radio suited him as it suited the rest of the cast. I think it was a very difficult transition. I think that he made it better than most. But it's very difficult to go from imagination to reality, particularly when you have this enormous audience who have been listening for all these years.
And they have a preconceived notion of what Dennis Day looks like, of what Mary Livingston looks like, of what the vault was like. All these things that happened. And that's very difficult to do visually because now all of a sudden you see Dennis Day and you say, gee, he's older than I thought he was. The vault worked on television, but I'm doing this personally now. To me, it was never as funny as on radio because seeing it is never as funny as what you imagine. You heard those fabulous sounds, the echoing footsteps and the clanking chains and this dungeon. I mean, and you just pictured this dungeon going down there. The reality is never quite that funny. So I think it was a much more difficult medium for him. God knows he had to work harder. You know, you really, in radio, I think he worked maybe four days out of a seven-day week. Whereas in television, it was...
really almost seven days a week it was and of course in the beginning he was doing both before he finally gave up radio and went solely with television I don't think he was ever really as comfortable with television as he had been in radio but he also was a pragmatic man he knew that this is what he had to do and I think you know certainly in the first the first five or six years he was very successful in television and then things changed he changed life changed the comedians changed the public taste changed uh and you know you all know what that's like television ate you up you the audience always wanted something new and it was very hard to last for a long time in television and i think his show was on the weekly show i think was on more than 10 years which is a pretty good run when you think about television shows yes i'm philadelphia and i heard you being interviewed over WSTAU, and you told a story about Desi Arnaz and his drum and your father and his violin. Could you repeat that? Oh, I'm asked to repeat a story that had to do with my father's violin and little Desi and his drums. What really happened, the story I told, had to do with when we first moved into the house on Roxbury that I was talking about, some people, the people who lived next door were named Burr, I believe, or Bird. And as i mentioned about all the sightseeing buses that went up and down and back then it wasn't only the sightseeing buses but things were much freer there there wasn't the kind of security we have today and people came up to the door and rang the doorbell could we meet mr benny could we have an autographed picture if he's home could we talk to him it was very friendly and very casual and and my father loved to go to the door and talk to his fans because he was a very casual man and so uh the burrs lived in a house that was almost identical white brick Georgian and they would get as many people coming to their door as we got coming to ours asking for Jack Benny and at one point they had had all they were going to take and I remember I came home from school one day and there in their driveway was an enormous sign and it said Jack Benny does not live here he lives next door and an arrow pointed to our house.
Well, that was the beginning of the story because apparently it didn't work awfully well. Eventually the burrs moved. I think they'd had all they were going to take. And that's when Lucy and Desi moved in. Well, our house was, you know, went straight across the front and had a wing going back. The Arnaz house was here. That was my room back here. My father practiced his violin in his dressing room, which went across the back of our house, so it was really adjacent to my bedroom. and little Desi practiced his drums in their driveway, which was right here, and the sound wafted right up to my bedroom windows. And I spent a few years there. It was pretty bad. And they were playing different, you know, he's going bang, bang, bang on the drums, and my father was doing da-da-dee-da-da-da-da-da. I mean, it was awful. That's the story of the violin and the drums. It was a cacophony like you wouldn't believe. Yes, back there. His favorite challenge.
uh what were his favorite radio shows and his favorite movies his favorite radio show if i had to pick one i think was amos and andy as i mentioned he thought that was the best written show on on the air he listened to most of the comedy shows but he i remember he particularly liked amos and andy um his other favorite radio shows were the fights i can remember going in his room when i was a little girl listening to the joe lewis fights love to listen to the fights and baseball games And the comedians, those were his favorite. I loved the detective shows. He didn't care so much about those. Favorite movie? I can't think of anyone in particular. He loved movies and he loved comedy, but I don't remember any one specific movie. Yes? What was his relationship with Phil Harris? They were very close.
What was my father's relationship with Phil Harris? Very much as I stated before, it was really a business relationship, as was the only one in the cast with whom we really had a personal relationship was really Mel Blanc. And the others were really... I'm sorry? Oh, but the statement was that my father helped Phil get his own radio show. That may be true. It perhaps is true. Maybe my father talks about it in the book. You know something? I don't remember the book now. It was so long ago when it went to print. But, again, that was a professional thing. I mean, they were not people who came to dinner twice a week at our house or we went to their house for dinner. It was a professional relationship. Can I throw out a name? Also a frequent visitor to this convention, the late Frank Nelson.
Oh, Frank Nelson. Well, that again was a professional relationship. He happened to be one of my favorite characters on the show because I thought he was so terribly funny. But again, I'm sorry, I really didn't know him in person. Yes? Did you ever appear on any of the shows, like radio or TV? You weren't listening or you came in late. I came in late. Okay, I answered that. But I'll answer for you privately later because I've done it for the audience. Yes? How many of the radio and TV shows do you have yourself that you listen to personally, and how often do you? That's an easy question. How many of the shows do I own personally, radio and television, and do I listen to them frequently? And the answer is no and no. I don't own any, and I don't listen to them. Occasionally when I'm in L.A., they're being run on WOR, the television shows, at 9 o'clock.
And once in a while, if I remember, I'm usually not home at 9 o'clock, and if I remember, I'll put on a few minutes of it. But no, I really don't watch the old shows or listen to. And I wish I did because particularly to me, the radio shows hold up. The few that I've heard in between here, they really seem to hold up, and I think they're still very funny. And I'm just remiss. I think I'd probably enjoy them enormously if I listened to them more. I haven't done that. There's a hand way back there that's been up for a while.
Can you hear that? The other books. The other books about your father. Have you read them? Oh, what about the other books about my father? Your mother wrote a book as well as his father. No, she didn't, but I'll tell you about that. Okay, there have been three other books. And I'm a pretty straight-out person, so I'll tell you the truth. The first one was written by Irving Fine, who was his agent. And Irving is, and by the way, I think Irving is the best manager and agent in the business, and I like Irving. But Irving is an agent, and Irving doesn't go from here across the wall unless he gets his 10% or 15%. I mean, Irving gets paid for everything. And I think that he thought he was going to be first off the starting line with a book because that's the one that was going to sell. It was written too fast. It was written just to get it out there. So it was a very unsatisfactory book, and it did not sell, and I don't think anybody had much interest in it.
The second one was the only, to me, the only good one, which was written by Milt Josephsburg, who was one of his writers. But Milt dealt really with the professional Jack Benny, with the show. And I thought it was a very interesting book. And anybody who wanted to know about the professional Jack Benny, you got it all. And I thought Milt was wonderful. He was also an extremely funny man, Milt Josephsburg. And the third one was an odd kind of book. was written by a ghostwriter, actually, and I don't even remember her name. Marsha? Okay, thank you. It's nice that somebody knows a lot more than I do. It was my uncle's doing, and his name was Hilliard Marks, and he got together with Marsha, who ghostwrote the book. I don't think Hilliard wrote much of it at all. I think she wrote most of it.
They interviewed my mother and they put her name on it because it sounded good to have her name on it. It was the white, the widow writing the book. It was very badly reviewed. I didn't even read it all. I was very unhappy with it. But a funny thing happened. Let me blow my horn for a minute because this was just so weird. About two pages was an interview with me and I insisted that it be done verbatim. And I said, I want to see it when you do it. I want it exactly the way I'm talking. So the book comes out, it's reviewed in the New York Times, and it's on page 27, and it's a pretty bad review. And towards the end of the review, it says something about, there were two pages by Joan Benny, we'd like to hear more from her. I mean, it was the only good part of the review was mine, and I went around for a year telling people, I got a good review in the New York Times. Anyway, do you know that that was always in the back of my head when I wrote this book?
It was like, I remembered, we want to hear more from Joan. I thought, okay, you'll hear more from me. Wait till I get slammed in the Times. So that was the third book. Yes. Yes. I'm sorry, go ahead. How were the sales for my book? It just got in the stores about three days ago. I had been told by Warner Books that it wouldn't be out until the first of November, and I was in California this... because they filmed Entertainment Tonight, which was very nice. I enjoyed that on Tuesday. And I came back to New York Wednesday, and a friend said, I bought your book today. I said, you couldn't have that. It's not in the store. Well, it's in the stores, but just as of maybe three or four days ago. So I don't know. I know that they shipped a lot of copies. I was very, very pleased that Warner's, I think they shipped 100,000 copies, which just seems like very nice for a first printing. Let's just hope people buy them now.
I'm sorry, you were up first, and then go over there. Why did my mother hate to perform when it was obvious the audience loved her so much? I really don't know for a fact. I can guess. I can even educated guess. But ostensibly, it was her nerves. She was very nervous about performing. She never really liked performing. And I talk a bit in my book about... her insecurities. And I think that was it more than anything else. I think she never felt that she was a wonderful performer. And she was so nervous every time she went out. She never felt that she was good. And of course she was very wrong, but people have their own self-image and there's not much one can do. Yes? Let me answer these one at a time so that I can ask. Let me go for the second one. Who was my favorite comedian today? I think just for His mind is Stephen Wright. I love that man's mind. He just knocks me over. And the first question was, how did my father feel about the Marx Brothers? I mentioned my uncle Marx, Hilliard Marx. There is something in the book that my father talks about, that there was a distant relationship between my mother's family, whose name was Marx, and the Marx Brothers. I don't know why, but I don't think it's true.
If it is, it must be terribly distant. First of all, my family was M-A-R-K-S. Theirs was M-A-R-X. In both cases, I imagine they all came from the old country, as they say. And I think it would be terribly remote if there had been some relationship. But it is possible, and I'm not sure of that. How did my father feel about them? I think he thought they were wonderful comedians. I think Groucho was a very difficult man. I mean, they saw each other at Hillcrest. part of the round table. And my father liked Groucho, but Groucho was a difficult man, but I think most people know that. You had a third question. No, it wouldn't have been Groucho, but I think maybe Harpo. As I recall, he spoke very nicely of Harpo. Yes, please. Let's do this first. Excuse me.
I don't know if you could hear, but we were talking about here about Portland on Fred Allen's wife and my mother. And this gentleman says he liked my mother a lot better than Portland. And why would, it's too bad that she felt that she wasn't as good. But I guess that's just the way it was. I think once she was on it, you know, and reading the script, I think she kind of got into it and perhaps forgot her nerves. But she had, you always knew when she was nervous if you knew where to look. You know, we all have our funny little things about nerves and how they show. My father was a nail biter. He bit his nails till the day he died. And you never thought he was nervous, but he was a very nervous man. But he had a self-assurance as a performer. My mother never had that assurance. Anyway, her nerves.
She'd break out in a rash, in blotches on the palms of her hands. And that's always how you knew she was very nervous, was how red her hands got. And they would get fiery red when she was really a wreck. You wanted something, Bill. One quick thing. I think that your mother, her approach on radio was sort of like a slyness that Portland did not have. Like, okay, Jack, I know, you know. Like, she was clued into everything before it happened. And that was, I think, what made her so wonderful on radio. A name that came up, one of the great writers of all time, Al Boesberger. Do you have any memories about Al? I have none. My father talks about him briefly, I think, in the book. As I recall, there was a, for those of you who remember Al Boesberger, quite frankly, I don't. There was originally a chapter in his autobiography about Al Boesberger.
But I think my editor at Warner's, as well as I, felt that most of the reading audience would not know who he was and would not be particularly interested. And I don't remember at this moment whether the entire thing was cut or whether there's maybe a slight mention of him. But that was very early on. And as I say, most of the public who would want to read about Jack Benny, I don't think too many of them would remember Al Boasberg. I mean, you all would, but he's a remote name. Yes.
Did she really work for the maid company, my mother? Yes, she did. Did your grandmother write funny telegrams and letters? Did my grandmother write funny telegrams and letters? No. I had a sister, the sister of the maid. No, wasn't it? No, no, no. It was Mary's mother from Plainfield who wrote that Babe, the sister, was on the show. And yes, my mother had a sister, Babe, and yes, she was on the show. But the letters, as I recall, didn't they come from Mary's mother in Plainfield? Thank you. That's what I thought. Yes, she did. No, my mother was never a professional singer, but I remember early on when she took lessons from a coach who was, I think, Dinah Shore's accompanist. And he would come to the house and coach her. My mother had a beautiful voice.
She'd occasionally get talked into singing at private parties if people were over at our house, but never really professionally. She never had the nerve. You were going to say something. Well, I was talking about Meredith and Steve. This is hitting me now. Why, during the professional career of your father, they always made Mary the girlfriend instead of the wife? Because with George Burns and Gracie Allen, they were known as a couple. And yet, on the radio show, they weren't. It was always the girlfriend. Later on. The question has to do with why my mother on the show was the girlfriend, so to speak. I'm not even sure she was his girlfriend. She was a kind of nebulous thing that really... But that they weren't married like George and Gracie or... Was Fred Allen married to Portland Hoff on the show? I thought he was. Yeah, it wasn't his Allen. And I don't really know the answer except, again, what my father has to say about it was that most of this stuff kind of evolved. She started out originally.
as a fan from Plainfield, New Jersey. And she auditioned for the part, which is how she got on the show to begin with. And the audience loved her. She asked for his autograph or whatever, and the audience liked her, and so my father said to the writers, write her on the show again. Well, they couldn't keep her as a fan from Plainfield, and so she became eventually this kind of secretary. Well, she wasn't a secretary, she was a girlfriend. If you try to describe what she was, it's very difficult. We're not sure. She was just on the show, and sometimes she was his girlfriend, but he was always dating other people. I mean, he always had those ghastly dates on New Year's Eve and whatever, and she had nothing to do with that. So she wasn't even really his girlfriend. It was a funny kind of role, and I think it simply came out of what worked. As I said, my father always trusted his audience, and if it worked, it got in the show. The following week, if it didn't work, it was thrown out.
the same thing with Rochester, who started out as a railroad porter, because they were going to California on the train. And they couldn't keep them on, I mean, they couldn't keep every Sunday going back and forth to New York to keep Rochester on the show, so he became the valet. So there were those kinds of reasons that things were done as they were done. Sometimes I wonder if it was just a conscious effort to not bring him too close for the sake of the comedy. The relations that they had, seemed to work, so it just stayed that way. Is Rochester still alive? No, Rochester died about a year or two after my father. I remember because I went to his funeral. What happened to the house outside the Playboy Club? What happened to, is that Rochester's house? Oh, it was not the Playboy Club, I'm sorry. It was Hugh Hefner's house, the Playboy Mansion they called it. Yeah, you said he moved out, his father moved out there. Yeah, they lived there until he died.
and then my mother kept the house until she died and then i sold it because it was a huge place and at this point at the time my mother passed away which was six years ago my children were grown i think the youngest was in college and i certainly didn't need that size house and besides i had a house of my own that i absolutely loved i didn't want that house but who lives there now uh Some people bought it, and they tore the house down, and they rebuilt another house. Now, let me say this. I would be very upset if anybody tore down 1002 North Roxbury. That was our house. I mean, that's where I grew up. I really could care less about the place on Charing Cross. It was a beautiful house, but it was... The people who tore it down did the right thing for the piece of property. It's a lovely piece of property, and actually the house was kind of situated in the wrong part of the property.
These people wanted a tennis court, so they put the house in another. I mean, they did the right thing. It needed to be torn down. Who lives there now? I don't know. It seems to me it's a psychiatrist. His wife is also a psychiatrist. I don't quite know. I've met them once, but yes. My father's personal opinion of his film career. He loved To Be or Not To Be. He liked George Washington Slept Here. And he liked Charlie's Aunt. I don't think he much cared about the rest of the movies. I think he would have liked a better, you know, a more active film career. But my father, again, was really not a very good actor. He wasn't an actor. He was a performer. He was Jack Benny. And he was not a man, unlike many comedians who are really quite good actors, he really...
You know, that character, that Jack Benny character, the miser, the 39 years old, it was so firmly established that it was very hard for the audience to believe him as anything else but Jack Benny. And the only picture to me that it really worked in was To Be or Not To Be, where you believed him as somebody else. And that was thanks to Lubitsch. Yes? Oh, did he really hate The Hornblows at Midnight? Well, I think he did. I mean, I don't think he thought it was a good picture. It certainly didn't do any business, but it certainly became a wonderful object of humor and a wonderful source of humor. Yes? Okay, about me. My favorite subject. What a terrible thing to ask because then I really get caught up. I mean, doesn't everybody love to talk about themselves?
So I'll be brief because that's really not, as I said, not what you want to hear about, at least in detail. Yes, well, I'll tell you outside. But I'll give you a little brief sketch because I'm so proud of my children. It's great fun to do. First, I'll start with I live in Beverly Hills. I have the house, as I mentioned. It's a house I bought when my youngest, I have four children, and when my youngest went away to school, I moved out of the house. flats in Beverly Hills with the six bedrooms and whatever the typical house of the flats which I needed with all those kids and then once they were gone I really didn't want all that extra space I wanted a house that was just nice and cozy and would be okay if the kids came home for a weekend but that's it once they moved out I said the happiest day is the day they're born and the next happiest day is when they leave and So, you know, now they come home once in a while to the Beverly Hills house, and it's so wonderful to see them, and it's so terrific. And after about two and a half days, it's, you know, when did you say your plane was? It's fine, thank you. Anyway, so I have the house in Beverly Hills, and about six years ago I bought an apartment in New York when my youngest, Joanna, left home. I'd always wanted to come back to New York. I'd spent a lot of time as a child in New York and wanted to live there, so I bought this little one-bedroom apartment.
not come from Plainfield, she actually came from Denver. One of her sisters settled in Seattle, and those grandchildren who are my generation, the oldest one is a young man named Doug, and he's very big with the Young Presidents Organization, YPO. And he's responsible for the resources. So one day he called me, and we're very close because I have no brothers or sisters. I don't even have first cousins, so they're really my closest relatives. So Douglas calls me, and he said, would I speak to a group of YPOers about growing up in Hollywood? This is, by the way, I think this is a hilarious story. I said, Douglas, you must be crazy. First of all, who wants to hear about growing up in Hollywood? Wouldn't be. I've never talked to anybody in my life. I mean, I wouldn't know what to say. But it was a year away, and it's easy to say yes when something is a long way in the future. Okay, Doug, finally, you talked me into it. I'll do it.
Well, it turns out, you know, the year went by very quickly, and here I am in San Diego at what they euphemistically call a university, and I was what they euphemistically call a resource. And I get to this university, which is a week long, and there's something like 1,500 YPOers. I didn't know too much about YPO or who these people were. And I get all the packet of stuff and where I'm supposed to be and what's going on and dinner tonight. Anyway, they had keynoters at every breakfast and every lunch. Then they had morning classes and afternoon classes. Now, the morning and afternoon classes, you could take your pick of any one of maybe six or seven or ten classes. The subjects ranged from soup to nuts. But they had people like Secretary of Education Bennett spoke on education. They had Mike Ledeen who spoke on terrorism. David Kempke who spoke on the secret...
Secret Diplomacy of Israel. The keynoters were Alexander Haig, Gerald Ford, Henry Kissinger, Admiral Stockdale, Donald Rumsfeld. And I said, Douglas, I'm going home. What am I doing here? Are you crazy? I was never so intimidated in my whole life when I looked over this roster of people. He said, oh, well, the subject range, you know, there'll be people to come and see you. Well, I did my thing, it was like Thursday afternoon at 3, and I did my stupid little speech, and it really was a stupid little speech, and I think I had about 15 people in the audience. It was a disaster. However, there was a lady in the audience who came to me afterwards, and she said, would you be interested in doing this professionally? You're very articulate, and growing up in Hollywood would be an interesting topic to a lot of the town hall groups. And I thought, Gee, Joanna's just going away to school. I was just thinking, what am I going to do with the rest of my life? And this fell into my lap, just the way the other things did. Well, it's now been five years, and I lecture all over the country. That's been a career for me. And it's great fun. Of course, my friends go to Rome and Paris and London on business. I go to North Platte and Toledo. And anyway, you get the idea.
Newer. Newer. Exactly. So anyway, it's been great fun, and that's what I've been doing. That, that I've been writing the book. The course I've been teaching is now, that conference is now defunct, but it's about to be revived. When the book tour is over and all this settles down, comes January, I will probably sit in my apartment and think, what am I going to do now? And I know something will fall in my lap again, because it always does, or I'll come up with something. But in the meantime, I have a lot of lectures in March and April, so I really have January and February off. So that's what I've been doing. Now my children. Pardon me? You said? Okay. Okay, quickly. Michael, my oldest, he is 35. Did you hear that in the back? He's a doctor. He lives in Los Angeles. He went to Stanford and Columbia Medical School. He took to math just the way I did.
This has to do, if anybody's interested, having to do with being adopted, which I found kind of interesting. I never had any interest in looking up who my real parents might be until many years later, after my mother died, and when I kind of reviewed my children's lives, and all of a sudden I thought, there must be something genetic here, because it certainly wasn't my parents. I mean, my father never got through school. My mother, I'm sure, could not do her multiplication tables. And I took to math. like a fish to water i was a math major at stanford i loved math i loved science i loved everything to do with that finance and so on my parents never understood me taking everything why is she doing math problems all the time it's my favorite thing to do and uh my older boy michael you know when he took his sats to go to high school and then go to college and then to go to medical school scored perfect 800s in math every time he took them And anyway, went to Columbia. He now lives in LA. And he's a doctor. His specialty is emergency medicine. My next one is Maria, who was 33. She now lives in Boulder. She was not a particularly good student because she had this dreadful older brother to compete with. And so she kind of opted out. She dropped out of school at some point in college. She didn't want to go back. So she worked for a while. And when she was 27, She decided she would go back to school, or 26. She applied to the University of Colorado, which is how she happened to settle in Boulder. Went back. She was there three and a half years because not too many of her earlier credits transferred. So, anyway, end of story. She graduated number one in her class, summa cum laude, with a degree in finance. And, as I said, it's math, math, math. Degree in finance, and she works for the Arthur Anderson Company in Denver. She's a systems analyst. See, very far from show business.
My next one, who came along quite a few years later, is now 26, and that's Bobby. And Bobby went to Andover and Brown. Again, he's taken three sets of SATs. Again, he's had perfect 800s on every set he's taken. And he went to Brown, where he was kicked out twice. He's had a very checkered academic career, but always managed to come through at the end. So he graduated Brown, magna cum laude, and he told me, he has a little bit of a swell head. He said, that's only because they don't have SUMA. So I said, okay, honey. This is after he caught up on credits. As we speak, you want to hear proud mother as we speak. He's a National Science Foundation fellow, getting his doctorate at MIT in mathematical theory. I mean, he is, he really, he almost thought he was God's gift to brains, and I never realized he was right. I mean, he really is smart.
And with it all, he's the cutest thing you ever saw. He's a blue-eyed blonde who's a champion water skier. He races cars. He flies airplanes. I mean, he's not your MIT nerd. He's really something. Now my pride and joy is my youngest, who is Joanna, who is 25, and who just made me a grandmother a week ago today. Thank you. I'm applauding you, too. I'm so excited I can hardly stand it. I've been waiting all this time to be a grandmother. She went to Duke University. She's the cutest thing you ever saw. I mean, she is such a nice and adorable girl. She married the most fabulous man. They're both the same age. They're both 25. And he is so cute. I mean, he's the one, he was changing the diapers and feeding the baby and spreading her hair out on the pillow. He's so nuts about her. I mean, he's so adorable. And what he sees in her, I don't know. I mean, she's okay. But my son-in-law, forget it. He's the best.
Anyway, they got married a little over two years ago in Beverly Hills. And I won't bore you more, but I could talk about them forever. I mean, they're just super. By the way, he's a computer scientist. I'll never get away from math. I mean, she even married one. Yes? Were your mother and father religious? The question is, were my parents religious? And that's an interesting question, which I really forgot about, and it was my editor at Warner Books who said, you know, you never talked about religion. I think it's something people would be interested in. And so I added a section, perhaps not as long as it should be. No, they weren't religious. I really didn't know my father's parents. His mother died before I was born, and his father died when I was about six years old, so I didn't know them. And I don't even know, really, if they were terribly religious.
i'm sure my father was bar mitzvah i'm almost positive that my mother my mother's parents lived in beverly hills they had a little house that i think my parents provided for them and they were a lovely old couple as i remember he was romanian and my grandfather i think was german jewish her maiden name had been wagner and even they weren't really religious i remember friday dinners when i was a little girl and i remember that she made Jewish food. She was a good Jewish cook. And I remember my grandfather read the Daily Forward in Hebrew, the four of it, so whatever. And he played pinochle with his male friends at the beach someplace. But no, we didn't go to temple. I don't think we really observed Jewish holidays. I was an adult before I ever went to a Seder dinner that I can remember.
We belonged to the Jewish Country Club. And, of course, my father, I mean, when you think about, you don't talk about Jewish comics. My father was not a Jewish comic. Jackie Mason is a Jewish comic. My father was a comic who happened to be Jewish, like George Burns. I mean, but he wasn't a Catskill or a Jewish comic. There was never any, there wasn't a lot of talk about it. I mean, we were absolutely, my mother, of course, was Jewish, too. Her maiden name was Marx. There was never any talk about, there was never any problem with, we were a Jewish family. There was no question about that. There was never any hiding it. There was never anything like that. But it wasn't a religious Jewish family. We celebrated Christmas. But then a lot of families in Beverly Hills did at that time. Yes? Yes?
Was my father witty? Did he tell jokes offstage? And what about George Burns? Well, George Burns is, I think, the funniest man I ever knew in my life. One of the great privileges of my life was the fact that they were best friends and the fact that, excuse me, that I grew up spending, you know, two days a week at dinner at their house and they spent two days a week at dinner at our house. We were together all the time. And, as I said, it was one of the great privileges. the relationship is one that grew from the very early vaudeville days when they first met and when george burns first made my father laugh it became like the conditioning that he did with his audience it became almost a conditioned relationship it was a symbiotic relationship they fed on each other george played dirty tricks on my father and my father would fall on the floor laughing and it got to be To the extent, as I said, it became so conditioned that one of the famous stories was when my father went to Hillcrest and George didn't say anything. You know, he said hello and didn't say much after that. And a few minutes later, my father was on the floor pounding the floor laughing and George said, what are you laughing about? He said, I didn't do anything. And my father said, yeah, but you're doing it on purpose. I mean, it was that bad. I tell you, they were so hilarious together.
And the sad thing about it is that there's no way to repeat these evenings or repeat the things that happened and to begin to convey how truly funny they were. As the old thing, you had to be there. But you not only had to be there, you had to have been there for 10 years. I mean, you had to have seen this relationship, as I say, to the point where George didn't have to say a word. And my father was on the floor. It was an unbelievable relationship. And no, my father wasn't funny at home. What you saw was what you got. He was the one the jokes were always played on the screen or on the stage. And that's what he was at home. That's not to say he couldn't be funny. If he had to come up with a line, I mean, it was like a challenge if somebody gave him a straight line where they're waiting for Jack Benny to say something funny, he could do that. He would say something funny. But he wasn't a wit.
Brett Allen was a wit. I think Larry Goldbart is a wit. You know, you say something to him, and you've got an answer like that, and it's funny, that acerbic kind of wonderful quick retort. He wasn't like that at all. Yes? Yes? I'm sorry. About 10, 12 years ago, there was a special on the network TV with Bob Hope and George Burns, and he was talking about letters to Jack Benny. Yes. Did I participate in the show that was called Love Letter to Jack Benny? It was something that was done after his death, and it was a tribute kind of thing to him. No. The answer is a simple no. I didn't participate in it. I watched it, but I had nothing to do with it. Yeah, I'm sorry. The lady back there.
My close friends today in the business are a very mixed bag and quite different from. I have kept up with some of my old friends. I still see Barbara Getz, who is now Barbara Windham, who was L.B. Mayor's granddaughter. We're still close friends. One of my closest friends is Maria Cooper Janis, Gary Cooper's daughter. We've kept up with each other. Let me think. My closest girlfriend is somebody you wouldn't know, but her father was an executive back then, and we grew up together. He was an executive at 20th and then at Universal International. His name was Rufus Lemaire, but I don't think too many people know him.
