Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
The Jack Benny Program artwork

From the The Jack Benny Program collection

Joan Benny: Same Time, Same Station

Episode76 min 59 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 61 min to read

You're listening to National Public Radio for Southern California. Members supported, FM 89.3 KPCC Pasadena. A broadcast service of Pasadena City College. This is Frank Nelson. You're listening to Same Time, Same Station with your hosts John and Larry Gassman on KPCC Pasadena. When I was young, I'd listen to the radio. This is the National Broadcasting Company.

Bob Trout speaking. This is the Columbia Broadcasting System. This is Mutual. This is ABC Radio Network. Will there ever be another Jack Penning? Never. Never. He is one alone. There will never be another one. They will try to impersonate him, imitate him, do things like he does, but there would never, never be another Jack. He was a member of an era that is fast dwindling in ranks, as we all recognize. And there just aren't people of that stature that are coming along on the scene today. Offstage, Jack is a very liberal, nice man, nice, warm human being. He's generous, kind. I love Jack. Good evening and welcome to Same Time, Same Station. I'm Dan Haefeli, along with Larry and John Gassman. And I guess this microphone will work a little better, won't it?

Tonight on Same Time, Same Station, we are going to have an interesting conversation with Joan Benny, who has recently published a book, Sunday Nights at 7, The Jack Benny Story. And we'll talk with her about her life growing up with one of America's most famous families in show business, and specifically about her parents, Mary Livingston and Jack Benny. Along with me, Larry and John Gassman. Hello, Larry and John. Hello, Dan. And we might as well just go right to the phones after we remind listeners also that during our conversation with Joan Benny tonight, we'll take your phone calls. Our telephone number, 818-793-3667. That's 818-793-3667. You might want to write that down. And later on, or even now, you can give us a call.

Conference you with Joan Benny. And before we do that, we have probably one of my favorite Jack Benny cuts. For those of you who remember Jack, you'll know all about him. For those of you who have not heard him in a little while, we thought we would start with a little bit of Jack when he first met the Colemans in 1945. And George Balzer remembers this as one of the classiest shows that they ever did. And this only runs about a minute and nine seconds, but it gives you, I think, a wonderful illustration as to the characterizations of Jack Benny, just in this one minute. The Coleman's are at dinner, and unbeknownst to them, Jack has decided to, well, he believes mistakenly that he's got an invitation to dinner. So he comes to dinner, and the results are hilarious. So is that. Let's hear it. Hello, Ronnie, Benita.

Uh, hello, Jack. Come in. Yes, yes. Come in. We're just about to have a cocktail. Mr. Benny, this is our friend Jack Wellington. Pleased to meet you, old chap. Well, I didn't expect anyone else to be here, but that's just like the Coleman. Always room for one more. Yes, sir. Ronnie. Oh, yes. Yes, sir. Well, the cocktails are ready. A toast. Benita, your health. Wellington, happy days. Benny, good luck. Too hard. I'm sorry. I didn't mean to break the glass. Oh, that set was 150 years old. Well, I'm glad I didn't break any of your new stuff. Jack Benny and Ronald and Benita Coleman on same time, same station. Let's say hello to Joan Benny. Joan, are you with us?

I'm with you. Good. What comes to mind when you hear a cut like that? Well, such nostalgia and such fun because, quite frankly, I don't hear the shows very often. As a matter of fact, I confess, I haven't heard most of them since they were originally done when I was a very little girl. And so that is almost brand new to me. What is amazing is how well they hold up and how funny they still are. And I find myself laughing at these shows. People think, well, Isn't that nuts? Because obviously she hears them all the time. Well, I don't. And they're wonderful. You know, this show holds up better than probably most, maybe the best of all of the comedy series. Some of them are a little dated. But good material holds up no matter how old it is. I guess that's the answer. It's amazing. I've just been on a book tour, and I've had people come up to me who say that they play these tapes in their car. And my 9-year-old is hysterical. My 9-year-old just loves these.

And the next one, my 12-year-old laughs all the time. And isn't that nice to hear that? It's wonderful. A lot of people come up to us as well who have kids. And if they had their way, we would be playing Jack Benny programs yearly. Every night of the week. Every week, yeah. It holds up very, very well. Oh, that's so nice. As I said, it's just so nice to hear. Was it difficult at all, or is it difficult for you shortly, say, after your father and mother's deaths, to hear and watch them? No, not really, because, well, this sounds very strange, but my father never really died for me. You know, he's so much alive, even today, 16 years later.

So I never felt a sadness. I enjoyed the book more than anything. It was a kind of, gee, there's Daddy. What about the book? I mean, why the book? Jack was a very nice, nice man, generous, and everyone who talked about him said he didn't have a mean bone in his body. Why the book about Jack Benny? Well, of course, what you said was true, and I think perhaps I'm going to rephrase your question as to why the delay about a book. Jack Benny. And what you said is almost the reason, or one of the many reasons for the delay, is I was so afraid that nobody was going to buy a book about a nice man, because I couldn't write Daddy Dearest. It would have been quite impossible. And I thought, well, gee, people want to read, you know, Dishy and Gossipy, and they're just, that's just my father. You know, in his own autobiography, and by the way, as obviously you know, this is Jack Benny by Jack Benny.

written about six years before he died, and never published. And I think the reason it was never published then, and of course then I had nothing to do with it, was my father says in his own introduction, if I had known I was going to write an autobiography, I would have had three or four affairs. So he really had the same problem. Then, many years later, after my mother passed away, and the manuscript or autobiography then became my property, so to speak, was the first time I really read it. The time he wrote it, quite frankly, I was busy with four children to raise and a husband and a life of my own. And writing that autobiography was simply one of his many projects. And I didn't place all that much importance on it at the time. It was later when it was rediscovered, so to speak, that I read it and discovered so much about his childhood that I really didn't know. Daddy wasn't a man who reminisced a lot, except with George Burns. And then they talked about...

But he didn't talk at any great length about his childhood. I knew his father, and I knew, you know, his Waukegan background, and I knew that he studied violin and that he got into vaudeville. But the details, there's so many funny stories and so much stuff that I had never heard before. And so when I read this, I thought, well, gee, this should be published. Besides, you know, it's the first time anybody will have read Jack Benny by Jack Benny in his own words. Did you know about the... Did you know about the manuscript before your father's death? Oh, yes, as I mentioned, I did know that he was doing it. But I repeat, I didn't place any great importance on it because it was just one of many projects he was doing. You might be interested to know, you mentioned George Burns. One of the little surprises that we attempted to...

to bring on the show today was George Burns, but I guess everyone who has ever interviewed you has thought the same thing, and so Jack Langdon said, no, if we let him do one, then he has to do all of them. So he wishes you the best, but wasn't able to be here on the show today. I guess he's getting ready for a 95th birthday party, which CBS is going to televise in January. January. Yeah. So that ought to be something unique in itself. I would think so. He's remarkable. Oh, yeah. He's just wonderful. I saw him last week, and he's just as sharp, and he's really just remarkable. Still smoking those cigars? Smoking the cigars and drinking the martini. Yeah, not necessarily in that order. Well, you know his wonderful line about that, which is my favorite, when somebody said to him, you know, what does your doctor say? He said, my doctor's dead. In fact, I think he's working on a new book, isn't he, concerning the...

Dedicating it to the six widows of the doctors he's had, I think, is what it is. We have some telephone calls, don't we, Dan? Yes, we do. Why don't we go to one right now? And we have Al in Sepulveda. Hi, Al. Hi. You're on the air with Joan Benny. Okay, Joan? Yes. Hi. Hi. I was a great admirer of your dad. Thank you. And for the last 39 years, it's been fun going around my 39th birthday 28 times. Don't we all? Really. And I wanted you to know that I think I lay claim to the only dollar bill that ever got away from him. It's my favorite story with and about your dad. He appeared at the Carousel Theater in West Covina. I remember that. And after the show, like all the others, I lined up online to get his autograph, and I put a dollar bill in front of him. And he just signed it and went right on by without any further noticing.

Later, though, and all through life since I've had that, I keep telling everyone this is the one dollar bill that got away from Jack. That's a cute story. It's been fun all the way around. It's been very nice talking to you. Thank you. Thank you. You're listening to Same Time, Same Station. Our guest this evening is Joan Benny, and we have another telephone call. Dan, you're going to have to tell me where this one's coming from. Sure. Our friend Walden in Costa Mesa is with us. Hi, Walden. Hello. Hello. This is you, Walden? Yeah. Good. Go right ahead. Okay, I got two questions for you, Mrs. Finney. Yes? I don't know if you know the first one or not, but as you know, your dad co-starred with Joe Lombard in the last movie. And then when the plane went down, your dad, I guess, decided not to go on the air that Sunday. I want to know, did he make the decision in a hurry, or did he think about it, you know? Well, of course, that was before my time. That happened in 1942. And I don't know how the decision was made, quite frankly.

how old I was only eight years old. So I really can't answer you. I'm sorry. Okay. And the other question, I think that year Jack celebrated his 10th anniversary on the radio. That's correct. And he, you appeared at the tail end of the show. Did they do that from the house or embassy remote? My recollection is it was done from the house. Um, I seem to remember being in our library and that's where, and that's, that's again, It was a long time ago, and that's all I remember. It was done from the house. Yeah, it was done from the house. Okay, thank you. You know more than I. Well, you'll hear it in a little while. We brought that clip with us today, so we'll play it in a couple of seconds. Interestingly enough, when they... Excuse me, you have a clip of that of me? Yes. Sure. Oh, we have a couple of them with you. I've never heard that, not ever.

Okay, well, we'll have to put some things together and get them to you. Oh, what fun. Yeah, it is fun. One other question, guys. It's number three. Thanks, John. We know that George Burns was your dad's close friend. Who was your mom's close friend in Hollywood during her lifetime? I'm sorry, I couldn't hear that. Who was your mom's close friend? We know that George was your dad's... Oh, my mom's close friend. Well, I think way back. I mean, I guess they changed a bit over the years, but... Her closest friends through the years were Barbara Stanwyck and Claudette Colbert and Gracie. Those are the three I remember best. Later, you know, Freddy DeCordova, who's the producer of The Tonight Show, his wife, was a very, very close friend of my mother's, and the director, Billy Wilder's wife, Audrey. Okay. Okay, Walden. Thanks a lot, guys. Thank you. Now, we talked a little bit about the clip from 1941. Yes. And this is done from your house.

And to set it up really quickly, it's Jack's 10th anniversary in radio. And so they did a 10th anniversary broadcast, a special show. After that show, he went to Los Angeles and they did a big gala dinner for him as well, which is interesting. But this little clip went from New York with a lot of his friends saying hello and then Chicago. And then eventually to Los Angeles where he went to Jack and Mary and you as about an 8-year-old child. So this ought to be interesting for you to listen to as well. You've got to turn your mic on. You're right. Am I going to have to cue you all night? No. This is from May 9th of 1941, and Jack and Mary are just getting ready to go to the big gala affair, and you come in near the end of the scene. As a matter of fact, something rather unique about this whole thing is he thanks a lot of the people in the early days who were responsible for the show. Oh, yeah, everybody. Why don't we hear that real quick? Okay.

I was seven, by the way. Yeah, okay. Let's go, Craig. See you Wednesday. Wrong one. Okay, well, we're eventually going to get to it anyway. That was the wrong one, but that's okay. It's only a ten-second theme. That particular cut that we just played was when Jack said goodnight to you, which brings up a question while we're waiting for Craig to cue up the cut we want to hear. Did you really sit around the radio at night? On Sunday nights, waiting for your father to say goodnight to you and we'll see you Wednesday and so forth when he was, say, out of town in New York? No, because I wasn't allowed to stay up that late. I had to listen to the shows on the acetates the next day. Okay. That's interesting. In reading one of George Burns' books, I think it was Gracie, it mentioned that Sandy and Ronnie would...

Well, at least George, for many years, thought they always listened to the show, and it turned out later on that they had had copies of the scripts, they read the scripts, and they knew what was going to be happening during the show, and while the show was on, they were doing other things. So I figured maybe you had a similar thing, because this is like 6, 6.37 o'clock, I guess, at night. Yes, no, in the early days, I remember I wasn't allowed to listen to it, but I'm talking about when I was maybe four or five years old. Then later, of course, I did listen to it. But I think it was in those very early days that he said, goodnight, Joanie. Or that was before I was, you know, I'm a little confused back then, but that was before I was allowed to go to the studio when he used to say, goodnight, Joanie. That was when I was listening to it. Yeah. We're ready to listen now to the little clip from 1941. Hey, Jack, this is going to be a pretty big affair. Don't you think you ought to wear a full dress suit instead of your tuxedo? This is a full dress suit. Well, where are the tails?

Oh, for heaven's sake, can't you see? Well, I'll be darned, I got them tucked in my pants. Imagine that. Gee, I'm so nervous. Gee, I hope I can remember my speech tonight. Well, if you forget it, I'll finish it for you. I've only heard it a thousand times. I mustn't forget to mention the people who have been associated with me during all these years. Let's see, of course, I'll mention my present cast. You know, Don Wilson, Phil Harris, Dennis Day, and Rochester. And Mary Livingston. Yes, of course. Oh, and don't forget Andy Devine and Schlepperman. That's right. Andy and Schlepp. And then I want to mention Ed Sullivan again. You know, he was the first one that I was on the air for. And then when I first started out on Canada Dry Ginger Ale, see, there was Ed Thorgerson, George Hicks, George Olson. You remember George Olson? Yes. And Paul Douglas, Ted Weems. And Andrea Marsh. Yeah, Andrea. Of course, Andrea. And there was a bunch who worked with me on Chevrolet.

Remember, there was Frank Black, James Melton, Howard Kleeney. And then, yeah, then later on in that same series, there was Frank Parker and Alois Havrilla. And Mary Livingston. Mary, everybody knows that. Let's see, and then when we went on General Tires after that, that's where Don Wilson joined us. And also Don Bester. And remember those spats he used to wear? Yeah, I bet he's still got them on. Now, let's see, where did we go from General Tires? To Jell-O. Oh, yes, good old Jell-O. That was back in 34. And then a little later on, Johnny Green joined us. Gosh, how he used to play the piano. Yeah. Oh, and don't forget Michael Bartlett. That's right, Michael Bartlett. And then Kenny Baker came along. Remember how bashful he was? Yeah, uh-huh. That Kenny was a swell kid. I wonder what program he's on now. He's with Fred Allen, and you know it. Well, anyway...

After Kenny. Oh, yeah, Jimmy Greer and Abe Lyman, they were with us when we traveled. Remember? Then let's see. Oh, yeah, then Phil Harris joined us. Remember how corny he was in those days? What do you mean, in those days? Well, that's just about brings us up to date, Mary. Gee, you've worked with a lot of people, haven't you, Jack? Those aren't the only ones, Mary. How about my writers? Bill Morrow and Ed Boulogne were writing my programs now. And remember Harry Kahn that used to write my programs? Yes, uh-huh. And how about all the other actors and actresses that appeared from time to time? Gee, they were all swell, too. Say, it's getting late. I think we better get started. Yeah. Gee, you think I look all right, Mary? I wonder if I ought to wear a carnation. Why don't you wear a bachelor button? It'll bring out your big blue eyes. No, I'll just wear this carnation. Well, look who's here. Hello, Joanie. Hello, Daddy. Hello, Mommy. Joanie, dear, we've got to leave now, so I think you better kiss Mommy and Daddy goodbye.

Why, Joanie, Benny, you're not going to the banquet. Why are you wearing an evening dress? Oh, Daddy, you're still silly. This is a nightgown. Well, I was only kidding. She thinks I'm always silly. Goodbye, sweetheart. Goodbye, Daddy. Pull your tails out. Oh, yes. I forgot. You know, Mary, I think... Mary, I think Joanie is going to grow up to be just like you. Come on, doll. Let's go. Now, what did you think of that, Joan? I thought I was very good. Is that a little eerie to hear yourself? Little kids are. Little kids are really good at that age without really even trying to work at it, seemingly. That's right. That's so funny. Were you reading that? Pardon me? Were you reading that, or did you memorize those lines? Do you know? Oh, no, I think I was reading it. You do? Mm-hmm. That was fun to listen to. We've got another one of you a little later on. You appeared at least, we can figure out, at least four times on the show.

I don't remember that at all. Actually, three times. Three times? I've been asked, was I ever on the show, and I've said no. Yeah, you were on three times that I know of. See, what a bad memory I have. Well, you shouldn't have to remember that stuff, which was quite a while ago. It's no wonder that you don't remember specifics about it. But you were on once in 1949, and then a couple of times in 1950. And all three of the shows exist. I've got one of them, and so we'll... Send it to me if you want to. Oh, I'd love that. I'd appreciate that. Oh, sure. It seemed odd to hear your dad without a studio audience, though, on that particular clip. Yeah. That goes back to the early days at CBS and Canada Drive when they didn't have an audience all that often. For those of you who have just tuned in on Same Time, Same Station at KPCC Pasadena, we're talking with Joan Benny about the book that, in a way, she and her dad did separately yet together.

Sunday nights at 7, taking her dad's manuscript and then adding her own thoughts and memories. If you'd like to join us on same time, same station and talk with her, our number is 818-793-3667. And we'll try to get to phone calls as best and quickly as we can. Like this one right here, we have Myron in La Cunada. Hi, Myron. Hi. You're on the air. Thank you. Johnny, I have one question concerning Phil Harris. It was a perfect foil for you. And I'm curious as to, could you shed some light on the nature of his departure, which I think took place in 1952? On his departure from the show? Yeah, it seemed so peculiar that someone who was as important to the show as that would leave. And I do recall the program, when they came back for the new season, when I guess he had Bob Crosby taking his place, they just mentioned very rapidly that...

Oh, yes, he had another show to do and he was very busy. But I'm sort of wondering if there wasn't anything else occurring during that period. Well, it seems to me that he got his own show. Larry, you might know better than I. He did. He did get his own show. He'd been working for Fitch. But I was just curious because it seems that they were absolutely perfectly matched for one another. And, of course, Phil Harris' show I don't think ever really took off. No, it didn't, but I think that was the reason that he left my father's show, was that he had his own show. I know he was also doing movies and recordings, and he'd been doing Fitch, and then eventually... Rexall and RCA. Rexall and RCA, so he was getting busier and busier. Well, there was another reason, though. Was there any problem that he might have been a second banana? Because he was a star in his own right. Well, there was another reason. The other reason was that Harris felt a little more loyalty to NBC. Aha, and then he went to CBS. Right.

One final question, if I could. What was the rationale for the ending lines in the program, we're a little late, so good night, folks? I don't quite understand why that was the end of every show. It wasn't. You're hearing a lot of that on KNX. Yes. That's prepackaged. The opening theme and closing themes are the same ones you hear every week, and the remarks saying we're a little late, folks, is prepackaged. Oh, I see. So that didn't end every week. No, no, no. Only when they ran out of time. Okay, so that they didn't run out of time every week. No, no, no. Fred Allen did a lot, but that was his problem. And that's another story. That's another program. Okay, well, thank you so much. You're welcome. Thank you. I'm sorry that some of these questions I leave to you because I don't know as much about the technical end of it as you do. Well, no, that's okay. All you need to do is... I can answer the personal questions. Right. We'll put you to work then.

We'll put you to work between now and the next few minutes to ask some more questions about Jack from the personal side as well, because the three books that came out earlier were more in line with Jack's, well, the two books actually, not the one that Marsha Voorhees wrote, but the first two were more in line with his public character. So this is kind of interesting to see Jack from a personal side and growing up. With Jack. We'll ask you when we return from our break about growing up with a celebrity, what that was like for you. Okay. We will do that in just a few moments. But first, we'll remind you, you're listening to Same Time, Same Station with Joan Benny and Johnny Larry Gassman and Dan Haefeli. And we'll be right back right after this. Hi, this is Gary Nistley inviting you to kick off your weekend with one of Southern California's hottest blues programs, Rockin' and Jumpin' the Blues.

If you like your blues low down and dirty, then check out some of the legendary blues stars from the late 1940s and 50s all the way to the brand new blues coming out here in the 1990s. That's Rockin' and Jumpin' the Blues with Gary Nistley every Friday night from 8 to 10 p.m. Join me this week on KPCC Pasadena. This is Same Time, Same Station with John and Larry Gassman and Dan Haefeli, and our special guest this evening is Joan Benny. We'll be playing clips here and there as time progresses, and of course, for those who... are waiting at 6.30 or so for the Cinnamon Bear, our Christmas fantasy offering. We'll be getting to the Cinnamon Bear as well. And we've got some other surprises as the time moves along. Now, before we broke, we asked you about growing up as the daughter of a celebrity in Hollywood. What was that like? It was wonderful. For me, it was wonderful. Again, you know, you hear the Daddy Dearest, or Mommy Dearest, actually. And, of course, my experience wasn't like that at all. I had wonderful friends.

father and a mother I got along with reasonably well. I mean, that's in the book. My mother and I had our problems together. Of course, Daddy, I was the apple of his eye, as most daughters are with their father. But the daughter of a celebrity side of it, that was, for me, very normal because my closest friends early on were children of celebrities. And so it seemed quite the normal thing. Sandy Burns was my closest friend, George's daughter. And my other friends were Gary Cooper's daughter and Joan Bennett's daughter and Loretta Young's daughter. So we all had celebrity parents. That was simply the norm. But in my own case, as I look back on it, it seems like it almost has two sides to it. I was on one show, this is an aside, that my son Bobby saw. And I said, I was a little nervous. And I said, well, there was a kind of duality about it. The next day my son called me and he said, Mom, did you have to say duality? Couldn't you have just said weird? I said, well, honey, I was nervous. It was the first word that came into my mind. He said, well, it sounds so intellectual. Anyway, let me put it this way. There were two sides to growing up as a celebrity's daughter, in this case, Jack Benny's. There was the side that was, you know, Daddy had privileges. He was treated wonderfully. He was famous. And I kind of basked in that glory and that was a little part of my life. I also learned at a very early age that he's entitled to all that fancy treatment and you're not. I mean, you didn't do anything to deserve any red carpet, so forget it right now. And I had to make my bed in the morning and I got my allowance and I had to go to school and do my homework and I had to have good manners and I had to respect my elders and I had to write thank you notes.

All of that. I was very strictly brought up, really. And as I said, learned at an early age that I was, as they say, when you go to a premiere, nobody. You know, the fans stick their head in the car and yell to the bleachers, who's in the car? And when I was little, it was that Jack Benny and Mary Livingston. And then when I got a little older and went with my friends, they'd stick their head in the car and yell, that's nobody. I guess that's all a part of growing up in the Hollywood surroundings. Something like that. Yeah. That same son, Bobby, when he was about seven years old, we were someplace. He was with his little sister, Joanna, who was sick. And we were someplace with my father, and they made a big fuss over him. So Bobby turned to me, and he said, Mommy, is Granddaddy famous? And I said, Yes, honey, Granddaddy's famous. There's a pause. He said, Are we famous?

He said, no, honey, you're not famous. Another pause. He said, well, we're pretty well known for our age. The wisdom of a seven-year-old. You mentioned a little bit ago about growing up with the Burns children. But you were good friends with Sandra Burns for quite a while, weren't you? Oh, absolutely. Was she your best friend for a long time? Maybe you've got another story or two that connects with the Bernses or the Bennys or both from your view as a child. Well, there's a great deal of that in the book, and I can only, I mean, when you mention that, you know how the photographs flash in your mind. Right. And I had an instant photograph of their living room, the Bernses' living room, and at the same time our living room, which were almost interchangeable. Our houses were very similar. And whenever we were in really deep trouble, that was where the conference took place.

I can see the two sets of parents. And I tell about it in the book. Sandy eloped. She was 18, who aided and abetted to Las Vegas. And I remember coming home at like 4 in the morning after she and Jim had gotten married at this little chapel. And we drove home. And by now, we had awakened Tony Martin. It's a long story, but you've got to buy the book and find out. So we get home. We go back to the Burnses. And there are the four of them, George and Gracie and my father and mother. My father and mother, of course, had been awakened in the middle of the night to discover what had gone on. And my mother was in her nightgown and robe, and they drove over to the Burns' those scenes. Fascinating, isn't it? Other things like that specifically call to mind.

When you're talking about Sandra Burns, I think, not word for word, but George Burns described a scene similar to that in the book when he talked about the elopement as well. And you mentioned as well that the houses were similar. Were they built, I would assume, around the same time as well, back in Beverly Hills? Yeah, George's house was built first, because they came to Hollywood before my parents did. And then our house was built, I'd say, about a mile and a half away. both in the flats of Beverly Hills. And our house was the same architect and very similar, exactly the same style and very similar in room layout and the look of the two houses. But, you know, Sandy and I were just always getting in trouble. And then along came Ronnie, and Ronnie was the adored son, the only son, of course. So he took press over Sandy, the older sister. And whenever Ronnie got in trouble, he always blamed it on us, and he always won.

And we really had a time. We had a great time. Lots of mischief and lots of tearing up. When you think of people specifically who you knew through, well, just being around your father, who are some of the favorites who come to mind, who maybe came to the house or people that you associated with who were stars in Hollywood? Well, I mentioned Barbara Sandwick and Robert Taylor. Way back when, they were very close friends. And that's, of course, when they were married. So that goes back to the 40s. And Claudette Colbert and her husband were great favorites of mine. Jane Wyman was a great favorite because she was always so nice to me. And she treated me like a person, not like a dumb kid. So I thought she was pretty terrific. Frank Sinatra was always very nice to me and one of my pets. And then when I was 14 years old, I met Clark Gable and never got over.

So you had crushes on these people even back then who were luminaries to a lot of people even in Hollywood. Yes, and to me there was that same, and I use the word Bobby Hayden, duality. They were Aunt Barbara and Uncle Bob, who were my parents' closest friends on one side, and I treated them as such. Close friends of my parents, you know, very casual, like all the time. But on the other side, they were... Barbara Stanwyck and Robert Taylor, and I saw Waterloo Bridge and Double Indemnity, and I had their autographs, I had autographed pictures, and I was as starstruck as anyone. So there was kind of two sides to my life. Growing up in Hollywood, back then, really meant something. Today, when you hear about people growing up in Hollywood, it has a completely different meaning. And I wonder if it'll ever be the same in terms of the kinds of special magic.

that is perceived by the public that was evident back then? Oh, no, it will never be the same. I don't know that it's any worse or any better. It just will never be the same. And, you know, I look back on it, and you think of the sort of golden age of Hollywood, and I was fortunate in that that is the time period that I grew up. I think about it now, and it's almost as though, was I really there, or did I dream it? Did I really know those people? They were bigger than life, you know? And that's no longer true of movie stars. There are very few today who are bigger than life. Yeah, that's a time gone by, actually. Yeah, long gone by in terms of those who were big back then that aren't specifically now. I mean, you think of John Wayne and Gary Cooper and Clark Gable. I mean, come on. They were bigger than life. And no one comes to mind when you think of names, at least not to me.

Nowadays, I can't think of anybody who would be as big as Clark Gable, Gary Cooper, and many of the others that you've mentioned. That's right. Or for as long a period of time, either. That's true, too. Longevity is something that's kind of gone from show business. Maybe we should quickly mention that this is Same Time, Same Station on KPCC Pasadena. And if you'd like to join us in our conversations with Joan Benny, our number in the 818 dialing area is 793-3667. You're invited to join us. on same time, same station. You know, we talked about writers back then. Not we, but Jack was talking about writers, the people who wrote his show. In the clip that we heard, a lot of the writers, some of the cast members, and he mentioned Ed Boulogne, and he mentioned Bill Murrell, who were the writers of the show, when that particular clip took place. A couple years later, 1943, a new set of writers.

began working the show with George Balzer and John Takaberry and Milt Josephsburg and Sam Perrin. Well, George Balzer is on the line with us now. George, are you there? I'm here. Hi, George. Joanie, how are you? I'm fine. It's good to have you on the phone. Can we have our own private conversation? Oh, my gosh. We have so much to talk about. Incidentally, you don't mind my calling you Joanie. To me, you've always been Joanie. I know that. And that was the name your father always used. That's right. You go back quite a number of years together. I'd say we do, yes. Well, I think I go back to about 43. That's 47 years ago. I didn't know how much you wanted to get into those figures.

Well, I wrote the book and the date of my birth is mentioned, so I guess I'm stuck with it. Marvelous. As I recall, the first time I met you, we met at the depot going to New York on the train. And I think you were eight years old at the time. Right. And I was about 12, I think. But it was a wonderful relationship working for your dad. So absolutely, when it came to talent to have to perform, whether in writing or at the microphone, he was the best. He made everybody so at ease. And, of course, he got the best out of them. Yeah. And it was just wonderful. Do you remember when I used to come in the library when I was a little girl and listen to you all writing the show? Oh, sure. Many times.

That was my next question. I wondered if you were privy to some of the writing sessions that went on. Oh, I used to love that. I'd come home from grade school, get my milk and cookies, and quietly sneak into the library where the four writers, my father and Secretary Jean, were at the table. And there was a little chair way in the corner, and I would sit in the corner, quiet as a mouse, and listen to them writing the show. That's right. It was just great. So you saw some of those floor-pounding experiences that have become so legendary. Of course. Oh, yes. Yes, Joni was in on what was going on at that time. And fortunately, we had a lot of fun. I think that was the big secret that made the show such a success. I remember it that way. We did have fun, and there was... I can't remember.

any time where there was panic. I just can't remember any time where there was panic. And that's saying something for a weekly show, because that could become a grind after a while to have to come up with new, fresh material every week. Well, you know, there's another secret, too. We fortunately, with the writers and with Jack, between us, we kind of knew when the show was right. And after we reached that point... We didn't pick at it anymore. And I believe today there are a lot of shows that reach a point where it's just right, but it happens to be Wednesday. They've got two days yet, so they pick it apart, and by the time it goes on the air, it's a shambles. Excuse me, there's a point about comedy that I really wanted to ask George. That in watching television today, watching sitcoms, I see a joke, and it always seems to me that they wrote it backwards. Do you know what I'm saying? It's like somebody said, this is a funny punchline. Now let's think of something that leads to it. Well, it's very true that some of the material does sound that way, and many times they will get into a conversation bit, which is to be funny, and they'll get right up to the joke.

and never do the joke. They don't realize that they really were right there and could have done this big joke, which was very obvious to me because I kind of follow them as they're building, and then when they're about ready to do it, they don't do it, they start something else. Why do you think that happens, George? I think it's because, and I hate to say this, I think there's a lot of people involved in comedy today. who really don't know too much about comedy. Ah, I'll go along with that. I don't know why you'd hate to say that, George. I think it's pretty evident. You know, I mean, time is... The business has sort of passed me by, and they have to now do their thing, which I don't understand. But that's it. Well, the decision-making process could be another topic for another show, I think. Sure, sure.

Joan, I was wondering, do you remember the reasoning behind or the situation which brought you into appearing on the show for the first time? Who made the decision? Now, you're talking about the first time we, as writers, we appeared on the show? No, Joan. Joan appeared on the show. Oh, Joan. Yeah. Well, as I told you before, when you played that, I don't even remember being on the show. So, George, help. Do you remember George? Yes, I remember when Joni was on the radio show, she was selling Girl Scout cookies. That's right. I was? Yes. Isn't that right? That's right. That's exactly right. Sure. From 1949. Now, I'll tell you why, well, yeah, this worked out so well. Joni came to the door and she was selling Girl Scout cookies, which gave us a very nice routine.

And the audience, of course, the studio audience, anyway, appreciated that this was Jack's daughter. And they just reacted great. It was just great. I didn't mean to get off when I said the writers. We appeared on the show a few times. And the reason we did, I did, I was on the show, oh, several times, is because any time we had to cast, Jack always tried to get the real people. We didn't get an actor and then give him a name if we could get the real person. And Jack just felt that it's much funnier if we were traveling and in the city and we had to do a routine about a mayor, we got the mayor. Or if we're in the capital of the state, we would get the governor. And it just gave great realism to this. I think that's great.

played so much better to have these people actually a part of the show because you never knew for sure what was going to happen because they were untested in reading scripts. Sometimes it worked real well, other times great ad-lib bloopers occurred. But actually, Jack had that ability to put even those who were inexperienced with radio and so forth at such great ease that somehow or other it came out just fine. They had confidence, I'm sure, in his abilities, and everything was going to turn out okay. They trusted him, sure. That's right. Yeah. Good. George, I want to thank you for coming on with us. Well... You've had a wonderful time, and you've helped us especially set up a clip that we're going to play fairly soon about Joni and the Girl Scout cookies, because that was interesting. Dennis Day has a nice large part in this as well. Oh, fine. Yeah. Just before I go, I had the...

Well, I talked to Phil Harris a couple of weeks ago. He called me about, oh, something. He wanted the name of somebody from out of the past which had slipped his mind, and he called me. So I gave me a chance to kind of go over the past shows with him, and it was a lot of fun. And it's also been great to have this chance to talk to Joni. For me, too. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you, George. Okay, bye-bye. Bye-bye. We'll talk to you soon. You bet. That's George Balzer, one of the writers on the Jack Benny Show. We're talking with Joan Benny on KPCC and Same Time, Same Station, where our phone number is 818-793-3667. And we've got several callers who are waiting. It's a good time as any to go on to the phone lines, I guess, right? Okay. Okay, why don't we go first to David in Placentia. Hi, David. You're on Same Time, Same Station. Hi. Hi there.

Uh, Joan? Yes? I heard a rumor, or I forget if Mary said it on the Tonight Show, I believe, that while they were alive, or while Jack was alive, he was sending a red rose to her every day, and that it was still being done after he died. I wanted to know if that was still happening. It was a rumor. Oh, I see. And are you going to be doing any signings? Oh, I wish I were. No, I'm going back to New York in a couple of days. Golly, I'd love to sign a book for you. I wish there was a way to do that. I'm so happy when anybody buys a book, and I'm so thrilled to sign them. Well, I started reading it just recently, and it's wonderful. And Jack is before my time, but KNX editions, and usually Saturday night at my house, so that I can tape those. I still believe that Jack Benny is probably the leading comedian still to this day. Well, thank you. That's the best plug I could get.

And, David, tune in here Christmas Eve for our 11-hour marathon at 6 o'clock. Oh, I will. You'll hear some Jack Benny shows. Great. And if there comes a time, Joan, when you do do some signings here in the Southern California area, we'll let the listeners know, too. Okay, thank you. We might be able to set one up. Thank you. Thank you, David. Thank you. Thank you so much. 818-793-3667 is our number on same time, same station. And let's go now to Los Angeles and talk to Daryl. Yes. This question is for Mrs. Benny. Mrs. Benny? Yes? First of all, I would like to say I listen to your favorite show on a certain radio station here or in the early hours of Sunday morning when they have it repeated again. On KNX, yeah. They do it at 9 and then they repeat it at 2, yeah. Yes.

As I mentioned, this question is for Mr. Benny, and it's about one of the characters that he mentioned earlier, he being Mr. Benny, Rochester. How did Rochester get on the Jack Benny show, and how long did he stay on it? Did he stay on it on radio and TV? Yes, he was on the entire time. He originally came on as he auditioned to play a part that the writers had written. The show had to do with my father moving from New York to California and taking the train. and this was in the mid-30s, and they needed a character to play what was then a stereotypical railway porter. Rochester auditioned for the part, and he got it. And he was so popular on that one show, and my father liked him so much that the rest is history. Yes, so I think somebody said he stayed on the show for 20 years on both radio and TV? Yes, at least that. That's true. In fact, interestingly enough, when Eddie Anderson first, was brought on the show, he'd appear every four to five weeks. And in June of 1937, they had him appear finally as Jack's valet at the movie studio. Now, before this, he was like, say, for example, a clerk or other roles, but not a valet attached to Jack until this one day when he was in the studio. And then he disappeared until January of 1938, when suddenly, magically, he was there as Rochester. And...

stayed on the show from that time on. I don't know why they did it that way. I don't think... It may not have dawned on them right away, or they may not have figured out right away how to write him into the show. Yeah. Okay, and my other quick question was, do you think Rochester was usually a favorite of some of the fans from your father's shows, or what happened? Oh, he was a great favorite. As a matter of fact, that is the question I'm asked most often, is, what was Rochester like? Really? As often as people ask me, was your father really a miser, they say, what was Rochester like? And, of course, he was very well off. He had his own big house and stables and horses and everything else. Oh, yes, he did. So he was doing very well for himself. Well, I was just asking because I always thought so much about, well, Rochester, so I thought I might ask about Rochester. Good. I'm glad you did. We're glad you did. Thank you very much for joining us, Daryl. All right.

This is Same Time, Same Station, our number 818-793-3667. Let's go to Glendale and talk to Rob. Hi, Rob. Hi. Miss Benny, you mentioned that you didn't want to write because you weren't one, and I was just wondering what your thoughts were on those types of books and having the experiences that related to those. That's a good question, and yes, I did. The two that come to mind, of course, are Christina Crawford's book, Mommy Dearest, Gary Crosby's book, Going My Own Way. And I knew both of them, both Gary and Christina. What can I tell you? They were absolutely true. I felt that they should have been written, certainly in Christina's case. In Gary's case, I think that he wrote it too soon. I think his timing was bad because at the time he wrote it, I think that the public in general loved Bing Crosby.

And I think it's only been in the last few years that the word has started to trickle that he wasn't as nice a man as he was cracked up to be. And I think if that book had been published today, it would have had far more acceptance. But unfortunately, when he wrote it, the public really came down on him. You know, how could you say nasty things about this wonderful man? They didn't want to hear it. They didn't want to hear it. And Gary's book, of course, was absolutely true. Bing was not a nice man. I'm sorry to say it, but it's true. But that was your experience, that Bing Crosby and Joan Crawford weren't such wonderful people? Well, I knew I didn't know Bing personally. I know that, well, I'll give you a little insight that I don't think I said anything about in the book, because my father really was a man who loved everyone. There were very few people who riled him. There were very few people he didn't like. And quite frankly, Bing Crosby was one of them. Really? He didn't like Bing.

Did any of that stem from that incident which is covered in the book and I think we've talked about on the show before where Crosby said hell on the radio in an era when that wasn't really permissible? I don't know. There was another story about him. Was there something to do with he had agreed to be on my father's show and then canceled at the last minute? I don't remember the exact story, but there was another story about things. No, I think what bothered my father more than anything else was he felt that Bing was the most ungenerous man. Oh, okay. Professionally of his kind. Anyway, he was not one of daddy's favorites. Okay, well, I guess that says it all really, doesn't it?

Rob, we thank you very much for joining us on Same Time, Same Station. Good question. Thank you. Yes, thank you very much. 818-793-3667. This is Same Time, Same Station. Larry and John Gassman over there. Dan Haefeli over here. And we'll take your phone calls, including this one. Here's Charles in Hollywood. Hi, Charles. Hello, sir. How are you? We're doing okay. Yes, I was wondering if there was anyone who is on the telephone at this moment who is hooked up with your station. who remembers an episode of the Jack Benny Show, where, I think this was in 1945 or 1946, where Dennis, I believe it was, was doing live, anyway, shows these days were live, where he was doing it live, and then he was coming off the script with something about, I was walking across Jack's lawn last night and stepped on the...

He meant to say grass reek, but he said grass reek. Oh, that was my mother's line. Everybody cracked up. And then the following week... Yeah, that was Mary's line. I see. And then the following week, Dennis Day, I think it was, who came in again on this, said something about we were driving across, we made a shortcut across Jack's Lawn to the driveway and ran across a skunk and boy, did that grass reek. Mm-hmm. Yes, well, I do know about that because the original, my mother every so often would really fluff a line. I remember one time it had to do with a Swiss cheese sandwich, and she said, And whenever things like that happen, my father always made the most of it, and it became part of the show for a while, and there were all kinds of follow-up jokes. And that was one of the fluffs that she made. She was supposed to say, She read it on the air. It came out, And so they followed up on it, and that was the reason for the following show.

They had to find some way to keep getting in the word grass reek. That's interesting because the show won, I recall, the first one before the second, that Dennis Day was clearly, at least clearly in my memory, that he said he was walking across Jack's lawn and he stepped on the grass reek. Yeah, right, exactly. That brings up an interesting question, and I don't know whether you would even know the answer to this, Joan, but what happens, say, if that line comes up on a show directed at the East Coast? Now, what do they do? Because they still have a West Coast show to do. They've got a West Coast show to do. I'm sorry, I don't understand your question. If this line comes up on a show that is beamed towards the East, you know, because they did the show more than once. That is if the fluff comes up on the first show.

Oh, you mean at the time when they were doing the show twice? Yeah. Right. Oh, I don't even remember. That was a very brief period of years, wasn't it? Yeah, it was up until the mid-40s, and then they began to put it on tape. I would imagine they would have to go to the script for the West Coast show and stay with it. Yeah. I would think. Yeah, I'm not sure. Probably so. Should have asked George. Yeah, we will. Should have asked George. I have no idea. Yeah, we will. We can always call him back. I'm certain that they did the show twice. What's that? I'd forgotten that they did the show twice. Yeah, they did for a long time until tape came in, and then they would take it and do it once and then play the tape back. Especially, though, that was common in the era before you can remember yourself. Yeah. But wasn't there a time, now I'm asking the question, wasn't there a time when the show was live at 4 o'clock and we on the West Coast heard it at 4 and the East heard it at 7? Uh, no. You would have heard it, let's see.

We always heard it at 7 o'clock here in Los Angeles. I don't know about that, Larry. I think later on it was live. I remember that there was a time when we heard it here at 4 o'clock. You know what? There's people listening to the show. All four of us are too young, fortunately, to know the answer to this question. Cop out, cop out. Not only is it a cop out, but it's also true. I'll bet there's somebody listening who will call us later on. They can't call us right now because all of the phone lines are full. I do know that they... The Jack Benny was a unique case on KFI and KNX as well. They would take the second show and you'd hear it at 7 o'clock and then they'd rebroadcast that show again at, say, 8.30. Or 9. Or 9. So you'd hear the show twice on a Sunday. As to whether it was ever on before, I don't know. That was in the late 40s and early 50s.

Well, I think that we've probably answered all of your questions, right, Charles? I guess so. However, I'd like to make one last comment. Sure. I'm going to miss, I'm going to very, very much, again this year, as every year since the days of radio, I'm going to miss Dennis singing It's Christmas in Killarney with all the folks at home. I love that. And I wrote to him and he answered my letter and I've still got it someplace. Great, good, great. Wonderful memories, Charles. Thank you. Okay, bye-bye now. Bye-bye. Thank you very much. It's coming up in about four minutes before 6 o'clock here on Sunday night. This is Same Time, Same Station with Larry and John Gassman and Dan Haefeli, and we have a whole bunch of phone calls. We'll go to another one in just a moment. We were talking about your mother's fluffs earlier, and that brings to mind the fact that my understanding is your mother was never really comfortable being on the air. Is that right? No, never.

Did that contribute, do you suppose, to her fluffs? Probably. Oh, I'm sure it did because she was terribly nervous. Terribly. Do you recall private conversations with her or while you were around to hear her talk about not liking to be on the air? Well, I just knew she was so terribly nervous about being on the radio, and it got worse as the years went along. And then, of course, by the time television came, that was when she had an excuse to say, that's it, no more. And then you, of course, began to read her lines during the tapings of the studio. That's right. Which I think we've traced back to about January of 1954 onward. In fact, I think I've heard a show in which you read the lines. You did a good job, too. Thank you. I think you even made a fluff, and Jack made something of it.

If I remember right. Oh, golly. Again, you remember more than I. Well, I heard it more recently. When I was either in high school or college that I was doing that. How long did you do that? It seems to me that it was only for one season. But again, I could be wrong. Well, I know Jeanette Barnes. I mean, Jeanette Iman, who was the script girl, did a lot of those as well. I think she's now Jeanette Barnes. There's somebody else we should talk to someday. She did a lot of the readings as well. Yes, I think so. Yeah. We were talking about the last season when you played the part of Mary for the live audience and then Mary's lines were spliced in. But let's go back a few more years when you were a young girl, a junior in high school, and you came to Jack's door. Scavenger Hunt. Scavenger Hunt. That's right. This is from 1949. Or 50. 1950 it is. Let's play that. Oh, excuse me. Mr. Benny? Yes? My name is Joan. The girls in my high school class are having a scavenger hunt.

And I was selected to come over here and get something personal from you. Something personal? Very personal. Oh. Oh, I bet I know what you have to get. A lock of my hair. I'm supposed to get the whole thing. Well, Joan, step in for a minute. I'll go into my room and get you one. Excuse me, ma'am. I'll be right back. Hello. Hello. My name is Joan. I'm a junior at Chadwick High School. My name is Dennis. I'm a private in the Foreign Legion. I leave to join my regiment tonight. Gee, you mean you're going all the way out to the desert? Uh-huh. Way over to North Africa? I thought it was in Palm Springs. Wait a minute. I know who you are. You're Dennis Day, aren't you? Uh-huh. Gosh, wait till I tell the rest of the girls in my class I met Dennis Day. They think you're a wonderful singer. They do? Yeah, they think you're almost as good as Vic Damone. Ugh. Well, here you are, young lady. Gee, thanks, Mr. Benny. And when the scavenger hunt is over, I'll return it.

Oh, you needn't bother. Just turn it loose. It'll come home. Yeah, yeah. Well, goodbye, Joan. Goodbye. She was a pretty girl, wasn't she, Dennis? Dennis? Dennis! And he left with her. Say, boss, I finished making out my income tax. I'm ready to send to the government. Have you got a three-cent stamp? Processer, you've already got a three-cent stamp on the envelope. I have to put one in the envelope. That's my tax. Uh, that's wonderful. You obviously don't remember that, Joan, but you did very well on that one as well. Well, I think I did better with the earlier one, but that wasn't too bad. That must have been, I had to have been 16 or 17 when I did that. What year was that? That was March 12th of 1950. 50. Yes, because the mention of Vic Dumont. Yeah. There's a reason for that. Did you hear all those whistles from the audience? I was dating him then. Were you really?

Hello? Yes. You there? Yes. Hi. Yeah. Hello? Hi, go ahead. That was my big romance. Oh, okay. That's why it was named victim mode. I see. I see. Now that fits in a little bit. Yeah. We need to take a break for just a second and let everyone know that you're listening to listener-supported FM 89.3. This is KPCC Pasadena Community Service of Pasadena City College. You're listening to Same Time, Same Station. Larry and John Gassman and Dan Haefeli and our special guest by telephone. is Joan Benny, who we were talking to about her life growing up with her parents, Jack Benny and Mary Livingston. We have a number of people on the telephone line, too. And why don't we go to Stuart in Los Angeles. Hi, Stuart. Hi. Who is this? Larry, John, or Dan? I'm Dan. You're Dan. And I'm Larry. And by process of elimination... I'm John. Right. And I'm Stuart Kanin, and I don't know whether Joan remembers this, but...

I was a young man, a young man. I'm talking about December 30th, 1936. I played Schubert B. on the Fred Allen Show, which started the great Allen-Benny feud. Jack mentioned this, and Frank Klein mentioned it in his book. I think they all did. They all did, because it was one of the great radio feuds of radio history. Maybe you could tell us that story from your point of view as the one who, in a way, started it all. Surely. remember back in 1936 none of you probably do remember that none of us remember 1936 none of us would ever admit to remembering it right well I have to say that I do because I was there and the times were hard and Fred Allen had a program called Town Hall tonight I believe and it was broadcast at 9 o'clock on Wednesday evening and we did a repeat show at midnight and He was having young talent on the show. He had the trumpet player, tap dance, just young musicians in general. And I auditioned for Uncle Jim Harkins. I don't know if you know him. Sure. A protege of Fred Allen's. Fred Allen's, right. And I played something, a piece by Kreisler called Perludium and Allegro, which took about four minutes. And Uncle Jim said, Stuart, we'd love to have you on the show. You have something that will take about a minute.

Well, I said, I think I do. I went home and I practiced the daylights out of the B, Schubert's B, and I got it down to 45 seconds. And they loved that piece, and I went on December 30, 1936. It's a B. Fred said something about this young boy playing, just an ad-lib, total ad-lib, about this young boy playing the violin so well, and that so-called comedian, that 39-year-old comedian, could hardly get the violin out of the case. There's some funny line in there. And no one thought anything more of it the following Sunday. And, of course, America listens on Wednesday to Fred Allen and Sunday nights to Jack. And the next Sunday, Jack just answered Fred. And the following week, Fred answered back. And this went on and on. And actually, I was on Jack's television show in 1963. He asked me to come back. I happened to have been teaching.

professor of violin at Oberlin College at that time, Oberlin Conservatory of Music, and I asked Jack at that time if he had ever gotten together with Fred, and he said no, they let this thing ride for about nine months to a year, and then finally the writers got together and they built it up into one of the, you know, great old-time funny feuds on radio. That's a great story. Yeah. I'd never heard that from your perspective. We'd read about it in books. Well, I was on Jack's show a number of times, times, and each one would have me on his show to kind of prove their own point. And then in 1940, of course, they decided to call an end to the feud, and they made the movie called Love Thy Neighbor. And at that time, they presented me with a check for $1,000, which in 1940 went a long way to helping me do my musical career and study. And of course, I've had a very nice career in music. I was concertmaster.

the San Francisco Symphony for many years. Now, you said that they decided to call an end to the feud, but the feud really didn't end, did it? Oh, you know, my memory is a little cloudy. I think really it didn't end until Fred Allen's passing. Yeah, it went on for many years. It was a lot of fun to listen to as well. Probably did, and of course reading these books and now having Joan's book and reading, the only thing I have to just call attention to is a slight error that Jack, for some reason mentioned in the book that I played Dvorak's B, but it really was not the great Franz Schubert who wrote all the great symphonies, but a lesser light whose name was Francois Schubert who wrote the B, and that's probably the only piece the man ever wrote. The only thing that had any notoriety. Had any notoriety, right. Those are great stories, and we sure appreciate you sharing those with us. In fact, we'd like to talk to you off the air for a moment. Could you hang on for a second? You can hold on when we're done, all right?

Anyway, we need to move on and cover some other areas, but we do appreciate Stuart calling and the many others who have. And we might even have time to fit one or two more calls in, 818-793-3667. If you just joined us, we're talking with Joan Benny, daughter of Mary Livingston and Jack Benny. New book, Sunday Nights at 7, The Jack Benny Story. You're listening to Same Time, Same Station on KPCC in Pasadena. Now, we were mentioning Fred Allen, Joan, and I wonder, from your perspective as a young girl growing up in the Benny household, how you saw Fred Allen and the feud and his relationship with your parents. Well, I can really best remember that my father was such a great admirer of Fred Allen. Ah.

I didn't know him personally very well because, of course, he lived in New York. He's one of the few who never made that move to the West Coast. And so I met him a few times, but I didn't know him. My father thought he was by far the best writer of comedy in the business and admired his wit because, of course, Fred was very sharp and very quick with the repartee, which was not my father's style at all. And as I say, he was just a great admirer of Fred and the show and the writing. And I just remember Fred with great, very fond memories. The feud, of course, the feud was a lot of fun. And, of course, as everyone knows, was put, I think. Right. I have a quick question about the book tour that you've been undergoing for the past, I don't know, a month, six weeks, whatever it's been. Oh, no, it hasn't been that long, please. I thought maybe it might seem that long. I'm wondering if the people that you've had asking questions of you in the world of radio and television, especially those who are younger, if they are still familiar with the name Jack Benny or if they're just reading about him for the first time, what the situation may be in that regard. Well, I think a lot of young people are.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑