Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Lights Out artwork

From the Lights Out collection

The Sea

Episode 022March 2, 194322 min 22 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 16 min to read

Lights out, everybody. It... This is Arch Obler bringing you another in our series of stories of the unusual. And once again we caution you, these lights out stories are definitely not for the timid soul. So we tell you calmly and very sincerely, if you frighten easily, turn off your radio now. I am I am, Father Donahue. And old as I am, I'm not ready to die until... Ah, come closer, Father, and hear my miserable confession. You know me as a good woman in the village. Yet I've heard what you say. There's no finer old woman in all the islands. Ah, but that's not so, Father Donahue. And if I'm to meet all my old friends in the island of Paradise, then hear me out and pray for me. You know my sons, Thomas and Paddy.

Born on the same cold winter's night they were. In the firstborn, Thomas was as good as an angel in paradise. But the second, the one I named Paddy, was evil from the moment he took his first breath of God. It was Thomas that carried the load of the family on his back. Fishing from early to late. But Paddy, drinking and brawling and running from work as if the devil himself was pulling him away. I prayed to the good God every night. Some goodness come into the man's heart. But with every year, he grew worse, stealing what his crooked tongue couldn't talk away from honest men. Ah, but his brother Thomas, he repaid me for all the trouble. A good boy. And when he came to me with the word that he was to marry Eileen, the heart in me sang for the good God always meant for the two of them to be together. Ah, how I remember the day of the wedding. The sun shining.

And the sky and the sea smooth as a baby's cheek. I was so happy. Little known of the horror of what was to come. Ah, it was a happy morning. Ah, listen to the mother. Did you ever hear a happier sound in all creation? Why, shouldn't they be happy, Thomas? It's not every day that such a blessed marriage comes on the island. Ah, the prettiest girl in all the black is waiting to be your bride as soon as the sun starts setting. My bride. Ah. Oh, mother, that's a grand word. I'm happy for you, my son. I wonder where Patty can be. Patty. Yes, he isn't around. You know where he is. Oh, that's right. It'll be a better wedding without him. Oh, now, Mother, don't say things like that. After all, he's your son and my brother. There is sorrow in my heart as he's drinking and brawling. Paddy, you did come. Speak of the devil. And why shouldn't I be here? Is it only strangers that are welcome at your wedding? Oh, now, Paddy, that's not the way to talk. There's food and drink and... No, wait a minute. I've got more important things to do than to be filling me belly. Listen to me, Brother Thomas.

Is your head that full of weddings that it can't hear the chance of making us all richer than the Yankees? What do you mean? Yes, speak up, Paddy. What devilment are you up to now? Devilment? Nothing. It's honest money I'm talking about. And may the next pipes and tobacco be at me on wake if I'm not telling you the truth. I'm listening, Paddy. Let's hear what you have to say. Do you remember the hulk of a ship that was wrecked off in East Navarro a bit ago? Well? Well, I went there yesterday to see if there was anything worth having. Oh, listen to me, brother. In the bottom of a pool no deeper than this room.

He's lying enough bolts of copper and brass to make you and me the richest men on the island. What? Ah, you can believe your ears? Wouldn't you rather bring the bride a pocketbook filled with gold sovereigns than the empty leather you've got now? But, Paddy, I... Ah, I wish you, Mother, you'd talk to the man. But if it's in the sea, it'll wait until after the wedding. Oh, wait with it. And with those innish boats sailing out around the place, I tell you it's now or never. And may my sword to the devil if I'm not saying true words. Thomas, it would be nice to have a bit of money in the house. Yes. Then what are you waiting for?

You've got a boat big enough to handle the stuff, and I'll be there to help you. And in three hours, you can be back here dancing. Oh, it's Eileen. Let her have the word whether you stay or go. Stay or go where, Mother Dinell? What's going on, Tom? Well, uh, you see, Eileen... Ah, you're of the day short, let me say it. Eileen, there's a fortune in brass and copper bolts waiting for us in water no deeper than a man's neck. Over off in East Nabor. And Tommy here thinks you'd be fool enough to say no to his going. But must he go now? The sea doesn't wait. We'd be back in three hours, Eileen. I just think, Eileen, you'd have it just for every day of the week. Thomas, do you want to go? We could build a new house with the money. Mother Danelle, do you think Thomas should go now? I mean, with all them out there? Well, we're so poor, and Thomas, young as he is, so worn and weary from work. Maybe this is God's blessing. A gift from heaven for putting our faith in him who watches over all of us. God's blessing is right. A hundred pounds, and we'll be kings of the island. Come on, now.

We can take the side path down to... Wait, brother. Eileen, is it your wish? I'd be a poor wife to you, Thomas, if I stood in your way of making a living before our marriage. My darling. Ah, there'll be time enough for that now when we get back. Come on, Thomas, let's get out of here. Hurry back to me, my dearest. The sea will take me to our good fortune and the sea will bring me back. Out this way, Thomas. Come on, hurry up. Yeah, I'm coming. I'm due to the wedding, darling. God, go with you. Thomas! Yes, yes. I'll be back in three hours, mother. As rich as a Yankee. Bye. Oh, Eileen. Oh, little baby, why should you cry? Thomas is proud to see so many times. Why should you cry this time? Mother Danelle, I'm frightened. Frightened? Then tell me, why should you be frightened? I don't know, but when that door closed behind him, it seemed as if the waters of the sea were closing over. Oh, Mother Danelle, hold me close. And soon, Father Donahue, Eileen and I left the dancing and the fiddling behind.

and climbed the long path up to the top of the cliff so her eyes could see far out over the water. And all the time, Mylene kept crying that she'd never see Thomas again. That she'd never see Thomas again. Oh, Thomas. Oh, stop crying and saying the things you're saying, girl. It's tempting as devil to do with evil work. Oh, I haven't climbed this path for a minute. It's a little too steep for me old bones. Thomas, where are you? Oh, now stop that, girl. That Thomas has found so much copper and brass, it's taken him longer than he thought. Thomas wouldn't come back, Clay. He wouldn't. Oh, well, Paddy would if there was a shillin' extra to be made, and he'd talk Thomas into it with that child son of his. Ah, the last tip. I know we'll see them. They're both weighed down with good fortune. Eileen! Eileen, stay away from the edge. I'll go over the cliff. Oh, Mother Denel. Don't let my baby let wind. Where did it come from? Out of the west, where he was. But, but in all my years, such a wind has never been before. Water.

Look at it swirling and tossing before the wind. Not dead, my comrade. Oh, that was a time, Father Donahue. The wind grew wilder and wilder. In a minute, the sea was pounding at the base of the cliff. And the girl shrieking, she wanted to die with Tom. And me fighting her back from the edge and praying to the good God to give me old arms the strength to hold her back until she came to her senses. Ah, none of us got a wink of sleep till the light of morning. Ah, that wind. I can hear it now. Snarling. Talk. Winter Denel. What? A boat. A boat. Your son's to the west. Why, my son. Aye, aye. Come on. Dead. No, no. The boat's coming, and there's living hands on the oars. Come on. God, we just got him, and he's just taken to their mercy. Mother Denel. I heard they... Mother Denel. Oh, dear me. I lean the merciful God has brought them back. Oh. Come on, quick. They're trying to get into land. Hurry now. Oh, Mother Denel. Quickly now. No, wait, child. Your shawl. Your shawl there. Now give me your arm. Oh, my arm is trembling so I can hardly walk. Yes, yes. Lean on me.

Yes. Yes, I'm moving fast as I can. It's hard. It's hard to get against this wind. Let him live. You bless us for the life of one. And I bless it for the life of two. Good neighbors. Good neighbors, let us through. My son. Let us through. I can see nothing. It's in the dark. I see the boat. Oh, blessed boat. I see it. Praise God, I see it. There's only one in the boat. Where? Oh, dear. Thomas. Oh, no. Yes, forgive me. Come on. I'll help you. Oh, good girl. I know you're a good girl. Oh, which one? Which one? Thomas. I know it. Thomas, I know it. Yes, Thomas. The good Thomas. He lives. And aside, everybody. Let the widow down and the girl through now. Let them through. Let me through. My son. My son. Which one? Well. Well, I'm back, mother. How do you know? Are you pleased to see me? Harry.

We need to stand back now. You, Paddy. Yes. Yes, me. Ain't I got a right to live? Tell me. Tell me quick. Where is my son? Where's Thomas? Tell me, Paddy. Where is my Thomas? Where do you think he is, old woman? Dead at the bottom of the sea. Aye, Father Donahue. That was what he told me. My good Thomas was dead at the bottom of the sea. Dead. The good Thomas dead and Paddy, Paddy the evil one alive. Ah, it wasn't right, father. And in the days and nights that followed, I cried to God, why did you do it? Why? Why did the sea take my dear Thomas from the boat and leave Paddy? Was there no reward on earth for goodness and sweetness of soul? And in the seventh night of my sorrow, there came an answer. I was lying on my bed. Outside the sea was singing and whispering. My window was open and I could hear the sea talking at that day there, crying. Crying from alongside my dear.

Cry, mother. Why? Mother. I heard a voice. You are with me, brother. Tell me such voice. Oh, no. No, it's some wildness in my weary head. Mother, I am so weary. You must listen. Oh, dear Scott. Why do you do this to me? My son is dead. Daddy must see me. Why do you bring me the memory of his voice? Mother, mother, believe me. If I could only see you, I would believe. Oh, no. The horror the sea made of me. Wind and wave and grinding rock against my flesh. I wouldn't care, my son. Just let me see that it is you, not my own voice speaking in my head. Oh, mother, you don't know what you ask. But if there is no other way, close your eyes until I give you a word to open them. I've... I've closed them. Now open and have no fear. I beg you. This was... Mother. Mother. Why did he murder me? Murder? The sea was calm. We reached the pool where he set the copper in the brass lid. I stripped off my clothes and dove under. Oh.

And when I tried to come up for another breath of air, oh, mother, you wouldn't let me do it. With his hand he held me under. My hands, they tore at his arm. But he held me down. Down until at last I screamed for mercy. The water filled my mouth. My lungs entailed me. My own brother killed me. And that is why I tore myself out of the sea. I want to know why he did it, mother. Why? I cannot rest in peace until I know and understand. You tell me, mother. Oh, speak, mother. What gain could come to him for such a horror? I do not know. Oh, believe me, my son. I do not know. Then I must go back. I cannot stand this pain. Oh, my good Thomas. Look at this, what was Thomas Denner's face like.

Look at it and give me your oath you will not tell my Eileen or my brother this night. Oh, but I... Your oath, mother. They must not know. You hear me? They must not know. I swear it, Thomas. Oh, merciful one, this pain. I go to the sea. And will we ever meet again, my son? Yes. The day I find out why he made me drown. I will return. I will return. Thomas, my son, come back. Oh, my son. My son. But he was gone, Father Donahue. Gone back to his nameless grave in the sea. Then, then it happened. Paddy talked his way into the good graces of the girl. Simple little Eileen. What did she know of the evil of men? A devil Paddy and my good Thomas's Eileen. Ah, took their life out of me.

It made me long for the quiet of my grave. And then, then came the day of the wind. Again the fiddler was playing. Again the good people of the islands were happy. I alone was sad, weeping, weeping at what I knew. Mother Danelle, why do you sit here apart from all the rest and weep? I'm not weeping, girl. Oh, weep, you've been so sad. Can't you find a little joy in your heart for this day of... My marriage to your own son. My... My son. Oh, I do not love him as I did dear Thomas. May he rest in peace. But Thomas himself told Patty that if he died, he wished that Patty would care for him. And Mother Danelle, what is it? He's so strange. Now he knows. I just remembered. Now he knows. What do you think? There you are, my little bride-to-be.

Why waste your wedding day with this old woman? Mother of mine, though she be, her face is sour enough to curdle milk. Come on away now. No, no way, Paddy. Mother Denel, you must tell me. What is it that makes you stare at Paddy with such an aweful look? That's the look she's always had. Look how the sun glints on the sea. It's a day for a king. And I'm a king marrying the girl I've always wanted. Come kiss me, Eileen. Kiss me so that all shall see me kissing the prettiest bride in all Ireland. No, please. Kiss me. Let the sky and the sky... Mother, don't know. What did you make that sound for, old woman? No, no, no. Now then, speak up, mother. Why did you shriek like that? The sea. What of the sea? What are you putting your bony finger at out there? What are you... Look, at the water's edge.

Say, what is... Something's coming out of the sea. Look. Something's coming out. Yes, anyway. I see it now. It's a seal. That's what it is. A seal. Where's the club? It's not a seal. It's a man. Look. A man. Bones. Just bones. Let's get out of here. I mean... I'll leave you, but look. Do not look. Ah. Ah, blessed Mary. She's fainted. She will not see you. What? What? What is it? I... I can't move. I can't... Cannot move. No. You cannot move, my brother. You cannot move. That... That voice. Bone and little flesh. And yet you know the voice. Thomas. Your brother Thomas. Come back again. No. Because now he knows. No. Now he knows. Knows what? Why you murdered me. Your flesh and blood.

I heard it from your own lips. You wanted my Eileen always. That's why you did it. Your clever tongue can no longer save you, brother of mine. I have come a painful way to get you. No. No. No, you won't get me, dead thing. No. I'll get away. I'll run. I'll run. And so he ran, Father Donahue. He turned and ran up, up the path that led to the top of the cliff. And behind him... Slowly, stubborn with the pain that tore at his dead bones, climbed my dead Thomas after him. And after Thomas, dragging my old bones, I went. Oh, for they were my sons. And I had to see that right was done. Until at last Paddy stood on the very edge, the sea five hundred feet below, shrieking, yelling and wailing. He stood there shrieking at that horrible thing that once was his son.

Nothing. Stay back. Stay back. Come through, my brother. I come through. He fell. He fell. Mother, see? He didn't get me. Those rotten bones gave way beneath him. He didn't get me, Mother. Mother, what are you going to do? Over the cliff Paddy went, turning and twisting, and into the sea where the water covered him over. When the others of the village came up there at last, I told him that the old-borners of Thomas had done it. Had clutched Paddy close to him and thrust him over. Oh, Father Donahue, listen. It was I that gave that final push that sent the evil son of mine to his death. Thomas tried and failed before he had his last measure of revenge. So I did it, Father. I gave Paddy the man of life.

And I gave him death. Is there any forgiveness in heaven for what I did?

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑