The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 11 min to read
I believe that's our ring. I don't get long. I believe you're right. I'll see. Hello. John, I'm down store. This is Laman Abner. Let's see what's going on down in Pine Ridge. Well, today's the opening of the trial in which Squire's camp is suing Laman Abner for $1,000 as a result of his fall in the old fellow's theater a short time ago. As we look down the little community today, we find our friends gathered in the courtroom at the county seat. The trial is already underway, and at the moment, both lawyers are conferring with the judge, while Lum and Abner are wondering what's going on. Look, Phil, what are they doing now, Lum? What's the matter, anyway? I don't think nothing's the matter, Abner, is it?
arguing about something, looks like. Well, why don't the lawyers argue out loud so we can hear them instead of standing up there whispering to the judge? We're the ones that's being tried, not them. Well, if it's all legal stuff, Abner, some technicalities has come up more likely. Well, I'd love to hear what's going on. If we're going to get thrown in the penitentiary, doggies, I want to know exactly what first. Why? Everybody will hear you. I don't care. Let them hear me. Wait a minute. Here comes our lawyer. He'll tell us what they've discussed. Well, I hope so. I ain't followed nothing they've caught and told for in this trial.
Uh, what was it, Mr. Devon? Do you have any trouble? Oh, no, no trouble at all. Uh, did you tell me that your Pine Ridge doctor was here in the courtroom? Yeah, he come with us. That's him sitting over there in the second row. Doc Miller, excuse me. Is he being arrested for something, too? Oh, no, no, no. The plaintiff just wants to borrow him. Huh? Well, Dr. Hurley's been called out in an emergency case and can't be here. So they need a reputable M.D. to explain the X-ray picture of Mr. Skinner back to the jury. Oh, I see. Who's Dr. Hurley? Well, he's a local doctor here. He's a good man. He's the one who took the x-ray picture. Oh. Well, I know Doc Miller will be glad to do whatever he can. Well, that's good. I'll go over and have a talk. Well, does that mean that Doc Miller is going to be on Squire's side now?
No, it just means that we'll get a better deal out of it, I think. We will, huh? Well, you know Doc Miller won't try to make Squire's injury sound no worse than it actually is. Yeah, but you know what Doc said after he seen that X-ray picture the other day? He said it showed that Squire must have sure enough hurt himself something wonderful when he fell down on our picture show. Yeah, I know it. I wish they hadn't have brought that thing up at all. Look at that gadget they're putting the X-ray picture on. See how it lights up there? Oh, yeah. Yeah, I've saw them before. They do that so that everybody can see it better. Huh. Well, I believe they're ready to get started. Huh. They're going to start up again. Oh. They've got Dr. Miller up there now. Oh, because I hope he says something good for us. Order in the court. Order in the court. Swear there, witness bailiff. Raise your right hand. Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? I do. Your name, please? Dr. Cyrus W. Miller. All right. Your witness, counsel. Counsel? I thought Squire's lawyer was named Clark. It is Clark.
Dr. Miller, you are an M.D., are you not? I am. And you practiced in Pine Ridge and vicinity for a number of years? Yes, about 35 years now. Dr. Miller, did you examine an X-ray photograph of Mr. Skimp's back a few days ago? I did. Displayed at your right there is an X-ray photograph. Have you ever seen it before? Yes, yes, that's the one I looked at the other day. All right. Now, will you tell the jury what injury or injuries, if any, that photograph reveals? Well, the X-ray shows that there is a fracture of the transverse process of the first lumbar vertebrae. Huh. You see right here, gentlemen, just below the junction of the dorsal and the lumbar vertebrae. All right, doggies. Object. Object. Well, the other day, Doc said it was Squire's back that was hurt. Now he's saying something different. No, no, no, Mr. Peabody. Those terms refer to the back. That's just medical language.
Oh, well, we never hit square no lumber, I know that. He never said we did. Sit down. All right. He said something about lumber, though. I heard him. I heard him myself. Order, order, please. I suggest that the defendant confer with his counsel before making any more demonstrations. All right. Continue, counsel. Everybody here named his counsel? Hey, sir. Uh, Dr. Miller, would you say that the injury indicated in the x-ray is of a serious nature? Well, yes. Yes, yes. In fact, it's more serious than I imagined it could be after examining the patient the night of the accident. I see. But the x-ray does reveal such an injury as you described. Yes, yes, it does. And would such an injury cause considerable pain and suffering? Oh, yes, indeed, yes. The usual symptoms are pain, tenderness in the region affected. The pain is more noticeable when the patient moves around, and there is sometimes motor and sensory paralysis. But apparently...
There are none in this case. I see. Thank you. Thank you very much. The defense may have the witness. Just one question, please. Dr. Miller, could a fall such as Mr. Skimp has said was taken cause the injury shown in the x-ray? Well, yes, it's possible. But not probable, generally speaking, that is. Well, that's hard to say. It all depends upon how the spine is struck and what it lands on in the fall. Yes. All right. That's all. Thank you, doctor, for helping us out. All right, next witness. We'd like to call Mr. Lum Edwards, Your Honor. Call Mr. Edwards, please. Mr. Edwards! Mr. Edwards! You don't have to call me. I know what to do. I'm in the same business as you fellas are in. See, I'm Justice of the Peace. Raise your right hand. Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? Why, sure. I do. Howdy, Jay. State your name. L. Edwards. Justice of the Peace of Crow Relief Township. Mr. Edwards.
I have here a letter which Mr. Skimp received while he was confined to his bed following the accident. Now, I want you to look at this letter and tell me if you recognize it. Yeah, yeah, sure, I recognize it. Or two, I wrote it myself. Is that your signature there? Why, sure, can't you read? And that's Abner's signature right under mine there. Thank you, thank you very much. May it please the court, I would like to read this letter and submit it as evidence. It reads... Well, I know what it says. Dear Squire, we are awful sorry you got hurt falling down in our theater. We feel bad because it's our fault for not having more light in there so you could see where you were going. Anything we can do, be sure and let us know because we feel responsible for the whole thing. And it's signed by Lum Edwards and Abner Peabody.
Mr. Edwards, this letter is identically as you wrote it, is it not? Yeah, it's identical, all right. But I'd like to say right here that... That's all, that's all. Thank you very much, Mr. Edwards. Your witness. More questions? All right, Mr. Edwards, that's all. Call the next witness, please. But, Judge, I'd like to say a thing or two. You'll have opportunity for that later, Mr. Edwards. Call the next witness. That gentleman won't even let us utter a test. Um, Your Honor. We'd again like to call Mr. Skimp to the stand. Very well, call Mr. Skimp. Mr. Skimp, Mr. Skimp. Yes, yes, yes. Here, baby, will you give me a hand, please? I'm pretty crippled up, I'm afraid. Look at that, Abner. That ain't this one. He don't need to walk bent over that. Why, he could stand up straighter than that when he come in our store the other day. Of course he could. He's even more bent over now than the other time he'd taken the witness. Reckon he's had a relapse? No.
Oh, no, he's just working on the sympathies of the jury. Makes me so disgusted, I wish I could get up and walk right out of here. Well, you can't walk right out in the middle of the trial. Mr. Skimp, earlier today, you told the court how you purchased a ticket at the theater operated by Mr. Edwards and Mr. Peabody, how you entered the theater, and because of improper lighting, you stumbled and fell and did not regain consciousness until you were home in bed under the care of the doctor. And how, since that time, you've suffered untold pain and agony. Oh, yes. Now then, up to the time of the accident, what was the state of your health? Well, up to that time, I'd enjoyed the very best of health. Never knew a sick day in my life. Yes. Now, did you ever have any other accidents?
that might have caused any injury to your back? No, sir, I never did. Did you ever have any other accidents or receive any other injuries of any kind? Well, the only thing of that nature that I can recall was the bullet wound I received in action in the Spanish-American War, when, as a mere lad, I led a company into battle to fight for the glory of my country's flag. And to this day... I still carry that bullet lodged in my body. I have the pleasure of honor on the grounds that it's immaterial and irrelevant. Objection sustained. All right. That's all, Mr. Skimpy. Defense may have the witness. No question. Well, I think we better have a recess here. The members of the jury will recall the admonition I have given them, and I trust that they will adhere to it. The court is now in recess for five minutes.
Doggy, did you hear that cradle-cradle that Squire was telling about getting wounded in the Spanish-American War on? He never was in no war. Well, he might, but he never got that bullet that way. He told me himself he got that in a duel in St. Louis once. St. Louis? Well, I heard he got it in Kansas City, got in some kind of a scrape-up there. Well, it was something like that. I recollect once he showed me the score where he claimed the bullet went in. Hmm. I don't know what he want to bring that up for anyway. Oh, he's just doing that for the benefits of the jury. He ain't claiming he shot him now. He don't know. He figured that if he... Wait a minute. Wait a minute. Huh? I just happened to think of something. Abner, do you recollect what was the name of that doctor that couldn't get here today? Oh, I don't know. Hurley, I believe they said. Hurley or something like that. Oh, wait a minute. There's Grandpappy Spears. Hi, Grandpappy. Well, allow me to say, sit your trial. Sit your trial.
Did you hear Squire say he got a bullet in him in the Spanish-American War? Yeah, we was just talking about that. I know good and well he got that over in Oklahoma once. Oklahoma? Why, he never done no such a thing. It was in Kansas City is where it was at. Oh, so Oklahoma. No, no, no. He sold some fellow oil well, and none went dry, and the fellow just up and shot him. That's what I heard. No, no, the way I heard it was. Hey, buddy, where's Mr. Edwards? I want to talk to him for a minute. Oh, he's right here. Oh, wait a minute. Dogus, where is he? Didn't you see him? He got up and went out just a minute ago. Went out? I sure got his hat and coat off the hall seat over there and left. For thy land's sakes. Well, I never thought he had so many. For thy land's sakes. You never meant what? Why not five minutes ago? We were sitting here talking and he said he wished he could get up and walk right out of here. But lo and behold, I never figured he'd do it. Well, no matter where he went, Mr. Peabody, we've got to find Mr. Edwards right away.
Thank you.
