Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Nick Carter, Master Detective artwork

From the Nick Carter, Master Detective collection

The Case of the Graveyard Gunman

Episode 322January 11, 194827 min 12 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 11 min to read

88 plus. New post-war old Dutch cleanser famous for chasing dirt presents Nick Carter, famous for chasing crime. Each week at this time, two great names are joined as new post-war old Dutch cleanser brings you one of the most resourceful and daring characters in all detective fiction. Nick Carter, master detective. I just don't like tramping around in an old cemetery in the middle of... Careful, Betsy. The smaller gravestones are hard to see. You're telling me. I almost broke my neck on them. Betsy, look. That headstone there. What about it, Nick? Don't you see the name on it? Yes. So what, Nick? This grave holds the key to the whole mystery. Now, the case of the graveyard gunman. Today's exciting adventure starring Lon Clark as Nick Carter brought to you by new post-war old Dutch cleanser. As our story opens...

The somnolent quiet of Patsy Bowen's room is suddenly broken by the harsh, urgent jangling of the telephone. Hello? Hello, Patsy? This is Nick. Nick. Nick, it's 2 o'clock in the morning. Where are you? Down at the Homicide Bureau, in Maddie's office. Well, what's happened, Nick? You remember Nate Benedict? The guy who stole the Felix Garth jewels? Nate Benedict? You helped send him up about three years ago. That's right. Escaped from the pen about 10 o'clock last night. Yes. I'll pick you up in 20 minutes, Patsy. Put Benedict in prison, and I'm going to see that he goes back. What do you do at the office, Nick? A couple of things I want to check up on. Name and address of Nate Benedict's girlfriend, for one. Well, I remember her name. It was Kay Florian. Why, yes. That's it. You think Benedict will try to contact her? He might. One thing we can be sure of, he'll go after the $50,000 worth of jewels he hid somewhere. Miss, I wonder where he hid them. You're not the only one who wonders, Betsy.

When Benedict refused to talk, the insurance company had to pay off. Felix Garth collected the full $50,000. Here we are. I've got my key right here, Nick. Oh, thanks. I'm still sleepy. Snap on the lights, will you? I've got them. The place is a shambles. Nick, there's been a fight in here. It certainly looks that way. Get a load of that filing cabinet. Somebody's forced it open. Let's have a look at my office. Right. My office has been ransacked, too. Right by your desk is a man lying on the floor. Turn on the lights.

he is, Patsy. There's no use asking him. He's been murdered. Stay on the phone, Nick. He'll be right over. Oh, thanks, Patsy. Did you find anything on the body to identify him? Just this slip of paper in his pocket with an address on it. 1019. 1019 Willow Hill Drive. Uh-huh. What do you suppose he was after, Nick? Whatever it was, it was important enough for someone to follow him here and take it away from him. After he put up a fight. Exactly. My guess is that whoever killed him didn't mean to do it here in the office. When the fight started, there wasn't any choice. Nick, maybe we can find out what they wanted if we check our cross files against the files in the drawer that was forced open. That'll tell us if a file folder is missing. Ah, that's my girl. Good idea, Patsy. I'll read the names of the cross file and you check them against the folders in the drawer. Good. You ready? Uh-huh. Adams, Albright, Anderson, Applegate, Babcock, Bannister, Parton, Benedict. Oh, hold it, Nick. Yeah.

Nate Benedict is missing. And five hours ago, Benedict escaped from prison. That's no coincidence, Patsy. Why would he want our file card and his own Kate? Why would anyone want it? The answer to that is somewhere on this cross-file card. You mean because it contains all the information we had on the original card, the one that's missing? Yes. It has everything, down to Benedict's family name. His family name? Yes, he changed his name years ago. His father's name was Benedetto. Oh. According to the cards... Strange. What, Nick? The address written on that slip of paper I found on the dead man was 1019 Willow Hill Drive. You know whose address that is? No, whose? Felix Garth's. The man Benedict stole the jewels from? The very same. Patsy, as soon as Maddie gets here to take over, we're going to pay a call on Mr. Felix Garth. Sit down, Mr. Carter. Miss Bowen. Thank you. Sorry to break in on you at this hour, Mr. Garth, but... Oh, not at all, Mr. Carter. As a matter of fact, I just heard of Nate Benedict's escape and was about to call you. Call me? Why? About a visitor I had yesterday. Who was he, Mr. Garth? He wouldn't give me his name, but he said he could find out where Benedict had hidden my jewels. That so? Yes. And he offered to get them for me if I'd pay him $5,000. And you agreed? Why not? The insurance company is offering a reward of $5,000 for the jewels. What did this man look like, Mr. Garth? Oh, he was rather nondescript characters.

Small, sandy hair, wore a gray pinstripe suit. Nick. Mr. Garth. Less than an hour ago, we found that man in my office. Murdered. Murdered? Good heavens. Oh, excuse me. Hello? This is Sergeant Matheson of the Homicide Bureau. Is Nick Carter there? Yes, just a moment. For you, Mr. Carter. Oh, thanks. What's the matter, Nick? Where's the guy you found in your office? Who was he? His name was Sammy Gates. Got out of the pen on parole last week. What? By the time Sammy was in the can, his cellmate was our old pal, Nate Benedict. Is Matty going to meet us at the Melbourne Arms Apartments, Nick? He said he'd be waiting out in front. He wants to be there when we question Benedict's girl, Kay Florian. What does he expect to find out? I don't know, Patsy. As far as I'm concerned, the only question I want answered is, what was on that file card that would have told Sammy Gates where the Felix Garth jewels are hidden? You're sure that was why Gates was after the file?

Well, that's the only way it adds up. Gates was Benedict's cellmate in prison. Yeah? Evidently, he learned enough from Benedict to know he could locate the jewels from something in our file. And he tried to do it, but Benedict broke prison, found Gates, trailed him to our office and surprised him there. Then there was a fight and Gates was killed. The way it looks at the moment, Patsy. Well, here's the mail bow and arms, Nick. Oh, there's Maddie waiting for us. Good. Hello, Sergeant. Oh, hello, Patsy. Hiya, Nick. What's the word, Maddie? Should we go in and talk to Kay Florian? Yeah. I've been casing the joint a little. Her apartment's on the first floor. Right around the corner from the desk. This way. Follow me. I take it you've had someone watching her. Sure. I planted a man out here as soon as I heard Benedict escape. But the dame hasn't budged from her room. Oh, here we are. Apartment 101. I'll knock. Yeah, wait. I tell you, I can't see you. Too dangerous. She's talking to someone on the phone. Oh, she hangs up. Okay, Nick. She's talking to Benedict, Nick. Sounds like it.

This goes right around here to the left. All could lead us to Benedict. Oh, there's the sergeant. Any luck, Matty? Yeah, Nick. The operator traced the coal. Yeah? It came from the caretaker's cottage out at Wildwood Cemetery. Wildwood Cemetery? Yeah. That's where Nick caught up with Benedict when he arrested him. Right, Nick? That was the place, all right. We fought it out with him out there. That's where the newspapers called him the graveyard gunman. Then he must be there again, Nick. I will soon find out. Matty, I suggest you call headquarters. Get as many men as you can spare out to Wildwood immediately. Right, Nick. I'll have the cemetery completely surrounded in five minutes. Operator. Operator, operator. Get me police headquarters and step on it. Hello, headquarters? This is Sergeant Matheson. I want to... What? What? What is it, Matty? Yeah. Yeah, I got it. Okay, I'll be right in. What do you know about that? What's happened, Matty? The state police cornered Nate Benedict a half hour ago. What? There was a gun battle.

And Benedict was killed. Killed? Where did they find him? That's what's so screwy, Nick. He was only five miles from the penitentiary when he was trapped. He never got any farther. Only five miles? But that means he hasn't even been in town. Right, Patsy. And that means that our theory has blown up in our faces. Nate Benedict couldn't have murdered Sammy Gates. Momentarily stunned by the unexpected news of Nate Benedict's death, Nick realized that what seemed to be an open and shut case has suddenly developed into a deep mystery. and that he's dealing with a daring and desperate murderer. We'll see what happens in just a moment. Now, back to the case of the graveyard gunman. Today's adventure with Nick Carter, brought to you by new post-war Old Dutch cleanser. As we pick up our story, Nick, Patsy, and Matty have returned to Nick's office following the news of Nate Benedict's death, a death that has turned the murder of Sammy Gates from what appeared to be a clear-cut case into a perplexing mystery.

Well, with Benedict dead, I admit I'm stymied, Nick. Where do we go from here? There's only one other lead, Matty. Yeah, what's that, Nick? The fact that I first arrested Benedict out in Wildwood Cemetery, and that tonight his girlfriend, Kay Florian, got a phone call from out there. But we thought the call came from Benedict. Sure, but now we know it couldn't have. Right, so who was it that called? Well, the sergeant traced the call to the caretaker's cottage. Then wouldn't the caretaker be worth talking to? Oh, come on. Oh, Nick, we're not going out to Wildwood Cemetery. Why not? Everything else in this case has turned out to be a dead end, so why not try a cemetery? Gosh, Nick, I just don't like trampling around in a graveyard in the middle of the night. Yeah, and what's it getting us? The caretaker isn't home, his cottage is dark, so why don't we blow? Because he may be back at any minute, Maddie, and I think it's worth hanging around for a while. Here, let's go this way. Oh, but Nick. Careful, Betsy. It'll be hard to see those smaller gravestones. You're telling me. I almost broke my neck. Hey, wait a minute. Wait a minute. What's the matter, Nick? What is it? What are you looking at?

The headstone there, the one my flash is on. You see what I see? Just another headstone as far as I'm concerned. Look at the name. Joseph Benedetto. Benedetto! That was the name on the cross-piled card. What are you talking about? Matty Joseph Benedetto, the man who's buried here, was Nate Benedict's father. Well, I'll be a monkey's uncle. And hey, look here. Behind the headstone. Hey, fresh dirt. Somebody's been doing some digging here lately. Unless I miss my guests. What they got out of that hole was Felix Garth's jewels. Of course. That's what Sammy Gates was after in our files. Nate Benedict's family name. Right. Gates must have known that I arrested Benedict out here in this cemetery. Uh-huh. Apparently, he'd wormed the information out of Benedict somehow that the jewels were buried behind his father's tombstone. Which means that to find the jewels, all he had to do was to find out the right name of Benedict's father. But, Nick, that means that someone besides Benedict knew the jewels were buried here. Sure. And whoever that someone is...

Followed Gates to your office and killed him to keep him from finding out the name on this gravestone. You may be right, Matty. You bet I'm right. And I'll lay you odds I know who it was. Kay Florian's the only one it could have been. Kay Florian? Sure, she was Nate's girlfriend. She's the only one... Hey, don't look at me. Hit the ground. Shooting at us. Oh, yeah? Well, two can play that game. Shots were put behind those bushes. Right. I'll smoke them out. I think you've scared him away. Oh, Nate. You all right, Betsy? As soon as they get my heart out of my throat, I will be. Well, looks like we've got another graveyard gunman on our hands, Nick. Come on, let's take a look at those bushes. Oh, careful, Nick. This is the spot, right here. No one's here now.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑