Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Philo Vance artwork

From the Philo Vance collection

Muddy Murder Case

Episode 104July 4, 195026 min 12 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 21 min to read

Sit down, please, Vance. Sit down and be prepared for the most ridiculous situation you ever heard. Well, Markham, that takes in a lot of territory. As a private investigator, you've encountered a lot of weird murders, I know. As a distant attorney, so have I. I'm well aware of that. What's so completely fantastic about this one? Let me give you a rundown on it. All right. First of all, you've heard of John Williams. Rocket leader, gunman. Shot dead last night. Yes. I read about it on the way down here. You only read part of it, believe me. Williams had a three-way deal with two other operators, Sam Foster and Whitey Morrow. They had a working arrangement, but as I understand it, they split last month. Nothing too fantastic about the situation yet, Markham. Wait. It's reasonable to believe, as we do, that either Sam Foster or Whitey Morrow killed Williams. The motive is obvious. Markham, please. All right, all right. I just wanted to bring you up to date on the background. Now, listen. Williams lived in a house in the country. Yes. You know how it rained all day yesterday? Certainly I know. I just had my car washed. Always rains immediately afterwards.

I have the same thing happen when I wear a suit. It's just impressed. Let's get back to Williams. His house in the country was surrounded, completely surrounded, mind you, by a sea of mud. Williams was shot inside the house. There was no way for the killer to get in except by going through the mud, and there were no footprints. Uh, Vance. How did I know? Yes. That would be fantastic, and you assured me this case was. Yes, yes. How do you know the killer didn't arrive and leave before the rain? Your guessing was good, Vance, but not complete. Williams had a housekeeper. She was home when the shop that killed him was fired. She came downstairs but saw nobody, put on the yard lights and immediately noticed no footprints. And there were no convenient trees, if that's what you're thinking. She might have killed Williams. Or she might be lying. I doubt it. No, Vance, she is not a killer. Whoever it is, Sam Foster or Whitey Morrow, has figured out a murder that we can't possibly tie to him. Because there isn't a way in the world it could have been done. Mr. Foster. Yes, Hunter. What, yes? You just said, hey, Mr. Foster. Oh, yeah.

Hey, Mr. Forster, eight subway trains pretty. Do you mind what you're doing? I said eight subway trains pretty, Mr. Forster. I heard you. I'm keeping my mind on what I'm doing. You know, Oscar, if you weren't so handy with a gun, I couldn't stand you around me. But I am keeping my mind on what I'm doing. Will you please answer the question I ask and not the one before? You're driving me nuts. Well, if I wasn't handy with a gun, why couldn't you stand me? I'm past that. Oscar, do me a favor. Shut up. You know why I don't answer the same question you ask and I answer the one before? Why? Because it takes time to get things through my head. I ain't quick. Except with a gun. Now, look, forget everything I said up till now. Just listen. Huh? Listen to me. Okay, okay. That's better. We know Whitey Morrow comes to his office every day using this subway. He hates cars. I am listening, brother. Oscar, stay with me. Yeah.

Tomorrow is due here any second. He'll wait for a train. When it comes in the station, you let him have it and we get out. You understand? Sure, I understand. What do you understand? I should listen to you. That's fine. That's fine. I think maybe I'd better call off. Oscar, there's Whitey. He's going through the turnstile. Whitey is due here any second. When he comes, I wait for the train. The train's coming in. He doesn't see us. We're walking back of him with me. Come on. What? Walk you back up with me. Come on. Oh, come on, you. That's right. What? The gun. Give it to him right in the back. Now? Now, tonight. What? I should kill him? After. Okay, okay. Now. Come on, Oscar. Let's beat it. You know something, Mr. Forrest? What is it? I think we ought to beat it. Whitey Morrow's in pretty bad shape, Mr. Vance. There were three bullets in him, but he's lived up until now, although I don't know how.

Pretty tough character, eh, Doctor? He certainly is. Only in a little while we'll be saying he certainly was. He doesn't have a chance. Does he know that? I've told him. The police have told him. He's pretty hard to convince. It's about the last thing a man wants to admit is... I suppose so. Anyhow, you can go in. You're working on this case, Vince? Only if it ties up with the murder of a man named John Williams, Doctor. Williams was killed under completely impossible circumstances. Oh? Williams and Whitey Morrow inside were two... thirds of a crime syndicate. It wouldn't be strange if the other third, Sam Foster, killed Williams and almost got Morrow in the subway. Anyhow, that's what I want to find out. Call me if I can help. I will, Doctor. Hello, Morrow. I'm Philo Vance, Whitey. Remember me? Did you a favor once? There'll be another one I'll get for. Who shot you, Whitey? Get out of here. You watch the papers. It's a guy that gets bought. The doctors say you wanted everybody to get out of here. But it ain't one. It shot them.

Oh, me. So who should know? I'm going to get better than him. Oh, me. You and John Williams were in partnership with Sam Foster, Whitey. You broke up. Foster wants to run the whole racket, so he killed Williams and he tried to kill you. The nest. Unless you killed Williams. Friends. Besides, I could figure out a way to kill him with a flock of blood outside his house. Footprints. Whitey. Whitey. Dr. Manders. Dr. Manders. Yes, Vance. I'm coming. What is it? Take a look at the patient, Doctor. I think he's dead, only I didn't take time to make sure. Yes, he's dead already. Although how he lived this long after being shot is a mystery. You think that's a mystery, Doctor? How about the one I'm going to work on now? How a man could walk through 30 feet of mud without leaving a footprint. Oh, Sam. Sam, you're private. You ever hear the one about... Wait a minute, babe. Who is it? I said, who is it?

See, I'd commit to force it. Could I commit? Beat it. Come back next year. Oh, man. I said, could I commit? Later. Next year? Okay, I'll come back next year. I'm Oscar Sammy Price. Look at him. Am I getting heavy on your knee, Sam? Sure. But it's worth it. Give it. Come closer to you. How could I do that? Oh, Sammy Price. Look at him. It feels good, doesn't it? Well, why not? I'm with the biggest man in town. That makes me the biggest gal in town, doesn't it? Well, it depends on how you look at it. You're glad Johnny Williams is out of the way. Almost as glad as you are. You did give me a rough deal. But you had nothing against Whitey Morrow. No, I kind of liked him. He had a lot of funny jokes. Honestly, he told me when I nearly died laughing that he was proud of me.

You read about how Johnny Williams died, didn't you? Read about it? Oh, sure, I read about it. I can't figure it out, but I read about it. You weren't the only one who can't figure it, Julie. Johnny Williams ain't the only one I read about either, Sam. I read about a fellow named Philo Vance that's working on the case. Good, I'd like to see a fellow have a job. Oh, you're smarter than that, Sam. You know Vance has got plenty on the ball. Sure, but he's got nothing on me. Good enough for now, but you know how you do, Josky Talks. He thinks as though he's always one sentence behind what you ask him. Sure. What about it? Well, Vance, I hear, is just the opposite. He's thinking one move ahead of you all the time. The guy's cross with Vance. I wouldn't think of trying to buy him off, maybe. He's kind of careless, too. I wasn't thinking of trying to scare him off. He isn't deathless, is he? I know Vance. Hold everything, Markham. I haven't even begun my investigation yet.

I'll get back to you as soon as I can. Where are you, Vance? As soon as I hang up this phone, I'm going out to Johnny Williams' house. The house of mystery. What's the point? There's nothing there. It's just a house. On the day of the burger, it was surrounded by a sea of mud. It's the same way right now, then. This rain will see to that. But I want to question Williams' housekeeper. I understand. I hope you understand that Sam Foster is the new underworld king of this town, now that Williams and Morrow are dead. Yes, I realize that. And I hope to prove to be a little sunshine to Mr. Foster. You're going to be a little sunshine to Foster? How do you mean? You said he was the king, didn't you? Yes.

Well, weather reports to the contrary. I'm going to try to see that he doesn't rain anymore. Oh, man. Hello in there. Anybody home? I could have sworn. Hello. Well. I said hello. My name is Philo Vance. You're Johnny Williams' housekeeper? Yes. Rather chilly out here and more than a little wet. May I come in? If you like. Thank you. Ah. Keeping character, I'm surprised you don't have an Angora cap on your shoulder. I hate caps. May I ask your name? Mrs. Stewart. What do you want here, Ben? Mrs. Stewart, I'd like you to understand something. Well? Police are convinced that Mr. Williams was killed by somebody who came into this house and left it without leaving any footprints, even though this house is surrounded by mud. And you're not convinced? That's right. Before I knocked at the door, I tried to think of how I could possibly get from the road to the porch, distance of about 30 feet, without leaving any prints. And? My footprints are in the mud. It can't be done.

In as much as it can't be done, my theory is that Mr. Williams was killed by somebody in this house. I was in the house when the shots were fired. That's what I meant. That I shot him? Why not? You had opportunity. You had a motive, and you might very possibly have had a motive. Duck down! Did you get hit? No. No. Thank you for the warning. Never mind that. Let's find whoever it is that fired at us. You stay here. Where are you going? Out through the door. A shot came from the front window. The killer may be outside. I'm going outside to see. There are floodlights that light up the entire yard. Wait a minute. There. And if you're going out, I'm going with you. Very well, but stay in back of me. I don't see anybody. What else don't you see? What? What else don't you see? I don't understand what you mean. How many sets of footprints do you see in the ground, then? How many? Yes. Why, there's only one set leading to the house. Close in mind. You were with me when someone broke the glass in the window and fired.

You must have seen a figure on the porch or you couldn't have warned me. Yes. That's the situation you said was impossible. The same situation that occurred when Mr. Williams died. Do you still think it's impossible, then? This is District Attorney Markham. The Muddy murder case began with the shooting of Johnny Williams, his racketeer. Although his house was completely surrounded by mud, although Williams was killed at close range, we found no footprints in the mud. Nobody but Williams' housekeeper was in his home. We suspect a racketeer named Sam Foster. especially since we think he killed another former ally. But Vance, who is in my office, can often... That's the story, Mark. I was in the house, saw a figure on the porch, was there when the shots were fired, so I know somebody crossed 30 feet of mud without leaving any footprints. That settles it, then, doesn't it? It can be done. Would it surprise you if I told you that now I think I know how it would be done? Nothing you tell me surprises me anymore, Vance. You're not thinking of anything as fantastic as a helicopter or some sort of flying apparatus, are you? Mark! No, I didn't think of that.

Having an idea and doing something about it are two different things, though. This Sam Foster, Mark, the man who takes over the town's rackets, what about him? It's reasonable to believe that he killed Williams and Whitey Morrow, too, in order to get sole control. Is he a college man? I'm sure I don't know. I'm sure you could find out. Yes, I suppose so. You think he found a mathematical formative for reducing the 30 feet of mud to one foot and stepped across it? No, that isn't it at all. Find out for me if he went to college. and what college it was he went to. Then maybe I'll find out something for you. You know what I don't understand, Julie? I don't understand why you don't like me. What are you talking about, Oscar? You just don't understand it, that's all. I'm big, I'm an important guy, I'm Mr. Fort's right-hand man. That's true.

All right, so I ain't pretty. Look, you better not let Foster hear you. What am I talking about? I'm talking about you and me, Junie girl. One half of that is a very interesting conversation. So, Foster finds out. So what? So you'll find out. Which half of you would be his interest? Give me a break. Here, cut that out, Oscar. You didn't hear me say give me a half, baby. I said cut it out, Oscar. Okay, so I come to you. No, no. Don't that feel nice and cozy being here while you're up? You can leave me alone, Oscar. Hey, what's he playing in here? Beauty and the Beast? Sam, the baby has tried to go in the mix on me. Let's go inside, Oscar.

What do you mean, beauty and the beast? What does that mean, beauty and the beast? You only look good to me, I tried to tell it. You tried to show me, I mean. I told you what would happen when I told Sam. What did happen, baby? You ain't saw. You ain't going to take this big lug apart. Oscar is a very important member of my organization, June. Oh, and I'm not. Not of my business organization. And business, you know, honey, always comes before anything else. Hello, Vance speaking. Mr. Farrow, Vance. Unquestionably. Well, Vance. You don't know me. Sometimes you may realize how bad that is for you. Well, in that event, let's make that some time right now. Uh-uh. No can do then. Look, I read that you're working on the murder of Johnny Williams. Like to know who killed him and Whitey Morrow? Sam Foster. That's right. What did Foster ever do to you? You mean, why am I tipping you off? Yes. Because I'm playing second fiddle to a gun-crazy goon, that's why. Good enough reason.

You can prove that Foster killed Williams and Morrow? He killed Williams and he had that gun-crazy goon I was telling you about kill Morrow. How was Williams killed with all that mud surrounding his house? Search me. That would hardly clarify the situation. Well, I... You mean you don't know? That's right. I don't know everything. What you've told me, miss, is what the police and I already suspect. Can you prove what you're saying? What's the matter? Ain't my word good enough? It is for me, but a jury is unreasonable. I'd like to have proof. Yeah. But perhaps I can get that proof. The district attorney found out for me that Foster went to state college. Now you tell me where Sam Foster and his friend can be found. Ray Doll Apartments. They got a suite. You go there, Vance, and see that they get a headache. Look, Oscar, one thing you've got to stop. Oscar, are you listening? Yeah, Mr. Foster. That's what I mean. You've got to stop answering questions a minute after I ask them.

I gotta stop answering the question. Oh, yeah, I get you. But I explained that to you a hundred times. It takes a long time for me to get things in my head. By the time I do, you're asking me something else. I wish that you weren't so handy with an automatic. By the way, keep away from June. That happens to be... Happens to be what? When I put the door up. Oh, wait. That's just like people. For once, I concentrate. I answer the question you're asking, and you switch to something else. Shut up. You want me to get the door? Get the next room. I'll take care of it. All right. I'm coming. Well, I'm Philo Vance. You're Sam Foster? Yes. Now that we have the introductions out of the way, so long, Vance. Congratulations, strong man. You pushed open the door.

What are you going to do for an encore? Twist an iron bar around your arm? Foster, there are a lot of things in the world I hate, and you represent most of them. Murder, smugness, disregard of other people. Oscar! Oh, Oscar! Calling for help already, Foster? Nothing like being prepared. Only this help of mine takes a little time to understand things. Oscar! Did you call me, Mr. Foster? Yes, Oscar. He does look a little like a ape. Wait until he realizes what you just said, Vance. You will be the one who needs help. I look like a what? You look like... Vance, why don't you be a nice guy and get out of here? Legs are nice things to walk around on. You shouldn't want yours broken. I don't see anybody here that's capable of giving me even a little exercise. Oscar, go to work on him. What is it I look like? Go to work on this guy. Make him sorry he talks so much now. Oh, go to work on him. Why didn't you say we was having a party?

This is it. The things the guy said. What am I supposed to do? Roll over and play? Took him a little while to realize he was not cold, eh, Foster? Apparently. You handle yourself pretty good, Vance. You mean pretty well, don't you, Foster? They never taught you to say pretty good at State University, did they? What about me in State? Nothing much. I'm just waiting for one little bit of information. And the four years you spent at State will seem nothing to the years that the State has reserved for you. Yes, that's fine. Thank you. Thank you very much. Bye. Finally. You got what you wanted, D.A.? Yes, June, I did. That's good. That was State College, and as usual, Vance was right. I don't see yet how this solves the Johnny Williams murder mystery, but I'm sure Vance does. You know, I think Vance knows everything. Yes. I tried to tell that to Sam Foster, and that's one reason I think he took a shot at Vance out at the Williams house when Vance was talking to the housekeeper.

Undoubtedly. As for you, young lady, I think now that Vance has sent you to me, I'd better see to it that you're taken care of. Oh, you're priceless, Mark. I mean, placed in protective custody. Oh. Yeah. After I'm sure you're all right, I'll meet Vance and the two of us will go to see Foster and Oscar. Only, don't leave without arresting them. I don't feel safe anymore with either one of them around. When Foster took Oscar's side, I had an idea he'd let that big lug shoot me if it would make him happy. That's why I went to Vance in the first place. I understand. Everything will be all right for you, June, after Vance and I visit your former friends. It'll be all right for you and annoying to a couple of men who are all wrong. It isn't that Oscar and I aren't very honored by this visit, you understand. You're very kind. It isn't often that a district attorney and a distinguished private investigator come to call on us. Right, Oscar? Never mind that nonsense, Foster. I came up here to tell you that you and Oscar are going downtown with Markham and me. What's right, Mr.

Cool. Shut up, Oscar. Cool. I will take that slower, Vance. What makes you think you can drag us downtown? On what charge? Murder, of course. Murder of John Williams and Marty Morrow. Oh. I killed them both, eh, DA? According to our information, you killed Williams and had Oscar shoot Morrow. I'm pretty sure the information is right. Hold everything. How can you think I killed Williams when you can't even think of how the guy was killed? You know somebody was in his house, but there were no footprints leading to and from that house. That's perfectly right, Foster. There weren't any, because William's killer didn't walk through the mud. Oh. He flew through it, huh? Put on wings and flew over it. You're pretty close. But what's more important, so am I. Remember I asked you about State when I was here last? So? Mr. Markham called State. He found out some very valuable information in regard to your athletic activities in school.

You guys know too much. Let's get them, Oscar. Okay, with me. Two down, Vance. I'm sorry I had to shoot that Oscar, but it was neither him or me, and I'm selfish that way. I don't blame you one bit, Markham. He's still alive and still able to stand trial, I think. You won't have to worry about getting a conviction, I don't believe. With your theory and the girl's testimony, not to mention the possibility that the death bullets in Williams and Morrow will match the guns belonging to these individuals, I'm pretty sure we'll be all right. Pretty cute idea Foster had for the Williams murder, wasn't it? The no footprints thing? Mm-hmm. Very cute. In fact, it was one of the most interesting gimmicks I've ever encountered. Let's talk about it as soon as we take these two characters down to headquarters. Wait a minute, Vance. I'll give you a light. There you are. Thanks, Markham.

Now tell me, what gave you the idea that Sam Foster was an athlete? It was one way a man could get over 30 feet of mud, Markham. Using a pole such as vaulters use in athletic meets. Uh-huh. Run on the road, insert the pole in the mud, pull yourself up and out. You could land on Williams' porch without leaving any tracks. As soon as State told us that Foster had been a pole vaulter, I knew what your theory was. And he knew that he was finished as soon as we brought up the fact that we did know. Yes. And Markham, I'm very happy about the whole thing. It really had me confused for quite a while. He undoubtedly followed me to the Williams place and tried to kill me when I was there questioning the housekeeper. Uh-huh. Although I thought for a minute it was she he was after. It doesn't matter now. As far as any killings or would-be killings are concerned, Foster and Oscar are finished. And you know, Markham, so is the muddy murder case.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑