The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 20 min to read
I didn't understand it myself, but... Uh, date? Uh... Two. Sergeant Frank Nilgus, Robbery Detail, San Francisco Police. You're fast today. Subject, Ben Comiskey. Who? Ben Comiskey. C-O-M-I-S-K-I. Sam! You went to Elbert High School with a boy named Ben Comiskey? Is he the same one? Very likely, yes. Oh, Sam, tell me, did he turn out bad? Is he good? Did he get married? Down, Effie! Sam, I knew you, boy! This is one mystery you're not going to solve by reading the last chapter first. Dear Frank, it was one of those days. The sky was black and it looked like rain, but when I put on my trench coat, the sun came out. At breakfast, it looked like I'd ordered fried eggs and I wound up with pancakes. Also, I discovered I was wearing one blue sock and one black one. After that, I gave a cab driver a five instead of a one and let him ride off with a change. And there was one other thing. Sam, banks have called. They're overdrawn.
They're nuts, Ev. I made a deposit two days ago. I checked, Sam. You're nuts, too. I made out the slip myself and I... Oh. Give me, Sam. I'll take it right down. You better do that, Angel. Oh, can I help you, miss? Come right in, miss. Sit down. Miss Perrine, you may go and do that. Instruct them that if such a mistake occurs again, I shall take my account elsewhere. Yes, sir. I'll, uh... Please sit down, Miss... My name's Louise Miller, Mr. Spade. I want to hire you. How much will it cost? Well, now, Miss Miller, let's talk about it a little first. I haven't much time, Mr. Spade. I have to be at the office in a half an hour, and I have to cross town. You see, I... Well, Mama thinks I should forget all about him, but I can't, and I... Well, here, I've got $95. Will you please do something? Just something! Come on, now, come on. Sorry, I...
It's all right. Now, who is he? What's he done? And why does Mama want you to forget him? Ben. Ben Comiskey. We were going to be married pretty soon. We even picked out our furniture. It's all right. Go on. What's he done? They say he held up a store two nights ago. They picked him up on the street today. He's in jail. Well, if he's innocent, I'm sure they'll find that out. He won't even see me, Mrs. Spade. He won't see anyone. Ben's good and kind and sweet. I love him and I want to marry him. I want you to find out why, what it's all about. Look, Miss Miller, I think you should be in the office of a good lawyer. I'm sure that... He doesn't want a lawyer. He won't even see the public defender. He doesn't want anything. Oh, please. Please, Mrs. Spade. I just want to die if Ben went to prison. I just want to die.
I'm no sentimentalist, but faith is a thing we're a little short on these days, so we came to terms. It was a grade she could pay me after the job was done if there was any job to do. She left for work, and I phoned you, Sergeant Milgus, and found out Ben Comiskey had already been arraigned and was being held in a city jail. When I dropped in 20 minutes later, you walked me back to his cell. What's it all about, Sam? No, no, just looking into it. He won't tell you anything. No? Captain's trap shut all the time he's been here. As far as we've been able to find out, no previous record, no background. Well, maybe it isn't so bad for him at that, huh? First degree, Sam. Liquor store proprietor, a man named Potter, over on Army Street, identified him in the morning lineup. Just like that. Picked him out of a dozen guys we hauled in. Then what? We send a couple of the boys out to Comiskey's room and find all the dough in the dresser drawer, 900 coins.
Take it easy, Comiskey. This is Sam Spade. He wants to talk to you. Ben Comiskey was tall, dark complexioned, about 29 or 30 years old. His hair was black, straight, and closely cropped. His features were regular, not good, not bad. I've seen plenty of hold-up men and gun-toters in my day, and he wouldn't have been cast on the part in my movie. I didn't know what I expected to say to him or what I expected him to say to me, but I didn't expect what I got. What are you trying to do? Get out of here. It's got here, Ben. Well, you can just leave. Hasn't a citizen got any rights? Even in jail? Well, they start to lose them when they use a gun to make a living. I don't want any lectures. I haven't got any to hand out. I'm a private detective. A friend of yours hired me. She thinks you're a pretty nice guy. Louise. Why won't you see her? She's nuts. She ought to have a head filled. What's she worrying about anyway? I'd say she was worrying mostly about you. And I'd say it's the sick kind of worry that gets into a girl when she loves somebody. She shouldn't. She's nuts. You said that.
Did you rob that store? The guy who runs it says I did. I suppose I did. Why? For laughs. The complaint says you make 65 bucks a week in an architect's office. You can eat on that. Look, Spade, go back and tell her this. I didn't want furniture at $10 a month for the next 80 months. I didn't want a car the same way. I didn't want her working and me working and getting nothing but wrinkles. Tell her I got caught and to go and find a guy who can pay the way. Is that all? That's enough. You're charged with armed robbery in the first degree. That means not less than five years. I know it. Shut up about it. Why'd you turn down a lawyer? Hadn't you heard, Spade? They're holding up my indictment. I'm a prized pigeon. They think maybe I knocked over ten or twelve other places in town. Pigeons? Sure, sure. But don't worry about me. And tell Louise not to worry about me. I've got a million bucks salted away, and I'm gonna buy my way out through the DA's office. Okay. Have it your way, Ben.
I found myself strolling around Ben Comiskey's old neighborhood. A man named Gabrini, who owned a grocery store, remembered him and liked him. A woman in a bakery shop told me how he'd gone into the army as a private and been discharged a first lieutenant. A phone call to a Mr. Henderson, a light architect, revealed that Ben Comiskey was in line for a raise and promotion. All in all, I was getting a composite picture that didn't look quite right. I decided to try his mother's place. It was on Lombard Avenue, a street that starts on the waterfront. According to the penciled note above the doorbell, it was out of order. The slot in the mailbox read, Mrs. Anastasia Comiskey. Yes. What is it, please? You're Mrs. Comiskey? I'm busy now. I picked lunch for my son. He come back from Cincinnati. Please. Oh, well, Mrs. Comiskey, I'm here to talk to you about Ben. He's your son, too, isn't he? Yes. Ben is my son. Well, I'm trying to help him, Mrs. Comiskey. Why?
He has no money. I have no money. A friend of his, Louise Miller, hired me. Oh, Louise. She's a foolish girl. Very foolish. Her heart should not be with Ben. I think he's a very lucky man to be loved by somebody like that. If not for her, Ben would not be in jail, in trouble. Oh, you don't want to help my son. She don't want to help him. She'll leave him alone if you want to help. Ben is bad. Not good like my son, James. James... Always good. Times is the way he sends me money. From what I hear, Ben's always been pretty good, too. Always one good son, one bad son. What's going on, Mom? Who's this? He needs to come to ask questions about Ben. Huh? I'm Jim Comiskey, Ben's brother. Where am I? You run on in, Mom. I'll talk to this gentleman. Get out of here. Look, I'm just trying. If you've got any questions to ask about Ben, go to the police. They can give you all the answers.
And stop bothering my mother. It's been through enough in the last two days. If I catch you around her again, I'll break you in half. The man who slammed the door in my face had the same angry look and the same angry glare of Ben Comiskey. The angry Comiskey brothers definitely wanted nothing that looked remotely like help, it seemed to this casual observer. I went back to my office to wait for 6 o'clock. That's when I intended to call my client, report my opinions, and drop the case. But at 5.30, she called me. Hey. Yeah? This is Louise Miller. Oh, yes. I was just going to call you. I'm afraid I haven't been able to do much. It looks like... I know, Mr. Spader. I just telephoned downtown. Ben pleaded... Ben pleaded guilty at the indictment this afternoon. He's going to be sentenced tomorrow. And that, to all appearances, Sergeant Milgus, was the crop. But two hours later, and for the second time in one day, I found myself doing what I didn't think I'd be doing. Walking around a dull, gray, two-story apartment house on Adams Place.
My ex-client's address, to be exact. I was wondering what a lonely, distraught girl would be thinking the night before her boyfriend was shipped away to prison. I found out. I got a whiff of it as I walked down the hall. It was coming out from under her door. I had to use my shoulder. The room was acrid and stinging with gas fumes. And Louise Miller was stretched down on the floor in a six-foot kitchen. When I picked her up and carried her out, I wasn't sure whether she was dead or not.
Ten seconds after I'd found Louise Miller, I'd called a police ambulance, and in a matter of minutes, an intern was working over her with a pull motor. Her breathing became regular and her pulse picked up, but she was still unconscious. Lieutenant Kelsey of Homicide showed up and said it was obviously a suicide attempt, which is his kind of ingenious thinking. I thought not. If she were going to commit suicide, she wouldn't have called first to pull me off the caper. She'd have let an insignificant detail like that take care of itself. Now, she was too strong to pity herself and too sure of what her intuition told her to believe even Ben Comiskey's confession. For that kind of faith, I owed it to her to poke around the ashes while they were still hot. I did. It turned up a live cold in a faded blue shirt and wrinkled brown pants. Bert Singleby, by name and by vocation, manager of the Greystone Arms Apartments. What kind of a girl was she? Oh, nice, clean, sincere. Kind mothers always want their sons to marry. Oh, I wish I'd listened to mine.
Did you know her boyfriend, Ben Comiskey? Oh, salt on dirt. I can't understand him pulling a hold up like that. But then, you know, the war did strange things to me. Yes, I guess it did. I almost stayed in Europe and married myself up to a French doll myself. Yeah. But Sandra, that's my wife, you know, hunted me down in Tibet. It was easy to come home and face the music. Yeah, well, about Louise, you know any reason why she might commit suicide? Frankly, no. I met her in the hallway tonight, and she said, Mr. Singleton, she said, Ben didn't do that hold-up, because I'm pretty sure I know who did. Well, I figure she's just keeping up a front. But if she did really know that Ben didn't do it, she wouldn't have turned on the gas now, would she? No, she wouldn't. Did she tell you who she thought did it? No, that's all she said. Quiet, girl. Not like my wife. Now, Sam. Yeah, did you see or hear anything that might have been suspicious or unusual around her apartment tonight? Look, I don't want to go around breaking up any homes or spreading dirty gossip around.
Oh, Sandra's relative. Mr. Singleby, I promise you, sir, that I'll treat any information you give me confidentially as long as I can. Oh, Sandra told me not to say it. Because, you know, it's a lot easier to rent a suicide apartment than a murder apartment. You know that? Confidentially, I'm a humanitarian. But if you tell anybody I said this, well, I'll just lie about it. I'll never tell a soul. We were out of butters, so I had to run down to the store. When I passed the mailboxes outside, a guy was standing there. He asked me which apartment Louise Miller was in, and I said 12B. What did he look like?
Oh, we'll see now. A 5'10", medium build, pantsuit, dark shirt, sort of a wide-brim hat. Kind of flashy. Mm-hmm. Wore three or four big rings. Diamonds, they look like. Yeah? Three or four big diamond rings on each hand. The Iceman. Why didn't you tell all this to the police? Why? Is why. Sandra always says, keep your mouth shut and you'll keep out of trouble. But me, I don't know. I just love... No! No! Yes, Sandra, dear. Closing it. The Iceman. I'd heard about him for years. A Chicago import, but I had never bumped into him before. He'd been headquartering at the Red Spot Cafe, the kind of a place that skid row winos visit when they want a slump. It was dark inside, but I strode manfully to the bar. Something? The Iceman here? What do you want him for, huh? He's a friend of mine. You're a friend of whose? What are you giving me? You got bull written all over you, from the top of your stupid head to the bottom of your flat feet. He had the tan suit, the flashy rings, the dark shirt, and a wide-brimmed hat.
He stared at me with eyes that were icy and insolent. He rubbed the knuckles of one hand into the palm of the other as if he just ached for a chance to bruise them, which I was sure he did. Four guys sauntered over to lean on the piano, and as ugly as they were, I knew it wasn't a barbershop quartet. Two more left the bar and stood behind him, and a few others got up from nearby tables and joined the group. I should have brought my team, but I hadn't. You're a friend of mine, huh? Well, if it isn't Claude Bettering, the juvenile delinquent of 1940. Is that so? And you're a real brain. Who are you, brainy? Sam Spade. Oh, now, ain't that a pretty name? You got something on your mind? I just wanted to talk with you about what you did to a girl named Louise Miller tonight. Never heard of her. Sounds cute, though. Girls are a lot easier to push around, aren't they, Claude? Call me Ice. Claude. Some guys are just as easy as some dames. Where have I been all night tonight, fellas? Here, Ice. You heard that, Spade? I've been here all night. Any of you guys ever hear of a Louise Miller?
Sorry, nobody ever heard of her, see? Well, she has a lot of friends who have. The police, the people down at Mercy Hospital, and me. And none of us are gonna forget it, or what happened to her, and who did it. Got something you'd like to do right now, maybe? Yeah, but I'll pick my time. All right, enough of this cheap chatter. I don't want to be seen talking with you too long. I got my reputation to think about. Now blow before I take one hand out of my pocket and push your stinking face back through that door. You'll need both hands, Samson. Go on, you creep. Fellas. All right. As I went rapidly through the door, Claude Bettering was standing, oily smile and all, polishing a couple of his oversized rings on his lapel. It was a picture I said I wouldn't forget, and I didn't. I went and rented myself a car, parked it down the block in the Red Spot Cafe, and waited almost all night. I knew that Louise Miller was not the kind of a girl who would have anything to do with a guy like Bettering. And if he came to her apartment, it must have been for some unloving purpose.
probably to keep her from telling who actually did the holdup Ben Comiskey had confessed to, if she found out the truth. Finally, a bunch of palookas came out, Bettering included, climbed into a car and drove off, me after them. One by one, Bettering dropped his men off at their hotels and apartments until he was finally alone. He stopped at a brownstone on Hobart, and I caught him just as he opened the door of his apartment. Well, the tough guy. You're gonna find out. Don't think I'm easy. And he wasn't easy. He was three inches shorter and 25 pounds lighter, and wherever he had picked up his reputation for toughness, he earned it. But I never enjoyed a fight in my life any more than that one. I batted him to his knees and into the floor, and he still wouldn't give up. You stinking creep. Why did you beat up Louise Miller? I didn't. The house manager identified you. He's a liar. Who did you do it for? Nobody. Who? Who? Who? He went out. Quite a guy, the Iceman.
I used his phone to call the police and tell them to pick him up for attempted murder. Then with dawn coming up and my energy going down, I went back to the city jail, got a pass, and woke up Ben Comiskey. Why don't you stop messing around in my business, babe? Did you ever really love that girl of yours? Get out, you sadistic jerk. Well, she's in Mercy Hospital now. You can send her a card. Write something nasty on it. So long. Babe. Yeah? What's she in the hospital about? What do you care? Tell me. Please. Somebody turned on the gas in her apartment and tried to kill her. It's nothing, really. Who did it? Who did it, Spade? I think it was a guy named Claude Bettering. They call him the Iceman in certain circles. But why? That's what I'd like to know. Who's Bettering? I don't know. Your girl believed you were innocent, Comiskey, but you said you weren't. My guess is that somebody figured she knew something and tried to shut her up. I think Bettering was hired by somebody. Spade, look, I don't have any doubts.
But I want to get out of here. For one day. You know anybody who can raise the bail? I won't skip. And I'll pay back anything you want. Why? I've got to see somebody. I don't think I can. Who do you want to see? My lousy, dirty, low-down, no-good brother. He hired veterans? Who else? He did everything. Always done everything wrong. He held up that liquor store. But he's on parole. A two-time felony offender. One more rap and he'd go up for 20 years. I did this for him. Yeah. Look, I did it for him, and he tries to kill my girl. Your mother said he was a good boy, hardworking, lived in Cincinnati. Me again. I told her all that. She believed me. I started a whole stupid lie and had to go through with it. I could explain two years, three years to her, but not 20. He promised he'd go straight. He promised. I see. I even said her money I earned and said it was from him. Oh, you never saw anybody like me before, did you? No, I haven't. Get me out.
Get me out, Sam, and I'll drag him in by himself. Thanks anyway, but I'll do it myself. Steve, let me do it. Let me do it, please. I drove over to Mrs. Comiskey's house and knocked on her door. She came out in a housecoat, hair must, and sleep still in her eyes. Yes? I'm sorry to bother you at this hour, Mrs. Comiskey, but is your son home, Jimmy? Jim? No, he went out last night. He didn't come back yet. I see. When do you expect him? Well, he didn't come. He didn't have to because I saw a closet door move and I was in and across the room. In a second, I pulled the door back and Jim Comiskey came out, gun and all. She hurried across the room, threw herself between Jimmy and me and started wrestling the gun away from me. He put one hand flat on her face and knocked her halfway across the room. I went at him. He shot, but it went into the ceiling. I didn't give him a chance to do it again. You held up the liquor, so I did. To kill Louise Miller? Yeah. And you're gonna take your own rap.
From now on. Yeah. Yeah. I will. And he did. Period. End of report. Oh, foolish. Yeah. Yeah, she lived in a dream world built by a son who had too much heart and not enough common sense. But Sam, that man in the liquor store identified Ben as the hole cut man. Well, when he saw the both brothers together, he realized he'd made a mistake. At night, with a hat pulled down and a collar up, anybody could have confused the Comiskey brothers. Why is the world so cruel? Because people live in it. Now go and type it in, huh? I say so. It's a lesson to everybody. If you say so, Ed. Oh, Sam, I'm just infuriated. Now, now, don't go too far. This place loves the people like you. Step in and kick things in half. Back to work! Sam, well... Are you finished? Well, it's a sociological feeling, too. It's not an automatic seek new case. Happy, I just kissed you. I just kissed you. Delayed reaction. I said...
