Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Suspense artwork

From the Suspense collection

Beyond Good and Evil

Episode 162October 11, 194525 min 47 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 18 min to read

Suspense. Tonight, Mr. Joseph Cotton as star of Beyond Good and Evil, a suspense play produced, edited, and directed by William Spear. Why, Dr. Pierce, good evening. Good evening, Mary. Is Dr. McKillop still awake? Oh, yes. We don't put him to bed until eight or later. Is evening service over already? A shame, Mary, a parson's housekeeper, and you forget we don't hold service on Wednesdays? Why, it slipped my mind it was Wednesday, sir. Of course, you come to read to Dr. McKillop. He'll be so pleased. There's so little I can do if he were able to let us know in some way. I can tell by his eyes, sir. Whenever you're here, they fairly glow. Well, I suppose, but helpless as he is, not able to speak or even write, my visits are at least a diversion. You?

You're more than inversion, sir. You're his hope, if I may say so. No, Mary. The Lord is his hope. Oh, yes, sir. The Lord struck him down with paralysis. And in time, the Lord will surely free him from it. Where is the doctor? In his study, sir. We'll leave him there until bedtime. Very well. I'll go in for an hour or so. Stay as long as you like, Dr. Pierce. We won't disturb you. Dr. MacKillop, it's Dr. Pierce come to read to you. Good evening, Dr. McKillop. Good evening, good evening, good evening, good evening. You're a most satisfying companion, McKillop. You hang on my every word and you never talk back. Never but once. And after tonight, you won't get the chance. So speak up, Doctor. Why don't you? No? Oh, of course, the cat's got your tongue. Well, I'll turn up the lights a bit so I can at least bask in your baleful stare. There.

That's better, much better. Yes, tonight is your last chance, McKillop. Tonight is the consummation, the grand finale, the end, the act three curtain on a great play about death, redemption, about good and evil. And I won't shrink from your eyes tonight, McKillop. Your eyes can't kill, but I can kill. I have the mind and the will and the hand. I've killed one man that you know. And tonight, I'm going to kill again.

No reading from the good book tonight, Doctor. No more metaphysics now. I'm going to tell you a story. Much of it is ancient history to you, but I think there is enough new to hold your interest. I know it will hold my interest because I enjoy talking about myself. Well, you already know I killed a man. You know who he was. And you even know... Who I was before I became Dr. Howard Pierce, pastor of this good and godly community. At least you know the name Philip Gentry. But you never knew the soul of Philip Gentry, Doctor. The contempt, the sum of evil that was in me that night it all began. That was three months ago. A stormy night, as you remember. And where was I? I was crouched in a swamp with a man named Mac. Because we had just escaped from prison, hiding like an...

Animal in the deep mud and ooze. Alien from the whole human race. Gentry, where are you going? To the highway, fool. Got to get out of this mud and make time. But Pete's back there in the swamp. You can't leave him. Why not? Because he'll die. We all got to stick together. He'll die back there. Listen, we took equal chances when we made this break. I'm not going to take extra chances for anyone. We have to make time before daylight, before the rain stops. They'll bring out dogs in the morning. Dogs? Okay, okay, you're the boss. See? At the highway now, beyond the tent. Yeah. So what do we do? Where do we go? We split up. But Gentry, shouldn't we stick together? We split up. I go my way, you go yours. I'll meet you in Chicago later. At Tony's place? Tony's place. Okay. Two or three weeks. The manhunt cools off. Okay, we'll make a great team, you and me. We'll make them suckers scream. Chicago. And then maybe South America. All right, Mac. Save the dreaming for later. Right now, you've got to get moving. Now go on, fast. He headed north. I walked a mile or more this way south. Then I saw the car.

It was parked close to the edge of the road, its headlight almost blacked out by the driving rain. And by the glow of a flashlight, I saw a man bending into the rain, struggling to change a tire. He was alone, so I walked up to him. Oh, you startled me. I didn't expect to see anyone out this late. You picked a bad night for a flat. Yes, and it's the second today. I'm going to be awfully late. Here, let me... Oh, no, no, but if you'd hold the light. Oh, sure. Come a long way? From Detroit. I'm on my way to Carlton. I'm supposed to get there this afternoon. At your home, Carlton? Well, it will be. I'm the new minister there. My name's Pitt. Oh, of course. I didn't notice you were a preacher. Do you know Carlton? Well, pretty well. I'm taking over for Dr. O... Dr. McKillop at Grace Church. Oh, yeah, yeah, I've heard of him. He's been in bad health, so I'm taking his place. Oh, I see. Bolt is stubborn.

I can't seem to... Here, let me try. No, no, no, I'll manage. Give me the wrench. No, really, just hold the... I said give me the wrench. Well, all right, it's awfully good of you. What? Wait, what are you doing? I need your card. Pierce, you're going to be even later than you thought. No, please, please don't hit me. Oh, oh. Here, let me see your license, buddy. Huh? My license? Oh. Oh. Oh, yes, I... Oh, I have it here. Here it is. Hmm? Howard Pierce. Occupation? Oh, a minister. I didn't notice. Yes, but, uh, well, what is it with high speeding? No, we're checking all cars on this road. With a bad break at the state pen, three men, they might come this way. Say, but I won't hold you any longer, Reverend. Going far? Well, to, uh, Carleton. Oh, now I get it. Imagine me not catching on right away. Catching on? Sure. You must be the new preacher for Grace Church. You're taking Dr. McKillop's place. Why?

Yes, I am. You're going to Parsonage now? I was going. Well, I'm going into headquarters now, and I have to go right by Dr. McKillop's house. You follow me. I couldn't. It's not out of my way at all. Not more than a block. I'll go slow so you can't lose me, okay? All right. Well, that's the ticket. Really tickle old Dr. McKillop to have you delivered right to his door. Say, I bet you never counted on this kind of reception in Carlton, Reverend Pierce. Now, did you? No, I certainly didn't, my son. So that was it. My arrival in your dull, pleasant town of Carlton, remember? Officer Owens and your very beautiful daughter escorted me to your study. Father.

Mr. Owens brought Dr. Pierce. Dr. Pierce, come in, come in. You and Mr. Owens wait outside for a few minutes, Lucy. Yes, yes, all right, Father. Sit over here, Dr. Pierce. I can't tell you how relieved I am to see you. I'm relieved to finally be here, Dr. McCullough. Yes, well, I really couldn't bring myself to sleep tonight without first talking to you. You see, the situation's serious. Serious? My health. I'm a sick man. I've had one stroke, as you know. Oh, yes. You wrote. Yes. Well, I could have another one at any minute. The doctor says a worse one. But I feel it essential that the work of the parish is in firm hands. This parish needs a young man. Well, I hope to be of service. I've heard only good of you, Dr. Pierce. And you know, you're even younger than you looked.

And I looked... In the picture you sent the doctor to your hair. I'm afraid it wasn't a good likeness. I have the picture here somewhere on my desk with you. What did you want to talk to me about, Dr. McKillop? Oh, the work of the parish. Oh, yes, yes, here's the photograph. It's Dr. Pierce. Is there something wrong, Dr. McKillop? It's not. Who are you? This isn't your picture. Who are you? I don't think that would interest you, Dr. McKillop. Something's happened to Dr. Pierce. What did you do to him? You're... you're... What do you think I did, Dr. McKillop? Go on. Guess. Guess. Don't play with me, you sanctimonious fool. Speak up. Speak. Oh, brother, don't tell me. You've had a stroke. You can't speak. Is that it? Well, I'll find out. I'll take that picture, Dr. McKillop. Now, if you don't mind...

We thought... Yes, Miss Lucy, something's happened to your father. We were talking and all... Hey, he's sick. I'll call the doctor, Miss Lucy. Yes, please, Mr. Rowan. It's another stroke. He can't speak. Apparently, he can't move. Father. Father, what can we do? You'll have to wait for the doctor. Maybe even... I know. The doctor said he could be paralyzed for months, years, but he mustn't die. Oh, I'm sure the Lord will spare him if we have faith. Yes, yes. Look. He can hear us, see his eyes. I see. It's a blessing you got here tonight, Dr. Pierce, a blessing. You are going to stay. But you must. Well, I wasn't sure, but since this has happened to your father, yes, I'll stay. I hope I prove worthy. Dear friends, you may wonder that I chose this subject for my first sermon to you, The Agony of the Thief. It is no wonder.

For as I spoke to you of such a man, a thief beaten, outcast, and alone, I spoke at the same time of each of us, from the mighty to the fallen, of that substance which we all share, our human dignity, as beings made in the image of God. Remember, the agony of our Lord was shared by two thieves. crucified beside him, that he might be numbered among the transgressors. And remember his words to one, Verily I say unto thee, Today shalt thou be with me in paradise. We will sing hymn 426. O God, our help in ages past. My first sermon, Dr. McKillop, and it was duck soup for me. You couldn't understand how such a thing could be done without faith. Well, you didn't know I'd been a lawyer. I've done a lot without faith, McKillop. It doesn't take such a holy man to care for your sheep. From the first day until now, I've been the ideal boss. Even the day I got that call from young Hubbard, yes. I played the part. Oh, I forgot. This is all news to you. You didn't know about that, about the conversation I had with young Hubbard.

in the study in the church. Dr. Pierce? Yes? I, uh, I missed your first service, son. Doctor, I thought I'd pay you a call. I'm glad you did. Sit down. Oh, thank you. Uh, my name's Hubbard. I work at the bank, First National. I'm a chief teller. Well, that's a very responsible job for a young man. Oh, I don't know. I suppose it is, but I don't have much more responsibility than the other fellas, except the end of the month, and it's a strain. The end of the month? Oh, sure. Well, that's when I, uh... Well, you... You know, I've never told anyone about this. Well, it's confidential. Oh, naturally, not so far as you're concerned, Dr. Pierce. You see, the 30th of the month, we move all our deposits to the Federal Reserve Bank. $50,000 a month. Well, you can see I wouldn't want some people to know that. You mean you take the deposits alone? Oh, no, that'd be even worse than it is. There's an armored truck that comes to take the money. It comes by around 9.30 at night. But I'm alone in the bank until it gets there.

Sometimes when I'm sitting there at my desk, I think how easy it would be. All someone would have to do is shoot me through the glass door. See what I mean? Faith McCullough. God never sendeth mouth, but he sendeth me. Out of all this community's 35,000 souls, Puppet chose me to share his secrets. I sent a letter that night to Mac, care of Tony's in Chicago.

Two months to wait. Two months until the death of young Hubbard. Two months until I had $50,000 and a clear getaway. Two months until tonight. Two pleasant months to play a saintly part, warmed by adulation, warmed by love. Because even you could see what was happening to your daughter, your very beautiful daughter, Lucy. Do you ever think of anything besides your work? I don't know, Lucy. What sort of thing? Well, do you ever think of yourself, of a full life for yourself? Why, of course. That's why I work. My work gives me a full life. You don't know what I mean. Yes, I think I do. You see, I have to tell you, even if you don't want to hear. Lucy, my dear. I have to tell you that I love you, Howard. I know I can't expect that to mean much to you. It means a great deal. Not enough. Lucy, dear, you told me once that you were engaged to someone. Yes, I...

I'm supposed to be. Oh, Tom's all right, but he's little and unimportant and afraid. He's afraid to dare anything or do anything. He's meek. Ah, the meek shall inherit the earth. You don't believe that, Howard Pierce. Even if you are a parson, you don't believe it. What do I believe, Lucy? I don't know exactly. But when I first saw you, I knew that you were like me. You have boldness and strength. You... You have an inward feeling about life. I let it ride. Wasn't any harm in that, Doctor, so far as I could see. Lucy was a great help, blinded by what she called love. And what did I feel? Love? Doctor, a man who has mastered the use of words as I have no longer knows what they mean, but only what they do. With Lucy, so long as the word love so served me, I used it. After a while, it became a source of danger.

That was last week, Wednesday, when I came to the evening to read to you. Howard. Howard, the most wonderful news guest. How can I guess? Don't you know? The most wonderful thing that could ever happen to me. No, no. What's that, Lucy? Well, I never breathed a word to Father about us because you asked me not to, Howard. Not until he can talk to us and give his blessing. Lucy, you didn't. Oh, no, not yet. But the doctor was here today, and he told me Father will speak again soon, any day now. No, no. He doesn't know why he hasn't already. Isn't that wonderful? Yes, yes, it is. Howard, what's the matter? Nothing's the matter. Well, but there is. I can see... Well, sit down, Lucy. I was going to tell you before, my dear. You see, well, I can't marry you, not ever. You can't... Please, you mustn't ask me why. It doesn't matter why. Do you understand? Because you don't love me. If you have to believe that, all right. Only you must go on and live your life as though you've never met me.

As though I'd never met you. Do you know what that means? It means I'll marry Tom. It means I'll have a little, quiet, secure life. Best life for you, Lucy. Tom. Tom in place of you. Well, maybe you're right. I won't ever have great happiness with him, but after this, I'll never have a greater unhappiness. Mustn't be better, Lucy. If you hadn't known me, you would have married your Tom, and yes, you would have loved him. All right. I will marry him. I'll marry him this week in church. And you'll perform the service, Howard. You'll be the one to make me Mrs. Tom Hubbard. Who did you say? Tom Hubbard. I'll be a banker's wife. I never knew his name before. Well, no matter what you think, Lucy, I'm sure you'll be happy. Don't ask me why I didn't kill you, Dr. McKillop, when I heard that you might speak now at any time.

I can still smother you with a pillow and no one would ever know. I suppose killing will always be distasteful to me, a job for cruder minds. It isn't because of any moral scruples, believe me. And don't you believe, Doctor, that ethics had any part in what I did about Lucy either. Not for one minute. It's just that I... It's just that I wanted my hands free this last week. It was just that I believe in leaving a place tidy, no loose ends. If it happens that my neat habits turn in a good deed now and then, that doesn't make me a boy scout. After all, if I were a higher being like you, I might be upset by thinking of things like, uh, no, like, uh, killing Lucy's husband tonight, Tom Hubbard, as he sits at his desk at the bank. Here it is, the 30th, and I've got a very important date in half an hour.

Well, Doctor, did it interest you? Now that you know the real Philip Gentry, do you understand? I doubt it. I doubt if you, with your good book and your hymnal, your years of tending the good sheep in the rich green pastures here, could ever understand one-tenth of what a man like me feels and is. But it doesn't matter. I don't need your understanding. Good night, Doctor. Sleep well. Good night, Doctor Pierce. Will you drop in tomorrow? Oh, tomorrow? Well, we'll see about tomorrow. We'll see. Who are you? It's Dr. Pierce, Tom. Let me in. Just a minute. I wanted to make sure. You see, this is the night when the truck is... Yes, I remembered. That's how I knew where to find you. Did you want something? Lucy's feeling sick. I came to send you home. Lucy?

Oh, but I can't. I have to stay. I can stay for you. Gee, I don't know. I'm supposed to stay. But Lucy is calling for you, Tom. She's really sick? Well, all right. I guess with you here, it'll be all right. Just tell me what to do. Well, that's the money already in those sacks. Yes. And I sit here? Yes, right at this desk. Gee, I don't know what the directors will think. Now, run along, Tom. They'll never know. Even if... Someone walks by from the outside, they'll never know if it's you or me sitting here. That got him right to the head. He ought to have the money ready somewhere near him. Mac. What? Who's there? Mac. Come here, Mac. Gentry. Gentry, Mac. What's up, screwy? You said in your letter that... I know. I didn't have a chance to tell you.

The plans are changed, Mac. Gentry. Honest. Honest, Gentry. I didn't mean to shoot... I know, I know. You'd better go. I'm dying, Mac. No. No, I ain't gonna leave you here. What do you think I am? Yes, you are. They won't get me, Mac. Huh? The plan is all changed. Okay, okay. That don't matter. The money is... Remember. Remember me when thou comest. What are you talking about? That's from the Bible, Mac. You wouldn't know it, I guess. It's from the Bible. This, dear friends, was the man Philip Gentry, or Dr. Pierce, or what other name he may choose in eternity. The man whom we bury today. That night when he stood above my bed, pouring defiance and bitterness into my ears, thinking that I was paralyzed.

I could both speak and write. My paralysis had been gone for many days, but I did not speak, because I knew what Philip Gentry would do, what he had to do. I knew what he denied, that to accomplish work as he had in God's vineyard, a man must have faith, even though he denied that faith. That is why, in spite of all, he protected my daughter's happiness. That is why he could not kill me, for the work he did here had molded him, in spite of himself, into a man who was truly a servant of God. To such a man our Lord would say, Verily I say unto you, Today shalt thou be with me in paradise. Joseph Cotton, a star of beyond good and evil.

Tonight's study in offense. This is the Armed Forces Radio Service.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑