Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Suspense artwork

From the Suspense collection

The Diary of Sophronia Winters

Episode 763August 10, 195824 min 1 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 14 min to read

Suspense. And the producer of radio's outstanding theater of thrills, the master of mystery and adventure, William N. Robeson. One of the axioms of drama might be summed up in the words, don't cheat the audience. Yet one of the most famous short stories of the century, The Lady of the Tiger, does just that. We are not about to bring you that famous masterpiece, but the story we are going to tell, in addition to being well calculated to keep you in suspense, is also guaranteed to start a lot of arguments, none of which we hope will become too serious. Frankly, we don't know whether Sophronia Winters or Hiram Johnson is telling the truth, and whether one or both of them are crazy. But there's one point at which we can all agree. Sophronia's diary makes mighty thrilling reading. Listen. Listen then, as Miss Mercedes for Cambridge stars in the new Sophronia Winters. Just a moment. Another visit with Joe and Daphne Forsythe.

Hey, honey, I'm Lee. Oh, what's the matter, honey? Don't you speak to me, you... you Don Juan. Don Juan? Kathy, I'm no Don Juan. No Habla Español. Very funny. Ha, ha, ha. Well, it was no prize winner, but... Neither are you, you... you lethario. I've often wondered, what's a lethario? I don't know, but that's what the wives on TV always call their husbands. I guess it applies. You want me to go out and come in again? As far as I'm concerned, you can go for a long walk, preferably on a short pier. Well. Oh, come on, Daphne. What's wrong? Your good friend Harry called, and he spilled the beans. Which beans? He said, quote, Tell Joe he was right about those blondes. They're great. Unquote. Blondes? That's what he said. Well? He didn't say blondes. He said bonds. Savings bonds.

I am on the payroll savings plan. And I told Harry he ought to do it, too. Savings bonds have a guaranteed interest that pays back $4 for every three, which is a pretty good investment. That's a pretty good story, too. It's true, so help me. That's why Harry's so happy. Savings bonds are great. Well, maybe you're right. You wouldn't really fool around with blondes, would you? You're too faithful and sweet. Kind and fast-talking. Mercedes McCambridge. February 1st, St. Petersburg, Florida. I, Sophronia Winters, have hereby begun this diary because on this date I feel for the first time in my 60 years that I have begun to live. It happened this morning. I had just...

settled myself on the beach when I noticed a man, a thrilling-looking man, strolling toward me. Sitting out here all by your lonesome? Oh, yes. Yes, I am. Didn't I see you last night over at the starfish tea room? The starfish tea room? Oh, yes, yes. I was there yesterday. I said you might go to the table over there. Mind if I sit down beside you? Not at all. Oh, just a minute. Sit on this magazine. This sand sticks to your clothes. Oh, sand, don't bother me. Johnson's name, Hiram Johnson, comes from Green Harbour, Maine. We're in a big hotel up there, some of us. That's my whole history in a nutshell. My name is Sophronia. Sophronia Winters. Sophronia? Mm-hmm. What a coincidence. My sister-in-law's name is Sophronia. Sophronia Johnson. You ever heard of her? She looked quite a bit like you.

Sepronia Johnson? No, I'm afraid I haven't. Who was she? Someone very famous? I'm so ignorant about these things. No, Sepronia wasn't very famous up in the state of Maine for a while, some time back. Well, look where that sun climbed to. I'd say it was close to lunchtime, and I'm going on a hunger strike unless you have lunch with me. Dear, dear diary, Now I know what they mean by the young in heart. There is indeed a boy for every girl in the world, and I have found mine. He is so kind and so generous and so strong, and I am so weak because I want to be. Oh, what's the good of waiting, Sophronia? I've got to be back at the hotel in a week. We may never see each other again. Oh, Hiram, don't say that.

I couldn't bear it. Then let's do it right away. Tomorrow. There's a passing out on Coral Avenue will do the job for us. We can take a nice moonlight drive out the alligator farm afterwards and have a nice shore dinner. Then climb on board the Orange Blossom tomorrow night for Maine. Oh, but what would your family think? Wouldn't they be shocked? Family's all dead. I'm my own boss. I'll just be the two of us alone together. The two of us alone. Together. The two of us alone. Together. But dear diary, not exactly as I had imagined it. Our wedding trip north on the Orange Blossom Express was all that I could have dreamed of. But now, now we are at the end of the journey. Looming in front of us in the deepening winter twilight is a huge resort hotel. Hiram's Hotel.

Its wide veranda empty. Its ancient cupolas menacing against the gray sky. And not a single light burning at any of its hundreds of windows. What are you locking the gate for, Hiram? Why not? Nobody coming in after us or going out again for a while. But I thought you said the hotel. The hotel is empty. Hiram. Well, what is it now? Hiram, darling. I know it sounds silly, but let's not go in there tonight. It's so dark and empty. Let's wait until morning. Let's stay in the village just for tonight. We'll stay in here. Now, get inside. Oh, my arm. You remember me telling you down in Florida about my sister-in-law, Sophronia? Yes. Well, that's her. That painting there on the wall. Now, you take a look at her. Good look.

But why? She was a murderess. She was hanged in Portland 25 years ago for the murder of my brother, Ephraim. Here in the lobby of this hotel. They come downstairs singing a hymn and murdered him in cold blood with an axe. That fire axe hanging over there on the wall. How horrible. Yeah. Now you stand over there under that painting. Hiram, I... Get over there. Hiram, please, you're hurting me. You stand there quietly. I remember I said you resembled my dead sister-in-law. Well, you do. You are a spitting image. Can an act of military heroism be acknowledged? In one example, the form is a rectangular blue ribbon set in a gold-colored metal frame of laurel leaves, worn centered over the right breast pocket of the uniform. A bronze oak leaf cluster may be affixed to the ribbon for each subsequent award of the same decoration.

This is the emblem of the Distinguished Unit Citation, awarded to units of our armed forces and those of our allies for extraordinary heroism in action against an armed enemy. One of America's newer military decorations, it is designated to recognize activity on or after December 7, 1941. The Distinguished Unit Campaign Streamer is blue. with the name of the cited action embroidered in white. To be eligible for this citation, the degree of heroism required is the same as that which, in an individual, would warrant the presentation of our second highest award for valor, the Distinguished Service Cross. The Distinguished Unit emblem may be worn permanently by all those involved in the cited action, but for those individuals joining the unit later, The emblem may be worn only for the duration of their assignment. Both as individuals and as members of military units, America's servicemen have proved themselves worthy of medals and worthy of admiration by their countrymen. And now, starring Mercedes McCamber, Act Two. I cannot understand it, and my heart is heavy. The hotel is deserted, unchanged.

and apparently uninhabited for 25 years, wash bowls and pitchers still stand in the empty rooms covered with cobwebs. The great dining room with its oak woodwork is alive with rats, and a row of broken rocking chairs on the front porch faces emptily out to sea. Does he mean this to be my home? And now, Medea, let me show you the grounds. Oh, but it's dark. I want to show you where my sister-in-law Sophronia is buried. But can't I see it tomorrow in the daylight? You'll see it now, Sophronia. Hiram, you're hurting me. I'm sorry, my dear, but you must learn to do what I say. And then we shall have no trouble. Just yonder on that mound is where my sister-in-law Sophronia was laid away 25 years ago. There are cells without a service out here by herself on the grounds. Ethan's buried in town.

But not Sopronia. I had a feeling I'd have to keep an eye on her. Keep an eye on her? I knew she was one of those restless sleepers who wouldn't stay quiet in a grave. You mean you think she haunts this place? Nope. Not this place. She never had any use for it. Alive or dead. No, she makes for the warmer climates. She was always a cold-blooded little woman, freezing and shivering all the time. Places like California and Texas and Florida she makes fun. Florida. Yeah, one of her favorite haunts. Only around St. Petersburg. She likes the flowers and the sun and the romance. Hiram, I feel cold. I'm shivering. Do you mind if I go inside now? In a minute. I haven't explained everything. You see those birches over there? Under every one of them is a grave. See, I found her wandering the earth in disguise three times. I killed her three times. Still don't do any good. She's still restless. You mean you...

Killed three different women. Now I keep another grave open. Reminder, waiting now. Would you like to see it, Sophronia? Oh, no. Oh, Hiram, no, please. You afraid to see it, Sophronia? No, I... Oh, Hiram, you don't think just because my name happens to be Sophronia and that I look a little like... Think what, Sophronia? Nothing. Well, you come back along in the hotel. I'll show you to your room. My? Your room.

cleanest in the hotel. Always expected to be occupied again sometime. Kept everything just as it was. What's the matter? Nothing. It's just that... Seem kind of familiar? No. No. Just as she left at that afternoon, she walked downstairs to murder my brother. See her embroidery on the table, needle sticking in it? Her hymn book still open? She's very fond of singing hymns, if only you was. Had a nice voice, too. I used to accompany her on the harmonium down the parlor. Oh. Well, I'll turn down the bed for you. And you can get undressed while I go make you some hot tea. No, I don't want any. Now, there's the closet. You can put on one of Sophronia's dressing gowns, make yourself at home. Hiram, why are you locking my door? Safer, my dear. Safer? Always lock door, outside and inside. Windows, too. Safer for everybody.

It must be nearly midnight now. I don't know. I don't know how long it's been since he locked that door on me and left me alone in this horrible room with its hideous little mementos of a dead murderess. I have lit the pink-flowered oil lamp and I am sitting here at her little wicker table trying to maintain my sanity as I write this. I can hear him downstairs, in the shabby little parlor off the lobby, playing the harmonium, playing the same piece over and over again. My hand has just brushed against her needlework, lying beside the open hymn book, open as the same hymn he is playing, the same hymn he is playing. I shall go mad!

I shall go back. Ample capacity in freedom to defend freedom. This is NATO, the North Atlantic Treaty Organization. Month after month, since April 4th, 1949, the activities of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization have moved steadily forward on many fronts. This complete cooperation must and will continue because the concept of national self-sufficiency is out of date. Countries of the free world are interdependent. And only in genuine partnership, and by combining their resources, sharing tasks in many fields, can progress and safety be found. The United States of America is a part of NATO. You should be aware of, and alert to, the objectives and programs of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization. And now... February 12th. Can it be only a week since I became the bride of a madman?

Now I live only from moment to moment, listening to each creak on the stairs, each note as it slowly wheezes from the old harmonium, wondering when he will come for me, when he will drag me out to join those other Sophronius in their frosty graves beneath the naked birches. It's come. Sophronius, come downstairs. I want you to sing with me. Sing. Seeing she sang with him, he said, How can I come downstairs when my door is locked? It's unlocked. You try it. Unlocked? Oh, no, how could it? Oh, it is. It is. And I never knew it. I never knew it. How many times have you thrown it out? He unlocked it sometime while I was still sitting there. Oh, why didn't I try a few more times? Why did I just sit there assuming? No. No, he'd have caught me anyway.

he'd have known. But I might have got away. Now it's too late. He's going to kill me. Sopronia! Hiram, I'm coming. Where are you? At the harmonium. I'm waiting to sing with you. All right. I'll sing. I haven't sung in years, but I'll try. I'll sing with you. I'll stay out here in the hall. My voice will carry better. Always did carry better in the hall, didn't it, Sopronia? Of course, you know. and back door of the loft. Yes, I know, Harvey. Lord, will me abide. There's only one more page. So, shall I read it to you, nurse? Yes, go ahead. March 22nd. I have been sick for a very long time. The pages of my diary are blank. But I shall take you out again, poor diary, today.

and start you over again. I shall never look back at the other pages. I shall only write on and on about this beautiful place, so that no one reading this diary will ever know. That door, the stairs, and heard the music, and I saw the fire axe still hanging on the wall. I sang the hymn into that room where he was playing. If a reflection of that axe had so much as glimmered across the wood, it even turned. But I was clever. So much cleverer than he. I kept on singing. And now I'm free. Free as a bird. I'm free. And he shall never catch me now. Not this time. Or ever again. Because he's dead. Isn't he, Mary? Mary? Isn't my dear brother-in-law, Hiram?

Really dead? Yes, Mr. Cronier, he's dead. And now we'll put the diary away, shall we? Remember what the doctor said. We mustn't overdo if we're to get well. Oh, but I don't want to get well. Ever. I like being sick. I feel so... Charles Swenson. And again next week, we return with Miss Kathy Lewis starring in...

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑