Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Suspense artwork

From the Suspense collection

Stand-In for Murder

Episode 928June 3, 196222 min 38 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 12 min to read

And now, a tale well-calculated to keep you in. Tonight, a well-honed accounting of a lethal impersonation. In just a moment, Stand In For Murder, written especially for suspense by Gladys Gallant. Kay, answer it. Jim, I'm cold, I'm afraid. My voice, it isn't her voice. Will you answer it? Please, Kay, you've got to prove that Laura Morgan is still alive. Oh, it stopped. Oh, thank God. Jim, this is agony. When that phone rings, I freeze. I can't talk. Hey, listen to me. Laura's friends have to think she's leaving for Europe, and they have to hear it from her. Her voice, I can't remember how it's supposed to sound. Don't you want... Play the tape again. That last show she did. Play the tape again. No, Laura. No. Will you please? Laura Morgan paid particular attention to how she... Please be quiet so we can listen. ...will dismay but determine. These were the fatal words.

I remember thinking this must be a kind of dream, a terrible nightmare. And when I awoke, everything would be just as it was before Jim asked me for a divorce. I would never agree. I knew there was somebody else, but I just kept hoping that someday he would come back to me. One night... Jim. I've got to talk to you, Kay. The answer is still no. It's not about the divorce. Oh, really? I suppose you just dropped in for a drink, is that it? Well, that's very nice. It's like old times. Look, never mind about all that now. Please, really, I insist. Oh, is it still on the rock? Kay, please. Just like us, Jim, huh? On the rock.

I said never mind. Morgan, isn't that right? You know, I heard we looked so much alike. I could give you a detailed description. You know, people and talk and all that jazz. Okay, let up, will you? Laura Morgan, tall, blonde, sometime actress, but full-time girlfriend. What's this, your night out? Kate, stop it. I know just what you meant. Last night we came back to you. She became hysterical, went off. Well, what are you going to do? Did you... Did you call the police? Call the police? Kay, if I called the police, I wouldn't have a chance. Jimmy, they will find her. They'll know it was you. No, no, no. They'll never find her. Now, you see, I... Down the stairs and into the car. No one saw me. And then near the bridge... Now, stop, please. For God's sake, I don't want to know anymore. Sorry for this mess. Sorry I left you. Sorry for everything. Kay, I still love you.

Jimmy, Jimmy, Jimmy. What chance have we got now? There is one chance. Depends on you, Kay. On me? Yes. Help me set up an alibi. An alibi? Twelve hours later in a two-room apartment on a quiet street in the West Sixties, I became Laura Morgan. As Jim planned it, it would be for only a few days, just long enough to establish her existence. But those few days were a lifetime of terror. the constant ringing of the phone right from the start. And the trouble I had imitating her voice. Acting wasn't my line at all. And Jim, playing that tape recorder so I could hear Laura's voice again and again. Okay, you're just not getting it. Now please pay attention, huh? Right. All right, now we've got to get it right. Will you be quiet? All right, all right, just listen. With the fateful words they exchanged.

What about Marion? What about her? The party. The party. Live hall. It was just beginning. Ending. You hear that? The phone is driving me crazy. All right, answer it or I'll take the tape. No, no, let it ring. Don't be a fool, Kay. Answer it. Hello? Yes. What is it? A reporter from the Globe. He wanted to ask me... About the murder Wednesday night. Wednesday night? Jim, please. Let it rain. Let it rain. No, no. No, wait. Pick it up. Jim, I can't. Go on. Pick it up. Now say you're Laura Morgan and let him do the talking. Hello? Yes, this is Laura Morgan. We were disconnected. Well, I didn't see anything. Who was killed? Somebody was killed, but he doesn't know about Laura Morgan. Somehow I carried it off.

Somehow I went on to establish the fact that Laura Morgan was still alive. The next day... The Jiffy cleaning service, Miss Morgan. Ah, yes. What can I do for you? About that powder blue wool suit you sent back to us. Men worked on it to get that spot out that you complained about, Miss Morgan. Oh, the spot. Yes. Did you get it out? Miss Morgan, if you go out of your way to look for it, there's still the faintest remains. Frankly, any more solvents and you'd wind up with a hole instead of a stain. But if you don't know it's there... we can do. I'm sure it'll be good enough, Miss... You mean it'll be okay? The other day, he nearly took my head off that it didn't come out right. Even when I explained, it's just some things that you just don't... Yes, well, just send it right back today, please. Oh, yeah, sure. Right away. Within the hour. That afternoon, wearing Laura's powder blue suit, I left the apartment. My heart skipped a beat when I saw the doorman looking my way. I hurried past him. My face turned away. Afternoon, Miss Walker. What a lovely day it is. That's nice.

Jim's plans seemed to be working. To kill time, I went to a movie and then decided to walk home. It was a relief to be caught up in the anonymity of New York with its crush of people at 6 o'clock. I was just turning west on 64th Street when... A block of concrete, a cornice or something, fell right from the top of that brownstone. If you're by an inch, you better call the police. No, no. Please, I'm fine, really. You ought to file a complaint, lady. You could have been killed. No, I have to hurry. I'm very late. I have an appointment. Hey, lady. Well, you never can... figure a dame. Here she's almost killed and she has to hurry because she's late for her hair appointment. Yes, this is Laura Morgan. Who is it? Concrete block. What about it? No accident. Who is this? What do you want? Who are you? I stood there trembling in the darkness of the room. The crash of concrete on the pavement, the ominous threatening voice on the telephone still ringing in my ears. Oh, I wanted to scream out, Laura Morgan is dead.

But I had to protect Jim's alibi. I tried not to panic. I asked myself, if I were Laura Morgan, what would I do? I would call the police and tell them someone was threatening to kill me. Why not? Jim would still be safe. He needed a live alibi, not a dead one. I reached for the phone. Operator, get me the police department and hurry things. Police department, this is Laura Morgan. Hang up the phone, lady. Hear what I said on the phone, Miss Morgan? One word about the murder, you're dead. Who are you? What do you want? I'm not Laura Morgan. You're making a very big mistake. She's dead. I tell you, she's dead. What are you trying to pull? You're Laura Morgan, all right? You just sold her to the police. Oh, too much. The window. He won't get far. We have a squad car downstairs. Take it easy. Take it easy. That's it. All right. All right. Look, I'm from Homicide. Lieutenant Kelly.

We've been watching this building all day. You witnessed the gang killing at Clint Toback Wednesday night. Were they a racketeer? Yeah, your late neighbor. He was shot right in this lobby. The doorman said you were coming in when it happened. Well, were you? That must have been just before it happened. Tell me, did you get a good look at the killer's face? Sorry, I really can't remember. There were several people past me in the lobby. You know what? I really didn't notice. He noticed you, all right. Where did you disappear to Wednesday night? We've been looking for you for two days, Miss Morgan. I know. It seems a lot of people were looking for me. Police and newspapers. A killer. I'm getting out of here. It's safer to stay put until we apprehend that killer, Miss Morgan. Stay here and take another chance at my life? Oh, no. Don't leave this apartment, Miss Morgan. If you do, you'll wind up as dead as your late hood neighbor, Clint Toback.

It's me, Jim. Oh, Jim. I got here as soon as I could. What happened, Kay? I couldn't make out what you were saying on the phone. My God, you look awful. Someone... Someone tried to kill me. What? Who? I don't understand. Laurel Morgan witnessed a murder right here in this lobby Wednesday night. Did she say anything to you about it? We... We had other things to talk about. The killer is after her, even if she didn't see his face. If he thinks she can identify him... But you didn't know. All right, all right. You've got to get out of here, Kay. Now, you start packing. I'll try to get you on a plane tomorrow night. Now, wait a minute. The police said I can't go anywhere until they catch the killer. Police? They said I'd be safer here. They're watching this building. Police? Kay, are you out of your mind and you get me over here? Jim, I had to. Don't you see? You've got to tell them the truth. Now you've got to tell them Laura Morgan is dead. Tell them.

I ruined my life, our life, Kate. Jim, what is the matter with you? You didn't commit murder. It was an accident. The police will understand that. Oh, sure, sure. I'm sure they'll be very understanding. Jim, don't you see? If you tell the police, it will be in the papers, on the news broadcast. Don't you understand? Then nobody will try to kill Laura Morgan if she's already dead. Oh, I see one thing. I've got to get out of here and fast. Police, Miss Morgan. Remember your Laura, Morgan. As long as they believe that, we can get away.

A reporter man was seen coming up here. Oh, yes, yes. That was just a friend, Lieutenant. Oh, please, won't you come in? Yeah, thanks. This is Mr. Benson, Lieutenant. Benson? Uh, Jim Benson. Uh, Miss, uh, Morgan tells me she's been having some trouble, Lieutenant. Yeah, quite a bit of trouble, Mr. Benson. Miss Morgan, uh, I'm afraid I have to tell you there's more trouble. What do you mean? Well, it seems to be, uh, seems to be some question about, uh, your identity. Did you say my... Identity? Yeah, the doorman of this building. Come in, Brady. We can settle this right now. This is ridiculous, Lieutenant. This is an invasion of privacy. At the moment, Miss Morgan's life is hardly private. What do you say, Brady? Is this Laura Morgan? No. No, that's not Laura Morgan. Are you positive? When you put me back on the door today, sir, I knew she wasn't Miss Morgan. She wore the same suit. And she even looks like her.

But that walk, the way she kept her face turned away, they made me think certain. This lady here isn't Laura Morgan. What do you mean I'm not Laura Morgan? Never heard of her. Okay, okay. All right, who are you, miss? Why are you impersonating Laura Morgan? Don't say a thing, Laura. I'm calling my attorney. And who are you, Mr. Benson? Did you set this woman up as a decoy so you could kill the real Laura Morgan? We haven't found her yet, but the police are dragging the river. All right, just stay where you are, all of you. I'll answer it. Lieutenant Kelly? Speaking. Yes, Captain. Come on in, Captain. Well, this is the lady who says she's Laura Morgan, Captain. That's very interesting. I'm Jim Benson. What are you doing here before I call my attorney? Introduce Laura Morgan, the real Laura. And Jim, you said she was dead. Laura, are you all right, Laura? Yes, darling. But Jim, my timing was off as usual.

I guess I was at the wrong place at the wrong hour. I did just what you said Wednesday night, but they managed to find me. Jim, you knew she was alive. You knew somebody wanted to kill her, and you made me take her place. And you botched it. Just as you botched your marriage, Kay Benson. Jim, you said you killed her. You said you wanted me. You said you wanted me. Never mind what I said, Kay. That's a farce. How exactly, Walter Benson? God, you wanted me to be killed.

I pleaded with you for a divorce, Kay. And when she wouldn't give it to you, you set your wife up as a Tarn's killer. Stand in for murder. Starring Terry Keene and Larry Haynes. And written especially for suspense by Gladys F. Gellar. Produced and directed by Fred Hendrickson. Music supervision by Ethel Huber. Heard in tonight's story were Claire Neaton, Ivor Francis, Bob Reddick, Tony Darnay, Bill Lipton, Jack Grimes, and Joseph Julian. Listen again next week when we return with Formula for Death, written by Jonathan Bundy. Another tale well calculated to keep you in...

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑