Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
The Fat Man artwork

From the The Fat Man collection

Fatman Murder Shows an Unfamiliar Face

Episode26 min 18 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 22 min to read

Miller shows an unfamiliar face. This one began on the state highway just about ten miles out of town. I was coming home late one night from a boat club banquet. When being alone, I had the old party up to about fifty. It was plenty dark that night. As I came around the curve, my headlights picked out a woman standing right in the middle of the road. She was waving her arms, trying to flag somebody down. So I slowed up and pulled over to the side of the pavement. Right away, I could see that she was kind of cute.

Waving at me, sister? Yes. Oh, yes, I was. Thanks so much for stopping. What's the trouble? Nothing. I just wondered if I could hitch a ride. Sure, get in. Which way are you headed? Your way, back to town. Fine. Your boyfriend leave you stranded? No, I didn't have a date. I thought maybe you were walking home from a buggy ride. Oh, no, no, it wasn't anything like that. What was it? Nothing. I just missed the last bus back to town. A girl like you to be out, isn't it? Especially on a dark road. Yes, I know. That's why I was so glad when you came along. How did you know it was going to be me? It's a risky business riding with strangers. Well, I haven't any choice. I couldn't stay there all night. Oh, don't worry, kid. You're safe with me. I'm a professional chaperone. What? Private detective. Oh, for a hotel? No, for Brad Runyon. Brad Runyon? Yeah, that's me. Oh.

What are you doing out here so late at night, baby? Oh, well, I... Look, are you really a private detective, Mr. Rooney? Sure, why? Because... Well, you might be able to help me find him. Who? My father. Where's he gone? I don't know. I... I don't know. Hey, hey, hey. Wait a minute with that. There's a law against crying in this town. But I... I was so mean to him. Okay, you were mean. What did you do? I just never went anywhere with him. Never let him meet any of my friends. Not even the boy I was going to marry. Why not? What's the matter with the old guy? He's sick. Mentally, I mean. His mind sort of wanders off and he can't remember things. So you don't want him to clear your romance, huh? That's right. Has he ever walked out on you before? Oh, just once when my mother died. He lost his head and disappeared for two days. Well, that's why I'm out here tonight. I thought he might have been...

He might have been in their grave. Was he? No. Well, dry your tears, kid. I'll call up somebody at the Bureau of Missing Persons first thing tomorrow morning. They'll help you find him. Who want you? Look, honey, I'm a pro. I've got to take cases that pay off. Well, I'll pay. Not my kind of though. I need plenty to feed this starving carcass. Don't you see how thin I am? I'll give you anything you want. No, kid. Nothing doing.

Oh, yeah. Who? For heaven's sake, where have you been all my life? I thought you were going to call me up sometime. I'm calling you now. Well, this is a fine time, you big stiff. Don't you know it's two o'clock in the morning? Yeah. All right. Tell me what's about. I want you to do me a turn, beautiful. Uh-uh. I did one for you once, remember? But I'm in bed. All right. I'm coming over with a sweet little girl. What? Her name's Dorothy, and I want you to look after her for a while, she said. What's the matter? Her father's missing, Kathy. Been missing for almost two weeks. Oh, I'm sorry. Yeah, so am I. That's why I'm taking the case. Let me drop her off at your place. Sure, bring her over. Thanks, honey. Do you think you can find her, Father? Well, I'm going to try. Where are you going? To the morgue.

and I know it isn't exactly quicker to ask you a lot of questions. Okay, okay, get to the point. Well, I'm looking for a man about 60 years old, gray hair, blue eyes, and not a mark of identification on him. Uh-huh. You got anybody like that? Have you any idea when he might have been brought in? I'm not sure he was brought in, but it might have been any time in the last two weeks. Gray hair, blue eyes, about 60. That's it. Wait a minute. You say he had no mark of identification on him. Nothing in his clothes? Not a thing. He wasn't even wearing a ring. I know the man you mean. He fell or jumped off the viaduct over Kearney Street. I don't know what he did. Is he here? That's what I'm asking you. Well, he was here, but he's not here anymore. What do you mean? The body was claimed. By whom? His wife's dead and his daughter's the only living relative. Wait a minute. I'll look it up in the file.

Hurry it up, will you? Oh, take it easy, Runyon. For a lousy cigar, you want an awful lot of service. Come on, come on. Okay, here's the guy you're looking for. The body was brought in Friday night and claimed yesterday morning. By whom? Mrs. Robert Hubbard, 610 Thornton Street. Mrs. Robert Hubbard, who's she? I don't know, but according to the statement she made, she was his wife. Yes? Good morning, Mrs. Hubbard. Yes? What is it? Don't be alarmed, Mrs. Hubbard. I really shouldn't have called this early in the morning, but I did want to speak to you. Are you having breakfast? Why, no. What did you want to speak to me about? Your husband. Oh. May I come in? Yes. Yes, come in. Thank you. Were you a business acquaintance of Mr. Hubbard? No, my name is Runyon.

I'm a private investigator. What? Oh, it's nothing to get excited about. I just wanted to ask you a few questions about... What seems to be the trouble, Alice? Oh, it's nothing, Gordon. What do you mean, it's nothing? Who is this man? A private investigator. Investigator? What do you want? He wants to ask a few questions about Robert. Well, this is a fine time to come here. Young man, do you realize it's only two days? Gordon, please. Let him go on, Mrs. Robert. Found it. Haven't you detectives any sense of decency? This poor woman has just lost her husband. And for two days now, you people have been cross-examining her like a common criminal. Gordon, Gordon, for heaven's sake. I don't care. I'm fed up with this nonsense. And I'm not going to put up with it any longer. Oh, now, now. That sort of attitude never got anywhere. You really must excuse my brother-in-law, Mr. Runyon. He suffered a great loss, too. You see.

Mr. Hubbard was his only brother. Well, in this case, I think he's right. I'll come back some other time, Mrs. Hubbard. Oh, no, no, you stay. I want you to. But... No, I want to know what questions you were going to ask me. Oh, just the usual things. How long were you and your husband married, Mrs. Hubbard? Twenty-six years. And you lived together all the time? Oh, yes. We were very much in love. He'd never been married before, had he? No, of course not. Well, just one more question, then. When you claimed his body yesterday, Mrs. Hubbard, you had it taken to a funeral parlor. Yes? Why? I thought I might stop in and see it, if you don't mind. Why? Well, I just want to find out how much he resembles a man I'm looking for. I'm afraid that's impossible. Impossible? For me to see the body? Yes.

Mr. Hubbard was cremated last night. Yeah, I'm still hanging on, Mac. Have you got any information for me? Yeah, some. The accountant profiled the one on the rocks about six months ago. In 1936, he worked for a bank, so he must have been bonded. That means there's a record of his fingerprints. Right. Can you get it, Mac? Can you get those fingerprints and match them with the ones down at the morgue? I've got to find out if that body they claimed was really Robert Hubbard. Okay, okay. I'll find out and call you back. Not at the office, Mac. I'll be over at Kathy's place. Kathy? Son of a gun. Business or pleasure? Business, Mac. My business. Hi, Kathy. Hi. Am I in time for breakfast or have you had it? Had it. It's my luck. I came over here on an empty stomach.

Oh, is that the way it looks when it's empty? Hey, hey, no cracks. Oh, sorry, I couldn't resist it. I'll get you some toast, Brad. Good. And while you're at it, throw a couple of eggs on it. Okay, this way to the kitchen. Thanks. Where's the kid? Dorothy? Yeah. Oh, she'll be back in a minute. She just went down to the corner with her fiancé. Fiancé? Yeah, she called him up this morning, and he came right over. He said he had something important to tell her. So you let her walk out with him? Shouldn't I have? How do I know? I told you to keep an eye on her, didn't I? But what? Nothing. I want that kid to stay put till I work this thing out. Well, don't yell at me, sweetheart. I'm not yelling. I'm just a little steamed up about this case. And if I don't hang on to that girl, I won't have anything. Oh, don't worry about... There she is now. I'll get it. Dorothy? Yes? Oh, I forgot you had company. Oh, this is my fiancée, Mr. Runyon. Call Weldon.

How do you do? How do you do? Any news about my father? Not yet, kid, unless you have some. Well, we do have a kind of clue. At least Carter. Yeah? Tell him about it, Carl. Yeah, tell me. Well, it's all kind of strange, Mr. Runyon. I've never met Dorothy's father, so I can't really be sure, but it must have been him or he wouldn't have spoken the way he did. Who? What are you talking about? Oh, this man. He stopped me on the street and said he was Dorothy's father. He seemed sort of vague about things, but he knew we were engaged and he wanted to wish me luck. Go on. Well, that's all there is to it. I spoke to him for a minute and then he was gone. Disappeared into the crowd. When was all this? Yesterday, about five o'clock in the afternoon. Yesterday? What's the matter, Brad? Is he wrong? I'll say there is. If that man was Dorothy's father, I've had the wrong slant on this case from the very beginning. What do you mean? It's too hard to explain.

I just took it for granted that somebody was trying to fool me. Who? A woman by the name of Hubbard. I thought she might have had something to do with your father's disappearance. But I'm all wet. The body she claimed at the morgue really was her husband's. What? Morgue? Oh, Mr. Runyon, don't you think my father's alive? I do not, kid. It was just a mistake on my part. If I hadn't been looking at the case from our side, I never would have made it. I'll get that caveat maybe for me. Hello? Oh, Brad, this is McKenzie. Yeah, Mac, I know. Know what? About the fingerprints. They match, don't they? No, they don't. You were right about that body at the morgue. It wasn't Mr. Hubbard. Why did you leave her in my apartment, Brad? Because that's the safest place for her. You think she's in danger? Could be. In a case as screwy as this, almost anything can happen. But it's my apartment. That's not a safe place. Why not?

Only three of us know she's there. You, me, and the boyfriend. Oh, and you trust all of us? I trust you and me. I'll find out about the boyfriend in a few minutes. How? By waiting here in my car. Get in. Well, what's this going to prove? Nothing, I hope. Honey, I told that kid the apartment was being watched. If he's up to something, he'll try to get her out of there. If he isn't, they'll stick. Huh. And what do we do while waiting for Rome to burn? Just sit here for a few minutes and make the small talk. If you get bored, I'll amuse you. How? You gotta get bored first. Oh, um... Come on, come here. Why, Brad, don't tell me you're gonna hold my hand. I will if you take off that glove. Oh, I'd take it off this room for two. With a poor like this? I like that poor. Why? For Pete's sake, Kathy, what do you see in me?

You? Baby, that's the nicest thing I ever heard in my life. I'm going to kiss you for that. Oh, Brad, no, not here. I can't wait till we get someplace else. Look out, baby, quick, get on. Good heavens, what happened? Somebody threw a stone at us. A stone? Yeah, with a note attached to it. Probably came from a passing car. What's on the note? Let me look. Here, Mr. Runyon, if you drop the case you're working on, there's $500, and that's for you. If you don't, there's a slab waiting for you at the morgue. Oh, Brad. Don't get excited, chick. I've had notes like this before. What are you going to do? What do you think? Take the 500. You're crazy, Runyon. Absolutely not. Now listen, Mac. I want to drop the case. The whole thing. I've got a yellow streak down my back. Who are you kidding? Nobody. I don't want to get bumped off any more than you do. I'm fat, but I'm not covered with armor. Come on, come on. What's the setup? You heard it. I'm scared. I want to drop the case. The last 24 hours.

Well, that's more like it. I've got to drop it so I can find out who wants me to and why. Now, if you keep quiet about those fingerprints for a while, I'll split the reward with you when we make the arrest. Reward? For what? I don't know yet. Pick your pick. Blasphemy, fraud, embezzlement, or murder. Kathy, what are you doing here? I asked you to wait for me in the car around the corner. Brad, listen, he's gone. He's left the apartment. Who? Dorothy's friend, Carl. How do you know? I just saw him in the street. What? He passed by right in front of the car, so I got out and followed him. Kathy, for Pete's sake, will you... It's all right. He didn't see me. Was he alone? Yeah. Where'd he go? Come on, I'll show you. Hurry up. There's something awfully screwy about all this. You said that once before. This time I mean it. I'm beginning to think that note we got wasn't on the level. What do you mean? Nobody's trying to buy me off this case. That $500 offer is just a stall. For what? Time. While I'm running down that note, the guy who wrote it is covering up his tracks.

His or hers? No, no, no. This way, Brad. He went through this alley and down those basement stairs. Okay. Hold it up a second. What's the matter? Want to unbutton my overcoat? Brad, what are you doing? Putting the gun on the outside. You stay here, baby. I'm going down those stairs. But, Brad, you can't... Do as I tell you. If I'm not out in two minutes, don't come after me. Yes, Mackenzie. All right, Brad. Don't look at me, kid. Get your watch out. I've got it.

Oh, that was a mean one. What happened, Dad? Who hit you? I don't know. Somebody let me have it over the skull and beat it in the dark. Here, let me see your head. It's all right. The hat took some of the sting out of it. Oh, can you get up? I don't know if I want to. Oh, Brad, you're ripped. Right there, mister. I'm deadly with a .45. What? Brad, it's Carl. Can't be. Mr. Runyon. Now, what are you doing here? Catching up with you, Carl. I think you owe me an apology for slugging me over the head. What are you talking about? Come on, come on. You had your chance when I came through this door. If you didn't want to kill me, what did you want to do? You must be mistaken, Mr. Runyon. I've been looking all over this basement for Dorothy's father. What are you giving me? I know it sounds crazy, but I was told I'd find him here. Who told you that? A woman on the telephone. She called up the apartment and told me to hurry over here. A woman?

Just a plain, ordinary woman. No, no, she mentioned a name. What is it? Mrs. Hubbard, I think. What? Mrs. Robert Hubbard. Shoot it. She and Gordon must know Dorothy's in that apartment. How did they find out? I don't know. One of them must have trailed me there. Then that phone call was a trick to get me here. You said it. Quick, we've got to get to a telephone. Hello? Oh, hello, Mr. Runyon. Are you all right, kid? Why, yes. Nobody took you to the apartment to get you out of it? No. You'd better bolt the door, kid, and keep away from the windows. Why? What's wrong? Never mind. Just stay where you are till we get there. Don't even answer the phone. But... Do what I tell you, Dorothy. I'm not afraid of murder. All right, Mr. Runyon. I'll stay here till you come. Goodbye. Well, now what do you want me to do, Mr. Hubbard? Put the receiver down. Look, you can't hold me at the point of that gun forever, Mr. Hubbard. They'll be here in 20 minutes. That's all the time I'll need.

Sit down, Dorothy. I want to talk to you. What about? Your father. Do you know where he is? Yes. He's dead, Dorothy. Oh, no. Yes. He fell off a viaduct about three days ago. How do you know? I saw his body at the morgue. No. Dorothy, you've got to listen to me. You've got to be brave about this because it means so much to Mrs. Hubbard. What are you talking about? She doesn't know about your father. She thinks the body we claimed at the morgue really was her husband. Your father and he resembled each other enough to fool us. But who would want to fool her? I would. I did, in fact. Why? Because I wanted to keep something from her. The fact that her husband was burned to death in a fire about a week ago. What? His charred body was found in the apartment of another woman. And I didn't want Mrs. Hubbard to know. So you claimed my father's body in his place. I didn't know he was your father, Dorothy. I didn't know who he was until I followed Mr. Runyon to his apartment and listened outside the door.

Oh, I see. You just went to the morgue and claimed an unidentified man. Well, I'd been looking for someone who might pass to Mr. Hubbard. When your father was brought in, I fooled Mrs. Hubbard into thinking it was her husband. You mean she still doesn't know? No, but she will if you continue this investigation. She'll know the whole story about Robert and this other woman. Won't you keep my secret? Mr. Runyon can't be bored off. It's all right, Mr. Hubbard. I'll make him drop the case. Not on your life, sweetie. I'm not dropping this case until I find out if that story he told you is true. But I believe him, Mr. Runyon. So do I. The part about your father, anyway. But the other part stinks to high heaven. Why? Because I got slugged on the head. What do you mean, Brad? Figure it out. You didn't do it, did you? Carl says he didn't. And Mr. Hubbard couldn't have because he was right here in this apartment when it happened. Then who did hit you? Mrs. Hubbard.

And if she's in on this deal, her brother-in-law's story doesn't stand up. Right here, Captain. Must you, Brad? What do you expect to find? A pot of gold, baby. How do you know Mrs. Hubbard has one? I don't. Brad, you'll get killed if anybody's awake in there. Can I go with you? No, just hold the light. I'll have a... Hard enough time getting in? I fell. I don't know why you can't let the police do this. I see what I came for. The album? Yeah. Right over here in the magazine, Mike. I'll be back. Just a second. Here. Flash the light on this, honey. What are you looking for? A picture of Gordon, Albert. If there is any such thing. Well, don't you think that is? Not if my hunch is... Duck, baby, duck. Somebody's coming. He shouldn't have done that. Why not? Somebody was at that window. I saw him.

Who is it with the fat man? So much the better. Turn on the lights. Gordon, it is the fat man. You killed him. Say what you are, Ellis. He's faking. Not faking, Mr. Herbert. Just giving my assistant a little more time to get to the police. What assistant? What are you talking about? You'll find out. So will you. Get up. What's the matter? Can't you kill me lying down? I'm not going to kill you. I'm just going to have you arrested for breaking into this house. I plead guilty. What's your plea, Mr. Hubbard? I don't believe I'm on trial. You will be when I find out how much insurance your brother carried. Oh, Gordon, please. Shut up. What's the matter, Mr. Hubbard? You're not the beneficiary, are you? No, I'm not. Then Mrs. Hubbard is. Naturally. What's wrong with that? Nothing. If her husband is really dead... Runyon, please. If you know what I told Dorothy, please don't repeat it. Not in front of Mrs. Hubbard. Please. The story I know, Mrs. Hubbard knows, too. You're her husband, Gordon. No. You must be. It's the only way you both can be honest.

You're trying to collect insurance on a man who never died. You're crazy. Am I? You needed money, Mr. Hubbard, badly. So you went to a plastic surgeon and had your face made over. The scars still show underneath your sideburns. Oh, Gordon. Thanks for the confirmation, Mrs. Hubbard, but I don't really need it. If he's the man he says he is, there ought to be a picture of him in this album I'm sitting on. Get up. Give me a lift. Get up or I'll kill you. Okay, Mr. Hubbard. He pulled my rug! Stop that gun or I'll shoot it out of your hand. Robert! Robert! What did you call him, Mrs. Hubbard? You called him by his right name, Robert. You can't prove it. Maybe I can't, Mr. Hubbard. But your fingerprints will. Well, Mac, what's the story? He's a man, all right. His fingerprints are the same as Robert Hubbard's. And that washes it up as far as I'm concerned. The police ought to be able to carry on from here. What about Dorothy's father? What do you mean?

Did they kill him or just claim his body at the morgue? Hey, you got something there. She has a bat. My little assistant is learning fast. Oh, am I your little assistant? You ran for the cops, didn't you? For all you knew, you were saving me from a death worse than fate. Now, that's gratitude for you. Now, wait a minute, you two. I want to know about this murder business. Now, Hubbard... Yeah? Cell phone, McKenzie. Okay. Now, don't go away, Ronnie, and I'll be right back. Well, Brad, what do you think? I think you're gorgeous, baby. Oh, no, no, no. I'm talking about the cape. You're too far away. I can't hear you. You're not listening. Do you blame me? You've got a figure that makes a guy stop and look but not listen. Oh, Brad, no. I can't hear you. You're not in a police station. Anyway. Copping and come in, Mac. You know how I feel about Kathy.

Well, I know you're not interested, but Hubbard didn't murder that girl's father. He just claimed the body of an unidentified man. How do you know? The kid just called me. Her father's still alive. What? Yeah. He'd been walking around in a daze for a while, and when it cleared up, he remembered who he was and went home. Oh, that's wonderful. Well, that's this business for you, Kathy. If he hadn't been lost, Mr. Hubbard would never have been found. Oh, here's the fat man.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑