The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 21 min to read
It isn't often that a woman shows up as an important figure in what we call organized crime. However, occasionally an exceptionally clever and attractive woman turns her abilities to crime on a big scale. And believe me, when that happens, the headaches of the police really begin. Especially when the crime involves murder. The printing on the frosted glass door said Oliver Winkler, Enterprise Incorporated. The card in my hand said, Oliver Winkler, appointment 11 a.m. I reached the door knob and then stopped suddenly. A tall, thin shadow had crossed the door somewhere inside, and an excited voice was speaking. I don't hear what you say, but you've got to be careful. I couldn't hear the voice, but it interrupted me. It finished whatever it had to say, and the first one continued. All right, all right, have it your way, but remember, I warned you. Don't ever say I didn't. And don't forget this, either.
It's going to be your funeral. The thin shadow suddenly filled the frosted glass and the door opened. Sorry. Who are you? What's the idea of hanging around here listening at keyholes? Take your hands off me, son. I said, what's the idea? Nobody's listening at the keyholes. I have an appointment with Mr. Winkler. I think you are leaving, so... On your way. I walked into the office. There was a desk in the far corner of the office. A coat rack stood nearby. A small derby, an undersized fur-collared overcoat, and a cane hung on it. In front of the desk stood a short, brown little man. He was fat all over, soft fat like a butterball. And he had the whitest skin I've ever seen. Everything smiled but his little pig eyes. And the voice when it came was the purr of a cat. I assume you are Mr. Runyon. Uh-huh. I am Runyon. Please be seated, Mr. Runyon. I am Oliver Weaver.
You must excuse my rather excitable young friend. There is no harm, I'm sure. Excitability and guns don't make a good mixture, Winkler. Guns? I'm afraid I don't follow you. He was wearing one on a shoulder holster. Neat little gun. The kind people with experience carry. I felt it when he bumped into me. William Donovan with a gun? Oh, it's difficult to believe. Oh, but of course that would... Please? Yeah, go on. Yes, yes, yes. It has to do with my purpose in calling you here this morning, Mr. Rennie. Just why did you call me, Winkler? I'll be as brief as possible, sir. My life has been threatened. I feel that such a person as yourself might be helpful in preventing, shall we say, an unfortunate accident. Who threatened your life and why? I am a businessman, Mr. Rennie. Such I cannot...
toward the luxury of modern sentimentality. Naturally. What is your business? I noticed the sign on your door says Enterprise Incorporated. What's that? Enterprise Incorporated is an investment and finance company. Not a bank? Oh, no. We merely invest money, our own, of course, in various businesses. We take mortgages and so forth. Sort of personal finance, eh? Call it that if you wish. However... The real bulk of our business is rather more in the speculatively consistent line. I see. So somebody you've loaned money to has threatened your life. Let's put it this way. Someone whose knowledge of business methods is extremely limited has suffered the most unforeseen and unfortunate accident which benefits this company and, as the saying goes, leaves her more or less in the cold. A woman? Precisely. What was this accident you mentioned?
The death of an unfortunate woman's husband. I don't get it. Let me explain. Since the war, there's been a policy of my company to lend various sums of money to veterans for the purpose of buying homes. Our terms are extremely liberal because I feel these lads are entitled to all the help possible and have therefore been quite in demand. However, as I have already told you, I am first and foremost a businessman. Yeah. What was the catch? The cat's quite wearing this. In each contract of mortgage drawn for these transactions, there is a provision that regardless of the number of payments made to this company, if any money was still due to us, the mortgage prophecy reverted to us in the event of the mortgage's death. In other words, even though the heirs of the mortgage are wanted to continue the payment, the property still reverts to you.
And the money previously paid back also remains yours. Exactly. You see, since the terms were so liberal, and these veterans were young and healthy, I felt that the company was entitled to such an insurance. I see your point. A moment ago, you asked if we were a bank. We were more of an insurance company in regard to these loans. We only stand to win in the event of debt. Gruesome gambling. What? Give it. What's the woman's name who threatened your life? Mrs. Etta Goodman. Here is her address. She's living in a mortgage house, but of course, we might have to beg her. She apparently knew nothing of the agreement, and when informed of it, she came here and made her rather dire threat on my life. By the way, Winkler, what caused Goodman's death? A bullet through the brain. Why is that? No, Mr. Runyon. Roy Goodman committed suicide.
I'm looking for Mrs. Ethel Goodman. I'm Ethel Goodman. What do you want? Let's go inside where we can talk. But I'm just going out. I'm in a hurry. This won't take long. Let's go in. Who are you? Why have you come here? Give you some good advice? I don't understand. If you're from that company, if it's about the house... Sit down, Mrs. Goodman. I didn't come to see you about the house. Why did you come then? I understand your husband committed suicide, you say? Suicide. Yes, that's what they said. The police, the doctors, but it wasn't suicide. It wasn't, I tell you. Roy was murdered. Is that why you threatened Oliver Winkler's wife? I threatened? What are you talking about? Who are you? Why are you asking these questions? My name is Runyon. I'm a detective. A police? No, I'm a private investigator. A minute ago, I said I came here to give you some advice. Murder is a serious business, Mrs. Goodman. Forget it. Forget that they murdered my husband, never. Not your husband. Winkler. Winkler?
But I don't understand. Didn't you go to see Winkler yesterday and threaten him? Why, yes, I went to see him. But I don't remember exactly what I said. I was upset and angry. You know how people say things they don't mean when they're angry. And I know my husband didn't commit suicide. I don't care what they say. And that man Winkler is trying to steal my husband. He's not stealing it, Mrs. Goodman. It's all perfectly legal and binding according to the mortgage. But it's not fair. You've got a point there, but your husband fined the mortgage. Did he ever tell you the terms of it? No, I don't think he knew. Maybe he didn't read it carefully, or if he did, he didn't understand. Tell me about your husband's death, Goodman. That was just two weeks ago. His body was found in the woods not far from here. He'd been shot through the head, and there was a pistol in his hand. They said it was suicide, but I know Roy wouldn't kill himself. What makes you so sure of that? There was no reason for him to kill himself.
No. I tell you, it was murder. The police wouldn't listen to me, but I'm sure that man Winker is behind it. I went to him and begged him to give me time to pay, but he wouldn't even listen. He said our house belonged to him now. I even went to the woman who sold us the house to see if she could help. But she could do nothing. Who was the woman you bought the house from? Mrs. Isabel Sutton. She said it was none of her business. She sold the house to us. That had nothing to do with the mortgage. Does she know this fellow, Winkler? Why, I don't know. I don't think so. Why? Nothing. I just wondered. Isn't there anything I can do? I mean about the house. I'm afraid not. But you're a detective. Couldn't you help me? Couldn't you find out if Roy's been murdered? If the police think it was suicide, it probably was. Besides, my only interest is in protecting my client's life.
Didn't you say there was nothing to your threat? I'll be running along. But please, you... Something's fallen down behind the cushions. No, no, please. It's nothing. Nothing? Since when is a gun nothing, Mrs. Goodman? A gun? But I don't understand. Here, let me see. What's it doing here? That's the gun that Roy was killed with. It looks like somebody hid it behind these cushions. Somebody who intended to use it again. What do you mean? I mean there aren't any empty chambers in it. It's been fully reloaded, Mrs. Goodman. How do you do, Mrs. Sutton? If it's a house you're wanting to buy, young man, you've come to the wrong place. I haven't a thing on the market right now. But if you'd care to leave your name... I didn't come to buy a house, Mrs. Sutton. I want to ask you some questions about the one you sold to Roy Goodman. Why? I'm just inquisitive. I believe you sold a house to a Mr. Roy Goodman several months ago. Goodman? Goodman?
Oh, yes. Now, remember, Goodman, yes, I did sell him a house. Poor fellow committed suicide recently, didn't he? His wife seems to think he was murdered. Murdered? She thinks so because a man named Winkler stood to get Goodman's heart, the one you sold him in case of his death. Do you know this Winkler, Mrs. Sutton? Now, you listen to me, young man. I don't know who you are or what you're here for. I don't know anything about the Goodmans or this man Winkler. All I do know is that I sold a house and that Mr. Goodman borrowed the money to buy it for Mr. Winkler. Whatever arrangements they made was their business. I know nothing about it. You understand? Maybe. So you don't know Winkler at all? I know often. He has on several occasions loaned money to people I've sold houses to. None of these other people happened to die, did they? Say, by committing suicide? Who are you? Why did you come here? My name is Runyon. I'm a private detective. A detective?
You still haven't answered my question, Mrs. Sutton. How should I know? I just told you that when I sell a house, I'm playing with it. You deal pretty extensively in real estate. Yes, yes, of course I do. I have to make a living. Real estate's my business. Then I'm sure you wouldn't mind giving me the names of the people who bought houses from you and used Winkler's money to pay for them. But I don't remember who they were. You must keep records. Naturally, but I don't keep them here at home. They're at my office. I see. Oh, never mind. I think I can find out at the plane company. Oh, Mr. Rudman, a moment ago you mentioned murder. There's nothing wrong with Mr. Winters committing a crime. I certainly want to help you. Okay, Mr. Sutton. I'll probably be back to talk to you later. Oh, by the way, have you ever seen this gun before? Gun? Yeah, take a good look at it. It's the one Roy Goodman was supposed to have shot himself with. I know. I've never seen it. Why do you ask? I just want it. Who fired you, Mr. Rudman?
Was it that Mrs. Goodman? No, Mrs. Sutton, it wasn't Mrs. Goodman. Who was it then? It was Oliver Winkler. Winkler? I don't understand. Well, I've got to show you something. You know better than to interrupt when I'm busy. Hello. Remember me, Donovan? What are you doing here? Showing Mrs. Sutton the gun and finding out a lot more than I bargained for. I'm sorry it took so long to find these files, Mr. Runyon, but with no more to go on than you gave the claims office, it took a time. That's okay. Did you get the rest of the information, too? Yes. One of our secretaries traced the history of each purchaser since they bought the house. Good. What did you find? Well, our records show five sales in which property owned by Mrs. Isabel Sutton was sold and paid for by money borrowed from Winkler's company. Is Roy Goodman included in that list?
Let's see. Yes. You know, this is really very strange, Mr. Runyon. What? All five of the men who purchased property from Mrs. Sutton and who gave mortgages to Mr. Winkler have since died. Good afternoon. Can I help you? Yes, I'd like to see Mr. Winkler at the inn. Why, no, sir. I'm afraid he isn't. Did you have an appointment? No. You know where Winkler is? It's very important. He doesn't like to be disturbed. I don't know if I should. I said it was important, sweetheart. Where is he? I'm not sure where he went. He had two phone calls about an hour and a half ago. He left the office soon afterwards. He seemed to be in a hurry. Do you know who called him? The first one, I believe, was from a Mrs. Goodman. How about the other call? I don't know who that was from. Mr. Winkler took a direct in his inner office. It was after that one that he left. And he didn't give you any hint as to where he was going? Well...
He did leave a phone number with me where he said I might get in touch with him if anything terribly important came up. Call it. But I... Listen, sweetheart, I said this was important. If you ever want to see your boss alive again, you'll do what I tell you. Alive? What do you mean? I've got to find him quick. Now then, get on that phone and call the number he left with you. Yes, sir. Act perfectly natural. Don't mention anything about me, understand? I understand. Find out whose number it is, and if Winkler isn't there, find out where he's gone. Just say it's something about business and that you're trying to locate him. Hello? This is Mr. Oliver Winkler's secretary. Oh, yes, yes, Mrs. Sutton. Is Mr. Winkler there? Do you know where he's gone? Something important has come up. I'd like to get in touch with him. See? Is there a phone there? All right, Mrs. Sutton. I guess I'll just have to attend to it myself.
Thank you. Goodbye. Where did he go? That was Mrs. Isabel Sutton's home. I know who she is. Where did Winkler go? Mrs. Sutton said he went out to look at a house he's going to take a mortgage on. Where is this house? It's in the country about a mile from the city limits on Coldview Road. It's an old red brick farmhouse that's just been deserted for some years. And it sits back on a hill just beyond Bedford Creek. You can't miss it. Did Winkler go there alone? Why, no. Mrs. Sutton said he went with her assistant, Mr. William Duncan. It was already dark when I left Winkler's office, and the rush hour traffic was just getting underway. Even so, I made fairly good time and cleared the city limit 35 minutes later. I threw my car off the main road and bumped along to a dark natural tunnel formed by slow overhanging trees. Five minutes later, the glare of my headlights picked out a small wooden bridge 100 yards ahead.
That would be Bedford Creek. According to Winston's secretary, the farmhouse lay just beyond the creek. I slowed down, rattled across the rickety bridge, and pulled off the side of the road and saw something steep. I walked slowly up the drive, and the house came to be. It looked empty, distant, and dark. On the porch, I stopped for a second, and there was no sign. I tried the front door, and found that I'm lost. In my time, I eased and turned. met on the flashlight and played it slowly along. I was in the musty, dust-covered hall. Our beds hung from the deep, and the well-worn staircase leaned drunkenly against the second floor. An open door stood on my left. It led into what was evidently the living room. I walked to the door and saw the light quickly. There wasn't any furniture in there. There wasn't even a fireplace. But there was a man lying in the middle of the floor. He lay on his back with his eyes wide open.
and he wasn't the man I expected to find. He was Mr. William Donovan. My light swung quickly round to the far corner of the room. The figure of a woman pounced there in the glare. Her eyes were filled with terror, and she held a gun in her hand. She wasn't pointing the gun at me. It hung limply in her hand as if she'd forgotten it. Drop the gun, Mrs. Goodman. Mr. Runyon? Yeah, get up. Oh, you found another gun. No. No, that isn't my gun. Where's Winkler? Did you get him too? I didn't kill that man on the floor. I've never even seen him before. You expect me to believe that when I find you here with a gun in your hand? One shot's been fired out of this pistol and not long ago. But I didn't do it, I tell you. He was there, there on the floor when I got here. Why did you come to this house? He telephoned me to meet him here at 6.30. I didn't want to come out. Who? The Winkler, of course. He said if I'd come, he might be able to arrange for me to kick my home.
You'll have to do better than that. I happen to know that Winkler came here with this dead man down with him. You followed him, didn't you? Then you shot this guy and Winkler got away before you could finish him. Isn't that what happened? No. No, I didn't. Honestly, I didn't. Mr. Winkler wasn't here. I haven't seen him since yesterday when I was in his office. Go on. And it better be good, sweetheart. Because you're sitting about three feet from the electric chair right now. Oh, no, please. You've got to believe me, Mr. Runyon. Late this afternoon, he phoned me and told me to meet him here. I decided to come when he told me it might be he's arranging for me to keep my home. How did you get out of here? My car. It's parked around behind the house. When did you get here? About 15 minutes ago. The house was dark like it is now.
I had a flashlight in my car, so I stopped and came around to the front. There was no sign of Mr. Winker. I'd been there about five minutes when I thought I heard something inside the house. So you went in. Yes, I don't know why. I guess I thought Mr. Winker was in here. I called several times, but got no answer. Then I looked in his room and saw this man there on the floor. He was dead by then. The gun was lying beside him. I must have picked it up. I don't remember. I was... Terribly frightening. I can imagine. While I was standing here, I heard you walk up on the porch. I didn't know what to do. I was terrified. Some of it might make sense and some might not. But it's the truth, I swear it. I think Jonathan brought Winkler here to kill us. But it could be that Winkler got him first. But why? And why did he call me to meet him?
Unless I'm mistaken, Winkler, a woman named Sutton, and this dead man were working together in the real estate mortgage record. I think the Sutton woman and the dead man were afraid Winkler had gone too far and they'd tip the works. When you became suspicious of your husband's death, and when I came into it, I think they figured Winkler was double-crossing them, and so they decided to kill him. But evidently, he got wise and knocked off Donovan first. But why did he call me? That's the part that makes me believe your story, sweetheart. You were suspicious of Winker, and you made threats. In other words, Winker called you so he could frame the killing on you. Come on. We've got to move fast or we're going to trap him before he pulls his next killing. Where are we going? To Mrs. Sutton's house. No matter what I say, you agree with me, you understand? There's a car in the driveway. It's probably Winker. He is here, then. Where is he?
You're lying, but you're not going to get away with it. Here we go. What do you mean? What do you mean breaking into my house? What are you doing here, Winkler? I've come to get a murderer, Winkler. Then it's true. You did kill him. You killed Bill. Shut up, you idiot. Why? This isn't true. No, it isn't, Winkler. You were too smart for your own good this time. What are you talking about? He killed Donovan, all right, tonight in a deserted farmhouse just outside his town. The body's still there. I didn't kill him. No? I told you you were too smart for your own good. You thought you'd frame Mrs. Goodman for the killing because you knew the three of you had dwindled her and murdered her husband. So you called her to come to the farmhouse. But he fooled you, Winston. Fooled him? What do you mean? I mean Mrs. Goodman got there before Donovan and Winston did. He suspected something like this.
So she hurried and hid herself in the house. And she saw the whole thing, Winkler. She's lying here, Runyon. She killed William. She threatened me. You know that. Sure, sure. You were banking on that, weren't you, Winkler? Now listen to me, Runyon. Listen to my... Oh, you did kill Bill. You dirty, double-cropping little fool. No, Isabel, no. Don't you see what he's doing? I only see what a little wreck you are. You're right, Mr. Runyon. He's a murderer. He saw to it that all those purchasers died. Accidentally. After they mortgaged their homes to him. She's lying. Lying. She was behind it. It was her idea. Oh, no, Oliver. Not my idea. Perhaps I'm guilty of helping you. But if I can see you in the electric chair, I'll gladly take my own punishment. You're insane, Oliver. Don't believe her on you. Don't believe her. Shut up. Can you prove he's the murderer, Mrs. Sutton? Of course I can prove it.
I've all the papers to prove it right here on my desk drawer. You may have them gladly. You've got a gun! Yes, my dear. I have a gun. I told you she'd think it. I tried to warn you. Quiet, Oliver. I'm going to kill you now. I'm going to shoot you just like you shot Bill. No. No, Isabel, please. Put that gun away. Don't be a fool, Mrs. Sutton. I know what I'm doing. You're going next, Mr. Rodney. No, Isabel, no! Goodbye, Oliver.
No, Mr. Runyon. You are. That beam came in very handy. Now, give me that gun. No, no. Let go of me. Let go of my hand. My arm. You're breaking my arm. Yes, yes. Give it to me. Now, Mr. Sutton, I will hold the gun. You saved the state from trouble by disposing of Wink. It will put you right in the electric chair, Mr. Sutton. Oh, Mr. Runyon, I was so frightened that time. I don't know what happened. Skip it, sweetheart. You saved my life. If you hadn't startled her by screaming, I'd be lying there dead by now. Okay, Mrs. Sutton, let's go. They did murder my husband, didn't they? Yeah. There's one thing you won't have to worry about now. What? I've got a hunch that heart of yours is going to stay right where it belongs. With you, Mrs. Goodman.
