Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
The Fat Man artwork

From the The Fat Man collection

Fat Man Murder Runs an Ad

Episode28 min 56 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 18 min to read

The recipe for everything in this modern world. Take some flour and stuff, mix them and bake them, and you've got hot biscuits. Take some uranium and a sort of neutrons, put them down the middle, you've got atomic energy. Take a blonde and two guys, add a dash of larceny, a heaping amount of jealousy and greed, bring to a boil before pulling the trigger, and you've got the perfect recipe for murder. And now, here is the fat man in Murder Runs Awonted.

There's 20,000 restaurants between the Bronx and the Battery. A New Yorker can spend a lifetime robbing out a full life of a gourmet and also robbing out his waistline. The night I bumped into Dwight Burgess, I'd had a yen for ravioli and green noodles, so I'd spent two hours in Benini's in Greenwich Village. I left there around 9.30. As I made my way along a dark passageway street just off McDougal Street, a door suddenly opened and somebody blundered right into my $4 dinner. Watch where you're going. Here, get out of my way, can't you? Take it easy, Mac. You're not in the subway yet. You don't get out of my way. Don't swing, pal. You might regret it. Don't my arm. Come over here. Under the light. Now, listen, I'm warning you. Wait a minute. Thank you, Brad Runyon. Now, guess my weight. How'd you know me? I've seen you around. Hey, listen, Runyon, you've got to help me. Help you do what? Spend a Class A hangover? No, it's more than that. It's Lela. Who's Lela?

My wife. Here, come inside. I have a tear in the hole. Here. Oh, and a heap on the floor, huh? She did, Runyon. My wife's dead. Murdered. Dead to the heart. I didn't do it, Runyon. I didn't do it. Where were you running to get an aspirin? I... I lost my head. I had too much to drink and then... When I... When I followed her here... Followed her? What does that mean? Look, I meant to kill her, but I didn't do it. I didn't. Tell the cops that maybe they'll believe you. Oh, they won't. I know they won't. You've got to help me. Okay, I'll do what I can. Well, find out who did it. Run in and hide me out. Don't let the police find me. I'll help you, but I can't hide you. You've got to. You can't let them get me. Don't be a dope. I can't cover up for you that way. Oh, I can get back against the wall. Stay where you are, fat man. Stay right where you are. Nobody with all these marbles argues with an automatic.

I let him go. Then I turned to the murdered woman on the floor. Even in death, she had a selfish, handsome face. I went to her purse and came up with loose chains with thick compacts to drive it like. Her name, Leela Burgess, address, Sutton Place. All this, plus a typewritten letter, signed eight times to make an appointment at the address where she'd be murdered. I told Homicide and then caught a cab to Sutton Place. It was possible Widow Burgess had run back home. When I entered his apartment building... Oh, excuse me. Excuse me, ma'am. Oh, not at all. It was my fault in time. Anything I can do for you, ma'am? I don't reckon so. I came to see Dwight and Leela Burgess, but they don't seem to be home. I reckon you came a long way to see them. How can you tell? All the way from North Carolina.

I only came across town, but it's still a long hike if I'm going to miss them. Oh, you know Dwight, too? We're great pals. Too bad nobody's home. Such a shame. And the evening's still young. Yeah. My name is Brad Runyon. You think we might find someplace where we can talk? Have a drink? Well, now, Mr. Runyon. My name's Betty Lou. Betty Lou Barlow. Just lead the way. Oh, what a cute little bar. Oh, thank you. The customers make it that way. Some of the customers. Why, thank you, Brad. If you don't mind if I call you... Brad, go right ahead. You in New York on business? I surely am. How'd you get?

I read the tea leaves in my last old fashion. How long will he be here? Oh, just long enough to tell Dwight and Leela the good news. Good and bad news, I guess you'd call it. What's the news all about, Betty Lou? Money? It surely is. Dwight's uncle back home, he's left him all his money. $200,000. You mean they don't know about it yet? Goodness, you know, I came up to tell you. You see, I'm Uncle Waldo's attorney. More uncles should have attorneys like you, sweetheart. Honey, I may not look like Paul Schiff, but I reckon I know how to save you. I have a better look. Bright and Leela both inherit his money, eh? Uh-huh. In the event of either one passing on, the survivor inherits the entire thing. When did Uncle Waldo pass on?

Just four nights ago, he was killed by an unknown fire. That's all? A burglar? My, yes. Somebody broke in late at night. Uncle Walter woke up and then got himself killed. But let's not talk about that. Let's talk about something special. You're so big and strong. Now tell me what great big eyes I've got. Conversation developed as a basic baby talk after that. A.M. before I dropped Betty Lou off at her hotel. A month later, I was jerked out of sleep by some goon leaning against my door buzzer. I guess so. His name's Dwight Burgess. Burgess? What's he want? I don't know, Runyon. He got me out of bed an hour ago, said he was in a jam, gave me this sealed envelope for you, and then beat it. That's all he told you?

He didn't say more than two minutes. Hey, what's wrong with him? Has he got anything to do with Lela? Alert me to the envelope first. Fine. Well, what's happened, Runyon? He encodes this $200 cash from the key to his office. And he doesn't want me to talk to anybody about the trouble he's in. Well, you can tell me. The Burgesses are my best friends. They happily married? Well, uh... Well, yeah. They've been married four years now. He came here from North Carolina. What business is Burgess in? He runs a small brokerage office. I do happen to meet him. Why all the questions? I'm in the same business. Now, what's happened to him? Sorry, Gusby. Burgess asked me to keep it to myself. I can't betray a client's confidence. Okay. Well, I'll go and find out from Leela. She'll tell me what's happened. I'll let Gusby go his way. He'll learn the news soon enough.

Burgess' note asked me to go to his office and pick up a threatening letter he'd started to write to his wife. Swore he was innocent and again begged me to help him. That's great when I left my daughter to his office. It was small and neat, like a high-class telephone booth. I found the letter popped up on his desk. My dear Leela, she is, I know the truth. You don't love me, have never loved me. Yet you say you're going to stay married to me because of my money and because of the money we'll get when Uncle Waldo dies. Well, you're wrong, Leela. We won't stay married. I won't be made a fool of, and I give you fair warning. Hello? Dwight? That's no Dwight. No, it isn't. Who's calling? Oh, I reckon I must have the wrong number. No, you haven't, Betty Lou. Well, I'll declare it.

Who in the world? This is Brad Runyon, sweetheart. For goodness sake. Is Dwight there with you, honey? No, he isn't. Well, I just don't know what happened. I tried to call Dwight and Lita at their apartment, and a strange man answered. I simply hung up on him. You did, huh? Well, the cops will trace your call. Cops? Brad, honey, what's going on here? I think you haven't seen the papers yet. Of course not, Jenny. I'm not even dressed. Well, I mean, hey, I'm still up here in my room. Better get dressed, baby, than go buy yourself a paper. Oh, why, for goodness sake, what's going on? I've got a visitor. See you later, Betty Lou. But, Brad, honey. Runyon. Runyon, I hope I find you here. Come on in, Guthrie.

Sorry, broken the papers, huh? Yeah, look at it, Runyon. Leela's murdered. Police searched for missing husband. Yeah, I know. How do you know? How do you get mixed up in this? Later, I guess. Look, I've got the note. Tell me where Dwight is. What makes you think I know where he is? The note he wrote you. Now, where is he? Sorry, I don't have my crystal ball with me. But Leela's dead. I've got to find him. Why? So you can send him over to the police? What makes you say that? Because you were in love with Leela Burgess. Now, wait a minute. Why didn't I? All right, I was. So what of it? Did Burgess know about it? No, he didn't. And I didn't get anywhere with Leela. Madly in love with her husband, eh? She said she wouldn't leave him. Now, look, tell me where Dwight's hiding. You've got to tell me. Don't care for it. I'll take it. Mr. Burgess, this is the Jade Collector's bulletin. Jade Collector's what? The bulletin.

You still haven't picked up the answers to your warrant ad. Would you like to drop by for them? Will I? Yes, I'll drop by. Thanks very much. What was that about? It wasn't Burgess. Anything else you know about the Burgesses, Guthrie? Nothing I care to say. I'm going back to my office. Let me know if you have any need of it. Tell me. I went to Burgess's desk before I left his office. I found one item of interest. A reservation envelope for an airline ticket to Durham, North Carolina and back dated four days before. I put it in my pocket, checked the address of the Jay Fletcher's bulletin, and then caught a cab. The bulletin's office was on the ninth floor of a broken-down office building on Lower 4th Avenue. A tall brunette in a tailored suit and a holocron glasses stepped out of the elevator with me. We reached the bulletin's office door at the same time. Oh, no.

I didn't know you were coming in here, too. Yeah, I've got some letters to pick up. Maybe you're the one who phoned Dwight Burgess about the ad. Oh, no, that was Susan Weston. I'm late in getting down here this morning. What on earth? What's wrong? I don't know. The door's locked. Here, let me try my... Thank you. What? ...in a heap on the office floor. Tiny redhead who must have been a lively city mouse when she was alive. Now she was a limp bundle of rags with the back of her head thin. You'd better get a hold of yourself. This is no time to go to pieces. We'll call the police on it. Who are you? I don't understand. I'm working for a client named Dwight Burgess. Goosen called his office about a want ad in the jade collector's bulletin. He said she had some replies for Burgess to pick up. Yes.

The bulletins we see newsletter will circulate among trade collectors. Susan's handle of want ad sex. I'd like to see that ad and those replies. But what about the police? Why don't you call the police? As soon as I've seen the ad. We can't waste time with that. We've got to find out who killed Susan. That want ad may give us a lead on her killer. Oh, quit stalling, sweetheart. Get me that ad. Well, here it is. Must be in this one, too. Okay, I'll find it while you get those letters. I'll have to check the box number in the book first. Here it is. Box HF. A blind ad. And Dwight Bird just paid for it? Yes, that's the name. Okay. Here's the ad in this box. Hey, get those letters for me now, huh? All right. All right. They'll be in this box. A real blind ad.

Need money quickly, we'll sell my very rare tiny jade necklace to Wright Fire. Wright Fox, H.S. for a pint. Mr. Ryan! Now what? The letters! The answers to the ad! They're gone! Homicide detail arrived. I had to tell them all about Dwight Burgess, his want ad, and the stolen letters. But it didn't help them find out who had killed Susan Weston. After they'd finished questioning... I don't have anything to say. Leela's police will take care of everything now. What? Well, as a matter of fact, he was. He made a big thing of it. Did he read a magazine called the Jade Collector's Bulletin? What? Are you hard of hearing, Guthrie? Or is this a bad connection? I asked you if Mila Burgess read the... Yeah, she did. Why do you want to know? Just trying to wear in my dough? I intend to find out who killed my client's wife. For hanging up on Guthrie, I called the airline office to check on the ticket Burgess had bought to North Carolina.

Then I went to Betty Lou Barlow's hotel. Oh, Brad, honey, I've seen the papers. Poor, poor Dwight. I think he killed Mila. Do you think he killed Betty Lou? I don't care to answer that. Why not? You're not under oath. Well, I just wouldn't care to say. You've known the Burgesses a long time, haven't you? Ever since we were knee-high to a parson. You knew Burgess before he married Leela? Of course I did, Sally. What's unusual about that? Well, it occurred to me you might have been in love with him. Oh, for goodness sake, honey. What put that crazy notion in your head? You did, sweetheart. I did? Yeah. You're not at all concerned about Leela.

But you're plenty upset about Dwight. Oh, you detectives think you know so much. How did you know I'm a detective? I found out. Snooping, eh? Well, I've been doing some snooping where you're concerned, baby. You've been registered at this hotel for two days now. There's nothing wrong in that. Maybe not. But maybe the police will want to know why you didn't get in touch with the Burgesses right away. I wanted to mix pleasure with business. I wanted to have a good time by myself. Better think of a smarter answer than that, sweetheart. What are you talking about? Lady lawyers can be cute, Betty Lou, but they're not dumb. Better give up that sweet but stupid routine, baby.

Just what do you get now? Your Uncle Walter's attorney. Who killed him? I've already told you. An unknown prowler. An unknown prowler named Dwight Burgess. That's crazy. Dwight hasn't been home in four years. Burgess inherits all the money in our leader's debt. What happens to your state if he dies? Dwight isn't going to die. Who gets the money if he kicks off? It goes into a trust fund for charity. Who's the executive? I am. I'll handle it. You will, huh? Very interesting. Now, see here. Just what are you insinuating? For one thing, I'm saying you were in love with Dwight Burgess back home and jealous of Lela. That doesn't mean anything.

You can't make a case out of that. And furthermore, Mr. Runyon... I'll answer that. Don't you dare! Give me that! Sweetheart! Who's calling? That's your register. How do you know? Yes, that's right. Let me talk to him. Give me that. Late, sweetheart. He hung up on me. You should have let me answer. He would have talked to me. Yeah. He'll have plenty to say to me when I find him. We were operated to trace the call, but it got lost in the wealth of incoming and outgoing switchboard calls. I phoned Frank Guthrie's office again, but he'd gone for the day. At 11.30 in the morning, Guthrie was the one person in New York outside of Betty Lou who knew anything about the Burgess family. So I paid a hunt and took a trip to Central Park West with Betty Lou tagging along beside me at Frank Guthrie's apartment at Fort Penn.

No. I still don't know what you expect to find out from him. After all, he is just a friend of theirs. You ever meet him, sweetheart? Frank Guthrie? Why, no. Here, poor tan. Let's see if he's home. I don't know why you didn't phone him first. I did. It's just the office and home. Hold it. There's someone coming. Who? Come in, Runyon. You two better know. What? What are you doing here? Come inside. Now, shut the door. What? I don't understand, honey. Stay where you are. Both of you. I had a hunch I'd find you here, Burgess. Couldn't ask for a better hiding place, could you? What have you found out, Runyon? Tell me. I'm not so sure you'll want to hear it. Tell me. Okay, pal, here it is.

I found evidence that proves you killed your wife. Oh, honey, no. And you killed a girl named Susan Weston. You've got the evidence that proves that? Your wife read the date collector's bulletin, didn't she? She read it. And you knew she'd answer that one. I told you last night. That's why I followed her there. But she was already dead when I got there. You'll have a tough time making the cops believe that, Burgess. Especially after that want ad was paid for in your name. Ah, you're out of your mind. Am I? The girl who took the ad was murdered this morning. And the answers to the ad were stolen. You think you're going to tell the police, bud? They already know it. And they'll know about your trip to North Carolina. You're not going to frame me. I won't let you. Dwight, no, you can't. Get out of the way, Betty Lou. Stop it, Dwight. I'll shoot if you move. Frank!

Ah, it's in the other door. Thanks for the interruption, Guthrie. I guess you know you can be held for harboring a fugitive, though. Well, he was my friend. I thought he was innocent. You mean now you think he's guilty? Well, you heard what Runyon found out. You'll have to give yourself up to it. No! You can't make me any of this. You've got two murders set up against you, Burgess. Three. Counting that trip to North Carolina, he must have killed his uncle, too. You won't frame me. I won't let you. Runyon, look out! No, you don't! Jeffrey thought he was playing Notre Dame when my 239 pounds hit him. He went out hard. But he was still struggling as I cried out to Burgess, Don't shoot! Hold it, Burgess! Hey, you fool, Runyon. Let me up. Not yet, pal. Give me that gun. Come on, give me snow. Snow right there.

All right. Now your pockets. Nice thoughts. Kill them back. Give those letters to me. Brother, these letters are going to the DA's office. I mean, what's all this about? Here's the killer, Burgess. Your friend, Guthrie. What? Frank killed Leland? And Susan Weston. And your uncle, Waldo. And he just tried to kill you. But all the evidence against why? Now frame up, sweetheart. Guthrie framed you. Listen, run. You're not... Don't move, Guthrie. You inserted that ad in Burgess' name, and you bought that ticket to North Carolina in his name. Then you planted the ticket envelope in his office. But why? Why did you do it, Frank? Because he was in love with your wife. He killed your uncle for her, then she doubled-crossed. He said she meant to stay married to you, and all that dough. Frank, no. No, you couldn't.

He did it all right, didn't you, Guthrie? Yes, I did. But how did you know? You said Burgess must have killed his uncle. Only Barry Lou and myself knew he was dead. That meant you killed him. But the letters, what about them? These are the replies to the want ad. Five of them, all unopened. And one of them from Leela Burgess. Yet Leela received an answer to her reply. Yeah. That ad was bait for murder. I ought to kill you for this, Frank. Don't waste your bullets or your life on him, Burgess. Space will handle that job for you.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑