The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 18 min to read
Traveler. This is the Mysterious Traveler, inviting you to join me on another journey into the realm of... I hope you will enjoy the trip, and it will thrill you a little and cheer you a little. So settle back, get a good grip on your nerves, and be comfortable. Murder. As I was walking along one of the main streets of a large city, by an elderly man, he seemed extremely agitated. On me turn. May I speak with you for a moment? Of course. Yes, perhaps this will help. Oh, please, please. It isn't money I want. I just want someone to listen to me. No one is interested in seeing justice done. I'd be glad to hear what you have to say. You will listen to my story? Yes. I want to confess something that's on my conscience. I've confessed a hundred times, a thousand times. Yet no one will believe me. You must help me make them believe. It all began that day in my office, when Martin, my son, came in to see me.
Glad you're here. I want to talk to you. Oh, sounds as if I've done something you don't approve of, Dad. Did you read the gossip column in this morning's Daily Legend? Why haven't you told me about this woman, Diana Winters? I'm sorry, Dad. I just didn't think it was important. You've always told me about your other friends. Are you ashamed of Diana Winters? No, of course not. How should I be? Martin, you know as well as I do that her reputation is, well, spectacular, to put it kindly. Well, stories about her are all lies. I'm not taken in by gossip, Martin. I happen to know that this woman is just...
Playing no good. Dad, I won't have you talking about her like that. Martin, you don't love this woman, do you? Yes. Yes, I do. Martin, you must give her up. Dad, I'm old enough to make my own decisions. Can't you see what she's doing to you? She's just a predatory gold digger. Dad, stop talking about her like that. All right, son. If that's the way you feel about it, you'd better go. Goodbye, Dad. Oh, perhaps that's... Come in. It's you, Norman. Hello, Walter. What's the matter with Martin? This person in the reception room, he appeared to be quite upset. We've had a quarrel. Huh? It's the first one we've ever had. Was it about that bit of gossip in this morning's Daily Ledger? Yes. Imagine Martin's name linked with that of a... Martin will be all right. He'll get over it. No, no, he won't. Stand by and watch him ruin his life? I've got to do something. I wouldn't if I were you, Walter. I'm going to let Martin make his own decisions. He's no child. Oh, you're a fool, Norman. You expect me to watch the only person who means anything to me get hurt? No, I suppose you won't. What are you going to do? I'm going to have a talk with that woman, Diana Winters.
Yes. Would you come in? Thank you. It's Walter Cabot. Walter Cabot. I see. And I have a word in private with you. Really, I have a guest. It will only take a few minutes. All right. Come this way. Thank you. No, I'll bother us in here. I hardly know how to begin, Miss Winter. Then let's be frank, Mr. Cabot, and save ourselves time. You've come here to ask me to give up your son, haven't you? Yes. Well, then you may as well know that you're wasting your time. I love Martin, and I won't give him up. I know better. Since we're being so frank, I'll get to the point. How much do you want to let Martin go? Are you insinuating what I just said? On outcome, Miss Winters, there's no need to put on an act for me. How much? Really, Mr. Cabot, you know, you're far more interesting than your son. Shall we say, um, 100,000? 100,000? Yes, 100,000. You love your son. Surely he's worth it. I haven't anything like that amount of money. Oh, I'm sorry. Do you believe for a moment that Martin has any money?
No, no. But he will inherit a quarter of a million dollars from his mother's estate in a few months. Oh, so you know about that. Yes, of course. What other reason would you have for leading Martin on? None that I can think of. What if I were to tell Martin of our conversation? He wouldn't believe you. You can't do this to him. I'm afraid I must be getting back to my guest, Mr. Cavett. Now, wait, please. Please listen to me. Martin is everything I have. If I had the money, I'd gladly give it to you. But I haven't it. Oh, sorry. Women like you don't deserve to lose. Please leave at once. If you don't give Martin up, I'll kill you. Oh, get out of here. I'll have my friend throw you out. I'm warning you. Stay away from Martin or I'll kill you. He tried to bribe her to give me up. Is that true? Yes, Martin, it is. You did that after I told you I loved him? Yes, because I know she doesn't love you. And why weren't you able to buy her off? Because she wanted $100,000. You're lying. She never asked you for one cent. Have you ever known me to lie to you? Dad, I told you I was fully capable of making my own decisions and I meant it. An hour ago, I asked Diana to marry me.
Can't you accept it? Yes. Just a few days. Are you going to ruin your life for a cheap gold digger? Dad! I told you not to speak about it like that. If you feel differently, Diane and I will be happy to see you. Get out. Get out, do you hear? All right, all right, I will. I've done everything I've tried to do in his life, do you hear? But what can you do? If there's no bride, there can be no wedding. If there's no bride? Walter, you don't mean you... Why not? You think of anyone who deserves less to live? For years, my hobby has been the study of famous murders. I've studied hundreds of cases closely. In each case, I was able to pick out the flaw that prevented it from being a perfect crime. And then one day, I began to work out a perfect crime for myself. Walter, what are you saying? I was merely doing it for fun, just as some men do crossword puzzles. Norman, I did hit upon a way to commit a perfect murder. And now I have a motive. You must stop talking like that, Walter. There's no such thing as a perfect crime. You're wrong, Norman. And I'm going to prove it. Walter.
Can't you see that what you want to do is insane? It's far better that Martin marry that woman than for you to become a murderer. Now, if Martin were to marry that woman, it would be the end for both of us. At least this way I can be certain that his life won't be ruined. And that's all that counts. As for the police, Norman, they'll never catch me. Never. Can you tell me the name of the horrible place? There ain't nothing horrible about Valley Springs, stranger. 1,242 people think it's my design village. I've never seen an uglier place. What do people live here for? I'm drinking, haven't you? Well, I'm warning you, mister. You'd better stop insulting this village or I'll run you in. I'm the village council. Oh, so you're going to get rough. I will take this. Hey, I'll learn you to push the law around. You're under arrest for drunkenness and disorderly conduct. You and me are going to see George Hutchins, Justice to Peace.
And after insulting our village half a dozen times, Your Honor, he attempted to attack me. And that's when I arrested him. Hmm. You did right, Pete. What you got to say to the charges, Mr... What's your name? I'm not gonna tell it. He sure had his jug full, Your Honor. Hmm. Charges, drunkenness, disorderly conduct. How do you plead, stranger? Give me, Your Honor, joy. Well, stranger, since you've met the killer, I'll only... I need $20. What if I don't want to pay? Well, I'm afraid in that case, you'll just spend the night with Dad. I won't be intimidated. I'm not going to pay my fine, and you can make me. I do. Pete, looks like you'll have to lock him up tonight. Take him away. Stranger, now you can see what the inside of our jail looks like. It still ain't too late to pay your fine.
Now, don't you want to pay it and sleep in a nice, soft bed? No, I'd like it here. Which of the two cells is mine? I'll give you one on the right. Sleep in the other. I've got to guard you. Go ahead, get in so I can lock the door. Just as you say, constable. Now, I don't want to hear anything now. The other morning, I had enough trouble sleeping in here without remodeling it. I'll be so quiet, constable, you won't even know I'm here. dream. The place would be perfect for my plan. If only the door doesn't creak as I open it. Car and drive to the city are the most important part of the plan. What do you mean by breaking into my apartment? What do you want? Do you remember what I said to you the other night? What you said? I'll refresh your memory. I'd kill you if you didn't give Martin up. You wouldn't dare. Oh, but I would. My friend said you threatened me to get the chair. I don't think I will, Miss Snickers.
Why are you looking at me like that? You're not trying to frighten me, aren't you? I tried to reason with you, but you wouldn't listen. You should have. No, you can't kill me. That's when I came in, and I have the key. Please listen to me. You can do anything you want. I'll get Martin up. I'll go away. You had your chance. Twelve and stop it. The exact time I was being arrested in Valley Springs, and my son is free. Free. Constable. Constable. Wake up. Wake up. Let her drink. I want another drink, and I'll take it straight. Oh, go to sleep, you hear? It's four o'clock, and he ain't getting out of here until late in the morning. I don't want to hear any more out of you. Yes, sir. So, constable, anything to oblige your gentleman. He spoke to me at four o'clock in the morning in my cell, and I was very drunk. Everything's worked out. He'll never be able to prove a thing. In a few months, the murder will just be a thing of the past.
And Martin and I will once more be as close as ever. My partner told me a few minutes ago that you've been looking for me. And we're putting it mildly. A five-state alarm out for you for the past 24 hours. What? We've been vacationing at a small resort a hundred miles upstate. That wasn't vacation, wasn't it? What? Yes. Say, I read about that, Kelly. That's rather nice. Not so. I'm afraid I'm going to have to do that for the DA. Oh, I won't be able to. I really can't remember where I was last night. Cabot. I think you're going to wind up in a place you're... Set your hat. We're going down to headquarters. Ah, that sounds serious. Well, do you mind if I speak to my partner and explain matters to him? That won't be necessary. You'll be able to read all about it in the papers. And believe me, it isn't going to make pleasant reading. ...that testified that the defendant, Walter Cabot, happened to kill Diana Winters. And how has the defense replied to the charges of the state? It hasn't. Can we accept...
the flimsy story of the defendant, that he was drunk the night of the murder and hasn't any recollection of his actions. Anna Winters, where he cold-bloodedly strangled her as he vowed to do before a dozen witnesses. There is only one verdict you can render. Murder in the first degree. Since you've insisted on defending yourself, ready for the defense's summation, Mr. Cabot? I've often observed the strange twist of fate by which a man is saved or condemned. My inability to recall any of my actions on the night of the 22nd left me without a defense. Yesterday, frankly, I regarded my case as being hopeless. Today, however, through a twist of fate, I have received a new lease on life. I'm now prepared to prove my whereabouts on the night in question. I should like to call upon a witness for the defense. You have the court's permission. Thank you, Your Honor. I wish to call Peter Wilk to the stand. Peter Wilk to the stand. Here I am. Take your right hand, please.
You're telling me to swear to tell the whole truth and I don't want the truth to help you, Grant? I do. State your name and occupation, please. Peter Wilk. I'm constable for the village of Valley Springs. Mr. Wilk, will you tell the jury exactly what you told me this morning? Well, yesterday, George Hutchins, he's our justice of the case, and myself were looking at a city newspaper. And in it, we see a picture of a man, Mr. Cabot, right on the front page. It says he's being tried for a murder committed on the night of January 22nd. Well, George and me recognizes him right away. As the fellow we locked up in our jail that night on a drunken and disorderly charge. Dear son, it's good to see you again after all these months. Oh, Dad, can you ever forgive me for running away when you needed me? Forgive you? There's nothing to forgive, son. Dad, I know how right you were about Diana. Oh, you don't know how happy it makes me to hear you say that, son.
I've been through a great deal lately. But it doesn't matter. I'm glad to be back. I promise you I'll never let you down again. Quite sometimes, as I've seen you. For the Winter's murder. Do you mind, Kelly? No, nothing special. Have you seen the latest edition? No. Anything of interest happen? If you might find it interesting, it could mean a client. What's happened? Here's the late paper. Oh, thanks. Suspect for Winter's murder. Can't be. Why not? If you didn't kill Diana Winters, someone down at headquarters... But you must be mistaken. What evidence have you got? Evidence? Yes. Well, we can prove the guy we've got was at Diana Winters' apartment that night. What's that? That he was seen leaving just after midnight, after a flail of a quarrel with her. Quarrel? What about? Oh, you should think. Both know what Diana was. Gold digger. Yes, of course. Plenty other boyfriends than your son. Not the others, but... Yes, but... That night, the guy who killed her found...
I found out a few things about her and bumped her off. No, I don't believe it. I told you he left right after midnight, didn't I? That's right. Well, her watch was found on the floor where she dropped it during that fatal struggle. That watch is going to hang the guy. He may have been wrong in your case, but this time we have the right man and we'll make it stick. And all the evidence is circumstantial. I'd better be running along tonight. You might want to read the whole story.
Suspect held for Winter's murder. And the coverage apparently concludes... I had it planned perfectly so that no one, no one could be held for it. Look, something. Norman said that. But I knew better. And now an innocent man has been arrested for my crime. Yes. I can't let him die. Gentlemen of the jury, you have reached a verdict. You have found the defendant guilty of murder in the first degree. In the courtroom. No. No, no, it can't be. You're wrong. Silence in the courtroom.
Mr. Cabot, you'll kindly refrain from such outbursts. But, Your Honor, I protest. The evidence submitted by the state was purely circumstantial. It was more real. May I remind Mr. Cabot that this case may be appealed. Our attorney is quite uncalled for. But the prisoner is innocent, Your Honor. You haven't any right to... Another such outburst, Mr. Cabot, and I'll hold you for contempt of court. Your Honor, the defendant was convicted on purely circumstantial evidence. But I have positive proof of his innocence. Why did you wait until after the jury rendered a verdict to make this statement? I hoped, Your Honor, that the defendant would be acquitted and I wouldn't have to reveal my proof of his innocence. But I would like to do so now. This is highly irregular, Mr. Cabot. Since the jury has already rendered its verdict and cannot be influenced, you may proceed. Thank you, Your Honor. I know for a certainty that the defendant is not guilty of the murder of Diana Winters. For it was...
I who committed the crime. Mr. Cabot, you say you confess the murder of Diana Winters? Yes, Your Honor. I and I alone am responsible for her death. You must believe me. Mr. Cabot, only three months ago you were acquitted of the murder of Diana Winters. You well know that a man may be tried only once for a crime. This confession now can do you no harm. The court sees your confession as being motivated. Only by your desire to see the defendant go free. No, no, Your Honor, that isn't true. I did murder Diana Winters. Then I broke her watch, and I set it back to 12 o'clock. You must believe me, you must. Manif, have Mr. Cabot escorted from this courtroom. Prisoner will remain in his cell. No, no, no, wait, Your Honor, listen to me. He isn't guilty, I am, I believe. Diana, in court, I've confessed a thousand times, and yet no one will believe me, no one. But you, sir, you will help me, won't you?
We can't let an innocent man die for a murder I committed. No, of course not. But will I hardly see how I... Every minute that passes brings him closer to the end. We must save him. We must. If you only... Hello, Cabot. Oh, Kelly. I was just telling this gentleman here my story. We can't let an innocent man go to the electric chair. Kelly, you're a smart man. You believe I murdered Diana Winders, don't you? Yes, I do. You do? Then... Then you'll help me save him? People wouldn't believe me any more than they do you. But they would, Kelly. They would. Why should they believe your story? You can't be tried again for the murder of Diana Winters. Innocent, Kelly. Martin, my son is innocent. He was convicted only because he was near her apartment that night. And now there's so little time to do anything. The execution is set for midnight. And it's all the... It's twelve. Well... My son. My son. Never again.
Too bad about poor Walter Cabot, wasn't it? Such a brilliant man. His own intrigue sent the one person he loved. Any chance you're contemplating murder will find your son. Perhaps we'll meet again, too. You have just heard chapter 67, the final chapter of this series of The Mysterious Traveler. Tales of the strange and terrifying. In tonight's story, murder goes free. Ed Latimer played Walter Cabot. Tony Barrett played Martin. And Irene Winston played Diana. The Mysterious Traveler is written by Bob Arthur and David Kogan, and original music is played by Henry Silvern. The entire production is under the direction of Jock McGregor. The Mysterious Traveler is presented from our New York studios. This concludes the present series of The Mysterious Traveler. Next Saturday evening at 9.30 Eastern Wartime over most of these stations, Mutual will present a new program, radio's first nationwide audience participation mystery series. It's called Calling All Detectives.
We invite you to be with us for Calling All Detectives next Saturday night at 9.30 Eastern wartime. This is the Mutual Broadcasting System.
