The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 20 min to read
The Mutual Broadcasting System presents The Mysterious Traveler, written, produced, and directed by Robert A. Arthur and David Colbert, and starring two of radio's foremost actresses, Gladys Thornton and Abby Lewis, in The Knives of Death. This is The Mysterious Traveler, inviting you to join me on another journey into the realm of the strange and the terrified. I hope you will enjoy the trip, and it will... thrill you a little, and chill you a little. So settle back, have a good grip on your nerves, and be comfortable, if you can, as we join two little old ladies who have one burning ambition in life. They want to solve a murder. It's a story I call Knives of Death. Perhaps you remember two sweet old ladies named Grace and Florence Murdoch. Grace is 72, and Florence is younger. She's only 70.
After a lifetime in a small town, they've set out to see the world. Well, up to now, their only recreation has been reading mystery stories. Now they're determined to find real adventure, but not just read about it. In their hotel room high above New York, Grace Murdoch is looking out at the great city below them with eager anticipation. New York, Florence, think about it. We're in New York. I don't have to think about it, Grace. I know we're in New York. Look at the lights, the enormous buildings, the traffic. George, think of the adventures waiting for us down there. The people we'll meet, the mysteries we may encounter. I don't want to encounter any mysteries. At my age, I'm perfectly content to have a nice, quiet time in sight.
Oh, sightseeing. Really, Florence, you sound just like a retired schoolteacher. Well, I am a retired schoolteacher, and so are you. That doesn't mean I have to act like one. As soon as we've changed our clothes, we're going down to Chinatown to have dinner. Grace, you're forgetting. Forgetting what? We promised to go out to New Jersey to see Matilda Smith tonight. We did. I don't remember doing any such thing. I don't even remember any Matilda Smith. That's her married name. She used to be Matilda Johnson. She was a pupil of mine the first year I taught school. A thin, unattractive southern girl with just lots of money. She sounds simply dismal. Why do you want to look her up? Because of her husband. He used to be a professor. He made several trips to Africa, wrote some very interesting articles about the strange tribal customs he encountered. Now I'll phone her and tell her we'll be out later. Hello? Operator?
I want to make a person-to-person call to Mrs. Matilda Smith in Dobbs Corners, New Jersey. That's it. Yes, I'll do it. That's it. The chairs are all in place. Now the table to hold my notes. Will you help me move it, Matilda, my dear? But be careful of the African knife. It might... Oh, oh, make me. It almost hit my foot. I told you to be careful, my dear. I have it. What a beauty it is. Sharp as a razor. And notice the carvings on the blade. The greatest witch doctor in Africa made this knife. I don't want to hear about it. And I forbid you to talk about it tonight, do you hear? But our little gathering tonight is for the express purpose of hearing my talk on the worship of death among the Dambongi savages of Africa. And a very select group it is. The leading grocer and his wife. The owner of the local garage and his wife. Chief of police Hoffman. All our very best neighbors. Talk about something else. Why do you have to talk about death all the time? Death, death.
But we discussed all that, my dear. And we agreed that the only way to overcome the morbid fear of the world is death. Now, what is death? It's just a word. Nothing to be afraid of. We all must die in time. Some of us sooner than others. But there's no need to cower in fear of the inevitable. But, Matilda, I... You just need to torture me. You want me dead. Kill me if you dare, but you don't dare. You know the whole world would know the truth. My love, you're hysterical. You must calm yourself. Remember, we have guests coming in a few hours. Well, I do believe we're going to have a storm, too. Well, then we'll just make an appropriate setting for my little lecture. The Dambongi savages, you know, believe that on a stormy night, death is able to walk abroad to select his next victim. Expect me if you talk like that anymore. Oh, Matilda, hadn't you better answer? Oh, no, he must come again.
Trying to kill me. Goodness, what a night. Florence, are you sure that Matilda said her husband was trying to kill her? Of course I'm sure. She said he was trying to scare her to death. Oh, do you realize that we've read over a thousand mystery novels and in none of them has a victim ever been scared to death? What of it? Don't you see? It's a brand new murder method. Why, Florence, this may be an adventure. Much more exciting than a trip to Chinatown. That's a very callous attitude. I only hope we're in time to help Matilda. Over the telephone, she sounded positively terrified. Tell me again all you know about her, just in case. Well, she has lots of money. And she's very stingy with it. A few years ago, she married this professor. A man much younger than herself. Apparently, he married her for her money. He's been furious at her ever since because...
He can't get his hands on heaven. Go on. Well, anyway, he's very brilliant. He studied witchcraft in Africa. And Matilda is sure he'd kill her if he knew how to get away. Our taxi seems to be slowing down. Do you suppose we're actually there at last? Yes. There's one of those little glass signs on the lawn. Look, it says, the house is awfully dark. Goodness, I do hope we're in time. Is anyone home? They're an awful long time answering. Matilda said the professor was giving a talk tonight to some friends. Maybe they don't hear us. Yes? Who is it? Grace and Florence Murdoch. Matilda invited us. Oh, of course. Come in, come in. We were afraid you weren't coming. We took the wrong train. We'd have been here hours ago. Oh, what a pity. Let me take your thanks.
I'll hang them here to dry. Your friends, my dear. They finally located our humble abode. My dear, you must control yourself. I hope you'll understand about Matilda, dear lady. She hasn't been herself in recent months. She's obsessed with the emotion she's going to die. You see, she has a death phobia. The very word upsets her. And, most unfortunately, this evening I was asked to lecture on the worship of death among the Dambongi savages. Fascinating topic. Death to the Dambongis is a living creature. The thunder is the echo of his footsteps. Matilda, there now, it's all right. Really it is. Professor Smith, Matilda should be in bed. She needs a sedative. Just what I told her. But she insisted on staying up to greet you.
Her room is right here. If you could persuade her... I will. Matilda, come with me. I'm going to put you to bed. Oh, such a pity, my wife's affliction. But I'm sure her old friend will be good for her, Miss Grace. Now we were in the midst of my little talk. If you care to come into the living room and join us, I'll continue. Now, my friends, having discovered beliefs concerning the sentence of death held by these savages... the Dambongi tribe of Central Africa. I'm going to show one of the sacred knives of the tribe. I'll hold it up here. Notice the tremendous blade, razor sharp, and the curious carving. The Dambongi believe that a knife like this is the house in which death lives. Such a knife possesses the life of a soul and can seek out and kill a victim with no human hand. That's superstition, of course. But still...
Strange things do happen in Africa. I'll cut the knife. Do you care to look at it? Yeah, I guess so. Handle it carefully. It could give you an aftercut. Oh, look out. Jimmy, you dropped it. Well, I have it. I have it. No harm done. It sent a twist right out of my hand, like it was alive. The unexpected weight, of course. But perhaps I'd better not pass it around. Someone might be cut. Instead, I'll start the projector and show you the exact... tribal dance in which this knife was dedicated to death. Grace, where are you? Here, to the left of the door. Oh, I couldn't see. Sit down. How's Matilda? She's asleep. I gave her a tablet. Grace, she's frightened. She swears he'd kill her if he did. Did you lock her door? Yes, I turned out the light and I set the cat so the door locked automatically. Why?
Because this husband of hers is up to something. I don't know what. But all this talk about the death worship of dambungate savages and the rest of it, it's pure hocus pocus. You mean it's not true? Not a word of it. There's no such tribe. Look at that film. It's just an ordinary tribal dad. But he has all these people in here, their neighbors, sitting on the edge of their chairs. Then he's up to something. Yes, so we'll just stay here with Matilda tonight. Tomorrow we'll discuss what's to be done. With the door locked, she should be safe enough. Yes. The window's locked, too, because of the storm. Nobody could possibly get into that room. Well, the dance is over. Now shut off the projector. Now, friends... What was that? What was that? Grace, that was material. Please, everyone, remain calm. My wife may have been having a nightmare. It was no nightmare, Florence. It certainly was not, Grace. Come on.
Rusty, what's happening? Please, dear ladies, don't alarm yourselves. Poor Matilda frequently has nightmares. That doesn't sound like a nightmare to me, Professor. Nor me either. Oh, I forgot. I locked the door just now. I'm sure she's all right. But just to make certain. Matilda. Matilda, my love. She doesn't answer. Perhaps we had better break the door down. Chief Hoffman, if you'll help me. Yeah, sure. Then come on. Once. Twice. Now once more. There's it. Now, let me find the light switch here. Oh, she's dead. She's lying right in the middle of the bed where I left her. Only now she's dead. With one of those African lines straight through her heart. Is this wall solid? Yeah, this one is, too. Well, it beats me. The walls are solid. The windows are locked. We know the door was locked because we had to break it down. And still, somebody got in and killed poor Matilda. But how?
Extremely puzzling. More than puzzling, my dear Miss Murdoch. Impossible. Surely by now it's obvious that at last Matilda could endure her terror no longer and ended it by seeking the very death she feared. Nonsense. You mean you don't think so? Of course not. I've known Matilda since she was a girl. She was always emotional. She certainly wouldn't kill herself. Florence is quite right. Nobody who worries so much about dying ever kills himself. Then, my dear ladies, we have an impossibility. If in this tightly locked room my wife didn't kill herself and wasn't killed, what other answer remains? I don't know yet. If we rule out those two possibilities, we're left with a picture of a huge African knife, dedicated to death by the mystic spell of an African witch doctor, rising in the darkness, floating through the air, and plunging itself into its victim's heart. Ah, she killed herself. That's what I say. I stick to it. Just...
How did that knife that killed Matilda get in this room? I don't think that's been explained. I brought back a pair of them from Africa. They're very rare and extremely valuable. One I kept, one I presented to my wife. She kept it in here, on her dresser. I would hardly expect you to keep something she dreaded so much in her room. Because of the value of the knife. Matilda, for all her wealth, was extremely close-fisted. Anything valuable, she liked to keep close to her. There's one thing you men are overlooking. Yeah, Miss Murdoch? I helped Matilda to bed. I saw her take a sleeping potion just before I turned out the light. Then she shouldn't have. She couldn't have killed herself. The medicine would have put her to sleep too quickly. Just what I was trying to point out. Well, Professor, you say that. What can I say, dear lady? Only what I've said before. Here in this locked room was a night animated by the very spirit of death himself. The storm is raging outside.
The sleeping spirit in the knife stirs. The knife moves. Now, this is Dobbs Corners there, New Jersey, not Africa. That kind of stuff don't happen here. I say she killed herself. It's the only way it could have happened. And I'm going home. I decided there ain't no case here for the police, and that's that. Yes, of course, you're right. It couldn't have happened any other way. I'll see you to the door and tell my other guests that they're at liberty to go home. You will all understand that I want to be alone. Well, Grace, you wanted adventure tonight. I guess you've gotten it. Poor Matilda. That monster murdered her. The least we can do is avenge her by proving it. If he murdered her, I'm sure. I don't know how. He was out in the other room talking to us when she died. Yes, he was just turning up the lights when she screamed. Oh, but we must try.
There's the knife he was showing us there on the table in the hall. Get it for me, will you? All right, though I can't imagine why you want it. Here it is. Now, bring it over here to the bed. There now. Hold the knife close to the one that killed Matilda. I want to make sure they're identical. Very well, Grace. Grace! What, Florence? The knife is my hand. It moves all by itself. Look, I'll show you. I'll hold it close to the first knife like this and... See? It practically jumped to touch the other knife. Very strange. Let me try it. You're right. There's a strong and definite attraction between these two knives. As if... as if there was something living in them. Like Professor Smith said. Yes, and I think I know what it is. Oh! The lights almost went out there. Yes, lightning struck the wires, but flourished. I need ten minutes. Go out and somehow try to keep the...
Professor, for interrupting me for that long. But how? Oh, how do I know? Use your feminine wiles on him. I never learned any. That's why I'm an old maid. Then say to do something, anything. But I need ten minutes to discover the kind of black magic Professor Smith used to kill Matilda without ever coming near her. Grace? Yes? Chief Hospital is just driving away. The others have already left. Professor Smith will be coming back any minute. Let him come. I'm all ready for him. Help me put this stepladder in the closet. All right. What in the world were you doing with the stepladder? I found it in the hall. And I was using it to practice black magic. Grace, what on earth are you talking about? Look around and you'll see what I mean. I don't see a thing different. There's both children.
body, just as we discovered her. And everything else is the same, too? Not quite. Florence, look at the knife that killed Matilda. Notice how straight it went into her heart. Why, yes, quickly straight. And from reading more than 1,000 mystery novels, we know that when anyone strikes a fatal blow, it usually enters. That's an anger. Of course it does. And this knife went in as straight as it could go on, point foremost, and... That's it, Florence. Now you're looking in the right place. There's a huge knife lying on the ceiling. I just finished putting it there. But what makes it say there? Black magic, Florence. Black magic, Professor Smith. Magic? Oh, my goodness, madam. What were you saying about me and black magic?
I was asking what were you saying about me and Black Magic. You've been disturbing poor Matilda's body. Grace, I think it's time we were gone. Oh, yes, Florence. It's very late and we must be getting back. Stand still, you two. Wait. You're gone, Hatter. And it's loaded. Furthermore, I'm an excellent shot. You'd never shoot two defenseless women. Since he's just murdered one defenseless woman, Florence, I wouldn't be too sure of that. I'm tired of this little comedy. And of you two busybodies, you stand there until I can see what you've done to Matilda's body. Why are you rolling Matilda's bed out from the wall? So that I can stand between it and the wall. Keep an eye on you two while I examine Matilda. My late, unlamented wife. Good. Grace, what are we going to do? He may kill us, too. I know, I know. You got us into this. Now get us out. Oh, I wish we...
Just go on to Chinatown like I wanted. Never mind wishing. Think of something. Can't. My mind's frozen. That gun looks so big. Florence, I'm scared. Maybe we can distract him by talking. Professor? Professor? Yes? You're not looking in the right place. I suggest you look up and see. I don't need to prepare to admit that you've probably guessed my little scheme to rid myself of you. Oh, it was a clever scheme, but not clever enough. I think it was. My little talk about witchcraft and black magic and knives that move by themselves confused everyone else so thoroughly none of them will ever seek for a more rational explanation. But we know. At least, I think we do. And you, my dear ladies, are going to be silent as the grave. Oh! A nice turn of phrase, isn't it? Silent as the grave? You're going to.
Killers? As soon as the next clap of thunder comes to drown out the noise of the shots. Oh, no. Why, we have tickets for Around the World Voyage, and we haven't even started. You'll not need them, I assure you. You'll be caught. I never read a mystery yet where the killer wasn't caught. How different life is from books. You see, there's a pool of quicksand a mile from here in the swamps. Your bodies will go into that pool, and you'll never be found again, particularly as no one is likely to come looking for you. Oh, dear. We won't even have a headstone. Change its form, son. Because it caught Zip Ladder. Oh, I see what happened. When the light went out, because the lightning hit the wires, I ran for the door. Only I got the wrong. You did indeed. What is this? There. There on the floor beside Matilda's bed. In his bag? Yes, Florence. He's dead, thank goodness. Here's the diary.
Tonight, we actually solved the murder. And in a locked room, too. The manner in which we solved this dastardly crime. Grease? Yes, sir? I'm writing up our diary. Yes? And I want to put down how we solved Matilda's murder. How did we solve it? I'm still a little confused. Oh, well, in the end, it was quite simple. You see, Florence, for 50 years you taught history, but I taught physics. What is that to do with it? When we were examining those two knives and some strange force drew the two blades together... Yes, I remember. I recognized it at once that one of the blades must be magnetized. Magnetized, of course. Now, hard steel becomes magnetized when in the field of an electromagnet. So I reasoned...
There was a magnet somewhere in the ceiling. And when we got Cheap Huffin to come back, he found it under the floor of the room above, directly over Matilda's bed. So all Professor Smith had to do was to switch on the electromagnet, then place the knife against the ceiling, and it stopped him? Exactly. You helped Matilda to bed. Neither of you noticed the knife, because the room was lighted only by a small bedside lamp. Then ten minutes later, in the living room, the professor pretended to switch on the lights. At the same time, he pressed the switch that controlled the electromagnet. And the knife fell and plunged straight into Matilda's heart. But how did the professor get killed? I'm trying to nerd over that and telling Chief Hoffman what happened. While I'm testing the apparatus, I put the second knife against the ceiling, and the electromagnet held it there. Yes?
Then the professor came in and stood under it while he pointed his gun at us and waited for a flash of lightning. That was like a bad dream. But when the lightning came, the flash blinded him. We ducked. The lightning itself struck the wires, cutting off the current and causing the electromagnet to cease working. So that the knife fell and killed the professor. He was destroyed by his own evil schemes. Exactly. By his own black magic, he killed him. You might even say he was executed by heaven itself. This is the mysterious traveler again. Well, that was hard luck for the professor, wasn't it? It's really too bad when a murderer has a perfect scheme. It kills him, too. And just because the locks work. So, Grace and Florence Murdoch are going to London soon. If you happen to be traveling to Europe in the near future...
And to encounter two elderly maiden ladies with an odd gleam in their eyes. Duck, because you may be involved in a million before you know it. You may even become the victim. Oh, that reminds me of my story from Eastwood. A Coffin for Charlie. It's about a Englishman who inherits a coffin. A million-dollar coffin, which he... Oh, you have to get off here. I'm sure we'll meet again. I take this same train every week at the same time. You have just heard The Mysterious Traveler, with the title role played by Maurice Tarpley. Others in our cast were Gladys Thornton, Abby Lewis, and Wendell Holmes. Original music composed and played by Al Finelli. All characters in our story were fictitious. Any resemblance to actual persons was purely coincidental. Phil Tonkin speaking. This program came to you from New York.
