The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 12 min to read
Today's drama, a gift, just beginning to fall as a smartly dressed young woman knocks on the heavy door of Coral Covington's country estate. Miss Eva! Surprised to see me, Jackson? Delighted to see you, miss, and I know your brother will be overjoyed. Come in, come in. Gerald was saying only last week that he hoped to get back from Europe in time for the party. Party? Did you say party? Yes, miss. A party here? A little gathering in keeping with this glad season. As I remember Gerald, he considers all seasons equally glum. I, uh, know this, but this, you see, is in honor of your Aunt Frances. In honor of Aunt Frances? Do you mean to tell me that Gerald is giving a party for Aunt Frances? Indeed, Miss. Where is he? In the drawing room, trimming the Christmas tree. This I've got to see. Eva, what a happy surprise, I can't tell you.
Christmas tree? Yes, I did it all myself. And presents? For your Aunt Frances. Is it so strange, Eva, that I should want our aunt to have a lovely tree? Yes. My dear Aunt Frances is 72 years old. We may not have her with us long. Darling, last year she was 71, which isn't precisely adolescent. And all she got for Christmas was a dozen handkerchiefs and a cold in the head. Things are somewhat different. So I noticed. Last time I was in touch with this little family circle, you and Clyde hated Aunt Frances like death and taxes. You may speak for our brother Clyde, but as for me, I've always adored the dear old fool. Really? Really. Shall I show you what I have for her? Do. An antique music box, the sort of thing she loves, and in solid gold. Isn't it charming? God rest ye merry gentlemen. Expensive item, I'd say. I paid $500 for it, but nothing's too good for... Possible, is it, that Aunt Frances has come into money? Well, that is... She has.
Well, the truth is an old admirer of hers, Mr. Onslow Fraser, remembered her in his will. How distinctly did he remember her, Gerald? Quite distinctly, Eva. She's inheriting a million dollars. When did you hear of her? Only yesterday. A Mr. Timber of the firm of Elkhart, Elkhart & Duveen in Boston brought news. Now I see it all. The tree, the presents, the party. You're competing with Clyde for Aunt Frances' affection. I am only trying to brighten the end of her life. You are only trying to become a chief beneficiary of her will. Nonsense. Sure I will be a beneficiary. as you will, Eva, though I doubt that Clyde will benefit very much, if at all. Why not? The day before yesterday, before Mr. Elkhart appeared, of course, Clyde was unfortunate to me, a certain. Letter? A letter, my dear, suggesting we put Anne Francis in home. No. Correspondent has laid eyes on it. I shouldn't be surprised if she cuts out altogether. And you're going to let her lay eyes on it, of course. What do you think? Does Clyde know you do? Oh, my dear. Home for the past two days, begging and threatening my life by turn.
Why does not a man who let himself be pushed too far, Gerald? I'll risk his ride. I must go upstairs and rap some music about Sir Anne Francis. You'll greet them for me, won't you? Who's coming? Principally the family. Clyde and how it did. Possibly the lawyer, Mr. Elkhart. Anyone else? Just that young couple Anne Francis is so fond of. Mr. Cranston and Margo Lynn. It's my desire to please them. You bet I know. I'll be down in a moment. She should be driving to the city. And the... Write red ribbon for the holiday. I'll be finished with this wrapping in a moment. There, now, I think this makes a very charming little gift, don't you? I said don't you. Oh, perfect night for a holiday party. Perfect. Snowflakes by special arrangement with the weatherman. Just for Aunt Frances' sake. For him to see in the crowning touch of a Christmas candle. Oh, I'd be glad to try. Very good, my lady. We shall fill the night with music. Me, me, me, me. Me, me. Merry gentlemen, let nothing you dismay.
if something has someone very much dismayed. Ring the bell. What's the matter? You look as if you've seen a ghost. Five minutes ago, sir, Mr. Gerald came up here to his study to look at this music box. The shot was fine. Anyone else in the house beside you and Miss Evo? No. The ashtray. I'd murdered Gerald. He looked angry, but when I tried to stop him, he said he had to see Mr. Gerald on a matter of great urgency. What sort of matter? Something about the letter. He told me about it just before he came upstairs. It must have been somewhere in the study, probably the desk. He said he was keeping it to hold over Clyde's head. Yes, here it is. I'm afraid I'm a little baffled. It's only too simple. In this letter, Clyde suggested putting Aunt Frances in an old woman's home. What? Frances just inherited a fortune. This letter was written the day before yesterday. It wasn't until the next day that Mr. Elkhart appeared with the news about Onslow Fraser's will. But it's perfectly obvious what happened, isn't it? Mr. Chesil to get the... But if he did, why didn't he take the letter with him? It's probably because you two came running too quickly. Yes.
And not having gotten the letter, don't you think Clyde may still be somewhere in this house, waiting his chance? If he is, I suggest Bax to be very careful. Why, sir? Because you know too much, and he knows you do. You mean you think he just killed one man, hasn't he? Listen, there's someone moving about downstairs. Clyde! What are you going to do, Lamont? Don't worry, darling. Who's down there? I'll shoot. You wouldn't shoot a defensive old woman, would you? And so near Christmas, too. And Francis. Thank heavens. Lamont. Let's go down before she comes up. Go ahead, darling. I'll join you in a moment. Hello, Aunt Frances. Margot and Eva. Dear little Eva. When did you get back, child? Just today, Aunt Frances. Surprised to see me? Surprised and happy. But then all the surprises I've gotten, they give an happy one. Which reminds me, Miss Lane, Miss Covington, this is Miss Elkhart. Aunt Elkhart, Elkhart and Denise. How do you do, charmed Miss Lane?
You're the lawyer who brought the news about Onslow Fraser's will, aren't you? One and the same, Miss Covington. And happy I was to bear such tidings, just as this joyful season. I should say. Speaking of this joyful season, isn't there something in the drawing room that Aunt Frances is seeing either? There certainly is. What? Now, you're not to ask questions. Just stand where you are. Making news. Now then, Margo, open the door. Merry Christmas, Aunt Frances. For me. All for you. A lovely treat. Indeed, a very lovely tree. It's so beautiful. It's really so beautiful. Now then, my dear. It's been so long since I had a real Christmas. I've forgotten how wonderful it can be. Yes, one does forget how wonderful things can be. You rang for me, Miss Everson? Yes, that's me. Merry Christmas. Same to you, Aunt Frances. I can't think of a better time. Shouldn't we wait for Gerald? I don't think so, Aunt Frances. And Clyde. Where's Clyde?
Right here, Aunt Frances. You don't think I'd miss your pocket, do you? Merry Christmas, Aunt Frances. And may you wear these for many, many happy years to come. A choker of perfectly matched curls. Mr. Alcott, look. Exquisite. Really exquisite. You must have spent a fortune on these, Clyde. And I haven't a thing for you. That doesn't matter, Aunt Frances. Oh, but it does. I'm rich now, you know. And I insist that you tell me exactly what you like for Christmas. I'd like you to be well and happy. Ah, that's very sweet. But isn't there something you'd really like to have? I think I can tell you what Clyde would really like to have, Aunt Frances. What's that, Eva? A letter. Eva, just what are you talking about, Eva? A letter, Clyde. A letter that you wrote Gerald the day before yesterday. I never wrote Gerald a letter. Oh, no? How peculiar. And I have it right here, signed by you. May I see that? No, you may not. May I see that, Eva? You may not, Clyde. May I see it now, Eva?
Mr. Covington. He's got a gun. Clive. Hand it over. Come on. Give it to me. Thank you. Clive, what's the meaning of this? There's no time to explain just now, Aunt Frances. I must go. However, I beg you not to believe any of the poisonous lies these people may tell you about me behind my back. I want you to know that I do wish you the very merriest... Drop that gun! Don't go on me! Drop it! Drop it! Take up that gun, Baxter. Yes, sir. Take Mr. Clyde up to the study and hold him to arrive. Holding the culprit under as fast as you can. Christmas? Immediately.
Christmas party like this, Aunt Frances? Oh, Lamar, my dear, you had no choice. Aunt Frances. Yes, my dear? We found this upstairs. A little remembrance that Gerald bought for you. A music box. And a very lovely one. Oh, how charming. And look, it's gold. A proper gift for a golden-haired lady. What did you say, Mr. Elkhart? Mr. Gunston! Mr. Gunston! Come on! That came from the back of the house. Clive. He's killed Baxter. Come on, Margot. Right, McClane. Oh. Though I can't say as much for my prison. He tried to escape, sir. He tried to escape? How could he try to escape with you standing over him with a gun? I'm afraid, Mr. Cranston, you will just have to take my word. A mound Baxter standing over Clyde Covington. A smoking revolver in his... Killed Clyde deliberately, no more. I'm sure Baxter shot him in cold blood. I'd rather agree with you, Mark. But why? Possibly because Clyde had an alibi. An alibi Baxter didn't want him to use. That Clyde may have not come to the game. Not even to get the letter?
He wasn't the only person who might have been interested in getting that letter, Margot. No? No. Baxter could have used it nicely to hold over Clyde's head as long as Aunt Frances lived. Game of a nice summer. I see what you mean. Then it may have been Baxter who killed Gerald, too. I don't know. It's only a theory. There is worth a visit from the shadow. Who's that laughing? Who is Baxter? Here to see justice is done, Baxter. My mind is slipping. I want the truth back, sir. Go away. Go away. Not until you tell me why you killed Gerald Covington. Leave me alone. Please. I didn't kill Mr. Gerald. You can't lie your way out of murder. I didn't kill him. That's not what I've lied about. He's unconscious, but he'll leave. This case is getting more confusing every minute. I don't understand his position in this little mystery at all. What did he say when I gave Aunt Frances the little gold music box? Proper gift for a golden-haired lady. Exactly. How does he know Aunt Frances had golden hair? Her hair's been snow-white for the past 20 years. And very con...
Confusing. Oh, confusion. Margo? Yes? Whose overcoat is this hanging in the hall tree? I don't know. If it isn't yours, it must be Mr. Elkhart's. Elkhart's? Why? I just saw this sticking out of a pocket. Clyde's letter. What's it doing in his office? I must have grabbed it in the confusion. Our dignified old friend also saw the value in holding it over Clyde's head. Not much. We're going to find out. To Boston, Massachusetts. To what number, please? Oh, I don't know the number. It's the law firm of Elkhart, Elkhart, and, uh... Duveen. And Duveen. Yes, sir. I will place a call and ring you back. And make it fast, please. Yes, sir. Then what do you really think? Time has come to stop thinking, Margo. Words are the kind of discovery that cracks a case wide open. Yes. Look, I want you to go into the drawing room. When you get in... Where's Aunt Frances? Lying down upstairs. She's had more excitement than she can very well stand. Sit down, Miss Lane. Thank you. Miss Eva and I were just saying that this case is becoming quite perplexing.
It is indeed. This attack on Baxter is the most puzzling thing of all. Now that Clyde is dead, who could have done it? I don't know, but there's certainly no doubt that Clyde's guilty of Gerald's murder. That is, just before Gerald was killed. I'm afraid that's not true, Mr. Elkhart. Baxter admitted he was lying about that just before he was wounded. That cigar, the one that Miss Evesh traded? Yes, Mr. Elkhart, it did. It even had his initials on the band. Do you really think Clyde would have been foolish enough to leave a piece of evidence like that behind, Mr. Elkhart? Well, what are you suggesting, Miss Lane? I'm suggesting that with Clyde out of the way, the margin of guilt is narrowed down pretty closely, Mr. Elkhart. To me, Miss Lane? Yes. To you. I've been with Aunt Frances all afternoon. I was with her at the moment when Mr. Gerald was murdered. Can you prove that? Of course I can. Aunt Frances is right upstairs. You have my permission to ask her.
Then it wasn't you? Obviously not. Obviously, Miss Lane, you can now draw the logical conclusion. I'm afraid we can't. Before you do, put up your hands. Eva, put that gun away. I'm sorry, Mr. Elkhart. I'm really quite sorry that you two, who aren't members of this greedy little family...
