Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
The Shadow artwork

From the The Shadow collection

The Nursery Rhyme Murders

EpisodeFebruary 22, 194824 min 13 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 15 min to read

A wealthy young man about town. Years ago in the Orient, Cranston learned a strange and mysterious secret. The hypnotic power to cloud men's minds so they cannot see him. Cranston's friend and companion, the lovely Margo Lane, is the only person who knows to whom the voice of the invisible shadow belongs. Today's drama, The Nursery Rhyme and Murder, is a private sanitarium located in a densely wooded area in the suburbs. It's about 8 o'clock in the evening as Superintendent Alfred Foster walks down the corridor on his way to visit one of his patients. Good evening, Bert. How are you? I'm fine, thanks, Dr. Foster. I've been waiting for you. You should be asleep by now, Bert. I've been waiting for you to come and read to me. But we can't read to you every night. But you promised. You said if I ate all my supper, you'd read a story to me. And I eat it all, Dr. Foster. Every bit of it. The cereal and everything.

Read to me now, please. We told you, Bert, that after you'd been here a while, we'd have to stop reading to you at night. You're not going to read to me? You're tired tonight. A little feverish, too, I think. Now, just go to sleep, and in the morning... I won't. I won't. You promised to read me a bedtime story, and now you broke your promise. Bert, Bert, you mustn't get excited like that. You broke your promise. Bert, stay where you are. Don't come any near us. You're bad, and I'm going to hurt you. Bert, no, no. Take your hands off my throat. Orderly, orderly. I'll make you read me one. Orderly, hurry. What is it, Dr. Foster? Get him off me quick, Andrew. Let him go. Let him go. There. Now stay over there, Bird. Thank you, Andrews. It was close. He promised to read to me, and he broke his promise. You want me to get one of the other orderlies, Dr. Foster? No, that's all right, Andrews. Bird just got a little excited. I can handle him all right. I don't know. I think we ought to send him over to the violent ward. You better not send me away.

You better not. Oh, now, Bert. You better not try and send me away. If you do, I'll hurt you all. I'll hurt you all bad. Orderly. Go to sleep. Three o'clock. I want a drink of water, Andrews. I want a drink of water. Go to sleep, Bert. Please, Andrews. Please. Bert, just a second. I'm thirsty. Here you are. Thanks, Andrews. Now, give me those keys. No, you don't. Give them to me. I got the key. I'm going to get out. I'm going to get out. This is Polly Andrews. I'm Harvey Andrews' wife. Oh, yes. Hello, Mrs. Andrews. Is my husband there? I'm sorry, Mrs. Andrews, but he isn't in. All the orderlies are out on the grounds hunting for Bert Eustace. He escaped last night, you know. Well, that's just it, operator. Our cottage is at the north end of the ground. I understand Eustace is violent. I'm here all alone and...

Well, I'm frightened. I don't know what we can do. I'll tell Mr. Anders to phone you when he gets back here. Well, all right, thanks. Not at all. Goodbye, Mrs. Anders. Goodbye. Lamont, I know it's presuming on our acquaintance, but I want to thank you and Miss Lane for coming to my office this morning. I'm glad to be of service. The fact is, I need your help desperately. You see, Lamont, I'm a psychiatrist, not a criminologist. I don't think it's a case, police, but I do need help in trying to find this escaped patient. And the searching party found no trace of Burt Eustace last night, Dr. Fox? No, Miss Lane. He's still at large. I feel pretty badly about it, too. Burt was showing signs of violence. In fact, he attacked me yesterday. But instead of sending him to the violent ward, I kept him here for observation. Then you think he's capable of being a killer? I'm afraid so, Miss Lane. What kind of a case was this, patient Burt? Not fundamentally a criminal type, but extremely unbalanced emotionally. During his periods of irrationality, he reverted to his childhood.

and lived in a complete juvenile world. What do you mean by that? But he went to bed when it got dark. He ate his cereal faithfully and insisted that I read bedtime stories and nursery rhymes to him. Bedtime stories and nursery rhymes? How have you been handling the case? Trying to find out as much as I can about his background, especially his childhood. Any luck? Well, I haven't been able to get much out of Bird himself, but his father has given a pretty good lead. His father? Yes. He's a well-to-do but eccentric old man. He used to come to visit his son devotedly every week. He's been coming less and less. You think Bert has some sort of a father complex? Perhaps his father's been neglecting him lately? Yes. He's become more and more unbalanced until he reached the breaking point and decided to escape. Yes. Something like that, Lamont. Bert is... Doctor. Foster. Yes, what is it? What's the matter? Mrs. Andrews. Harvey Andrews' wife was murdered in a cottage last night. What? They just found her strangled to death. But the rest of it doesn't make sense. What doesn't make sense?

The killer carried her body upstairs and left it in the fireplace. Poor woman's body curled up in the fireplace like this. Very strange resting place. Notice one other thing, Fred. Yes? Killer took the shoes off the corpse. Why? Why did he take her shoes off? Why did he carry her body upstairs and put it in the fireplace? It doesn't make sense. Contrary, Margo, it does make sense. What do you mean? The tortured depths of Bert's mind, he acted with a... Terrible logic. I don't think I'd follow you, Lamont. Neither do I. You said this man, Bert, loved bedtime stories and nursery rhymes. Yes, that's right. Well, in my opinion, he killed this woman right out of a mother goose rhyme. What? Listen to this, Margo. Little Polly Flinders sat among the cinders warming her pretty little toes. Lamont, the dead woman's first name was Polly. Yes, and she sat among the cinders. That would mean the fireplace, Margo. Yes, and warming her pretty little toes. No wonder the killer took her shoes off. Precisely. The clues are all in the rhyme. I wonder if it's...

only the beginning. What do you mean, Lamar? I wonder if the killer's going to stop with this first murder, Margo. Because with all the Mother Goose stories there are, death can rhyme many times. Miss Lane, I'm glad you're here. I thought after we got your phone call, Fred, what's wrong? We haven't been able to locate Harvey Andrews, the husband of the dead woman. But it's midnight now. You mean you've been looking for him all day? Yes, Miss Lane, ever since his wife's death. Andrews was out trying to find Bert with the rest of the searching party, and now he's vanished. A woman is killed and her husband disappears. Oh, pardon me a moment. Hello? Listen to the reception room for a minute. Yes, yes, of course, Mark. Lamont, Miss Lane, if you'll excuse me for a moment, I'm going out to the reception room. Maybe the searching party has come in. Yes, of course. Can't suppose Bert has killed the orderly as well as his wife? I don't know, Margo. It's strange they haven't been able to locate him yet. Oh, it's Dr. Forster's phone line. I suppose I better answer it. Hello? Bert Eustace, Margo. Come on, I think we'd better get outside fast. Where are we going? To the farm and back to the sanitarium.

Who do you expect to find out there? I wouldn't be surprised, Margo, if we found little boy blue. On the ground in the middle of the night without Dr. Foster. I used to be very glad we left without him, Margo. Hold the flashlight up. Right. Isn't there a haystack next to the barn? Yes, there is. He's walking into a trap. Digging. Do you expect to find? The killer's given us a clue, Margo. If I'm not wrong... Body under this head. Two orderly jackets. Yes, Margo. See, this little boy blue isn't just fast... Please. After you found the body, Lamont? Yes, we ran after him, but lost him in the darkness, Fred. First it was little boy Flinders, then it was little boy Blue. I wonder who Bert will pick next. I can guess his next picture, Miss Lane. Myself. Brave the same thing, Fred. Bert hated me as much as he hated Andrews. As I see it, he went to Andrews' house to kill him and found Andrews wasn't there and killed his wife instead. Then he caught Andrews in the grounds later and killed him and buried him under the haystack. Yes, and logically, I come next. I could be right. I'm afraid I am.

We've got to find this man. We've got to. The police have a statewide dragnet out for him now. Yes. They're so busy covering the highways and terminals. I wonder if they haven't given the most logical place a very fast examination. The most logical place? Yes. Bert's home. I think we'd better have a talk with Bert's father, Lamont. I wouldn't be surprised if he knew a great deal more about where his son was hiding. Good idea. Come on, Lamont. I'll get my things. That won't be necessary. What do you mean? You're not going with us, Fred. It's not safe. Oh, but I... You admitted yourself you were probably next on Bert's list? Yes. You're the psychiatrist. I'm the criminologist, remember?

We'll phone you here at the office as soon as we've seen old man Eustace. Well, all right. See, Eustace, the doctor forced a suggestion. We decided to come here to see you. I know you're as anxious to find Bert as we are, Mr. Eustace. Yes, I am, ma'am. If we could just step inside for a moment, Mr. Eustace, and talk to you. All right. All right, step inside. Thank you. Follow me into the parlor. He's really intimate. Anything like this old mausoleum? No, and I don't think anybody else has for the last 50 years. Here we are. It's a little dusty. You haven't used the potter for some time. Sit down. You live here all alone, Mr. Eustace? All alone ever since Bertram went away. And before that, Mr. Eustace? Before that, it was just Bertram and I. Bertram's mother has been dead almost 40 years. I see. Of course, that Bert left the hospital. Yes. Written the papers, I suppose? No, I didn't read it in the papers. I know it. Couldn't by any chance tell us where Bert is now, could you, Mr. Eustace? I don't know, Mr. Crank. What was that noise?

Must have been the cat. She must have knocked something over upstairs. Those are hardly the footsteps of a cat, Mr. Eustace. Well, they aren't, are they? Must be someone else in the house. I think there is. Then I'd better find out who it is. Come back here, Mr. Eustace. Mr. Eustace! He's locking the door. Mr. Eustace! Certainly has, Margo. We're locked in. Mr. Eustace, we were too slow. Yes, while we're breaking out of the parlor down there, both Mr. Eustace and Bert have disappeared. Come on, Margo, we've got to make sure. Go down this corridor. Stay here. Don't worry, Lamar. Oh! What's the matter, darling? Ran into another of those...

Spiderweb. Spiderweb won't hurt you. Maybe not, but there was a spider in the middle of this one. No wonder Bert was unbalanced living in his old mansion. That's why the queer old duck-like used it for a father. Certainly. Bert, he's upstairs on the floor above us. Come on, Margo, down the end of this corridor here. Must be a flight of stairs there. Here are the stairs. He's up there. Top of the stairs. Goosey, goosey, gander. Come on, it must just be useless. Wait a second till I have a look. Here's the flash. Are you the old boys? Margo, this isn't Mr. Eustace. Mr. Eustace couldn't have just vanished into thin air. Looks as if he did, Margo. We'd certainly run over every inch of the house. Do you really think we can pick up his trail at Dr. Foster's house? It's the most logical place to look for him now. Well, that's Fred's place up ahead. Thanks. Now, if we can just... What's the matter? Well, I saw something in the car headlights. There's a man back there behind the garage. And Eustace... Margo, I'm going around back.

You go into Pritt's house. Tell him I was delayed. Careful, darling. Please, that old man is a crazy killer. Shadow's going to set a trap, Margo. I think the crazy killer has spoken his last nursery rhyme. The same figure Lamont saw when I stopped to pick up the mail. Old Mr. Houston. Yeah, and he left this in the mailbox. What is it? Mr. went to Gloucester. Shower of rain. Stepped in a puddle up to his middle and never went there again. Then old Mr. Houston is here. Lamont did see him. He must have. It must mean that that crazy killer is going to creep into this house and murder me in the night. He's out of his mind. None of us is safe anymore. We're all... What is it? Oh, really, it's close. Here's another note. Here on my desk. Must have slipped in through the window and left it. Another note? Yes. And the odd part about it is, it's addressed to you. To me? Yes. So, Marjorie Dahl, Jackie shall have a new master. He shall have but a penny a day.

Of course, he can't work any faster. I don't understand. Marjorie Dahl. You mean the killer. I mean, I'm afraid he means you. Very close, aren't they? Close enough for optical purposes. Dr. Foster, look at me like that. It's a nice rhyme, isn't it? There's a swing to it. I... He saw Marjorie Dahl. Jackie shall have a new master. A penny a day, because he can't work any faster. You're the nursery rhyme killer. Yes, Miss Lane, I am. I love nursery rhymes. The poor dog. Stay away from me. Little Jack Horner sat in the corner eating his Christmas pie. Jack and Jill went up the hill. Peter, Peter, Pupkin, eat us. These tall modules. I don't see anyone. I can't see. Who are you? You like your little nursery rhyme, Dr. Foster? Who are you? I have in and out with more than I can see. Stop. Very, very likely from the heels up to the head. When I jump into my bed. Stop it. Stop it. I'm going mad. No matter.

All righty, Foster. Your mind has been put to dark shadows. You profess to study. Who are you? Who are you? The shadow. Oh, here to see. You thought you could blame these murders on Bert and then on his father. Case that your own mind broke under the stress. Let me out of here. I've got to get out. Now, Foster, we recite nursery rhymes. Sorry, Margo. Foster wasn't a doctor at all. He was just a clever quack who outsmarted us. He became so obsessed with abnormal cases such as Bert Eustace's that he became unbalanced himself. Is that it? That's right, Margo. Burt's escape must have been the snapping point that forced his mind. He went on a rampage, blaming everything on Burt. And when we went to see old man Eustace, Burt was afraid we'd find Burt, get the truth out of him. We had to get rid of Burt and then shift the blame to the father. When Buster was the one Paulie Andrews saw, and it was his voice we heard on the phone, both Burt and his father were completely innocent. That's right, Margo.

Still don't see why he called you in on the case when he was guilty, Lamar. That's how he outsmarted himself. He didn't want to risk calling in the authorities, but he did need an outsider to verify his alibis and collaborate his statement. I'm a criminologist. We've met before. It seemed like the logical choice. I see. Well, after that case, there's one thing I'm sure of. No, what's that, Margaret? If I ever have to read to a child again, it's going to be from the Encyclopedia Britannica.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑