Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
The Shadow artwork

From the The Shadow collection

Struggle With Death (Recreation 4-11-2019)

EpisodeApril 11, 195424 min 41 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 20 min to read

The Shadow. Ladies and gentlemen, welcome back to yet another exciting adventure of The Shadow. In today's episode, The Shadow will continue to demonstrate to old and young alike that crime does not pay. The Shadow, the mystery man who strikes terror into the very hearts of sharpsters, lawbreakers, and criminals. Lamont Cranston, a man of wealth, a student of science. and master of other people's minds, devotes his life to righting wrongs, solving crimes, protecting the innocent, and punishing the guilty. Using advanced methods that may ultimately become available to all law enforcement agencies, Cranston is known to the underworld as The Shadow. Never seen, only heard. As haunting to superstitious minds as a ghost, as inevitable as a guilty conscience. Today's drama, Struggle with...

Dead. It is early evening. In the fireplace of the Reynolds apartment, a pleasant fire is crackling, and the living room has an air of peace and contentment. In the bedroom, however, the atmosphere is charged with bitterness and rancor as Elsie Reynolds continues to pack her clothes into a suitcase, ignoring her husband's protests. You can't do it, Elsie. You can't leave me. Can't I? Just watch me. But why? Why? You know very well why. How long do you expect me to put up with this sort of life? What's wrong with it, honey? We've got a nice little apartment. We eat well, we dress well. That's not what you promised me. You told me all about your family's millions. You promised me cars and men's coats and jewels. You'll get them, dear. Someday. Yeah? When? After your disgustingly healthy parents finally die? No.

Now. Don't make me laugh. They wouldn't even let me into their fine house, let alone hand over one of their precious gems to me. They won't hand it over to me. I'll go and get one myself. Tonight. You will? I'll get you the bleeding heart ruby. It belongs to me. It's in the safe now and the family's away in Europe. I'll go and get it for you tonight. You mean that, Jim? You bet I do. I'll do anything. But don't leave me. Please. Okay. It's a deal. You go grab the train right now. You can get to Philadelphia and back in about two hours. I'll wait for you that long. And if I bring the ruby, you'll stay? I'll stay, Jim. You know how crazy I'm about you. You bring that ruby, and you'll see how nice I can be. Good. Good. I'm on my way. So long. Okay. Okay, I'm coming. What's the big... Roger!

Yes, Roger Small, in person. Surprised? What are you doing here? That's my line, sweetie. You were supposed to meet me an hour ago. We were going away together, remember? I'm sorry, Roger. It's all off. It's what? I'm staying with Jim. We've made up. Just like that, huh? You've made up, and I'm out in the cold? It's a long story, Roger. I can't talk about it now, so... Oh, no you don't. Nobody double-crosses me. Roger, get out of here. Get out. I will, but not quite yet. I've got something to attend to first. What are you going to do? That knife? No, get away from me. Don't touch me. Lying, double-crossing little gold digger. Play me for a sucker, will you? Roger, no, don't. Jim's your best friend. He was, until you came along. Now you've ruined both our lives, but you won't ruin any more lives. I'll see to that. No, Roger.

Don't! I'll go away with you! Now! I'll do anything you... No! Candy! Sandwiches! Papers! Paper, mister? No. Which way's the smoking car? In the rear. When did we get to Fergie? We just pulled out of Philly ten minutes ago. You got almost an hour to go. Candy! Cigarettes! Sandwiches! Hey, what are you doing here, miss? What? What do you mean? Where did you come from? I didn't see you a minute ago. I've been sitting here since the train pulled out of Philadelphia. Oh, no, you weren't. Some guy was sitting here. That's a lie. You... you must be one of them. One of who? What's the matter with you? Are you crazy? Don't say that! Don't ever say that, you hear? Okay, okay. Mister, I'm in a terrible jam. Could you... could you help me out? What do you want? I'm hungry. Terribly hungry. I want a sandwich. Sure. Eighty-five cents.

I don't have any money. Huh. That's too bad, sister. Candy! Megan! I'll trade you. I'll give you a compact. Very valuable. I'll give it to you for a sandwich. Yeah? Let's see it. Don't you believe me? Look. I've got lots of things in my pockets. Where'd you get all that junk? They're mine. Everyone wants to take them from me. They're after me all the time. They persecute me. Who does? Everyone at school. The dean, the professors, all of them. But I won't let them do it anymore. Here. Here's the compact. Yeah. Yeah, this is okay. Here. Here's your sandwich. Take two, even. Thanks. You won't tell anybody about me, will you? No, I won't tell. Don't worry. Candy. Sandwiches. Magazine. Papers. You killed her, didn't you, Reynolds? Why don't you admit it? I didn't do it, Mr. West. I wouldn't kill my own wife.

And I've told you a hundred times, I wasn't there when it happened. Commissioner, mind if I ask Mr. Reynolds a few questions? Go right ahead, Lamont. That's why I asked you and Miss Lane down here to see if you had any ideas. Lamont usually has, Commissioner. Jim, when did you last see your wife alive? I've been over it so many times. I left Elsie at 7.30 last evening. I went to Philadelphia, was there about 40 minutes, and caught the train back. I was back here in town at 10 o'clock. And his wife was killed at about 8.30. According to the medical examiner. Isn't that right, Lamont? Yes, he has a good alibi, hasn't he? If he was really in Philadelphia. Sure. If. Only he can't prove it. Look, I went to Philadelphia to my parents' home on Eastview Drive. I opened the safe. I took out the bleeding heart ruby. The brooch I promised Elsie. Prove it, son. Prove it. Where is the ruby brooch? It's gone. Ha!

Just like the knife you killed her with. Somebody took the ruby. Stole it from my coat pocket. Who? How could anyone have known you had it? I took it out on the train to look at it. I didn't think anybody was watching me. You don't believe me, do you? Frankly, no. Check the family safe, why don't you? You'll find that the ruby brooch is gone. That wouldn't prove you were there. Or that you were there last night. But if he could prove he was on the 830 train, then... If, if, if... We've checked the crew on that train. Nobody remembers seeing him. Could they? He's a quiet man. He probably didn't talk to anyone. There's one person who probably remembers him. Who, Lamont? The thief, Margo. The person who stole the ruby brooch. Oh, come now, Lamont. Don't tell me you're taken in by that fantastic story. I'm not so sure what. I'm not quite ready to reject it either. Mind if Miss Lane and I check it a little further? Go right ahead. Have a good time.

But if you come up with anything, I'll eat my hat. Higgins, take the prisoner back. Mr. Cranston! Huh? I beg your pardon? I'm Roger Small. Oh, yes. You're Mr. Reynolds' best friend. Like Missioner told us about you. He was questioning you when we arrived. Unfortunately, I couldn't tell him anything. It looks bad for Jim, doesn't it? I'm afraid it does, Mr. Small. You've got to help him, Mr. Cranston. Jim wouldn't kill Elsie in a million years. They were in love with each other. Jim would never lay a finger on her, much as stab her to death. You've got to save him. We'll try, Mr. Smith. We'll do all we can to save him. If he's innocent. Unwilling to reject Jim Reynolds' alibi, which would prove his innocence, Lamont Cranston and Margo Lane undertake to check it further, to see if they can locate the person who, according to Jim, stole the ruby brooch from him on the train from Philadelphia.

Meanwhile, in a brownstone house not far from Cranston's apartment, Mary Hoyt, who was on that same train, argues with her aunt. No, Aunt Hazel, I won't go back to that college. Ever. You've got to, Mary. I promised your mother you'd be taken care of and educated properly. Please, Aunt Hazel, don't send me back. I'll run away again. I can't stand it, I tell you. Why, Mary? They drive me crazy. They persecute me. They say I steal things, but I don't. I don't. The teen didn't say anything about that. Mary, have you been having that trouble again? I never steal things, Auntie. You know that. I find them. Nice, shiny things. Pretty things. Here, Auntie. Look at this. This lovely piece of red glass. Mary! That looks like a...

A rupee? Oh, no. It couldn't be. I found it on the train. I mean, a man gave it to me. He wouldn't be likely to give me anything valuable now, would he? Oh, you've got to give it back, Mary. You've got to find the man and give it back. No. No. I won't. It's mine. And no one can take it away from me, you hear? You mustn't tell anyone about this, Andy. Not anyone. Ever. I'm going to put it in my box with all my other lovely little trinkets. Candy. Magazines. Papers. What do you read, folks? Papers? Candy? Come back here, Bill. Lamont, don't you think we've questioned him enough? I don't think so, Margo. I think he's holding out on us. What is it now, mister? Look, Bill, I know we've been badgering you for quite some time since we got on the train, but... I'll say you have. I'll be glad when this trip's over. You worked the same train, the 830 from Philadelphia, the other night, didn't you? That's right. I work it every night. But you don't remember the fellow whose picture I showed you. So what? I see thousands of guys every day. Maybe they buy a chocolate bar.

Maybe they don't. So what? I don't take their fingerprints. Do you know what may happen to this man, if you don't remember? No. And I don't care. This man is charged with murder. Can't prove that he was here on this train the other night. He's gonna die. He is? I wish I could say I remember him, but I don't. Honest, I don't. Do you remember anyone else on the train? Someone who might remember seeing Jim Reynolds? No. Like I said, I don't remember no one except... Except who? Uh, nobody. You're holding back, Bill. You do have something to tell, don't you? Leave me alone, mister. I'm busy. No. Not when you have some information that might save a man's life. Come on, son. Out with it. You'll protect me. You'll see that I don't get into trouble for not telling the cops. I'll do my best. Okay. There was this girl on the train that night. There was something odd about her. I could see that right away. How do you mean? She kept roaming all over the train. She might have sat near this guy for a while. How do you happen to remember her? She told me she was hungry.

Said she was running away from school. She traded me a compact for a sandwich. What? A compact? I think it's pretty valuable. What? I guess maybe I shouldn't have taken it, but... Have you got it with you? Yeah, here it is. Don't let the conductor see it. It is valuable. More valuable than you think, Marco. Got a curse of a school on it. Let me see, I... Hawthorne College? Boy, that's a very exclusive school. Just outside the city, Lamont. We're going to look up that school, Marco. Have a little talk with the dean.

Checking Jim Reynolds' alibi, Lamont Cranston and Margo Lane went to Hawthorne College, the school Mary Hoyt ran away from. Although the dean was reluctant to discuss Mary, he finally gave Cranston the address of Mary's aunt, Hazel Foster. Margo called Mrs. Foster but was unable to get Mary on the phone. So now, Margo has left word that she has a valuable compact belonging to Mary and that the girl may call for it at her apartment later in the day. As Cranston and Margo wait for Mary's arrival, they are talking to Roger Small, who has dropped in unexpectedly. Do you really think this girl will show up, Mr. Cranston? I don't know, Mr. Small, but I certainly hope so. If she does, and she happens to remember seeing Jim Reynolds on the train, he'll have an airtight alibi. Won't that be wonderful? Yes. A happy ending. Just like the movies. Ending? Aren't you overlooking something? Huh? If your friend Jim is innocent, then there's someone else who's guilty. Someone else killed his wife.

Until she starts all over again. Yes. Yes, I see what you mean. If Commissioner Weston would only... Miss Lane? Yes. And you must be... Mary Hoyt. My aunt gave me your message. I'm so glad you've come. Won't you sit down? This is Mr. Cranston. And Mr. Small. How do you do? Pleased to meet you, Miss Hoyt. Cigarette? Thank you. Light? Oh, what a pretty lighter, Mr. Small. I love that little gold crown on it. It's real gold, isn't it? Yes, I bought this light in England. It matches my wallet. See? Oh, they're both just beautiful. Miss Hoyt, this compact is yours. My aunt told me about it. Why couldn't you leave it at the house for me, Miss Lane? We wanted you to see it. We wanted you to talk about it and other things. I'm not sure I like that. It sounds sort of underhanded. Underhanded? Oh, no. I don't trust strangers.

I've had too much trouble with them. But we're... Maybe Miss Hoyt is bothered by my presence. Oh, no, Mr. Small. I feel comfortable with you. Just the same. I think I'll run along. Goodbye, Miss Hoyt. Goodbye, Mr. Cranston. Don't get up. Goodbye, Miss Lane. So long. Goodbye. Now, about the compact. Here it is. Is it yours? Oh, yes. You know where I got it? I can't imagine. From the vendor on the 8.30 train from Philadelphia. Oh, I see. Well, what do you want for it? Information, Miss White. I want you to look at this picture and tell me if you saw this man on the train. Oh, is that all? I don't mind. I have a good memory for... Oh. No. No, I never saw this man in my life. Oh, no. Are you sure, Miss White? Look at the picture again. I don't have to look. I already told you. No, I never saw that man. He wasn't on the train. Please.

His life may depend on your remembering. I'm sorry. I never saw him. Is that all? May I have my compact? Yes. You may have it. Thank you. Goodbye. I'm sorry I couldn't help you. One moment, Miss Hoyt. I think you accidentally picked up something more than your compact. What? Yes. If you look in your purse, you'll find a leather wallet. It's a small one. Lamont, are you sure? We can check it. Come on, Miss Hoyt. Open your purse and we'll... No, no. I won't do it. I think you will. All right. Here, look. Just as I thought. You don't mind if I take the wallet? I know it got into your bag, accidentally. Of course. Mr. Small must have left it on the desk, and I suppose you were planning on returning it. Yes, yes. I was. May I... May I go now? Of course. Goodbye. I don't get it. What's going on? I thought we were investigating a murder, not petty larceny. We are, Margo. It's all one case.

A neat little package of crime that's heading for a solution. Lamont Cranston and Margo Lane have located Mary Hoyt, who is on the same train as the suspect, Jim Reynolds, although she denies having seen him. Cranston, who thinks he knows why, explains his theory to Roger Small when he and Margo call on Small to return the wallet that Mary, accidentally or otherwise, lifted. You really think she's a thief, Mr. Cranston? There's the evidence, Mr. Small, right in your hand. No more. But she seems to be well-to-do, Lamont. That compact, her clothes, her manner, that fancy school she attends. Why would she... She's not actually a thief, Lamont. She doesn't steal for profit. I'm afraid she's a kleptomaniac. You mean, she's mentally disturbed? It's obvious, isn't it? She can't help thinking. Shiny attractiveness, as a rule. I'm sure she's not even aware of their value. And you think she... I think she was on the train with Jim Reynolds. And saw the bleeding heart where we wrote from.

And that's why she climbed up when she saw his picture. Yes, she was afraid to admit she'd ever been near him. But the maniacs have a wonderfully cunning instinct of self-preservation. What? What are you going to do? Inform Commissioner Weston. He'll get a search warrant, and when we've found the ruby brooch in her possession, I'm pretty sure Miss Hoyt will tell the truth. And Jim will be saved. Yes, and then Weston can start looking for the real murder. Now, Munger, let's go. So long, Mr. Small. Lamont, isn't it going to take too long? Getting a search warrant and all that red tape? Yes. That's why after we give the commission of the fact, there'll be work for the shadow. I don't know what to say, Mr. Small. That's all right, Miss Hoyne. It was obviously a mistake. What earthly interest could you have in my wallet? I always needed you to come here just to reassure me. That wasn't my only reason for coming. It wasn't? No. I wanted to see you again. You did? Really?

You're nice, Mr. Small. So much nicer than most people. I'm glad my aunt's not home, so we can have a nice long talk. Yes, I'm glad too. You're so understanding. I like to show you some of my things. I have all kinds of trinkets. Right here, in this box. Mmm, lovely. Beads, watches, bracelets, and... Oh, the stone in this brooch is magnificent. No, no, that's nothing. Just a piece of red glass. Are you sure? It looks like a ruby to me. No, it's nothing. It's worthless. Give it back to me, please. Where'd you get it? Mr. Small, my wrist. You're hurting me. Where did you get it? Answer me. I don't know. I don't remember. Oh, don't you? I'll tell you where you got it. You stole it from him. From Jim Reynolds. On that train. No. No, I never steal. I find things. I never, never steal. You steal and you know it. And you're afraid of being caught.

That's why you said you didn't remember seeing Jim on the train. Please let me go, my arm. But when the police get here and find this brooch and begin hammering away at you, you'll crack, won't you? Please, please help someone. You'll crack. You'll tell them you stole it from Jim, that he was on the train. Then he'll be free and they'll start hounding me. No, no, I won't tell them. Of course not. You won't be able to talk ever again. What? What are you going to do? Their robe? No! Why not, my dear? It's only a necklace. A necklace of hemp. A lovely... Who's that? Who laughed? The shadow, Roger. Shadow? What shadow? I don't see anyone. No one sees the shadow. But the shadow sees all. No, it's a trick. A trick of the imagination. No, Roger. It's not a trick. It's real. And grim.

As real as the knife which you stabbed Elsie Reynolds. No, no. As grim as a corpse lying on a carpet. You killed her, Roger Small. Killed the wife of your best friend. And then tried to pin the guilt on him. Friend? Jim was no friend. He stole Elsie from me. Twice. Once, when he married her. And again, when she was about to go away with me. I had to do it. I had to. I loved her too much. To let another man have her. And now you will pay. No, never. He'll pay. Jim Reynolds. He is innocent. No one will ever be able to prove it. Not after I'm through with this stupid, interfering little thief. Drop that rope, Small. And let the girl go. Not till I... Let go, I say. Drop it. My arm. My arm. You'll have to stand the pain for another second or two, Mr. Smith. Oh, listen. On the stairs now. The footsteps of the police brought here by Miss Lane.

Your days are numbered, Roger Small. The shadow knows. Yes, Margaret? I shudder every time I think of how close Jim Reynolds came to being convicted of murder. All because an unhappy, mentally sick girl couldn't resist stealing a brooch set with a glittering red stone. And that deprived him of his proof of innocence. It's no wonder Roger Small went berserk when we turned up with her. Yes. By that time, he'd convinced himself that he'd never be suspected on killing Elsie Reynolds, and that his best friend would pay for the penalty of crime. Lamont, when did you first suspect Roger Smalls? The first time we spoke to him outside Commissioner Weston's office. Smalls said that Jim Reynolds would never have stabbed his wife. I'm pretty sure the police have been careful to keep the method of murder a secret. I know the police are usually careful about that, but still, they might have mentioned it. Then later, my suspicion was confirmed when I glanced through Smalls' wallet, the one Mary Hoyt has tried to steal.

And it was a snapshot of Roger Small and Elsie Reynolds, taken quite recently. On the back was written, all my love, signed with the initials, the R. So you set a trap for him by telling him that Mary Holt probably had the ruby brooch and would be made to talk. Yes. Then he knew his only chance of safety lay in silencing her. What strange things people will do in the name of love. Not love, Margo. Jealousy, hate, envy, and egomania. Those are the things that drove Roger to do what he did. And Mary Holt? What drove her to do the things she did? That's what the psychiatrists are trying to find out now. And I hope they succeed. So do I. It would be nice to know that someone profited by this senseless, gruesome murder. This story is copyrighted by Street & Smith Publications Incorporated. The characters, names, places, and plot, fictitious. Any similarities to anyone living or dead are purely coincidental. Listen next month for our season finale.

When the shadow will demonstrate that? The weight of crime bears its bit of fruit. For crime does not pay. The shadow knows.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑