Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
The Whistler artwork

From the The Whistler collection

The Doctor Prescribes Death

Episode 108June 11, 194429 min 33 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 22 min to read

Good evening, this is Peter Lorre. Welcome to another performance dedicated to the shadier side of life. The mysterious, the criminal, the oftentimes murderous side of life. Oh, please understand that this is not that life can be beautiful or love thy neighbor. Oh, no, no. No, my friend, this is the Mystery Playhouse. Probably no stranger. No more unexplainable source of mystery than the human mind itself. It twists and turns sometimes, in labyrinthian confusion, and often becomes the victim of a grim and horrible obsession that has no relationship to the life surrounding it, but one that is very real to him who is obsessed. Listen. The Whistler.

And I know many things, for I walk by night. I know many strange tales, many secrets, hidden in the hearts of men and women who have stepped into the shadows. Yes, I know the nameless terrors of which I dare not speak. Professor Arthur Rugby had a theory. Professor Rugby is a psychologist, and this is his theory. I contend that a person who has decided to kill himself can very easily be turned from this desire to the desire of taking the life of another. I can prove my theory, and if necessary, that is what I will do. Do you agree? Do you believe that if you were about to commit suicide, you could be swayed from your purpose and become a murderer? Professor Ruggs thinks so. But he's just made this strange statement to his publisher, Mr. Hellman. Hellman glances at the manuscript and smiles. The professor leans forward and asks, Well, Hellman?

What do you think? It's purely conjecture, simply a theory, and I wouldn't advise publishing it. But I've worked on it for a long time, and it will work. Good, good of you accomplished it. You can prove it. It's negative. It's not negative. It's positive. I know it. It's so silly, fancy. An ordinary human being has suffered reverses. He's sick of it all. He wants to leave it all behind him. And you say he can be changed to want to kill somebody else. I do. Self-destruction and the destruction of other life are closely related in the mind. It's like, well, a hair's breadth. The dividing line is infinitesimal. It's ridiculous.

You won't publish it? Granger would fire me. Why? He told me that if you came in here with any more silly ideas like the last one to tell you that you're no more of a psychologist than he is, that in his opinion, you should be in the asylum. Mr. Granger, I didn't say that. It's you who think I'm crazy. You've never liked me. For some reason, you're trying to tear me down. Well, we'll see, Mr. Hellman. We'll see. Wait a minute. I'll show you whether my words are illogical. I'll show you. Oh, calm down. I'm going to make you eat those words. I'm going to prove my theory, and then I'll bring it to a conclusion, and you'll know that my theory's on. Good night. Professor Rugsby, seething with resentment, rushes from the office, strides angrily down the street, muttering to himself, and goes home late for dinner. He finds a note from his wife, Myra, saying she's decided to go to the opera and will be home around 11.30. Then he gets some inspiration. He will find a subject for his experiment. So he goes to the bridge over the deep canyon.

The bridge calls suicide. And strangely enough, he hasn't long to wait. As he stands against the railing in the fog, a figure appears a few feet beyond, steadying the distance below. Wait a minute. That's very silly. Don't call me. Oh, no, I couldn't do that. I need you. Get away. It's 500 feet to those tracks below. Hard steel rails. Don't believe what you heard about not knowing what happened. Let loose. People don't always die instantly. They live in agony for minutes and sometimes for hours. It's a horrible death. I know. How do you know? I'm a doctor. Doctor? Yes. I can tell you much simpler ways, much less painful ways, and quicker. You're a nice-looking girl. An intelligent girl. Maybe after I've talked to you a while, you wouldn't want to do this at all. No. Maybe a few minutes' talk will change the entire picture for you. What could you do to help me? There's a motive back of your wanting to do this, and I'd like to know what it is. Nothing to do. Haven't you any relatives, any loved ones you'd like to do something for? Yes. Thank you.

Talk with me for a while. Maybe I can find a way to clear that up. You sound crazy to me. Oh, no. I may be many things, but I'm not crazy. All right, I'll talk to you. Where? My apartment. I might have known. No, no, no. I'm serious. I really want to talk to you. All right, I'll take it. Now, first, you know that you're a very pretty girl, don't you? Yeah, that doesn't always mean so much. You were the right man at my... That's what I thought. I found out it didn't mean a thing. Harder than it was because of the man. I knew it. Really? How did you get it? Well, I'm a student of psychology. A student? You're a little past student days, aren't you? No, I'm a writer, then. I write subjects on psychology. I'm Professor Arthur Rubsky. I see. And you want to know what makes me tick? You want to know the reason behind my actions? That's right. I'd like to know what happened to make you want to kill yourself. Suicide is a mental aberration, you know. I'd like to know what preceded the decision to destroy yourself, and also...

What you thought up until that moment I stopped you on a bridge. What little lesson? You told me you were not broke, but also you said you had some loved ones you'd like to do something for. I meant I wasn't broke to the point of being hungry. I had a few dollars. But you suggested help to someone in larger form. Yes, I did. Who was the loved one? My mother. You were her only means of support? You intend to kill yourself? Yes. That's being selfish, isn't it? Selfish? Yes, you're concentrating solely on self. Thanks, sir. What else? First law of human nature is self-preservation, right? Yes, sir. And the second law is the preservation of family. Yes. So you decide to deny the first law. You destroy yourself. And as a consequence, you deny the second. You leave your mother alone and in need. You indicate a form of insanity. What would be normal? Destroy the other person. The one who has done you wrong. Destroy him instead of yourself.

Have you hurt him? No. But he has hurt you, hurt you deeply. He's done the wrong, correct? Yes. Then the one who's done the wrong should be the one to suffer. You have no legal recourse. No, no, sorry. I guess you would kill yourself and let your poor mother suffer because of the wrong of another. Why shouldn't he be the one to suffer? I think you're right. Why shouldn't he? What happened? Why not tell me about it? Were you married? No. You never seem to find time to get around a marriage. What's your name? Gladys. Gladys Tanner. How long have you known him? Almost four years. Have you always thought he meant to marry? Yes. Until? Until three weeks ago. On July 1st, he had to leave town for a week on business. He said he was going to Kansas City. When he came back, he seemed too busy to see me. And a week ago, I found a snapshot along with several others in the desk at his home. May I see it? Certainly. It's a picture of a woman and another woman. But the picture was not taken in Kansas City. No?

It was taken on the beach in Atlantic City and it's dated by the finish of July 3rd. He didn't return. He's refused to see me. And yesterday he finally said he didn't care to see me anymore. So I better forget him. It isn't so easy, is that it? No. I figured I'd done something. I blame myself. Do you know the blonde woman in the snapshot? No. There must be a woman he's met recently. You've known him for five years. I don't think you're to blame. He's the one who's in the war. And he should be made to suffer. Huh? Were you ever going to kill yourself? Why should you? Kill him instead. He's ever crossed you. He deserves it. Let me go in a little deeper into the situation. Whenever a person has reached a conclusion... Sure you've made up your mind, Miss Tannery? Positive. Now, if you're careful, you won't be caught. But whether you are or not, I'm giving you this check for $1,000. It's made out of cash. It'll be sent to your mother only after the man's dead. Uh, write his name on this, Pat. There you are. Hmm.

I don't know what's happened with the newspapers. I'll withhold payments until I learn that you've gone through with it. It'll happen tonight. Very well. Are you sure you're determined? Absolutely. Nothing could stop me. Now, I'll tell you my reason for this. I'm a psychiatrist. I've had a theory that a person bent on suicide was akin mentally to a person bent on murder. And that the difference between the two was so slight that the suicidal desire could easily be changed to the homicidal desire. And that's what's happened to me? Exactly. Well, now that I know what you're getting at, suppose I change my mind again. Yeah, you won't. I know. Here's a small revolver. It'll fit easily into your purse. All you need is to wipe your fingerprints off and leave your gun near the body. Well, goodbye, Dr. Rugsby. Goodbye, Gladys. Good luck. I'm so glad I've believed Rugsby. I mean, start off to the house of her victims on the outskirts of town. Rugsby stands for a while lost in thought. Then takes his hat, steps into the street.

And 20 minutes later, he stops his car a block from Hellman's bungalow. Remember Hellman? The editor who ridiculed the professor's theory? Oh. Hello, Rugsby. Good evening, Hellman. I thought I'd drop out and have a little chat with you. Why this time of night? Eleven? Didn't think I was late for you. Oh. Come in. What's on your mind? I... I want to talk to you about my theory you ridiculed so damn much. My theory about suicide. I bet I'd prove it, didn't I? Yeah, but what are you getting at? It's going to be proved. My theory's going to be proved tonight. Go ahead and prove it. It isn't funny, Alvin. No? How in the world can you prove anything like that? What good will that do you? More than you'll ever know. I don't like you, Herman. I've never liked you. And I know you don't like me. I can't help that, Rooksey. What are you staring at? Someone here with you. Certainly not. That woman's a person that haven't... Well, I dropped by earlier this evening with a manuscript.

I must have forgotten. She's not here now. Of course not. I'll continue. I found a subject. A girl who was ready to commit suicide because a man had tossed her over for another woman. In a few hours, I was successful in changing her thoughts from suicide to homicide. And she's going to kill the man tonight. Take that. There may be a dozen murders tonight. Ah, but you'll know which one I mean. You'll know about this murder. What do you mean? Because I'm going to tell who the victim's going to be. You know who the intended victim is? Why don't you stop it? And prove my theory. You put the girl up to it.

You're insane, Roxy. You think so, Herman? No sane man would ever think of such a useless, senseless idea. I'm thinking about the victim. What did he learn? Who is the victim? Morton Hellman. What? Yes, you. Who is the girl? I know of no girl who'd want to kill me. Well, this one does. No, no. I wouldn't put it past you to hire somebody to do something like this. No, no. This girl's no fake. This girl's silly. Deadly silly. Who is she? I don't know. You're the only one I know who doesn't like me. You're the only one I know with a motive. But believe me, Rugsby, you'll not get away with it. You've probably hypnotized some poor woman, figuring she'd never remember what happened. Oh, Hellman, you underestimate me. Maybe I do underestimate your evil mind, but believe me... Put your hands up. Get away from that desk. I'll just take care of your gun, Hellman. When did you start carrying a gun, Rugsby? A gun? Don't be silly. This isn't a gun in my pocket. It's off my pipe. See?

What do you hear, Hellman? Nothing. I heard it, too. Sound on the porch. Well, I'll leave now. Back way. I'll put your gun in the kitchen. Don't look so anxious. I'll be very careful to remove all the fingerprints. You insane fool! Fancy. You. You, Hellman. You're going to help prove my theory. Good night. You devil. I'll have him locked up before he gets across town. Mr. Hellman. Through the patio door. What do you want? I wanted to talk to you. You sure that you're not under the influence of someone? What a strange question. What do you mean? That crazy professor. You've been hypnotized. It's just a magnet thing. And what are you doing here? I wanted to tell you something. Yeah? When you first indicated to me that you were through with me, I was terribly hurt. I thought all along that we were to be married. I couldn't understand. I tried to think of something I'd done to cause our breakup. I happened to find a snapshot in your desk. Snapshot? Take a look at it. Kansas City? No. Atlantic City, New Jersey? You and a blonde.

And the date is stamped on the back. Business trip. I just wanted you to know that you weren't so slick. I wanted you to know that I knew about the blonde. That I knew you'd mind. Now that you've told me, what good does it do you? A lot of good. First, I thought you came here intending to kill me. Goodbye, Morton. And good luck in your new venture. Thanks. What venture? This one. Gladys. Wish me luck. And mine.

And Gladys stands staring for a moment at the body. Then she wipes off the gun, drops it to the floor, takes the professor's check from her purse, steps to Hellman's desk, takes pen and paper, calmly writes a note, puts it with the check into an envelope, addresses it, hands it, turns out the lights, and steps quickly out the door and down the street. At the corner she pauses, drops the envelope in the mailbox, and disappears. Well, Professor Dugsy, there you are. You heard the shot. The perfect crime. You can go home now and go to sleep. Myra. Oh, Arthur. What are you doing asleep on the Davenport? Do you know what time it is? Must be afternoon, right? I've been waiting for you. Where have you been? I walked around downtown for a while. I got into club for a night, Captain. How's the opera? Oh, fair. Nothing to brag about. Who sang the lead? Oh, Captain.

He wasn't very good. He's a poor old fellow. A fellow? I thought they were doing I.E. tonight. No, they switched because someone was ill. I guess it's the same as staying at home. Have a night, Captain? No, thanks. I'm tired. I think I'll go to bed. I'll be along, President. Good night. Good night. Well, Professor, it's been a great day. A triumph for you. Your theory proved and nothing to be traced to you. Now, one perfect crime. He sits over his drink for a while, then turns out the lights and goes to bed. The night passes and morning comes. The professor rises cheerfully and prepares for breakfast. Now get it, Marv. Yes? Are you Professor Rugby? Yes. May I come in? I'd like to talk with you. Oh, of course. Uh, what is it? Is your wife in? Yes. I'd like to see her, too. Oh.

Who are you? I'm Lieutenant Davis, Detective Headquarters. What? What do you want? Will you call your wife? Why, certainly. My, uh... What's this all about? What is it, Arthur? This is Lieutenant Davis from Detective Headquarters. He says he wants to talk to us. Oh, really? What about? May I ask where you were last night, Mrs. Rugsby? Why, certainly. I went to the opera. What time did you get home? Oh, I imagine it was around 11 or shortly after. Were you at home last evening, Professor? Well, I was at the club and got home about 12.30. What's this all about? Do you know Morton Hellman? Certainly. What about him? He's been murdered. Murdered? Good Lord, when? Around midnight last night. They found him this morning. Terrible. I've known him for years. He was editor-in-chief of the company publishing my writings. I'm a psychologist, you know. Yes, I know. But what do you want to know from us? We weren't connected socially with Hellman. Just in business.

Did you know him, Mrs. Rugby? Yes, yes, I knew him, very slightly. Do either of you know of anyone who'd have reason to kill him? Oh, certainly not. Everyone thought highly of him. Did you ever know of a girl named Gladys Tanner? Gladys Tanner? No. Did you know of a Gladys Tanner, Mrs. Rugby? No. Who is she? She went with Hellman for several years. They were supposed to be engaged. For some reason, it blew up because of another woman. So what? Is this your purse, Mrs. Rugby? What? Oh, of course it is. That's the one I gave you last Christmas, Myra. Yes. I must have lost it downtown. Where did you find this, Lutheran? At Hellman's home. Hellman's home? Well, how in the world did he... Heavens, but how? He found it on the sofa. I can't imagine how it could get there. And this is the revolver that killed Hellman. Found on the floor beside him. No fingerprints on it, Oliver. What? May I see it? Oh, Myra, this is your gun.

I bought this for you two years ago when I went away on that lecture tour. Yes, I think it's mine, but it just doesn't make sense. Did you have the gun in your purse when you lost it last night? Well, perhaps I did. I'm so confused now, I can't believe it. Well, think, Margaret, think. This is terrible. I know, I know. Oh, dear, I feel ill. Did you ever fire this gun? Yes, once last year up in the mountains. I wanted to see how it worked. Ever reload it? Why, no, I didn't. When did you see it live? Oh, yesterday. And you've never reloaded it? No, I've never reloaded it. Just didn't think about it. Maybe I did put it in my purse. I don't know. And whoever found the purse may have used the gun to... What? I just can't seem to think of... This gun misfired on the first two shots. The other three killed Hellman. This is the most amazing piece of coincidence I've ever heard.

Why would my wife want to do such a thing? Why should she go to Hellman? She hardly knew him. Are you sure about that, Professor? Of course I'm sure. Well, I'm sorry to say I think she's lying. What? Oh, this is ridiculous. This is going to be a shock to you, Professor, but here is a snapshot we found on Hellman's desk taken in Atlantic City last July. Good heavens. This is you, Mara. You and Hellman. You were at your mother's in Florida in July. Mara, look at me. What does this mean? I can't. I can't. I can't believe such a thing. It just doesn't seem possible. May I have the purse? The gun and photo? Thanks. I'm sorry, but I'll have to take her down to headquarters. I didn't kill him. I didn't. I wouldn't. I loved him. Better put yourself together, Mara. We'll have to go with him. And if we want photos and fingerprints... Better get ready, Mara. No, I can't do it.

Certainly looks bad for her. I'm afraid it does. Looks like an open and shut case to me. Will you come along, too, Professor? Certainly. Now, it's several hours later at police headquarters. They've taken fingerprints of Professor Rugsby and his wife, Myra, and questioned them both. And Rugsby is just about to leave with a gloating smile on his face when an officer steps in and speaks softly to Lieutenant Davis. Lieutenant. Yes, Rankin? I stayed at Professor Rugsby's place, as you said. Look, thing's over. A few minutes ago, this special delivery letter came for the professor. This'll knock your eye out. Read it. Well, I'll be fits perfectly with the handwriting we were trying to make out on Hellman's blotter. Uh, professor, I'd like you to read a letter sent special delivery to you a few minutes ago. Postmarked last night. Read it. Dear Professor Rugsby, you're very wet to a certain degree. You'll convince me I should kill him before that.

Garnier gave me misfire twice, I almost... Then, as I looked at him on the floor, the old feeling of self-destruction came back. I'm going ahead with my original plan. Here's your check. I won't need it. Besides, I haven't a mother. She's dead. Better luck next time, Professor. And, Lieutenant, half hour ago, they found her body beneath Suicide Bridge. Well, it all worked out beautifully for the professor, up to the point where he changed his plan. And that was at the moment that Gladys Tanner showed him the snapshot of Hellman and the blonde girl on the beach at Atlantic City. The professor wasn't really going to let the girl kill Hellman. But when he saw the snapshot and recognized the blonde as his wife, Myra, he started to change. And when he visited Hellman before the shooting and recognized his wife's purse, he was doubly determined to see Hellman killed and place the blame on his wife, Myra. Yes.

It would have been a perfect crime, perhaps. But he sacrificed his fairy for revenge. The whole thing backfired and caught him. The girl wished him better luck next time. There won't be a next time. Not for the professor. I know. Well, well, well. It looks like Professor Rugby's obsession for scientific experimentation melted away before the more ordinary urge for revenge. It goes to show that we are all human, doesn't it? Or does it? Maybe the whistler knows the answer to that one, too. Don't go, please. I want you to hear about our next performance at the Mystery Playhouse. Come with me to the green room where our players are rehearsing. Come. Robert, before leaving the theater tonight, someone told me that you and Julie Winthrop are going to be married. Me too? Yes, we'll be married in two weeks, right after my wife gets a decree in Reno.

You must not marry Julie. Not marry Julie? Who are you to tell me what I can do? I know Julie well enough. I also know you. That's why you must not marry her. South, it might be better for you to mind your own business. Julie and I are in love with each other. No, you're not. She's fascinated by your good looks. She's impressed by your fame. But she does not love you. Now, look here. We may be old friends, but after all I'm going to, I... Wait a moment. I get it now. You're in love with her yourself. I? I'm in love with Julie. No, we are just friends. Friends? You're madly in love with her. That's why you came here tonight, isn't it? No. Friends. Why are you laughing? You, in love with a girl like Julie. Why should my love make you laugh? Oh, so you admit it, huh? Oh, right, I do. Why is it so funny? Do you think she'd have you? You? A clown. Ugly. Clumsy.

in love with Julie. And why not? Why not? You're laughing. Nothing. Look at yourself. You don't know. Might be worth listening to. How do you think that little man sounds familiar? I must have seen him in pictures. Anyway, the scene you just heard is an innocent mystery. And we'll be honest before. This is Peter Lawrence closing the doors of the mystery playhouse. Good night. Sleep tight.

The Armed Forces Radio Service.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑