Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
The Whistler artwork

From the The Whistler collection

That Cutlerville Affair

Episode 624May 30, 195423 min 54 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 19 min to read

I'm the Whistler, and I know many things, for I walk by night. I know many strange tales, hidden in the hearts of men and women who have stepped into the shadows. Yes, I know the nameless terrors of which they dare not speak. And now, the Whistler's strange story, that Cutlerville affair. The night train from Los Angeles, chattering the stillness of the countryside, had just raced over the North River Bridge. Now began to whine serpent-like along its mountain roadbed as David Talbot, sitting in the club car, folded the evening newspaper in his lap and looked at his watch. Then he leaned back in his chair and sighed a happy, contented sigh. Suddenly he tensed. He stared as a slender, attractive blonde and her male companion entered the car. Quickly he picked up the newspaper again to shield his face. But he was too late. Dave!

Dave Talbot, of all people. Nora, this is a surprise. Imagine running into you again after all these years. How are you, Dave? Oh, just fine, Nora, fine. Still looking as handsome as ever. Oh, you've never met my husband, Frank Williams? Frankie, this is Dave Talbot, an old friend. Yeah, how are you, Dave? Nice to know you. Mr. Williams. Make that Frankie, huh? Everybody calls me Frank. Dave and I used to work for Jack Skelly years ago, darling. Skelly, huh? The private eye? That's right. Jack used to say that we were the best operatives he'd ever had. That's so. Well, what do you know? You, uh, you mind if we join you, Dave? Oh, please do. Oh, here you are, Nora. Oh, thank you. Oh, this is simply wonderful, Dave, running into you again. Simply wonderful. Buy a round of drinks, Frankie. You hadn't expected ever to see Nora again, had you, David? But now that you have, it's brought back a flood of memories. Unpleasant memories.

Yes, your past has caught up with you, hasn't it? And you're disturbed, uneasy. Hardly listen to her as she goes on chatting about the good old days when the two of you worked for Skelly's detective agency. Remember the time, Dave, that Skelly put us on the Cosgrove case? Cosgrove? You know, the old gentleman looking for his daughter? Surely you remember. Oh, yeah, yeah. He was a funny little guy, Frankie. But loaded with dough. That so? Mm-hmm. His wife had divorced and... Years before, taking their child out west with her. Somehow he lost track of them while he was in Mexico. What'd he do, find a nice juicy gold mine? No. No, he and a partner had gone into some sort of business. Do you remember what it was, Dave? No. No, not exactly. He had his fingers in several different things. Anyway, Frankie, he came back with around 200 grand. One to find his daughter so he could leave the money to her when he passed on. Ah, lucky gal. Maybe she wasn't.

You see, we never did find him. Did we, Dave? No. No, we didn't. Too bad. Let me see. Ann Cosgrove would be about 25 or 26 by now. That was her name, wasn't it, David? Ann? Yeah, that's right, Ann. Look, you two, I'm sorry to have to break away, but my stop is coming up. So, Nora, Frankie? I guess I'll say goodbye. Oh, not goodbye, Dave. We'll all see one another again, won't we? Why, sure, sure. When you're out in the city, why, just give us a call. We're in the Los Angeles phone book. Do that, Dave. Yes, of course I will, Nora. Of course. Dave! Oh, Dave! Hi! Oh, hello, darling. The train was late. One whole minute. Well, never mind that. How have you been feeling? I'm better. Sure.

Well, how'd the deal go? Oh, just fine. I sold it up. Oh, that's wonderful. Darling, I'm so proud of you. I'm sort of proud of myself, the way I handled it. That property sale will net us a nice little commission. The company bought the entire seven acres? Uh-huh. Got to start building as soon as possible. You know, Couplerville should be mighty proud of you, too. Well, it isn't every day a big chemical company decides to build a million-dollar plant. David, you've been doing wonderfully well in the few years you've been in the real estate business. Oh, just... Been lucky, I guess. No, darling, it's more than that. You worked hard. You like what you're doing. And people like you. Well, I like Cutlerville. And now, Mrs. Talbot, how about feeding your husband, huh? I'm famished. Of course, darling. Dinner's all ready and waiting. Honey, sure you don't need any help? No. I'll clear the things off the table. You go on in the den and relax.

We'll have a coffee in there. Okay. Oh, who could that be? Expecting anyone, Nora? Mrs. Chambers, to pick up some sewing I have for her. But she couldn't be this early. See what it is, David. I'll take the dishes into the kitchen. All right. Hello, Dave. Nora. Well, hiya, boy. Couldn't help noticing the town woman when you got off the train, darling. It was so friendly and warm, so after you left the train, we decided to get off, too. Who is it, darling? And what a charming little home. Cozy. Yes, real cozy. Yes, sir. Always thought I'd like to settle down in a nest like this someday. White picket fence out the front, roses around the door. You know, the works. Oh, this must be the little woman, eh? Hello. Oh, darling, I'd like you to meet some old friends of mine, Nora and Frank Williams. Hello, Anne. It is Anne, isn't it? Yes, that's right, Mrs. Williams. Make that Nora.

And this is Frankie. Well, hiya. As I was telling Dave, we were just passing through. We decided to drop by and say hello. I hope we're not intruding. Oh, no, of course not. We were about to have our coffee in the den. Won't you join us? Well, fine, fine. This way, mister... Frankie. That's the ticket, Annie. Yes, sirree. Well, Dave, it looks like my hunch was right. Nora, what's the idea? Always were a pretty good private eye, Dave. That's the way I figured it. Not only found Ann Cosgrove, the missing heiress, but you married her, too. What you feared most has happened, hasn't it, David? That someday someone would learn the truth about your coming to Cutlerville. And now Nora Williams and all acquaintance has guessed the reason. Knows why you married Ann. You're on edge and tense. Take little part in the conversation as you sit in the den with your wife, Ann, Nora, and her husband, Frank. Fortunately, Nora says nothing of your past association with Skelly's detective agency.

All of your part in the search launched by Ann's father in an effort to locate him. Finally, you breathe a sigh of relief as Frank gets to his feet and glances at his watch. Hello, baby. If we're going to catch the train... Oh, is it that time already? Since we just got here. Must you rush off so soon? Yeah, afraid so. Got to be in farming in the morning. Oh, really, Ann, darling? We'd love to stay, but we can't. Some other time, though. We've so much to chat about. Haven't we, Davis? Yeah, that's right, Nora. Oh, uh, Dave, you mind if I use your phone? I'd like to call a cab. Oh, don't bother. David will drive you down to the depot. Wouldn't want to put you out, Dave. No trouble. Now, you three run along. I'm expecting my sewing woman, so I'd better stay here. I've so enjoyed meeting you, Nora, Frank. Oh, thank you, darling. And we've looked forward to the pleasure of meeting you for such a long time. Haven't we, Frank? Yeah, that's right, Nora, baby. We sure have.

You're being rather quiet, Dave. Am I? Well, he's probably got a lot on his mind, Nora. Puzzled, maybe. Well, I'm sort of puzzled myself, David. Here you are driving a three-year-old car, residing in a modest little cottage. Oh, it's nice enough, but hardly what I expected. I thought we'd find you living in style and keeping with that nice fat bank account. Yeah, that's right. How come, Dave? I just don't happen to have a nice fat bank account. That's all. Oh. David, come now. Ann's father died over a year ago. Surely you must have arranged for his lawyer to find her. No, I haven't arranged anything. Really? Tell me more. Sure, I'll tell you the whole story. I had a plan all worked out when I came to Cutlerville and I carried it out. I met and married Ann Cosgrove in what the locals called a whirlwind courtship. Go on, David. This is interesting.

And I figured I'd wait six months or so and then fix it so that Ann would learn about her father and the money. I just never got around to it. And why not? Because something went wrong with my fine plan within a few months of the marriage. Ann became ill. Very ill. Almost died. That's when I realized how much I really loved her. Oh, no. Did you hear that, Frankie? The man is telling us he fell in love with a girl. I don't expect you to believe me, Nora, but it's true. Ann is different from any girl I've ever met. The clinging vine? fragile, the helpless type. They can really get their hooks into a man, can't they, Frankie? Yeah, not like you can, Nora. You're my kind. Thank you, darling. Go on, David. Tell us more. I'm afraid there's nothing more to tell. Here's the depot. A few people are going to catch a train. Oh, we've got a few minutes yet. Go on, David. Tell us how you began to feel like a heel about the whole thing.

marrying the little doll for her money. I felt exactly like a heel. Well, you've done nothing about the inheritance, eh? Just tossed it out the window. All for love, eh? My, my, my. Well, now I've heard everything. You've heard the truth, every word of it. Would Ann believe you? I think she would. But you're not certain, are you? I wonder how she'd react to that affair in Seattle you were mixed up in a few years ago. Remember, David? The little widow, Marsha? Marsha Winston? Uh-huh. A skeleton in the lad's family closet, eh? Something I don't know about? The widow and David were engaged to be married, Frankie. They met a charming couple. Dave with his looks and the widow with her money. Of course, she had to have money. All Dave's girlfriends have money. Oh, naturally. It made her so attracted to David. And she was so smitten, she even went as far as to change her will. Leaving everything to Davey here, eh? Right.

David planned it. Now look, Nora. And then a terrible thing happened, Frankie. Before the wedding could take place, the widow accidentally took an overdose of sleeping pills. Died. Also according to plan, Dave? You know I had nothing to do with that, Nora. Well, the courts decided that way, but the newspapers seemed to feel that your acquittal was a travesty on justice. Well, got off the hook and got the cash too, eh? Well, unfortunately, Dave didn't get a cent, Frankie. What? What's that? No. No, you see, it turned out that the widow had had a change of heart. A week before she died, she changed her will again. But Dave didn't know about that when she accidentally took the overdose of sleeping pills. Did you, Dave? You mean that Davey here didn't collect a single sou? Not one. After all that trouble? My, my, what a staggering blow. Makes an interesting story.

Doesn't it, Frankie? Oh, very. That must be our train, baby. Don't want to miss it. Thanks for the lift, Frankie. Yes. Thanks for everything, Dave. Just forget it. I'll be seeing you. Yes. We'll be seeing you again. Real soon. You're uneasy, jittery in the days that follow, aren't you, David? Everything you told Nora is the truth, isn't it? But you wonder how your wife, Ann, would react to the story of the Seattle affair. Especially the news stories of your tribe. New stories you're sure Nora has. Stories you're certain would shatter Anne's belief in your integrity and sincerity and shock her so severely the strain might be too great. Fragile and sensitive, Anne's well on the road to recovery now, isn't she? And you don't want anything to interfere. Then as several weeks go by and there's no word from Nora, you begin to breathe a lot easier. One afternoon as you return home from the office, Anne comes down the walk to meet you.

Well, hello, darling. I thought I'd close the office up early and... Ann, is something wrong? David, I've... I've just had a visitor. Oh? A Mr. Berwyn. An attorney representing my father's estate. Your father? You remember I told you I hadn't seen him since I was a child? I didn't know where he was? Yes. Well, Mr. Berwyn brought me the news, David. Father's dead. He died last year. Oh, Ann, honey, I'm sorry. I'm very sorry. I knew so very little about him, David. Somehow I wish I could have seen him again. I know, darling. I'll have to go out to the city tomorrow. Mr. Berwyn is anxious to settle things. It seems father left a considerable amount of money. He's willed everything to me. It's all Nora's doing, isn't it, David? Yes. She told Mr. Berwyn of Anne's identity and whereabouts because she's anxious for you to share Anne's inheritance. And you know why. Yes.

Nora has plans, hasn't she? Plans to blackmail you because of what she knows. The following day, you and Ann drive up to the lawyer's office in the city. The meeting is brief. The formality is over quickly. And as the two of you leave the office... David, there's something wrong. It has to do with the money. You're a wealthy woman, darling. The money is as much yours as it is mine. No, no. No, it isn't that. It's yours. All yours. But, David. When we get back to Cutlerville, I want you to open a separate account at the bank. Darling, that's silly. No, dear, it isn't. But I thought we could invest a moment. Ann, listen to me. If you want to invest, why don't you have a talk with Carter down at the bank? Let him handle the matter for you. But, David, I don't understand why. Because it's your money. I don't want any part of it. David. No, I... Ann, I'm sorry, but please do as I ask. Won't you?

Well, all right, if that's the way you want it. Yes, David, that's exactly the way you want it, isn't it? It's a move on your part to block Nora and her plans, to keep the money out of reach, and you're certain it'll work. You're certain of something else, too, aren't you? Yes, and it happens a few days later as you walk down Cutlerville's main street. The yellow convertible pulls up at the curb. Well, Nora, just passing through again? Yes, I dropped by to see Ann and she informed me of her recent inheritance. I was thrilled, of course, weren't you? Did Ann tell you what she plans to do with the money? Oh, it seems that it's all tied up by some friend at the bank. He's going to see that she invested properly. That's right. And I don't have a thing to do with it. Really? Your idea, of course. Did Ann say it was? No, but I have a hunch. How clever of you, David. Suffer. What does that mean? Well, it's like the affair in Seattle.

Same thing all over again. And certain ants made out her will to you, leaving everything to you. The lawyer told you? No, David. Ann did. A few minutes ago. And now that you stand to inherit her money, I hope for your sake she doesn't take an overdose of sleeping pills. After that Seattle situation, it would look bad for you. Real bad. Nora isn't going to give up, is she, David? No, you're certain she's going to do something and... You're sure she'll give the matter some very careful thought before deciding what. The weeks go by. Tense, anxious weeks of waiting and wondering what Nora has planned. Then one night as you return home, you find the house in darkness. You remember that Ann had a late afternoon appointment at the doctor's office in the city. You settle down in the den with a highball and look through the evening paper. Oh, yes. What is it, Sheriff? I'm phoning from the hospital, David. There's been an accident. An accident? Yes.

It's Ann. You better come right over. Now, take it easy, David. Forrester said she's had a close call, but she'll be all right. How did it happen, Sheriff? Where? Oh, on the old Crown Hill Road. Another car sideswiped hers. Ann lost control, ran off the bank. Some youngsters out on a hayride saw the whole thing happen. They claimed the other car ran Ann off the road deliberately. What? It just kept right on going. It was a yellow convertible. Yellow convertible, David. Yes. Nora Williams drives the yellow convertible, doesn't she? Inside the hospital room, you stand at Ann's bedside. Look down at her lying still and quiet. They've done this to her, haven't they, David? Nora and Frank. They tried to kill Ann because they felt certain that with her death, you would inherit everything and then pay them liberally for their silence. A rushing, beating wave of cold rage engulfs you.

And you're trembling with wild hatred as you turn and hurry out of the hospital. Back at the house, you make up your mind. You decide to make certain neither Frank nor Nora will ever hurt Ann or anyone else again. You take the .45 automatic out of your dresser drawer. Flip it into your pocket. Then you pick up the phone. Call the depot. Depot. Oh, Jess, this is Dave Talbot. Mr. Talbot. Now, listen, Jess, I've got to get to Los Angeles right away. Isn't there a train due shortly? Yep. One due at 8.20. But it don't stop here unless I flounder. At 8.40, I can just make it just like it now, will you? Sure thing, Mr. Thomas. A moment later, you rush out of the house. The night air is cool and crisp. And as you walk the sixth block toward the depot, you're thinking things out more and more clearly now. The anger, the hatred you felt back at the hospital subsides a little. As your thoughts turn to ants, you begin to realize that what you planned to do is all wrong.

Even though you're sure you'll lose Anne's love, her belief in you, and your reputation and career in Cutlerville, if the story of your previous situation in Seattle is made public, you still can't take the law in your own hand, can you, Dave? No. You've got to give Anne the best protection you can, and you're sure that she'll suffer less in the long run from learning all about you than she would if you went into Los Angeles and took care of Nora and Frank in the manner you feel they deserve. You're only a short distance from the depot when you reach a decision. You turn into the main street and hurry into the sheriff's office. Ah, David. What are you doing here? Sheriff, I'd like a word with you. Why, sure. Have a chair, David. And tell me what's on your mind. You've made your decision, haven't you, David? Yes, you're going to tell the sheriff everything. Why you came to Cutterville and married Ann. And you'll explain how later you changed your mind about the money.

How Nora Williams forced your hand. How she tried to kill Ann. Yes, David. You've got to tell the whole story, even if it means losing Ann's love. It's a chance you have to take to protect her from any further harm. But before you can tell the sheriff anything, he's interrupted by a rather lengthy phone call. Yeah. Yeah, I understand. I understand. Uh-huh. All right, Sergeant. I'll be right over. I'm sorry, Dave. I'm going to have to leave. Something's happened. You remember that yellow convertible I was talking about? Oh, yes, of course. Well, he put out a bulletin on the car right after Ann's accident. That was the state trooper I was talking to. Spotted the car about 30 miles up the highway and chased it back in this direction. Oh? Well, go on, Sheriff. When the convertible reached Cutterville here, it left the main highway, turned up into the cliff road. If they were really hitting it up, the car skidded on a curve, crashed into the ravine. Uh-huh. Both occupants of the car were killed instantly. Killed? Mm-hmm.

Both been identified as Nora and Frank Williams. It's too bad. They'd probably be alive and in police custody by this time if they hadn't been forced off the main highway. What do you mean, forced off? The main highway was blocked off at the depot here by the 820 train waiting to pick up some passengers. The 820? I was the one who called Jess to have the train stopped. I was the one. What? What's that, Dave? Nothing, Sheriff. Nothing? Well, I'll be back shortly, Dave, if you care to wait here. No. No, I guess I won't wait, Sheriff. What I wanted to tell you about, well, it isn't important anymore. Featured in tonight's story were Bill Foreman as the Whistler, Larry Dobkin, Michael Ann Barrett, Julie Dennis...

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑