Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
The Whistler artwork

From the The Whistler collection

The Prosecutor

Episode 652December 12, 195429 min 58 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 20 min to read

Armed Forces Radio invites you to sit back and enjoy another strange story by The Whistler. I am The Whistler, and I know many things, for I walk by night. I know many strange tales hidden in the hearts of men and women who have stepped into the shadows. Yes, I know the nameless terrors of which they dare not speak. And now, The Whistler Strange Stories. The Prosecutor. The courtroom was tense now. Assistant District Attorney Philip Graham was beginning to summarize for the prosecution. In the case of the people versus Thomas Anderson, the thrill of success was in his speech as he moved in for the kill. In addition to the fact that circumstance links the defendant irrevocably to the killing, he still persists in his refusal to testify.

still offers no explanation as to his whereabouts on the night in question. Solely on the basis of possible self-incrimination. And you were right, weren't you, Philip? Less than ten minutes after the jury retired, they walked back in with a verdict you knew was coming. And Tom Anderson was on his way to the cell in condemned role. But that wasn't all, Philip. No, far from it. Most important was what your colleagues were saying as they clustered around you. Well, this will put you to the top of the heap, Phil. You'll have that mahogany desk, old man, in the Hall of Justice. And there'll be a brass nameplate, Philip B. Graham, District Attorney. You betcha. With this conviction, you can't miss. And they were right, weren't they, Philip? The voters made it official two weeks later. And only you know what kind of a job you really did. Yes, it isn't easy to convict a man when you know in your heart that he's completely innocent.

But you're not thinking about that at the victory celebration. There's too much else going on. Congratulations, back-slapping, important people. And above all, a beautiful brown-haired girl with clear blue eyes and a quick, easy smile. I, uh, didn't quite get that name. Corinne Scott. Oh, Mr. Graham. How wonderful to actually meet you. Not at all. The pleasure's mine. I know you've heard it many times, Mr. Graham, but... Well... I thought you were magnificent at the Anderson trial. No, I was only doing my job. A public prosecutor. My, it's almost like playing safe. Now, wait a minute. I mean the idea of holding the fate of a fellow human being in the palm of your hand. It's a little frightening. It's such a responsibility. Yes, it is a responsibility.

Of course we make pretty certain of our facts before we step into a courtroom and start making accusations. Of course you do. Old American custom, you know, a man is innocent until proven guilty. But just think, Mr. Graham, in this case, the jury was about to let that killer go free. Why, if it hadn't been for you... Yes, I, uh, I had a feeling about Tommy Anderson from the very beginning. It must have been a very hard fight. It wasn't easy. Of course, if a man knows what he's doing and... And where he's going. What do you mean? Well, I guess I... I admire ambitious men, Mr. Graham. I admire them very much. I do, Miss Scott. I probably shouldn't say this, but... But you do. Well, I think this is a silly way to celebrate anything so important as becoming district attorney. A stealthy reception of a lot of politicians. Now, if I were running things... Yes.

I'd get rid of the holidays. I'd review the pages of a tool, the little restaurant I know, where the steaks are heavenly and there's vintage wine, crepes and that. And champagne? There's Clicquot 1940 and all that. How does it sound? You're a pretty good salesman. Well, that's all. That's what I do. And when would you do? Oh, tomorrow night, perhaps. Day about nine. And you know I'm a married man, of course. What's that got to do with a victory celebration? Well, if that's the way you look at it. Nine o'clock tomorrow night. All right. Well, Philip, you know it's a foolish thing to do. But there's something in the way she looks up at you and smiles that makes it all sound very reasonable. And you forget about everything else. Your wife, your son David in medical school, his good friend, Professor Bentley, who thinks you're the greatest man who ever lived.

At 8.15 the following night, you're standing before the mirror in your bedroom, adjusting your tie. Karim is lovely, isn't he? And as you put on your dinner jacket, you're thinking of the first light in the morning. Oh, there you are, Dad. Here he is, Professor. Almost gave you up, Dad. Thought you weren't coming. Hello, Dad. You got the culprit at last. I told you you wouldn't walk out on us, Dave. Hurry up, Dad. We're a half hour late as it is. What do you mean we're late? Say, what's the idea of the dinner jacket, Mr. Duff? Yeah, there's nothing formal about it. Wait a minute. What's this all about? Huh? You going somewhere? Are we going somewhere? Dad, you didn't forget. Forget what? Tonight. You promised you'd go. I promised I'd go where? Don't you remember? The faculty's having a father and son night. Professor Bentley's in charge. Good Lord, I did forget. Oh, I know, Mr. Graham. You're a busy man. Dad, you've never forgotten before.

You've come with us every year now. I'm awfully sorry, son. Professor, I just can't make it. What is it? Where are you going? Well, it's a committee dinner, son. Very important. I simply can't get out of it. But, Dad. I said I can't get out of it. Let it go at that, will you? All right, Dad. I'm sorry. And that was the beginning, Philip. You didn't know it then, but you made a choice that night. A choice between your family, your home, and Corinne. And as you and Corinne continued to meet secretly during the weeks that followed, it began to worry you. Not your family, of course. It was your position. Your reputation. Oh, Philip. I think it's wonderful. All you've accomplished. Corinne, I, uh... There's something I think... You don't have to say it, Philip. I know what you're thinking. You're wondering when I'm going to tell you I want out. When I'm going to tire.

Loving a man I can never be seen with. Corinne, dear. Isn't that it? Frankly, yes. Please don't think about it anymore. I don't want to break up your home. I never will, darling. Because it would hurt the very thing I admire you for most of all. Your career. That's all. Well, Philip, you can have it all now. Your family, your career, and Corinne. She's right, isn't she? The one all-important thing in your life is that nameplate on your desk. Philip B. Graham, District Attorney. And you know now that you'll never have to choose between Matt and Corinne. And then one night, a few weeks later, you return unexpectedly from a business trip and decide to drop in to see her before going home. As you walk up the steps out of the porch, you hear voices. Disturbing voices.

That is just the way I feel about it. You can't tell me everything's over between us. It's got to be over. I can't turn my love off just like that. As you grab the handle of the front door, a rage wells up inside you, gripping your stomach, rising in your throat and bursting in your brain like a shell. Open this door. Why did you come here? Never mind that. Who were you talking to? Oh, Philip, be quiet. Don't lie to me. Where is he? Philip. Tell me I heard someone in here. Where is he hiding? Oh, please, Philip. Get out of my way. You step past. The closet door is partly open. And as you walk toward it, Corinne steps to the light switch. The room goes dark. Turn on that light. There you are. I knew it. I keep struggling with him in the darkness. You realize he's too powerful for you. He forces you back against the table. Your hand lights on a heavy metal bookend. In a blind rage, you swing it high. Now do it. Better turn on the lights, Corinne. Yes.

Hurry up. All right. Oh, Philip, why did you do it? He didn't mean anything to me. Nothing at all. He came here because he found out about us. He wanted me to stay away from you. Well, get some water quickly. It's no use. He's dead. Oh, no. You killed Professor Bedford, your son's best friend. What's this, Alfred Hotkick? Does the name John McHale mean anything to you? Perhaps it should, and I shall tell you why. Four hundred years ago, it was only Curl who was a respected scholar and diplomat. He wrote many learned articles and compiled a dictionary of the French language. Quite appropriately, his own name came to be part of most later dictionaries. Well, you see, while Monsieur Curl was serving as ambassador to Lisbon, He became fascinated by a strange plant that had been brought over from the new land of America. When he returned to his own country in 1560, he took some specimens of the plant with him. And in this manner, he introduced tobacco to France. Nicot's countrymen began to associate his name with the smoke-producing leaves. But the older Indian word, which sounded like...

tobacco became more common. Nickel, however, was not completely left out. His name lives on in nicotine, the poisonous drug in a plant he introduced to France. So there you have the moral of my story. Beware of those who would name something after you. Should it be the wrong thing, You may find your good name. Boys. Well, Phillips, you never expected anything like this. This couldn't be happening to you. It's all so horrible, so fantastic. For weeks now, your association with Corinne Scott has seemed so completely wonderful. Now, with the suddenness of the jealous rage that spurred your wild action there in the dark room, a beautiful dream has turned into a nightmare. And Professor Bentley, gentle, friendly Professor Bentley, Your son David's friend lies dead at your feet. As you stand there, son, looking down at what you've done, you're vaguely aware that Corinne has come forward and picked up the heavy bookend you used. You sink down into a chair as she moves about, straightening things up, scarcely looking at you. Slowly, you lower your hands from your face and look up at her. Corinne. Corinne, what are we going to do? You killed him, Philip.

It's still an innocent man who did nothing more than come here to ask me to stay away from him. I know that. As soon as the light went on and I saw who it was, I knew why he was here. Oh, Corinne, Professor Bentley was such a good friend to my son, to me. What am I going to say? How can I explain? You wouldn't have to explain if you could get him out of here, Phillips. What? If he was found somewhere else, maybe miles from here. Corinne, would you help me do that? Yes, Phillips. I would. I never knew anyone could be so devoid. So much in love with him. I'm not doing it because I love you, Philip. What? Because I don't. I never have. Lynn, what are you talking about? I love you, Philip. I despise you and everything you've ever stood for. Have you lost your mind? Oh, the man of stone is crumbling. What's the matter, Philip? You're shaking. Shaking like a man in a death house. You're scared and bewildered, just like Tommy Anderson up there in the state penitentiary. Anderson? Tommy Anderson?

What do you know about him? I know that he was innocent, Philip. And so do you. I know that you put in her ears and condemned Roe because it made you a district attorney. I don't know what you're saying. And I don't see what it has to do with you. It has everything to do with it, Philip. Everything in the world. Because that's what Tommy Anderson means to me. What? I know you'd be surprised. You see, Philip, you're not the prosecutor on the case anymore. I am. You mean you planned it? You got the professor... No, not the professor. I had nothing to do with his coming here. I simply intended to involve you in a scandal, Philip. Or rather, a threatening scandal. And then... Then I was going to give you a choice. A choice of being ruined through disgrace... Or of telling the truth about Tommy Andrews. Right? Exactly. Now you have two alternatives, Philip. You can either free Tommy or stand trial for murder. But it's impossible.

I can't go back on what I've said about Anderson, not without... Not without admitting you've produced false evidence against him. I'd be thrown out of office in 24 hours. Is that worse than the gas chamber? Is that the choice you're giving me, Corinne? That's it, Philip. You haven't long to make up your mind. The neighbors should be coming home any minute now. They might get curious if they saw a body being carried around. Don't talk about it. I'll do what you say, Corinne. Where's Professor Bentley's car? He said he parked in the next block. He didn't want to be seen. I'll go get him. I'll go with you. You don't have to. I'll come back. I'm sure you'll come back. Because, you see, while I was taking a look around here, I hid that bookend. The one with your fingerprints all over it. I'm not missing a bit, Arnold. I can't afford to. Tommy Anderson's life depends on it. Shall we go? Yes. You find the professor's car a block away. Run it into the drive alongside the duplex.

Corinne helps you carry the professor's body out of the house to the car, warns you to call her soon, and returns to the apartment. In the next half hour, you live your life over, don't you, Philip? Driving grimly through the night, not knowing exactly where you're going. Trying to stay on the darkest streets until you reach the edge of town. The university looms up ahead, a big slumbering shadow. And you decide there's no better spot than Professor Bentley's own campus. You run the car in beneath the clump of trees, turn off the motor, wipe away your fingerprints, and sign up. Some distance from the campus, you swing onto a trolley car and get off 20 minutes later and walk a few blocks to your home. Not much hope for sleep, is there, Philip? Nothing to do but wait for the axe to fall. The minutes of morning papers hit the streets. University Professor Slane, extra, extra.

Police offer the theory that the killing might be a gangland reprisal against District Attorney Philip Graham, whose home the slain professor often visits. Recent efforts by the Graham regime to rid the city of gangster domination are known to have caused threatening talk in many quarters, as City Hall spokesman said today. While Graham himself could not be reached... Hello, Paul. Hello, Matt. Anything to wish there was? The boys have been out at 48 hours now without a rest. You're not giving up, are you? You know me better than that. The day I give up, I'll resign as police commissioner. You know what the professor meant to you and your boy, Phil? We'll get the guy I did it with that takes us 20 years. Oh. Scott called him. Wait a minute. I told you. But... All right, put her on. Hello, Philip. You called at a bad time. I'm busy with the police commissioner. Go ahead, Phil. Don't mind me.

I've waited two days now. That's all I intend to wait. I want a signed statement about Tommy. Uh, look, I'll have to see you first. I'm not going to wait any longer. It had better be tonight. Uh, all right, tonight. Make it ten. All right, ten. And I wouldn't be late if I were you. No, no, of course. Goodbye. Appointments, favors, business as usual. What do you think I am, anyway? Well, Tony, I know, Phil. Well, I better get back and see if the boys did anything with the one lead we've got. What's that? A girl? A girl. We think the professor had a date with a girl last night. That dame who was paid to lure him into the trap. You mean on the campus? Nah, he wasn't killed on the campus. We knew that from the first. He was probably murdered in the girl's apartment. Ah, I see. They're checking every movie made that night. We'll find her if she's alive. What do you mean by that? Well, she's a pretty important girl.

They're both our side and theirs. I wouldn't be surprised to find her in the river one of these mornings. See you later, Phil. And you're thinking about the girl as he talks to you, aren't you, Philip? Of what she told you that terrible night in her living room. That you have two alternatives, Philip. You can either flee Tommy or stand trial for murder. But there's another choice now, isn't there? Yes, it's been done before. The usual disappearance of the key witness with all the gangster trimmings. They'll never question it for a moment. At five minutes of ten, as you walk onto the porch of Corinne's house for the first time since the murder, you've made a correct decision. You're going to kill her. Then you're right on time, Philip. I'm always on time. Well, it won't take long. I didn't quite understand what you meant this afternoon about discussing it. There's nothing to discuss. I wanted a signed affidavit that you sent Tommy Anderson up on manufactured evidence. I'll be only too happy to walk out of your life.

It's very simple. It's not that simple, Corinne. I want that bookend for one thing. Naturally. What about your signed statement? Here you are. I wrote it at the office this afternoon. It's all there. Hmm. Certainly is. What about the bookend? Just a minute. I'm enjoying this. You know, Philip, I'd never believe you could be so cruel. Where is it? It's there on the table in plain sight. You didn't hide it. Not that one. I hid the mate to itself very conveniently, just in case you decided to steal it, in a drawer under a pile of papers where I knew you'd find it. You could never tell them apart without a microscope, of course. Theta prints are hard to see. So, you... Wait a minute. You can't get away... Sorry, Corinne. It's too bad you didn't realize. It's a third choice. Graham speaking. Go on. The girl I told you about. She's more than a theory now. She's a corpse. Not her dead in her apartment.

Any idea who did it? Pretty quick work. Want me to send a car for you? Look, where are you? Oh, you... You have him there? For sure, man. Send a car. I'll be right over. This is Alfred Hopkins, baby. Once upon a time, there was an Apache named Goyathlet. Really translate, this means one who yawns. Obviously, this was not a proper name for a warrior who wished to strike terror in his opponents. So Goyasle, perhaps after consulting an early-day version of an act of phasing, selected a name which he felt was more appropriate. Soon, he was the Terror of the Southwest. Throughout the area, people trembled with fear when they heard the name.

Geronimo. Years later, of course, Goyopolo's nom de guerre came into difference here. American paratroopers added it to the English language, and they cried Geronimo as they leaped from their planes. The exact meaning of their cry is a bit obscure. Old Geronimo, by the way, did not die in battle. He retired to reservation life in order to work on his memoirs and join the Dutch Reformed Church. May I add, there is absolutely no truth to the stories that Geronimo entitled his autobiography. They're lost when I raided a village and then I changed my name. The idea is absurd.

Well, Philip, it was a terrible moment, wasn't it? Listening to Police Commissioner Matthews telling you over the telephone they knew who killed Corinne Scott. While your mind reached out frantically for some detail you might have overlooked. The bookend. The bottom of the river where it belonged. The affidavit. Carefully burned after you left the apartment. Fingerprints, tire tracks, witnesses. You'd been too careful for that. Then the wonderful words that almost made your heart stop. That they had the suspect there with them. Someone else, Philip. They've made a mistake. A staggering, wonderful mistake. The homicide squad is all over the apartment when you arrive. I'm glad you got here so soon. I dropped everything, of course. Where's the suspect? In the bedroom. You know, Phil, I wish there was some mistake about this. Huh? For the first time in my life, I wish I had nothing to do with tracking a case. What are you talking about? Bring him in here, boys. Matthews, what do you mean by that?

I was hoping we'd be alone. There's just no other answer. And the guy comes walking right out of the victim's house and can't tell why. David. Hello, Dad. I won't say a word. I was waiting for my father. He called me up early last night, Dad. He said he could tell me something about what happened to Professor Bentley. I came on over and he told me everything. I sounded crazy. I told her it was a pack of lies. After I went home last night, I couldn't sleep. That's why I came back here this morning. What did she tell you, David? I've said all I'm going to say. You know what that means, of course. I think so. Yes, Bill. You'd better get a stenographer. A story to tell you. A story that begins with Tommy Anderson. Featured in tonight's story were Bill Foreman as the Whistler, Frank Nelson, Jeanette Nolan, Gil Stratton Jr., Hal Gerard, and Herbert Litton.

The Whistler was directed by George W. Allen, with story by Joel Malone, music by Wilbur Hatch, and was transmitted overseas by the Armed Forces Radio Service. The Whistler was entirely fictional, and all characters portrayed on The Whistler are also fictional. Any similarity of names or resemblance to persons living or dead is purely coincidental. Tune in again next week at this same time for The Whistler. The Whistler has come to you through the worldwide facilities. of the United States Armed Forces Radio and Television Service.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑